Dr. Jonathan AC Brown - Hadith and the Development of the Western Historical Critical Method - 2012

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 32

  • @4681MM
    @4681MM 4 роки тому +38

    I remember hearing this talk a few years ago on another channel. I wish Dr. Akram Nadwi and Dr. Brown co-teach again! And mashallah Dr. Brown always looks the same whether it be 8 years ago or now! The only thing that seems to change is his constant increase in ilm and zuhd. An internally and externally beautiful scholar hafizahulla

  • @siffatnahar4697
    @siffatnahar4697 Рік тому +6

    What a wonderful course! May Allah bless Dr. Brown.

  • @zizou2003sm
    @zizou2003sm 3 роки тому +11

    Excellent talk. Complements his book on hadith really well. May Allah bless everyone involved in making this talk available for us.

    • @ARmirzaful
      @ARmirzaful Рік тому +1

      Aameen. A true balanced doctor...Brown the doctor we need but not the one we want. :)

    • @niket527
      @niket527 6 днів тому +1

      It's basically a summary of the hadith book he wrote, in case anyone doesn't have time to read it.

  • @aladinndrake110
    @aladinndrake110 3 роки тому +4

    Mashallah Amazing. May Allah Bless Dr Brown n his loved ones. I was so impressed to hear someone reaffirm that Allah and His Prophet is the ultimate authority in the life of a Muslim.

  • @Ronakalin70
    @Ronakalin70 3 роки тому +6

    An excellent talk, as always! Thank you dr. Brown.

  • @majeedkhan7515
    @majeedkhan7515 2 роки тому +3

    Dr. Brown is an impressive scholar.

  • @cdseventy6435
    @cdseventy6435 3 роки тому +5

    JazakAllah Dr. Brown. This was great

  • @retnadewayani6917
    @retnadewayani6917 4 роки тому +17

    Oh i watched the old youtube version was terrible but still i enjoyed his lecture tho i hd to replay it several times. This much better. Tq

  • @hamza1947
    @hamza1947 3 роки тому +3

    What an epic talk. I learned so much...

  • @nasdzeuropa4627
    @nasdzeuropa4627 3 роки тому +3

    MashaAllah may Allah almighty bless you

  • @hashmihere6379
    @hashmihere6379 3 роки тому +3

    Love 💖

  • @ARmirzaful
    @ARmirzaful Рік тому

    I always long for the England affirmation as well, lol. This scholar is really on a different planet, he really understands how orientalists think.

  • @bibishah7754
    @bibishah7754 2 роки тому +1

    To everyone searching information on UA-cam regarding islamic scriptual sources. Be critical if the UA-cam video does not allow comments. Propaganda is when critucal questions or comments are not allowed.

  • @NotesofKhan
    @NotesofKhan 11 місяців тому +1

    Amazing Lecture?

  • @AhmedIsa-no6iw
    @AhmedIsa-no6iw 3 роки тому +3

    iam ahmed from egypt i think you are musulm more than me ربنا يثبتك وينفع بيك الإسلام والمسلمين

  • @nabilrady6767
    @nabilrady6767 3 роки тому +3

    I am an Egyptian, can someone explain what's wrong with " The muslim brotherhood assassinated el saddat" ?

    • @BasedYeeter42
      @BasedYeeter42 3 роки тому +1

      They weren’t responsible for Sadat’s assassination, it was Gama’a Islamiyya instead

    • @antonisorususii4658
      @antonisorususii4658 2 роки тому

      يا عم
      لك مشايخ في مصر تستطيع أن تسألهم
      و ربنا أكرمك و جعلك مصري سبحان الله.
      في ايام مبارك درست في مصر (أم الدنيا)
      انصحك ان تدرس الاسلام و ان تتعلم دينك

    • @ofarah7902
      @ofarah7902 Рік тому

      the fact that it's completely made up nonesense. Clearly the fact you're Egyptian doesn't prevent you from believing false information.

  • @lana-ss6lo
    @lana-ss6lo 2 роки тому

    Interesting 🙂

  • @ej1068
    @ej1068 9 місяців тому +1

    1:44:35

  • @Kimeikus
    @Kimeikus Рік тому

    35:02 - Fantastic point. I was taking a religion class and it was based on the Historical Method and this was one of the major assumptions that we began with.
    50:40
    Another fantastic exposition.
    55:43
    Nice

    • @ARmirzaful
      @ARmirzaful Рік тому +3

      He is really solid at presenting non muslims criticisms in an unbiased manner. World Class Scholar.

    • @Kimeikus
      @Kimeikus Рік тому +3

      @@ARmirzaful
      I’ve been getting into his content more recently. He’s a fantastic speaker. May Allah increase him.

    • @hjj2892
      @hjj2892 Рік тому

      Assalamualaikum
      could you summarize his points brother? Im assuming you watched this full

  • @shihab2468
    @shihab2468 3 роки тому +4

    "Whole bunch of noise with no basis."

  • @katarianshareef8923
    @katarianshareef8923 Рік тому +1

    How norani face of his ma sha allah