These Artist WILL DELETE Your Chanel If You Listen To Their Music
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- #firsttimehearing #Reaction #music
This is the story of why i haven't been able to make First Time Listening Music Reactions. I Know most of you have subscribe to the channel because of my music reactions and have been wondering where I've been. Hopefully this video clears up everything
Tags
First Time Hearing Steely Dan
First Time Hearing Led Zeppelin
Firs Time Hearing Harry Mack
First Time Hearing Jolene Dolly Parton
First Time Hearing The Beatles
First Time Hearing Beethoven 5th Symphony
Reaction
Reaction Video
Reaction Videos
Reaction channel Reaction Hall And Oates
Reaction steely dan
How reaction videos are made
reaction to BTS
reaction to Squid Game
Reaction to
Thanks for all of the feedback so far I'm going to try experiment these next few weeks with different types of videos to see what sticks I'm also going to try to upload a few music reactions but I won't be able to upload only music reactions like I did in the past until the restrictions are lifted off of the channel. Thank you all for understanding.
There are some reactors such as andy & alex for example, that put reactions to certain groups known for copyright strikes on patreon and only put safer stuff on UA-cam. Some will put a video on UA-cam that's just the review of the song but no misic and a link to another site like dailymotion with the actual reaction
If you want to be first to react to my videos/music... I promise to not complain.
u good bro? you haven't uploaded in awhile.startin to worry
I understand that there is a generation of people who knew music by the videos, but I am very happy with just the audio recordings. It's the music that matters, not the video.
Is James allowed to post a reaction to the audio only? Is it the video that they have a problem with?
No unfortunately it’s both UA-cam automatically blocks the music videos but the copyright owners can still take down videos even if its just the audio by itself and that’s unfortunately what happened to me
It's impossible to fully appreciate Hurt by Johnny Cash without watching the video.
In the long run it'll be the artist who loses. Many young people are discovering new sounds, new groups from The Righteous Brothers to Marshall Tucker Band to AC/DC to Eminem and they like it enough to buy a download - all thanks to reaction channels. How else does an artis from 20 - 60 years ago expect to get exposure to younger demographics...
Even newer ones lose out. The only reason so many people in the US know about Dimash Kudaibergen is because of all the reactions to his music on YT. He was super interested in breaking into America in a bigger way and was really cool about letting reactors react to his music without blocking any of it and, man, it really got him out in front of a lot of people who otherwise wouldn't even know he existed. Then, sadly, he hired a new management team that started copyright claiming and blocking every reaction to his music on YT. Now he's kind of dropped off the YT radar again and that momentum he was building in the US appears to be slowing down.
Granted, he's a superstar all across Asia, huge in Russia, and probably isn't hurting for money so maybe they don't feel he needs the extra exposure... but I can tell you that the vast majority of people in America still have no idea who he is. His new management team basically killed the very movement that was introducing him into the market they're hoping to break. It's SO DUMB.
That being said, I think it needs to be said that a lot of reactors on YT don't help artists and publishers see the value of reactions. When you play an entire song without pausing, people can just come to your channel to listen to the song instead of going to the artist's channel and giving them the click. If all reactors paused more, it would be harder to argue that it was a replacement for just going to the artist's channel. Also, a lot of reactors just nod along and then, at the end, say, "Okay, thanks for watching. If you liked my reaction, click and subscribe..." etc. and don't actually add any value to the video. They just basically hijack the person's song and monetize themselves sitting in front of it. I can see why artists and publishers would be against that. Unfortunately, people who give real reactions (like James, Jamel, RSR, etc) get treated the same way even though they're genuinely sharing reactions. And even vocal coaches - who are bringing added value by using the music as a teaching tool - end up getting treated like the reactors who don't add value.
TBH, the whole thing's just a mess. The lazy reactors ruin it for everyone else and the artists who don't take the time to understand what the real reactors are doing for them just stomp on everyone indiscriminately. It's unfortunate.
Exactly this. It's such incredibly bad business to work against UA-cam (and Twitch etc) content creators today instead of with them. They're basically turning down a free advertisement super highway straight into the hearts of the very target groups it would benefit them the most to reach just out of some stubborn greedy mindset that "if you didn't pay for it, you're not using it". But I'm guessing these companies are ran by people who are so old and hopelessly out of touch they probably don't even know what UA-cam is.
Unfortunately 99% of the time it’s not up to the musicians, but the label itself. Most musicians don’t own the publication rights to their music.
It’s stupid, these reactors do nothing but keep their music alive and introduce it to more people! I’ll still be a subscriber but it isn’t fair !
Your typos are killing me😫
I don't understand how some channels get instant copyright strikes, whereas others openly play music from those artists and seem to have no trouble.
Really do miss your music reactions. You were without question one of the best. Thankyou for what you gave .
I used to be pissed at so many artist for this but then I realized most of them don't own their catalog or have shared interests on a company that is most likely the one that copyrights
Don’t give up, you are the first reactor that I subscribed & my all time favorite 💞☮️🥰
Hey Rome glad to see you, sorry this has happened. I can't understand why they don't understand their music is being exposed to new listeners which is ultimatelya great thing. But it's about control and money I guess. Does this happen with movies too? There are some good ones out there you should react to. But mainly do what YOU want, the rest will follow! 💜
In artists denfense, its probably not them who are removing these videos, its companies who own the rights to their music.
It's the principle of protecting intellectual property. Regardless of who holds the rights, why should this guy be allowed to consider copyrights to be merely an obstacle to be dodged? I suspect if he created something original, which others wished to manipulate, he'd have a much different opinion.
UA-cam are killing their own platform. There are other platforms where you can avoid all this crap.
{:-:-:}
I'm pissed off that this happens.....they should be happy that people still want to hear thier music. SME, SONY are a sure 🚫. I will look forward to reaction from you very soon. I have been watching reruns of your reactions , especially Hall and oates. They don't block....either does live from Daryl's House. much love to you and your family.
Sorry you are dealing with this issue. Been watching you for awhile but only recently subscribed. Hey, I'm 72, A little slower.😂 Even audio or lyrics is great. It is the music that matters. Does my heart good to see younger people react to the music I knew from the 50s onward. Keep on, you man, keep on.
Thank you for doing this video. I have been watching your music video reactions for awhile and went back to try to rewatch your awesome reaction to Led Zeppelin In My Time of Dying and was disappointed that all LZ reactions were gone. I am sorry this has happened to you. Will support whatever direction you take. Love the basketball reactions.
The Michael Jackson estate owns the rights to Beatles songs. Paul McCartney tried to but didn’t have as much money. It’s kind of messed up
Sony bought the rights from Jackson's estate in 2016, and in 2017 McCartney arranged a private settlement with Sony for the rights to his music. So he owns it now.
@@kwanshiyin That's what I saw as well.
@@kwanshiyin it was reported that a new law allowed him to, but it was never confirmed if he got it back because the rights acourding to that law belong to Paul and also Yoko ono, John's widow
@@rebelpunx88 "In 2017, Paul McCartney filed a federal lawsuit in New York seeking a declaratory judgment to begin reclaiming his copyright interests in his Beatles’ songs, which stem from Love Me Do (1962) to The Long and Winding Road (1970). It is a clever move by McCartney and his legal team to use an obscure part of the Federal Copyright Act of 1976 to get back the rights to the music.
Shortly thereafter McCartney filed his claim in the Southern District of New York, Sony/ATV quickly decided to settle in June 2017. It did not seem like they wanted to have a nasty legal battle go on for years. “The parties have resolved this matter by entering into a confidential settlement agreement and jointly request that the Court enter the enclosed proposed order dismissing the above-referenced action without prejudice,” said a letter from McCartney’s attorney. ***One additional note about Lennon’s side of the issue: A provision of that law states that if the songwriter were to die within the first 28-year period, the writer’s heirs would be eligible to recapture that publishing share at the end of that first period, which in the Beatles’ case would be 1990. Lennon died in 1980, and sources told Billboard in 2009 that Sony cut a deal with his wife Yoko Ono prior to the expiration of that period to retain ownership of Lennon’s share for the duration of the copyright period, which covers the 70 years after the owner’s death; in this case, 2050.
@@kwanshiyin thanks for the update!
I won't unsub ya. Gl to ya kid. If you catch my interest I'll be here
James. Thank you for the explanation. But honestly I really enjoyed your music reactions. Your fans will enjoy the audio versions just as much. But I get it. And it's fun to see the other sides of you.
I like movie reactions and travel reactions too. I will check back from time to time to see how you're doing.. Good Luck to you!
Makes no sense why you're being blocked by youtube and copyright when other reactors are still doing theirs.
Many had to reduce the screen size to a stamp, others have had to fog out the video so it was unwatchable.
Yeah I don't really get it either but from what I was told Some peoples video are allowed to stay up and others get taken down it all depends on if they copyright owner is aware of them or not
A lot has of it has to do with it's parent company Google
@@thomaswest7746 I heard that artists/recording companies employ dozens of people to find videos. I would have figured there was a search algorithm but apparently it's not 100%.
@@foxchasejrt1 UA-cam is owned by one of the problems in this country they conform to the Government's agenda just another to control any Media source
@@thomaswest7746 Where did you hear that? I've never heard that before.
I'll never understand people who have to leave "Your content changed! UNSUBBED!!" tantrum posts...
It's not the artists, it's the corporations who own the rights to the music. Very short-sighted of them to block free advertising...
Artists. Plural. “These artist?”
This is so strange. Some reactors seem to be okay, some (like yourself) have disappeared. Hope you can work it out. Truthfully, I'm only in it for music reactions.
Same. I only care about music reactions.
Hi Hun, I wonder do the same copyright rules apply with Anime and Cartoons? Especially older animation. I remember that it's something that your fond of.
Sorry they're giving you such a hard time, I don't have the answer I'm afraid but hopefully someone on here does. Best of luck hun, don't let the b****s grind you down. xxx
I really miss your music videos and am glad you will be coming back.
Appreciate the update. Today i stumbled upon your reaction to the Neil Peart drum solo, almost by accident. Before i saw it, my first reaction was "This man's mouth gonna be open in disbelief." And that's what i saw.... i loved what you had to say so i suscribed right away, because you get it. i didn't post on that feed, only because about 65,000 other people already had and i couldn't find the end.... i will just say this: They didn't have such impressive kits, but for sheer drumming you should check out Bev Bevan and Ian Paice. Ian plays (yes, PLAYS, present tense) for Deep Purple. He was there when the band started inh 1967 and still is. Bev played for Michael Schenker Group, and toured with Black Sabbath on the Born Again tour when Bill Ward's health made him unable to do the tour, among others. Check out MSG's 'Enter the Arena' and Deep Purple's 'Speed Freak' if you get a chance. Thank you for the channel
Glad you are taking a positive attitude. An idea is you can get a group of songs from your subscribers. Listen to them off camera and then list your top 10 and let of know why.
Welcome back James! You've been missed! I was worried you were going to start losing subscribers. Part of the reason I subscribed was not just for the music, but I love your personality!
To me the fun part is your reaction to the music. It’s less about reacting to the video itself. YOU are the video I’m watching as you react to the music. Can you try a reaction to straight audio, say played off your phone? Watching you get introduced to all the great music of my childhood, some of which I had forgotten about, was a silver lining in this pandemic. Thank YOU for bringing me back to so much great music!
WARNING from The Beatles;
Let It Be
Good to know
Stand-up comedy and Family Guy cut compilations seem to do quite well. And MrBallen reactions.
It was your genuine and thoughtful reactions that got me to subscribe in the first place, not just that it was music reactions. That being said, I'm not into sports AT ALL so I don't really click on your basketball vids and whatnot because it's just not a subject I'm interested in, no matter who's reacting to it. I'm always rooting for you though, James, and I can't wait to see how you continue to evolve the channel. I've stayed subscribed since early days and continually check in to see what you're up to that does coincide with my interests. Plus, I'm def looking forward to your movie reaction collab with RSR (assuming that announcement earlier wasn't your channel getting hacked or something). Y'all are gonna kill it!
As far as music reactions: It might be easier to argue Fair Use if you can find a unique angle that adds value to the video beyond just reacting to it. Every reactor has to deal with copyright issues, strikes, and blocks, but vocal coaches, e.g., seem to get away with it more often because they're actually analyzing the vocal technique, using the music as a way of teaching something about singing, and pausing a lot to do so (so it can't be argued that people are going to their channels just to listen to music without giving the artist a click). Not sure what talents you have or what unique value-add you could bring to a music reaction but maybe that's something to think about. The more the copyright holders crack down, the more YT reactors are going to have to evolve to justify what they're doing. You might as well get out ahead of the pack.
If you can't go back to music reactions, though, no worries. I look forward to whatever you do (other than the sports stuff, lol, sorry) and will continue to be here supporting you with my clicks, likes, subscription, bell, and whatever else helps keep building your own personal Rome.
Hi bro, 56 year old white boy here. Look, first Awesome channel brother!
To answer your question, try a whole series on the greatest live rock shows ever. Metallica in Russia (1.6 million people at that one), Iron Maiden (you pick but I would lien toward San Pablo or Tokyo) AC/DC Back in Black Tour, any live concert by Pink Floyd....... folks love that stuff and it proves what can be done live with analog. It's just better.
Peace bro.
It's not the artists, it's the record companies/managers. It's very short-sighted of them.
How are 14 years old kids going to hear Led Zeppelin, Steely Dan or the Beatles these days and buy the CD/Spotify thing? Dig out their grand dad's vinyl collection from their grand ma's attic, and then try and find a vinyl system to play them on?
{:-:-:}
As long as you don't go back to those horrible shorts, I'll be happy to support you
You could alter the audio and only show parts of the video, and have a timer next to the video like the normies do.
Yeah Jamel aka Jamal , has been having trouble with youtube
unfortunate but understandable.
I've really enjoyed your reactions over the past year or so but its really only music or movies that would probably keep me watching. No offense to you but its just what I have time to view. Peace man, keep it up! 👍🏼
I'll watch anything you post. I love your positive attitude.
So ridiculous. Don’t they understand they’ll make MORE money by people watch ur videos & downloading the music 😐
Here is some audio only versions of some songs: DIA - Will you got out with me ua-cam.com/video/aLDF9ovzPYo/v-deo.html , Saturday Night - Son Dam Bi ua-cam.com/video/hZyLUXa73Jk/v-deo.html , Love Tonight - Hong Jin Young - ua-cam.com/video/Q852tXWjQ4o/v-deo.html , Lie - T-ara ua-cam.com/video/0kCJPMSUoQc/v-deo.html , Saturday Night - Crayon Pop, ua-cam.com/video/yMeK51EfrCw/v-deo.html , Wouldn't it be Good - Nik Kershaw ua-cam.com/video/AYMAtbq0bjY/v-deo.html , Astronomy - Blue Oyster Cult ua-cam.com/video/U0t_wb0lUW0/v-deo.html , Animal - Platinum Blonde ua-cam.com/video/wHBNqnxC1yI/v-deo.html , Suburban Dream - Martha and the Muffins ua-cam.com/video/oabYMMRPMRs/v-deo.html , Unicron Medley - Vince Dicola ua-cam.com/video/uj14nNuoodw/v-deo.html
I can hear it in Australia
Sorry you have to deal with that. Thats all I got.
have you thought about reacting to old movies such as Charlie Chaplin's "The Great Dictator', Cary Grant's 'Operation Petticoat. Both are great comedies.
Its not the artists its the music owners
Every reactor seems to have their own theories on how to get music reactions to work, but it's all based on trial, error and luck cuz they still make conflicting decisions on a daily basis. The one I've seen many mention that your format went against was trying to let as much of the song play through and then giving your analysis afterwards. Many seem to swear by needing to pause the song or add a silent placeholder in to break up the song every 45-60 seconds. Again, it's all heresy. I don't blame you for wanting to switch up content.
Movies - The Rocky Horror Picture Show 20th Century Fox 1975
It usually isn't the artists that block you it is their record label that does the blocking, sometimes it is the artists, but most times it isn't. Warner, Sony, Rhino, Capitol, Universal, and Atlantic are some of the Major record labels who will block you for sure. Most of the smaller record labels don't care if you share videos they own
I'm fine with audio, but there's some live performances you should be alright with, especially with the European groups like Nightwish. Except for Poet and the Pendulum. A rapper sampled that one. Live at Wembley might be ok, but, it's really long. ( worth it, but long. ) Other than that, I haven't seen reactors struggle with them. Home Free is another group that is usually really good about reactors. A few post them on our private FB page so we can all come watch :) Try Working for a Livin cover, it sounds great and is really funny. I also wouldn't mind those "times when animals did amazing things/melted everyone's heart " type videos. but your channel! :) I'm here for it. XOXO
As a .musician/Songwriter no UA-cam music reaction person should be able to make money off other peoples music....They shouldn't get one red cent but they should pay just to watch their video or listen to their music?!
Yo brother there is a really well made video on lebron vs jordan goat analysis non biased made by dangerproductions, pls react!
I would love to see you react to something different - an African vibe. Please react to some Johnny Clegg. Clegg was a white South African who fought against apartheid (correct pronounciation being apart-hate, which kinda tells you everything) at a time when it was dangerous to do so. Here's one of my favourite tracks of his: ua-cam.com/video/2X-o7Kfqbuw/v-deo.html "We are scatterlings of Africa"! Thank you for all you do and for sending out such positive vibes to us all.
Just audio music
I have no comment on this video, but I want you to check out Carter Beaufort
If you are still alive post a new video.
James, I enjoy the audio-only music videos (or lyric videos) and don't mind not seeing the original music video. The only other reaction videos I care about are true crime and movie reactions. I know lots of people love sports reactions, but that isn't my cup of tea. I was really happy to see you post today!
It is stupid to not allow the free advertisement of their music.
No one is going to say to themselves "I feel like listening to (insert artist) but...I want my vibing to be disturbed by pauses and commentary"
Do cover songs videos
There it is, I had to reboot. I can hear now.
Some reactors do lyric videos or they pause in the middle of the song and talk about it and then continue on. It can be a little annoying, but that could help you with your copyright issues you've been getting
Sorry to hear you've fallen victim to the blocking police.
I have noticed several ways reactors have tried to cope with blocking, maybe can help?
The ghost imaging as already suggested - I find that distracting myself and usually go hit another channel. But it does seem effective against the blocking.
Also have seen - a full screen official copywrite statement at the very beginning of the reaction shown for bout 10 seconds. 👍🏻
Many reactors use much smaller windows for the video, sometimes too tiny.
I've also seen some chopped videos (top quarter of screen missing, or video zoomed in).
And of course, frequent pausing. I'm not a big fan of this. I understand it's necessary, but I'd rather a quick remark during the song and at a volumn that doesn't blow my eardrums - I always listen to my music at high volume, I was a concert fanatic growing up (228 concerts attended 🤙🏻) I love to feel music - my neighbors Hate me!🤣
It does seem that once you get blocked, it tends to happen again, very quickly. Several of the reactors I follow have had to deal with the same situation you described. All have managed to get past it using a bit of creativity I think 😁
Maybe once a channel has a video blocked, that channel is placed on a short term 'watch list' to make it more visible to the recording companies/artists auditors? It doesn't seem to last a long time though if you're careful.
I totally feel your frustration, it doesn't seem to make sense that the videos or songs are blocked or flat out not available. I can't listen on UA-cam Music to 1 of my fav artists and only a limited catalog of several others. Very frustrating when songs disappear off my playlists too.🤬
Artists that are blocking should follow Queen's example, they new upload videos very frequently - I know they have blocked some though too 😒 Look at how many people have discovered Queen and Freddie. It's astounding! Sure the movie helped some. To me, some of the most entertaining reactions are first-time listeners to Bohemian Rhapsody. I love watching people's expressions, very, very cool! I wasn't a huge fan of Queen in '70's-'80's, liked some of their stuff, but now I'm crazy about a few of their videos & songs ("Somebody to Love" live Montreal, the Live Aid performance - Wow!!🤩💕) I get the chills every time I watch those! And I never get tired of hearing"Don't Stop Me Now" - perks me right up when I feel blue!! 😁
I hope it gets better for you soon - wishing you luck.
I love watching your rock reactions! 😍💕
Use Live versions of the songs,
Or watch the video but distort the image for us, so you can still watch the video that we want you to see, but we will see it blurry.
Don't take chances on Beatles, Led Zepplin, or the Eagles. They just don't understand that you watching their video actually introduces people to songs they won't hear otherwise.
Try some ghost/haunted captured on camera reactions. They do well for others & there’s tons of that kind of footage available without worrying about CW infringement.
I've been wondering where you are. I have no interest in basketball. 😀 Put up a patreon channel, and announce the video on youtube linking to it in the pinned comment.
I agree with this approach. I’m only interested in music reactions. Post them on Patreon.
I miss your reaction video's. There are a few others I also watch. Some still react & others react to movies. It has put a damper on the viewers enjoyment. So sad.
I react to music and for sure you never know when the 'strike' will come knocking at the door months after you posted. My other channel is of my paranormal investigations so at least is free of copyright.
I've watched many of your videos and love the way you talk, break stuff down and analyse what you've watched or listened too. I think you'd be great talking about weird and mysterious phenomena or incidences in the world because you are intelligent and have a really good voice for it. But whatever you decide will be great I'm sure.
gpreactions - What's your take on Ghost Adventures? Can you post short clips from the show? I find a few bits of their collected evidence interesting. Much is drama and have heard accusations of fakery. I do love all the crazy tech they use.
I'm an open minded skeptic who had an experience in the MT state prison while sightseeing.
Will check out ur channel. ✌🏻
@@foxchasejrt1 I guess, similar to reacting to movies, you'd have to break their show down with editing and commentary which would be a longer process in editing but less likely to incur copyright, and even less so if you just pick clips and react to them or talk about the equipment they use.
💯🥰
There's no sound?
have you tired refreshing the video ?
Mike Tyson 🤓
Also Marcus Veltri is another amazing beatboxing pianist, with 4 million views, who can play ANY (yes ANY) song someone request. He loves reactors also, along with Harry Mack, who I mentioned in my previous comment. They did a collab together in "Harry Macks Omegle Bars #32" which is up for collab of the year! It's Fire!! Reacting to these guys is an excellent way to grow your channel.
I have copyrights, but feel they should only last as long as a patent would (20 years), then the work goes into the public domain. The way it is now, it goes on almost forever way beyond the artist's lifetime.
Channel likes basketball vids... expand that idea to more sports, like hockey, I'm Canadian of course that's my go to but there are lots of video's to see from fan compilations, individual player highlights to blooper gag reel on ice incidents. i can send links and more suggestions for idea's on where to start, regardless on how well you know the sport. and i will say the hockey community by in large is welcoming and copy strike friendly. As for un-subbing, not a chance spread positivity always.
Well I assume these artists or groups have not heard that any publicity is good publicity. Seems a good way to become extinct to me.
You could react to older music, bring back some great music no longer in the limelight. You know, if they’re not here, won’t be deleted by artist.
Hey James, how did your friends and family react to theGood,Bad and the Ugly video, way back then,I keep forgetting to ask you
Well James, lyric videos are fine. Your subscribers can always go and watch the videos there own self it they want to what the video looks like
Happy Mother's Day to your wife from Jacksonville, Florida
look at the stroy behind the song louie louie it will give you alot of insite into this
Damn looks like you got deleted! 😳 lol ain't seen you in like 5 months!
With these big tech Tyrants, rules are arbitrary.
You should do reaction to memes and stuff
Mr. Grinch - Small Town Titans
Young man, lol. Told you I was old.
If this is about the Beatles. I could have told you they SUCK! They are highly overrated. The Rolling Stones are waaaayyyy better!! The Stones are pure rock n roll. The Beatles overblown bubblegum pop.
Last time I checked the Stones never wrote a song for the Beatles but the Beatles gave the Stones a single….
I know all about that and they still SUCK!!!
@@sweett8351 They say opinions are like assholes…
and yours stinks 😋
@@scottelement oh yeah and The Beatles suck too! Hahaha!! 🤣🤣🤣
@Far Stox nah, still not a fan. I’m sorry but they did NOT invent rock n roll and the least edgiest band. I have forced myself to listen to them for many Sundays on KLOS and still felt like I was listening to easy listening Co-op granola radio. Just my opinion, if you love the Beatles…that’s great. I don’t and never will.
Hockey!!! Do Hockey Reactions!!!