How Bhutan created one of World’s Biggest Refugee Crisis | The EXILE | Part-1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 вер 2022
- Bhutan 🇧🇹 presents itself as peace loving, progressive and happy country and yet it does not acknowledge its dark history. Some three decades ago, Bhutan
Created one of the biggest Refugees Crisis in the World when it exiled almost 1/6th of its population as illegal immigrant. Almost all of them were “The Lhotshampas”, the Southern Bhutanese, who were from Nepali Ethnicity. They had been living there for generations with peace and then they were all exiled almost overnight.
In this first part of Bhutan’s Darkest Secret: we look at what lead to such dramatic measures from the Bhutanese Monarch for which we would have to start from the beginning, from the foundation of Bhutan, the impact of Buddhism plays in the country, how the current Monarch, Wangchuk Dynasty came to power and along with the gradual migration of Nepali Ethnic people for centuries and ultimately, how it culminated into such a massive Ethnic cleansing.
Let's connect :
If you are on Facebook: [ / dipesh.tripathi.35 .]
If you are on Twitter: [ / nepalicomment ]
If you are on Instagram: [ / dipesh.trip ]
Research by: Bishwa Rai ( / bishwa546 )
Edited by: Ajay Khadka ( / khadka__ajay )
Animations and Thumbnail by: Rabi Kandel ( / proto_flex )
Sources:
Articles and Books
1.Wangchuck Dynasty: 100 Years of Enlightened Monarchy in Bhutan
(www.amazon.com.au/Wangchuck-D...)
2. The Raven Crown by Micheal Aris ( / 388825.the_raven_crown )
3. Bhutan’s Dark Secret: (thediplomat.com/2016/09/bhuta...)
4. bhutaneserefugees.com/
5. reliefweb.int/report/nepal/pr...
6. Human Rights Watch (www.hrw.org/reports/2007/bhut...)
(www.hrw.org/legacy/background...)
7.myrepublica.nagariknetwork.co...
8.www.nrc.no/globalassets/pdf/r...
9.www.satp.org/satporgtp/countr...
10.thewire.in/external-affairs/i...
Documentaries:
1. The Magnificent History Of Bhutan's Royal Family: Real Royalty ( • The Magnificent Histor... )
2. Bhutan's prime minister: Al Jazeera English ( • Bhutan's prime ministe... )
3. Bhutan’s forgotten People : Al Jazeera English ( • Bhutan's forgotten peo... )
4. Bhutan’s attempt to clear itself of Nepalese: JourneyMan Pictures( • Bhutan's Attempts To C... )
This reminds me of my teachers who were also bhutanese refugees. Harka Gurung sir, Sabitra Rai maam, Gopal Tamang sir, if you are watching this, you are not forgetten.
Are you from rumjatar?
@@itsabjs he is
@@itsabjs Nope. Salyantar, Dhading.
Same - we had lots of Bhutanese teacher as well.
Dhanapati Acharya , Raju rai- so many good memories
We also had bhutanese refugees teachers in Gulmi, which is actually quite far away from eastern Nepal and is located in western Nepal. They were fun people. I heard most of them left for the United States after a while.
Thanks for this video brother, even though I was born in Nepal, my parents, grandparents & so on were born in Bhutan. We lived in refugee camps for years until we moved to different countries. I remember my families telling me how all that went down. Currently living in the United states. Always loved your content but wasn’t expecting this one to come. ❤️
According to India-Nepal friendship treaty of 1950 , if any country attacks and invades Nepal, then India will come and protect Nepal from invading country 🇮🇳 🇳🇵
❤️❤️❤️
@@JimmySpace69 Ya. But what is the invader is India?
@@Ahdurun India will never invade nepal
India respects the integrity and sovereignty of Nepal
@@Batmeth69420 It might be true but do check videos regarding nepal-india border in terai region. How india is slowly taking nepal’s land.
I had many Bhutanese friends who lived in the refugee camps. They are now resettled in the US. Thanks for reminding me of them ;we were out of contact for like a decade.
They are not BHUTANESE, they are your own people
Many of those Nepali are from Northeast India pretending themselves to be Bhutanese to get free rice bag in camp and free visa toward USA. Ask them to speak a sentence in Dzongkha if they are true Bhutanese 😂 Neither they look Bhutanese, nor they speak Bhutanese, nor they follow Bhutanese culture. Isn’t it common sense?
@@tenzinthinley9791 fuck you thinley. They might be Nepalese ethnic group but a Bhutanese national. Does your land belong to you and your king. They also migrated from somewhere. Don't forget that.
@@tenzinthinley9791 main is they want to settle in abroad country 😂🤣
@@tenzinthinley9791 lol just cos you’re bhutanese don’t mean you have to speak in dzongkha
I needed this one so much. Too much smugness around the whole world about Bhutan being this "symbol of peace and happiness". A symbol built on Nazist ideology. No sugar-coating it.
According to India-Nepal friendship treaty of 1950 , if any country attacks and invades Nepal, then India will come and protect Nepal from invading country 🇮🇳❤ 🇳🇵
Did you even research about it?
It's one sided story. What do you even know about bhutan?
@@SaG_BabY he is absolutely coreect
@@JimmySpace69 pretty sure india is the only one eyeing nepal and will be the 1st to atk.
@@SaG_BabY Every monarchs of world write country's history in their favour. Your king also did same so don't believe on those history books which published in your country.
As a Bhutanese refugee who was born and raised in eastern Nepal and now living in America, I have seen and lived the aftermath of this state sponsored ethnic cleansing of ethnic nepalis. My grandparents were from Panchthar Nepal who migrated to southern Bhutan in early 1900s. My parents were born in Bhutan. Having lived in a refugee camp for 14 yrs, I’ve seen some of the worst human sufferings but nowhere close to what my parents went through just for being ethnic Nepalis in Bhutan. Their traumatic experiences were passed down to us as a bedtime story. Stories I heard growing up were stories of their trauma. Stories of banning nepali language, burning of nepali books and library, murders of nepali teachers to burning villages, physical torture, killings, and rape. Their crime was, they were ethnic Nepalis. Bhutanese government must be held accountable for all these sufferings. What is needed is acknowledgment and accountability for these heinous crime of Bhutanese government. You can never pay back or undo what has already been done. Tremendous human sufferings, the massive psychological damage, undermining of our cultures and resulting refugee crisis that took away even more lives cannot be reversed. What can be done is acknowledgement of what has been done and public apology to all those who suffered at the hands of Bhutanese regime. I think this will bring tremendous peace within the hearts of those who suffered. Bhutanese government to this day denies any wrong doings and pride itself in being the most happy country in the world. You can’t kill, torture, rape and carry out a genocide that cleansed 1/6th of its population and call yourself the most happy country in the world. Bhutanese government has as much blood on its hand as that of hitler.
Sad thing is most Bhutanese(inside Bhutan) talk as if expelling own Citizens is a normal activity.
Hey now you are at world's stage.. ie American.. you have the power of free speech...and if you feel whole world should know the truth.. and unmask these Bhutanese kings you should do something.. at least share these stories to news or western publicans so that all may know the truth abt this happy kingdom
And still Bhutani who have been brainwashed by their society, their schools, think since they have some Lhotshampas beaten into submission still residing in Bhutan, that this means the exodus must have been a voluntary one. Very similar to what happened to Kashmiri Pandits in Kashmir at the hands of Islamic terrorists.
Did you want Bhutan to become another Sikkim for Nepalese origin people? That is basically what you guys are doing going around. Have some decency and let Bhutan survive its culture and religious traditions. When you go to another country, you respect and become part of that while retaining your own cultural and religious beliefs. You don't try to take over that country esp a small kingdom like Bhutan. Bhutan is not a country for immigrants like USA or some western countries that have colonized other countries. It is its own country that at times need outside population to work. That does not mean they have to be held in the same standard as powerful western countries. It is totally different.
@@bhoeshung You have the very wrong grasp of your own history buddy. Here is the history lesson for you. Ngalongs, who live mainly in the central and western regions of Bhutan, are of Tibetan descent; their ancestors arrived in Bhutan in the eighth and ninth centuries. The Ngalongs speak Dzongkha and follow the Drukpa Kagyu school of Tibetan Buddhism, which is Bhutan’s state religion. Bhutan’s king, Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck, is a Ngalong. The Sharchhops, who live in eastern Bhutan, are descendants of the earliest migrants to arrive in Bhutan; they are of Indo-Burmese origin, speak Tshangla (which is closely related to Dzongkha) and follow the Nyingma school of Tibetan Buddhism. Together the Ngalongs and Sharchhops are known as Drukpas. The third major group, who differ greatly from the Drukpas in terms of culture, language, and religion, are ethnic Nepalis in southern Bhutan; they speak Nepali and are predominantly Hindu. So, get your facts straight.
Most of my school teachers were Bhutanese refugees. They were very talented and knowledgeble. One of our teacher Indra sir used to recite his story that his house aagaan was big enough to play football with team of 8-9 player each. Our social studies teacher R.B Rai completed his bachelors degree in Bhutan before they ran away from Bhutan. Now. most of them resides in USA and i think are having very good life. They were really multitalented like good at sports, singing, art and craft, storytelling. They introduced Volleyball, Basketball, Leadership training, magazine writing and many thing which were completely new to us. I and all my school mates owe them so much as they have been huge part in making us who we are today. Their camp was at Beldangi, Damak which was 30 minutes walk from our school but had to cross river. They were well paid and could afford good lifestyle but were not allowed to have electricity, bank account, bike license, etc as that would make them look that they could afford quality life and donor like UN would not send donation as their basic needs like food, clethes, shelter, medicine, etc. Though many refugees were literally very poor and uneducated, they used to work in our field during paddy plantation and cutting. They were preffered one because of cheap labour and freindliness. My house was buit by all refugees thekedaar "maila badaa" and mistiriss. They are still in touch as most of them are abroad. The cinema hall next to my house used to get housefull most of the time(most audience were them) but after Bhutanese refugees has gone abroad, the film hall is shut down. They were very important to our towns market.I dont know what other think about them, but Some people like my teachers, those mistitis, workers uncle and aunty were so friendly. I know every of them by name. I miss them and feel good for them that after facing such humiliation all life, they are finally living a better life abroad.
thanks for such a brief report
Do you know the teacher by the name Dhanman Khadka he is my grand father he was a school teacher for 25 years
A hora
What rubbish
So called Bhutanese refugee has said in Ted talk show that they were came to Bhutan to do work like slaves now let me tell you what i know after that as a thanks they were given Bhutanese citizen afterwards they wanted there own rule and culture and don't want to follow Bhutanese rule and culture shit shameful act .
If I stay in your house and your family has accepted me and after that if I didn't listen to your family rule and do whatever I like to do then of course with no doubt your family will kick me out ...
When we look down from space , there is no territory ,no border just a single globe ; yet we are divided just for the sake of obtaining power, influence and wealth. Really touched by the question you asked at the end.
Kahiley gayou space ma?
@@kushalshrestha3913 astiii gako .. 😎
praise humanity
Jaya atheist😂😂😂
PLEASE make an English version of this. The world needs to know and not forget how the genocidal regime killed and or exiled millions!
there is English subtitle
@@lbng6311 of course there is BUT not to reach a wider audience in youtube, subtitles is not really the way. If the content was in English, a LOT more people might actually watch it.
@@PrasitGhimire right
@@PrasitGhimireYes maybe you are right brother, but I'm not so sure about that. If people were really interested in learning about this subject, then they would take the time to read the subtitles like I did. And if they found this difficult, they can always press the pause button to take it all in and then do further research in English in language to find out more.. If the maker doesn't have English as his first language, this would be difficult for him. Perhaps you may know someone who would be interested to transcribe the subtitles into English dialogue and dub over the Nepali soundtrack. However, what may help to spread this message would be a note in the title that English subtitles are available.
Lmao you should make an English version of it since you are so concerned, beecha$$$
I am the one who remained in Bhutan, we lost grandparents, Thank you nepal for giving homes to them. Thank you bro, keep digging 🔥
Why don't people talk about this in bhutan ???
Now everything is normal, we are equally treated, rights have given to us.
@@lilmangal and you don't feel bad for those who had to run now?
@@hillnsky5535 It can be painful for people to talk about bad things that happened to them in the past. Of course we all feel bad about bad things that happened in the past but we don't live in the past and we can't change the past. We can remember the past and learn from it, so we don't repeat our mistakes and we must never forget it, but it's not productive or healthy to dwell on the bad things of the past and hold hatred or grudges against what some people did in the past. It can be a challenge to think this way, but I believe we must meet this challenge, in order to move forward and live in peace and harmony.
@@hillnsky5535 obviously we feel bad, but now Bhutan prefers peace, yes it's our home❤️.
I was born in Nepali while My parents are from Bhutan 🇧🇹 but my parents fled because of crises. I still have a lot of relatives in Bhutan that live there still.
नेपाली बोल्ने नेपाली मात्रै हो भुटानी धोती होइन। जति चाँडो यो कुरा नेपालीले बुझ्छ त्यति चाँडो नेपालीको गुमेको ईज्जत फिर्ता हुन्छ विश्वमा, नत्र भुटान बाट खेदायो अब सिक्किम बाट खेदाउने हो पछि नेपाल बाट नै खेदाउछन् धोती विदेशी मिलेर। एकजुट भएर सबै नेपालीले एकअर्का लाई सहयोग दिनु पर्छ। भुटान बाट खेदाएका हाम्रै नेपालका आमा दिदी हुन। नत्र नेपालीका आउने पुस्ताको हालत रोहिंगिया शरणार्थी जस्तै हुन्छ जुन देशमा गए कुटाई हुन्छ अब नेपालीको। देश युक्रेनको बाटो लागिसक्यो।
And ur relatives are really happy now .....due to their wise decision in the past
@@DRkworld-w5dyes so true if you do not believe you can ask your relatives in Bhutan...
Thanks for bringing up this video. Until 1980, Southern Bhutanese used Nepali as the official language. We still have Bhutan's Tax documents written in Nepali. Our grandparents did free physical labour to construct roads in Bhutan. Bhutan's roads were built from free labour of Bhutanese people, not by the autocratic king and his followers.
They came to work, not to be Bhutanese
They should have understood where they belong
Your own country did not accept your people
Sad reality
Our king gave you land to settle and farm in the exchange of the road work. But you ungreatful people went against the king and refused to follow Bhutan culture.
@@binodrai3653 it belonged to Bhutan not to those neglected Nepali refugees
@@jigmelhendup9371 Our great great grandparents were the first settlers in the Southern Bhutan.
Even without citizenship, we, formal refugees, fully exercised human rights and democracy in Nepal. Sadly, you guys have fake democracy in Bhutan.
@@tenzinthinley9791 in the past land did not belong to nobody. Our Great great grandparents were the first settlers. The land belongs to us. About Bhutanese culture all cultures practice inside Bhutan is Bhutanese culture wheather Kheyung, Sarchop, Nalong, or Nepali.
Being and Bhutanese I can say that I love Bhutan and I live in Bhutan 🇧🇹
Did you not watch the video?
Such a shame!
@@kookielover1125 why shame mf ..mf.nepalies don't know anything..
What about killing of hindu
Wtf bro watch the video....
If what you said is true, then why does Bhutan currently have ministers, doctors, teachers of Nepali ethnicity? You my friend are misinformed, bhutan did not ban the Nepali language we still speak it along with the many other dialects like sharchop, bumpthap, kurtoep, and many more. We simply instated Dzongkha as the National language because it makes us distinct from any other nations. We also have a national dress which we have to wear for official work and educational institutions but that being said one is free to wear whatever at home in towns and villages. During this period there were certain intellectual people in the Nepali community with the thirst for power began to devise their plans for a separate state altogether. They wanted to abolish our kings, they confused and brainwashed ordinary Nepali people who then refused to identify with the national language and national dress, they used Nepali national dress and language to teach children
protested and wanted democracy so they could put these leaders on top, burned down our flags, used violence. All our kings wanted was for all of us to stand together as “one nation, one people” so that we could secure sovereignty for ourselves and our children in the future and all times to come. Unfortunately those that refused to abide had to be kicked out because it was leading to instability(could have become civil war) through which larger nations could use as an opportunity to destabilize and take over the whole country.
What he said is true. Many left the country. And the motive was to minimize the growing Nepali Population of south. And mind it only people from urbanized areas like Gelephu, Sarpang, Samtse, Phuentsholing etc were chased because they were at the access point. Another was to instill a fear in people of bhutan regarding these people. They were successful in both the situations.
The population that was 40% of bhuatn's mainstream people got minimized to 25% and this 25% are kept happily with equal opportunity as they are minority now.
Bhote muji Chuplag
@THEVIKING1596 show me the evidence of your mom, brother and sister. Name, photos, incident and witnesses. I don’t know everybody in Bhutan, but I do know there are ethnic Nepali Bhutanese in all ranks of society even the high posts. Why do you want to raise your voice? To cause trouble? Do you want to harm other people?
Amazing and well researched video as always! Keep up the good work!
The cause is because of ethnicity and leads to genocide.i am Bhutanese and accept this cause and sorry for those people.
What a great time to drop this content, as a Bhutanese boy gets selected in Voice Nepal, maybe it's just a coincidence but what a timing
Coincidence✌
hats off bro for this insightful content. We love the Bhutanese people, you were always a brother to us more than a refugee.
nice, i was really looking forward to this one.
I am Bhutanese and I appreciate your research and Information ♥️🇧🇹
just imagine how it feels to die from hunger and miner sickness. And children being homeless, identity less and have no place to go, nothing to eat, and nothing to wear. Those bhutanese kings and people who don’t admit that they committed a terrible sin by murdering and forcing their own citizens leave, please have you ever questioned yourself that what did you all do? God, do you even know we would still sing the national anthem of Bhutan every morning, celebrate national day of Bhutan, learn Dzongkha at school and more even after leaving Bhutan ? for what reason? Shameless, cruel, evil 👿 act by Bhutan that is yet to be repaid! And now you talk about happiness and humanity and all, have some degree of shame!
@@CatchAndCookTravelAndCamping not just in bhutan try in any country, try to create your own state and go against the country you will be faced with same consequences
you're doing an awesome job bro, keep the content coming, and keep the benchmark increasing.
Loved the fact that you showed the real Flag of Tibet. My heart goes to Bhutanese refugees. We all long to go back to our home country. May we b able to do that someday.
So called Bhutanese refugee has said in Ted talk show that they were came to Bhutan to do work like slaves now let me tell you what i know after that as a thanks they were given Bhutanese citizen afterwards they wanted there own rule and culture and don't want to follow Bhutanese rule and culture shit shameful act .
If I stay in your house and your family has accepted me and after that if I didn't listen to your family rule and do whatever I like to do then of course with no doubt your family will kick me out ...
I've met many many peoples from Bhutan, especially the older peoples they are so deeply scarred and mentally destroyed. Some break down during Therapy, some don't even properly remember their name. I've heard stories from those who were strong enough and were able to share stories. Such horrors, such calamities. Hope they've got the life they deserved and not the life they were forced.
I hope those refugees who were treated outlaws by their own ethnic country Nepal, hope they got the life they deserved, not the the life they are forced to
God bless those refugees in America
Those were the saddest human to be neglected by their own motherland Nepal
They brought that crises to themselves. Who told them to protest against the government and king? We rest of Bhutanese are happy here in our GNH country Bhutan with our god kings.
@@tenzinthinley9791 1. Fᴜᴄᴋ ᴀʟʟ ᴛʜᴀᴛ.
2. Wᴇ ᴍᴜsᴛ ʜᴀᴠᴇ ʀɪɢʜᴛs ᴛᴏ Fʀᴇᴇᴅᴏᴍ ᴏғ ʀᴇʟɪɢɪᴏɴ, sᴘᴇᴇᴄʜ, ᴘʀᴇss, ᴀssᴇᴍʙʟʏ ᴀɴᴅ ᴘᴇᴛɪᴛɪᴏɴ.
4. Cᴏᴍᴘᴀʀᴇ ᴜsᴀ ᴡɪᴛʜ ʙʜᴜᴛᴀɴ ᴡʜʏ ɪs ᴜsᴀ sᴏ ᴅɪᴠᴇʀsᴇ ᴀɴᴅ ᴅᴇᴠᴇʟᴏᴘᴇᴅ? I ᴡɪʟʟ ɢɪᴠᴇ ʏᴏᴜ ᴛʜᴇ ᴀɴsᴡᴇʀ ʙᴇᴄᴀᴜsᴇ ᴘᴇᴏᴘʟᴇ ᴀʀᴇ ᴅɪᴠᴇʀsᴇ ᴛʜᴇʀ ғʀᴏᴍ ᴀʟʟ ᴏᴠᴇʀ ᴛʜᴇ ᴄᴏᴜɴᴛʀʏ ᴡʜɪᴄʜ ʜᴀs ɴᴏ ᴋɪɴɢ, ᴋɪɴɢ ᴡɪᴛʜ ᴀ ᴄᴏᴜɴᴛʀʏ ɪs ᴄᴏᴍᴍᴜɴɪsᴛ.
5. Eᴠᴇɴ ʙʟᴀᴄᴋ ᴘᴇᴏᴘʟᴇ ᴡᴇʀᴇ ᴍɪɢʀᴀᴛᴇᴅ ᴛᴏ ᴜsᴀ ᴀɴᴅ ғᴏʀᴄᴇᴅ ᴀs sʟᴀᴠᴇ
6. Fᴜᴄᴋ ᴛʜᴇ ᴋɪɴɢ
7.Tɪᴍᴇ ʜᴀs ᴄʜᴀɴɢᴇᴅ ɴᴏᴡ.
8. ᴄɪᴛɪᴢᴇɴ sʜᴏᴜʟᴅ ʙᴇ ᴛʜᴇ ɪɴ ᴄʜᴀʀɢᴇ ᴏғ ᴛʜᴇ ᴄᴏᴜɴᴛʀʏ ɴᴏᴛ ᴀ ᴘᴜssʏ ᴋɪɴɢ ᴡʜᴏ ᴄʀɪᴇs ʟɪᴋᴇ ᴀ ʙɪᴛᴄʜ.
@@tenzinthinley9791 Ofcourse you are happy when things are in your favor. Don't forget that people of Nepalese origin have been in Bhutan since 1620, when Newar craftsmen were commissioned to come to and build a stupa in Bhutan. They have been there ever since. Get your facts starlight before you make such a baseless claims.
@@jigmelhendup9371 That's why we laugh on your logic's
And Refuggee must thank Your King
Because of his kinddness
They are in America Developed Nation And you are still in Bhutan developing Nation like ours ❤
Unity is best policy Sir/Mam
Bhutanese inside Bhutan are mad in the comment section which means this is great Video. You are going right direction, keep it up brother
Ignorance is real with these people
We getting hurt is a cheerful thing for you, it's a sick mindset, stop spreading misinformation.
Okay then if some video about your country is made where there is only one sided story wouldn't u dare to defend and then some random guy of the opposite country try to say omg nepalis inside nepal are mad...bro sense we feel same we ain't devil
Cry harder baby... do whatever you want but we don't give a fuck to the traitors
@@ugyenwangchuk3026 ohh you guys have feelings too?? Nice to know
My uncle is still in jail I have gone to visit like 3 times. Somehow he calls us sometimes saying we might not be able to see him again as our family has now migrating to Australia. But it was very nice to learn more about the history that I always questioned.
did you migrated directly from Bhutan or from the refugee camp of nepal?
My grandfather is still free in Bhutan. He neither have Bhutan's citizenship nor Nepal's citizenship.
Learn both stories
So called Bhutanese refugee has said in Ted talk show that they were came to Bhutan to do work like slaves now let me tell you what i know after that as a thanks they were given Bhutanese citizen afterwards they wanted there own rule and culture and don't want to follow Bhutanese rule and culture shit shameful act .
If I stay in your house and your family has accepted me and after that if I didn't listen to your family rule and do whatever I like to do then of course with no doubt your family will kick me out ...
I used to hate Bhutan for this particular reason and still hate for the same reason.
And no one cares what you think....so you can keep hating but those people living here know what true happiness is.... 😁
@@tsheringdorji8297 and the people living in usa refugee camps know what true suffering is...due to bhutan
@@whitneylj90 exactly
This guy is a gem. the amount of research in his videos can really be seen and the quality of his videos are consistent and keeps getting better...
Some right some wrong but you should ask the real question how Mr.Tek Nath played the role into this dirty politics. Even now our Bhutanese refugees who are settled down in the western countries don't like him because he is the one who brain wash our lhotsampa Bhutanese who makes them suffer for their identity
Nahhhh he still needs to do enough homework
@@trojajn3031 yeah very much brother...it is like being one sided tbh
Basically he downloaded some clips from UA-cam videos made by some western person about the royals. The rest can easily be accessible on internet. Basically you can get any information on google.
नेपाली बोल्ने नेपाली मात्रै हो भुटानी धोती होइन। जति चाँडो यो कुरा नेपालीले बुझ्छ त्यति चाँडो नेपालीको गुमेको ईज्जत फिर्ता हुन्छ विश्वमा, नत्र भुटान बाट खेदायो अब सिक्किम बाट खेदाउने हो पछि नेपाल बाट नै खेदाउछन् धोती विदेशी मिलेर। एकजुट भएर सबै नेपालीले एकअर्का लाई सहयोग दिनु पर्छ। भुटान बाट खेदाएका हाम्रै नेपालका आमा दिदी हुन। नत्र नेपालीका आउने पुस्ताको हालत रोहिंगिया शरणार्थी जस्तै हुन्छ जुन देशमा गए कुटाई हुन्छ अब नेपालीको। देश युक्रेनको बाटो लागिसक्यो।
great content bro. Happy to see you videos in youtube. Get going bro, I've been supporting you frok beginning and will be supporting you till end. Love you bro❤️❤️❤️❤️
Those who says they’re pure Bhutanese and have mother tongue as Dzongkha they’re Tibetan refugee as They came down to Bhutan and came in power,make their language as National language before that Bhutan don’t have official language and as of now with Indian influence that day is not so far when Hindi became Bhutan official language and Bhutan just a state of India.
You and your so called Nepali brainwashing propaganda 🤣
In fact the reality is that you guys were the one who destroyed the tribal languages of Khas/Newars (IDK what you call them), interfered in their food habits and imposed Nepali language on them.
Bhutan is not an Hindu country like Nepal nor an economic power like Bangladesh. So, why would we make Bhutan as a state of India when it is already respecting India's sovereignty and supporting India's national interests.
And by the way Nepal is the one who getting influenced by Hindi.
@@ashaypallav4158 India's has huge English speakers and influence.. does that mean West is trying to grab India?
Nepalese can understand Hindi, English and there is growing interest in learning Chinese.. if majority of us can learn these languages... We can trade with 70% of people in the world and doesn't need a translator. 😉
@@obito4203 Tell this to your friend Deepan 😂
mf dhotis spreading everywhere
The whole world is enemy,,but it's ok ,,we the people of Nepal always going to welcome those refugees because my mother once told me that...
sad guest are another face of God and we should respect them and serve them as equal like our home mate
Bro what ?
Aww so cute.
Did your mother also tell you to marry someone of your own caste only? Because that's what most mother tell their children in our lovely country that treats guests well.
And same bhutanese refugees who are now well settled in US becoz of Nepal are talking bad about Nepal
@@sarwasadharan Why you're bringing caste system here? Even if mum didn't told this we will marry our own caste.
@@DeusEstAmor________137 lol sherpa got roasted
TQ for reminding me of this ... The year was 1997,i was studying in class 2 at STRBS Pang Parbat , our teachers Mr dev, Miss Puja, Miss Namrata , Mr T.B sir were telling us about this incident why they become refugees.
They are long gone from beldangi to baltimore, but this story reminds me of all of my guidance they tell us ...
Tq again
that's deep.
Same here they taught me back in the days .
So called Bhutanese refugee has said in Ted talk show that they were came to Bhutan to do work like slaves now let me tell you what i know after that as a thanks they were given Bhutanese citizen afterwards they wanted there own rule and culture and don't want to follow Bhutanese rule and culture shit shameful act .
If I stay in your house and your family has accepted me and after that if I didn't listen to your family rule and do whatever I like to do then of course with no doubt your family will kick me out ...
Looks like there are so many vultures waiting for Bhutan to fall. Our visionary leaders bold defiance might have won wreath from those refugees but he did it for our country's prosperity and security. Who told them to posed severe threats on the southern Bhutanese? Jeopardizing the peace and security of the country, if their doings isn't terrorism acts, then tell me what is it? What our visionary and magnificent leader did has purpose. So don't blame Bhutan when they are at fault. Don't talk bullshits when you don't know the depth. Don't be so jealous when you were not fortunate enough to be under his visionary reign.
Lado khaa pakhe mugi bhutaness india ko dhoti samayera fursad xaima mugi dhoti ko bachha dherai english nabhuk
Jealous and of your country!!?? Nah we don't have time for that 🥱
well done bro! this thing needs to come out to show the truth of happiness index
This reminds that citizenship is sensitive issue and our politician are planing to distribute nepalese citizenship like Toffees ..
Thank you for the history of our country sir... Bhutan as of now I wasn't have any ideas because..these truth was never reveled and never thought in our school days also... like how Nepali peoples were arrived and had flourished in southern part of Bhutan.
Could you also shed some light on the mass exodus of skilled manpower, like doctors, engineers, nurses, etc. ? Also how the Nepal government is willingly propagating this exodus of youth abroad, just so they can get a taste of that "remittance tax"..
P.S. Nepal is going to face a huge shortage of doctors and nurses in the coming 5-8 years. Even, reputed and established doctors are flocking abroad..... all the while, the policy makers do nothing to encourage the retention of this skilled man-power... Sahujis and influential doctors are themselves the policy makers and make policies that helps them gain their personal benefits...
Gorkha Kingdom at its greatest comprised mainland Nepal, Kumaon-Garhwal province in North India in the west to the Teesta River in the east, today in the Darjeeling hills. Ever since, the land has been receding. Owing to this, today our Gorkha community faces identity crisis in our respective countries as well as among ourselves. We have been in so much decline that today, to buy anything relating to our culture, we have to buy from non-Gorkhas. We are slowly enslaved by outsiders in our own land and definitely burn out from human History. Where is the Jai in 'Jai Gorkha'?
@@Hardik.Lohani For an even bigger picture, look at the Soviet Union and Russia. All the previous Soviet Republics had differing ethnicities, culture and ways. Just like Kumaon-Garhwal differing from Mainland Nepal then or East Nepal being significantly different from West Nepal or Darjeeling hills differing from Mainland Nepal.
.
Today those previous Soviet Republics are different countries but have the connecting link due to past events. You can whine about it, turn away but that was how it was. We are at a similar situation. It's not about hatred or who did what to whom. Read my previous comment carefully cause there I talk about how those Gorkhas and their legacy is of no use to the current Gorkha population because we have fallen from grace. I did not intend to offend you, it's me talking of our fall and not bitching about you.
.
If history would have played out any different, we'd be talking differently about these events, but it is what it is.
.
Relax I'm from India too. I love Uttrakhand. Spent 4 wonderful years there. Kumaon-Garhwal is no far from heaven. Peace
@@Hardik.Lohani we're talking about 2 different things now. Totally missing each other's point so congratulations you won in what you're trying to say. Peace
@@Hardik.Lohani Let's have a drink and talk about it shall we? You're mixing whatever I said. Very typical. Very much.
@@Hardik.Lohani Yeah. You bet!
@@Hardik.Lohani thanks connoisseur.
The quality and information in this video is so detailed and interesting that teenage also loved to watch 😍🙂
So called Bhutanese refugee has said in Ted talk show that they were came to Bhutan to do work like slaves now let me tell you what i know after that as a thanks they were given Bhutanese citizen afterwards they wanted there own rule and culture and don't want to follow Bhutanese rule and culture shit shameful act .
If I stay in your house and your family has accepted me and after that if I didn't listen to your family rule and do whatever I like to do then of course with no doubt your family will kick me out ...
This was a long time coming. Bhutan today has cleverly made itself known as the land of Shangrila and a place where the happiness index is measured. This is a dark history that the west has ever so calmly decided to forget from Indian influence.
I don't think it's been that long. The refugees are still alive and still want to return to their homes.
Fake national gross happiness because I have been there for 20 years
@@lalgurung2443 If Nepal were to be overtaken by Indians (you call them Bihari's) or the Chinese I would like to see what their reaction would be. Get a dose of reality check and some perspective.
Land of shamgrilla propoganda is not new. It was even in the 1980’s or 1990’s when ethnic cleanisng was going on. So it’s hard to believe that anything has changed. You can’t criticize tsa wa sum(king, people and country). Criticize any part, and you will be declare anti national in bhutan.
@@wonderfullife737 just ask to yourself, is your country worth living, I guess not worth more than Bhutan
eagerly waiting for part 2!! Nice content brother. Lots of love!!
Still world does not knows the True Black face of Bhutan.
Some of them are still living in Refugee camps in Jhapa. They refused to go to US in a hope that they could go back to their country. They were chased for demanding democracy. Now that they have got democracy, they should really consider taking them back.
I am a young boy. From 2005 till now I am happy to be a Bhutanese and I am Lhotsampa .i am very proud of my country. U have learned many things of Bhutan's past .
Now let me tell u that u only know the past let me tell u the present our king celebrate our dassi . N our king has helped many Lhotsampa our king does not compare. ♥️♥️♥️Long live our king
Because lhotshmpa are no more demographic threat. Their percentage is now low enough it doesn’t threaten ngalop dominance.
@@santoshrai10111 ya u will be in hell, and our king and their legacy will continue… just dream on
@@wonderfullife737 did u research about that.
@@wonderfullife737 small minded people, do yoga and bring in some positive thoughts
@@sailorbride8385 you people talk about yoga, meditation, happiness, blah bla while defending Ethnic cleansing and genocide. First give us our land, house, property back than we will do medication, yoga, whatever. You hypocrite.
Bhutan's king doing good for there limited losonpa who lived in Bhutan right now because he know that losonpa are able to talk about their rights and become against the whole Bhutan .
so
I think it is a biggest fear of Bhutan king
And another question
Is Bhutan got the peace ??
Who say Bhutan is peaceful nation..
Who make refugees their thousand of citizens
Bhutan the land of happiness, an irony. How? The world should really observe the past about this little country.
Hard work paid off! Thank you so much for sharing it! Truth Never Dies!
Truth immigrant creating mess in the country,and eating and shiting on same plate
Bhutan always had a fear of supression of growing Nepali Population in the south and another factor was illegal nepali migration and cross boarder marriage with Nepali of Assam and West Bengal. So the King was forced to chase them away with lot of reasons and this is the valid fact how much they try to hide the information.
Today the country has once again restored its image as a peaceful nation and accepted this 25% of minority as their citizen.
It's just like the partition of Pakistan and India but this one is bit serious as they had to stay in refugee camp of other nation unlike Muslims getting shelter in Pakistan and indian getting home in India.
The third world accepted this refugees and now today they live in advanced part of the world like the US.
Love you from bhutan great analysis brother
These Bhutanese refugees received amnesty and asylum in USA but the Nepal ( Brahman ) government took that opportunity and send their own families instead. I read this in NY times. Poorer the country more corrupt the people
The cultural homogenization of Bhutan reminds me of the same that happened in Nepal especially under King Mahendra. Like you can't really criticize Bhutan for this if you also support the "one language,one dress,one culture" ethos that itself destroyed Multiculturalism in Nepal,the effects of which is still visible today.
Not to be pro Bhutan in this butttt Bhutan is a mirror to Nepal in this.
What u talking about?
@@Siddartha.Gautam Basically hypocrisy of people who'll denounce Bhutan for hegemonizing yet will support the mono-ethnic state & its present fragments that Mabendra himself created. Like there's a reason why non Nepali languages died and still are dying.
The cultural homogenization of Nepal in itself is a very very interesting topic which I hope Nepali comment makes a video on.
@@lalitthapa101 I guess you are okay with glossing over the fact that Bhutan committed forced exodus with mass human rights violations. Like yeah Nepal has it's issues but it's such a gross overgeneralization that you think that because this happened in Nepal, that this exodus cannot be blamed on Bhutan. It's asinine really.
I completely agree. Mahendra's one country, one language, and one culture policy absolutely ruined the country's livid multi-cultural aspect. The irony is that this is precisely the opposite of what his ancestor Prithivi Narayan Shah wanted, as said in his Divyopadesh. Everyone now speaks Khas Nepali as their first language. And almost no Newah, Tamang, Gurung and Magar children speak their mother tongue. And this is true for most indigenous communities, except for the Madhesi people who have been able to successfully preserve their languages.
@@whitneylj90 Not really though. I'm not trying to excuse Bhutan from this.
I've not at any point In my comments tried to pave an excuse path for Bhutan.Bhutan is in the wrong here.
What I am talking about though is that the goals of both have been same=Mono-culturalism.
I clearly state you can't criticize Bhutan *IF* you defend Nepal's goals of the same as "important for nation building" type excuses that's visible in basically any discourse of matters like revival of ethnic languages.
I'm just commenting on the hypocrisy of those who are critical of this until it comes to their side.
I m Bhutanese....I think this is truth ...
Here people are all brainwashed by their history text ....mentioning Bhutanese and their leader as always a good and a nice one.... therefore if you are reliveing the truth people out here will mad.
But I support you... because truth cannot be hidden
Do you even know what might have surely happened if the king didn’t made those changes?
There would have been strikes, lots of protests every time the government didn’t meet people’s demand like it’s happening in Nepal and other countries.
Just because somebody posted a video for their content growing channel, you started to assume and believe anything they shared.
You vividly knows that the Whole of Nepal’s beloved royal family was massacred by their own people.
Just think what if the country had two governments, one Bhutanese and one Nepalese (Lhotshampa)..
do you think the country Bhutan would stand today as an independent country?
The country would have already been invaded or conquered by China or India.
You should be really grateful for what the kings of Bhutan did.
You need to grow up and think in a broad way rather than having a narrow mind.
Be thankful that the country is peaceful and loving compared to other countries.
@@waterecstasy835 So you consider North Korea to be an ideal county? There are no protests and their citizen demand nothing from their dictator. Bhutan is exactly what North Korea would look like if they had good PR.
@@sandorclegane5258 Mate! How on earth do you even compare North Korea and Bhutan ?
You outta mind or what?
North Korea wouldn’t even come any near to Bhutan!
Man! You gone stupid !
There is always a story unheard from another person. The story he said in the Video is his side while there is a story from other side too.
@@waterecstasy835 Bhutan is a sugarcoated North Korea. You hide your country's actual status with a Happiness index bullshit, you have no democracy and the citizens are brainwashed into believing that your dictator is Buddha.
@@waterecstasy835 Maybe; maybe not. but no one can predict the future and say just think what would happen in the future if this or that happened or didn't happen in the past. this or that would happen. Maybe it would; maybe it wouldn't. If we could predict the future then King Birendra of Nepal would have surely appeased his son in some way so that he didn't feel his only option was to kill his parents, his siblings and himself. (If indeed Prince Dipendra did this - some people believe it was not him). But will we ever really know the whole truth behind the Nepali Royal family massacre? Yes, for sure we can be very thankful that today Bhutan is a peaceful and loving country. But maybe we also have to think of the misery, sorrow and pain that many people went through to get Bhutan into this peaceful and loving state today and put ourselves in the position of being Lhotshampa today. Remember they didn't choose to be born Lhotshampa. Actually, the truth can sometimes be hidden, but not forever and there are two sides to this story which need to be considered if we want to see it from a balanced point of view. One side is never usually absolutely right or absolutely wrong There are usually degrees of right and wrong and truths and non-truths on both sides.
as a marwadi in Nepal, I wonder and fear if this might happen to us as well someday.
Marwadi openly speaks Hindi and promote Agra/Mughal culture of wedding.
Marwadi should try to adopt Nepali culture and language in their home as well
@@DeusEstAmor________137 No one needs to adopt anything tbh. But also no ones trying to kick no one out of Nepal either 😂 If he fears this so much maybe have a plan for an exit for the future 😂
Marwadi people exploiting our nepali economy and politics..67 marwadi controling our resources, politics and politician..recend chaudary bashbari kanda is enough how yr community misuse our politician..if it continue definitely our society goes in war
It is one of the most notorious crime on humanity in the recent history in Asia.
Thank you brother for this amazing video ❤ as a Bhutanese refugee myself and growing up in camps, I have only heard stories from my parents and other elderly people, it’s great to watch and hear more detailed information/stories.
Its definitely heartbreaking when your own government/people doesn’t want to accept you as their own because even though many people in camps were born in Nepal, we were never considered actual Nepali and were accepted by people.
Anyway Can’t wait for part 2
Thanks for the great video
Much love ❤🇳🇵❤
This video was not Amazing
Only if those refugees understood that they were treated as Refugees in their own country Nepal
How could Nepal govt do that
Did your parents told you that how they refused to be Bhutanese and refused to follow Bhutanese culture and traditions, and had Nepal king Photo in the wall??? If you are King, How would you feel if you see your people having photo of different king in the wall?? This shows Nepalis were Ungrateful people in Bhutan.
Did your parents tell how they go again the king when he want to make 1 country 1 national kill innocent people and go again national dress..
@@jigmelhendup9371 How come some people that have been been living in Bhutan for 3 generations, have Bhutanese citizenship are Nepalese, yes at some point they migrated from Nepal, they do speak Nepalese and that is true, so does every one. Your four fathers migrated from some place at some point as well, Don't you know anything about cultural diversity, sir? You won't get it, the only day you will get is the day you are abandoned from your own country, and I pray to god you don't have to face that day any time soon.
@@sudipgurung7131 simple and logical answer to your pathetic opinion is those Nepalese were born with gratitude and integrity
I don't know about you but I don't like to keep snakes at my yard
Chup Sala! From the very start, this video is filled with historical inaccuracies, or should I call it manipulated info? Sala kaam chhaina. Howrey video banayera view khojeko? If you need income, at least make it in an honest way!
Shut the fu*k off . Why don't you read all the researches provide in the description .
Really well told video, keep up the great job!
As a Buddhist i appreciate your work and research ❤💙👏keep it up
Learn full story first.
A very well needed content about how Bhutanese Nepali people came to Nepal. Much needed content. Expecting more of this type of content in the future.
According to India-Nepal friendship treaty of 1950 , if any country attacks and invades Nepal, then India will come and protect Nepal from invading country 🇮🇳 🇳🇵
@Toxicity How is India attacking Nepal?
Elaborate please
@@JimmySpace69 chal nikal
@@Batmeth69420 but you cannot deny the reality, that, India encroaches Nepali land without a reason
Ya they are back to where they are originally from..👍🏻
Thankyou for these information. We can clearly see the effort you put to research all these history. 🙏
Just want to know, Those Nepali people who were evicted from Bhutan are still living in southern Nepal camps or they're back to Bhutan? Where are they?
@@Fandomreal1 I do know that many (but probably not all) were taken in as refugees by Europe, America, Australia and New Zealand.
So called Bhutanese refugee has said in Ted talk show that they were came to Bhutan to do work like slaves now let me tell you what i know after that as a thanks they were given Bhutanese citizen afterwards they wanted there own rule and culture and don't want to follow Bhutanese rule and culture shit shameful act .
If I stay in your house and your family has accepted me and after that if I didn't listen to your family rule and do whatever I like to do then of course with no doubt your family will kick me out ...
Those people never wanted to abide by the law and order of Bhutan.
So, they went against Bhutan. They don't even host Bhutan flag in the school, they refuse to wear national dress. Now, when they see peaceful Bhutan, they wanted to destroy the fame of this people country.
Who keep these kind of people in the country?
Hey people, there are lot of people who speak nepali, and follow their culture. And happily for three decades, one of ten ministers is Lotshampa.
Bhutan king was afraid that 4 out of 10 minister will be lhotshmpa if parliamentary democrasy comes to Bhutan which is inevitable in today’s world, so he made plan to reduce Lhotshampa population from 40% to 20%, now Ngalop power is safe, wangchuk dynasty is safe.
@@himalayahoo The democracy started in 2008 and the ngolop happened way back in 19s.
Wtf you talking about? To 20% Lotshampa? Where the fuck you saw this statics 🙄. I see all you fucking lie and trying to destroy the fame of this country.
I ain't surprise that you were chased away ✌️
Deserve it!!!!!!!!
We owe our kings so much gratitude.Having been born and raised in Bhutan, I am aware that everything my king did was for the benefit of my country, as opposed to what the film would have you believe. Any disparaging remarks or false facts cannot erase our love, respect, and faith in our kings. Pelden Drukpa Gyalo !
You can not criticise king in Bhutan, you will be declared anti- national, and will be killed or will go missing
Friendly reminder that king are humans and can make mistakes. They aren’t gods meant to be worshipped
Palden drukpa gyalo 👍👍👍
ain't that the irony calling 100+k refugees a false fact.
I am AASHISH TAMANG. Tamang a Nepalese born Buddhist not Brahmin. So I have an Asian face. So, few weeks ago a Brahmin friend of mine called me Bhutanese refugee.I couldn’t say anything. I was speechless. Ever since I am very keen to find if there is that connection between me and Bhutan. And you upload a video on Bhutanese refuge.
Anyway good video
Bhutanese refugees can be brahmin\chhetri
ewar\gurung\tamang\limbu. Tell that guy to politely "f off" and that he looks indian :).
what a content;really grateful brother ;wanna seriously praised your research;presentation and hardworking.👏👏👏
Completely support what Bhutan took steps to stop illegal immigrants. If it wasn't done then today Bhutan would be like Sikkim and Darjeeling rule by immigrants Gorkha people. Bhutan wont be so peaceful like it today. Bravo Bhutan😊
Some uncovered facts about those refugees:
- They revolted against The King and Government.
- Denied peace talks and opted for violence.
- Refused to speak national language and wear national dress which is the real identity of a nation.
- Stopped sending their kids in school saying they don't want their kids to learn national subjects.
- Killed and abused innocent Bhutanese residing in southern areas.
- Came up with their own law and constitution.
And for your information, today we have Lhotshampa's holding position like Ministers, Engineers, Doctors, Teachers, Actors, Singers and many more who are loved and respected by every Bhutanese. We have Lhotshampa friends with whom we eat and sleep together. Bhutan would have already lost its independence if those revolvers have not been punished. We are Bhutanese and we are proud Bhutanese.
Long Live His Majesty..... Long Live the Wangchuck Dynasty🙏🙏🙏
Nice propaganda and villainize attempt spread by the regime to justify ethnic cleansing of innocent people. Did your regime told you that schools were converted into army barracks??
We don't care about you brother .....we.r nepali ..we care ..who is Bhutan....fuck you Bhutan
@@aricksamrat3161 Jeezuz bro no one said anything bad to you.. why you so triggered.
@@randomfunclips3505 he was speaking facts
Maybe you got triggered by actual facts?
So . This is how u are brainwashed . U can say anything u want but do not tell me those 1 lakh people werent bhutanese . Bhutan did exiled their own people bcz they didnt looked liked what a real bhutanese should look like . Thats a fact .
And whatever u mentioned as points to justify the action . U r a fool mate if u think it justifies the actions taken by bhutan.
Some people are crying in comment section as if they were the victim of that mass deportation.
I am Bodo tribe my home is less than 15km distance from bhutan in baksa dist,lots of migrants enter nearby by our village after conflict
Thanks for the history which has not been taught to us in school.. Bhutan is a peaceful country, we are proud to be Bhutanese, but we deserve to know the history... but now i think everything is back to peaceful state..
Bhutan is pooo
Great research and analysis and preparation, much needed video.
Great work bhai
Your video is so much awesome and informative...love it keep it up brother 😅❤️
much needed content, thank you for covering this one 🙏. I had so much queries about this since I watched herne katha- ep 56. Patiently waiting for part 2
We r happy that we r bhuddhist..u 4got one things..that u people who betrayed our government..u killed our many south people..that y our army send u guys out of country..And if u be same like that..u will never welcome to our land..long lived the king..
Can' wait for part II❤️❤️
This video is going to be so controversial, I don't know the whole truth but we all understand, that not all countries have happy endings.
Tell the reason behind why Bhutan did this wrong
It was because of high numbers of lotshampa population back then which was 40% of total population of Bhutan. King felt a threat of losing power and identity. Every country has black history.
Really appreciate this channel .
I can smell the hardwork and homework you did just for 20 mins video.
Kudos for that.
Keep the content coming.❤❤❤
Search done from Google university ❤️
Does anyone knows if there’s any button that a person can click to translate videos to other languages or add subtitles.? I really want to see this video but I don’t understand the language.
Any input will be greatly appreciated
आफ्नो रुचीको बिषय नभएपनि तपाईंको भिडियो आएपछि चाहिँ हेर्न छुटाउन नमिल्ने रहेछ। धेरै क़ुरा जान्नबुझ्न पाईने।
भूटानी शरणार्थीप्रति पनि सम्मान बढ्यो अब मेरो।
धन्यवाद 🙏
Lots of love to Bhotang from Nepal. World happiest and only Buddhist country,, Bhutan taught what is Buddhism: Unlike Buddha who left his kingdom and palace, modern Bhutanese Buddhism practice is all about expelling non Buddhist. How to be happy: just expell sad ones and stop revolt. What a country. Each nation should learn how to create a hypocrisy
To all the Bhutanese people reading this comment please remember Karma is bitch.
A joker narrating a story and another fool setting an example through the comment section.
@@Steverog3ahaha ur such a joker and call yourself buddist what a joke
This has to be noted well. Guru Rinpoche is not a Tibetan Leader, although he is a well respected and powerful buddhist tantric, he is from India.
he is from udiyana somewhere near the border of Pakistan and Afghanistan
@@johnjones99124 ooh man it still come under ancient India
@@AMAN-gh2hp now it does fall in India
@@AMAN-gh2hp whatsapp University graduate is telling that guru rinpoche was born in India when there was no such things called India existed
Indian people telling like this 😂😂
Everything is our 😂😂
I have read through most of the comments and found that most of the Bhutanese are justifying this incident by asking, “how would you feel if a guest comes over and starts enforcing laws on you?” So to all those who have such mindset let me also ask you guys this question, “how would you feel if the land in where your parents were born, where they built house where they cultivated food grains and lived for generations is suddenly taken by someone saying that this land belongs to me and you from tomorrow you’ll have to obey my orders.”? That is exactly what happened in the south. Some of the Nepali/Lhotshampas were settled in the southern foothills of Bhutan from 16th and 17th Century itself. It was during those days that the Greater Nepal was being formed, so there were many civil wars and bloodshed happening in Nepal during those days. As a result of this conflict most of the eastern part of Nepalese fled Nepal and reached what is known as Sikkim, Assam and Bhutan today. But during those times there were no boundaries and borders defining Nepal, Sikkim, Bhutan and most of the North East part of India. So, see guys, the Kingdom of Bhutan was formed In 1907 only and before the formation of the kingdom, the political leaders of Bhutan had no authority and conflict as such with the southern part of Bhutan. Their Jurisdiction were just in westen, Central and Eastern part of Bhutan. But after 1907, Bhutan officially marked the southern foothills under its border and called it their land. The Nepalese people settling in the south were not even aware that the land that they are living and had been living for generations has come under the Kingdom of Bhutan. Some estimates shows that there were about 30-40 thousand of Nepalese origin people settling in the southern foothills during those times. But they didn’t oppose the change and decided to be part of the newly formed Kingdom. And during 2nd or Third kings reign more Nepalese were invited to settle in southern foothills because the ngalops couldn’t go and settle in the southern side because of the climate difference. Now tell me how did these Nepalese become guest?
Let's just leave the past, no one gains nothing, and not all were ordered to leave , only illegal immigrants who immigrated in the early 1990s were made to leave, those immigrants were the main reason why nepali population was rising rapidly in the southern part of Bhutan.
brilliant! keep up the good work!
Unity is what makes Bhutan strong and independent. If Bhutan let them have their own nationality then Bhutan would have become easy prey in the past . They did it for to protect their countries . Peace ✌️
Same thing followed by Nepal towards Madhesis and other minorities is justifiable then Bhutan is also right ❤️❤️
Started with a factual incorrect: Guru Rinpoche is not a Tibetan master but was an Indian Tantaric master who was invited to Tibet by Tibetan emperor.
सत्य कुरा त के हो रे भन्दाखेरी जसरी बाहुन भारतबाट नेपाल आएर देशलाई कंगाल बनाए त्यसैगरी भुटानलाई पनि कंगाल बनाउने सम्भावना भएको ठानेर लखेटेको भन्ने कुरा छ त।
India could have acted and stopped 15000 Nepaali hindu from genosie and expel.India also didnt do anything to stop pandits genocide in kashmir.
Is India really a Hindu country?? It's just so hard to believe. USA and UK have helped persecuated Hindus more than India. Remember when idi amin of Uganda expelled Gujarati hindus, it was USA and UK that gave them refuge. Same with Fiji Hindus.
Im from Bhutan and i love both Bhutan and Nepal.... And thats the past and i really feel bad...but past is past and it has been changed drastically...and Ive never been to other places apart from Bhutan and i dont want to go either...why? Because Bhutan is something else...the people the King the laws the peace everything ♥️♥️♥️ and no hatred towards nepal too i love nepali people's too...they are kind and when asked about our country lhotshampas too says that they love Bhutan
Padmasambhāva ("Born from a Lotus"),[note 1] also known as Guru Rinpoche (Precious Guru) and the Lotus from Oḍḍiyāna, was a tantric Buddhist Vajra master from India who taught Vajrayana in Tibet (circa 8th - 9th centuries).[1][2][3][4] According to some early Tibetan sources like the Testament of Ba, he came to Tibet in the 8th century and helped construct Samye Monastery, the first Buddhist monastery in Tibet.[3] However, little is known about the actual historical figure other than his ties to Vajrayana and Indian Buddhism.[5][1] .
Waiting from yesterday for this video
I hope it goona be 🔥🔥🔥
According to India-Nepal friendship treaty of 1950 , if any country attacks and invades Nepal, then India will come and protect Nepal from invading country 🇮🇳❤ 🇳🇵
Thank you for such informative content as always.
I believe Identity/ sense of belonging/security is what humans are always in search of .
A group identity gives a sense of security. Be it Nationality/religion/language/culture/race/ethnicity/institutions/political party.
In 21st century group identity of National Identity is prevalent.
When fear (actual /virtual) drives the ruling king/party/group, they take extreme measures. Refugee crisis is one of them.
Informative but you should also know the reality of Nepal government
They wore same dress and spoke same language
Still then Nepal government didn't consider to give them Nepali citizenship
@@jigmelhendup9371 Its sad indeed. Govt. should give them.
@@jigmelhendup9371 why don't you give Tibetians regugees Citizenship then... they follow the same culture. Infact same people...!!
@@obito4203 they are assholes ..one day China will invade Bhutan and kicks bhota ass from Bhutan 😂history repeat 🔁
@@obito4203 well my friend, u are asking wrong guy.
Thanks you so much bro you are the best creator of Nepal ❤️
According to India-Nepal friendship treaty of 1950 , if any country attacks and invades Nepal, then India will come and protect Nepal from invading country 🇮🇳❤ 🇳🇵
You have a type of voice that no one can ignore. Thank you for making this type of videos.
Even though I am lhotshampa I can proudly say I love my king, country and people and what ever you said was trust but every coin have 2 sides like that it's not all about bhutanese government fault there was nepali fault somewhere also. Anyways brother you explained it perfectly through the point of view of refugees now make a video in the point of view from us lhotshampa bhutanese. My father was engineer in Bhutan from 1988 in Bhutan and still we are living happily in Bhutan till now, own house in punakha second capital of Bhutan and in our village we are only one nepali family in whole ngalong community but they never treated me down they always looked after me as their son and my parent used to keep me in their house for month. So I totally not agree with you in fullest. My brother mo pani nepali ho. I am sorry for what happened in past and still in Bhutan there is 40 percent nepali but we have been blessed with our handsome fifth king who never let any bhutanese down thank you brother
A human requires 3 things to live a meaningful life: competence, autonomy and belongingness. Ani aafno desh bata excile gare pachi "belongingness" nai rahandaena. Mero desh Nepal ma jati sukai problem kina na hos, at least ma arka ko desh ma refugee banera ta basnu pareko chaena 😊
"No one decides where they were born. Our birthplace was decided by faith. I was born here and you were born there. A Border is a concept created by the lucky. Today you sit in the seat of the fortunate. Dont forget what put you there. Fate." - Messiah (2020)
Love you man. They way you make me question a lot of things makes these videos priceless to me.
How come bhutan be the last shangrila, while they tried to hurt the chindens who came from the land of their spiritual leader BUDDHA. Once again i am proud of my country even though we have our flaws, never in a miloin years we pushed and hurt anyone. Bhutan as a whole did not at all acknowledged the teaching of buddha. for me its not a buddhist place. i met quite a few people around europe who were bhutanese nepalese and were one of the most kind and welcoming people ive ever met. my best friends grandmaa whom i know since im living is also from there. all i want to say THIS SHIT WRONG
The last line🥺🥺🥺
How might have those people felt? Cant imagine
Thank you for sharing this!
what a content.. superb bro keep going...waiting to see more
I can't even imagine being in such situation. Thank u god for everything. 🙏