Відео

Masha Allah

Ma Sha Allah

Thank you for this

AOA In my humble opinion, We should keep in mind/consider the difference between a person who is Arabic and a muslim (Ajmi) who who can't understand Arabic, We should not view them as same and apply Hadiths without taking this critical factor, If a hadith is quoted highlighting the virtues of reading (Tilawat) of the Qur'an and it was quoted to the Sahaba's who could understand and appreciate every word of it, and preach the same hadith to someone who does not understand Arabic, does not make sense to me, It cannot and should not be one size fits all !! Allah (swt) knew that fourteen centuries later Islam would spread around the World and 85% of the muslims would be unable to understand Arabic language, so he created resources for its translation into all the major languages, So that none may remain deprived of its Message, However most of the scholars still insist and continue on insisting to read it in the original Arabic script without advising that if we do not read it with understanding we would remain deprived of its fundamental purpose of revelation, See Surah Yusuf , Ayat 2, The key point in this ayat is "So that you may UNDERSTAND ". The key purpose described in the above ayat is to "UNDERSTAND," So how would we understand the message if we read the Qur'an in the language that we don't understand?? Either one should learn Arabic or read it in the language that one understands.

now see how they treat freelancers online.. as if we are literal slaves

❤🇮🇩

Christian guest had great answers..im muslim agnostic, was an salafi muslim for 10 years, left that sect bcs of these issues..harshness, we are right everyone is wrong, we can enslave, conquer and rule, we are the chosen ones arrogance..

I’m currently reading the book, the author gives a comprehensive overview of the development of Islamic philosophy and theology over the centuries. An excellent read.

excellent explanation about how to interpret hadith literature, mashaAllah

Dr. Jonathan Brown seems to have his own biases. Dr. Brown criticizes the Orientalists who use HCM, by pointing out their biases and making assumptions of what is probably going in their heads, yet he claims that the Orientalists cannot possibly do the same about how people back in the days used to think and act. So Dr. Brown actually uses HCM to attack the Orientalists and is confident that the method reveals Orientalists' true intentions! and yet is critical when HCM is used to weigh hadith narrators. He also sights how Qadi Iyad used HCM and pointed out defects in hadith, and seems to be proud of it, yet is very critical if a non-muslim scholar does the same using HCM. I believe that Dr. Brown, a revert from Christianity, would gladly welcome Orientalists' HCM and embrace their conclusions with no qualms when it comes to Biblical criticism or their doctrines. In this realm, it is possible for him to accept that the vast majority of scholars for 1500+ years across different cultures and traditions could all understand a doctrine as fundamental as trinity from the Gospel, yet they were all just wrong. But in the realm of hadith, it is impossible for the same to happen, not even for a fringe issue as Aisha's age. Regarding Aisha's age, Dr. Joshua Little makes arguments from silence (i.e. silence in medinan sources and early Hanafi fiqh sources) and he is being criticised for that. But Dr. Brown also makes the same argument from Silence (i.e no debates in islamic history about her age, not even by non-muslims). The silence in non-muslim sources (like John of Damascus) could probably be due to her age not being widely known at that time, which could be proof that the hadith came to be circulated much later. I think the argument that underaged marriage was common throughout history is inflated by Dr. Brown to include underaged girls of all ages. It is not the norm in any major society to marry off girls before puberty. It was only the exception. To unhesitantly inflate that to include a 6 year old girl reveals a BIAS that people like Dr. Brown have - which is - if u criticize hadiths in the "Sahih Canon", your whole traditional usul-ul-fiqh would fall apart. • They dont care about other reports that cite various ages from 6 to 16, • they dont care about the Quran making a connection of the Marriageable age to soundness of judgement in Surah Nisaa, • they dont consider why would the Prophet (sall.) marry a child of 6 in his year of grief, • they dont care if Hisham was a mudallis or became weak after her went go Iraq, • they dont care why Imam Malik (who also narrates from Hisham) doesn't narrate this hadith eventhough it's very useful for his fiqh, etc. etc. ••• All they care about is the "sanctity" of the "Saheehayn".

Well said but the part of the wars was wrong

Muslims use the historical critical method against Christians all the time!

I'm Sunni Muslim Arab and I don't think sahih bukhari is 100 % correct

😁🤲☝️❤️

Readi in Arabic with understanding I do so...

Salaam, Yes please tell us where you got the hoodie?… and welcome to the deen brother 🙏

Keşke kitaplarınız başka dillerde çıksaydi

Where did this jahil study Islam Doesn’t know nothin about Islam

let me comment on the hadith of Aisha's age رضي الله عنها 1.about the narrator Hisham ibn Urwah, he went to Kufa when he was old & there were several Islamic scholars علم رجال الحديث who said that he was struck by senility while in Kufa 2.Hisham spent much his time in Medina, & his most famous pupil was Imam Malik. but as far as I know I did not find this hadith in Al Muwatta. 3.for Az Zuhri ,, Ibn Hajr said that he was placed in the third group of 5 groups مدلس. Imam Shafii & Ad Duruqutni also said that Az Zuhri is مدلس. & Almost all the narrators under Hisham & Zuhri were Kufa people 4.we must remember the history about Shiites with Aisha & the majority of Kufa residents are Shia adherents. how they not liking Aisha (who was Abu Bakr's daughter). is it not possible that this hadith was "invented", to make Aisha's credibility lower as the wife of the prophet? that Aisyah married the prophet at a young age..so what does she know about political matters. (Aisha is very vocal about political issues) what is missing from Mr Brown's explanation is : 1 does not explain about علم الرجال of the NARRATORS. in the view of hadith experts, knowing the life history, personality, his medical history, even beliefs, & sect of a narrator, is a very important thing. why? because surely a person's background will influence his thinking or action to a greater or lesser extent. 2 does not explain the history of the sects that emerged throughout the history of Islamic civilization. in this case especially Shia, & how Shia views Aisha. 3 does not explain that this hadith can contradict Quran An Nisaa 6 & 19. while the function of hadith is to explain in more detail about the Koran, not to contradict the Koran verses

بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ dear dr. brown, i truly enjoyed yr work. May الله bless u & yr family with ❤. Thank u again for the education.

54:24

Great to hear more about professor Brown's personal perspectives

I would like to add my experience to help understand Aisha (RA) story. When I got married at the age of 20, one of my non-Muslim friend’s boyfriend told her like he wondered who would like to marry me, since I looked like a kid. I was short and kinda under developed for my age plus cute looking. I can recollect I always got advantages of being treated as a kid, even after getting into job. That said, marriage happened, started consummating… I had given an initial consent, but it turned out that I was hating the act and the frequency. My friends noticed I was gloomy at work. I even started praying to conceive inorder to get a break. Long story short, after 2 deliveries only I started enjoying sexual life.. and now I consider my past as a medical condition I had because of may be hormonal issues, malnutrition , over exposure to rape news etc. I sometimes miss those early days.. Rape fantasies are true for many women. So in total, my point is Aisha’s story is morally OK for people like me because of the below beliefs 1. Biological development is not always dependent on age. 2. Even if a woman is underdeveloped, marital rape happens and it is fine. Even if she may not feel it then, she may feel good about it after. Like, if 110 billion people ever lived in earth, there are that many possibilities of relationships. Sometimes I feel like non scholarly, non academic people have larger insight on such matters because they don’t try to generalise things for study.

Well that was vapid. You didn't actually say anything of importance or new. Just went around in circular logic.

but us who are not arabic. if we read and we make mistakes in reading, than what? that is my largest fear. Dr Brown, can you help me on this question?

Mashallah!

Dr. Brown is an ocean of ilm, mashallah

I am the first to like this video

Dr. Brown's contributions keep going up and up mashallah! Hafizahulla

Jonathan Brown : intersectional Atha'ari

Dr Brown ... as brilliant always!!! 👏

Why is this video here? There's no Dr Brown

Very insightful from Dr. Brown and I love the keffiyeh themed jacket!

Ramadan Kareem, Dr. Jonathan, and to the entire Islamic nation

Assalamualaikum I am the first to like this video

1:44:35

Dr Brown is a gem. Now I can see almost everyone is a slave in one form or the other.

Amazing Lecture?

I was very happy to hear the host laugh at tucker giving an attempt at a sincere "the prophet pbuh" lol

What are you talking about slavery isn’t forbidden what is this you fraud! [7:33] Say, "My Lord prohibits only evil deeds, be they obvious or hidden, and sins, and unjustifiable aggression, and to set up beside GOD powerless idols, and to say about GOD what you do not know."

Assalamu alaikum professor Brown, You always give us something deep to ponder upon regarding current situation. What an intellectual genius Allah has gifted our ummah. May Allah increase your knowledge and ability to teach.

Jazzak Allah Kheir!

Sunah? Which frqa sunnah to follow.Quran says sunatullah ,guide me it’s making me confused always😊

Dr Jonathan still looking handsome as ever mashAllah

Shia muslims don't believe in sufism

When u agreed on salafism i think u still live in "misquoting muhammad". No harsh Islam. Sufi is the best interpretation of Prophet Muhammad life of joy, sad, peaceful, wisdom and everything that flourish islamic golden age.. Islam is not about takfir people and wasting time with debate..like all those wahabis did

This is so cool! I wish Dr. Brown did these kind of setting talks more often!

I can't wait for Dr. Brown's next book!

Yahya related to me from Malik that he heard that the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, said, "I have left two matters with you. As long as you hold to them, you will not go the wrong way. They are the Book of Allah and the Sunna of His Prophet." Muwatta Malik USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 46, Hadith 3 Arabic reference : Book 46, Hadith 1628

It was narrated from ‘Awf bin Malik that the Messenger of Allah(ﷺ) said: “The Jews split into seventy-one sects, one of which will be in Paradise and seventy in Hell. The Christians split into seventy-two sects, seventy-one of which will be in Hell and one in Paradise. I swear by the One Whose Hand is the soul of Muhammad, my nation will split into seventy-three sects, one of which will be in Paradise and seventy-two in Hell.” It was said: “O Messenger of Allah, who are they?” He said: “The main body.” Hasan (Darussalam) Reference : Sunan Ibn Majah 3992 In-book reference : Book 36, Hadith 67 English translation : Vol. 5, Book 36, Hadith 3992