Frederic Malle Music for a While (2018) Niche Fragrance Review
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 сер 2024
- This is my full review of Frédéric Malle Music For A While created by Carlos Benaïm in 2018.
If you want to discuss perfume with me further please email me at ramseysmellsgood@gmail.com or IG @ ramseytheramsmellsgood
If you are inclined to support the channel you can buy me a coffee at ko-fi.com/rams...
#fragrancereview #colognecollection #fragrancecollection #perfume #perfumereview #parfum #perfumefragrance #perfumecollection #nicheperfume #nichefragrance #fougere #longlastingfragrances #lavender #2018 #caron #tedlapidus #lapidus
Other Fragrances Discussed During This Episode:
Frederic Malle Hope
Frederic Malle Monsieur
Lapidus Pour Homme
Caron Pour un Homme
Literally just searched for a review of Music for a While and saw this. Perfect timing Ramsey!
How is that for timing 😂😂😂
Back in my earliest frag days when I got into the whole niche market solely because of aventus and its supposed greatness, music for a while was what I thought I was going to be smelling when people said, "this smells like the pineapple top notes from aventus."
There's a Floraiku called between two trees that has a pineapple note that's similar to my nose, but music for a while is still to this day one of my favorite fruity creations. I don't know if it's full bottle worthy because I've yet to finish my decant, but it's certainly the black sheep of the frederic malle lineup.
Ohhhh absolutely.... the hard core Malle fans hate this stuff and some of them hate the Desert Gems, I love them & can't wait to smell Hope 😊
MFAW's a masterpiece, absolutely LOVE it. Anise is the real star of the show to me.
It & Monsieur are easily my favorite FM's. Musc Ravageur is close behind but those two are just incredible.
Thanks for watching & commenting 🍻
One of a kind fragrance.
Very unique indeed
Thanks for watching 👀
Classic , I was only looking at this one a few weeks back . Great job 👏
Nice! Thanks for watching & commenting 🍻
Agree with so many of your points here - the change of Aventus where it became less of a chypre is where it lost the love from me. I have a more recent bottle and it’s just meh. Also like what you said about changing tastes as you go through the journey - mine has really changed over the years and on top of that the different facets you catch from fragrances over multiple wears- it sort it reveals its own personality. Great video and explanations as always 🫡🐏
Thanks for taking the time to watch & comment 🍻
Music for life, not just for a while !
Thank you Ramsey.
Scent Of The Night :
Ralph Lauren - Safari for Women (vintage)
👍🏻💪🐏
I love this vid. Thank you!
@@anniethomas5282 thanks for the support 🙏
I hated this fragrance the first few times I tried it. That was until I smelled it on someone else 2 years after its release, didn’t know what it was, asked the wearer, and was shocked to hear that it was this one. Let’s just say I fell in love with this one. To this day I absolutely adore it and have since even bought a backup. The patchouli dry down is to die for.
It's crazy how our tastes change... but I wasn't a fan of it at first either
'The Pefume Guy' told me he is sensitive to pineapple, and did not perceive any of that note in the perfume which blew my mind, because all i get, especially from the opening, is a sweet, juicy lavender and pineapple smoothie. Love this juice.
Wow I think he really missed a big part of this one if that is the case
Glad to see this review. I bought this blind buy about six months ago. (I tend to have good luck with blind buys). Love it. I live in Hawaii and don't find too many limitations on when I can wear it.
I m a big fan of Frederic Malle.
Yes I could easily see this is an all year round fragrance 💪🐏
After watching the review, i really need to revisit the fragrance. It's been a while. Thanks Ram!
Anytime thanks for watching 👀
Believe me , as much as I love Frédéric Malle and I’ve been to their boutique multiple times … I’ve still not had my hands on Music for a while …maybe it’s the name (I’m one of those person maybe ) but I’m gonna try it soon 🤞
Try it try it! And report back and let me know what you make of it
I made a complete U-Turn on this too, used to hate this but now i find this lovely. Interestingly enough i had a YSL Jazz mini that turned sour : it literally smelled like Music for a While
😆😆😆
Jazz Prestige is maybe closer to my nose but yes you are spot on
14:50 exactly my sentiment, first time I hear someone else verbalize it. I may ignore fragrances for weeks, months or even years (been collecting for two decades), to circle back to them again and view them in a whole different light, discover new facets and nuances, appreciate them more (sometimes less) or be charmed by a rarefied note all over again (tarragon in Sous le Vent, last week: hadn't worn this for many years). I also just love the singular character of a more or less intact collection, warts and all. (Another advantage: it forces me to be discernful; i don't want a freakishly large collection).
Yes the knowledge of the experienced collector... although there is something to be said about the youthful running head first and buying everything early on when it's all new
But you can't teach experience lol
Too funny. I ordered a 2ml sample weeks ago, sprayed it once and thought, ick, don’t want to smell like pineapple lifesavers thank you very much. But I saw this and thought, ok let’s follow along with a spray. And sure enough, it’s exactly as you say. Much, much more going on. I get lavender and herbs very quickly and now it’s transitioning more. Still not feeling the vanilla or caramel but I’m still watching lol.
Anyway, I’ll give it a full wear tomorrow. Thanks for the inspiration!
Yes sir! Thanks for watching & following along in a snifathon 🙂
Had this on the back of my hand as I listened to your review.yes it is an interesting one for sure Ramsey.purchased it earlier this year so good to have more information on it . Thanks
That's awesome.... thanks for being here with us 🍻
Well said Ramsey. I may not care for a fragrance now but it doesn’t mean I will sell it right away. I have over 200 fragrances and I keep every single one. Because there’s a good chance I’ll fall in love with it. Happens more times than I can count
It's great to find the beauty in things, although there are still things I hate 😆
Most underated Malle and the last great from them (havent smell Uncut gem and Heaven must wait)
I haven't smelled Heaven can wait either but I have reviewed Uncut Gem on the channel and a new malle is coming out within the next month Called Hope
Great review, as always. Thank you.
Thanks for watching 🍻
Always learns something on Rams channel. Fragrance School!
Yeah buddy! Thanks for watching & commenting 🍻
@@RamseytheRam👌🏾
i put off reading the ghost perfumer until i saw eugen and ducks interview with gabe oppenheim. influenced into buying a book 💀
That was a fantastic interview
Dominique Ropion is probably my favorite perfumer ,Music for a while is only FM I have. After about 6-7 hours it smells like potting soil! Miracle Grow
This is a Carlos Benaïm creation... but I love Ropions work as well 😎
Thank you for doing music for a while
I do enjoy wearing this one, although it’s a little bit sweet
Yes exactly 💯
Just started watching, but i do really like music for a while especialy for spring summer. The pineapple note is just beautiful and the lavender...😍
Agreed!
It's great in the heat
Also , I think it’s one ☝️ that’s a bit odd up close , but the sillage is quite nice. Unique enough my wife automatically knows when I’m wearing it
Yup spot on
YSL Caban is also Carlos work and its stunning but under rated.
I don't think I smelled that one before 🤔
It's on the never ending to sniff list 🐽
This is a weird yet sexy perfume. The performance is amazing, and the combination of lavender with that sweet pineapple is very original. I think that the name is a tribute to Purcell’s Music for a While composition.
Yes I should have mentioned this.... thanks for the shout out
Since you have many bottles of Frederic Malle, do you know if the newer boxes come without the barcode on the red box? I mention it because i own 3 and they all have a barcode and recently purchased a Rose & Cuir and that one didn't have Barcode on the red box. Just wondering.
Hmmmm that's interesting I am at work but I will make a note to go back and look when I get home
Well, this is one where we are at odds. Our scent appreciation is a Venn diagram where some we agree on and some we disagree on. And I'm pretty much stuck at your initial impression of Music for a While. I've always been driven to try to understand what this fragrance is about. What Carlos Beniem, who created my favorite frag of all time - Polo Green, was trying to get at. I've been working from a decant and now will go back to see if I have any juice left. After four or so wearings, I haven't been motivated in continuing to try it for over a year. But, in a nutshell, Music for a While seems disjointed, without a coherent identity. It hits me as confused and unfocused As Fragrantica author Eddie Bulliqi said: "like a storyline that doesn’t lead anywhere". I agree with the often hilariously wordy Bulliqi on Music for a While. He wrote "It’s interesting, but strange, as if a great pause has taken place between each tone and something is missing or unsaid". Yep. "imbalanced"? Seemingly so. "a storyline that doesn’t lead anywhere, a pointless dead end that wasn’t thought through in relation to the overall map". Yep. "pulls in too many directions, lacks focus, and feels confused, with some beautiful materials but an ugly arrangement". Unfortunately, that's what I get too. But your journey over time with this monster has motivated me to go back and keep trying. I usually keep old review text in my Fragrantica reviews and just add updates to purposely show how my scent appreciation changes over time.
I also would question the fougere characterization. I'll be looking for it next wearing, but usually the dominant fougere accord will immediately hit me in no uncertain terms. It's my favorite genre. I just don't get that in this sweet mess. Not everything with lavender is a fougere. And Fragrantica, not known for consistent accuracy, lists a Geranium note. It may have the thinnest of threads giving a curtsy to the fougere in that tangled mess of accords, but nothing to label it a fougere. All in my opinion.
Very well said and thought out as usual JT... impressive commenting & I couldn't argue with a thing you said... other than you still using fragrantica of course 😆
@RamseytheRam I sprayed Music for a While on card tonight to reaquaint myself with it, and I do detect a fougere lurking in the background. I'll wear it again soon, but tonight my SOTN is Chanel Boy.
Top fragrance imo. The last good Malle imo 🐏🦆
I haven't smelled the newer stuff like Acme Studio or Heaven can wait...but I trust your nose Rich🐏🦆
@@RamseytheRamyour divorce has absolutely outraged me, this perpetual no buy will finish me off 😂🐏🦆
😂😂😂
Well maybe not perpetual... but probably through the end of the year 😬
Interesting one… Thanks !😊
Thanks for watching & commenting mate 🍻
can u wear this in summer ?
I wear everything anytime... I don't do seasons personally... so for me yes I wear it in summer no problem