It's amazing to me how the same choreography can look so different on other dancers, depending on their phrasing and what they accentuate with their own personalities. I appreciate being able to see them dance side by side. Thanks for sharing this!
To be fair and square both dancers are incredible and just perfect, but for me, Marianela Nunez's musicality, which makes her the best of the best, and her grace and elegance is unmatched and unreviled. I couldn't take my eyes off of her. She is above all...
@@sophieistiredandwantscooki8806 On the video, I just loved the moment after she's been poisoned and is accusing Gamzatti: "You!!!! Yes, you!!!!" Likewise the thing at the end of that pdq in the last act where the "little girl" shows up with the flower basket and all but shoves it in Gamzati's face. Love this production!
The big jumps and the fast turns cant save a bravado dancer , this choreography test the technique of the most refined ballerina . In this chorography every move is slowed down to snail pace and makes it impossible to hide flaws from a trained eye . Cynthia Gregory I believe was first cast to dance in Makarova's La Bayadare "Gamzatti" , but it eventually for some reason it went to Cynthia Harvey . I love Cynthia Harvey and took many class's with her. However I would have loved to see Gregory's version. To this day there are very very few ballerinas that have the same regal presence on stage as Cynthia Gregory for me , notwithstanding Sylvie Guillem , and the Bolshoi's Maria Alexandrova . Nunez is unrivalled of all the Gamzati's I have seen .
Nela, Nela , Nela es la mejor !!! Osipova tiene lo que nunca pudo sacarse la gimnasia artística con la que nació. Las líneas de Marianela son magníficas y ni hable.os de la interpretación en eso le gana a todas las demás!!!
Osipova es un pony de circo, la ponen en el escenario a hacer trucos y piruetas en modo automático como si tuviera un látigo atrás, y a la gente le gusta eso . Pero artisticamente tiene la misma sensibilidad de un robot. A los rusos les duele en el alma aceptar que Nela es la mejor del mundo .
The fluidity and dramatic edge in Marianela’s dancing used to haunt me when I first saw her in this variation. As much as I love Natasha and her powerful dancing, this variation is not hers. There’s tension in her shoulder and neck so, epaulement is not there
both great... and it really comes down to taste as all art is subjective. I love them both for different reasons and would happily see both if I had paid ( I am selective when I go to the theatre to see the casting 1st LoL ) In my humble opinion Nuñez is more measured and controlled and Osipova seems to have a penchant for changing dynamics. I often find her she can "messy" when going for extreme speed for example but, to an audience that is not counting on perfect positioning, dynamics are often what makes a performance exciting! Sooooo there are my 2 cents I love them both ... with a wee bit of a preference for Nuñez.... but that is me. :-)
Bravo! Mariela Nuñez... Bravo! Osipova...ambas excelentes .. pero NUÑEZ un ejemplo para muchas futuras bailarinas Argentinas que están lejos de tener una posibilidad en el mundo... y sueñan con su grandeza.
I enjoy when you do them separate. The side by side hurts my brain. Plus the both deserve my entire attention. Love you channel though. Just feedback not criticism. I’ve viewed many of your videos again and again. Thank you 🙏 🩰❤️🎼🎶
Núñez without a doubt my favourite Gamzatti and Osipova without a doubt my favourite Nikiya I saw them in that configuration at the ROH and it was just spectacular ... I was wayyy less impressed the other way around
Coincido, no se nada de ballet pero si puedo apreciar el arte que hay en el. Siento que Nuñez tiene el cuerpo mas adecuado, por lo menos en esta variación. El torso es más largo y así se aprecian mejor los movimientos de éste; además es como si se tomase mas tiempo para ejecutarlos y eso hace que se vea más elegante. Y la cereza del pastel son las expresiones faciales. Esos ojos hablan!!
Wow, Nathalia is awesome but Marianela is better at this variation she is very flexible and sharp. On the other hand Nathalia spacing and expression are excellent.Great job you two!!!
Osipova, who I usually love, isn't great here. Is it sloppiness? Her movement isn't extended, her arabesque penche is tight & low, & she doesn't pick up her legs. She looks strained & is breathing heavily. Her pointe shoes look dead. Marianela, on the other hand, is beyond luscious. It's like she is constantly threading an exquisite needle. Marianella is regal, yearning, and effortless.
@Brenda Anne Du Faur: 'strained' is a great word to describe Osipova's performance here. She did not dance with her usual extension and interpretation. Across this past year, I have become a great fan of Nunez and loved her dancing here.
I think osipova may have been very tired for a while, I know she had to cancel ballet for poor health reasons at the beginning of 2020, I saw it in her Instagram.
Thank you for this comparison!! First of all, the costume and music are beautiful. Both dancers have great techniques and talent, of course. Even though there were differences, it was a pleasure to.watch Natasha and Nela who seemed to be more refined. ❤❤❤
This is the one time I prefer Nunez to Osipova. I usually prefer Osipova's attack and characterization, in Nikiya/Gamzatti, Swan Lake, Giselle, Kitri... But this time, there's something about Nunez's movement that fits this music better for me.
N.Osipova has wonderful jumping skills to me. HOWEVER..."Sylvie Guillem" is THE ALL time INCOMPARABLE ballerina (imo)!!! There are certainly MANY others on the rise...yet she (S.G) possesses a certain unmatched "je ne sais quoI" that none other can quite grasp. It's consistent and uncanny to me. She BREATHES BALLET. I see that same certain quality present in M.Nunez, Iana Salenko, and Alina Cojucoru for sure. I STILL believe the Russians (particularly The Vaganova & Bolshoi trained dancers) are the MASTERS of the art of ballet.
I love Natalia Osipova is the best ballerina in the last times for thecnique, but also for her capacity to be complitetly herself while dancing. Ilove Nunez, Zakharova too,thy are great ballerias. SIlvie Guilleme,in my opinion, is absolutely unique. Look at hear while dancing ,and you'll agree with me,I ' m sure. The same, enspecially as Giuliette,was for Alessandra Ferri
Osipova est une très grande danseuse, sa technique est irréprochable mais voilà Nunez est d’une finesse, d’une élégance, elle transpire l’émotion du personnage. Elle est imprégnée de son rôle. Sa présence est incomparable.
@@yoanadineva4824 absolutely not. Osipova ignores musicality and artistry to do as she pleases, or for the sake of tricks, very regularly. And comparing her technique to the one of Nunez is blasphemous. She's not in the same league as Nunez, but alas, very few are.
You had a good opportunity to connect Solor's passage from the left frame to the right one, it's a pity that you didn't take advantage of such an interesting moment!) ☝ 2:07 - 2:10 🤪 Finally, you've come to the perfect comparative video format!)) 👍 ☝ 👍 👏👏👏
@@ian1856 Excuse me, is this addressed to me?)) If to me, then you should be more attentive to whom are you writing to?) 🤣 You go to my channel and after that I hope your point of view will change! ☝ 😜
@@lululisalu4396 This happens when someone gets involved in someone else's conversation! Moreover, he @ian1856 makes a remark out of place! Read his first post and then go to my channel and it will become clear that his remark was reckless and hasty! And with all this, he did not draw any conclusions! We have a complete mutual understanding with the author of the channel, as evidenced by our correspondence! ☝🙂🤟
I think Osipova here reflects more the personality of Gamzatti, like she were saying "I am sneaky and insidious, be careful", while Nunez is beautifully technical and clean. I prefer Osipova for that
Was going to comment exactly the same, may I add that ballet is just not about technic; but about art as well, I love them both;but Osipova interpretation is on point!!!
Что-то Осипова в этом отрывке не очень (если совсем честно). То ли устала, то ли нездорова. То ли роль ей не подходит. Хотя, Осипова - великолепная балерина, одна из лучших в наши дни.
Entrambe ballerine meravigliose! Sono splendide, fantastiche ma se devo scegliere scelgo Natalia Osipova (0,000001%), Marianela Nunez è bravissima, fantastica meravigliosa(secondo me Gamzatti è il ruolo che meglio le si addice) ma Natalia ha quel pizzico(in realtà è un camion) di malizia che secondo me è tipica di Gamzatti
For this type of choreography I much prefer Marienplatz Nunez - she has long lean lines. I love Osipovas energy and huge leaps but this is Marienelastype of dance.
Marianela looks up at her hand when it is extended upwards. Do any other ballerinas do this? Heaven. I feel this comparison is unfair to Osipova: this variation is not suited to her magnificent talents.
Very good idea to show comparison with split screen at the same time between two dancers under the same dance. Their dances almost closed to the same way and same movement, hardly tell whom is better, except Nunez showed one small mistake, closed to lost balance.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 It's not a variation for her 😄😄. She is not good enough to dance this, sorry many pirouettes for her 😁. It's one of the most difficult variations, not suitable for everyone. Just Núñez (and may be Darcy Bussell) could dance it well 😍
Thanks!
Wow! A million thanks for your support, we really appreciate it 🙏 We hope you could enjoy more of our videos ✨🩰 Thank you so much ❤️
It's amazing to me how the same choreography can look so different on other dancers, depending on their phrasing and what they accentuate with their own personalities. I appreciate being able to see them dance side by side. Thanks for sharing this!
Can't we just love them both equally? Different interpretations from two dancers with astounding skill.
I agree two styles Bolshoi and RB different musicality but both beautiful!!❤
Yes! My sentiments exactly
Yes, chalk and cheese, and really not comparable.
To be fair and square both dancers are incredible and just perfect, but for me, Marianela Nunez's musicality, which makes her the best of the best, and her grace and elegance is unmatched and unreviled. I couldn't take my eyes off of her. She is above all...
Nuñez's elegance and precision is incomparable. When I see her I see Gamzatti.
Elegance, precision without forgetting acting. Nela is Gamzatti!
Nunez is the strength and poise in Dance Poetry in motion. Nunez is the Dancer Dancer...total perfection...we aim to dance like her.
Natalia osipova is my favorite dancer period but i just feel that marianella is more suited to this variation 💕
Nunez was my favorite! She really conveyed the character, and told the story beautifully. ❤️
And she's also a brilliant Nikiya!
@@minissa2009 Oh absolutely! I think I love it more than I love her Gamzatti.
@@sophieistiredandwantscooki8806 On the video, I just loved the moment after she's been poisoned and is accusing Gamzatti: "You!!!! Yes, you!!!!" Likewise the thing at the end of that pdq in the last act where the "little girl" shows up with the flower basket and all but shoves it in Gamzati's face. Love this production!
They are both amazing. Two of the best dancers.
Marianela is just awesome, majestic in the role of Gamzatti and in any role she dances!!!!! 🎊🎊🎊🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
I really like Natalia Osipova, she's absolutely gorgeous and talented, but Marianela is beyond perfection.
Exactly what I was going to write! An imposing Marianela, the stage is hers…
I like both 💞But Nunez is the cleaner and sharper dancer!
😃
Both amazing in their own ways. We are lucky to have them.
The big jumps and the fast turns cant save a bravado dancer , this choreography test the technique of the most refined ballerina . In this chorography every move is slowed down to snail pace and makes it impossible to hide flaws from a trained eye . Cynthia Gregory I believe was first cast to dance in Makarova's La Bayadare "Gamzatti" , but it eventually for some reason it went to Cynthia Harvey . I love Cynthia Harvey and took many class's with her. However I would have loved to see Gregory's version. To this day there are very very few ballerinas that have the same regal presence on stage as Cynthia Gregory for me , notwithstanding Sylvie Guillem , and the Bolshoi's Maria Alexandrova . Nunez is unrivalled of all the Gamzati's I have seen .
I'll take Nunez any day! Do some still stops and watch the positions of head and arms. It's night and day. Nunez is so elegant, regal and gorgeous.
I love Osipova's interpretation and Nela's musicality... My favorite dancers
I live to see them both! I marvel over their grace and talent.
They're both fantastic, but Marianela exceled in her interpretation.
Osipova is amazing!
Musicality, control, story-telling and even just on physiques, Nela is no doubt the Number One in this comparison!!!
They both are beautiful but my eyes were drawn to Marianela.
Both are perfect dancers and they put their soul in it. 💖💖💕💗👌
Osipova is more on the music. Born to dance.
Nela, Nela , Nela es la mejor !!! Osipova tiene lo que nunca pudo sacarse la gimnasia artística con la que nació. Las líneas de Marianela son magníficas y ni hable.os de la interpretación en eso le gana a todas las demás!!!
Osipova es un pony de circo, la ponen en el escenario a hacer trucos y piruetas en modo automático como si tuviera un látigo atrás, y a la gente le gusta eso . Pero artisticamente tiene la misma sensibilidad de un robot. A los rusos les duele en el alma aceptar que Nela es la mejor del mundo .
The fluidity and dramatic edge in Marianela’s dancing used to haunt me when I first saw her in this variation. As much as I love Natasha and her powerful dancing, this variation is not hers. There’s tension in her shoulder and neck so, epaulement is not there
Osipova is one of my two fav Nikiyas but Nela is one of my two favorite Gamzattis!! Both of them are equally great ❤️
Who is your other favorite Nikiya and Gamzatti?
both great... and it really comes down to taste as all art is subjective. I love them both for different reasons and would happily see both if I had paid ( I am selective when I go to the theatre to see the casting 1st LoL ) In my humble opinion Nuñez is more measured and controlled and Osipova seems to have a penchant for changing dynamics. I often find her she can "messy" when going for extreme speed for example but, to an audience that is not counting on perfect positioning, dynamics are often what makes a performance exciting! Sooooo there are my 2 cents I love them both ... with a wee bit of a preference for Nuñez.... but that is me. :-)
Nela's panche and pirouettes! 😱 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Nunez both for technique and artistry ☺.
Both of them are beautiful!!!
Bravo! Mariela Nuñez... Bravo! Osipova...ambas excelentes .. pero NUÑEZ un ejemplo para muchas futuras bailarinas Argentinas que están lejos de tener una posibilidad en el mundo... y sueñan con su grandeza.
Marianella supera todo lo conocido..no solo por su tecnica. .sino por su Gran calidad artistixa!!!
Mademoiselle Nunez dans ce rôle éclipse littéralement Mademoiselle Osipova
Grazie.... Adoro veder ballare contemporaneamente due artisti.... Grazie ancora
Nunez ❤️
Nunez is absolutely captivating with her long, seductive lines, supple back and expressive arms.
I enjoy when you do them separate. The side by side hurts my brain. Plus the both deserve my entire attention. Love you channel though. Just feedback not criticism. I’ve viewed many of your videos again and again. Thank you 🙏 🩰❤️🎼🎶
Thank you so much, always appreciated ❤️🩰
Núñez without a doubt my favourite Gamzatti and Osipova without a doubt my favourite Nikiya I saw them in that configuration at the ROH and it was just spectacular ... I was wayyy less impressed the other way around
La postura, los brazos de Marianela Núñez recuerdan a una verdadera bailarina oriental. En este rol y esta escena es claramente mejor.
No soy de la misma opinión.
Coincido, no se nada de ballet pero si puedo apreciar el arte que hay en el.
Siento que Nuñez tiene el cuerpo mas adecuado, por lo menos en esta variación. El torso es más largo y así se aprecian mejor los movimientos de éste;
además es como si se tomase mas tiempo para ejecutarlos y eso hace que se vea más elegante.
Y la cereza del pastel son las expresiones faciales. Esos ojos hablan!!
Y la flexibilidad, se sentía mas ligero pero controlado
Wow, Nathalia is awesome but Marianela is better at this variation she is very flexible and sharp. On the other hand Nathalia spacing and expression are excellent.Great job you two!!!
Osipova, who I usually love, isn't great here. Is it sloppiness? Her movement isn't extended, her arabesque penche is tight & low, & she doesn't pick up her legs. She looks strained & is breathing heavily. Her pointe shoes look dead. Marianela, on the other hand, is beyond luscious. It's like she is constantly threading an exquisite needle. Marianella is regal, yearning, and effortless.
@Brenda Anne Du Faur: 'strained' is a great word to describe Osipova's performance here. She did not dance with her usual extension and interpretation.
Across this past year, I have become a great fan of Nunez and loved her dancing here.
I think osipova may have been very tired for a while, I know she had to cancel ballet for poor health reasons at the beginning of 2020, I saw it in her Instagram.
In this instance, it's Nuñez for me. Significantly Nuñez.
Thank you for this comparison!! First of all, the costume and music are beautiful. Both dancers have great techniques and talent, of course. Even though there were differences, it was a pleasure to.watch Natasha and Nela who seemed to be more refined. ❤❤❤
This is the one time I prefer Nunez to Osipova. I usually prefer Osipova's attack and characterization, in Nikiya/Gamzatti, Swan Lake, Giselle, Kitri... But this time, there's something about Nunez's movement that fits this music better for me.
Ambas me fascinan, pero en este caso Nuñez me gusta más. La expresión, las piruetas, la interpretación... me pone los pelos de punta de la emoción.
nunez really is a spectacular dancer
Love you nela💓
Brava ladies!! 💖💖💖
Natalia is the greatest ballerina who ever lived. The perfect ballerina. The music box dancer of all time.
N.Osipova has wonderful jumping skills to me. HOWEVER..."Sylvie Guillem" is THE ALL time INCOMPARABLE ballerina (imo)!!! There are certainly MANY others on the rise...yet she (S.G) possesses a certain unmatched "je ne sais quoI" that none other can quite grasp. It's consistent and uncanny to me. She BREATHES BALLET. I see that same certain quality present in M.Nunez, Iana Salenko, and Alina Cojucoru for sure. I STILL believe the Russians (particularly The Vaganova & Bolshoi trained dancers) are the MASTERS of the art of ballet.
Condivido
I love Natalia Osipova is the best ballerina in the last times for thecnique, but also for her capacity to be complitetly herself while dancing. Ilove Nunez, Zakharova too,thy are great ballerias.
SIlvie Guilleme,in my opinion, is absolutely unique. Look at hear while dancing ,and you'll agree with me,I ' m sure. The same, enspecially as Giuliette,was for Alessandra Ferri
Osipova est une très grande danseuse, sa technique est irréprochable mais voilà Nunez est d’une finesse, d’une élégance, elle transpire l’émotion du personnage. Elle est imprégnée de son rôle. Sa présence est incomparable.
Marianela!!! 😍😍
Love Osipova !
Marianela is the BALLET BOOK.
Marianela oh my!
This time my eyes were drawn to Marianela.
Осипову очень люблю. Но техничнее здесь чаще Марианела, на мой взгляд.
Но Осипова по настроению чувственней)
Вот что значит высокая балерина, линии потрясающие!!!
Nunez definitely eclipses Osipova for both technique, artistry and musicality. It's no match here.
@@yoanadineva4824 absolutely not. Osipova ignores musicality and artistry to do as she pleases, or for the sake of tricks, very regularly. And comparing her technique to the one of Nunez is blasphemous.
She's not in the same league as Nunez, but alas, very few are.
The split screen is fun.
Nunez. ❤️
Nunez forever 🥰
Nuñez bellaa
Nela. From far...
I slightly prefer Nella for this variation. We are blessed to see them both dance in this role. ❤️
Oh lá lá o profissionalismo e técnica são primorosos a coordenação entre ambas é :ui ui, é nitidamente descoorneda!...
Osipova number one
You had a good opportunity to connect Solor's passage from the left frame to the right one, it's a pity that you didn't take advantage of such an interesting moment!) ☝ 2:07 - 2:10 🤪
Finally, you've come to the perfect comparative video format!)) 👍 ☝ 👍 👏👏👏
Ahahahah nice one 😂❤️ thank you
@@ian1856 Excuse me, is this addressed to me?)) If to me, then you should be more attentive to whom are you writing to?) 🤣 You go to my channel and after that I hope your point of view will change! ☝ 😜
@@ian1856 Yes, you understand everything! Your channel fully reflects your worldview and disposes for respectable communication !!! ☝ 🤣
I REALLY don’t understand the exchange between Ian and KED, below. Can one of you enlighten me?
@@lululisalu4396 This happens when someone gets involved in someone else's conversation! Moreover, he
@ian1856 makes a remark out of place! Read his first post and then go to my channel and it will become clear that his remark was reckless and hasty! And with all this, he did not draw any conclusions! We have a complete mutual understanding with the author of the channel, as evidenced by our correspondence! ☝🙂🤟
NUNEZ !!!!
I think Osipova here reflects more the personality of Gamzatti, like she were saying "I am sneaky and insidious, be careful", while Nunez is beautifully technical and clean. I prefer Osipova for that
Agree
Was going to comment exactly the same, may I add that ballet is just not about technic; but about art as well, I love them both;but Osipova interpretation is on point!!!
The one on the right, Nunez.
Наталья Осипова👋👋👋🌹🌹🌹!!!
Nunezz.. 😍
Osipova😍
Две великолепные танцовщицы. Но на лице у одной из них эмоции, а у другой маска.
Осипова умеет классику сделать ещё великолепнее!!!!!!
Что-то Осипова в этом отрывке не очень (если совсем честно). То ли устала, то ли нездорова. То ли роль ей не подходит.
Хотя, Осипова - великолепная балерина, одна из лучших в наши дни.
Наташа лучшая
Osipova! ❤️💔❤️💔❤️
Osipova is my favorite dancer of all time. But Bella is the perfect Gamzatti.
Entrambe ballerine meravigliose! Sono splendide, fantastiche ma se devo scegliere scelgo Natalia Osipova (0,000001%), Marianela Nunez è bravissima, fantastica meravigliosa(secondo me Gamzatti è il ruolo che meglio le si addice) ma Natalia ha quel pizzico(in realtà è un camion) di malizia che secondo me è tipica di Gamzatti
More solid Osipova and artistic
Nunez physical techniques are superior yet Osipova's pacing and drama is better.
For this type of choreography I much prefer Marienplatz Nunez - she has long lean lines. I love Osipovas energy and huge leaps but this is Marienelastype of dance.
Forgive my misspelling of Marienals name.
Nella Nella Nella
Thought the one on the right danced it better
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❤️❤️
多謝！
谢谢，我们很高兴你喜欢这个视频 😍❤️
Nunez more expressive
N🔥E🔥L🔥A🔥N🔥U🔥N🔥E🔥S!!
ALL DAY HERE🙌if we're comparing?
Marianela looks up at her hand when it is extended upwards. Do any other ballerinas do this? Heaven. I feel this comparison is unfair to Osipova: this variation is not suited to her magnificent talents.
Felicitaciones a Marianela por los éxitos logrados , pero Natalia es insuperable e inigualable 👏👏👏👏
Natalia for ever...the best...the perfect...the absolute. No one like her.
私は右側のバレリーナが大好き❤️身体のラインが違うし、凄いと思う💕
Marianela NuñeZ
Nunez simply defines this role. Incomparable. (Just as Osipova completely outdoes her as the Black Swan.)
Descoordenada
Обе в этом танце хороши , техничны
Very good idea to show comparison with split screen at the same time between two dancers under the same dance. Their dances almost closed to the same way and same movement, hardly tell whom is better, except Nunez showed one small mistake, closed to lost balance.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What?
👏👏👏👏👏🌸🌸🙌🌸
Osipova i Nunez play more than beautifully.Where is Svetlana Zaharov? 🌸❤❤❤🍀
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 It's not a variation for her 😄😄. She is not good enough to dance this, sorry many pirouettes for her 😁. It's one of the most difficult variations, not suitable for everyone. Just Núñez (and may be Darcy Bussell) could dance it well 😍
@@paulagiliberto7386 I love Núñez, and Darcy Bussell dances it beautifully!
@@mariamartin8516 Both dancers are spectacular in this variation. Darcey and Marianela have great techniques and a natural radiance. ❤❤❤
@@cynthiafletcher9845, yes, but Núñez is better, she is firmer and safer. She is exact technically while she continues to be an artist
For me, Zaharov,Osipova and Nunez magnificent play. 💙💛💖
Nunez dances her off the screen
To me Osipova dances, Nunez moves.
But the tempo of the music must be different for them both