Did Luis Suárez Deserve a PK in the 102nd Minute!? Why Two Goals Were Disallowed in New England?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- Andrew Wiebe is back for another edition of Instant Replay as he breaks down the most controversial plays from Matchday 35.
📺 Watch every match with MLS Season Pass on Apple TV: apple.co/MLS
The 🐐 plays here. Join The Messi Insider for insider news, early access to Messi promotions and more: www.mlssoccer....
➡️ Subscribe Now: / mls
➡️ Follow us on:
- TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
- Instagram: / mls
- Twitter: / mls
- Like us on Facebook: / mls
➡️ Para Español:
- Instagram: / mlses
- Twitter: / mlses
- Facebook: espanol.mls
For more information about MLS, go to the league's official website: www.MLSsoccer.com
#mls #highlights #mlsseasonpass
3 penalty no-calls in austin. Just cause we aren’t in playoffs doesn’t mean we dont deserve a fair match.
Nope. Keeper cleared the ball first.
Good calls all around, except for not carding Anunga.
this was actually a really instructional vid on rules of offside interference, well done refs
I don’t really agree with the foul call on NE second goal. Doesn’t seem like much contact. If that’s a foul, there are 3 or 4 fouls every time someone takes a corner. But I could be wrong lol. Just didn’t see much in it.
1:00 "... what we all see, that Malanda got a touch before making contact with Gomez" over footage that shows clearly that he made contact with Gomez first. Not sure if that makes it a foul or not, but it's clearly a false statement despite trying to convince our eyes otherwise!
I question the timing as well. What I do see though is that the attacker was leaning into the defender even before the defender go there trying to create contact. I do question how clear and obvious this was, however, for VAR to get involved. Seems like more re-referring to me.
@@MrCho14 He was not leaning, he was getting ready to position himself to kick the ball and the guy comes from behind, not once does Gomez see him.
@@arosalesmusic Didn't see him? He ran right past him. Of course he saw him.
As a Miami fan I still don't think there was enough in that to deem it as "making contact with Gomez first". If you're going to count his shorts/thigh brushing against Gomez' thigh, then I think you're reaching. He timed it to the last possible second and it was pretty risky but he looks to have pulled it off. Watch the first behind perspective, the upper leg isn't impacting Gomez, only sliding passed.
@@zharth. How about the arm pulling on the shoulder/neck area? Check out the Major League Soccer highlights here on UA-cam. Pause at exactly 3:32. Clearly early contact on the shoulder/neck and lower body before contacting the ball. And I can't stand Miami...but can't stand referees more.
3:17 That’s New England not Nashville?
Script writer was obviously drunk during that segment
@@whypick1_y’all he said “former”
@@legobricksking785 Andrew starts off the play by saying "Should _Nashville_ have either tied this game or won it?" when it clearly shows New England putting the ball into Nashville's net.
@@whypick1_ph then it’s a mistake
No. Falló miserablemente. Que vergüenza
1:01 why the hand GRAB for an ALL ball no contact tackle?
Exactly. Author of this video is an idiot. Just like referee
That’s insane that they took away NE’s goal after that push from behind but in the NYCFC vs IM game Bright got two handed shoved to the ground off the ball and there was no foul called. MLS refs are so inconsistent.
Redbulls vs Atlanta had a similar one last week which was on Inside Video Review. What was interesting about that one was that VAR said live that there was a potential foul and then forgot about it once the recommended a review for a foul/PK.
I feel like they are trying to get these off the ball fouls and impeding the opponent situations in the box under control which is great. Things will still be missed. No all of them will reach the level of clear and obvious to go to an on field review either.
Malanda assaulted Gomez before touching the ball. Awful, awful VAR.
MLS needs to award an Oscar for "Best Actor" at season's end. Every team has their "injury specialists", it's time to recognize the most dramatic players and then vote! (D. Garber might disagree).
Didn’t even look at Acosta getting absolutely cleaned out in the 5th minute of Cincy vs LAFC? God forbid the league has to say something bad about Chivas USA, huh?
It's not before it's that the intent was on the ball and the fact that the player actually touched the ball before doing any damage to Suarez
Can you talk about the controversial calls in campeones, Canadian championship and us open cup?
Aren’t you supposed to get a yellow card for making the VAR symbol to the ref? It would have been funny if the ref took back the yellow for the foul, and gave a second yellow for making the VAR symbol. 😂
That was the something that originally was said. More recently I've heard 'excessively' gestures for a review. It basically falls under dissent. I know emotions are high in the heat of the moment, but it's funny to me when they do it because, as a PK was called, it 100% is going to be looked at by VAR which will recommend an on field review if they think one is justified.
If the last one is a PK then the first one has to be 😂 crazy
No pen at all and a dive from him as always.
Andrew you are dead wrong on the Gomez PK. Freeze frame on the point right before he touches the ball. Defender is hanging on his shoulder, sliding in through the hip of Gomez from behind and made contact with the player BEFORE the ball. Is this a pen? Idk, tough call, but saying this is a clear and obvious error to overturn - that’s 100% wrong.
All else aside......"saying this is a clear and obvious error to overturn - that’s 100% wrong."
His job is now to provide cover for the refs and the league
Good commentary ❤😊
Loving the Messi fans crying 😂
Messi fan here! Why would we be crying about stuff that has nothing to do with the GOAT himself (messi)? As far as I'm concerned, messi did everything he could in the game (including a banger), so why would I care about the ref not calling. Smh
And you seem obsessed with hating. Go outside and get a life, bro. 😂
@@jr4chargers ikr kelebformthe704 bro shut up it was no pk who cares we should win vs cbus and the supporters shield it was a dive as a Messi fan touch some grass kelebformthe704
US football is lame
As a Messi fan Suarez dived
😱😱
No penalty for Suarez as he got his shot off before the contact
For me, that's the best explanation for not giving the PK. If the contact had occurred before Suarez's shot, the PK should've been given.
That is not the rubric for a foul. See my comment at the top.
Not only he hits Gomez leg before hitting the ball he also pulls Gomez down by the shoulder with his right hand too. Y'all didn't put the frame by frame cause you know exactly what it proves
womp womp
1:00 slow this down to frame-by-frame, that should have been a penalty. The defender's thigh impacts the offensive player just before touching the ball. Foul and red card. Miami was robbed.
he touched him before touching the ball penalty on the first Miami one
He made contact on Gomez first… then the ball. Its the only way he could get to the ball is by GOING THROUGH Gomez.
Disagree
Agree
It was all ball 🤦
@MetaWoody Did you add CC due to being deaf? Even slowing it down can help you too
Delusional
Rules of the game, Gomes PK should be given. He hit the left side leg first and connected with the ball second. You can see the impact 1:00
Lol good pronunciations Andrew!!! 'No era penal Luis' !!!
Suarez would have scored with his usual bicycle kick
Suarez went through the MK Ultra with his boyfriend Messi. Now he will get Hollywood contract and attend the rituals
oh no the refs are professionals... yeah who would figure
Worst episode ever
Dude needs anger management
I didn’t watch any of the Miami game. But if someone did, was the added time legit? Was there that much stoppage time to add almost 12 extra minutes? Feel like the league gives Miami so much extra time when they are not ahead.
@@CLBCrew96 it was 9 at first, which tbh did feel a bit much, but they added an additional 3 bc a kid ran on the field and Charlotte delayed the restart. Charlotte should’ve been given 3-4 yellows for delay.
@@PoorlyThoughtOut Thank you. I can't stand watching when players waste so much time. Glad the league is starting to do something about it. I know many people who are turned off by the sport because players are wasting so much time going down and acting like they are hurt.
I was there for NE Vs NSH.
Nope. Nope. Nope. The first one was without a doubt a penalty. Check out the Major League Soccer highlights and pause the video exactly at 3:32! Miami player senses the contact, sticks his leg out (like any good attacking player does) defenders arm is on the shoulder/neck area, there's contact through the lower body before the eventual contact of the ball. In real-time it may appear he "got the ball" first, but this is not the case, and besides, you can "get the ball" and it still be a foul! Defender was caught, it was from behind, and if you slow it down, clearly made contact/pulled back on the Miami player prior to luckily getting a touch of the ball. This should have been kept a penalty and second yellow. Love that we have all this technology at our disposal yet they continue to make terrible calls. You need CLEAR proof from the VAR to overturn the call on the field, CLEAR.
I don't necessarily think this was a penalty, but I certainly don't think there was a clear error on the field. VAR should have stayed out of this and stopped re-referring the game. Whatever the call was on the field, there's no way it should have gone to an on field review.
That Charlotte tackle is ludicrous. Easy red and pen. You can't go through a player to get the ball.
even if its a foul, there's no way that's a red. Several years ago it was, but not anymore
To be a foul, the ball must be in the field of play. If the contact is made when the ball is out of bounds, then it is not a foul but a misconduct - and not punishable by a free kick.
Therefore, there is no penalty kick in favor of Suarez. However, the goal keeper should receive a yellow or red. That is the proper call.
PK for Suraez ❤ is necessary