If you close your eyes and listen to the plaintiff, his speaking patterns sounds like the amazing actor Christopher Walken.m (even though Walken’s a NY’er and plaintiff’s from Mass). Also, the plaintiff’s real life demeanor is also like one of Walken’s gangster characters! I love the line where the nephew is about to claim money was stolen the plantiff says in his Mass accent “bee keehfuul…😂
As an Executor of 3 different estates. You much keep track all of the money that is attached to that estate(s)and deposit into the estate account a.s.a.p because you can get sued at anytime because of it, even years later.
😂 The defendant failed to mention that he was a bum from a broken home. Judge Mathis proved that he was a liar. The Judge is the coldest one. I watched this one twice. 😂😂
“Here ran away eleven years ago”. The plaintiff looks like he’s pushing 70 so if he ran away eleven years ago that’s hilarious. I didn’t know senior citizens in their right mind could run away.
Psalm 96:4-5) For the Lord is great, and greatly to be praised: he is to be feared above all gods. 5.For all the gods of the nations are idols: but the Lord made the heavens.
It's sad how much money viewed as the most important thing amongst people while living and even more important after death. Doesn't matter what the relation is. So sad world and society.
This guy wrote that letter himself and passed it off as his mother and it went right above judge Mathis head😳 The defendant handed an affidavit to the judge supposedly behalf of his mother but if you pay attention when judge starts reading it at the beginning it says "when my father passed away" but it should have read "when my husband passed away". You could see the terror on his face when when he realizes the mistake! And the judge doesn't even notice! I wonder if they ever look back at these and realize when they miss or mess something up🤔
@@jessicad8561 I'm not sure about that, but even if that was the case, is his father his mothers father as well? Why would the letter from his mother supposedly collaborating his story start off saying "when my father passed away"🤔
@@randomthoughts378 because the people he was raised by was his grandparents and so the actual mother was the daughter of his grandparents. So that’s why she said “when my father passed” because that was her father
You can tell the plaintiff’s worked the streets at one point in his life and wasn’t about to let some entitled nephew come in and run some scam on him. He has this cool dark side like Christopher Walken’s character in True Romance….
I have been a in home care hospice care giver off and on for over 25 years.Most people by the time we their put on hospice they aren't in the mindset to be petty enough asking family members to collect debts after their deaths.So the father was most likely as petty as his son.For trying to collect this debt after losing his father. Very dysfunctional family. This is something petty between him and his uncle.
J. Mathis had the crowd laughing at first and then they just kept laughing at everything the defendant said. It really pissed me off. The plantiff was the liar!
All the defendant was doing was trying to smear the guy's reputation so that he could get away without repaying him. Should've added punitive damages to his lawsuit for defamation of character.
The defendant definitely took a reach with that counterclaim, but very annoying JM keeps cutting him off. I believe the defendant. The plaintiff seems sus.
Im exhausted just listening to this mess about the "father's wishes" OMG. Take accountability!!! I spoiled my son after his dad and I divorced. Thank God I didnt do too much damage. I saw what I was doing by "over compensating" for his father's shortfalls. Its an easy trap. Not sure how this defendant became so "needy"
I hope they doing internal investigation behind the scene give they judgment coz all u need is a paper that says what u want and talk good...u win. If the ppl in court lough at the other person...u definitely win too. The judge is acting as all judges do. He probably bully more than most judges but he's judgment is a hit and miss as most judges do.
True because of the defendant was adopted then it makes sense that he would be left an account. He could have been drawing money out against the money he was to be left. The plaintiff was definitely bitter to me,
@@dennissmith7214 unfortunately for the defendant, it is the Executor's duty to collate the deceased assets & liabilities to be shared out as prescribed. This way things are above board, collusion, pilferage, stemmed. The plaintiff is obligated to follow up his father's dues
@@dennissmith7214 it is more like who seems more credible, a judge has limited time to decipher one's character, evidence, & facts provided. That is why once you are caught out in a lie, your goose is cooked
Why couldn't this money owed/given be credited as paid The dead has no more say and the keeping track was between the grandfather and grandson; and I am certain the grandfather on his dying bed didn't request for the plaintiff to collect what is owed As executor of the deceased estate, he, the plaintiff gets an allocated allowance or stipend; thus why the defendant didn't fight this and not decline due to duress. Even in death, many family like this one is being messy Thank goodness all my assets is going to the homeless NPO in Jamaica and to help feed and provide resources for gainful employment. I too loved Jamaica and other island of the Caribbean, but Ja is number one, thus I partner with good friends to buy land to build shelters upon on.... Five years thus far and more homeless are in need due to the pandemic and getting put out of their rented homes or apartments (it is not like the States)
you know it was all funny till the Jamaica part came up and the letter happened. That plus the ending makes me think there's a lot of truth to the story about the plaintiff's old ways and the idea that he may be a trash dude but there's just no way I could expect any judge to take it seriously when the rest of the case was so cartoonish.
The note from the mother also called the lender "my father." Which doesn't make sense at all since it was the DEFENDANT'S father!!! Not his grandfather. He probably wrote that letter himself!!!
It’s a huge responsibility especially if the estate has a lot of money and assets and people typically don’t want to deal with the headache and hassle of dealing with multiple beneficiaries and the potential drama
Judge Mathis YOU WERE WRONG IN YOUR RULING. YOU SHOULD HAVE ASKED FOR EVIDENCE OF THE ACCOUNT THAT THE NOTE WAS REFERRING. WAS THE DEFENDANTS NAME ALSO ON THE ACCOUNT?
He didn't because he didn't believe a word the guy said. It was hard to take him seriously AT ALL. The note from the mother also called the lender "my father." Which doesn't make sense at all since it was the DEFENDANT'S father!!! Not his grandfather. He probably wrote that letter himself!!!
Any one notice the defendant seems nervous and looks worried I feel sorry for the defendant I don't blame him I be nervous is well if I was in court I be dry lips and sweating
I tell you what, not on my bed going home to glory, will I be concerned about money owed 😂! I’m glad that the plaintiff won, sounds like he has another case for defamation and slander 🤷♀️
Idk I believe the defendent I think he was stumbling bcuz he was nervous and JM was cutting him off before he could finish his sentence. Those IOUs we're probably written by the plaintiff
Maybe, but the defendant provided ridiculous lies and zero evidence to proof his case, JM can't just give him a judgement because his mommy "wrote" a statement!
I can't believe people laughed. They are dealing with their fathers estate and people find it funny. I'm sorry but in my eyes a old jank can always lie so great. ... laughed at in a courtroom ooofftt... what a mess
Wth Is the audience always laughing in court downtown Detroit it has to be silence in our court house, this seems to be a comedy, and the judge mathis leads the audience to laugh not cool
Mathis turned the lying defendant into a blithering mess.
😆
I’m telling you blustery, blubbering, bumbling mess the defendant is. 😂😂
The defendant is a prime example of what happens when you coddle your child and turn them into a spoiled brat.
Yeeeeesssss! He can’t even utter a believable word. Like a fish underwater bubbling. Smdh
After watching this, I feel like Erick owes me some money!
@Mi Comunidad Vegans
EXACTLY 🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣 me too!
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Defendant needed to get his story straight he was all over the place, people laughed at him because he sounded ridiculous.
Yes
Trying to get some damn 💰 lol
The prime example of a kid that never gets called on their bull shit growing up to be a grown liar.
You know you’re desperate if you have to bring up alleged incidents from 1999 to try and sue over emotional distress.. 🤦🏾♀️😒
Big up from Jamaica 🇯🇲 judge mathis
Yaaaaasssssss!!!!!
Hello my bruda
I love Jamaica... Yea mon!
😃hi my Jamaican brother
🇯🇲
The defendant turned this court room into a comedy show. His lies caused everyone to laugh like he was an opening act.
The uncle gangsta 🤣😭 y'all saw him at the end
yep..i new at the beginning
Yes! Too funny😏
Yeah he definitely was with the shvts back in his day 😂😂
😂😂😂
If you close your eyes and listen to the plaintiff, his speaking patterns sounds like the amazing actor Christopher Walken.m (even though Walken’s a NY’er and plaintiff’s from Mass). Also, the plaintiff’s real life demeanor is also like one of Walken’s gangster characters! I love the line where the nephew is about to claim money was stolen the plantiff says in his Mass accent “bee keehfuul…😂
This is definitely one of my favorites I got to save this one. Judge Mathis hit him with some funny Matlock way of breaking the defendant. 😂
The audience be laughing like hell in there 😂😂😂
😂😂😂
I don't like how the audience always laughs, on all the shows
As an Executor of 3 different estates. You much keep track all of the money that is attached to that estate(s)and deposit into the estate account a.s.a.p because you can get sued at anytime because of it, even years later.
Some States also called it an Executor a Administrator or Fiduciary to the estate.
Where can I get more information on this please?
😂 The defendant failed to mention that he was a bum from a broken home. Judge Mathis proved that he was a liar. The Judge is the coldest one. I watched this one twice. 😂😂
He called the plaintiff's family "dysfunctional", but he admitted that the plaintiff's parents adopted him and everyone was jealous of him lol
The defendant sounds like he’s making things up as he goes 😂😂😂
“Here ran away eleven years ago”. The plaintiff looks like he’s pushing 70 so if he ran away eleven years ago that’s hilarious. I didn’t know senior citizens in their right mind could run away.
Good one LOL. So he ran away when he was 60 or 50 years old 😂😂
Psalm 96:4-5) For the Lord is great, and greatly to be praised: he is to be feared above all gods. 5.For all the gods of the nations are idols: but the Lord made the heavens.
all godS?
Loved his dismissal.. "bye now"
Nephew sure does looks like a goldfish when answering questions.. 🎏
Not a gold fish 😜 lmao 😅
can’t fast talk the Judge
or double talk
The Defendant shaking like a stripper trying to get some kind of settlement 😂😂😂😂😂
The defendant made my head hurt at 3 minutes and 45 seconds. It's obvious you lying 🤥
WTF any man that let's another assault his gf & does nothing AINT A MAN🤦♂️
I’m sorry… “Bye now…🚶🏼”
That sent me. 😩
It's sad how much money viewed as the most important thing amongst people while living and even more important after death. Doesn't matter what the relation is. So sad world and society.
You got that right.
#AMUN #RA!!!!
#MY FAMILY*!
Defendant just kept throwing up crazy 💩💩💩 to try and make it stick. He needs therapy or something…
I don't know about either if these two they both seem shady and like the defendant mentioned distinctional.
"Well, to be honest with you sir." I'm pretty sure that you were NEVER honest with him!!!
Just pay it, defendant! You know you’re doing your uncle a disservice.
did he say "homegrown terrorist" lmfao
The audience throughout the guy's defense: 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
This guy wrote that letter himself and passed it off as his mother and it went right above judge Mathis head😳
The defendant handed an affidavit to the judge supposedly behalf of his mother but if you pay attention when judge starts reading it at the beginning it says "when my father passed away" but it should have read "when my husband passed away". You could see the terror on his face when when he realizes the mistake! And the judge doesn't even notice!
I wonder if they ever look back at these and realize when they miss or mess something up🤔
I think he was talking about his biological mother
@@jessicad8561 I'm not sure about that, but even if that was the case, is his father his mothers father as well? Why would the letter from his mother supposedly collaborating his story start off saying "when my father passed away"🤔
@@randomthoughts378 because the people he was raised by was his grandparents and so the actual mother was the daughter of his grandparents. So that’s why she said “when my father passed” because that was her father
The deceased is the defendants grandfather. That letter was from his mother, who was the plaintiffs sister.
@@tarynjohnson3022 ahhhhhh now all of it makes sense now. Whew I had to watch it again i dont know how i missed that small/HUGE detail🤦♀️
You can tell the plaintiff’s worked the streets at one point in his life and wasn’t about to let some entitled nephew come in and run some scam on him. He has this cool dark side like Christopher Walken’s character in True Romance….
He used that money and went to jamrock 😂😂😂
I have been a in home care hospice care giver off and on for over 25 years.Most people by the time we their put on hospice they aren't in the mindset to be petty enough asking family members to collect debts after their deaths.So the father was most likely as petty as his son.For trying to collect this debt after losing his father. Very dysfunctional family. This is something petty between him and his uncle.
Even with documents and a will people will still go crazy over some damn money. It’s crazy to see.
I believe the defendant.
I do too.
J. Mathis had the crowd laughing at first and then they just kept laughing at everything the defendant said. It really pissed me off. The plantiff was the liar!
Based on what? He has 0 proof to back any of his claims up
Me too.
I do too
Now, why would his mother have referred to her husband as "my father" in that letter? Oh! Because he wrote it and claimed she wrote it...bruhhh
Great uncle maybe instead of a direct uncle???
Not a homegrown terrorist
Lmaooo just said the same thing before I seen ur comment. I’m cracking up
I said the same thing out loud m
The defendant crazy smh 🤦🏾♀️ trying to get some money
The plaintiff is a O G.
I caught it from the start...
All the defendant was doing was trying to smear the guy's reputation so that he could get away without repaying him. Should've added punitive damages to his lawsuit for defamation of character.
What is a dead man gonna do wit settlement. This just seems so selfish
It will be given to the people who are inheriting his estate.
@@rachelw6237 exactly, it is all about the estate, the deceased's wishes, not the plaintiff's
Nothings greedier than collecting debts owed to a dead man.
Nothing greedier than not paying people back when you owe them🙄(alive or dead)
@@mbhonimongwe3994
What does a dead person need money for? That’s the problem with people.
People's should not be Judged, that little skinny man got a lot of bad stuff going on with him
Ugh the defendant is like a big spoiled baby 😷
The plaintiff with the shit on the low 😂 talking bout keeping it nice lol
Gotta keep it nice stay out my life
He really tried to finesse
Facts
This man was making it up as he went along. It ended up being pretty funny though 😆
The audience sure thought so too!!!
The defendant definitely took a reach with that counterclaim, but very annoying JM keeps cutting him off. I believe the defendant. The plaintiff seems sus.
Im exhausted just listening to this mess about the "father's wishes" OMG. Take accountability!!! I spoiled my son after his dad and I divorced. Thank God I didnt do too much damage. I saw what I was doing by "over compensating" for his father's shortfalls. Its an easy trap. Not sure how this defendant became so "needy"
Am I the only one who thinks the plaintiff was lying?
Probably, yeah.
The defendant emotional claim lasted half the episode 😂😂😂
I hope they doing internal investigation behind the scene give they judgment coz all u need is a paper that says what u want and talk good...u win. If the ppl in court lough at the other person...u definitely win too. The judge is acting as all judges do. He probably bully more than most judges but he's judgment is a hit and miss as most judges do.
Yeah JM decides his cases on who he likes most of the time not just the facts! 🤷🏽♂️
The defendant had no case and was lying. Had 0 proof as well
True because of the defendant was adopted then it makes sense that he would be left an account. He could have been drawing money out against the money he was to be left. The plaintiff was definitely bitter to me,
@@dennissmith7214 unfortunately for the defendant, it is the Executor's duty to collate the deceased assets & liabilities to be shared out as prescribed.
This way things are above board, collusion, pilferage, stemmed.
The plaintiff is obligated to follow up his father's dues
@@dennissmith7214 it is more like who seems more credible, a judge has limited time to decipher one's character, evidence, & facts provided. That is why once you are caught out in a lie, your goose is cooked
I almost chocked my juice when judge mathis asked if he loved his fiance 😆 🤣
I believe the defendant, something slimey about the plantiff...
Honestly the audience was doing too much
As always.
So the defendant mooched off his father? Gotcha!
That defendant is a snaky person...people are always trying to get something for nothing.
Defendant is a fool 🤣😅🤣😅🤣
Why couldn't this money owed/given be credited as paid
The dead has no more say and the keeping track was between the grandfather and grandson; and I am certain the grandfather on his dying bed didn't request for the plaintiff to collect what is owed
As executor of the deceased estate, he, the plaintiff gets an allocated allowance or stipend; thus why the defendant didn't fight this and not decline due to duress.
Even in death, many family like this one is being messy
Thank goodness all my assets is going to the homeless NPO in Jamaica and to help feed and provide resources for gainful employment.
I too loved Jamaica and other island of the Caribbean, but Ja is number one, thus I partner with good friends to buy land to build shelters upon on.... Five years thus far and more homeless are in need due to the pandemic and getting put out of their rented homes or apartments (it is not like the States)
Not sure if I believe this man he seems shady.. but lack of suitable evidence damned the defendant
I couldn't really understand the defendants case bc the audience is laughing too much
you know it was all funny till the Jamaica part came up and the letter happened. That plus the ending makes me think there's a lot of truth to the story about the plaintiff's old ways and the idea that he may be a trash dude but there's just no way I could expect any judge to take it seriously when the rest of the case was so cartoonish.
The note from the mother also called the lender "my father." Which doesn't make sense at all since it was the DEFENDANT'S father!!! Not his grandfather. He probably wrote that letter himself!!!
Everything he saying sounds crazy
Why decline to be executor??
It’s a huge responsibility especially if the estate has a lot of money and assets and people typically don’t want to deal with the headache and hassle of dealing with multiple beneficiaries and the potential drama
Yeah, I'm not an executor I'm just a beneficiary. My mother is a staunch Jehovah Witness our views on saving lives don't align.
Yes judge mi want that $700 deal to Jamaica 🇯🇲 lol love my Country and people....
The judge is from Chicago dude.
People in the back really trying hard to laugh at everything lol
Can you really blame them??? So was I!!!
Judge Mathis YOU WERE WRONG IN YOUR RULING. YOU SHOULD HAVE ASKED FOR EVIDENCE OF THE ACCOUNT THAT THE NOTE WAS REFERRING. WAS THE DEFENDANTS NAME ALSO ON THE ACCOUNT?
He didn't because he didn't believe a word the guy said. It was hard to take him seriously AT ALL. The note from the mother also called the lender "my father." Which doesn't make sense at all since it was the DEFENDANT'S father!!! Not his grandfather. He probably wrote that letter himself!!!
Because his grandfather died he didn’t want to pay back his debt
Defendant in court "my family".
Defendant out of court "this family".
Judge" U seems a little Too hard on this defensive on this guy. U not giving him a fair chance. Every one is not as fortunate as u are
Any one notice the defendant seems nervous and looks worried I feel sorry for the defendant I don't blame him I be nervous is well if I was in court I be dry lips and sweating
I’m literally cringing watch the defendant
Judge Mathis funny asf😩🤣
Who is the lady with the cackle in the back
Help me understand lol How is this so called dysfunctional family not his family.?
I tell you what, not on my bed going home to glory, will I be concerned about money owed 😂! I’m glad that the plaintiff won, sounds like he has another case for defamation and slander 🤷♀️
So the dependent had a chance to be the boss of the entire estate have power of attorney n all but he turned it down? What the fuck
Idk I believe the defendent I think he was stumbling bcuz he was nervous and JM was cutting him off before he could finish his sentence. Those IOUs we're probably written by the plaintiff
Man said home grown terrorist
The Jamaica trip seemed true. Both should have won their cases.
He lied the whole case and his credibility was shot I don't believe that either but that's just me
Maybe, but the defendant provided ridiculous lies and zero evidence to proof his case, JM can't just give him a judgement because his mommy "wrote" a statement!
i believe the defendant lol
I believe the Defendant.
Blessed the mathis crew 🙏🙌
Defendant dug himself in a giant hole. Tell one lie you gotta keep telling them. Unfortunately for him he didn't tell his good enough. Lol
Lmaoo not a homegrown terrorist
I can't believe people laughed. They are dealing with their fathers estate and people find it funny. I'm sorry but in my eyes a old jank can always lie so great. ... laughed at in a courtroom ooofftt... what a mess
Judge Judy would have shut the whole room up real quick
Honestly I don’t understand why the audience is laughing the way they are but they’re really f’ing annoying.
They really are disrespectful.
I totally agree, this is an intense situation and so rude in general.
Hey y'all. Tell me that Erick, as he is walking in 0:22 don't have the SAME look on his face as that dude that owes you money! Tell me!
He’s there to collect for himself, The dead don’t need money🙄
Jesus Christ is the only way to heaven amen 🙏🏾 John 14:6 amen 🙏🏾
No. Zeus is the way. BALLA 1-2-3
No it's not
Amen🙌🏿🙌🏿🙌🏿🙌🏿
Jesus is the only way.
@@Proverbspsalms Prove it. Oh you can't.
Wth Is the audience always laughing in court downtown Detroit it has to be silence in our court house, this seems to be a comedy, and the judge mathis leads the audience to laugh not cool
This case was VERY ANNOYING... And it DOES NOT HELP..When judge Mathis..WONT SHUT UP😩😩😩
Jamaica 🇯🇲 lovely 😍😊☺
Did unc jus did a gun sign?🤣🤣🤣the nephew really torn up.way to mess up someone's reputation..talking bout homegrown terrorists😔😔
Yeah too bad the audience isn't there to laugh at him for that one too!!!
Home grown
Menace to society?? 🤣🤣
Hi
Believe on Jesus in order to be in heaven
I declined because I was under duress…🤨 🥴🤷🏾♀️
🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲