THE PEASANTS Trailer | TIFF 2023
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- Get ready for the 48th Toronto International Film Festival this September 7-17. Become a Member by August 21 for early access to tickets.
For more about the Toronto International Film Festival and our year-round programming TIFF Bell Lightbox, visit tiff.net. - Фільми й анімація
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
First ,,The witcher'', now ,,The Peasants''. I'm very happy that my Polish culture is at least a little reaching abroad and has its own little place in pop culture.
Witcher games* (or books) because netflix's witcher is an abomination
@@mrlucky9157 tbh its because netflix's adaptation is based on the books. The Witcher games are just superior.
@@mw00295 ??? Books are 100 times better than this netflix tra$h. And if not for the books there would be no games. I suggest you read them because games are basically Cdpr's homage to the books.
@@mrlucky9157 both netflix show and books suck.
@@mw00295 The main reason netflix' witcher sucks is because it strays from the source material (the books). And while opinions vary in regards to the saga (which I admit has some flaws), the two short stories books are generally considered to be great.
Also did you read them in Polish or translated to english/other language? Because it may not seem like it, but the books' main appeal, for me at least, was how they were written, and AFAIK many phrases, jokes, references etc can get lost in the translation.
absolutely breathtaking movie. deserves an oscar
Sadly it's true what was said above. To be nominated to Oscar there need to be diversity quota met (that's a requirement now). Unless they will treat the cast as minority group (as slavic). Americans have a weird way of looking at race.
eh oscars are utterly meaningless, especially when it comes to animation
@@phoearwenien4355sooo... Foreign countries need to meet quotas that only apply to usa? Seems either crazy or made up
@@phoearwenien4355 TThis is movie about Polish countryside at the turn of the 19th century, how can there be racial diversity? This is quite ridiculous, that in order to make a historical movie that could qualify for any awards we need to go with historical revisionism.
@snowdropsinapril3045 Poland during that period was a highly diverse society, with multiple ethnicities... so unified monolithic bullshit is actually revisionistic
Just watched this during the Festival de Film de Cannes a Bucarest and it was one extraordinary experience and it so resonates as well with the romanian novels and soul. Exceptional movie. well done! You cannot help yourself not thinking about this movie after you watched it. Maybe I should read the novel as well.
Zachęcam zatem wszystkich obcokrajowców do przeczytania książki Władysława Reymonta p.t. "Chłopi" nagrodzonej Literacką Nagroda Nobla 1924 r.
Yeees! I was at Union last night as well.
I kept thinking about Rebreanu's "Ion" and its plot.
I absolutely loved that novel. And I for sure am deeply impressed with this movie also.
The soundtrack is breathtaking, as well as the traditions and mentalities depicted here. I went home blasting in my earphones all the songs used in this movie, not wanting to let go of all the beauty, the brutality, and the ethereal emotions that were presented to me last night.
Simply amazing!!
The novel is called "The Peasants" in English but I am sure that there is also Romanian translation because it was written in XIX century and it is one of the most important novel for Polish literature. It is sometimes called "Epos of Polish nation".
@@lookash3048it was awarded Nobel prize first of all
@AnaMaria-pt2mv La fel! Îndată m-am gândit la Ion! Sunt asemănătoare ideile de lupta pentru pământ.
I can't get myself together after watching this. Music, pictures, the story, acting - all these made me feel it so deep. The novel is a masterpiece and the movie (though different) is as good as the novel.
"Love comes and goes but land stays" Words of wisdom
yeah, SPOILER ALERT
.
.
.
.
.
book is ending with that older guy woke up in midnight, goes to throw seeds on field and died :v
Generally book was about deep meaning of circle of time (4 seasons) and deeply connection with land, with nature cycles.
Despite what happens between people.
this is not true about the ending lmao, book has 4 parts@@26Saddam
while i'm just single in an apartment
ua-cam.com/video/ZP_wymk8ORQ/v-deo.html
Ed O.G. & Da Bulldogs - Love Comes & Goes
The whole point of the movie is to prove this bs wrong
“Loving Vincent” was one of the most sumptuous theatrical experiences I’ve ever had. I cannot wait for this.
This is better, based in a Nobel Awarded story. I am proud of this so much 🇵🇱
This is much much better. Cannot even compare
And this is much much much better and far superior to "Vincent". The Peasants is a true artistry, a masterpiece that contains many cultural and artistic elements of the magnificent Polish culture. Watching this beautiful movie has been a truly extraordinary and deep experience. We absolutely love it. ❤
Poland the magnificent and unique, the most beautiful. This is the masterpiece, pure love, pure beauty.
MUSIC IN THIS FILM IS VERY AMAZING ! ❤
The music is a truly magnificent and a movie is the masterpiece. Amazing Polish culture.
Resonates with me - slovakian motives and stories are the same cause we are neighbors😊. So yes, I understand - land stays... Looking forward to see it!
Much respect for Dorota Kobiela (DK Welchman) - from stunning visual artist to brilliant filmmaker. One of the great ones working today along with her equally genius husband, Hugh Welchman. Cannot wait to see this.
If the presentation of very conservative village women as street walkers of past era is a brilliant artistic achievement.
Yes, she is the main director and also an artist herself. Well done, Mrs. Dorota Kobiela DK.
Saw this yesterday. An extraordinary experience!
made by super talented insane people who love their craft
aka a.i.
EW NO this wasn't done by ai, look up the making off, and behind the scenes @@atsukoonishi1358
people who use ai for any form of arts are lazy people who dont care about art at all lol@@atsukoonishi1358
@@atsukoonishi1358Painters, not AI: "more than a hundred painters in four studios in Poland, Lithuania, Ukraine, and Serbia painted oil paintings based on the shots"
@@atsukoonishi1358Maybe A.I would make smth like that but you cannot sell A.I movies for profits. Legalny impossible
Visually beautifully done, but brutal. Loving Vincent was ethereal
It's different because it's inspired by a different art style and a Nobel winning book. While Loving Vincent was inspired by post impressionism, The Peasants are inspired by Chełmońskiego paintings - realism. One of the scenes in the trailer is literally Chełmoński's painting "Babie Lato" - on display in the National Museum in Warsaw :).
are you 5 or what? if "the story is too brutal" is the only thing you don't like about it, then go watch Dora the Explorer or something, jeez
What's brutal about it?
wąchaj!
@@ktom5262 Maybe Kuba Socha cutting his own leg and dying alone in the barn? Book was pretty brutal.
Uważam, że film warto zobaczyć. Nie jest doskonały, ale sama forma przepiękna, treść fajnie, że podana w formie, która zyskuje pewien rozgłos na świecie. Fabuła względem książki zmieniona, ale nadal ciekawie się to oglądało.
Szczochy
@@olafjansowidz ok
Nie podobała mi się ta zmiana narracji na "biedną Jagusię", ale wizualnie film przepiękny, do tego muzyka świetnie dopasowana.
Every frame of this movie is a masterpiece ❤. You deserve Oscars guys🔥🔥
and the oscar goes to
they are neither trans nor black so sadly they will not get it.
Getting Oscar nomination would be an insult to this piece of art.
They didn't get into the Oscars because of the new racist law in the US. Real shame.
I’m still digesting the beauty of this film.
This is a masterpiece! Story, music, pictures… Whoever doesn’t appreciate it needs to work on their traumas.
Love from Greece!
Absolutely incredible Director.
It's a woman, her name is Dorota Kobiela (DK).
I loved the visuals and cinematography. Oil painting meets film. A remarkable standard to be reached within modern cinema.
After making the movie it took 12 artists more than 3 years to paint this masterpiece.
Did the paint it? Looks like ΑΙ to me
12? It was over a 100 my guy
@@TheGeorgepao13they started long before ai could do that, it's a shame that the movie is compared to ai now
Cannot wait ! 😍
Just saw the movie and it’s breathtaking
Yeah it's beauty
Woah from 1:11-1:22 uhm the score and visuals are mind blowing like KahPOW.
Amazing
It looks very interesting... Great!
beautiful movie
Everything is top notch about this movie especially the music.
Imagine getting to own one of the paintings
my aunt has a copy of 0:05 in her dining room (movie pays homage to real, existing paintings)
@@blueshit199 and what's it called?
@@furkanuner8989 "Bociany" by Chełmoński
@@furkanuner8989 "Bociany" by Józef Chełmoński
@@furkanuner8989 hell if I know. i read a textbook where it was named way back in school, but i let that memory slip my mind
Must see!
I know that ,,kissing" scene here was much less descriptive than in the original book, but I sincerely doubt it was this necessary. Now it would feel awkward if I watched with my parents...
But other than that, it all looks great. It looks and feels like an actual billion-dollar film, but all painted manually. I can't even imagine the craft, talent and dedication the authors must have had to paint manually all of the scenes.
Many frames were based on polish (but not only polish) paintings from that tkmw and about that time.
A zaczął od zabijania taksówkarza - szacun Panie Baka
I'd love to see a Picasso or Dali bio pic from these guys
Anyway, not Rubens.
I think bio pic of tamara łęmpicka (also know as tamara de lempicka) done by this studio would be amazing, especially bc she was polish and studio is polish, and her artstyle is really unique and amazing
@@hekate3930 Yo, Tomasz Sętowski and Zdzisław Beksiński. 🗿🗿🗿
@@polskimaestro9454Movie based on Beksiński's art would be absolutely stunning
@@hekate3930 I would like to see them make the animation about the Polish Soldier Bear aka Wojtek The Soldier Bear. I love hist story. ❤🐻
Yesterday saw this in Riga IFF festival. Story is old as human society: there is no bigger power than jealous women, bullying beautiful one and telling fake stories to make one feel miserable.
Yeah but it's like the men also didn't help to say the least. Most characters suck as people here
I really want to see this movie in the cinema but I live in Calgary. I was hoping they would have play it at the CIFF but unfortunately not. Any premiers coming up anywhere else other than Toronto?
Don't worry, I checked and US premiere is coming around dec/jan, Canadian premiere should be in similiar time. They are working on english dubbing rn. I watched this movie in Poland last week and it's amazing.
I'm waiting in Australia. No info yet. Only that Sony bought distribution rights.
I'm waiting in Edmonton AB Canada hopefully I can watch it soon.
The Peasants - a Witcher Story. Very similar music, even the logo seems weirdly familiar. This is what Geralt would witness in the villages, if he wasn't so preoccupied with slaying monsters.
True.
Sapkowski wrote The Witcher
80 years after Reymont won Nobel prize
For The Peasants. Both drew inspiration from Slavic culture and tradition.
@@zanetttta there is actually very, very little Slavic culture and tradition in the Witcher, but I get where you're coming from.
@@ThiluPLmaybe in the tv series, i was thinking about the novel :)
@@zanetttta I'm talking about the novel as well. I have read the whole saga more than once, in Polish. There aren't many Slavic influences in there. What gave the Witcher its Slavic vibe were the games, because that's how they wanted it, and I actually know some of the artists behind this project myself.
@@zanetttta Polish culture and tradition
wow
Super! ❤🎉😊
Miroslaw Baka One of the best actor .....😊😊😊😊.From "Wybrzerze" Theathre Gdansk Poland.....................
woooooow 🤩
I was sure Witcher will enter at the end 🐺
Unfortunately, the writers and producer destroyed that show, so it's better if he stays out of this brilliant work. 🙂
OMG, what if these guys produced the Witcher instead! That would be something!!!
Haha, so funny, because, you know, Witcher is the only thing that exists in Polish culture.
genialny!
A movie as a painting. Or a painting as a movie???
A moving picture...
Every frame is an oil painting
yeah it is not just a filter, it is all hand painted
Oh wow. That must have been a lot of work.
@@ashleylodewyk745440.000 paintings and 200.000 hours of work if I remember correctly
Прекрасний фільм
Шедевр .а вежь так и дили в те времена.оскар однозначно
Was this filmed before it was painted ? It really looks like it was painted above an actual footage
That's right, painters painted their pictures based on previously recorded scenes
@@darktravel9318 I wonder how much AI had to say in this.
Just like rotoscoping animation (very popular up to 1960s) this is filmed with actors and then painted over but in 'Young Poland' style (1890 to 1918).
@@piotrmalewski8178no AI was used at all in this movie
AI is not yet able to make such a good looking video
@@darktravel9318 I know, but technically you could simplify the process of painting by painting only some frames, then feeding this to AI and letting it fill the gaps in frames you didn't paint, perhaps only adding minor corrections.
HYPE!! ;D ;D
Come to Seattle!
Narzekanie to polski sport. 99% jęczących to polacy.
Jak nie, jak tak
What is the name of this soundtrack? Is great and powerful!
ua-cam.com/video/amHCTTvWP4o/v-deo.html
L.U.C, Kayah - "Jesień - tańcuj"
Does anyone know what the trailer's soundtracks are ?
This is what I read: "The Peasants is set to a soundtrack composed by Lukasz L.U.C. Rostkowski, who teamed up with a Slavic music collective as well as notable folk musicians such as Tęgie Chłopy, Laboratorium Pieśni, T.Etno and Maria Pomianowska to create a modern take on Polish folk music."
It's Jesień - tańcuj by L.U.C
It's not the music from the trailer, but it's still music from the movie. L.U.C. & RB Film Orchestra ft. Kayah, Dagadana, Laboratorium Pieśni, Tęgie Chłopy - Jesień - Tańcuj
ua-cam.com/video/amHCTTvWP4o/v-deo.htmlsi=xXFRtfKskbcLBNuS
soundtrack release coming in early November
@@OlaCh93 is this certain information?
How the fuck was this NOT nominated for Oscars?!
No black people, no homeosexual no trans people in it. That's why
@@E_w_a how many black, homosexual or trans people were in Oppenheimer lol
SOMEONE PLS TELL ME WHERE I CAN WATCH THIS MOVIE !! I’m looking forever!😢
Hi, where are you from? Maybe it didn't have a premier in your country yet. I read they are working on English dubbing now.
@@oliwiam4996 in from the Netherlands!
I want to know too! I’m from Argentina. Doubt it will premiere here :(
@@delfinaciancio my father is lived in Argentina when he was a boy! Yeh I hope we all get to see this movie Cz it looks so good
@@delfinaciancio Sony Picture Classic has got the license, and so far I know, they are also active in South America, so there is a chance ;)
The only complaints is the text between in the trailer is not oil paiting. 😢😢 everything else is beautiful.
I love animation 🥲
This is not animation. It is film digitally processes to look like oil painting.
@@undefinednull5749 It’s rotoscoping. It took them THREE YEARS to paint each frame!
@@undefinednull5749Wtf no xD
There are even photos on the Internet of painters painting frames from this film
@@darktravel9318 a movie has typically at least 24 frames per second! Do you really believe that 100 painters painted at least about 60* 120 * 24 frames per 2 hours of film? This is 7200 *24 = 172400 paintings! Each painter would have to paint at least 1724 paintings!
Can you believe it?!
@@undefinednull5749 Actually it was about 40000 paintings. Educate yourself.
There will be no Oscar because there is not a single black gay or lesbian in the film
Omg
Jak bardzo Kamila jest podoba do Margot Robbie...
Kurde, a mi ona tak strasznie przypomina Amber Heard
Необычная картина
🇵🇱
I am a feminist after watching this
Why?
@@mrlucky9157what why? Not strictly in alignment with the novel, but the movie displays the awful truth of how violent the culture and traditional society has been to women, to an individual simply seeking their freedom.
@@5sunniva5 This movie is set around 1900 🤔So why become a feminist now?
very impressive animation although i wish it was a little more stylized like in Loving Vincent. As it, it does just look like realism paintings...idk maybe thats the point
That's inspired by mainly Polish paintings, not Vincent's
@@lalka_motanka good point
Where to stream or buy it?
For now, the film is only in cinemas
Ready to serve. Milord? What is it? Hello.
work work.
Stop rockin' the boat!!
Wokeists wont let that masterpiece get oscar anyway, if youll get the chance, dont hesistate - go and watch it, very good movie.
This movie is sooo woke.
@@annaNieZmieniajcieMiNicka What?
@@pawehebda2583 Zarówno książka, jak i film przedstawiają to, jak patriarchalne, chłopskie środowisko traktuje kobiety, które chcą same o sobie stanowić. To jest totalnie woke.
@@annaNieZmieniajcieMiNicka Ale to jest na podstawie prawdziwych zasad jakie kiedyś panowały XDD. Tak było, wszystko w tym filmie kiedyś się działo oprócz głównej histori. To tak jakby mówić że film dokumentalny o niewolnikach jest woke 💀. Pozatym książka jest z 1902 wtedy woke ani nawet koncepcja tego typu nawet nie istniała
genuinely mentaly deluded take
Where can I watch it online?
Yesterday was a premier in Polish theatres. Welcome to Poland
@@blajdzik on my way to Poland then
@@marym.7416 screening started in foreign cinemas (we already have it in Ireland), after someone time it should be available on some streaming platforms
If they got a cameo by Cavill....
Хороший фильм говорят
Think you need to find it out for yourself
My eyes.
Kamila Urzedowska is such a scorcher.
up
The peasants old version 1972
A fine lass.. Fond of the lads... 🤔
The Witcher in the countryside
that's 90% of the Witcher
POLSKA GUROM
Górą !!! ośle 🐴
i morzom
@@AdeM-kc7sc o borze szumiący 🌲
No I co z tego jak za granica nigdzie nie mozna go obejrzec
Po nowym roku będzie można 😊
A jak mieszkasz w wiekszym miescie to poszukaj festiwali filmowych, na kilku był już wyświetlany
A no to super! Poszukam po nowym roku! 🎉
Można w Hiszpanii
Dziś obejrzałam w Korei Południowej. Premiera 10 stycznia.
Weird; I only like the stills of this movie, I thought I’d love it but can’t seem to like it
Stary oblech
szlauf
What a weird animation
Oula bon pour avoir une crise d'épilepsie ça me fatigue lol
Chłopi mówiący czystym, współczesnym polskim...to tak, jakby do sukmany założyć adidasy.
Jagna full make up, z czerwona szminką. Trochę to plastikowo wygląda.
@@03817 👍
Za to Wy narzekacie iście po Polsku 🤣
@@Kalambury266 narzekać można na pogodę. My krytykujemy.
@@Kalambury266 różnica między narzekaniem, a krytyką polega ma tym, że ta druga jest merytoryczna.
Nothing beats the original from the 70's
Actually I like this much more.
@@AirsoftAddicted you ar wrong
@@77mako77ful Nope. I did not managed to get over the one from 70s... so damn boring.
But this looks much more interesting.
@@77mako77ful How can it be wrong to like one thing more than another? XD De gustibus, my friend, de gustibus. ;)
Nowa wersja jest o niebo lepsza. Muzyka, obraz, emocje, cudowny film.
Funny how this trailer suggests that Jagna is the victim in this story, while the girl was a spoiled and selfish idiot who didn't care about anyone's feelings except her own, and she met her well-deserved fate in the end.
Stick to games kiddo.
I wouldn't say her final fate was deserved, but she indeed was a materialistic dumbo who was highly unlikeable and got around way too much, didn't enjoy that narrative change, since it's one of my fave books.
Watch out! Spoilers alert! ;-)
I agree with your opinion. Everybody are sorry for this stupid girl but she deserved that.
But this movie changes a lot of things form the book, including characters, so Jagna from the book is way different to Jagna in the movie
@@deathcookie7605yeah. Improved for modern audience sensitivity xd
This trailer is so frickin' misleading wtf
Why?
@@DarkBladePL9 It portraits the story like a Romeo and Juliet type deal with the "forbidden lover" when in reality, she gets thrown into an arranged marriage with the village chef and seeks comfort from her best friend, only for him to rape her in the woods because "he loves her so much"
what's misleading about it?
It's such a great movie that they had to quietly remove the original series Peasants from 1970 from YT so no one will confuse this shitty remake with the original masterpiece peasants 😂😂😂
Ciesze się ze chłopkom szminki, mascary i pudru nie poskąpili. Gdzie iPhone i elektryczne samochody? Zaprezentowanie wszystkich chłopek jako ladacznic jest ogromnym odbiegiem od ówczesnej rzeczywistości i krzywym odbiciem spójności z intencjami autora książki. Film jest niczym innym jak paszkwilem obyczajowym.
1. Były w starych wsiach sposoby na malowanie się oczywiście nie aż takie jak u Jagny ale u innych kobiet w filmie mniej to widać
2. Serio w końcu polski film który możemy z dumą pokazać za granicą a ty wolisz ludzi do niego zniechęcać bo Jagna ma makijaż xD
@@anonymousofwonderland4850 Zupełne przekręcenie intencji autora zaprezentowania całej społeczności chłopskiej na rzecz propagandy feministycznej opartej na historii Jagny nie jest powodem do dumy. Fakt, że reżyserem jest kobieta wyjaśnia tę rozbieżność jak i to, że chłopki wyglądają jak miejskie prostytutki z minionej ery. Feminizacja jakiegokolwiek zawodu to obniżanie standardów.
@@gancarzpl Nie każda adaptacja filmu musi być jej 100% wierna a jeżeli twierdzisz że ten film jest feministyczny to nie oglądałeś tego filmu xDD
@@anonymousofwonderland4850 Może to ty powinnaś zobaczyć film ponownie?
@@gancarzpl Nie bo nawet powstał cały tiktok o tym dlaczego ten film nie jest feministyczny?
Paniusie z salonów Agata udają chłopki. Wieś z pokolorowanego plastiku.
I would love to see it without that AI filter 🥴
?
Bro are you on drugs or something?
It's not A.I, very sad that people can't appreciate human work. Artists across four countries worked hard to make this movie. Stop spreading misinformation
Tragedia
gdziez tacy chlopi....! z takimi twarzami i tak ubrani....hahahahaha co za bzdury !!!
Przynajmniej nie są czarni 😅
W Polsce.
Ale że co, jakie te niby twarze są i co jest nie tak ze strojami?
według ciebie mieliby być pryszczaci, obleśni i bez zębów - byłoby tak przaśnie ......
@@knotte7598Choćby to, że nie oddają strojów ludowych polski centralnej, żadna chłopka na wesele w XIX wieku nie ubrałaby się w białą suknię, wystarczy przeczytać książkę, by wiedzieć, że strój ślubny Jagny był kolorowy
To nie jest polski film, ale tylko polskojezyczny... Reymont przewraca sie w grobie... Manipulacja...
Weź idź bucu, Polska kultura w końcu jest doceniana na świecie i musi przyjść debil bo to niewystarczająco polskie
Dlaczego to nie jest polski film?
Serio to jest zrobione w wersji rysunkowej? To pie*olę ten film. XDDD
Razi mnie to w oczy. 😂😂😂
W imieniu filmu pragnę złożyć oświadczenie: też ciebię pierdolę.
Nie znasz różnicy między rysowaniem i malowaniem?
Polecam bezpłatne badanie wzroku
"Painters spent 200 000 hours on painting scenes manually"...yeah, right, who do they want to cheat? I bet software like Midjourney has been used
Making ofs? Hundreds of painters who worked on it for 4 years in Poznań? And hundreds of millions of budget?
ua-cam.com/video/QE9Q_7bfHsM/v-deo.html
the above link show the process they went through with the last movie of the studio ;) This one is based on the end of XIX's century painting style from Poland. I hope we will see the making of Peasants soon as well ;)
Sorry mate, but Poles do things like this. We call it 'art'.
Shesh, because western countries tend to be lazy with their entertainment, it doesn't mean everyone else is XD
Oh, fun: the (just won't f-ing die) 'you have to take a wife' premise. Repeatedly rejected old guy somehow magically has nubile girl/woman fall in love with him (for no apparent reason). The visual effects look fantastic. The story line is easily rejectable... disappointing.
He is rich.
Read the novel.
Wtf? This story isn't about that at all, and not much is shown in the trailer anyway. This is a story based on a book written over 100 years ago and awarded with the Nobel Prize. It shows the life of peasants in the Polish countryside at the beginning of the 20th century, the position of women at that time and the role of the respect for land and family rooted deeply in peasant culture, all subordinated to the rhythms of the constantly changing and returning seasons.
I assume you're judging from the trailer only? Well, you couldn't be more wrong. It's based on polish classic novel "Chłopi" by Władysław Reymont and the story line is far from what you expect. It is pretty depressing, though.
There are 4 main storylines in the book, as many as calendar seasons. Jagna and Boryna marriage is just one of them. It's depressing book about reality of Polish peasants from XX century
Even in the trailer you can hear Jagna complain that she cannot decide about her own marriage. Where did you get the idea that she married that old guy out of love?
Idiotyzm
Bo?
They didn't get into the Oscars because of the new racist law in the US. Real shame.
Oni to oskra zgłosili XD to już lepiej znachora by dali
Rozumiem, że to żart.
No chyba nie. Obejrzałem obydwa te filmy. Znachor to dla mnie takie 5/10. Nie żeby był to fatalny film, po prostu jego problem polega na tym właśnie - że nie jest Znachorem. Jako fan poprzedniej ekranizacji w reżyserii Jerzego Hoffmana oraz książki nie mogę przeboleć że wywrócono całą fabułę do góry nogami. Potencjał był spory, można było np. rozwinąć wątek doktora Pawlickiego, który w książce nie do końca był taką mendą na jaką wyglądał w wersji z 1981 (kochał swoją rodzinę i chciał poprawić ich sytuację życiową). Niestety jest to moim zdaniem zmarnowana szansa.
Natomiast Chłopi to dla mnie 9/10, ten styl nazwijmy "animacji" poprzez obrazy pasuje do tego świata i historii jak ulał, znakomity dobór aktorów (można by wymieniać przykłady, ale to daremne bo niemal wszystkie role odegrane są perfekcyjnie). Jedynym zawodem, a w czym pokładałem wielkie nadzieje jest muzyka - są momenty świetne jak motyw z nocnego spotkanie Antka i Jagny który słyszymy też w trailerze, uśmiechnąłem się gdy usłyszałem dobrze mi znanego "Odchodnego" od Tęgich Chłopów podczas sceny w karczmie, ale są też momenty jak w scenie z siekaniem kapusty - niby widzimy skrzypka i harmonistę, ale... harmonii nie słyszymy. W uchu słychać tradycyjny archaiczny przedwojenny duet - skrzypce i basy, co akurat jest zgodne z czasem akcji książki/filmu. Nota bene jest także sama harmonia - nie powinna się ona pojawić w ogóle. Raz, że pokazana jest harmonia 120 basowa - takie harmonie powstawały choćby w zakładach Stamirowskiego w Warszawie dopiero na przededniu 2 WŚ, na dodatek jest to harmonia biała, kryta celuloidem, a takie powstawały po I WŚ, wcześniej harmonie były tzw. czarne, kryte fornirem. Więc jeśli miałaby się pojawić w tym filmie harmonia to czarna jedno-dwórzędówka z góra 24 basami, a nie to co nam pokazano. Rozumiem że o tego typu instrumenty obecnie trudno, ale powinno się z tego pomysłu całkowicie zrezygnować.
@@sleyser1224k ogólnie się zgadzam ale z tym doborem instrumentów to chyba zabrnąłeś w zbyt głęboką szczegółowość i możliwe, że jesteś jedyną osobą, która wychwyciła tę nieścisłość. Dla mnie nie miałoby to żadnego wpływu na ocenę filmu bo to zbyt mały szczegół. Muzyka bardzo mi się podobała.
@@sleyser1224k myślę że założenie było takie, by uwspółcześnić muzykę i oddać jej charakter ale w formie przystępnej dla każdego dziś, gdziekolwiek żyje.