My favorite western. The music is perfect and from the perspective of time, nostalgic and sad. Wistful. There will never be another western like it, never.
It was a movie without flaws. It wasn't just Ladd who played well, they all did. I'll mention Brandon deWild. His portrayal of a lonely young boy in the west was very good. I grew up on the Idaho side of the Tetons. We admired guns and those that were good shots. A lot of our food came from that. I've known a lot of Shanes in my life.
I'm glad I was born in a time that I learned to hunt and fish and do things outdoors. I'm from around San Antonio, TX. One of my uncles lived outside of a town called Runge. You go about 60 miles from San Antonio to Kenedy a town of 3000 people then you take hwy72 for 11 miles in between all you have is the San Antonio River on it's way to the Gulf of Mexico, theres Runge, population 619, then go another couple of miles and you turn left on this dirt road and go another couple of miles. That's when you got to Uncle Slim and Aunt Ruby's house, nothing but miles and miles of country and it wasn't until us kids could smell Aunt Ruby's homemade bread was about ready that the grown ups would see or hear from us. I swear you could be miles from the house and up wind, but you could smell that bread when it was about ready and all the kids would be in single file line at the back door, because if you hadn't caused any trouble she would cut off a slice of bread with butter on it for each kid. Young ones now have no idea what being a kid in the country is like, wouldn't trade it for all the oil In Texas. Take a potato and your bb or pellet gun, shoot a dove, clean and gut it, dig a whole put your potato in it , throw. Some dirt on top of it build a fire on top of that , put a stick through your dove and cook it. By the time it was cooked kick the fire aside, get your potato and peel it . Top would be a little blackened but you had a lunch fit for, well for a country boy out in the country. Glad I was able to have those times, I'm sure you adapted to the ways of Idaho, but have memories that are in that line of living. Yeah, we were very fortunate, hope your time growing up was good for you
When that music began the sadness just overwhelmed me for a minute or two,if i ever had a wish that could come true it would be sitting in the picture theatre way back in the fifties watching this movie for the first time with my Mum and Dad,i miss you both so very much,just to glance across in the dark and see you once again i would give up everything for that.
What more can be said that hasn't been said about this Classic?😍😊😘 Everything and everyone in this movie is Pure Perfection 👌👍💖 No remake of Shane can ever beat this original!!!!!!
I totally agree! I miss them all...John Wayne in Red River, The Searchers, and Hondo. Jimmy Stewart in Far Country, Winchester 73, Man form Laramie. Never see the likes of them again. Different world.
If any body came looking for money to do a remake of Shane, first we could hear the laughter coming from Hollywood in Texas. Secondly, you would get a report from TMZ about a person that was sent to a mental institution. I know that nobody is that brave in Hollywood and even there, you can't find someone that stupid. Close, but no....
Tengo 77 años Esta película de Alan ladd la Vi cuando tenía 10 Años y no se Me olvida Un buen recuerdo De las películas De moda de aquellos Tiempos Los cowboy
También vi esta película cuando salió por primera vez. En ese entonces era una emocionante película de vaqueros. Después de verla como adulto, esta película tiene un significado más profundo en cuanto al final de una forma de vida en el viejo oeste. Gracias por ver este video. Gracias por compartir tus pensamientos.
part of his success in this movie was that he wasn't an overwhelming physical presence. pretty hard to think of others of that period who could've done it. Wm Holden, maybe - always loved his work. He was a youngster then, maybe 33.
teller 121 I heard someone mention Richard Widmark or Yul Brenner could had played the role of Shane . Both great actors. But I´m glad that Alan Ladd got the part of Shane ☺ 👏& 👏 2-27-20
@@teller1290 I don't recall ever seeing that movie Johnny Udo. I am going to take some time & watch it on UA-cam & If I like it I might order it on D.V.D thanks for the information -March 17,2020
@@sheiladavis6523 his character is named that. The movie has another name. He plays the villain. I think it might've been first film he was noticed in. I believe it was a couple yrs before Shane. Just check Widmark's imbd filmography.
I saw the movie in 1950's when I was about 10 years old. The emotionally haunting theme song which in my opinion contributes significantly to the movie's success brings back memories for people of my generation. Over time a great movie become nostalgic and even becomes a great myth in the good sense in the history of movies down through the centuries.
I did not see Shane until much later when it was available on TV. My childhood best friend saw it and always said it was a great movie. So I watched it. Had so much more meaning for me seeing it as an adult. I liked it so much that in 2006 I went to Jackson, WY and hired a man who had spent his life documenting the sites where the movie was made. Amazing how they make things so realistic. Ernie's cabin was still there then. The ranch site with the stream was there, but a huge bull buffalo was way too close for comfort. Visited cemetery hill. A trip to remember.
Yes it does, who ever came to the decision to use that music theme for the movie should get 10 Academy Awards, ever once in a while the stars align, and something comes together that is as close to perfect as it can be, the movie wouldn't be Shane without that music, that's simply one of the greatest musical scores for a movie in the history of making movies. It made a great movie a immediate legendary movie. Funny, especially from when you were young how you can hear a song 30 years later and relate it to what grade you were in and other specifics of your life when you first heard that song. Isn't anything about this movie that is not top shelf. Shane come back Shane, those days are gone, just like the character in the movie.
@@garyh1449 Yes, that was Walt Farmer. I had the pleasure of taking his tour of the Shane Movie locations. It brought the movie alive, just to see where the action took place, from Ernies's cabin to cemetery hill, to the Starrett homestead. We sort of bonded since Walt was a veteran and I was working at a VA hospital. I purchased his CD, which he autographed. My wife and I were lucky to have met up with Walt since he was winding down his activities due to illness. Last I heard from him was in 2008. Easily one of the most memorable times of my life. It is great to hear from someone else who knows about him. Take care.
Seriously great, made the movie an instant western movie legend. The setting, Alan Ladd the supporting cast, the kid and Jack Palance is the baddest bad guy in the world. Prove It, ...( in fact that was the subject of my comment that I left)
When I saw it as a child, it was a good western with shooting and the little kid....as an adult, the hidden meanings became quite clear. Themes were the old wild west was coming to and end, love, innocence, did Shane die? This is definitely a classic and will endure in spite of Star Wars. Thanks for watching.
Wonderful film. I read the book when I was in school, couldn’t believe such a work was in the library. I do prefer the exchange between Shane and Wilson in the book. Shane says: ‘you’re a pushing man Wilson, so I guess I’ll have to accommodate you....’ So measured and so dangerous.
my god ! love this movie. especially during gun draw and when shane is leaving and that boy keep callin him to go back. " shane.....................come back......" and I got tears in my eyes and I felt the scene in reality of life.
Just like the character, we can't go back. As The Great Merle Haggard said in his song, " wish coke was still cola and a joint was a bad place to be", that was then
Imagens,cenários, musica, roteiro, atores, etc fizeram desse filme um dos 3 melhores filmes de western de todos os tempos na minha opinião. Emocionante filme.
Am I just like other old people, who on looking back into the past feel that the old movies are better than the stuff we see today. Back then they had to have well written scripts, devoid of sex, car chases, explosions, computerized monsters, and the actors seemed to be at the tops of their craft. SHANE had everyting, George Stevens as director, Alan Ladd, Jack Palance, Jean Arthur, Ben Johnson, Ellen Corby, Nancy Kulp, and a host of other character actors that altogether created a classic. It was not just a "western," it was a story about the changing of the so-called wild west to a more civilized state (the settlers), the underlying admiration (love) theme between Ladd and Arthur, deWilde's admiration of Shane, and the hard working pioneer farmers. All is summed up in the dialogue between Shane and Ryker, when in the gunfight in town, Shane tells Ryker that his kind of days are over (that of ruthless cattle barons pushing sodbusters off the land) , Ryker than replies "what about your days, gunfighter?" And Shane replies, that the only difference between him and Ryker is that Shane knows this fact but Ryker does not. Great lines. Great movie!
I agree with you. This was a classic western. The last scene was sad with the little boy calling out for Shane. The question remains, did Shane die from his wounds in the gunfight? Thank you for watching.
To this day, if someone wants to know how to be a bad guy, all they have to do is watch this movie and study Jack Palance.. Baddest of the bad, good guy/Shane -"you are a dirty low down yankee liar", bad guy answering in the coolest tone of voice ever, "prove it". Now that's a bad guy, his picture should be next to the term" bad guy" in Webster's book of terms.
There are several differences between the book and the movie. I t was fun picking them out. The book, of course, has more character development. I was able to find a tour of the sites where many of the Shane scenes were shot in and about Jackson, Wyoming. It was fantastic. Like being in the movie. Enjoy!
Correct. If I posted this video today, I would get a copyright hit. Back then you could use theme songs. Without the song, th video is not as good. Thanks for watching.
i love this movie... my favorite western, unfortunately i never watched it to the finish. this was back in 89 when i was in primary school. could you upload the full movie if possible pleeeeeese?? btw, my cousin named her first son shane after reading the book.
If you go to settings- overview- advertisements- you can choose to not have any ads shown on your channel, just if wanted to know. Thanks for the upload! I have such great memories of watching this with my siblings (this and High Noon)
Thanks for that info i was intrigued as i have been fighting a battle with this cursed thing over the last year they say the worms will have their way in the end one way or the other Ty pal
Had this theme tune on my mind last night, so looked it up...glad i did. some things you never forget do you...this movie will always be very special to me. btw, the name hpylori got my attention, what's the connection if you don't mind me asking...it's a name i'll never forget either
H. pylori is the bacterium that has been found to cause stomach ulcers and stomach cancers. The discovery of this bug as the cause of ulcers revolutionized the treatment and course of peptic ulcer disease. I was so impressed that I adopted this as my email name.
Agree, but there is just something magic about the original movie....Alan Ladd, Jack Palance, Van Heflin, Jean Arthur, and little Brandon, and many, many more. Never to forget the only real cowboy....Ben Johnson.
@goldbullions Same here! I was maybe 12 and what the West was really like and about. Sure, it was like 1892, but the history was right on - the homesteaders and the ranchers. The gunfighting days were coming to an end.
Jack Palance steals the show yet again in yet another formulaic Western trying to describe World War 2 and the resultant Cold War as some type of "moral good." The result? Only Jack Palance "gets it"(so to speak..
Maybe Shane died somewhere in the end. According to the book he received a gunshot wound from Wilson "just above the belt" though he told the boy Joey "it was nothing". Probably just to reassure him.
To me Shane is a movie that has everything but the most important message that some may overlook is the fact that Shane realizes that he has fallened in love with his friends wife and would-be a complicated affair.He decided to move on. He is a hero.
My favorite western. The music is perfect and from the perspective of time, nostalgic and sad. Wistful. There will never be another western like it, never.
It was a movie without flaws. It wasn't just Ladd who played well, they all did. I'll mention Brandon deWild. His portrayal of a lonely young boy in the west was very good. I grew up on the Idaho side of the Tetons. We admired guns and those that were good shots. A lot of our food came from that. I've known a lot of Shanes in my life.
I'm glad I was born in a time that I learned to hunt and fish and do things outdoors. I'm from around San Antonio, TX. One of my uncles lived outside of a town called Runge. You go about 60 miles from San Antonio to Kenedy a town of 3000 people then you take hwy72 for 11 miles in between all you have is the San Antonio River on it's way to the Gulf of Mexico, theres Runge, population 619, then go another couple of miles and you turn left on this dirt road and go another couple of miles. That's when you got to Uncle Slim and Aunt Ruby's house, nothing but miles and miles of country and it wasn't until us kids could smell Aunt Ruby's homemade bread was about ready that the grown ups would see or hear from us. I swear you could be miles from the house and up wind, but you could smell that bread when it was about ready and all the kids would be in single file line at the back door, because if you hadn't caused any trouble she would cut off a slice of bread with butter on it for each kid. Young ones now have no idea what being a kid in the country is like, wouldn't trade it for all the oil In Texas. Take a potato and your bb or pellet gun, shoot a dove, clean and gut it, dig a whole put your potato in it , throw. Some dirt on top of it build a fire on top of that , put a stick through your dove and cook it. By the time it was cooked kick the fire aside, get your potato and peel it . Top would be a little blackened but you had a lunch fit for, well for a country boy out in the country. Glad I was able to have those times, I'm sure you adapted to the ways of Idaho, but have memories that are in that line of living. Yeah, we were very fortunate, hope your time growing up was good for you
Thanks for the posting, what more can be said that has not already been said,
Simply the greatest western ever made.
Agree
💚💚💚💚
When that music began the sadness just overwhelmed me for a minute or two,if i ever had a wish that could come true it would be sitting in the picture theatre way back in the fifties watching this movie for the first time with my Mum and Dad,i miss you both so very much,just to glance across in the dark and see you once again i would give up everything for that.
Now you have me in tears for the same reason. You are lucky to have had a wonderful family.
One of my All time favorite. I've seen about 20 times.
I agree. Well done with several hidden meanings on the end of the "wild west."
I named my son "Shane" because of the character in this great 50's style western classic.
I saw it when I was 12 years old.......put a tear in my eye even then!
Agree. Thanks for watching.
I've wondered why there was never a remake of this movie.
Then I realized, no way it could be done ... It's perfect.
Great comment. .and so true.
Palance deserved best supporting actor for his role.
Agree
What more can be said that hasn't been said about this Classic?😍😊😘 Everything and everyone in this movie is Pure Perfection 👌👍💖 No remake of Shane can ever beat this original!!!!!!
I totally agree! I miss them all...John Wayne in Red River, The Searchers, and Hondo. Jimmy Stewart in Far Country, Winchester 73, Man form Laramie. Never see the likes of them again. Different world.
If any body came looking for money to do a remake of Shane, first we could hear the laughter coming from Hollywood in Texas. Secondly, you would get a report from TMZ about a person that was sent to a mental institution. I know that nobody is that brave in Hollywood and even there, you can't find someone that stupid. Close, but no....
Tengo 77 años
Esta película de
Alan ladd la
Vi cuando tenía 10
Años y no se
Me olvida
Un buen recuerdo
De las películas
De moda de aquellos
Tiempos
Los cowboy
También vi esta película cuando salió por primera vez. En ese entonces era una emocionante película de vaqueros. Después de verla como adulto, esta película tiene un significado más profundo en cuanto al final de una forma de vida en el viejo oeste. Gracias por ver este video. Gracias por compartir tus pensamientos.
Alan Ladd was born to play Shane.Awesome.
Most people will agree with you. Thank you.
Igual que Rodolfo Beban para interpretar Juan Moreira
The music, the movie and the star. Perfection. Alan Ladd was the only one who could be Shane. Immortal.
part of his success in this movie was that he wasn't an overwhelming physical presence. pretty hard to think of others of that period who could've done it. Wm Holden, maybe - always loved his work. He was a youngster then, maybe 33.
teller 121 I heard someone mention Richard Widmark or Yul Brenner could had played the role of Shane . Both great actors. But I´m glad that Alan Ladd got the part of Shane ☺ 👏& 👏 2-27-20
@@sheiladavis6523 not bad. Never thought of him. Edgy, unorthodox, had played a loose screw in a movie in late 40s where he killed (as Johnny Udo).
@@teller1290 I don't recall ever seeing that movie Johnny Udo. I am going to take some time & watch it on UA-cam & If I like it I might order it on D.V.D thanks for the information -March 17,2020
@@sheiladavis6523 his character is named that. The movie has another name. He plays the villain. I think it might've been first film he was noticed in. I believe it was a couple yrs before Shane. Just check Widmark's imbd filmography.
I saw the movie in 1950's when I was about 10 years old. The emotionally haunting theme song which in my opinion contributes significantly to the movie's success brings back memories for people of my generation. Over time a great movie become nostalgic and even becomes a great myth in the good sense in the history of movies down through the centuries.
I did not see Shane until much later when it was available on TV. My childhood best friend saw it and always said it was a great movie. So I watched it. Had so much more meaning for me seeing it as an adult. I liked it so much that in 2006 I went to Jackson, WY and hired a man who had spent his life documenting the sites where the movie was made. Amazing how they make things so realistic. Ernie's cabin was still there then. The ranch site with the stream was there, but a huge bull buffalo was way too close for comfort. Visited cemetery hill. A trip to remember.
Yes it does, who ever came to the decision to use that music theme for the movie should get 10 Academy Awards, ever once in a while the stars align, and something comes together that is as close to perfect as it can be, the movie wouldn't be Shane without that music, that's simply one of the greatest musical scores for a movie in the history of making movies. It made a great movie a immediate legendary movie. Funny, especially from when you were young how you can hear a song 30 years later and relate it to what grade you were in and other specifics of your life when you first heard that song. Isn't anything about this movie that is not top shelf. Shane come back Shane, those days are gone, just like the character in the movie.
@@H.pylori Was that Walt the Wyoming movie guy?
@@garyh1449 Yes, that was Walt Farmer. I had the pleasure of taking his tour of the Shane Movie locations. It brought the movie alive, just to see where the action took place, from Ernies's cabin to cemetery hill, to the Starrett homestead. We sort of bonded since Walt was a veteran and I was working at a VA hospital. I purchased his CD, which he autographed. My wife and I were lucky to have met up with Walt since he was winding down his activities due to illness. Last I heard from him was in 2008. Easily one of the most memorable times of my life.
It is great to hear from someone else who knows about him. Take care.
@@randycrocker9459 Agree with everything that you said.
"I wouldn't pull on Wilson, Shane." Better advice..."I wouldn't pull on Shane, Wilson."
John Ford: As for Riker, he wouldn't have pulled on either of them.
I remember this music. Seriously good!
Seriously great, made the movie an instant western movie legend. The setting, Alan Ladd the supporting cast, the kid and Jack Palance is the baddest bad guy in the world. Prove It, ...( in fact that was the subject of my comment that I left)
not a big fan of westerns, but this transcends genres...amazing film.
When I saw it as a child, it was a good western with shooting and the little kid....as an adult, the hidden meanings became quite clear. Themes were the old wild west was coming to and end, love, innocence, did Shane die? This is definitely a classic and will endure in spite of Star Wars. Thanks for watching.
I wonder if they knew when they finished shooting the film that it was destined to be a classic, because it certainly is one
Interesting thought, but I doubt it.
Wonderful film. I read the book when I was in school, couldn’t believe such a work was in the library. I do prefer the exchange between Shane and Wilson in the book. Shane says: ‘you’re a pushing man Wilson, so I guess I’ll have to accommodate you....’ So measured and so dangerous.
Still amazing in 2020
Love this ❤️👍👊
Thanks for watching.
I love this movie.......
Was supposed to be another 50's western, but it ended up a great western.
Agree
my god ! love this movie. especially during gun draw and when shane is leaving and that boy keep callin him to go back. " shane.....................come back......" and I got tears in my eyes and I felt the scene in reality of life.
Just like the character, we can't go back. As The Great Merle Haggard said in his song, " wish coke was still cola and a joint was a bad place to be", that was then
Imagens,cenários, musica, roteiro, atores, etc fizeram desse filme um dos 3 melhores filmes de western de todos os tempos na minha opinião. Emocionante filme.
Eu concordo completamente. Obrigado por assistir.
Hard to believe, they were actually going to knock the script down to 1 hour and 10 minutes, film it in black and white, and show it as a B movie !
Would have been a big mistake!
GREAT MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
today I'm at my Fitness 100 Best Westerns of all time great acting everything
Am I just like other old people, who on looking back into the past feel that the old movies are better than the stuff we see today. Back then they had to have well written scripts, devoid of sex, car chases, explosions, computerized monsters, and the actors seemed to be at the tops of their craft. SHANE had everyting, George Stevens as director, Alan Ladd, Jack Palance, Jean Arthur, Ben Johnson, Ellen Corby, Nancy Kulp, and a host of other character actors that altogether created a classic. It was not just a "western," it was a story about the changing of the so-called wild west to a more civilized state (the settlers), the underlying admiration (love) theme between Ladd and Arthur, deWilde's admiration of Shane, and the hard working pioneer farmers.
All is summed up in the dialogue between Shane and Ryker, when in the gunfight in town, Shane tells Ryker that his kind of days are over (that of ruthless cattle barons pushing sodbusters off the land) , Ryker than replies "what about your days, gunfighter?" And Shane replies, that the only difference between him and Ryker is that Shane knows this fact but Ryker does not. Great lines. Great movie!
正統派の本物の西部劇ですね 哀愁ただようラストシーン 最高です。
I agree with you. This was a classic western. The last scene was sad with the little boy calling out for Shane. The question remains, did Shane die from his wounds in the gunfight? Thank you for watching.
Great movie, good message moral for all people
To this day, if someone wants to know how to be a bad guy, all they have to do is watch this movie and study Jack Palance.. Baddest of the bad, good guy/Shane -"you are a dirty low down yankee liar", bad guy answering in the coolest tone of voice ever, "prove it". Now that's a bad guy, his picture should be next to the term" bad guy" in Webster's book of terms.
Agree. Great observation.
There are several differences between the book and the movie. I t was fun picking them out. The book, of course, has more character development. I was able to find a tour of the sites where many of the Shane scenes were shot in and about Jackson, Wyoming. It was fantastic. Like being in the movie. Enjoy!
The melody is from the song, 'The Call of The Faraway Hills'.
Correct. If I posted this video today, I would get a copyright hit. Back then you could use theme songs. Without the song, th video is not as good. Thanks for watching.
Come back Shaaaane
a perfect western movie .
i love this movie... my favorite western, unfortunately i never watched it to the finish. this was back in 89 when i was in primary school. could you upload the full movie if possible pleeeeeese?? btw, my cousin named her first son shane after reading the book.
I do not know how to upload the movie, and fear that there would be a definite copyright violation. View the movie at AMAZON. Does not cost much.
If you go to settings- overview- advertisements- you can choose to not have any ads shown on your channel, just if wanted to know. Thanks for the upload! I have such great memories of watching this with my siblings (this and High Noon)
Thank you for the tip on commercials. I will try it out.
Thanks for that info i was intrigued as i have been fighting a battle with this cursed thing over the last year
they say the worms will have their way in the end
one way or the other
Ty pal
This was made before the tribe was running the Media...
True
Hermosa melodía para la película
Estoy de acuerdo. Gracias.
Had this theme tune on my mind last night, so looked it up...glad i did.
some things you never forget do you...this movie will always be very special to me.
btw, the name hpylori got my attention, what's the connection if you don't mind me asking...it's a name i'll never forget either
H. pylori is the bacterium that has been found to cause stomach ulcers and stomach cancers. The discovery of this bug as the cause of ulcers revolutionized the treatment and course of peptic ulcer disease. I was so impressed that I adopted this as my email name.
O melhor que eu já assistí!
Shane is a brilliant movie. Although David Carradine didn't do a bad job with the TV series.
Agree, but there is just something magic about the original movie....Alan Ladd, Jack Palance, Van Heflin, Jean Arthur, and little Brandon, and many, many more. Never to forget the only real cowboy....Ben Johnson.
I do not know how to upload the movie, and fear that there would be a definite copyright violation. View the movie at AMAZON. Does not cost much.
@goldbullions Same here! I was maybe 12 and what the West was really like and about. Sure, it was like 1892, but the history was right on - the homesteaders and the ranchers. The gunfighting days were coming to an end.
I read the book ,it is base upon the movie!!
Loved the book, We're reading it in Literature for All and we'll be watching the movie soon :D
PLEASE EXCUSE THE COMMERCIAL ADDS, UA-cam DOES THIS WITHOUT ASKING THOSE OF US WHO SUBMIT THE VIDEOS. I RECEIVE NO MONEY FOR THIS INTRUSION.
هل هذا الفلم لايوجد عندكم ام انه ممنوع عرضه
Está producción
Jack Palance steals the show yet again in yet another formulaic Western trying to describe World War 2 and the resultant Cold War as some type of "moral good." The result? Only Jack Palance "gets it"(so to speak..
Ese é outro fiumaco .q curto muito Tô ligado no canal senpre .Muito bom.
Obrigado por assistir. Estou impressionado com a forma como as pessoas em outros países apreciam filmes de faroeste.
Ive heard of you ... oh ya what ya hear???
where was the movie made at?
Grand Teton National Park in Wyoming, near Jackson Wyoming
Does Shane die in the end?
No, he returned as Clint Eastwood.
Johnny Morrison Shane never die he went missing after he retaliated!!!
Maybe Shane died somewhere in the end. According to the book he received a gunshot wound from Wilson "just above the belt" though he told the boy Joey "it was nothing". Probably just to reassure him.
@@AlbertTsosie 🤣 🤣
Rode through the cemetery as he heads toward the everlasting hills.
ارجو ان تكون الإجابات كلها بلعربيه
سيكون ذلك جيدًا ، شكرًا لك
Era
Era, que'?
Que sea traducida alcastellano
To me Shane is a movie that has everything but the most important message that some may overlook is the fact that Shane realizes that he has fallened in love with his friends wife and would-be a complicated affair.He decided to move on.
He is a hero.
@@leungdavid9718 Agree