Knock at the Cabin - Review

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @zeadsi
    @zeadsi Рік тому +2

    I dislike The Visit as well, but calling it "a movie made by a moron for morons" to describe a creative and fans of the work is a really tactless/pathetic thing to say. If M Night and his fans enjoy his brand of cinema, so be it. Someone's affinity to a specific artistic creation is not a measurement of their intellect. That was a very moronic thing to say.

  • @FCSchaefer
    @FCSchaefer Рік тому +3

    Sounds like the same old Shyamalan: he knows how to sell an interesting premise, but just can't stick the landing, and give us a satisfying payoff, which is what you absolutely have to do in a thriller.

    • @ryanisfollin
      @ryanisfollin Рік тому +1

      he has good movies, lots actually. the village, 6th sense, unbreakable, lady in the water, signs

  • @upgradED32
    @upgradED32 Рік тому +5

    Just saw the movie.... it wasn't great but wasn't bad either. Felt like 2020 though and a movie I think people shouldn't watch at the theater cause it's not a feel good movie. It's amazing this movie exists cause it was probably made during the pandemic and who wants to experience this again after what took place in 2020. People should pass on this one.

    • @collectornick4270
      @collectornick4270 Рік тому

      I know what you mean. Earlier when I heard about that massive earthquake in the middle east, all I could think was "A part of humanity has been judged." It kind of freaks you out a little bit.

  • @tjk3430
    @tjk3430 Рік тому +1

    I love how scorched earth (yet fair & valid) this review was on M. Kight's latest flick and career in general.

  • @batgurrl
    @batgurrl Рік тому +4

    Thanks James. 🙏☮️No matter how hard he tries, he will never match ‘the magic’ of The Sixth Sense. With one of AFI’s top 100 movie quotes, I see Dead people (American Film Institute)

  • @amcaesar
    @amcaesar Рік тому +3

    Here's why you keep going to see these -- there are vanishingly few filmmakers who are, themselves, the brand and franchise. And he's one of them, deserved or not.

  • @mohammadalirashed3103
    @mohammadalirashed3103 Рік тому +2

    I liked the movie, so I was curious to know why you didn't. I'd be down if you did a spoiler talk on why you thought the ending was dumb, and the logic of the movie was incoherent. I felt like it followed through on its premise. I admit that the themes weren't handled with subtlety, they were more or less spoon fed to the audience. Also the acting was a bit melodramatic. That said it didn't sour the experience for me.

  • @marinbobicmb
    @marinbobicmb Рік тому +2

    Off the topic, what did you think of Babylon?

  • @boyfromoz7
    @boyfromoz7 Рік тому +2

    Do you like any of his movie? Not the biggest fan.. I liked the aesthetics of The Village and the premise was cool but don't think to hard about it. I didn't hate Lady in the Water though I don't remember it so well. And I enjoyed Signs. Unbreakable and Split but thought Glass was a bit of a let down. I found the others I'd seen pretty stupid and he's yet to make a great movie. Maybe someone else should write him a good script and see what we can do just as a director?

    • @ryanisfollin
      @ryanisfollin Рік тому

      yeah i think most of his films are good; a few stinkers like avatar but for the most part they are above average. i loved the village, unbreakable, signs, 6th sense

  • @AdrianMendoza23
    @AdrianMendoza23 Рік тому

    You're a masochist James. I thought it was alright. It did begin to lose water towards the end. The only saving grace is the couple and their kid. I was rooting for them throughout.

  • @djalixer
    @djalixer Рік тому

    I’ve never see this happen at a movie theater but everyone could be seen gathering their things eager to leave a good 10 minutes before the movie finished. Definitely not a crowd pleasure. It was moronic.

  • @peybak
    @peybak Рік тому +1

    Don't worry James, I'll listen to the spoilers. TBH, it sounds like another Shamalama Ding Dong hit!

  • @samantaluna3870
    @samantaluna3870 Рік тому

    If the ending is bad is that Shaymalan's fault or Tremblay's fault? Do they stick to the original story?

  •  Рік тому +2

    Oh no!

  • @wormynp1384
    @wormynp1384 Рік тому

    You should review Hair-Trigger!

  • @AdrianMendoza23
    @AdrianMendoza23 Рік тому +2

    That's too bad. Thnx. James.

  • @clintwarner3008
    @clintwarner3008 Рік тому

    He got lucky wit sixth sense. He has been on the decline for some time now. But for whatever reason people keep giving him money so he can direct another piece of shit. Mayb he shud employ good writers to actually write the script, and he can concentrate on directing the visuals.

  • @marca5883
    @marca5883 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the review James💚🇬🇧🌱 slim pickings indeed...👍

  • @musicmann1967
    @musicmann1967 Рік тому

    Too bad Paul Tremblay's first adaptation seems to be a failure, at least in Jame's eyes. Although I haven't read "Cabin At THe End of the World", the novel on which this is based, I've read several other Tremblay novels and he's very good. This movie seems to be 'split' as far as opinions go (sorry) so I'll decide for myself. Seeing it tomorrow.

  • @marca5883
    @marca5883 Рік тому

    The Ark looks promising? 💚🇬🇧🌱

  • @sethkinle2254
    @sethkinle2254 Рік тому

    Love the CoC shirt. Deep cut

  • @novasite7795
    @novasite7795 Рік тому

    The book is better. More ambiguous (until the end).

  • @marca5883
    @marca5883 Рік тому +1

    Talking of rubbish movies, I got to see Black panther 2 last night... WOW 😳

  • @joeyjeffrey5892
    @joeyjeffrey5892 Рік тому

    I don't know I haven't seen it but I said it was frontrunner for movie of the year. Neck and neck with Oppenheimer.

    • @L33Reacts
      @L33Reacts Рік тому +1

      Nolan and M night aren’t even in the same universe man. M night has been a hack since the village, Nolan is still firing on all cylinders.

    • @joeyjeffrey5892
      @joeyjeffrey5892 Рік тому

      @@L33Reacts Yeah I know...was making fun of James calling out Oppenheimer as frontrunner for movie of the year even though he hasn't even seen it.

  • @temisanpopo8036
    @temisanpopo8036 Рік тому

    lol

  • @JukeHighwalker
    @JukeHighwalker Рік тому

    It stunk. Needless insert of the director in an infomercial just before a pivotal setup instantly throwing away any built tension, horrendous "TV" editing and a terrible third act ultimately ending with a gay guy being the new Jesus. Talk about preachy...