'No red dawn' massive Labour majority 'no surge for socialism' | Andrew Neil

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лип 2024
  • “This is no great surge for socialism. This is no Red Dawn.”
    Times Radio's Andrew Neil advises Labour to keep in mind that support for the party “is wide, but it’s shallow.”
    📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
    📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
    🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
    📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 682

  • @cretene1
    @cretene1 Місяць тому +224

    its not a labour vote its anti consevative

    • @darrell3716
      @darrell3716 Місяць тому +10

      @@cretene1 100 %

    • @BrianWMay
      @BrianWMay Місяць тому +7

      Exactly correct.

    • @loveulez
      @loveulez Місяць тому +14

      Crying Tories are confused

    • @nathupatel3782
      @nathupatel3782 Місяць тому +3

      You right

    • @hackinggeopolitics782
      @hackinggeopolitics782 Місяць тому +3

      You know we used to have a system like the UK in Northern Ireland, they called it gerrymandering - where 50% of the vote only got 25% of the seats.... caused pretty much a civil war over here you might remember. Wonder why the people of britain are so accepting of it?

  • @michaeltb1358
    @michaeltb1358 Місяць тому +54

    The Reform party took as many votes from the Conservatives as Labour. Thanks to the first past the post system Labour got all the benefits.

    • @paulLFC93
      @paulLFC93 Місяць тому +12

      It's been like this for years. Interesting how now Labour have benefited from it it's become a problem for people

    • @BegudMaximan-zp2tc
      @BegudMaximan-zp2tc Місяць тому +1

      In a truely fair elective system, the unfairness of first past the post would not exist.
      But it is in place to prevent fairness, as the elites of the status quo wish it to be that way, which favours playing to their tune.

    • @paulLFC93
      @paulLFC93 Місяць тому

      @@BegudMaximan-zp2tc you think the elites are Labour voters 🤣 Labour that plan to tax the rich. Do you realise how daft you sound?

    • @G_C340
      @G_C340 Місяць тому

      Thank God

    • @PumaKing4Ever
      @PumaKing4Ever Місяць тому

      ​@@G_C340get in the real world

  • @nowgrownup
    @nowgrownup Місяць тому +94

    Starmer is Sunak in a different suit both WEF puppets controlled by the same puppet master 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @cd9278
      @cd9278 Місяць тому +4

      And the great controller is who exactly ?

    • @Nik1718
      @Nik1718 Місяць тому +6

      go on, just say jews

    • @garethwatkins6347
      @garethwatkins6347 Місяць тому +1

      Spot on ❤❤❤

    • @MichaelLees-libertus
      @MichaelLees-libertus Місяць тому +2

      ​@@cd9278The family of the red shield

    • @ibrstellar1080
      @ibrstellar1080 Місяць тому

      @@cd9278 The Zionist banking cartel.

  • @geoffcurrie5508
    @geoffcurrie5508 Місяць тому +23

    It is NOT a swing to Labour!!!

    • @gerryparker7699
      @gerryparker7699 Місяць тому

      As a labour voter I know it's not. The entire vote is one of desperation in our political institutions and those that rise to the top of it. There is a crisis in political confidence. Their accountability is not proportional to their responsibility. They say they govern for the UK as a whole but end up feathering their own nests or actively/through inaction, benefit those powerbrokers that put them their etc etc. Serious checks and balances into MP/PM conduct is needed ASAP.

  • @user-fz8ep5ey4v
    @user-fz8ep5ey4v Місяць тому +21

    Tory votes went to Reform not Labour, in fact some Labour members lost votes badly including Kier Starmer .

    • @georgemather9082
      @georgemather9082 Місяць тому

      Today is the tories day of reckoning. They are on their way.
      Labour will get theirs. The Muslim vote along with the socialist vote will slowly peal away. I give the government a year before they start to crumble. Realignment is coming.

    • @paulm2467
      @paulm2467 Місяць тому +4

      @@user-fz8ep5ey4v yes but he didn't lose them to the Tories or Reform, he lost them to a single issue Moslem party opposing his stance on Gaza.

    • @nautilusshell4969
      @nautilusshell4969 Місяць тому

      Keir, not Kier, like Rishi, not Richi

  • @rbir2653
    @rbir2653 Місяць тому +62

    The labour share of the vote is not great for next time. Their percentages are fragile. That is what mr Neil is saying.

    • @SlowhandGreg
      @SlowhandGreg Місяць тому

      We had voter suppression with ID cards and endless talk of a super majority also the Tory messaging was project fear on steroids take a look at some of the Tory messaging it's dystopian

    • @compactcasette
      @compactcasette Місяць тому

      They will have 5 years of importing new Labour voters. Plus, they intend to drop the voting age to 16. They will be in power until the country is handed over to the EU.

    • @kingflynxi9420
      @kingflynxi9420 Місяць тому +4

      As long as the right is split between Conservative and Reform, we should see Labour winning seats

    • @leefox5596
      @leefox5596 Місяць тому

      ​@@kingflynxi9420they'll will be merged by then and if labour don't come to centre they will lose more to Dems

    • @axelbruv
      @axelbruv Місяць тому +5

      ​@@kingflynxi9420They'll merge.

  • @pv-mm2or
    @pv-mm2or Місяць тому +11

    this not a country for old men!

  • @rh8528
    @rh8528 Місяць тому +15

    The campaigns had nothing to do with it

  • @Steve-ys1ig
    @Steve-ys1ig Місяць тому +74

    What amazes me is that Reform get 14.4% of the vote which was more than the Lib Dems 12.2% = Reform 4 seats, Lib-Dems 71 seats. The Greens 6% = 4 seats. Plaid Cymru 0.7% = 4 seats. Something not right here

    • @xazarl3381
      @xazarl3381 Місяць тому +10

      Well take liz truss seat for example labour 11.8k, conservative 11.2k and reform 9.8k. So reform is getting lots of votes and taking from conservatives but it gives labour the wins this election. If some of those conservative people jump to reform next election could be a blow out.

    • @user-jo9yw6bj6z
      @user-jo9yw6bj6z Місяць тому +10

      It just shows you how well Labour and the LibDems campaigned in those targeted seats that they needed to win in FPTP system.

    • @nleak92
      @nleak92 Місяць тому +19

      Shows how broken our political system is

    • @Jamal-Ahmed786
      @Jamal-Ahmed786 Місяць тому +10

      Then it's reforms fault for not campaigning tactically in targeted seats

    • @billder2655
      @billder2655 Місяць тому

      shows that lib dem’s actually care about getting seats on local councils and working FPTP the way it is meant to be worked… creating a local support network and building upon local strengths. this is the way democracy works in the UK, it has worked this way for a long time - if farage wanted to create a proper party he has had more than enough time

  • @davidbent347
    @davidbent347 Місяць тому +110

    2017 - Corbyn - 12,877,918
    2019 - Corbyn - 10,269,051
    2024 - Starma - 9,634,399

    • @mikeelliott886
      @mikeelliott886 Місяць тому +13

      What was the percentage of the vote share though. Voter turnout was much lower than in 2019.

    • @SlowhandGreg
      @SlowhandGreg Місяць тому

      what's your point Corbyn was unelectable as a PM under FPTP and would still be unelectable under PR
      We had a huge amount of 1 voter suppression and 2 tactical voting

    • @SlowhandGreg
      @SlowhandGreg Місяць тому

      I'd add the date was deliberately chosen to try and suppress the Youth vote

    • @xazarl3381
      @xazarl3381 Місяць тому +16

      @@mikeelliott886 Labour won because at every conservative seat reform took votes from them. Take Liz Truss seat for example 11.8k for labour, 11.2k conservative, reform 9.8k so Reform took 9.8k votes from the conservatives in that seat and lost it they did this at every seat 20-50% of the vote went from conservative to reform making labour win. Next election will be interesting.

    • @simplesimon5739
      @simplesimon5739 Місяць тому +12

      2017 68.8%
      2019 67.3%
      2024 60.0%

  • @CupOfSweetTea
    @CupOfSweetTea Місяць тому +73

    Labour campaigned for a landslide number of seats, which they got, not a landslide number of votes.

    • @superhumantrueman
      @superhumantrueman Місяць тому +3

      But still more seats than anyone else. By a long shot.

    • @superhumantrueman
      @superhumantrueman Місяць тому

      @3brenm Its funny how the right only care about the flaws of FPTP when they have lost. Regardless, Labour have a stonking great majority under the system that everyones been perfectly happy with prior to this.

    • @eddyd63
      @eddyd63 Місяць тому +5

      @3brenm Labour campaigned for vote efficiency because of FPTP. Campaigning in PR is entirely different and would require a change of strategy. The exact percentages don't tell the complete picture.

    • @vulgar_scabby_beaver
      @vulgar_scabby_beaver Місяць тому

      funnily enough....seats are all that matter, your point?

    • @James-872
      @James-872 Місяць тому

      I know its a little too early in the day but will Keir be moving back to the promised 2019 manifesto 😮 or do we just assume the colour red is democratic socialism and manifestos are not needed 😂 Starmer is a Red Tory

  • @deanbenn918
    @deanbenn918 Місяць тому +54

    I feel there is a great amount of anger with the election system and this election only validates, this anger for example 9.6mil people vote labour and 412 seats resulting in 23,482 people per seat. On the otherhand. Reform got 4mil votes and got 4 seats resulting 1,021,974 people per seat. You can see the issue.

    • @jogreeen
      @jogreeen Місяць тому +5

      seethe, people just don't want the Reform party, they would have voted for them if they did. Seethe for 5 years.

    • @potopasta3044
      @potopasta3044 Місяць тому +13

      @@jogreeen They did

    • @sh.4409
      @sh.4409 Місяць тому

      Foreigners and their kids born here or not shouldn't get to vote.

    • @fabriciomanuel8775
      @fabriciomanuel8775 Місяць тому +7

      @@jogreeendo you know how fptp works

    • @nleak92
      @nleak92 Місяць тому +11

      ​@@jogreeenmore people voted for reform than the lib dems but the lib dems got more seats. Can you make that make sense?

  • @JeanRinger
    @JeanRinger Місяць тому +5

    They will make a massive mess then they will blame the tories

    • @user-qg2bt2qt9l
      @user-qg2bt2qt9l 29 днів тому +1

      There is already a massive mess. The Tories have left leaving a national debt at £2.7trillion!

  • @neilpearson157
    @neilpearson157 Місяць тому +42

    Two thirds of the electorate did not vote Labour.

    • @superhumantrueman
      @superhumantrueman Місяць тому

      So? They won the most seats, which is how elections work.

    • @Govanmauler
      @Govanmauler Місяць тому +8

      Remind what percentage of the electorate didn't vote for brexit ?

    • @robbiekop7
      @robbiekop7 Місяць тому +1

      What Brexit ? 😲

    • @oranjeblue70
      @oranjeblue70 Місяць тому +1

      Only 37% of the electorate voted for Brexit. In this election, 20% voted Labour. Draw your own conclusions.

    • @msimms-lp5qw
      @msimms-lp5qw Місяць тому

      @@oranjeblue70 Yes ,but that again is taking into account people who didn't vote. Their opinion is irrelevant

  • @Yomi-san
    @Yomi-san Місяць тому +8

    60% turnout, 35% of that vote is not a massive vote of confidence.

    • @msimms-lp5qw
      @msimms-lp5qw Місяць тому

      I agree ,but those who dont vote-dont count, Their opinion is null and void

    • @Yomi-san
      @Yomi-san Місяць тому

      @@msimms-lp5qw apathy is the death of democracy

    • @rob8493
      @rob8493 Місяць тому +1

      @@msimms-lp5qwThere opinions are not null and void. They weren’t inspired by anyone to vote. They didnt like anyone so what are they supposed to do.
      Vote for change. Don’t make me laugh.
      Let’s sit back and watch labour mess it up like they usually do,
      Let’s see all these millions of Lego built housing estates pop up all over the place. Let’s see our taxes rise and all our money being spent obsessed with net zero.
      I am genuinely concerned now labour are in!

  • @duckndive.
    @duckndive. Місяць тому +16

    Ooh! Sectarian voting Jonathan Ashworth, who would have guessed that would happen.

    • @davidrenton
      @davidrenton Місяць тому +1

      i head Aldi are hiring, he might be in luck

    • @dartskipper3170
      @dartskipper3170 Місяць тому

      I was watching a debate on the Parliament channel and Ashworth was sitting at the far end if the front bench in an almost empty chamber. He was staring at his phone screen and picking his nose. Very dignified, I'm sure.😂

    • @davidcooks2379
      @davidcooks2379 Місяць тому

      Islamists are taking over. Who will stop them?

  • @TheSkaffen
    @TheSkaffen Місяць тому +79

    Super majority with less than 20% of the electorates support.
    Quality Democracy.

    • @Jail_The_Far_Right
      @Jail_The_Far_Right Місяць тому

      Farage the Fraudster better look over his shoulder and stay away from Russian tea houses.🤣4 lousy seats like the tree hugging Greens. He promised Putin so much and he delivered so little.

    • @SlowhandGreg
      @SlowhandGreg Місяць тому +10

      Blame the Tories for all the voter suppression tactics
      I expect Labour to widen ID acceptability and introduce automatic voter registration as part of expanding the franchise

    • @jjharson7344
      @jjharson7344 Місяць тому +1

      @@SlowhandGreg let's hope they do.... I doubt it though.

    • @jogreeen
      @jogreeen Місяць тому +6

      Faridge got 5%, i thought the Reform movement was what the British people wanted.

    • @britishempire2501
      @britishempire2501 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@jogreeen Reform voters are just a bunch of noisy people who are high on culture war cool-aid, nothing more, nothing less

  • @soupalex
    @soupalex Місяць тому +6

    "this is no great surge for socialism"
    that's right. because starmer isn't a socialist.
    (it's not a surge for the labour party, either, so much as a surge for "please, god, not the tories, anything but that!". i just take exception to the assumption that, because labour didn't win so much as the tories lost, this therefore means that _socialism_ is unpopular. A->B and B->C does not assert that A->C; B may have other indicators than A, and C may be influenced by factors beyond B)

    • @soupalex
      @soupalex Місяць тому

      @PhoenixLord777 i know, it should be a given that the leader of the _labour_ party be a socialist, but yet…

    • @msimms-lp5qw
      @msimms-lp5qw Місяць тому

      Of course, they're a social capitalist blend- Like China😀

  • @Fedora_JP
    @Fedora_JP Місяць тому +5

    Because kier isnt a socialist , just like rishi wasnt conservative

    • @_Too_Late
      @_Too_Late Місяць тому +3

      Sir Keir was literally the former editor of 'Socialist Alternatives', a Trotskyist radical magazine, produced by an organisation under the same name, which represented the British section of the International Revolutionary Marxist Tendency (IRMT)

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому +1

      @@_Too_Late but now an avowed Centrist

    • @_Too_Late
      @_Too_Late Місяць тому +1

      @@joso7228 And if you believe that I've got a little red book to sell you

    • @Fedora_JP
      @Fedora_JP Місяць тому +1

      @_Too_Late and Liz truss was a liberal and Boris wanted remain. Right now in this moment , kier is not a socialist. A real socialist (corbyn) couldn't get into power, hence why the progressives in the labour party are not in love with kier.

  • @laurelhardymarx
    @laurelhardymarx Місяць тому +4

    Keir Starmer is literally the former editor of 'Socialist Alternatives', a Trotskyist radical magazine.

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      who has grown to a Centrist platform
      i was a hippy but i engage in the system now

    • @stuartmunro2474
      @stuartmunro2474 Місяць тому

      And since then he sold Corbyn out to an Israeli smear campaign. Starmer won - but Labour lost - this guy is more of a chameleon than Blair, and will end up being equally despised.

    • @markmasterson4811
      @markmasterson4811 Місяць тому

      So what?

  • @JeanRinger
    @JeanRinger Місяць тому +2

    Starmer is being run by Blair the liar

  • @janehersey7456
    @janehersey7456 Місяць тому +27

    No surge for a fairer society under Labour which had it's heart ripped out by Blair.

    • @simonjess8471
      @simonjess8471 Місяць тому +2

      It was the choice of changing or never being electable.

    • @garycant9399
      @garycant9399 Місяць тому

      So the correct way to get elected is to ditch all the principles you stood for, and adopt and assimilate the policies of your opposition. Otherwise known as opportunism, self serving opportunism!

    • @simonjess8471
      @simonjess8471 Місяць тому

      @@garycant9399 I am making no comment on the rights and wrongs of. It is simply an explanation as to why it happened.

  • @pauls3204
    @pauls3204 Місяць тому +23

    It is NOT a landslide , not by any remote means
    The numbers yes, the percentage of votes or vote increase NO ! Sir Starmer hasn’t increased the vote level so stop the rhetoric , barely 60% bothered to vote , that is one thing that should be addressed , mandatory voting is a minimal requirement in this parliament.

    • @cornishcat11
      @cornishcat11 Місяць тому +6

      why mandatory voting? if someone does not want to vote mind your own business

    • @hermanmunster3358
      @hermanmunster3358 Місяць тому

      It is CRIMINAL that in a General Election, the Turnout is around 50-60%
      It is ALSO Criminal that a 35% share of that vote, can translate to 70% or so, of ALL parliamentary seats.
      THIS is not Democracy, it is a GROSS MANIPULATION, of which both the Tories AND Labour have been guilty of perpetuating, for decades.
      Honour amongst Electoral Thieves!

    • @hermanmunster3358
      @hermanmunster3358 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@cornishcat11
      It is our CIVIC DUTY to cast our vote. Many lives were lost fighting for the right of the masses to choose their own representatives. And to refuse to vote, is to refuse to honour those who sacrificed their lives for that right.
      You may not know them, you may not care, but THEY made the sacrifice for YOU. So at least repay the respect by engaging in the process which was hard won!

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      @@hermanmunster3358 my 19 year old daughter voted but her friend said she had no interest in politics. And thats her Democratic right including staying away from seedy politicians and stories about nazis.

    • @alanrobertson9790
      @alanrobertson9790 Місяць тому

      @@hermanmunster3358 "It is our CIVIC DUTY to cast our vote". Why? If you want to vote, vote. If you don't want to, well don't. I would say people fought for democracy and the right of people to vote if they want to. Suppose you don't like anyone, recognise you know anything, have no interest or just can't be bothered. Well that should be fine. Why the compulsion?

  • @johneaston2293
    @johneaston2293 Місяць тому +3

    Labour now has 4/5 years to prove they can do a better job i hope they manage it well or we are back to square one .Good luck

  • @JK-pe6ft
    @JK-pe6ft Місяць тому +2

    Progressive parties collectively received a narrow majority of the votes like they usually do. While it was slightly higher than usual, the big difference is that those votes translated to seats much more efficiently, so we will now have a government that is perhaps a little more representative of what the electorate voted for... insofar that is possible under FPTP.

  • @blauewaffel1469
    @blauewaffel1469 Місяць тому +32

    ‘Are our offshore piles of loot safe? We’re not going to get t-t-t-taxed, are we? Please say our loot is safe 😬’

    • @andyp8464
      @andyp8464 Місяць тому

      It's not loot 😂

    • @loveulez
      @loveulez Місяць тому +7

      @@andyp8464oh yes it is

    • @EyebrowsGaming
      @EyebrowsGaming Місяць тому +3

      @@andyp8464 It is loot, and it's absolutely safe.

    • @ibrstellar1080
      @ibrstellar1080 Місяць тому

      Are you talking about the majority of Liebour and Con-servative MPs?

    • @justinstephenson9360
      @justinstephenson9360 Місяць тому +2

      You clearly are unaware that income from foreign assets (such as cash held offshore) is already subject to tax and has been for a long time. Given the number of information sharing arrangements HMRC has with foreign tax authorities there is little chance of hiding that income

  • @Gary0557
    @Gary0557 Місяць тому +4

    They barely increased their vote from 2019, it's just that the Tories voted Lib Dem or Reform.

    • @buzz1867
      @buzz1867 Місяць тому +1

      Correct! The right wing vote was split... Reformers crying but they know the rules before any vote is cast! Cudda wudda shudda syndrome 😂

    • @Robcupra360
      @Robcupra360 Місяць тому

      Didn’t they get less than 2019?

    • @Gary0557
      @Gary0557 Місяць тому

      @@Robcupra360 I thought they got 1.5 to 2% more. I could be wrong.

    • @Robcupra360
      @Robcupra360 Місяць тому

      @@Gary0557 not sure looked earlier they got 9.7 million votes but 10.2 million in 2019. Percentage may be more in their favour but less physical votes.

    • @Gary0557
      @Gary0557 Місяць тому

      @@Robcupra360 So Corbyn got more votes than Starmer.😂

  • @jean-lucpicard5510
    @jean-lucpicard5510 Місяць тому +2

    When even Andrew neil can see through Starmer.

  • @johnmoulton9728
    @johnmoulton9728 Місяць тому +2

    It’s a protest vote

  • @psibug565
    @psibug565 Місяць тому +4

    I’m not watching but am wondering if the coping and seething song needs to be played over this. What ever this is it is a massive loss for the Conservatives. I hope some other party replaces them that can actually hold this new government to account when needed. Reform or Liberal Democrat I’m not fussy just so long as it’s not this failed pathetic excuse for a party known as the Conservatives.

  • @bauer9101
    @bauer9101 Місяць тому +37

    Andrew, you were there at the Birth of GB News. Not to overstate your impact but you kind of got the ball rolling on all this.

    • @Jail_The_Far_Right
      @Jail_The_Far_Right Місяць тому

      Farage the Fraudster better look over his shoulder and stay away from Russian tea houses.🤣4 lousy seats like the tree hugging Greens. He promised Putin so much and he delivered so little.

    • @SimonSmith-yd6tt
      @SimonSmith-yd6tt Місяць тому +4

      Neil is deluded

    • @paddy6859
      @paddy6859 Місяць тому +4

      He also left sharpish when he saw the direction of the channel

  • @rh8528
    @rh8528 Місяць тому +2

    100 % prtest vote... only thing to worry about is Muslim vote effects

  • @Lightworkers.
    @Lightworkers. Місяць тому +8

    The UK historically has always hated extremes in politics. In general we are centre left and centre right. Whenever a party goes too far right or too left, the country reacts. This result is exactly that.

    • @williamdoonan736
      @williamdoonan736 Місяць тому +2

      Really? In what way were the Tories too far to the right? What do you understand by “right-wing”? The whole surge in support for Reform at the Tories’ expense was because they were too centrist. If the Tories are to be a centrist party, what’s the point in them? Why not just vote Lib Dem? Actually, I think the Tories should dissolve and merge with Lib Dems and Reform.

    • @williamdoonan736
      @williamdoonan736 Місяць тому

      @@Lightworkers. - just another point. There’s a perception that Starmer’s Labour is some sort of moderate centre-left party. I don’t think it is, and I think many people are going to get a shock when they realise what they’ve actually voted for.

    • @williamdoonan736
      @williamdoonan736 Місяць тому

      @3brenm - maybe so, but I think this is definitely true of Starmer’s Labour. If you haven’t already seen it, I’d recommend the last two episodes of David Starkey Talks. Yes, I too am in favour of re-nationalising the railways (among other things), and I note the small ‘c’ in your conservatism. The SDP are my party of choice, but they don’t stand where I live so I can’t vote for them.

  • @britishempire2501
    @britishempire2501 Місяць тому +25

    For people who think Labour is socialist.
    Labour changed from being a socialist party to just a party for workers after Tony Blair changed their objective. Keir Starmer had removed the last old-school socialists in the Labour Party & will try to block any new ones from joining.

    • @sjoyce100
      @sjoyce100 Місяць тому

      they are neo liberal/globalist

    • @uncletomsapprentice5733
      @uncletomsapprentice5733 Місяць тому

      Kier Starmer a self-described socialist is now Prime Minister OR should I believe you?

    • @mehegama
      @mehegama Місяць тому

      And that's a good thing. The vast majority of people are usually centrists. Left old style socialist policies are not popular, neither far right populist ones. Stay in the centre and that is what people mostly want

    • @ddmp1703
      @ddmp1703 Місяць тому +1

      What about Rayner? she's the one in charge.

    • @johnireland7612
      @johnireland7612 Місяць тому

      And the unions.

  • @robertnicholson1409
    @robertnicholson1409 Місяць тому +1

    It will end in tears........ it's a return to the past !

  • @hew34
    @hew34 Місяць тому +1

    "this is no red dawn", says man with reddist gammon red face you can imagine.

  • @informedchoice2249
    @informedchoice2249 Місяць тому +16

    I don't think anyone expected a sea change towards socialism, nor do I think the Labour party necessarily represents that. The Muslim vote is going to be more and more of a problem as time goes on.

    • @Shabs2456
      @Shabs2456 Місяць тому

      The Muslims like to live in a fair and just society, many Muslims follow the teachings of the Quran - read It and learn what it says. Of course it goes without saying that are some bad apples in the cart!

  • @kasperchristiansen4234
    @kasperchristiansen4234 Місяць тому +1

    Many seats for Labour but not so extreme in percentage:
    Labour 33.7%
    Green 6.8 %
    Conservative 23.7%
    Reform UK 14.3%
    Liberal Democrat 12.2%
    The great irony is that all the policies people are angry about (high prices, immigration & crime) are all Labour policies that the Conservatives have adopted.

  • @pilot3003
    @pilot3003 Місяць тому +5

    We need proportional representation in this country, when Reform pulled in 14% and got 4 seats whilst Tories got 24% of the votes and get 121 seats, this is everything that is wrong with this countries electoral system, totally bias towards two parties and totally un-fair. It needs to change ! In theory Reform should have 91 seats and the Tories 156 seats !

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      Did you shout about PR when the Greens complained years ago?

  • @ergunyildizoglu8018
    @ergunyildizoglu8018 Місяць тому +4

    New Labour has no diffrence then Conservative party.
    Why New Labour? They should have called New Conservative instead new Labour

    • @andyp8464
      @andyp8464 Місяць тому

      They're left wing so it's correct to call them labour

    • @cehaem2
      @cehaem2 Місяць тому +5

      @@andyp8464 There's nothing left-wing about Starmer's Labour. They ran on a centrist platform. Lots of slogans but if you carefully look at their manifesto it could have been Macron's.

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      Tories = Corruption
      Labour = Fairness

    • @John-kc4cg
      @John-kc4cg Місяць тому

      @@cehaem2 The platform they run on doesn't matter, what they do in power does. The Tories have promised to decrease immigration for years and have only increased it to the largest numbers in our history, they say they will cut tax but here we are with the highest taxes since WW2.
      Starmer will talk tough but when the time comes he will move left on issues of Immigration.

    • @cehaem2
      @cehaem2 Місяць тому

      @@John-kc4cg at the moment all I can see is them still bootlicking all the millionaires. Just like Farage does.

  • @DavidTaylor-sz2ec
    @DavidTaylor-sz2ec Місяць тому +2

    Masterminded lol, it’s like winning 5-0 against a team of one legged team.

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      Better than Southgate then

  • @The-Sea-Dragon-1977
    @The-Sea-Dragon-1977 Місяць тому

    Starmer replacing Sunak is like being in hospital in the 1980’s & hearing that Jimmy Saville has cancelled his visit but you hear the sound of a didgeridoo from down the hall.

  • @tomburroughes9834
    @tomburroughes9834 Місяць тому +3

    So I wonder where this leaves the argument about proportional representation.

  • @Martyntd5
    @Martyntd5 Місяць тому +7

    Vote share matters - 80% of the voting adults in the UK did not vote for Labour. When Labour take 60% of the seats with such low votes, that's a problem for democracy.

    • @markmasterson4811
      @markmasterson4811 Місяць тому

      Sadly, under fpp, vote share is entirely irrelevant. Try another voting method if you want to have popular vote be relevant. It's time for change on many fronts.

    • @Martyntd5
      @Martyntd5 Місяць тому

      @@markmasterson4811 Vote share is never irrelevant in any society that considers itself to be democratic.

  • @RobinHarding-ep1ud
    @RobinHarding-ep1ud Місяць тому +1

    Blair won’t start pulling Starmers strings …..Blair’s the only reason Starmers labour leader , as Blair told him to wind in his lefty attitudes and reel in far , far left MPs .

  • @acey457
    @acey457 Місяць тому +55

    nevermind red dawn he needs to sort out his red face

    • @killerkally7080
      @killerkally7080 Місяць тому +11

      Think he lives in France.... Yes the man who was all in for Brexit....

    • @iamkinginmycastle2018
      @iamkinginmycastle2018 Місяць тому +3

      Weak personal attack on him showing you being weak as f..

    • @0penminds
      @0penminds Місяць тому +2

      @@killerkally7080 When you can't understand leaving the EU is nothing against Europeans....

    • @britishempire2501
      @britishempire2501 Місяць тому +4

      @@0penminds Refuse to live in your own country after destroying it

    • @AppleAirsoft
      @AppleAirsoft Місяць тому +2

      a true gammon.

  • @davidsummer8631
    @davidsummer8631 Місяць тому +1

    Behind closed doors Labour will not be thinking that was a great victory

  • @gertstraatenvander4684
    @gertstraatenvander4684 Місяць тому +2

    Tory Light, nothing left of Labour.

  • @cehaem2
    @cehaem2 Місяць тому +2

    Starmer needs to be careful as he's only marginally increased the popular vote share - mainly at the expense of the SNP.

    • @SlowhandGreg
      @SlowhandGreg Місяць тому

      we had a slew of voter suppression tactics including voter ID favouring the Elderly, the removal of automatic registrations, wall to wall don't give labour a super majority and a Tory campaign that was a complete work of fiction describing a dystopian wasteland if you voted Labour.

    • @Jail_The_Far_Right
      @Jail_The_Far_Right Місяць тому

      YAP YAP YAP. Labour won and will be in power for at least the next 15 years.

    • @cehaem2
      @cehaem2 Місяць тому

      @@Jail_The_Far_Right Labour will be out by 2029. Labour will continue where the Tories left off, meandering through issues. They barely increased their electorate. There will be some infighting within the Tories but in the end they will realign themself with the hard-right mimicking trumpism and come back resurgent. As soon as they've gained some momentum the last One Nation Tories will either be silenced or simply fall in line. Now that Reform Inc. has a bridgehead in Westminster they will work the red wall in the North. The economic future of the entire continent looks bleak so unless a miracle happens that will throw a spanner in the works and Labour will fail to deliver. And the likes of Patel and Bravermann are already lurking in the shadows to come out as saviours.

  • @mrsteve170
    @mrsteve170 Місяць тому +9

    Voting rights for 16 years old is radical.

    • @nowgrownup
      @nowgrownup Місяць тому +5

      Certainly not at 16 they have no common sense 😂😂😂

    • @chesterdonnelly1212
      @chesterdonnelly1212 Місяць тому

      16 year olds still live at home with their parents. Next GE both of my daughters will be over 16. We will just order postal votes and I'll vote for the whole household.

  • @markmasterson4811
    @markmasterson4811 Місяць тому

    I'm not a political insider, who may know this, but how do we know it's wide but not deep? Won't we need time to really tell??
    In the meantime, they are elected, with a vast majority which means they can govern without too many external challenges. Let's see them get on with it and reassess them in 4-5years.

  • @TheGodpharma
    @TheGodpharma Місяць тому

    Neill is kind of correct, but with our ridiculous and unfair voting system there is a huge amount of tactical voting, so it's very difficult to tell the real opinion of the electorate. It's entirely plausible that Labour would have got a larger share of the vote in a PR system.

  • @garyb455
    @garyb455 Місяць тому

    Looking at Politics over my 72 years its very obvious the best economic times were after Thatcher sorted out the Unions and the Country's' finances in the 80s. We had a golden period economically with many years of good growth until Gordon Brown got hold of the chequebook and started the downward spiral. This has been continued by the Tories over the last 14 years and is why we are in the mess today. Until spending is brought under control ie slashed and taxes reduced the UK is on a one way decline. Nobody with any money is going to invest and create jobs here. One thing is certain Labour won't improve anything

  • @ednorton47
    @ednorton47 Місяць тому

    Are they going to abolish private property?

  • @joeingle1745
    @joeingle1745 Місяць тому +2

    A triumph for first past the post - the only real winner year after year after year.

  • @owendallison6913
    @owendallison6913 Місяць тому

    A mistake being made is to suppose that Labour lucked into this. They didn’t. They planned it. Votes are far less important than seats. They knew they could lose votes in lots of ‘safe’ seats and still win the seat. So, they focused on seats they could flip. This strategy meant going to the centre and it worked really well.
    Given how focused and pragmatic they were this election, I expect them to continue in that vein.
    Not sure why there is so much talk of socialism. Labour weren’t offering socialism. If they do better than the Tories have been doing, they will win the next election

  • @mccartney2
    @mccartney2 Місяць тому

    Reform...a foot in the door.....The start of the end for Red and Blue

  • @Johndoe10007
    @Johndoe10007 Місяць тому

    4 days of drugs and sex sounds like a total nightmare and a person would need to be very very unsatisfied with life to need to live like that

  • @charleswatson7281
    @charleswatson7281 Місяць тому +1

    we’ve elected a government that nobody wants

  • @justinstephenson9360
    @justinstephenson9360 Місяць тому

    A bad night for Tories. Obviously Reform peeled a lot of votes away from Tories but a lot of Tory voters simply didn't vote hence the lower turnout.
    A worse night for the SNP.
    The key for Kier is that he has a big enough majority that a few mavericks in his own party will not divert his policy program

  • @theoutlier9053
    @theoutlier9053 Місяць тому

    Labour need to understand this isnt a vote for them its a vote against the tories. As for their campaign. They didnt have one the Tories did it for them

  • @tonyaltass8290
    @tonyaltass8290 Місяць тому

    Labour played the game
    What these commentators are trying to say is like a football analogy , you won the game but we scored more goals in the second half.
    The undeniable truth is labour won a substantial majority. The vote share is immaterial it has no affect on any future elections The next election will be judged on merits of the governments performance.

  • @TheGreydemon
    @TheGreydemon Місяць тому +1

    "An independent won" You mean literally Jeremy Corbyn why so shy times?

  • @RayPerkins01
    @RayPerkins01 Місяць тому

    Starting with just 35% support, for Labour, the only way is down. I think they will become very unpopular very quickly.

  • @nigellee9824
    @nigellee9824 Місяць тому

    It’s my understanding that Scottish MPs don’t vote on English issues, so how does this help the Westminster labour government

  • @sharksbreath7
    @sharksbreath7 Місяць тому

    20% of the overall electorate, 1/2 were voting against the conservatives, the remaining support have some very opposing views and Labour have the numbers to do anything they want. This government will become very unpopular.

  • @philipgumm9243
    @philipgumm9243 Місяць тому

    To be fair, Starmer didn't overpromise and if he had he would have probably got more votes. Labour calculated this very well.

  • @rjw4762
    @rjw4762 Місяць тому

    Am 56 - Country has never been more divided - though 25 years of Liberalism does that to a country. Islamo-Socialism IS here.....and we Patriots and Indiginous folk had better start to realise what this means. For starters, it seems to mean a Foreign Secretary and Justice Minister who actually hate Britain ! A great start.

  • @davidkay7201
    @davidkay7201 Місяць тому

    No red dawn from the reddest gammon of them all.

  • @johnbirkett31
    @johnbirkett31 Місяць тому

    Starmer has to hit the ground running because with such a whopping majority expectations will be incredibly high and of course the media will be gunning for him. He has a very short honeymoon period. Maybe 6 months so let's see!

  • @alphabetaxenonzzzcat
    @alphabetaxenonzzzcat Місяць тому

    Yep - it was on a low voter turnout and on a very low percentage of the overall vote that Labour took power. That is not a ringing endorsement of them. It seems that people voted tactically(mainly Labour and Lib Dem) to get the Tories out.

  • @snowman2970
    @snowman2970 Місяць тому +2

    The public just wanted to go back to sensible politics where the politicians put forward policies to help and improve the lives of ordinary people above those of just the privileged and the already rich?

    • @adam7802
      @adam7802 Місяць тому +1

      What is labour going to actually do to improve your life? They have promised to do alsorts without actually telling us how they can achieve it. They want to do many things that cost alot of money whilst not spending any money. It's absolutely ridiculous.

    • @snowman2970
      @snowman2970 Місяць тому

      Lol! You believe the right wing propaganda? It’s Impossible to be worse than the Tories? and whatever their policies will be it will improve the lives of millions and not just of the wealthiest.

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      @@adam7802 every time they said any policies either -
      a. the Tories stole their idea but underfunded it
      b. the controlled Media ripped it apart on invalid claims
      Labour are doing well

  • @willsumnall3499
    @willsumnall3499 Місяць тому

    Starmer's Labour Party is not socialist by any stretch. It is only slightly left of centre.

  • @eveningstar777
    @eveningstar777 Місяць тому

    This is why voting should be compulsory! It will MAKE people THINK about the country and their vote! Thats so wrong 40% can't be bothered!!!! Would like to see the actual headcount per party as compared to 'seat' system It's ridiculous that scotland with a population of less than 6 million compared to England and yet is STILL able to get over 50 scottish seats to get into parliament as opposed to Nigels FOUR SEATS!!!! ITS SO WRONG!!!

  • @cryptotoad1462
    @cryptotoad1462 Місяць тому

    Is Andrew advising the UK from his house in the south of France

  • @user-ie7hm7cw3b
    @user-ie7hm7cw3b Місяць тому

    Update- Reform have 5 seats. After Labour insisted on 3 recounts! Lol

  • @CCFHymns
    @CCFHymns Місяць тому

    They didn't get 35%, they got 33.7%

  • @JonathanCheeseman
    @JonathanCheeseman Місяць тому

    Jonathan Ashworth had his nose rubbed in diversity.

  • @RJ-se4kp
    @RJ-se4kp Місяць тому +26

    The red dawn is his face

  • @bryanwalkerCT7729
    @bryanwalkerCT7729 Місяць тому

    We wasn't asked
    #BiggestInvasionSince1066

  • @nicksimmons7234
    @nicksimmons7234 Місяць тому

    Tories should listen more to Andrew Neil, Telegraph, Spectator. Mail etc etc
    It will been an easy second term win for Labour.

  • @stephenthwaite3115
    @stephenthwaite3115 Місяць тому +3

    Friends of mine did not vote
    They believe politicians are corrupt and democracy is dead.

  • @patrickyoung2815
    @patrickyoung2815 Місяць тому

    Why bother with a preview on an 8 min clip

  • @user-cc7ct1gd9m
    @user-cc7ct1gd9m 29 днів тому

    If you vote liebour & your prepared to pay the increased tax bill for those voting for sensible parties, I have no problem with a liebour government

  • @jimwilson-kl2xs
    @jimwilson-kl2xs Місяць тому

    Wrong, it's coming, a matter of time as the UK bobs alone in Atlantic singing rule Brittania after a Brexit vote won by Tory mistruths, we just want Brexit, we got sovereignty, a country headed to irrelevance and long term economic isolation irrespective of who is in power

  • @Mors_Inimicis
    @Mors_Inimicis Місяць тому

    I’ve been looking at some of the south coast labour gains from the conservatives (many of those places at the centre of the illegal boat problem) and Reform have helped labour gain those areas . Even the most hardened Reformer must be able to see the folly of that today ?

  • @ryandudley3616
    @ryandudley3616 Місяць тому

    Tell that to David Snarky (Starkey) who is currently having a full blown schizophrenic mental breakdown.

  • @RECONRED1
    @RECONRED1 Місяць тому

    The UK well be closed at 6.00 pm on a Friday ...lol

    • @joso7228
      @joso7228 Місяць тому

      great we can go to the pub after a hard week's work

  • @jeffreylawrence6928
    @jeffreylawrence6928 Місяць тому

    No it’s 5 years Hard Labour…

  • @davidreed9671
    @davidreed9671 Місяць тому

    There is no socialism on offer !!!

  • @gawaniwhitecrow2731
    @gawaniwhitecrow2731 Місяць тому

    I blame Dolph Lungren

  • @davidgriffin8958
    @davidgriffin8958 Місяць тому

    More like a ‘Landfill’

  • @CJ70-
    @CJ70- Місяць тому

    If reform and the Conservative had voted together they would have just managed to win the election, the Muslim vote how do factor in there loyalty you can't.

  • @nigeldix4841
    @nigeldix4841 Місяць тому

    Reform delivered for labour,

  • @user-dh5bn2fe4b
    @user-dh5bn2fe4b Місяць тому

    First Past The Post System was always good enough when the Torys won, Mr. Neil, regardless of how they managed it so why does vote share suddenly become an issue? Hmmm 🤔

  • @crazylife726
    @crazylife726 Місяць тому

    I knew Reform was part of why Labour won as it acted as a spoiler that benefited them + so much anger at the Tories after 14 years of getting nothing done that it was a vote against the Tories rather than necessarily in favour of Labour. It's tactical voting which I myself do if there's no decent choices

  • @jessebongo46
    @jessebongo46 Місяць тому

    Puppets out puppets in we cannot win.

  • @michaelmouse4024
    @michaelmouse4024 Місяць тому

    Sulky Lord Haw Haw. I await farage to be scrutinised on serious News channels about policy rather than being indulged as a celebrity. Also get Anderson to discuss educative, fiscal, infrastructural & medical issues. That would be a good laugh... like watching a chimp try to play the banjo

  • @ECECECECEC
    @ECECECECEC Місяць тому

    Pay your fair share of tax.

  • @James-872
    @James-872 Місяць тому

    The Conservatives wore thin........ trouble is too many believe the Labour Party is like Santa and there will always be something under the tree worthwhile 😅