I love how the 5 star Sleeping Beauty cake was aesthetically accurate, but the 1 star cake radiated pure unhinged chaotic energy that rivals even that of the film
I feel like the 1 star sleeping beauty cake would be exactly what the cake would look like in the real world. If it wasn't a cartoon it would definitely look like that
In Sleeping Beauty the animated cake is 16 layers of unbaked frosted cake sliding. The white areas are unfrosted cake. The 1 star bakery did a great job recreating it almost exactly.
Right? The five star may have the animated look, but it isn't faithful to the cake. If someone were to put the 5 star cake in front of me I would not immediately recognize that it was the Sleeping Beauty cake; I would assume it's a variant of the messy/melting/topsy turvy cakes. But I would immediately recognize the 1 star cake as the one from Sleeping Beauty.
My first thought what that the layers were too thick on the 5 star cake. I think it was a harsher reaction to the 1 star cake bc the cake that was asked for is a typical 1 star cake quality
i like the 1 star cake better too, the 5 star is beautiful but as for having the animated look, they may not have thought cartoonish and more of the cake dropping down and in the movie you can see the actual cake and i mean at least they cooked it unlike the movie 😂
It wasn’t wax on the 5 star tho, it just looked like it, which was a good thing cus it made it look more animated and like the picture. While the 1 star didn’t look like the picture at all, not animated like it was supposed to be.
@@brook1718 The sleeping beauty cake is not wax, the frosting is suppose to be like that. Yes I understand that he wants it to be more animated. Yes I understand that the 5star was more polished. BUT, the 1 start was more realistic of what the sleeping beauty cake would be like :) I do really appreciate your reply/input.
@Emery peak hehe For me personally, I would be disappointed if I receive that 1 star cake for my birthday. If I was expecting a sleeping beauty staggering cake, I would be more satisfied with the 1star. I was even kind of disappointed with the 5star cake just because of the animated picture he put on screen.
The 1 star cake was closer to the original. The 5 star cake doesn't look anything like the original. It's not supposed to be wax it's supposed to look like frosting.
when a bakery gets a pic for a cake, especially from sleeping beauty, they're gonna have to make it work. they can't make a 20 layer ugly cake for a customer
Ironically I think the 1star cake was closer to the movie. The whole point in sleeping beauty was that the fairies did a horrible job on the cake. I wish the had included a broom
How much did that "five-star bakery" charge him for that inedible plate of 100% fondant? Sure, it looked more cartoony, but at least the one-star bakery gave him actual food that he could eat instead of wasting his money on something he would throw away
Taste wise I would've been much more satisfied with the one star plate but at the same time I feel like even I could've made something better and more edible. They couldn't even frost the sandwiches properly!
I really feel like the sleeping beauty 1 star cake is exactly what it was supposed to look like. In the movie it’s a messy, falling apart cake. The bakery totally delivered on that
I think the main reason it doens't look anything like the pie in the movie is because the 5* bakery made a real pie, at least it looked like a real pie, if it is a cake they did a great job making it look like a real baked pie, the 1* was a cake covered in smooth fondant so it looked nicer.
The Beauty & Beast platter versions. In all fairness the 1 star bakery gave you fully edible cake and pastries vs the 5 star giving you everything fondant to chew on. Play-doe would have saved you money. Just saying.
Exactly what I was thinking!!! I would rather have the 1 star plate for beauty and the beast! I cannot imagine eating that plate of fondant! Plus- the 5star bakery’s gray stuff was brown 😑
The blue drips looked like they were made with candy melts rather than fondant. It's actually a lot quicker and easier than fondant, so they could have taken more time to split the cakes so there would be more layers.
If I had a Sleeping Beauty theme party, I would get the 1 star cake. It's perfect. The messy frosting, the sloppy work, the multiple layers. Perfect! Looks like the one Fauna made!
thé 5 star sleeping beauty cake interpreted the image more than recreated which I think is fine and the colours were SO PERFECT for real life. The one star said “we’re gonna give him EXACTLY what asked for” lmaoooo
Am i the only one who didn't like the sleeping beauty cake from the 5 stars bakery ? Like if i went to a nice place and asked them to recreate the cake and they gave me that i would be so dissapointed and mad, it looks nothing like the animated cake. Like i know it can't look exactly the same but ? The cake they made looks so small ? And like i would get making the cake smaller to be able to make it look more bent, but it doesn’t even look bent at all ! All in all i just thinks it looks bad ? I would have expected that result from a small budget bakery.
I can’t believe the 5 star plate of things weren’t edible cakes. What were they thinking? The 1 star won me over with the grumpy cake. It looked like maybe a different person had made that one.
I agree, or maybe someone just had like a really good idea what to make for that while for the cake that didn't taste that great it was more improvisation (and most time got lost for making the layers and stuff)
If the 1 star bakery had frosted the sides of the 1st cake before putting the layers together with the blue icing, it would have been perfect! They really came much closer to the disney image!
i feel like all the five star ones were more focused on making sure the cakes looked good than actually getting as close to the picture as possible. also i like that the one star bakery used actual pastries for the grey stuff and not just fondant or something
The 1 ⭐ sleeping beauty cake is actually what you asked for but in real life. A cake with many layers with frosting in between layers that's about to fall over~
The grumpy pie from the 5 star didn't pay attention to the details of what you asked. They deserve a 1 star for that. They literally gave you their version of an apple pie looking cake. Where as the 1 star bakery gave you what you asked for. Very 3D and animated. They deserve a 5 star rating
I think the 1 star hit the nail on the head with this cake.... it’s supposed to look bad, and the three play dough looking layers of the 5 star did not do it for me. The 1 star is what that cake would be in real life.
4:17 Honestly its more accurate. It’s not a clean looking cake but the one in the movie wasn’t either. Yeah. It looks like a disaster. That was the point. Sorry to disagree but the 1 star did better.
for the one star tier cake, the exposed layers look would've been much better if they had carved off the caramelization so it was just that pale colored cake like in the movie. Otherwise I feel like they did a good job. The 5 star pastry platter, I'm sorry, I would've sent that back. When I order from a bakery, I expect to be able to eat what I buy, and I don't want to eat a hunk of rolled fondant.
Honestly. Like unless that’s homemade fondant (which I doubt it is, it’s hard to make properly) it’s gonna taste like shit. That’s gotta be a pound or 2 of just fondant and it’s not even gonna taste good.
@@StereotypicalJesus can attest, I tried to make fondant a few times. It didn't taste bad but the consistency was a bit off. But also when he cut into it and was like banging it against the table. That is not food.
The 5 star plate of “grey stuff” looks like it was all just fondant. The one star bakery at least made items you’d actually want to eat. This guy has obviously never watched “how to cake it”
Sleeping Beauty cake... I'm just gonna be honest about the visual aspect! You may have asked for an animated version, but truth is the 1⭐ gave you the real deal in tilt! They could have tried harder with the dripping of the icing? But they got the animated flow correct!
5 star stuff were visually better, but most of them looked inedible, just full of fondant. While the 1 star bakery did a good job at making it edible. After all it's food, and we must eat it and not waste it to please our eyes.
The 1 star sleeping beauty cake is much better than the 5 star cake. The 5 star one looks like it's covered in melted crayons and smothered in fondant. The 1 star cake is so much more accurate to the movie and actually looks EDIBLE.
@@kandy1643 so you'd prefer to eat a three tiered thing covered in fondant and what looks like melted wax, rather than a much more accurate real-life recreation?
@@kandy1643 the 1 star cake actually looks at like the cake in the movie, while the 5 star dosen't really look as messy as its suppose to be like shown in the picture!!
ima say it. i don’t like the 5 star sleeping beauty one. I wish it had been messy. that’s the goal. it’s too neat. you can tell they tried a little too hard to make it look messy. The 1 star one honestly is better for that cake.
perpetual Mess, I mean, the 1 Star is lazy messy. The 5 Star looks like their own spin on the Cinderella cake. Making it have multiple layers is incredibly hard to do when the are different sides. Not trying to be too judgmental just wanted to correct you :)
The Beauty and the Best 5 star bakery looks pretty but it all basically looks like fondant. If it was purely for decoration, then it's fine but if you had to eat it, it would not taste good. I appreciate the 1 star bakery for using frosting and actual cake
Honestly the one star bakery did the best. Why would I order a whole plate of fondant. Although they did not make an actual apple pie but it looks how you wanted it to and looks delicious. And the sleeping beauty cake was way more accurate.
The biggest difference between the 5 star and the 1 star plate of gray stuff is that you can actually eat the 1 star bakery's take on it. The 5 star one is beautiful, but it's ALLLLLL fondant. I said this before I knew that he did a taste test. Guess I called it 😅
5 Star Bakery: does a mediocre job Raphael: 5 Star definitely! 1 Star Bakery: does better than the 5 star bakery Raphael: It’s not one star! Maybe like... 2
Although the 1 star Sleeping Beaty Cake looked sloppy, I like that one better than the 5 Star one. It looks more like the one in the movie and seeing all the layers and how they were able to hold up with all the lopsided layers is impressive.
honestly for me 1 star bakery wins both categories bc they first brought the food to real life as best as possible but also made them eatable at the same time.
i love how he doesnt hate on the 1 stars, they might not be good but he still gives them credit of effort and realizes it did take someone time even if it isnt good
Honestly I would have been pissed about getting the plate of fake food from the five Star bakery because of the fact that none of it was actually physically edible like I get using fondant and stuff over the cake to make it look real but the fact they literally just gave you straight fondant and no Rice krispie treat or anything like a lot of places do like it was literally just straight up fondant is absolutely ridiculous and I would definitely ask my money back because that was not even remotely edible.
I know, they were so close to greatness!!! For the leaning cake aaaaall they had to do was cut of that ugly caramelization on the sides and use a darker blue frosting and itd look soooooo much better
"1 star bakery does not deserve the one star..they deserve 2 stars at least. If you told me this came from the 5 star bakery I would believe it." ...um?.. xD
Honestly the 1 star cake is kind of way more closer to the look of the real sleeping beauty one. Because the sleeping beauty one had alot of the cake exposed and not frosted actually. Love it
OK so like I understand the one-star bakeries usually have shitty looking cakes but at least they are edible, the five-star bakeries usually look better but most of the cake isn’t edible🤷♀️
I hope you wrote good reviews for the one star bakery, expecially for the Grumpy pie. But the first one did have the layers and it was supposed to be messy, and the second one had right colors and looked great from a distance.
I really hope you leave good reviews for the 1 stars.... Lots of mom and pop bakeries can't afford for anyone but the owner to work that's even remotely skilled enough. Poor bakeries mean fewer mixers, supplies, etc. Boost their ratings!
Too lenient on the ratings. That so called 5 star bakery for the sleeping beauty cake is ridiculous. It was so sloppily done without effort whatsoever.
I'm not sure why they would use candy melts to make the drips on the cake? It's meant to be the sloppy frosting between the layers, not wax. The candles are pink, so if it was supposed to be candles melting it would be pink. I think frosting drips would taste much better than stiff chocolate texture.
Without seeing the result underneath the Box he is already making this shocked face just because he expected it to be stunning but the 8layer cake from sleeping Beauty is muuuuch better by the 1★ bakery the 5★ version is so ugly and looks nothing like the cake they had to rebuild
This have the same energy as the Disney animated classics vs the live action. The first one is aesthetically pleasing, but the other one is what it would look like in real life
I love how the 5 star Sleeping Beauty cake was aesthetically accurate, but the 1 star cake radiated pure unhinged chaotic energy that rivals even that of the film
Exactly !
I feel like the 1 star sleeping beauty cake would be exactly what the cake would look like in the real world. If it wasn't a cartoon it would definitely look like that
i agree, it looked shitty YES but that was kinda the point!
In Sleeping Beauty the animated cake is 16 layers of unbaked frosted cake sliding. The white areas are unfrosted cake. The 1 star bakery did a great job recreating it almost exactly.
Right? The five star may have the animated look, but it isn't faithful to the cake. If someone were to put the 5 star cake in front of me I would not immediately recognize that it was the Sleeping Beauty cake; I would assume it's a variant of the messy/melting/topsy turvy cakes. But I would immediately recognize the 1 star cake as the one from Sleeping Beauty.
Thats what I was thinking
@@jkitsakura clearly . That's how it's supposed to look. That's what he asked for
My first thought what that the layers were too thick on the 5 star cake. I think it was a harsher reaction to the 1 star cake bc the cake that was asked for is a typical 1 star cake quality
Exactly what I was thinking
Honestly the one star bakery did good for the sleeping beauty one. They went for making it look as close as possible to the picture
Totally agree!
Yeah, but the 5 star one kinda goed for a legit actual cake (ik that explanation seems kinda loose)
yes but they didn’t give it the animated look he wanted. but they did actually do a pretty good job compared to the image
i like the 1 star cake better too, the 5 star is beautiful but as for having the animated look, they may not have thought cartoonish and more of the cake dropping down and in the movie you can see the actual cake and i mean at least they cooked it unlike the movie 😂
I also believe the 1 star was closer to the movie
The 1 star sleeping beauty cake was actually spot on. It's frosting that is dripping from the cake, not wax.
It wasn’t wax on the 5 star tho, it just looked like it, which was a good thing cus it made it look more animated and like the picture. While the 1 star didn’t look like the picture at all, not animated like it was supposed to be.
@@brook1718 The sleeping beauty cake is not wax, the frosting is suppose to be like that. Yes I understand that he wants it to be more animated. Yes I understand that the 5star was more polished. BUT, the 1 start was more realistic of what the sleeping beauty cake would be like :) I do really appreciate your reply/input.
@Emery peak hehe For me personally, I would be disappointed if I receive that 1 star cake for my birthday. If I was expecting a sleeping beauty staggering cake, I would be more satisfied with the 1star. I was even kind of disappointed with the 5star cake just because of the animated picture he put on screen.
I would be SO angry if I received a plate of fondant rather than actual deserts covered in fondant. There is no excuse for that.
Right you can’t even eat it -.-
Who else just loves this dude and him not doing a 100 minute long intro he justs gets right into It:)
Guys tysm for the likes:>
Honestly
Tots
Nah his intros are pretty long but it’s not insufferable
Yuhhhhh get into it
Fr!!! Always getting us that good content quick 👌
The 1 star cake was closer to the original. The 5 star cake doesn't look anything like the original. It's not supposed to be wax it's supposed to look like frosting.
when a bakery gets a pic for a cake, especially from sleeping beauty, they're gonna have to make it work. they can't make a 20 layer ugly cake for a customer
Ironically I think the 1star cake was closer to the movie. The whole point in sleeping beauty was that the fairies did a horrible job on the cake. I wish the had included a broom
How much did that "five-star bakery" charge him for that inedible plate of 100% fondant? Sure, it looked more cartoony, but at least the one-star bakery gave him actual food that he could eat instead of wasting his money on something he would throw away
And candy mates are barely edible
r/FondantHate
For real If I had received that I would have been pissed
If you want to eat a cake eat a normal cake don’t eat a “fantasy” cake Smh
Taste wise I would've been much more satisfied with the one star plate but at the same time I feel like even I could've made something better and more edible. They couldn't even frost the sandwiches properly!
I really feel like the sleeping beauty 1 star cake is exactly what it was supposed to look like. In the movie it’s a messy, falling apart cake. The bakery totally delivered on that
Why is no one talking about the pie? Like the 5 star looked NOTHING like the pie in the movie. While the one star looked almost identical.
THATS WHAT IM SAAAYYYNNNN DUDDE ITS NOT EVEN REMOTELY CLOSEE WTFFF
I think the main reason it doens't look anything like the pie in the movie is because the 5* bakery made a real pie, at least it looked like a real pie, if it is a cake they did a great job making it look like a real baked pie, the 1* was a cake covered in smooth fondant so it looked nicer.
He changed the pies that is why
As someone who works as a custom cake decorator, that 5 star one that's first is a disappointment....like They could have done so much better 😩
Bruh I've been waiting for someone to say this
It looks sad
And all of these cakes look like they’re made of 90% frosting And fondant
Agreed
The Sleeping Beauty 1 star cake looked much better than the 5 star one and resembled the cake in the movie more.
True
Exactlyyyy
Yes, thought the same thing.
Lol true
Am I the only on though that the 5 star cake for sleeping beauty looked like TRASH and the 1 star look actually like the cake in the movie
I thought the same exact thing!
Same here
You're not alone
True! The 5 stars dont look messy enoigh 🤣
The 1 Star cake is missing the broom though
The Beauty & Beast platter versions. In all fairness the 1 star bakery gave you fully edible cake and pastries vs the 5 star giving you everything fondant to chew on. Play-doe would have saved you money. Just saying.
Exactly what I was thinking!!! I would rather have the 1 star plate for beauty and the beast! I cannot imagine eating that plate of fondant! Plus- the 5star bakery’s gray stuff was brown 😑
The blue drips looked like they were made with candy melts rather than fondant. It's actually a lot quicker and easier than fondant, so they could have taken more time to split the cakes so there would be more layers.
The 5star cake has nothing in common with the sleeping beauty cake beside the colors and the 1star is really authentic....
If I had a Sleeping Beauty theme party, I would get the 1 star cake. It's perfect. The messy frosting, the sloppy work, the multiple layers. Perfect! Looks like the one Fauna made!
JUDGE THEM BEFORE KNOWING THEIR RATINGS
Oh yes that would be more interesting!!!
thé 5 star sleeping beauty cake interpreted the image more than recreated which I think is fine and the colours were SO PERFECT for real life. The one star said “we’re gonna give him EXACTLY what asked for” lmaoooo
Am i the only one who didn't like the sleeping beauty cake from the 5 stars bakery ? Like if i went to a nice place and asked them to recreate the cake and they gave me that i would be so dissapointed and mad, it looks nothing like the animated cake. Like i know it can't look exactly the same but ? The cake they made looks so small ? And like i would get making the cake smaller to be able to make it look more bent, but it doesn’t even look bent at all ! All in all i just thinks it looks bad ? I would have expected that result from a small budget bakery.
I can’t believe the 5 star plate of things weren’t edible cakes. What were they thinking? The 1 star won me over with the grumpy cake. It looked like maybe a different person had made that one.
I agree, or maybe someone just had like a really good idea what to make for that while for the cake that didn't taste that great it was more improvisation (and most time got lost for making the layers and stuff)
The one star for sleeping beauty is literally how the cake is supposed to be. The white is unfrosted cake. It's supposed to be a sloppily made cake
If the 1 star bakery had frosted the sides of the 1st cake before putting the layers together with the blue icing, it would have been perfect! They really came much closer to the disney image!
the first cake from the sleeping beauty, the 5 star was animated enough but they should have stacked it like the 1 star bakery.
Yesss, that was my thoughts
Also its not melted wax it would be pink, it is melted frosting..
i preferred the 1 star sleeping beauty cake to the 5 star cake honestly. looked more accurate and like i could actually eat it
I'M SAYING THE SAME
I’d have to disagree. It was super messy and had a bad frosting job. They also missed a few details
they should've frosted it with some beige colored icing and then blue ganache for the drips
As a baker/cake decorator somebody is not telling the truth. Who rated these places?
Exactly! I think he’s just saying that for the video. There is no way that those 1 star bakeries always get it so good. There’s just no way.
i feel like all the five star ones were more focused on making sure the cakes looked good than actually getting as close to the picture as possible. also i like that the one star bakery used actual pastries for the grey stuff and not just fondant or something
They really gave you a whole plate of fondant
The 1 ⭐ sleeping beauty cake is actually what you asked for but in real life. A cake with many layers with frosting in between layers that's about to fall over~
RAFAEL PLEASE DO TWO FIVE STAR BAKERIES AGAINST EACH OTHER!! I feel like that would be way more entertaining to compare
Okay but the one star cake is what it’s SUPPOSED to look like. It’s supposed to be messy and falling apart
exactlyy
The grumpy pie from the 5 star didn't pay attention to the details of what you asked. They deserve a 1 star for that. They literally gave you their version of an apple pie looking cake. Where as the 1 star bakery gave you what you asked for. Very 3D and animated. They deserve a 5 star rating
Is anyone wondering what he does with all the cake 😂
i was going to ask the same!! hahaha i hope he can answer to this :)
He eats it of course
Throw them away and wasting so much food
Just imagine having a bunch of different cake to pick from in your fridge
He gives them to his little cousins and eats them 😂
I actually prefer the 1 ☆ sloping cake tbh, it's more authentic.
The 1 star sleeping beauty cake looks like the movie cake way more than the 5 star
Ok but I think the 1 star got the idea better, fauna didnt know how to bake, that's what I imagine it would've looked like IRL
How cool it is that we actually don't have to skip 1000 minuets of intro
Just 10000000minutes of him looking at each cake and discussing is shock. 💤
Both are a no for. I actually think the 1 star was more similar to the sleeping beauty cake. If they finessed the icing, they'd have nailed it
I think the 1 star hit the nail on the head with this cake.... it’s supposed to look bad, and the three play dough looking layers of the 5 star did not do it for me. The 1 star is what that cake would be in real life.
Exactly how I felt about the sleeping beauty one.
Seeing the layers through the frosting is really unprofessional
The one star bakery put a lot of hard work recreating something pretty difficult to make.
4:17 Honestly its more accurate. It’s not a clean looking cake but the one in the movie wasn’t either. Yeah. It looks like a disaster. That was the point. Sorry to disagree but the 1 star did better.
for the one star tier cake, the exposed layers look would've been much better if they had carved off the caramelization so it was just that pale colored cake like in the movie. Otherwise I feel like they did a good job.
The 5 star pastry platter, I'm sorry, I would've sent that back. When I order from a bakery, I expect to be able to eat what I buy, and I don't want to eat a hunk of rolled fondant.
Honestly. Like unless that’s homemade fondant (which I doubt it is, it’s hard to make properly) it’s gonna taste like shit. That’s gotta be a pound or 2 of just fondant and it’s not even gonna taste good.
@@StereotypicalJesus can attest, I tried to make fondant a few times. It didn't taste bad but the consistency was a bit off. But also when he cut into it and was like banging it against the table. That is not food.
@@haleylampley1056 Exactly. Like that’s awful... nothing you bake should sound like marble when you hit it against something.
i like the 1star 1st batch cake better, its like a real life version of the cake :D its so messy and chaotic that it fitss
I agree 100%
The 5 star plate of “grey stuff” looks like it was all just fondant. The one star bakery at least made items you’d actually want to eat. This guy has obviously never watched “how to cake it”
Sleeping Beauty cake...
I'm just gonna be honest about the visual aspect!
You may have asked for an animated version, but truth is the 1⭐ gave you the real deal in tilt!
They could have tried harder with the dripping of the icing? But they got the animated flow correct!
Agree!
At least the 1 star plate was edible. The 5 star was only fondant so I'd honestly go for the 1 star cause it looks delicious and EDIBLE
Fondant is edible
5 star stuff were visually better, but most of them looked inedible, just full of fondant. While the 1 star bakery did a good job at making it edible. After all it's food, and we must eat it and not waste it to please our eyes.
Honestly the 1 star cake would probably taste worse for me, I love the taste of fondant and chocolate on cake but I despise frosting. Lol
The 1 star sleeping beauty cake is much better than the 5 star cake. The 5 star one looks like it's covered in melted crayons and smothered in fondant. The 1 star cake is so much more accurate to the movie and actually looks EDIBLE.
Callie Gillespie it’s suppose to be cartoony like the picture.. not realistic messy
@@kandy1643 so you'd prefer to eat a three tiered thing covered in fondant and what looks like melted wax, rather than a much more accurate real-life recreation?
Desk Drawer yes because it’s higher quality and more like the picture
Desk Drawer the one you like more anyone could make at home lmao
@@kandy1643 the 1 star cake actually looks at like the cake in the movie, while the 5 star dosen't really look as messy as its suppose to be like shown in the picture!!
ima say it. i don’t like the 5 star sleeping beauty one. I wish it had been messy. that’s the goal. it’s too neat. you can tell they tried a little too hard to make it look messy. The 1 star one honestly is better for that cake.
perpetual Mess,
I mean, the 1 Star is lazy messy. The 5 Star looks like their own spin on the Cinderella cake. Making it have multiple layers is incredibly hard to do when the are different sides. Not trying to be too judgmental just wanted to correct you :)
The Beauty and the Best 5 star bakery looks pretty but it all basically looks like fondant. If it was purely for decoration, then it's fine but if you had to eat it, it would not taste good. I appreciate the 1 star bakery for using frosting and actual cake
the cake in the cartoon was supposed to look a mess, and that 1 star cake looks like a very cute mess... I like it more actually
I mean the one star one for sleeping beauty technically would be a realistic to what the cake was in the cartoon a hot mess
The one star sleeping beauty cake is what I imagine it would've been looking like if that situation happened in real life lmaooo.
To be honest, the 1 star Sleeping Beauty cake is what that cake would actually look like if that scene was live 🤣
Exactly! He needs to watch the movie and would then appreciate the second cake way more 😜
For real.
Fauna tried her hardest on that cake and she folded in the eggs by hand herself.
I agree
Honestly the one star bakery did the best. Why would I order a whole plate of fondant. Although they did not make an actual apple pie but it looks how you wanted it to and looks delicious. And the sleeping beauty cake was way more accurate.
thats true, i feel like the fondant taste baddd but they could have fixed it up a bit on the 1 star xD
The biggest difference between the 5 star and the 1 star plate of gray stuff is that you can actually eat the 1 star bakery's take on it. The 5 star one is beautiful, but it's ALLLLLL fondant.
I said this before I knew that he did a taste test. Guess I called it 😅
the 1-star Crumpy cake does not deserve 1 star. the cake looks amazing.
Rightttt
I cant be the only one who didnt like either of the sleeping beauty cakes. Neither of them look very good
It wasn't supposed to look very good.
the whole point is that the cake looks bad lol
Honestly the 1 star bakery Sleeping Beauty cake looks like the real life version of the animated cake so I really liked it haha
5 Star Bakery: does a mediocre job
Raphael: 5 Star definitely!
1 Star Bakery: does better than the 5 star bakery
Raphael: It’s not one star! Maybe like... 2
Just because they did good on this one cake doesn't mean they do that good normally, he constantly said it was better than the five star cake tho
That bakery CLEARLY doesn't deserve the 1 star! Please leave a nice review to up their score..
Maybe it's the taste that's why they are 1 star. not on the looks.
@@gpaderx6105 but rapheal said that it tasted amazing
@@sonic6866 no, I meant the cake they serve before this video that makes people rate this as 1 star. even the first cake raphael ate was bad.
honestly i think the 1 star cake for the sleeping beauty one looks closer to the original - as messy as it is, that was sort of the goal
1* bakery totally won!! Looked much more like the actual cakes!
Idk why I have the feeling the last cake was either mixed up or the 1 star bakery went bonkers
you should judge the cakes without knowing which one is the 5star and which is the 1.
I always feel like you have a bias in these videos
same
Honestly
I agree
Although the 1 star Sleeping Beaty Cake looked sloppy, I like that one better than the 5 Star one. It looks more like the one in the movie and seeing all the layers and how they were able to hold up with all the lopsided layers is impressive.
The 5 star of the sleeping beauty cake looks amazing but the one star at least tried to layer it just like the movie so im giving it a 3/10
ofc its gonna try to layer it like the movie its the picture he sent ._.
honestly for me 1 star bakery wins both categories bc they first brought the food to real life as best as possible but also made them eatable at the same time.
i love how he doesnt hate on the 1 stars, they might not be good but he still gives them credit of effort and realizes it did take someone time even if it isnt good
What is the name of the 1 Star bakery??? I need to see what else they make 🧐🧐 They made an amazing job.
Did you try to contact him in a mail
But the first 1 star cake looks more like the reference photo though.
I agree
Okay but I hate the amount of fondant from the 5 Star bakeries. Even if it looks cool it probably tastes disgusting
Because he order it like that to be with colors and unrealistic so they need to use that material for it to work.
Fondant is delicious though
@@jgon12 the colours for the 5 star cake is completely off....that blue is to dark.
Honestly I would have been pissed about getting the plate of fake food from the five Star bakery because of the fact that none of it was actually physically edible like I get using fondant and stuff over the cake to make it look real but the fact they literally just gave you straight fondant and no Rice krispie treat or anything like a lot of places do like it was literally just straight up fondant is absolutely ridiculous and I would definitely ask my money back because that was not even remotely edible.
And they sold no grey stuff to a color blind individual whom specifically asked for iconic grey stuff. Cancelled lol
The 1 star looks like good effort homemade creations. They did nail it with the pie.
The 1 star cake is like a realistic version of the fairies's cake and the layers are cool
I like the 1⭐ sleeping beauty cake better...it's a total disaster just like the cartoon one😂😂😂
Lmao the 1 star cake looks more like the one in the actual movie soo much better than the 5 star one
I know, they were so close to greatness!!! For the leaning cake aaaaall they had to do was cut of that ugly caramelization on the sides and use a darker blue frosting and itd look soooooo much better
I liked the 1 star cake, it looked like a real life version of the cinderella cake, whereas the 5 star cake looked like the cartoon cake itself.
"1 star bakery does not deserve the one star..they deserve 2 stars at least.
If you told me this came from the 5 star bakery I would believe it."
...um?.. xD
I thought the Sleeping Beauty 5* cake looked terrible... and then I saw the 1* cake. Wow.
"It looks terrible but it's got layers... also what my therapist says about my personality" I died
howabout Rafael vs 5 star bakery cake? like u choose a theme and try to bake a better cake then a 5 star bakery. would love to see that!
YESSSS
YES!
Yeees, or even 1 star vs 5 star vs Raphael
The Sleeping Beauty 1☆ looks way more like the cake in the movie
Honestly the 1 star cake is kind of way more closer to the look of the real sleeping beauty one. Because the sleeping beauty one had alot of the cake exposed and not frosted actually. Love it
OK so like I understand the one-star bakeries usually have shitty looking cakes but at least they are edible, the five-star bakeries usually look better but most of the cake isn’t edible🤷♀️
I always hated watching cake boss when over half the cake was PVC pipe or Rice Krispie treats 😂
The first 1 star cake looked way more like the picture
The Sleeping Beauty 1 star cake is more accurate lmao!
Exactly!!!!
I hope you wrote good reviews for the one star bakery, expecially for the Grumpy pie. But the first one did have the layers and it was supposed to be messy, and the second one had right colors and looked great from a distance.
I really hope you leave good reviews for the 1 stars.... Lots of mom and pop bakeries can't afford for anyone but the owner to work that's even remotely skilled enough. Poor bakeries mean fewer mixers, supplies, etc. Boost their ratings!
Thank you, finally a kind comment! Everyone in this comment thread is so negative!
Ok guys no way. The first cake comparison, the 1 Star cake was way more accurate. Way better.
I Agree
Am i the only one who thought he was shocked at the 5 star cake because it was ugly. 😳😳😳😳
D P no.
I would like - but were at 69 sooo yeah - but YES TRUE
Too lenient on the ratings. That so called 5 star bakery for the sleeping beauty cake is ridiculous. It was so sloppily done without effort whatsoever.
The visuble crumb coat was making me cringe soooo much
That 5 star Beauty and the Beast "cake" is literally just fondant. 🤔 how are you gonna eat that?
Honestly the 1st 1 star backery made what that cake would look like in real life lmao
The five star is the animated 3d version and the 1 star is the real life version hahhaha
I think he was a little biased in the first bc it's not possible! The one star one was very realistic
The sleeping beauty 1 star cake looks accurate to the real thing.
The 5 star bakery Sleeping Beauty cake looked more animated & the 1 star cake looked more realistic but I definitely think both did great jobs!☺️
I'm not sure why they would use candy melts to make the drips on the cake? It's meant to be the sloppy frosting between the layers, not wax. The candles are pink, so if it was supposed to be candles melting it would be pink.
I think frosting drips would taste much better than stiff chocolate texture.
Without seeing the result underneath the Box he is already making this shocked face just because he expected it to be stunning but the 8layer cake from sleeping Beauty is muuuuch better by the 1★ bakery
the 5★ version is so ugly and looks nothing like the cake they had to rebuild
This have the same energy as the Disney animated classics vs the live action. The first one is aesthetically pleasing, but the other one is what it would look like in real life
The 1 star cake would be great if they’d tried harder to match the frosting color and cut off the dark parts to make it pale like in the movie.