Why is everyone so negatives in the comments. They both brought different dynamics to the show so why are you pitting them against each other instead of just saying they are both great
I don't have a problem with Paige personally but the first power of 3's personalities compliment each other balancing every scene. Rose's role was a bit of a grey area.
I miss Rose as an actress but I’m just now discovering Charmed and I’m looking forward to watching Season 4 after I’m done with Season 1. I’m skipping seasons 2 and 3 and going straight to 4.
Well for me it kinda stared to decline half way tru season 5 season 4 was good but then went straight down to the toilet around 6 but they kinda pick up at end of season 7 and 8 what i hate is that phoebe never got all her powers back or thats as far i know cuz i havent seen all the seasons
i heard they took out phoebes flying powers because the cost of having to lift her and special effects. which always sounded odd to me because theres always special effects but idk
common guys you cant really say that rose is a good actress!! and how can aaron say that after working with hollywoods best tv actors and actresses? she cant cry she is carried away when she plays a part where she has to be excited making it ridiculous ! She is not a good actress! dont understand why they picked her up! But i guess most of those who started watching charmed after shannen left thinks rose was better! i was shocked when i realized prue wasnt comming back !everything changed!
I don’t hate Paige at all. It makes sense that a baby was brought about by the affair that was established way early on in the series. I just wish Prue could have came back in the later seasons and then the guy from Ms Hellfire gets released from jail and he and Prue finally end up together for real.
Guys, for pit sake stop being to both Rose and Shannon, while they bust there butts in outfits in the middle of the night trying to entertain you, you just lay there on your stomachs eating cup-cakes and chips complaining all they, why don't you come in and start rolling down the San Francisco hills if you think it will make it a better show, i am sick and tired of your insults to the girls and directors so just lay off god damn it and go to the bath room or something! God!
I would’ve liked the show more if Phoebe died instead of Prue a lot of people didn’t get along with Alyssa holly wanted to leave the show with Shannen and rose doesn’t like her either
![E! The Women of Charmed [Part 3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Bfc7_dehLz0/mqdefault.jpg)
![E! The Women of Charmed [Part 3]](/img/tr.png)
both paige and prue are awesome. the show had a more serious tone with prue and a more light hearted one with paige. both sisters are awesome!
I’m so glad she joined Charmed! Paige is my favorite Charmed One, she made the show for me!
Why is everyone so negatives in the comments. They both brought different dynamics to the show so why are you pitting them against each other instead of just saying they are both great
People can argue if Prue or Paige was better... I like them both. But Shannen left, so they had to deal with it.
I love them both!
Pure I misssssss youuuuu
to be honest Rose McGowan was the reason I started watching the show but I ended up falling in love with
Me too. I fell in love with her season 5 look
Thanks again!!! ;)
i love this show
im glad that rose mcgrown came in cuz she made the show alot better for me
Thanks!!!! =D
I don't have a problem with Paige personally but the first power of 3's personalities compliment each other balancing every scene. Rose's role was a bit of a grey area.
I like both Paige and Prue
I miss Rose as an actress but I’m just now discovering Charmed and I’m looking forward to watching Season 4 after I’m done with Season 1. I’m skipping seasons 2 and 3 and going straight to 4.
i miss prue :(
The best thing happened to Rose was Charmed.
Beautiful video!!! I love Halliwell's sister!!!! Can you tell me what Phoebe says at 2:08 until 2:11, please? Thaks to everybody!!! =D
the other choices for paiges part was jennifer love hewitt and neve cambell .. i wished they would have chosen Jennifer L. Hewitt
Holly !
@MrSistasista I think completely the same as you.
Well for me it kinda stared to decline half way tru season 5 season 4 was good but then went straight down to the toilet around 6 but they kinda pick up at end of season 7 and 8 what i hate is that phoebe never got all her powers back or thats as far i know cuz i havent seen all the seasons
i heard they took out phoebes flying powers because the cost of having to lift her and special effects. which always sounded odd to me because theres always special effects but idk
@@ourevilone actually that's true the show didn't had the money anymore at that point
i reallly think that when rose came the show became more interesting an cool
if prue didn't leave at all would you thing paige would be brought up in the series it would be cool though The Power Of Four
Danke! Can you make this of german? *heul*
i stopped watching the show shortly after rose mc gowen was placed in the cast
common guys you cant really say that rose is a good actress!! and how can aaron say that after working with hollywoods best tv actors and actresses? she cant cry she is carried away when she plays a part where she has to be excited making it ridiculous ! She is not a good actress! dont understand why they picked her up! But i guess most of those who started watching charmed after shannen left thinks rose was better! i was shocked when i realized prue wasnt comming back !everything changed!
I like Charmed soooo much better with Paige than with Prue!
Probably not the Power of Four... Rose was just a replacement
I don't think so.
I don’t hate Paige at all. It makes sense that a baby was brought about by the affair that was established way early on in the series. I just wish Prue could have came back in the later seasons and then the guy from Ms Hellfire gets released from jail and he and Prue finally end up together for real.
@danitydon22 Jennifer love Hewitt refused the role
Whaaaat jennifer love hewitt would have been such a good addition to the series omg i cant believe that she refused :'( sad
I didn't like Piper as the oldest sister.. It didn't fit. Phoebe was a terrible middle sister. It was much better with Prue !!
Brianna Bombshell Agree.
Guys, for pit sake stop being to both Rose and Shannon, while they bust there butts in outfits in the middle of the night trying to entertain you, you just lay there on your stomachs eating cup-cakes and chips complaining all they, why don't you come in and start rolling down the San Francisco hills if you think it will make it a better show, i am sick and tired of your insults to the girls and directors so just lay off god damn it and go to the bath room or something! God!
I disagree with you.
I would’ve liked the show more if Phoebe died instead of Prue a lot of people didn’t get along with Alyssa holly wanted to leave the show with Shannen and rose doesn’t like her either