The Quad Squad: Power and Purpose of the Polygon | Raisina Dialogue 2023 | S. Jaishankar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 бер 2023
- Raisina Dialogue 2023 | The Quad evokes images of security partnership, of a development alliance, and even of a consultative committee. One and a half years since the first Leaders’ Summit, the Quad is now facing a choice between focusing on its core identity, or seeking the benefits that might come from being a more amorphous and reactive grouping.
As nations shift their attention to growth and the reconfiguration of their global economic partnerships, how will the Quad remain relevant? How does the re-emergence of land war in Europe implicate the future of a maritime grouping in the Indo-Pacific? The US has signed an ambitious tech partnership with Australia and the UK; is part of the I2U2 focused on West Asia; has entered into a new bilateral technology agreement with India; and has a close tech alliance with Japan. How do these overlapping agreements and partnerships integrate with the Quad’s tech agenda? What path can it pick between a tight, action-focused coalition and a relatively minimalist ambition that might more easily incorporate other actors in the Indo-Pacific?
In Conversation:
Antony J. Blinken, Secretary of State, USA
Hayashi Yoshimasa, Minister for Foreign Affairs, Japan
Penny Wong, Minister for Foreign Affairs, Australia
S. Jaishankar, Minister of External Affairs, India
Moderator:
Samir Saran, President, Observer Research Foundation, India
About Raisina Dialogue:
The Raisina Dialogue is India’s premier conference on geopolitics and geoeconomics committed to addressing the most challenging issues facing the global community. Every year, leaders in politics, business, media, and civil society converge in New Delhi to discuss the state of the world and explore opportunities for cooperation on a wide range of contemporary matters. The Dialogue is structured as a multi-stakeholder, cross-sectoral discussion, involving heads of state, cabinet ministers, and local government officials, who are joined by thought leaders from the private sector, media, and academia.
The conference is hosted by the Observer Research Foundation in partnership with the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India. This effort is supported by a number of institutions, organisations and individuals, who are committed to the mission of the conference.
#RaisinaDialogue2023 #Raisina2023 #RaisinaDialogue #ORF
Raisina Dialogue 2022 Full Playlist Link: • Raisina Dialogue 2023 ...
Subscribe, follow and engage with us:
ORF UA-cam: / orfdelhi
ORF Facebook: / orfonline
ORF Twitter: / orfonline
ORF Instagram: / orfonline
Raisina Dialogue Twitter: / raisinadialogue
Raisina Dialogue Instagram: / raisinaofficial
Raisina Dialogue Facebook: / raisinadialogue
It's good to see that unlike japan and australia, India's policy is made in Delhi instead of washington dc.
Japan - well it because Japan lost to WW2 and US doesn't allow it to have a military, etc.. History can shed you some light to the why.
They live under the shadow of American ever since world war 2.
@@love2CUsmile86 what about Australia?
@@jogo798 Australians majorly consist of people of European origin, so natural alliance
@@jogo798 Anglo section heritage of the country
India 🇮🇳 is in BRICS
India 🇮🇳 is in QUAD 😊
India is playing a good diplomatic role
India is in SCO too
@Ashish Bagade yeah and w'll choose quad
brics is a waste of time
+++
It's like Neither male nor female
Whoever made the thumbnail actually added Samir along with other quad members 😂😂. He took blinken's joke seriously 😂😂
😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
Do u guys have whatsapp group?🤣🤣🤣
This team was a chill group of foreign ministers... Loved the Australian FM too she's a different vibe...each of them have a great sense of humor as well as good insight.....Great conversation.
What USA is doing in Indian Ocean..?
She ?
@@umbrellacorporation5723 Masters of Evil Empire!
@@umbrellacorporation5723 nothing unless you care to enlighten us
@@johndoe-vc1we Than USA should just leave right now, USA has no business In Indian Ocean.
Go and suck in Trans Atlantic
The whole India literally waits every year for the Raisina dialogue to know the perspective of different countries 🙌
Admit it everyone was waiting for S. Jaishankar sir ❣
Dr Jaishankar started it..
All foreign minister utilizing their skills to answer the questions with humor and taking jibe at the anchors/news whenever necessary..
I look forward to such awesome conversations..
We stand for something, not against something. Again one of the relevant and interesting remarks of our top diplomat, Dr. JAISHANKAR
Serge Labrov also said same
@@prameshsahu1957 his name is sergei lavrov
The coward Jaihanker in a recent interview said we can not get our land back from China because they are a bigger economy.
It's truly have a very deep meaning.
@@prameshsahu1957 One can use the same words, but mean something different, by stressing some words. God bless Dr. J.
That's one chill convo, always good to see that especially when it's a meeting of allies.
@Two and a half Front Exactly!
The comfort level and body language of the four FMs speak a lot.
I am Indian, was studying Masters degree in SPbPU Russia. I can say that even my Russian friends never wanted this war. I feel very bad for how they are suffering in Russia. My Russian friends told me to go back to India. I dropped my Masters and came back to India, I went through severe trauma and so are my Russian friends. All I can say is nobody is strong, it just takes minutes to kill someone. After seeing the war what I truly want is peace in this world. Please. It is time that we all unite and leave peacefully in this world. We all are living on a single planet. I hope my words get heard. Please and thank you.
U can’t snap fingers and wish it. The mess has to b cleaned. Manually. Everyone must participate in d cleanup. It’ll take ages and cooperation.
Tell me, how do u convince all parties to participate in cleaning up d mess?? Without dialogue/understanding/strategy/execution?? U think someone is sitting in d corner wishing wars??
Hoping for peace too 🙏
@@RojaJaneman do you think this person was here for argument?
They clearly wanted to emphasise ground reality which everyone tends to forget
@@RojaJaneman I can tell you some people definitely wish for wars whose business prospers in such conditions
@@hobbithallows Then y r u not prepared in advance like every other sovereign nation??
Samir Saran is deservedly the President of ORF. A very good conversation.
He doesn't get starstruck, or give softball questions in a bid to get them to come back. And the panelists respect him for it. I can see why Abhijit Iyer-Mitra chose to work at ORF for a few years before striking out on his own.
THAT was a really good conversation to watch happen. the ukraine discussion was avoided because that's not a public debate considering India and the U.S's positions at the moment. but nonetheless, i loved watching these 4. And Ma'am Penny Wong. By goodness what a smart on her toes and adequately eloquent woamn she is.
Well this was refreshing. I honestly wouldn't mind more of this stuff.
Truly enjoyed the panels down to earth approach, easily understood visionary statements and of cause a common collaborative spirit to create partnerships with valued connectivity. The attributes shared were insightful with all four panelist being mindful and remained collectively engaged to navigate changes in the Indo-Pacific. Good luck to all and it's a privilege to see India leading the world in peace talks. 🙏
It's good to have these 4 nation together.
Only 2 nations , India and USA & its vassals
Australia and Japan is not a sovereign country at all.
They're permanently under US occupation, they've no sovereign policies
It’s a disaster for the world
@@roscodotemmas why
@@utkarshmangal6559 definitely US is going to be the major player and forced the other countries to abide to what they say. Mind you all the other countries in the quad are puppet already to the US hegemony, except India and soon or later India will be forced or pressured. All ending in favour of the US geo politics in the Asia Pacific
One must understand that whatever critical and strategic issues these quad ministers discussed inside the room, has not been revealed here in this discussion.
BIN BRAIN....bjp wale.....cannot comprehend your point....
They only know to CLAP....
I thought that goes without saying.
Loving every bit of it.
Delightful conversation.
Best foreign minister jaishankarji 🔥 💯 🇮🇳 👏 in history of India
No to neo colonialist of West.
🇮🇳 🇨🇳 🇷🇺 🌍(Africa) Latin America, Caribbean 🇸🇦 🇮🇷
Such a sensible anchor from indian media needs many more
I happens only in India😅. Hate or love India , but nobody can ignore India's strength
Blowing one's own trumpet, will never thrive you ahead. Although, an act. 🙏
Dumb mofos, without an objective measurement of one's strength, blowing one's trumpet, Sigh!
@@Ganesh_Jadhav7 Purana aadat hai Yaar humlog kaa.. bakchodi duniya Bhar Ka..aur material work minimal.
@@Valkyrie1941 hahha bhonkta reh bhai...Tu jalta reh hum haste rahenge.. 😂😂
Wese bhi bharat ki kamyabi se jalne wale bohot hai desh ke andar.
Chest thumping theek nahi hai but yeh bolna ki all show n no work dikhata hai ki tujhe shayad current political scenario ki samajh nahi. Har desh ko apna prowess dikhana padta hai international level par relevant Bane rehna hota hai..
@@vishnunarayan8850 haa Yaar..Sara knowledge tujhe hi hai.. aur meko bohot jalan hai India ki tarakki se .... jal ke Kala ho Gaya Hu Sara manufacturing unit China se Vietnam shift hote Dekh Kar.. kyu ki Vietnam ki exceptional manufacturing industry growth means success of atmanirbhar Bharat❤️.. ye baat mere Jaise traitors ko kaise hazam Hoga. Success of Quad v Dekh lo....20 Saal hone ja rahe hai Quad formation ko... Avi tak India ke vishwa guru Vivek se quad me security component nhi aa paya.❤️ And we essentially became member of quad to counter China dominance...but mere Jaise traitors ko ye master stroke Kaha samajh Ayga.
Ek taraf se kehna hai India is biggest market...come and invest..fir when they come to invest then our babus create roadblocks for them to support atmanirbhar Bharat. Yahi to master stroke hai. Bangladesh has surpassed manufacturing sector per GDP but traitors ko ye master strokes wali baat Kaha se samajh ayegi..
Decades ho Gaye... Lockheed Martin f16s ki factory lagane Wala tha...we were supposed to building FGFA by now.. but 36 Rafael's 4.5th gen ki Khushi tum kya jano traitors.
It's India's diplomatic success and strength that FATF with Indian origin head released pakistan from grey list instead of throwing them in black list dungeon. Ye master stroke Wala success tum kya jano Laxman.
Hindus are being hounded and ethnic cleansed in Bangladesh at the time when we are giving them our hard earned negotiated oil form Russia.. but ye diplomatic strength tum kya Jano traitors.
Countries like tiny Qatar and our new friend Saudi,UAE forced Indian govt with 56 inch sena to apologize over Nupur sharma saga.. , our officers are in death rows in Qatar,Iran etc but ye diplomatic strength tum kya jano traitors.
Super power banna hai lekin basic assault rifles ke liye v foreign countries pe dependency ki strength tum kya Jano traitors.
Har Baar world Bank ki predicted growth se substantially Kam ki growth achieve Karne Ka success tum kya samjhoge traitors
Art 35a repeal Kar ke dhindora peetna..aur backdoor se domicile law la Kar same previous condition apply Kar dene Ka master stroke tum kya samjhoge traitors.
Free the temple movement ko support Karne ke bajaye Ulta uttrkhand me temple ko seize Kar Lena hi to master stroke hai.
CAA ko pass Kar dena aur fir 3 Saal baad v usko implement nhi karna yahi to master stroke hai..
you can see the spark difference in what all leaders were saying where the US put forward this is not military ties later on the Indian side said that working on maritime security like this is a hell lot of confusing
Security DOES NOT EQUAL military. It’s about securing trade over open waters. And we all know the name of the threat. Starts with a ‘C’ and ends with an ‘a’.
Primarily they don't want Quad to be portrayed as a military alliance as canvas area of cooperation to do greater good is much broader than that.
@@KarmHeeDharmHai Canada
Its up to India to deal with China in its nearby. Its not for US to deal with India´s problems.
5:02 The Host drank the water from Jai Shankar's glass 🤣🤣 His glass is on the left side of his.
Wtf😂😂😂
भाई दुनिया के चार बड़े फॉरेन मिनिस्टर बैठे हैं और तुम्हे पानी की ग्लास की पड़ी है 😅
Dr. S jaishankar is truly a gem 💎 great choice of words, on point... Where all other countries Foreign policy revolves around the US interests, India drives an independent foreign policy where we keep our interests in focus and that's where we make a difference.
I think palki sharma could be best moderator in this session.
she can be, but his guy is gold. he is an asset. poses questions nicely and is thorough with the background.
Bhai ye aadmi ke bare me padho pehle.palki is very good journalist but she is a journalist only while this guy brought pacific command on a table so many years back .
But she is too irritating to watch… how she loves the camera!
Yeah but this guy wasn't bad either.
Shes after fame. Not interest.
Why didnt they challenge blinken like they did lavrov? Blinken talks about "saving democracy & the rules based order" yet it doesnt support democratic values international rules
Care to elaborate?
@@rbrookeb i think he was refering to the Iraqi and Libyan war.
Because ORF is a US funded organisation, if you see their list of donors you will get a clear idea.
Most money come from usa so they do not bite there care taker
@@heblegirish it is India funded in the majority
Great initiative to allow young fellows at orf to qs the ministers!
HAMARI AAN, BAAN SHAAN HAMARA INDIA HAI SAB SE MAHAAN 💐
Penny Wong is very articulate and mature - she put the host in his place well :)
She’s a two face rat
She’s hated here in Australia
Great panel and Great discussion by ORF
Although one thing needs to be clarified , when India talks about standing up for values , why is it part of RIC , SCO and simultaneously in Quad . These groupings and their leads have completely different set of values
For India to exist in all these groupings at the same time ,it kind of shows that India's upholding the value of Multi engagement at the cost of other values , Are there any other values India stands for? If so , how does India reconcile conflicting values as it exists in conflicting groupings
All of the groupings have separate agenda which supports Indian stance and as a result Indians values
And here we go!! Just like jaishankar said.. all of the above groups stand for a reasons but what you're trying to define them as they're standing against something or some other groups.. it's like you're trying to make Quad stand against Brics when in reality the purposes and interest are different.. quad wasn't built to stand against Brics nor the vise versa.. all the countries which are in a specific groupe have a common interest which resembles the similar interests of that particular group's creation and foundation.. so if India is in quad and brics and other groups then it's likely all these groups have values that are similar to India's interests!! The countries in a groupe may not agree on some particular interests of that group due to various circumstances and relationships!! But they do agree upon most of the interests of that group.. this is the reason a country joins a 'grp' or 'org'.. to fulfil each of there interests..
Liked the name The Quad Squad 👌
Do you guys have a what'sapp group ?That line had me, that was very random, nice humor 😂👌
A very good interviewer !👍🇮🇳
Great session
Now it makes sense why Japan minister trying to avoid coming, need to be independent and confidence to come...🙏
Foreign ministers of BRICS on the panel would be spectacular...
Good questions by the way. But as usual they managed to answer them as politically as they ever did.
Purpose of the "polygon" ,, can't hide my appreciation of the mathematical knowledge of the writer
It tripped me up as well at first, then I remembered that a polygon is simply a closed shape. You might be confusing it with pentagon, a five-sided polygon.
India is Great Strong Secular And Largest Democracy in the Global World because INDIANS are Specially Blessed Talented Smart Hardworking Honest And Humble 🙏
Frank dialogue on serious issues world is facing today. Loved such collaborative spirit in the Quad
Actions of these nations will shape Asia specially future of small nations..so hope for actions rather than only sweet talking against terrorism ,communist nations etc
Quality content
Excellent panel!
The theme lighthouse in the tempest appears to be taken from anime 🤔
At 09:26 Is our beloved EAM eating limitless capsule or sugar bp 💊
Fan of Ms. Wong after this talk. This is what pointed and straight answers sound like. No "jalebis" with her.
By now, Samir has mastered in Dad jokes !!
Anyways, good insight and conversation
Wish someday Dr. Jaishankar will become india's PM...
Diplomacy is literally all about talking for hours without saying anything.
Democracy or diplomacy?
Nice that you've changed your previous statement
18:00 to the question what did you discuss in the room, honest answer would had been "security security security" and then we collectively decided to come out and fix the line "it's not a security arrangement" before every answer. Haha
Yes maybe on the lines of What would we do If China attacks Taiwan ,or China attacks india ,or china blocks the South China sea
Fortunately, we are in a different age now, UK's policy is now decided by Indian, not the other way. This is progress of democracy and humanity as a whole.
Proud to be studying in the same Institute as the host (Samir Saran). It's Manipal Institute of Technology for those who don't know
Very nice conversation among the quad leaders, especially where India is progressing. 🇮🇳 Looking forward for more such discussions in the future.
India is Real Neutral Independent Daring Diverse Democratic Secular country in the world.
Judging from the Ministers' reaction to Samir's 'quirky' questions they must probably be thinking like 'Ye Saran bohot zyada free horaha hai'.
Palki sharma should host this discussion.
Arre yaar
Simping band karo
Yes I was waiting for this comment
Do you know who Samir Saran is?
Are u aware who is Samir Saran & what is orf😄?
Lol
Samir was high on harpic that day 😂😂😂
🤣🤣
Probably. Loved him😂
Quad is Amazing.
21:00 Dr.Jaishankar sir 🔥
I was once excited about the quad but have now lost interest in what it can unpack for India.
There is no quad, only bi, usa with 2 puppets, and india.
😂
Exactly
There's only 2 countries in this videos india , USA & its vassals
Makes sense
Makes sense
Troll from Chinese Communist Party
Great Indian policy great man s jayshankar
Sack Audio handling team. Too much disruptions occurred in last all events of Raisina Dialogue.
I've always wondered how a man like Blinken reports into Biden.
He doesnt. Both Biden and Blinken report to the ziono fascists of the global.financial.cabal. you really think a demented buffoon like biden runs USA.
Why to you say that
Biden is actually sincere, the media keeps spreading bullshit about him
Binden is a dump
Focus on yourself.
Now those who want to spread Hindi and not English, where do you keep your faces during a summit like this. English is necessary and every Indian should know it for our country's growth. Regional language and English is the best way forward for the country.
What the fk bro why can't hindi and english spread simultaneously? It's the same situation like you criticising building of temple though building temple and developments are happening simultaneously
@@sicmanda It’s because there is value in learning English and no value in learning Hindi. So not keen on spreading it.
@@adithyaks8584 bro don't talk like a businessman... it's India's majority language spreading it should unite india and english is necessary for communication with other countries...you can't throw out your parents when they gets old because they can't support your financially... it's our country's language china talks maximum Chinese or Russian max theirs why not hindi in our country
@@sicmanda It’s because China or Russia had one language. India is a union of states formed on linguistic basis. Promoting one language over another will only create more division, hatred than unity. Please understand.
@@adithyaks8584 now again same situation why can't you learn hindi with your regional language, I'm from wb and we are learning both for proper communication with other states... it's our cultural language Sanskrit letters are hindi's are same...why so much hatr there?
Sa akin lang naman ang goal ko lang qy magiging matatag lahat na may pagkaka isa bilang tagapag masid sa tubig buhay. Or water life... kasi diyan naka depende po tayo lahat. No drinking water di tayo mabubuhay. Pag nagalit si dagat at ulan diyan rin tayo walang ligtas. At kung habang buhay na tayoy nag kakaalitan dahil lamang sa langis at dahil ayaw nating mag bayad sa ating mga pagkaka utang gamitin ang pwersa na meron ang bawat isa para mag bagsakan sa economya. Sa karagatan. Sa digmaan. Paano naman kming mga tao na naapectohan nito. At kung di natin harapin ito ngayon kelan. Pag wala na tayong lakas at hawak nila ang aging mga kamay at naka blind ang ating mga mata at mag amen nalang na lapastanganin nila tayong mga mamamayan.
War not bcz of the government prob war ay nalilikha dahil sa investment sa weapon. Kawawa ang mga bansa na walang laban tulad naming walang kakayahan na lumikha tulad nang mga nalikha nang mga capitalismo..
Pag naayos naman ito sa akin lang ang tanging hinahangad ko ay mabago ang systema nang lahat sa pamamaraan nang ating pakikipag kapwa sa ibat ibang bansa. Kasi lahat tayo kahit pa sinasabing mayaman ang bansa natin may di parin nakaka kain at nakaka ranas niyan aminin man o hindi.. pag nagka isa nan lahat gagawa tayo nang pundation para sa iba. At yan anv pondohan natin para maging tulad din natin sila. Na di natin hinahangad kung anong meron silang biyaya nang amang may likha. Bagkus tulungan natin ang mga bansang ito para maka rats din at maging tulad din nang iba. Kasi ang meron tayo in last 125 yrs ay kanya kanya. Pansariling interest at walang paki alam anong masisira basta makuha nila ang kung anong meron sa kawawang bansa.
Sa totoo lang nangangarap akong sana isang araw maging maayos na rin ang aking bansa at last na kaming generation na mag punta sa ibat ibang bansa paraag trabaho. Pilit Kong tinatahak ang landas nang tagumpay na iyan na maibalik kung anong pinag kait sa amin. Pero di ibig sabihin nito na para sa amin lamang ito kundi tupatin ang doctorina na para sa lahat nang nangangay langan na bayan.. paano natin ito ipapatupad kung di natin maitama anv Mali nang nakaraan systema. Kasi ang meron ay patayan nang economya at patayan nang democracya yan ang naglalaro sa lahat. Makasarili lahat. At lahat sinasabing tanga paano ka mabuhay kung unahin mo iba syempre unahin mo sarili mo. Ok andon na ako. Inuna mo nga sarili mo pero nilabag mo naman anv karapatan nang ibang bansa na lumago dahil kinuha mo ang bagay na makaka tulong din sa kanila. Maliit man yan o malaki yan ay tulong sa hapav kainan nila at di iyan para sa iyo..
Pag naisa ayos naman lahat iyan ah pagtulungan patatagin at pondohan para sa lahat. Para sa lahat walang dapat pinipili. Kasi pag puro mga higanteng negosiyante ang nag pop onto sa ating mga gobyerno kawawa tayong mamamayan at kawawa ang leader at gobyerno na masisi pag inayawan ka na nang negosiyante. Yan po ang new world systema na gusto Kong tahakin nang lahat. Kasi kawawa po kayong mga pinuno at di ang capitalismo. Ang aking mahal na lolo at ang dating pangulong marcos ay nagka isa noon para dito. Kasi yan ang picture na meron tayo. Sa totoo lang.. kayat ang meeon kmi pondo nang para sa government to everyone not only for my country not same all of u na inuuna ang sarili. Kasi kung tutuusin sobra sobra ito sa aking bansa. Now world 🌎
Mahirap ba yan na gawin natin. Para sa inyong mga gobyerno ag mga leader not for me and not the interest of the business man or typhoon business's kasi kulang sa atin ay pondo yan anv aking tinatahak then I'm done.
Pag isipan kung Mali ba ako o hindi but honestly kayo ang makikinabang nito dahil dina kayo control nang mga negosiyante. Kasi di lanv bansa ang naka gapos kundi naka kaduna kayong lahat sa network at mga negosiyante or funded nito. Sorry nakaka hiya at nakaka tawa but aminin o hindi yan tayong lahat lahat..
17:52 what did you discussed inside the room ? 😅😅😅
21:03 centre of the world,,joke🤣
29:06 would u guys have a whatsapp group? 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅lol
Jaishankar is awesome
QUAD needs to keep a strong Supply Chain for fuel, food and fertilizer. This is important however, India has to do bi lateral relations with only countries where both the societies like and work with one another. There are societies and people in some countries that look low towards Indians. So, we have to work with people and societies and not just governments. EU needs to understand that they still have a family large population with NAZI mentality. Indians should only work with those societies in EU and the world that are willing to work with Indians
Why not to include china in quad? Like not including Russia in NATO. Simply clear😅
But the primary criteria of this grouping is democracy.
Actually the US had asked Russia to join NATO in the early 2000s (yes relations had improved substantially)
@@aswinhanagal4293 actually Russia requested to enter NATO, as a "defensive" alliance, and was denied, because it was never "defensive", but anti-Russian and aggressive and deceitful to the resourceful developing countries that were making more money on their oil. And the leader is making the "rules", that are kind of different for itself. They need to be deterred in order to stop the wars in the world.
In fact,
@@prakashtiwari8003 can you define this notion, please?
Common ask good questions man. The host ignored Australia FM.
Samir my favorite entertainer.
👏👏👏👏
The Quad …. 3 subordinates…1 Master
17:40,21:00,22:10,24:05,28:12,29:05,31:00,15:00
Thanks>>
Bottom line is a military groups and stop telling lies😅🍺
Why are there 3 usa representatives and only 1 indian representative ? Shouldnt it be equal ?
It makes a powerful fist.
India should strive to be independent to U.S. to not need to join Quad to be at U.S.'s bidding. India is strong by itself and should seek its own seat in the UN as its permenant member.
By joining Quad, India stopped its own rise to the UN permenant seat. No way China or Russia would allow India now to accept India since India shows it could only give in to the biddings of the U.S.
U.S. looks at India as an obedient follower. A missed opportunity for India.
BRICS is for economic prosperty.
QUAD is for war?
russia actually support india's bid for permanent UN seat, if it didn't india might not have been neutral in ukrain war, the only problem is china and they have been against it long before india joined quad or even depened it's ties with US, china has never supported india's bid and will never support it, no matter what happens.
"Quad squad" remark by Mr. Saran in the beginning, made everyone a bit uncomfortable.
QUAD is a show, a military alliance, talks a lot but no investment made, no money. The SE Asia and Pacific island is invested by Chinese money with rich economic development benefits.
I see it as a deterrence to rising china instead in the form of alliance. That's there's no money and more of military actions as of now.
When the agenda for convo isn't decided by US or NATO
The most content free discussion. All to avoid displeasing China at a time when they need to be projecting a deterrence. Disappointing
They asked Good Questions.
Oh yeah?😕🤔 Which one?🤨😏
Beatles with Maharshi Mahesh yogi is Quaď...
🤣🤣🤣
Jay Hind
Watching this video makes me feel that QUAD is getting weaker
How so? care to elaborate what you feel
Yes I agree. They need to formalize the structure and include the military, like Aukus
@@johndoe-vc1we USA iS focusing more on AUKUS instead of QUAD
@@rohithbs5065 yet it was Biden that elevated Quad to Apex level meets every couple of years? before only the foreign ministers would meet. Now leaders will also every couple of years.
@@rohithbs5065 QUAD is an economic alliance to keep good supply chain, it was never an military alliance.
This should be be declared extended NATO
So, Blinken, Representing the biggest Import-driven economy talks about delivering something, and Aligning Agendas The Japanese Representative nods and says basically nothing apart from upholding the Status Quo, The Australian Representative talks about respecting Sovereignty (With East Timor still occupied, but hopes to open some export opportunities) And Jaishankar from India hopes for reliable cooperation from the most indebted countries in the world. I have seen some better planned Opium-pipe dreams.
Australian foreign Foreign Minister Penny Wong said Australians have no right to know if USA B 52 Bombers based in Australia are bringing.nuclear weapons into Australia and that it is irresponsible to even ask that question. This contradicts the Australian Constitution and undermines Australia's sovereignty. She is a condescending, sanctimonious hypocrite.
Penny, you rock. Good onya. Best wishes from a dyed in the wool larrikan.
Australian foreign Foreign Minister Penny Wong said Australians have no right to know if USA B 52 Bombers based in Australia are bringing.nuclear weapons into Australia and that it is irresponsible to even ask that question. She is a condescending, sanctimonious hypocrite.
20:30 😍
I remember. In another Raisiana interview the US side was talking about democracy again and again. The Indian interviewer(Palki Sharma)asked a question about the US being an ally of undemocratic countries in past like China. That was dope.😂😂
I wanted to hear a similar question here.😅
And Blinken's response😁
20.50 👍😀
Why has America not Signed or rectified The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS)?
And yet it continually invokes it against China
@@HalfBreedCreations: India supports this hypocrisy.
@@HalfBreedCreations: A few years back, it also invoked it against India in the Andaman Islands.
The problem is most of these groups are dead group in terms of hard core actions.
India 🇮🇳 Australia 🇦🇺, Japan 🇯🇵, America 🇺🇸
Hindustan ka koi bhi Neta bachega Nahin Re Laga Le jitni takat hai
Hindustan Zindabad 🇮🇳
Before Japan emphasis on law, it should reflect on the Franco-America alliance when France supported with money, weapons and even brought Spain in to help America gain its independence from Britain to find America betraying France. If you think was a long time ago, Charles de Gaulle did not think so and AUKUS reminded Macron again it is not that long ago
QUAD died with Abe.
The problem is that, the lighthouse trains guns.