This version of the song makes me feel a sense of triumph. Almost like a long inner battle has finally been won. Between the lengthened playing of trumpets after the chorus and the choir humming afterwards, I just feel... relief, joy, and a wave of tears erupting from my eyes. This film took an already great album and made it into something else entirely.
A very small, yet strangely satisfying attention to detail about this version of the song is the fact that, to my hearing at least, this version of the song doesn't include the phrase "Isn't this where..." While it may seem like a pointless omission, that one phrase completely changes the ending. That one phrase was pretty much the link between the end & beginning of the album where Pink sayes "...We came in?", suggesting that rather than recovering from his experiences that night when the wall fell, he just simply began anew, eventually building the wall once more. With not only the leaving out of that one phrase + the fact that the album begins with "When the tigers broke free" instead of "In the flesh?", this version of the ending suddenly becomes surprisingly uplifting. By braking that chain that connected the end & beginning of the album, it gives off the impression that Pink was actually able to break free of his wall. Possibly being able to eventually settle in with humanity.
I've always felt this version was more conclusive, and the original more circular. As a result, I like this version more. I am happy to know that the cycle was broken at some point in time.
AlluMan96 don't talk too fast, in the movie, in this scene there isn't the "isn't this were we came in" but if you watch the scene you can see that there a children and pink taking bricks of a fallen house to clean up the streets, pink is cleaning up but there is another boy taking bricks and putting it in a construction truck toy : it's the same message as "isn't this where we came in" it means that when the wall is teared down, another person take the bricks to make another wall
Agreed. I'd say it should replace the original but it probably wouldn't have been able to fit due to manufacturing constraints. Hence, why "What Shall We Do Now?" had to be cut.
It wasn’t meant to be conclusion on the album. If you listen carefully, you’ll hear “isn’t this where” at the end of Outside the Wall, and “we came in” at the beginning of In the Flesh. This points to the idea that the cycle of creating the wall repeats, and that Pink is trapped in this cycle. I suppose they perhaps wanted for Pink to reconnect to humanity in the movie.
They should of put hey you in the movie it would been a good part of the story but even tho it wasn't it still was a fantastic movie with awesome animation and emotions
Agreed, but the entire point of the album version is that it isn’t in fact a conclusion but a continuous cycle. The album wouldn’t work with this version even though it is a nicer song
@@papawuise6820 It's saying that it isn't easy for other people watching this happen to somebody, trying to help constantly but only being brushed off by them
@@papawuise6820 It means : some people are impossible to get through to. Impossible to love. Their 'wall' is so high / strongly built around themselves due to their past traumas etc, that they seem unreachable, but the humanity and empathy in us ,outside that wall , means we keep trying. Until we're exhausted.
@@papawuise6820 I think it means that people shouldn't cut themselves off emotionally, because while you might feel fine in your wall, the people who love you will suffer for it.
It always strikes me that they decided to end it without repeating the last phrase. It ends with: "And when they've given you their all, some stagger and fall, after all is not easy". A kind of humble acceptation of one's own weakness.
Bloxxer Studios I thought "Outside the Wall" meant good things are outside the wall? Like the entire film are bad things happen but when the brick wall collapse/explode we get to see innoncence picking up thrashes. Sorry for my bad English.
@@idiavolomc The madness or insanity in The Wall is represented on the Fascist Pink. He's fascist because he's going insane, so he tries to reach for sanity again. When Pink sings "Crazy, toys in the attic I'm crazy" is his acceptation wich leads to redepmtion or recovery or sanity. Here he's reaching for other people in order to overcome his mental issues.
In the film version, Waters actually sings this song, as opposed to the recitativo of the album version. Sometimes, the second crack is better. This is one of those times.
I also really like the live version of "Outside the Wall" too. I wish someone would make a Frankenstein fusion of this and the live version. Album version is easily my least favorite incarnation of the tune.
I really love both versions. This one sounds like victory and reunion and hope while the album version sounds like long hoped for peace and acceptance and freedom and clarity. I feel like the album version sounds less overwhelming in a sense. Like the album version is seeing the sun and hearing the birds chirp again after a long time of being locked away in a dark and small room, with chains around your ankles, all alone, and then seeing the green grass and the wild fields feeling the cool wind blowing through your hair. And the movie version sounds like watching a ship return after war to find that everyone is healthy and well and realising its over. I think they both have different nuances and feels to it and both of them are beautiful in their own way. I also actually like the aspect that the album loops which a lot of people here dont seem to like.
C'mon guys, just release the movie soundtrack and stop making us scrape around in the dark for bootleg recordings or, as you Brits like to say, "records of illegitimate origin."
The band have had over 30 years and multiple opportunities (e.g. box sets, compilations) to release the soundtrack music and so far only "When the Tigers Broke Free" has made it onto an official release. Even The Wall Immersion box set doesn't include the soundtrack music.
+dannydontgoin237 True, but honestly there would only be a few tracks from the film worth releasing officially - the re-recorded "Outside the Wall" obviously, "When the Tigers Broke Free," (done) "Bring the Boys Back Home," Bob Geldof's versions, and maybe "Empty Spaces." I mean, I can't see myself getting excited, let alone paying $150, for Immersion box set just to hear the slightly different bass line in the movie version of "Comfortably Numb." But, Roger Waters has been riding "The Wall"'s coattails for his entire solo career, especially in recent years, so maybe he'll have it released.
I get made fun of when I bring up Michael Kamen's orchestrations for the studio and film tracks. I love the additional purity and depth of the emotional content, but they really shone on the 1982 film remixes. So I'd be very happy to have JUST the orchestrations.
Of all the changes made for the film this is by far the best. It is so gorgeous and deep in emotion and offers such a cathartic ending to the entire story.
I love this version. It includes ”Its Never too Late”, a track not included in The Wall. I like this as much as the demo version (Outside The Wall Part 1+The Thin Ice Reprise+Outside the Wall Part 2+Its Never Too Late).
This short song is heartfelt about breaking free from the wall or our own wall puts me in tears while the movie was dark the movie describes what it was like to be depressed and Loneliness or just can't take the pain
Lol, I see all the comments on all the tracks saying how these recordings sound more like the movie than the album. Well yeah it's in the description. When I was 13 in 1985 I used to record the music off the movie onto a cassette for my friends because it was better than the album. You hear all the stuff in the background and honestly, the music is just better than the album. Thanks for uploading. I come back to these tracks periodically to remember and re live. ❤️
For a while I've been listening to "The Wall" & indeed it's one of the All-time best concept albums ever created & hearing this version (fighting back so many tears) here's my personal interpretation of both album version & this re-recording of Outside the Wall:- * (Album version) it's has a humble sound courtesy of a clarinet & a children's choir with Roger Waters narrating the lyrics acts more like a fable for people to take heed to. For Pink in this version is still somewhat trapped within his fractured psychosis with the indication of the book end "Is this where...." & thus "The Cycle Continues......" * This re-recording has a very different altogether uplifting mood; Pink after emitting a truly terrifying agonising scream as The Wall is torn down; he's made it! Pink is at last free of the horrors of his nightmares! * The anguish of a lost father * The resentment (in his mind) of his overprotective Mother * The Despair brought about by cruel teachers * To at least attempt to patch things with his wife.... YMMV how successful that could be. & so here; rather than build a Wall, instead Pink can build Bridges & thus with this version of the song "The Cycle is BROKEN!!"
That scream as The Wall comes down still cracks loose some tears. Oddly enough, the baby T-Rex cry from "The Lost World" also breaks my heart in the same way.
@@salmanojdboi on the album, he builds his wall again, this is confirmed by the "isn't this where..." and the line "...we came in?" This version doesn't have that, which probably means pink just went back to his life. No more walls.
@@SukkaPunch321 now a days I think he may have ended up in a mental hospital because if you listen to the reversed phone call in empty spaces Roger says please send your answer to old pink care of the funny farm
I presume in this version once he breaks down his wall he rebuilds on what was broken in his life possibly coping about the death of his father, the overprotective nature of his mother, the lack attention and care he gave to his now ex-wife and amending the shattered pieces of his reality.
It’s up to the listener to decide what comes next, for me I don’t believe he rebuilt his wall again, I believe the song “The Final Cut” comes next in the storyline and talks about his struggles and the loop in album has is a metaphor that others built their own walls from the bricks that was torn down from Pink’s wall because in the ending of the movie there are people coming and cleaning up the debris
Тhis movie is now avаilаaaаble tо wаtch herе => twitter.com/c8eb3d4a2c1e7ac70/status/796185716787056640 Pink Flоoооуd Тhе Wаll Musiс From Thе Film 25 Оutside Тhe Wall
The film track is different to the studio album,the cello sounds faster in the film jaws......away and have a word wi yourselves,turn up,tune in,drop out😂
This song reminds me of the end of Pokemon when Ash dies and everybody including Misty and his mother comes to his funeral but Team Rocket dies and the extinct of all Pocket Monsters. "HEARTBREAKING."
I think through all the (remastered songs) that they are pushing some kind of engineered Mandala effect on us all , because some songs just don’t sound right so I try to stay away from remastered crap Don’t get me wrong some of the songs they have made cleaner but I’ve some little nuances or totally missing instruments or lyrics. Might just be my mistrust of the governments or maybe im just getting old
@@tomb2577 I love echoes as much as the next guy, it's as a matter of fact my favourite PF song, but I can't think of it as someone's introduction to the band, it's lenght makes it extremely intimidating. My introduction for example was wish you were here (the song)
This version of the song makes me feel a sense of triumph. Almost like a long inner battle has finally been won. Between the lengthened playing of trumpets after the chorus and the choir humming afterwards, I just feel... relief, joy, and a wave of tears erupting from my eyes. This film took an already great album and made it into something else entirely.
That's actually a good analogy of this version. It makes me appreciate how different the album and movie versions are.
A very small, yet strangely satisfying attention to detail about this version of the song is the fact that, to my hearing at least, this version of the song doesn't include the phrase "Isn't this where..."
While it may seem like a pointless omission, that one phrase completely changes the ending. That one phrase was pretty much the link between the end & beginning of the album where Pink sayes "...We came in?", suggesting that rather than recovering from his experiences that night when the wall fell, he just simply began anew, eventually building the wall once more.
With not only the leaving out of that one phrase + the fact that the album begins with "When the tigers broke free" instead of "In the flesh?", this version of the ending suddenly becomes surprisingly uplifting. By braking that chain that connected the end & beginning of the album, it gives off the impression that Pink was actually able to break free of his wall. Possibly being able to eventually settle in with humanity.
I've always felt this version was more conclusive, and the original more circular. As a result, I like this version more. I am happy to know that the cycle was broken at some point in time.
I also prefer Roger's singing in this version as well. It truly feels like a conclusion.
I feel that the "Isn't this where..." part wasn't Pink, but another person, who ends up building their own wall.
the album is an infinite loop, maybe they wanted to let Pink rest at least
AlluMan96 don't talk too fast, in the movie, in this scene there isn't the "isn't this were we came in" but if you watch the scene you can see that there a children and pink taking bricks of a fallen house to clean up the streets, pink is cleaning up but there is another boy taking bricks and putting it in a construction truck toy : it's the same message as "isn't this where we came in" it means that when the wall is teared down, another person take the bricks to make another wall
This version is beautiful. I think it sounds more like a conclusion than the album's.
Agreed. I'd say it should replace the original but it probably wouldn't have been able to fit due to manufacturing constraints. Hence, why "What Shall We Do Now?" had to be cut.
It wasn’t meant to be conclusion on the album. If you listen carefully, you’ll hear “isn’t this where” at the end of Outside the Wall, and “we came in” at the beginning of In the Flesh. This points to the idea that the cycle of creating the wall repeats, and that Pink is trapped in this cycle. I suppose they perhaps wanted for Pink to reconnect to humanity in the movie.
Lapiam Dunwill i think the ‘isnt this where we came in’ is a quote from another person who is going to end up repeating exactly what Pink did
They should of put hey you in the movie it would been a good part of the story but even tho it wasn't it still was a fantastic movie with awesome animation and emotions
Agreed, but the entire point of the album version is that it isn’t in fact a conclusion but a continuous cycle. The album wouldn’t work with this version even though it is a nicer song
I always find that line funny, "It's not easy banging your heart against some mad buggers Wall". Just brilliant.
I always wondered, what does that line mean?
@@papawuise6820 It's saying that it isn't easy for other people watching this happen to somebody, trying to help constantly but only being brushed off by them
@@papawuise6820 It means : some people are impossible to get through to. Impossible to love. Their 'wall' is so high / strongly built around themselves due to their past traumas etc, that they seem unreachable, but the humanity and empathy in us ,outside that wall , means we keep trying. Until we're exhausted.
@@papawuise6820 I think it means that people shouldn't cut themselves off emotionally, because while you might feel fine in your wall, the people who love you will suffer for it.
Isn't this where...
We came in.
Not this time. This time it is over for good
It always strikes me that they decided to end it without repeating the last phrase. It ends with: "And when they've given you their all, some stagger and fall, after all is not easy". A kind of humble acceptation of one's own weakness.
The wall is a story about accepting your fears and weaknesses, and smashing down the walls that try to 'protect' you
Bloxxer Studios I thought "Outside the Wall" meant good things are outside the wall? Like the entire film are bad things happen but when the brick wall collapse/explode we get to see innoncence picking up thrashes. Sorry for my bad English.
@@bloxxerstudios8746 basically accepting madness or insanity
@@idiavolomc The madness or insanity in The Wall is represented on the Fascist Pink. He's fascist because he's going insane, so he tries to reach for sanity again. When Pink sings "Crazy, toys in the attic I'm crazy" is his acceptation wich leads to redepmtion or recovery or sanity. Here he's reaching for other people in order to overcome his mental issues.
In the film version, Waters actually sings this song, as opposed to the recitativo of the album version. Sometimes, the second crack is better. This is one of those times.
OMG this is so much better then album version
One of the few songs where the movie version is actually better than the album one
+mr box Empty Spaces movie version is better than the album
+mr box
I totally agree The album version is too short & quiet
+Quem Official the version in the film was originally going to be on the album, but they replaced it due to time contraints of vinyl records
I also really like the live version of "Outside the Wall" too.
I wish someone would make a Frankenstein fusion of this and the live version. Album version is easily my least favorite incarnation of the tune.
or songs from Roger Waters the Wall Live in Berlin 1990
I really love both versions.
This one sounds like victory and reunion and hope while the album version sounds like long hoped for peace and acceptance and freedom and clarity.
I feel like the album version sounds less overwhelming in a sense. Like the album version is seeing the sun and hearing the birds chirp again after a long time of being locked away in a dark and small room, with chains around your ankles, all alone, and then seeing the green grass and the wild fields feeling the cool wind blowing through your hair. And the movie version sounds like watching a ship return after war to find that everyone is healthy and well and realising its over.
I think they both have different nuances and feels to it and both of them are beautiful in their own way.
I also actually like the aspect that the album loops which a lot of people here dont seem to like.
so many final cut in this version.......beautiful.....
It's Never Too Late.
You hit then nail on the head.
This version is so much better then the album version.
C'mon guys, just release the movie soundtrack and stop making us scrape around in the dark for bootleg recordings or, as you Brits like to say, "records of illegitimate origin."
1:55
The band have had over 30 years and multiple opportunities (e.g. box sets, compilations) to release the soundtrack music and so far only "When the Tigers Broke Free" has made it onto an official release. Even The Wall Immersion box set doesn't include the soundtrack music.
+dannydontgoin237 True, but honestly there would only be a few tracks from the film worth releasing officially - the re-recorded "Outside the Wall" obviously, "When the Tigers Broke Free," (done) "Bring the Boys Back Home," Bob Geldof's versions, and maybe "Empty Spaces." I mean, I can't see myself getting excited, let alone paying $150, for Immersion box set just to hear the slightly different bass line in the movie version of "Comfortably Numb."
But, Roger Waters has been riding "The Wall"'s coattails for his entire solo career, especially in recent years, so maybe he'll have it released.
Captain Bud Sturguess haha @ “riding the walls coat tails” very true
I get made fun of when I bring up Michael Kamen's orchestrations for the studio and film tracks. I love the additional purity and depth of the emotional content, but they really shone on the 1982 film remixes. So I'd be very happy to have JUST the orchestrations.
The most moving version of this Song... :,)
I love this version of this song so much. :)
Of all the changes made for the film this is by far the best. It is so gorgeous and deep in emotion and offers such a cathartic ending to the entire story.
Both versions are amazing
But I’d say the original is better
People talk about how ambiguous the end of the Wall is, but to me it seems this song is telling you it’s going to be okay.
I agree guys, this version is much better than the album's.
Im in tears
I love this version. It includes ”Its Never too Late”, a track not included in The Wall. I like this as much as the demo version (Outside The Wall Part 1+The Thin Ice Reprise+Outside the Wall Part 2+Its Never Too Late).
Along with a few other songs, i prefer this version to the album version.
Thanks for including the big bang. Great song. Needed everything.
i wait for a 40th anniversary remastered version of the movie and the full original soundtrack -hope for this year 2022
This short song is heartfelt about breaking free from the wall or our own wall puts me in tears while the movie was dark the movie describes what it was like to be depressed and Loneliness or just can't take the pain
this sounds like The final cut, which is one the best albums ever for me.
This version was played when the Berlin wall came down. Perfection 🖤
Lol, I see all the comments on all the tracks saying how these recordings sound more like the movie than the album.
Well yeah it's in the description.
When I was 13 in 1985 I used to record the music off the movie onto a cassette for my friends because it was better than the album. You hear all the stuff in the background and honestly, the music is just better than the album.
Thanks for uploading. I come back to these tracks periodically to remember and re live. ❤️
The best version of the song.
feels like i've just eaten a meal after listening to that album!
For a while I've been listening to "The Wall" & indeed it's one of the All-time best concept albums ever created & hearing this version (fighting back so many tears) here's my personal interpretation of both album version & this re-recording of Outside the Wall:-
* (Album version) it's has a humble sound courtesy of a clarinet & a children's choir with Roger Waters narrating the lyrics acts more like a fable for people to take heed to. For Pink in this version is still somewhat trapped within his fractured psychosis with the indication of the book end "Is this where...." & thus "The Cycle Continues......"
* This re-recording has a very different altogether uplifting mood; Pink after emitting a truly terrifying agonising scream as The Wall is torn down; he's made it! Pink is at last free of the horrors of his nightmares!
* The anguish of a lost father
* The resentment (in his mind) of his overprotective Mother
* The Despair brought about by cruel teachers
* To at least attempt to patch things with his wife.... YMMV how successful that could be.
& so here; rather than build a Wall, instead Pink can build Bridges
& thus with this version of the song "The Cycle is BROKEN!!"
That scream as The Wall comes down still cracks loose some tears. Oddly enough, the baby T-Rex cry from "The Lost World" also breaks my heart in the same way.
Some stagger and fall after all it’s not easy.
Anyone with anxiety or Asperger's problems or depression problems will cry this song is so beautiful and meaningful
Facts!
Yeah
I agree
As someone with Asperger, agree
Yeah that's me w depression
Ty tyvm for all 25
Pink Floyd i ever remember you :')
I think this version is better than the album... the way he sings it
I agree ☝️
There Is Still Time.
I literally can't listen to this song with out crying. God damn the feels!
My favourite version all over i covered this and will cover it forever
Awesome 80s' 1982
I feel sorry for McJuggerNuggets he lost his games room today to Psychosis and his blue tractor so I dedicate this song to him
Batman11838
There's a novel coming????!?!?!
Isaac Vires
That episode is titled
Psycho Dad Demolishes gaming room
1:05 Your welcome
3:53
Goosebumps
That part kills me, kills me!
All and all...
You're just another brick in the wall
Essa canção me faz chorar demais!
What happens to Pink then?
@@salmanojdboi on the album, he builds his wall again, this is confirmed by the "isn't this where..." and the line "...we came in?" This version doesn't have that, which probably means pink just went back to his life. No more walls.
He tears down the wall and he’s okay.
@@SukkaPunch321 now a days I think he may have ended up in a mental hospital because if you listen to the reversed phone call in empty spaces Roger says please send your answer to old pink care of the funny farm
I presume in this version once he breaks down his wall he rebuilds on what was broken in his life possibly coping about the death of his father, the overprotective nature of his mother, the lack attention and care he gave to his now ex-wife and amending the shattered pieces of his reality.
It’s up to the listener to decide what comes next, for me I don’t believe he rebuilt his wall again, I believe the song “The Final Cut” comes next in the storyline and talks about his struggles and the loop in album has is a metaphor that others built their own walls from the bricks that was torn down from Pink’s wall because in the ending of the movie there are people coming and cleaning up the debris
1:06 😍
the soundtrack i got didn't play the whole song and that's what really sucks about the one i got.
Тhis movie is now avаilаaaаble tо wаtch herе => twitter.com/c8eb3d4a2c1e7ac70/status/796185716787056640 Pink Flоoооуd Тhе Wаll Musiс From Thе Film 25 Оutside Тhe Wall
She. Wrote whole. Album both voucle
The film track is different to the studio album,the cello sounds faster in the film jaws......away and have a word wi yourselves,turn up,tune in,drop out😂
3:05 4:39
1:30
0:40
1:00
This song reminds me of the end of Pokemon when Ash dies and everybody including Misty and his mother comes to his funeral but Team Rocket dies and the extinct of all Pocket Monsters. "HEARTBREAKING."
never saw that one
I think you were just tripping bro.
what were you on dude im pretty sure that never happened
Theres nothin
I think through all the (remastered songs) that they are pushing some kind of engineered Mandala effect on us all , because some songs just don’t sound right so I try to stay away from remastered crap Don’t get me wrong some of the songs they have made cleaner but I’ve some little nuances or totally missing instruments or lyrics. Might just be my mistrust of the governments or maybe im just getting old
Blah blah blah something about “isn’t this where….” Insightful comment. You get the idea.
Also this version lacks it
In the movie this song is a conclusion
Stink floyd
Nah man they are good
Give echoes a listen
@@tomb2577 I love echoes as much as the next guy, it's as a matter of fact my favourite PF song, but I can't think of it as someone's introduction to the band, it's lenght makes it extremely intimidating.
My introduction for example was wish you were here (the song)
@@tany5924 I think Seamus would be a pretty good introduction
@@Kodaigon72 nah... That song isn't Pink Floyd's best and most people would find that dog annoying
Pink Annoyed
3:05