If you were expecting the Whites moc toe video today I apologize for delaying it but it will be out on Thursday and then the Moctober finale on Sunday Nov. 1st with some guest appearances from Stridewise and Trenton & Heath!!!
I had to choose between the two about a month ago when buying my first pair of steel-toe boots. The Thorogoods were immediately comfortable. I actually prefer wearing them over my sneakers at this point. It's like walking around on a cushion of air
Im having to break mine in. I have a wide foot and 9 was the best size. Top of my foot and the sides is whats needs to widen a bit,and yes i got the wide size.
Just got an 8” steel toe pair for my new tire technician job that required steel toes. After a 8 hour shift of being on my feet for 99% of the time, they were basically broken in. Now after about a week worth of working, they are almost perfect. I assume they will keep getting more comfortable though.
I've been wearing my Thorogoods going on 3 years now on and off construction sites. It's just now to the point I'm going to send them in to be refurbished. They are super comfortable and I have no problem being in them for over 14hrs a day everyday. I've put major miles on my boots and although I've never tried Red Wing boots before. I don't see a reason to switch now. The break in was short. I just had to not tie them all the way up to give my ankle a break. Once broken in they are the best boot I've ever owned.
4+ years of wearing my thorogoods daily at work. At 3 years I got them re-soled. Leather is still going very strong. Change the insoles every 6 months-year.
I've been wearing Thorogood for years now. I've had about 3-4 pair and they absolutely blow away any other boots I've worn for work. Most boots including a pair of Redwings I've owned only lasted 6-9 months. My longest wearing Thorogood lasted me 1 1/2 years.
I love mine. Owned for only six months but I love them. I tried on the Redwing, but I really felt like I was wearing clown shoes. No offense to anyone.
I've owned both. The Red Wing soles wore out quickly. The Thorogood leather was softer and the boots were far more comfortable. (I also prefer the Thorogood style too.) I had the Red Wing soles replaced with a Vibram wedge and the leather still looks great. I still wear the Red Wing pair around town but buy Thorogoods for work.
Been a fan of Thorogood's for 5 years. I bought a pair of RW when I was in a pinch for a waterproof boot in some bad weather S Dakota. I wore them for three months and now that pair sits in my closet. Don't normally need a WP boot in So Calif. Love the Thorogood boots. Comfortable. I have NOT experienced any construction issues with the boots but I have seen some have meltdowns. IBEW electrician who can put on a pair of Thorogood right out of the box and come home with no blisters. Comfortable.
I'm really impressed by how much you've learned since your early videos. These newer videos are factually correct and actually offer information and comparisons that aren't readily available else where. I'm glad you're here providing some quality content for the GYW community and boot/shoe enthusiasts in general. Subscribed!
I've worn both for extended periods and Thorogood wedge lasted wayyy longer. Never had any issues with leather and condition once every few months. Overall comfort was better and I really didn't like the toe box on the Red Wings. Bonus is Thorogoods are made in USA with union labor.
Man! Good review! I’m a union carpenter I have used both of these boots for several years. I love the redwing boots! The comfort for a boot is off the charts! However, the longevity is below par. They lasted me 6 months! The stitching on the toe box came apart, and the sole was gone! I’m talking slick gone! For 289$ that wasn’t going to fly with me. Thorogood moc toe lasted me 1yr. Stitching still in place, the leather on the toe box scuffed a bit but nothing extreme. The outsole was in the same condition as the redwings were but in a 1yr span not 6 months. I currently use thorogood 1957 series 6” moc toe tobacco. Their waterproof and a real good looking boot.
I’m a licensed electrician who does commercial work and industrial work. I’m on my feet the whole shift. I have always bought Thorogoods, and I love mine so much that I wear them even when I’m not at work. They work great for riding my HD.
This video helped so much! I work in construction and I’m on my feet for up to 12 hours a day. I originally wanted Red Wings, but then I found out about Thorogood boots, and after this video I am for sure going with those over the Red Wing. Thank you!
This is just what I needed. I am a maintenance man. Meaning I work some days and sit on my bum on others. I put in about 10,000 steps on a shift. I want re-soleable boots. Thorogood look good but I'm going to pick up some RedWings this month then Thorogood early next year. I'll wear them a week on and a week off then give you feedback. Great channel!
Just bought my first pair of Redwings and I have to say I am kicking myself in the ass for not buying a pair sooner. The breaking in was a dream, I wore them 8-hours on day one with no blisters, and after a week I forget I even have them on. Awesome boot.
I own a 6yr old pair of Thorogoods and they’re pretty slippery. They don’t wear out much w/ even heavy work, but they are slippery on ice, water, and oil. Vibram christy soles are better than the poly based soles, imho
When trying to find an American made work boot about 10 years ago, as soon as I tried on the thorogood I knew it was the one. They are very comfortable right out of the box. I work heavy construction and the Thorogood holds up great.
@@boredandagitated American made All the way! Union made go away. Labor Unions have outlived there usefulness and a controlled by the Democrats. BTW. China is a Union also. China Communists Union.
Good video! Spot on! Im a union carpenter I’ve used both of these boots and your analysis is accurate. I personal was going back and forth with these 2 boots, and then thorogood came out with a waterproof boot called the 1957 series moc toe. I was really happy with these and then all of a sudden they stopped making a tobacco color way. So now I’m back going back and forth with the redwing classic moc toe and the thorogood standard moc toe. Thanks for the vid.
@@whiteout130 I've had both and liked the Thorogood more. Most people don't have time to break in a boot for a month. Thorogood you get 80% comfort out of the box and can fully break them in after a couple weeks. I like the 8" 814-3800
@@1tssen Appreciate the insight. I have been using Thorogoods for 2 years now. I go through a pair a year. By 8 months they're breaking down. 1 year they're toast. Usually wearing through the leather on my pinky toe side.. I might need a Wide verison come to think of it.. idk D with seems to fit well.
@@whiteout130 Thorogoods tend to run narrow. I wear a 2E width. At the end of the day it really depends on your working conditions. Any site that is extremely dirty or a lot of concrete will dry out the leather pretty fast so gotta condition more often.
Dude, I am out of breathe just watching you. But, I really like that you were consistent in your delivery and the popups to read summaries. Great video, well presented.
Thorogood all the way. Ive been through 3 pr of redwings and they were ok. I’ve just switched to Thorogood moc toe and they are so much more comfortable and have lasted just as long as the redwings. Im on my feet all day and use them for work.
Excellent comparison. I've owned and worn Red wing loggers (us made version) and while they last a long time , the first 2 months of working left me with calluses on my feet. Tried my first pair of Thorogoods last year and they were comfortable right from the start. Thick leather and hard wearing outsole along with US Union labor and I wont go back to Redwings with their blend of foreign made options.
I've had my Thorogoods now for 2 years with moderate use. I specifically wear the 814-3800 wedge sole, weatherproof, waterproof, steel toe arrangement. Mink oil once every 3-4months and prior to use in rain. I USE A REDWING IN SOLE FOR ARCH SUPPORT. Purchased one shoe size smaller and wore out to the bar a couple times for break in. Super comfortable... Thanks RoseAnvil forbthe awesome videos...
I bought the Thorogoods today. I was at a shop that sold Thorogoods ($169), Red Wings ($219) & Danners ($159); so I was able to try on and walk around in all three brands’ mock toe boots. All looked good, felt good and appear well built. All three were quite comfortable and I was splitting hairs on deciding. If I had been at a shop that only sold one brand, I probably could have left with any of these boots and been happy. In the end, to me, the Thorogoods fit slightly better, felt more comfortable from the start, and the leather was softer; all points Rose Anvil stated here. I have become use to using speed hooks on all of my other boots, so I liked that they are on the Thorogoods & Danners over the eyelets on the Red Wings. I do wish Thorogood would have used speed hooks all the way to the top instead of a top eyelet; it’s a little awkward having to stop speed lacing to the thread the top eyelet. The Thorogoods are a little taller, which I liked since I will be wearing these when I ride my motorcycle. All three boots are very nice and made in the USA; a tough decision.
I’ve always bought Danner’s for my work boot, but I bought my first pair of Thorogood boots a couple weeks ago. I purchased the 804-4375 and couldn’t be happier. Time will really tell, but I feel confidant these boots are true quality.
What’s funny is I’m completely opposite to a lot of these comments. I’m a union electrician and have tried both pairs. I started off with Red Wings and after about a year their sole was wearing down so I turned them into my camping boots and got a pair of thorogoods. They lasted 8 months before my feet were in legit pain every day at work. I currently rock the 8in redwings with their leather insole. The thorogoods stitching was worn out in multiple spots…water easily seeped through. Really comfy boots…I just think as prices of both are increasing it’s worth a break in period so that I can resole my redwings for another year at least.
I’m watching this after trying both for my garden maintenance business. I work about 7 hours a day 5 days a week. Just basically walking no landscaping. I walk on cement, grass, rocks, gravel, mulch, dirt, wet grounds, etc. The red wings lasted me 5 months before I started slipping on hill grounds. The thorogoods lasted me 4 months. Both comfortable but for me it’s about who’s outsole will last longer for my work. And another month of income is huge for me. Redwings take the win for me
@@greenterracelandscape6264 you have to buy gas for your car, fuel your mowers, weed eaters, blowers, trailer maintenance, car insurance, and whatever other overhead you have. That’s not a lot buddy. Hope you can find more hours.
Lol. I forgot you’re my accountant. I use a 2007 colorado. Paid off. I pay $90 for car insurance. I use all electric tools. No trailer set up. I understand overhead. I’m a licensed landscaper in the Bay Area. I’m a father of 2. And my wife has her own bakery shop that’s thriving. We prioritize our kids and each other. Not Tom Brady here. You seem upset about something. Can’t figure it out. Great day.
Both are American made, but those thorogoods leather is just so soft and nice. I’m purchasing the thorogoods, plus the price is just a bit better also it’s a winner to me!!
I have been working construction 6 plus years and started with Red Wings Irish Setters, switched over to Thorogoods a few years ago and by far Thorogoods are loooonger lasting in my opinion.
I just got a pair of Thorogoods and I am shocked at how comfortable they were day one. Hands down the most comfortable boots I’ve had so far and that’s saying a lot because I loved my “Cadillacs” & “Jungles” in the Marine Corps.
The redwings you are reviewing here are from their “heritage” line which is made more for fashion and walking around town, they also have a “work” line with a similar style (I believe it’s the 877 for heritage and 10877 for the work) I’d be curious to see the difference between the two. I’ve worn the 10877’s for years and they are quite possibly the best boot I’ve worn.
I have both..find i can wear the redwings all day no discomfort . Thorogood while comfy at first,cant wait to take them off after a days work at construction. Having said that , I love them both.
Bought Thoroughgoods for my job because I'm standing on factory concrete 9-12 hours a day - they're just plain comfortable as hell. Wore some RedWings when I was running a sawmill outdoors and they were great, but they just kill me on concrete. Gotta have that softness with the insole for that, in my experience.
I have worked construction 17 years (Ironworker) and tried both. Red wings wear out much faster than thorogoods the souls and stitching come apart on the reds, i can avg 2 years of hard use on thorogoods as long as you keep them oiled. Thats jus been my experience
My personal experience Thorogoods last longer than the Red Wings. Basically from wearing them everyday on a construction site. I've actually never had issues with the leather wearing out the soles are what wear out on me. I have never gotten them resoled though. I use to be a hardcore Red Wing wearer until they started making over half their boots over seas. Then I switched to Thorogood and would never switch back.
@@shurdi3 Its jobsite specific. A majority of jobs you don't need a safety toe. I've honestly have never been in a situation where a safety toe would have been beneficial. Also in my experience steel toes do wear out quicker. I have had boots that have had the steel exposed through the leather. On none steel toed I've never had a hole in the leather of the toe.
Got my first pair of thorogoods, steel toe plain toe with normal sole not the wedge but 2 years of hard use they're still holding up perfect and way more comfortable than my iron rangers ever could be, and people have asked me about and complimented the thorogoods but no one's ever said a word about the red wings. $100+ cheaper too and it's a no brainer if you actually work in your boots. IDK if I'll bother resoling them when they wear out since they're so affordable anyway, I've more than gotten my money's worth vs buying timberlands or wolverine work boots like I was before that never lasted more than a year.
Thorogoods definitely last longer and hold up to a lot of abuse. I've tried the Red Wing waterproof moc toe and wedge only lasted 6 months untill the heal was totally worn out. They also leaked water pretty bad. I wear the Thorogood 814-3800 now for almost a year and they are amazing, never had a drop of water inside and wedge is in still pretty decent shape, I can probably go another year before resole. I think they look better too
I work in a cnc mold shop , I step on coolant and oil and hot metal chips all day . My thorogood boots have lasted 3 years and still going. I am going to get them resoled soon
I've been wearing the same pair of 814-4200 Thorogood boots for years now. I've never owned RW's but can't imagine why I'd entertain the thought of switching away from the T-Goods. They're everything I want in a boot,and the comfort is top shelf.
I have enjoyed Moctober and I like the themed programs. I am looking forward to the winter boot series. I also have to say the quality of your show has significantly improved over time. Your confidence in front of the camera has also gone up and has really improved your show. Keep up the great work.
They are casual high quality work boots. They are casual because with simple search of work boot. Timberland and redwings will be the first to show up In the "high" end. Take that with grain of salt. You don't here thorogood or whites often. Only from an experienced worker who buys work boots on the regular.
Been making America great again for 25 years in a factory wearing Red Wings. I'm going to try the Thorogoods this year, but it will be a smooth toe. Moc toes are for beatnik posers, I run footpedals most days- the extra seam is a weak link. Not so sure about the wedge sole just yet. We shall see👀
The Red Wing has the leather footbed, which molds to the shape of your foot after a month or two rather than having a foam padded insole. Over time the leather insole, once molded, fits more like a glove, which translates into comfort when paired with the softer crepe insole.
Based on my experience with using Redwings and Thorogoods in the construction industry my Thorogoods lasted longer. The Thorogoods I kept for yard work have been resoled 3 times so far.
I wore redwings for 10 years. I switched over to Thorogoods 6 years ago. Union and American made and very comfortable. I think they look better as well.
Since watch this awhile back, I've bought both these boots. First the redwings. They killed me for about 2 weeks, meanwhile I got the thorogood. I wear those to work everyday now. And my redwings are my nice boots. The redwings took forever to break in, but I like them more. They won't be work boots for probably another year. Great comparison here
I've been wearing my Thorogood 804-4208s for about a year and a half, and I absolutely love them. Best boots I've ever had. All of my previous Redwing and Irish Setter boots (not moc toes) have had to be replaced yearly. I'm about to buy a second pair of 8" Thorogoods in a soft toe for casual wear/ riding as my steel toes aren't the best looking after all the hydraulic oils, rusty water, mud, stamping sludge and so on and they don't fit under my shifter easily. That said, they are still the most durable work boots I've owned to date and will be here for a long time.
I use power step inserts... game changer for me. I haven't said "My dogs are barking" while pulling off my boots in the locker room in probably 2+ years. They're about 60 bucks and you'll thank me for sure
Great video and you are 100% correct on most accounts. I've been buying Redwings for years and love them. They are more costly, do take a bit of time to break in and I wear the soles out way before the shoe itself. However, it almost costs as much to resole them as buying a new pair. I get the 2416 power linemans boots and they do have the speed hooks.
I am 65 and only work around my yard on weekends, had the same redwings but after a year my feet hurt at the end of the day. The boots where given away and I got the thorogoods,wearing them 3yrs now and they are great. Only wear them 2 days a week so I think they will last the rest of my life lol.
When I use to do roofing, a lot of guys I worked with loved the Thorogood boots-mainly comfort and they held up well although any boot no matter how thick doesnt last long before needing to repair the boot. Great info on the video!
As a mechanic our boots only last about 1 year. I wore Dannier for 15 years. I tried Red wings and they are the most comfortable boots I have worn. Only problem is they last about 6 months.
I bought a pair of the thorogoods with a black soul instead of the white because I hate white souled boots, and I am super happy with the thorogoods. The only thing I will change when I get them resouled is the welt. I'll probably change it out with a leather storm welt for more durability. Other then that, they are an awesome pair of boots!
I'm a foodservice truck driver. I deliver to most of the fast food chains that most people eat at with a focus on pizzerias and Italian restaurants. I put in about 10-12 miles of walking (more like pushing a dolly with a few hundred pounds from outside to inside of the restaurants and walking back and forth in a 48' trailer building/rebuilding pallets. Work boots last 6-8 months before they're done. Totally bald, glue coming apart near the toe box (extra toe guard on various redwing styles) or the outsole ripping apart from one end to the other. Thorogood boots. By far. Are the most comfortable boot I've ever used. I can put in a 10-12 hour workday and when I get home and the wife wants to go for a walk I leave my thorogoods on because they're better than any of my 'walking shoes'. I start at 1-3am in the morning. Small crowded parking lots and big rigs don't mix. Wedge boots have really bad slip resistance though. Redwing & Thorogood. They kind of suck on greasy tile floors. Redwing Heritage boots/Moc Toe are good for one thing: Fashion. That's it. I can't imagine them ever being a work boot. Thorogood boots are good at being comfortable day 1. Re-sole them once maybe twice if the shank and support is still there. Good for being on your feet all day on cement. Good for landscaping. Good for plumbing. Steel toe versions are heavy, but still incredibly comfortable.
Thanks for the review. I have the thorougoods Saftey toe and love them. Less than a hour break in time and just as comfortable as ever. I walk 10,000 to 20000 steps a day at work all on concrete and no issues at all. My feet feel the best they have in years and I only switched boot brands the work load is the same. I will say I have never tried the RW”s but guys and girls at work say they are just as comfortable after a few week break in if you feet can handle it.
I’ll probably grab a Thorogood moc for work, hopefully the sole helps with my lower back pain. I love Red Wing but I want something that I can just throw on and not have to break in.
I work for the Railroad in the track Department. I’ve been wearing the Thorogood model# 4375 for roughly 5 years now with 1 complete restoration in that time frame. Very comfortable boot that takes little to no time for break in in my case. I’m constantly on ballast, mud, sand, and getting hydraulic fluid on them. I even thermite welded a year in them where it was common to see them near extreme heat all the time. I’ve been on my feet for 24+ hrs many times and my feet feel fine in these. The cons are I do have to treat them for waterproofing once a month or my feet will get wet, this model isn’t waterproof and the elements I work in are really hard on leather. Definitely get the EE if you want to wear extra socks because they run tight. I’m in the Deep South so it’s not an issue for me personally. I’ll never wear a different boot and would highly recommend them.
Hey man Roll Tide! Just bought my first pair of Thorgoods to do construction here in Alabama. Also I do waterproofing so my boots will be exposed to that element quite often. What’s your waterproofing application to your boots? Ready for Bryce Young to shine this year! Take care.
Took a huge gamble watching this video AFTER dropping 3 bills on a pair of 8" steel-toe Thorogoods, but I just couldn't help myself. Glad I watched though. Awesome breakdown, and now I feel even better with my choice, as I plan to used these for work :-)
Thorough Good boots are the best I’ve ever worn and I’m going on wearing them a year and a half. They’ve been through tons of concrete and 100s miles of walking on asphalt. I will only buy them going forward.
I bought a pair of work shoes from Red Wing and I bought a real comfy insole. It was leather over foam but they are nice. I've had foot problems, foot surgery and walking can suck so I'm all in for the tumble leather the Thorogoods offer..good review, I don't think seen you take a single breath during your presentation!
Have you worn these boots. I wore this exact redwing for years and I’ve been wearing thorogoods exclusively for the last 5. Thorogoods are miles better then redwing. You should wear these boots and work in them before saying which is better.
Exactly. I’ve had Timberlands, Danner, Ariat, and Thurogoods. Multiple pairs of boots across 20 years of the hardest construction in America, foundation repair. Red wings are EXTREMELY overrated. Didn’t last 3 months. Ariat slip on are comfortable, but last about 6 months. Danner are a great boot that mix comfort and durability that can last 1-2 years with care. Timberland mid high hiking boots are the best bang for your buck. Lasting as long as top tier brands but at a much lower cost. Thorogoods are the most comfortable thing I’ve ever put on my feet. Consider your boots a tool, don’t skimp out on your feet. When your a real labor worker, fatigue and endurance can be easily manipulated by the boots you wear. (And socks, I like Duluth)
@@joeedwards1682 I just picked up some red wings. My job destroys boots (my wolverines which are $200 boots are destroyed after 10 months with the toes completely ripped off) so I decided to finally try something higher quality. I got this covering from the red wing store to protect the toes as I crawl but I don't know how they hold up since I just got the boots on Friday. Any recommendations? If these hold up I'll be happy to buy more. I got the insolated dynaforce steel toe with waterproofing as I work outside and get wet frequently. $330 with the fancy covering
Have work both red wing 2408 and for the past 2 years have work the 8 inch moc toe 4208 thorogoods . Does anyone have issue I am having . Recently my thorogoods have gotten soaken wet I let them air dry but now the leather on the outside smells so bad to the point where I can’t even wear them inside of the boot smells fine but the outside it’s terrible
I just wanted to thank you for all the info on your channel. Thanks to this, I got some Thorogoods and really learned a lot about quality work boots. Without it, I would honestly have bought some cheap Carhart boots on name, thinking they were just as good as anything else out there. Now I feel like I own some kit that I can really depend on and buying USA does feel good too! thanks!
I regret selling my Thorogood Moc Toes. I was about to buy another pair, but realized they doubled in price! I bought the 8” Moc Toe boots for $130 in 2012.
Ive had them both and while both are great boots and after having worn them both for years i honestly believe they will both realistically last the same amount of time with resoles but you get this longevity and durability at less sacrifice of price and comfort with the thorogood. Great great boot and just more practical.
As a single guy who is embarrassed to sometimes buy frosted flakes, I may give that cereal a go. :) Also, in my head, toaster is off camera with a watch on constantly tapping it and glaring at you.
I shopped around and searched the web looking for a MOC in size 13 EE. I bought the red wing 405 . this is my 3rd pair of red wing boots and my first non steel toe pair. I love the feel of the leather and the fit, they are little stiff but will adjust overtime.
Love your videos, very informative. I actually bought a pair of boots based on your knowledge. The one thing I noticed you don't mention a lot is Waterproof. Waterproof to me is very important when purchasing a good pair of boots. Again nice videos.
Ive worn redwing work boots for years and with the impression that they are made in america like they advertise. While shopping in a red wing store the sales person said only 1 boot was made in america and all the rest made over seas. since that day Ive being buying Throrogood which are mad int the good Ol USA!
I own both a tobacco pair of thorogoods and a black pair of redwings and having worn both a lot and both are significantly broken in, I will say comfort wise the thorogoods are hands down the winner. Plus the speed hooks are so much more convenient, so much so that I often find myself actively avoiding wearing my redwings because they are such a hassle to put on. Like, I literally have to entirely loosen the laces all the way down and unthread the top two eyelets in order to shove my foot in, not to mention the redwings don't have a little pull loop thing. You can also usually find thorogoods on crazy good sales, especially on dvor, redwings not so much. My iron rangers on the other hand are perfection. I'd recommend getting a pair of thorogood mocs and a pair of redwing iron rangers and call it a day.
For anyone with contact dermatitis . I've worn many different boots through the years & every one of them has caused me dermatitis except the Thorogood moc toe . Any interior fake materials cause me a huge rash . I got the Carhartt loggers years ago & those made the flare ups the worst .
I love Thorogoods, have 3 pairs and they are my go-to boot. That said, you still have to break them in a little. All boots have some sort of break in. I have found that the Thorogoods bleed (the color of the leather dye) onto my socks during break in, all of them have done that. I work construction (15+ years now & countless pairs of boots) so they are just work socks but I haven’t heard anyone else mention this happening to them too. Brown/ tan or black, happened on all 3 pairs. Once broken though, they’ve been more comfortable than most of my regular shoes.
Neither here nor there but I've been wearing steel to work boots for the better part of 30 years and I will say you get what you pay for but do your research!! I've worn both, as well as Danner, Nick's, and some lesser quality (less expensive) boots but I will say a quality boot with leather and/or cork insoles are WAY more comfortable than all the wonder foam, super polymer, etc shoes let alone boots... Aside from weight of course. I'm just happy that some companies still abide by form over function and wish other companies (especially in different fields) would take heed.
Definitely thorogood will be your best choice. Extremely comfortable compared to redwings. I had to change the bottoms before they even got confortable. On the other side, thorogood took no more than two week to feel so good. I walk on concrete every day at work, the soles still in great conditions. Don’t waste your money, don’t buy redwings. My good advice. 👍🏼
I put thorogood inserts in my Jim green razorbacks and they are so much better now. Just got a pair of thorogood 804 4200s and am very happy with them.
I just recently found your channel while looking for solid work boots and your content along with information is amazing. If you could make a video on the best steel toed boots that would be awesome.
Love the content, watched a lot of theses moc toe videos you have done learn something every time. Im in the restaurant industry and the slip resistance is never talked about when it comes to the sole. Show some love to the burger flipping drink slingers wearing good boots. After a10 hour day on your feet on wet tile I appreciate the segments on comfort it pays to do the research on a good pair so thanks for making my life a ;little easier
Great review, I’m personally over Redwings as Brooklyn hipsters glommed onto them quite some time ago, Its cool to look like you actually work. I think an aspect that we might be wondering about is water. How do they both compare keeping feet dry in water/snow? I don’t see you mention that in tests. when buying boots my purchase points are Protection, Comfort, keep feet dry, and so on down the line.
Ok, I’m a union sprinkler fitter putting up schedule 40 6” all the time. If you don’t know that is-look it up. I’m on ladders, lifts, cat walks. You name it. I do only industrial and commercial. I wore red wings for ten years, then I found thorogoods. Red wing soles last 6 months tops and then it costs a pretty Penney to resole them. My thorogoods lasted over 2 years before I had to resole them and when I did bought two extra pairs. The ankle support is phenomenal with the waterproof models and I’ll never buy another pair of red wings as kind as I live, although maybe a pair of Irish setter steel toe slip one. That’s another thing, all my boots are steel toe.
I ordered both, and I really wanted to keep the red wings but my wife hated them lol. I needed black and thorogood had black on black soles. Thorogood was definitely more comfy out of the box but the wings were better made.
My union rep got into a fight with the red wing supplier so we kinda had to switch to thorogood to get a deal.. but after my third pair of high hour welding abuse over the last 7 years the thorogoods have actually lasted longer and been more comfortable, I never can make it to a resole anyways because of toe dragging on grating crawling around but I would recommend them to anyone over redwings having the two brands being my only boots over ten years (besides a pair of caterpillar boots that were horrifyingly bad and got trashed within a couple months)
I wear the 8" thorogood with steel toe. Fantastic boots. Work maintenance and usually get 2 years out of a pair. Wear the toes out before the souls. First factory was a bakery, dry environment, boots were great. Current factory is a cannery, wet environment, boots not so great. Getting wet regularly I had the welt fail, that was the boots I transitioned jobs in so had a year on them. Current boots had stitching come apart under the lacing area behind my big toe. Never had that style of Redwing but I shy away from stiff boots. Hate spending 2 weeks with sore feet/legs while they break in. Spend 8hrs on my feet on concrete, thorogoods super comfortable right out the box.
I feel like I fall with a majority of the comments. I have both, and have owned and worn redwings for the last 10 years. The last 3 of which I have worn my Thorogood Mocs for work, and now for casual wear as well. Despite the Oro leather being higher quality, the boot just doesn’t cut it as a true work boot. It’s also no the most comfortable for long hours on your feet. Other than the heritage line, redwing has a lot of overseas production and overseas parts assembled in USA. USA union made Thorogood was my choice as a union worker myself. More comfortable and more durable at a better price point. Don’t get me wrong I love my redwing 877’s but you’ll never catch me wearing them on the job.
![BEST and WORST Moc Toe Boots - [TIER LIST]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BEoJkTpQ01k/mqdefault.jpg)
![Дон ДОН, Алаудинов и СБЕЖАВШИЕ из под Курска ахматовцы 😁 [Пародия]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dEfCf5IK26Q/mqdefault.jpg)
If you were expecting the Whites moc toe video today I apologize for delaying it but it will be out on Thursday and then the Moctober finale on Sunday Nov. 1st with some guest appearances from Stridewise and Trenton & Heath!!!
No problem
Love your content
No problem. Thanks for posting this video, it’s great! And Trenton and Heath are amazing. That’s super exciting!!
Ooh I love Trenton & Heath, great channel
🙌🏻
Take your time dude. I'm excited to see more cross-overs.
I had to choose between the two about a month ago when buying my first pair of steel-toe boots. The Thorogoods were immediately comfortable. I actually prefer wearing them over my sneakers at this point. It's like walking around on a cushion of air
Same here, they are comfortable as hell.
Im having to break mine in. I have a wide foot and 9 was the best size. Top of my foot and the sides is whats needs to widen a bit,and yes i got the wide size.
Just got an 8” steel toe pair for my new tire technician job that required steel toes. After a 8 hour shift of being on my feet for 99% of the time, they were basically broken in. Now after about a week worth of working, they are almost perfect. I assume they will keep getting more comfortable though.
@@KimballPrecision i hope the same goes for me. Im goin on my 3rd day.
Does red wing offer a steel toe in the 6in moc?
I like how he also rushed the ad
I've been wearing my Thorogoods going on 3 years now on and off construction sites. It's just now to the point I'm going to send them in to be refurbished. They are super comfortable and I have no problem being in them for over 14hrs a day everyday. I've put major miles on my boots and although I've never tried Red Wing boots before. I don't see a reason to switch now. The break in was short. I just had to not tie them all the way up to give my ankle a break. Once broken in they are the best boot I've ever owned.
4+ years of wearing my thorogoods daily at work. At 3 years I got them re-soled. Leather is still going very strong. Change the insoles every 6 months-year.
I can never wear another boot after Thorogoods I absolutely love their crazyhorse leather
same
I've been wearing Thorogood for years now. I've had about 3-4 pair and they absolutely blow away any other boots I've worn for work. Most boots including a pair of Redwings I've owned only lasted 6-9 months. My longest wearing Thorogood lasted me 1 1/2 years.
I got 3 years of work and casual wear into mine, hoping they die soon so I can buy another pair 🤣
@@aaronmyer3474 this comment convinced me to look into them now.
I love mine. Owned for only six months but I love them. I tried on the Redwing, but I really felt like I was wearing clown shoes. No offense to anyone.
I've owned both. The Red Wing soles wore out quickly. The Thorogood leather was softer and the boots were far more comfortable. (I also prefer the Thorogood style too.) I had the Red Wing soles replaced with a Vibram wedge and the leather still looks great. I still wear the Red Wing pair around town but buy Thorogoods for work.
Been a fan of Thorogood's for 5 years. I bought a pair of RW when I was in a pinch for a waterproof boot in some bad weather S Dakota. I wore them for three months and now that pair sits in my closet. Don't normally need a WP boot in So Calif. Love the Thorogood boots. Comfortable. I have NOT experienced any construction issues with the boots but I have seen some have meltdowns. IBEW electrician who can put on a pair of Thorogood right out of the box and come home with no blisters. Comfortable.
I'm really impressed by how much you've learned since your early videos. These newer videos are factually correct and actually offer information and comparisons that aren't readily available else where. I'm glad you're here providing some quality content for the GYW community and boot/shoe enthusiasts in general. Subscribed!
Goodyear Welt?
And, they have a community?
@@gellotion yep, they have a pretty active subreddit
Thanks for the nice infos on boots,etc
Thanks it’s definitely been a learning process! I actually want to go back and redo some of the early boots now that I am more informed ha ha
I've worn both for extended periods and Thorogood wedge lasted wayyy longer. Never had any issues with leather and condition once every few months. Overall comfort was better and I really didn't like the toe box on the Red Wings. Bonus is Thorogoods are made in USA with union labor.
Redwings are the made in the US too?
@@thesig301 some are made in US, some are made overseas. They don't use union labor
@@1tssenunion = lazy workers
Man! Good review! I’m a union carpenter I have used both of these boots for several years. I love the redwing boots! The comfort for a boot is off the charts! However, the longevity is below par. They lasted me 6 months! The stitching on the toe box came apart, and the sole was gone! I’m talking slick gone! For 289$ that wasn’t going to fly with me. Thorogood moc toe lasted me 1yr. Stitching still in place, the leather on the toe box scuffed a bit but nothing extreme. The outsole was in the same condition as the redwings were but in a 1yr span not 6 months. I currently use thorogood 1957 series 6” moc toe tobacco. Their waterproof and a real good looking boot.
Redwings have a year warranty.
As a Union carpenter you should buy a Union made boot not a Asian made boot like redwings
@@andrewmendoza1578 red wing is not aisian made.
I’m a licensed electrician who does commercial work and industrial work. I’m on my feet the whole shift. I have always bought Thorogoods, and I love mine so much that I wear them even when I’m not at work. They work great for riding my HD.
Riding hd in thorogood. Man of a culture i see here 🥸
This video helped so much! I work in construction and I’m on my feet for up to 12 hours a day. I originally wanted Red Wings, but then I found out about Thorogood boots, and after this video I am for sure going with those over the Red Wing. Thank you!
This is just what I needed. I am a maintenance man. Meaning I work some days and sit on my bum on others. I put in about 10,000 steps on a shift. I want re-soleable boots. Thorogood look good but I'm going to pick up some RedWings this month then Thorogood early next year. I'll wear them a week on and a week off then give you feedback. Great channel!
Just bought my first pair of Redwings and I have to say I am kicking myself in the ass for not buying a pair sooner. The breaking in was a dream, I wore them 8-hours on day one with no blisters, and after a week I forget I even have them on. Awesome boot.
Hahaha from a man that never owned a true American union made boot. Thorogood smokes red wings
Added info: rubber-based outsoles are much less slippery on ice. Greetings from Norway
Do you know if they help with oil and water slippage? Thanks for info 👍
Yeah, nearly died at the grand canyon in my thorogoods, can confirm they're super slippery.
We need to make “Added info:” a mainstay in the comment sections
I own a 6yr old pair of Thorogoods and they’re pretty slippery. They don’t wear out much w/ even heavy work, but they are slippery on ice, water, and oil. Vibram christy soles are better than the poly based soles, imho
@@nofacedetected they aren’t hiking boots sir
When trying to find an American made work boot about 10 years ago, as soon as I tried on the thorogood I knew it was the one. They are very comfortable right out of the box. I work heavy construction and the Thorogood holds up great.
I agree. And the leather is absolutely beautiful. I paid $229.00 for mine
and they're still union made! love supporting good union jobs in America
Surely you’d need steel toe cap boots on site?
@@boredandagitated American made All the way! Union made go away. Labor Unions have outlived there usefulness and a controlled by the Democrats.
BTW. China is a Union also. China Communists Union.
@@carloshathcock5518 Union workers are some of the most skill tradesmen we have.
Good video! Spot on! Im a union carpenter
I’ve used both of these boots and your analysis is accurate. I personal was going back and forth with these 2 boots, and then thorogood came out with a waterproof boot called the 1957 series moc toe. I was really happy with these and then all of a sudden they stopped making a tobacco color way. So now I’m back going back and forth with the redwing classic moc toe and the thorogood standard moc toe. Thanks for the vid.
I own both and love both! 8 inch Thorogood Mocs are my personal pick
Do you own both in 8in versions? Which would you pick to work in all day?
@@whiteout130 thorogood for me
@@whiteout130 I've had both and liked the Thorogood more. Most people don't have time to break in a boot for a month. Thorogood you get 80% comfort out of the box and can fully break them in after a couple weeks. I like the 8" 814-3800
@@1tssen Appreciate the insight. I have been using Thorogoods for 2 years now. I go through a pair a year. By 8 months they're breaking down. 1 year they're toast. Usually wearing through the leather on my pinky toe side..
I might need a Wide verison come to think of it.. idk D with seems to fit well.
@@whiteout130 Thorogoods tend to run narrow. I wear a 2E width. At the end of the day it really depends on your working conditions. Any site that is extremely dirty or a lot of concrete will dry out the leather pretty fast so gotta condition more often.
Dude, I am out of breathe just watching you. But, I really like that you were consistent in your delivery and the popups to read summaries. Great video, well presented.
I oil my Redwings up before I start wearing them. Softens the leather for easier break in.
Thorogood all the way. Ive been through 3 pr of redwings and they were ok. I’ve just switched to Thorogood moc toe and they are so much more comfortable and have lasted just as long as the redwings. Im on my feet all day and use them for work.
Excellent comparison. I've owned and worn Red wing loggers (us made version) and while they last a long time , the first 2 months of working left me with calluses on my feet. Tried my first pair of Thorogoods last year and they were comfortable right from the start. Thick leather and hard wearing outsole along with US Union labor and I wont go back to Redwings with their blend of foreign made options.
I've had my Thorogoods now for 2 years with moderate use. I specifically wear the 814-3800 wedge sole, weatherproof, waterproof, steel toe arrangement. Mink oil once every 3-4months and prior to use in rain. I USE A REDWING IN SOLE FOR ARCH SUPPORT. Purchased one shoe size smaller and wore out to the bar a couple times for break in. Super comfortable... Thanks RoseAnvil forbthe awesome videos...
I bought the Thorogoods today. I was at a shop that sold Thorogoods ($169), Red Wings ($219) & Danners ($159); so I was able to try on and walk around in all three brands’ mock toe boots. All looked good, felt good and appear well built. All three were quite comfortable and I was splitting hairs on deciding. If I had been at a shop that only sold one brand, I probably could have left with any of these boots and been happy. In the end, to me, the Thorogoods fit slightly better, felt more comfortable from the start, and the leather was softer; all points Rose Anvil stated here. I have become use to using speed hooks on all of my other boots, so I liked that they are on the Thorogoods & Danners over the eyelets on the Red Wings. I do wish Thorogood would have used speed hooks all the way to the top instead of a top eyelet; it’s a little awkward having to stop speed lacing to the thread the top eyelet. The Thorogoods are a little taller, which I liked since I will be wearing these when I ride my motorcycle. All three boots are very nice and made in the USA; a tough decision.
I’ve always bought Danner’s for my work boot, but I bought my first pair of Thorogood boots a couple weeks ago. I purchased the 804-4375 and couldn’t be happier. Time will really tell, but I feel confidant these boots are true quality.
If you want a redwing moctoe with an insole, just get the 1907's
They are built on a different lady as well so they are more roomy
8883 as well
I love my 1907 Redwings. Well, after two years of getting them broke in properly.
What’s funny is I’m completely opposite to a lot of these comments. I’m a union electrician and have tried both pairs. I started off with Red Wings and after about a year their sole was wearing down so I turned them into my camping boots and got a pair of thorogoods. They lasted 8 months before my feet were in legit pain every day at work. I currently rock the 8in redwings with their leather insole. The thorogoods stitching was worn out in multiple spots…water easily seeped through. Really comfy boots…I just think as prices of both are increasing it’s worth a break in period so that I can resole my redwings for another year at least.
I’m watching this after trying both for my garden maintenance business. I work about 7 hours a day 5 days a week. Just basically walking no landscaping. I walk on cement, grass, rocks, gravel, mulch, dirt, wet grounds, etc. The red wings lasted me 5 months before I started slipping on hill grounds. The thorogoods lasted me 4 months. Both comfortable but for me it’s about who’s outsole will last longer for my work. And another month of income is huge for me. Redwings take the win for me
7 hours? I remember my first part time job.
@@kickyourfaceandlaugh607 yup. I average $100 an hour. I drive for about an hour going client to client. And have a 30min lunch. Good day
@@greenterracelandscape6264 you have to buy gas for your car, fuel your mowers, weed eaters, blowers, trailer maintenance, car insurance, and whatever other overhead you have. That’s not a lot buddy. Hope you can find more hours.
Lol. I forgot you’re my accountant. I use a 2007 colorado. Paid off. I pay $90 for car insurance. I use all electric tools. No trailer set up. I understand overhead. I’m a licensed landscaper in the Bay Area. I’m a father of 2. And my wife has her own bakery shop that’s thriving. We prioritize our kids and each other. Not Tom Brady here. You seem upset about something. Can’t figure it out. Great day.
Both are American made, but those thorogoods leather is just so soft and nice. I’m purchasing the thorogoods, plus the price is just a bit better also it’s a winner to me!!
How are they?
I ordered my new Thorogood's from Midwest Boots yesterday and got 30 bucks off!! I love me some Thorogood Boots!!
I have been working construction 6 plus years and started with Red Wings Irish Setters, switched over to Thorogoods a few years ago and by far Thorogoods are loooonger lasting in my opinion.
I just got a pair of Thorogoods and I am shocked at how comfortable they were day one. Hands down the most comfortable boots I’ve had so far and that’s saying a lot because I loved my “Cadillacs” & “Jungles” in the Marine Corps.
The redwings you are reviewing here are from their “heritage” line which is made more for fashion and walking around town, they also have a “work” line with a similar style (I believe it’s the 877 for heritage and 10877 for the work) I’d be curious to see the difference between the two. I’ve worn the 10877’s for years and they are quite possibly the best boot I’ve worn.
You can tell hes kindof a hipster
I have both..find i can wear the redwings all day no discomfort . Thorogood while comfy at first,cant wait to take them off after a days work at construction. Having said that , I love them both.
Bought Thoroughgoods for my job because I'm standing on factory concrete 9-12 hours a day - they're just plain comfortable as hell. Wore some RedWings when I was running a sawmill outdoors and they were great, but they just kill me on concrete. Gotta have that softness with the insole for that, in my experience.
I have worked construction 17 years (Ironworker) and tried both. Red wings wear out much faster than thorogoods the souls and stitching come apart on the reds, i can avg 2 years of hard use on thorogoods as long as you keep them oiled. Thats jus been my experience
My personal experience Thorogoods last longer than the Red Wings. Basically from wearing them everyday on a construction site. I've actually never had issues with the leather wearing out the soles are what wear out on me. I have never gotten them resoled though.
I use to be a hardcore Red Wing wearer until they started making over half their boots over seas. Then I switched to Thorogood and would never switch back.
@@shurdi3 Its jobsite specific. A majority of jobs you don't need a safety toe.
I've honestly have never been in a situation where a safety toe would have been beneficial.
Also in my experience steel toes do wear out quicker. I have had boots that have had the steel exposed through the leather. On none steel toed I've never had a hole in the leather of the toe.
Got my first pair of thorogoods, steel toe plain toe with normal sole not the wedge but 2 years of hard use they're still holding up perfect and way more comfortable than my iron rangers ever could be, and people have asked me about and complimented the thorogoods but no one's ever said a word about the red wings. $100+ cheaper too and it's a no brainer if you actually work in your boots. IDK if I'll bother resoling them when they wear out since they're so affordable anyway, I've more than gotten my money's worth vs buying timberlands or wolverine work boots like I was before that never lasted more than a year.
Thorogoods definitely last longer and hold up to a lot of abuse. I've tried the Red Wing waterproof moc toe and wedge only lasted 6 months untill the heal was totally worn out. They also leaked water pretty bad. I wear the Thorogood 814-3800 now for almost a year and they are amazing, never had a drop of water inside and wedge is in still pretty decent shape, I can probably go another year before resole. I think they look better too
The redwing dynaforece 4215 have worked well for me. If you use steel toes you should put a toe protector on like tuff toe
It sounds like from reading through the comments that the thorogoods last longer on the worksite
I work in a cnc mold shop , I step on coolant and oil and hot metal chips all day .
My thorogood boots have lasted 3 years and still going.
I am going to get them resoled soon
Still rocking the thorogoods
Love them
One of the best comparison video I've ever seen
I’ve owed both, I wear Thorogoods exclusively for work and play. I actually find the Steeltoe’s more comfortable than not.
I've been wearing the same pair of 814-4200 Thorogood boots for years now. I've never owned RW's but can't imagine why I'd entertain the thought of switching away from the T-Goods. They're everything I want in a boot,and the comfort is top shelf.
I have enjoyed Moctober and I like the themed programs. I am looking forward to the winter boot series.
I also have to say the quality of your show has significantly improved over time. Your confidence in front of the camera has also gone up and has really improved your show. Keep up the great work.
Lol redwing a casual boot? Before hipsters started wearing them to the coffee shop, Red wings were the standard work boot
They are a cheap imported boot for the vast majority of their line and the USA boots are made with imported materials
@@banjobones8075 Yes they are, nearly 90% of their boots are made in China. only a small handful are made here with global materials
They are casual high quality work boots. They are casual because with simple search of work boot. Timberland and redwings will be the first to show up In the "high" end. Take that with grain of salt. You don't here thorogood or whites often. Only from an experienced worker who buys work boots on the regular.
Been making America great again for 25 years in a factory wearing Red Wings. I'm going to try the Thorogoods this year, but it will be a smooth toe. Moc toes are for beatnik posers, I run footpedals most days- the extra seam is a weak link. Not so sure about the wedge sole just yet. We shall see👀
@@zack9912000 exactly which boot did you buy?
The Red Wing has the leather footbed, which molds to the shape of your foot after a month or two rather than having a foam padded insole. Over time the leather insole, once molded, fits more like a glove, which translates into comfort when paired with the softer crepe insole.
People that have been wearing boots for years know the difference. synthetics are what they are plastic just like the welt on the thoroughbreds.
The format and speed of this video is outstanding. Thank you!!!!!
Based on my experience with using Redwings and Thorogoods in the construction industry my Thorogoods lasted longer. The Thorogoods I kept for yard work have been resoled 3 times so far.
I wore redwings for 10 years. I switched over to Thorogoods 6 years ago. Union and American made and very comfortable. I think they look better as well.
Since watch this awhile back, I've bought both these boots. First the redwings. They killed me for about 2 weeks, meanwhile I got the thorogood. I wear those to work everyday now. And my redwings are my nice boots. The redwings took forever to break in, but I like them more. They won't be work boots for probably another year. Great comparison here
I've been wearing my Thorogood 804-4208s for about a year and a half, and I absolutely love them. Best boots I've ever had. All of my previous Redwing and Irish Setter boots (not moc toes) have had to be replaced yearly. I'm about to buy a second pair of 8" Thorogoods in a soft toe for casual wear/ riding as my steel toes aren't the best looking after all the hydraulic oils, rusty water, mud, stamping sludge and so on and they don't fit under my shifter easily. That said, they are still the most durable work boots I've owned to date and will be here for a long time.
I use power step inserts... game changer for me. I haven't said "My dogs are barking" while pulling off my boots in the locker room in probably 2+ years. They're about 60 bucks and you'll thank me for sure
Great video and you are 100% correct on most accounts. I've been buying Redwings for years and love them. They are more costly, do take a bit of time to break in and I wear the soles out way before the shoe itself. However, it almost costs as much to resole them as buying a new pair. I get the 2416 power linemans boots and they do have the speed hooks.
I'm on Keto, thanks for the Sponsor info, I haven't eaten cereal in over a year and a half. Gonna give Magic Spoon a Shot. Thanks again 👊
Redwing soles wear out faster than any of my high end work boots, re-soling extremely expensive. A point to consider.
I am 65 and only work around my yard on weekends, had the same redwings but after a year my feet hurt at the end of the day. The boots where given away and I got the thorogoods,wearing them 3yrs now and they are great. Only wear them 2 days a week so I think they will last the rest of my life lol.
Had my Thorogood's for the last two years and I love them...one of the most favorite pairs of boots I have ever owned.
When I use to do roofing, a lot of guys I worked with loved the Thorogood boots-mainly comfort and they held up well although any boot no matter how thick doesnt last long before needing to repair the boot. Great info on the video!
thye did that becasue the price of the boots would rise dramtically.
As a mechanic our boots only last about 1 year. I wore Dannier for 15 years. I tried Red wings and they are the most comfortable boots I have worn. Only problem is they last about 6 months.
I bought a pair of the thorogoods with a black soul instead of the white because I hate white souled boots, and I am super happy with the thorogoods. The only thing I will change when I get them resouled is the welt. I'll probably change it out with a leather storm welt for more durability. Other then that, they are an awesome pair of boots!
I'm a foodservice truck driver. I deliver to most of the fast food chains that most people eat at with a focus on pizzerias and Italian restaurants. I put in about 10-12 miles of walking (more like pushing a dolly with a few hundred pounds from outside to inside of the restaurants and walking back and forth in a 48' trailer building/rebuilding pallets.
Work boots last 6-8 months before they're done. Totally bald, glue coming apart near the toe box (extra toe guard on various redwing styles) or the outsole ripping apart from one end to the other.
Thorogood boots. By far. Are the most comfortable boot I've ever used. I can put in a 10-12 hour workday and when I get home and the wife wants to go for a walk I leave my thorogoods on because they're better than any of my 'walking shoes'. I start at 1-3am in the morning. Small crowded parking lots and big rigs don't mix.
Wedge boots have really bad slip resistance though. Redwing & Thorogood. They kind of suck on greasy tile floors.
Redwing Heritage boots/Moc Toe are good for one thing: Fashion. That's it. I can't imagine them ever being a work boot.
Thorogood boots are good at being comfortable day 1. Re-sole them once maybe twice if the shank and support is still there. Good for being on your feet all day on cement. Good for landscaping. Good for plumbing. Steel toe versions are heavy, but still incredibly comfortable.
Thanks for the review. I have the thorougoods Saftey toe and love them. Less than a hour break in time and just as comfortable as ever. I walk 10,000 to 20000 steps a day at work all on concrete and no issues at all. My feet feel the best they have in years and I only switched boot brands the work load is the same. I will say I have never tried the RW”s but guys and girls at work say they are just as comfortable after a few week break in if you feet can handle it.
Thanks for making this. It’s EXACTLY what I needed to know!
Hands down , thorogoods are the best , most comfortable mock boot !
I prefer redwing i resole
3 to 4 times they fit
Custom to your foot
After they break in
Fantastic feel with wear
I’ll probably grab a Thorogood moc for work, hopefully the sole helps with my lower back pain. I love Red Wing but I want something that I can just throw on and not have to break in.
I work for the Railroad in the track Department. I’ve been wearing the Thorogood model# 4375 for roughly 5 years now with 1 complete restoration in that time frame. Very comfortable boot that takes little to no time for break in in my case. I’m constantly on ballast, mud, sand, and getting hydraulic fluid on them. I even thermite welded a year in them where it was common to see them near extreme heat all the time. I’ve been on my feet for 24+ hrs many times and my feet feel fine in these. The cons are I do have to treat them for waterproofing once a month or my feet will get wet, this model isn’t waterproof and the elements I work in are really hard on leather. Definitely get the EE if you want to wear extra socks because they run tight. I’m in the Deep South so it’s not an issue for me personally. I’ll never wear a different boot and would highly recommend them.
Hey man Roll Tide! Just bought my first pair of Thorgoods to do construction here in Alabama. Also I do waterproofing so my boots will be exposed to that element quite often. What’s your waterproofing application to your boots?
Ready for Bryce Young to shine this year! Take care.
Do you wear them all the live long day ?
A great comparison of the two, I really appreciate the work that you put into these to help people out to make a better decision on their purchases!
Took a huge gamble watching this video AFTER dropping 3 bills on a pair of 8" steel-toe Thorogoods, but I just couldn't help myself.
Glad I watched though. Awesome breakdown, and now I feel even better with my choice, as I plan to used these for work :-)
Had a pair of RedWings that absolutely destroyed the skin on my heels. Planning on going with thorogoods next.
Thorough Good boots are the best I’ve ever worn and I’m going on wearing them a year and a half. They’ve been through tons of concrete and 100s miles of walking on asphalt. I will only buy them going forward.
I bought a pair of work shoes from Red Wing and I bought a real comfy insole. It was leather over foam but they are nice. I've had foot problems, foot surgery and walking can suck so I'm all in for the tumble leather the Thorogoods offer..good review, I don't think seen you take a single breath during your presentation!
Have you worn these boots. I wore this exact redwing for years and I’ve been wearing thorogoods exclusively for the last 5. Thorogoods are miles better then redwing. You should wear these boots and work in them before saying which is better.
Which is his conclusion as well - wo wearing them ;)
Exactly. I’ve had Timberlands, Danner, Ariat, and Thurogoods. Multiple pairs of boots across 20 years of the hardest construction in America, foundation repair. Red wings are EXTREMELY overrated. Didn’t last 3 months. Ariat slip on are comfortable, but last about 6 months. Danner are a great boot that mix comfort and durability that can last 1-2 years with care. Timberland mid high hiking boots are the best bang for your buck. Lasting as long as top tier brands but at a much lower cost. Thorogoods are the most comfortable thing I’ve ever put on my feet. Consider your boots a tool, don’t skimp out on your feet. When your a real labor worker, fatigue and endurance can be easily manipulated by the boots you wear. (And socks, I like Duluth)
@@joeedwards1682 I just picked up some red wings. My job destroys boots (my wolverines which are $200 boots are destroyed after 10 months with the toes completely ripped off) so I decided to finally try something higher quality. I got this covering from the red wing store to protect the toes as I crawl but I don't know how they hold up since I just got the boots on Friday. Any recommendations? If these hold up I'll be happy to buy more. I got the insolated dynaforce steel toe with waterproofing as I work outside and get wet frequently. $330 with the fancy covering
Have work both red wing 2408 and for the past 2 years have work the 8 inch moc toe 4208 thorogoods . Does anyone have issue I am having . Recently my thorogoods have gotten soaken wet I let them air dry but now the leather on the outside smells so bad to the point where I can’t even wear them inside of the boot smells fine but the outside it’s terrible
I just wanted to thank you for all the info on your channel. Thanks to this, I got some Thorogoods and really learned a lot about quality work boots.
Without it, I would honestly have bought some cheap Carhart boots on name, thinking they were just as good as anything else out there.
Now I feel like I own some kit that I can really depend on and buying USA does feel good too!
thanks!
I regret selling my Thorogood Moc Toes. I was about to buy another pair, but realized they doubled in price! I bought the 8” Moc Toe boots for $130 in 2012.
Ive had them both and while both are great boots and after having worn them both for years i honestly believe they will both realistically last the same amount of time with resoles but you get this longevity and durability at less sacrifice of price and comfort with the thorogood. Great great boot and just more practical.
Owning both, that description at 5:15 was spot-on man!
Same, feels good.
Thorogood ALL DAY!
I've had mine for 3 years with zero issues. At all
As a single guy who is embarrassed to sometimes buy frosted flakes, I may give that cereal a go. :) Also, in my head, toaster is off camera with a watch on constantly tapping it and glaring at you.
I shopped around and searched the web looking for a MOC in size 13 EE. I bought the red wing 405 . this is my 3rd pair of red wing boots and my first non steel toe pair. I love the feel of the leather and the fit, they are little stiff but will adjust overtime.
Love your videos, very informative. I actually bought a pair of boots based on your knowledge. The one thing I noticed you don't mention a lot is Waterproof. Waterproof to me is very important when purchasing a good pair of boots. Again nice videos.
Ive worn redwing work boots for years and with the impression that they are made in america like they advertise. While shopping in a red wing store the sales person said only 1 boot was made in america and all the rest made over seas. since that day Ive being buying Throrogood which are mad int the good Ol USA!
Both my work boots and heritage moc toe are made in USA
I own both a tobacco pair of thorogoods and a black pair of redwings and having worn both a lot and both are significantly broken in, I will say comfort wise the thorogoods are hands down the winner. Plus the speed hooks are so much more convenient, so much so that I often find myself actively avoiding wearing my redwings because they are such a hassle to put on. Like, I literally have to entirely loosen the laces all the way down and unthread the top two eyelets in order to shove my foot in, not to mention the redwings don't have a little pull loop thing. You can also usually find thorogoods on crazy good sales, especially on dvor, redwings not so much. My iron rangers on the other hand are perfection. I'd recommend getting a pair of thorogood mocs and a pair of redwing iron rangers and call it a day.
For anyone with contact dermatitis . I've worn many different boots through the years & every one of them has caused me dermatitis except the Thorogood moc toe . Any interior fake materials cause me a huge rash . I got the Carhartt loggers years ago & those made the flare ups the worst .
I love Thorogoods, have 3 pairs and they are my go-to boot. That said, you still have to break them in a little. All boots have some sort of break in.
I have found that the Thorogoods bleed (the color of the leather dye) onto my socks during break in, all of them have done that. I work construction (15+ years now & countless pairs of boots) so they are just work socks but I haven’t heard anyone else mention this happening to them too. Brown/ tan or black, happened on all 3 pairs.
Once broken though, they’ve been more comfortable than most of my regular shoes.
Neither here nor there but I've been wearing steel to work boots for the better part of 30 years and I will say you get what you pay for but do your research!! I've worn both, as well as Danner, Nick's, and some lesser quality (less expensive) boots but I will say a quality boot with leather and/or cork insoles are WAY more comfortable than all the wonder foam, super polymer, etc shoes let alone boots... Aside from weight of course. I'm just happy that some companies still abide by form over function and wish other companies (especially in different fields) would take heed.
Definitely thorogood will be your best choice.
Extremely comfortable compared to redwings. I had to change the bottoms before they even got confortable. On the other side, thorogood took no more than two week to feel so good. I walk on concrete every day at work, the soles still in great conditions. Don’t waste your money, don’t buy redwings. My good advice. 👍🏼
I got thorogoods I’ve had them about 9 months and I’ve wore them all year around and they are great I love them so much definitely will buy again
I put thorogood inserts in my Jim green razorbacks and they are so much better now. Just got a pair of thorogood 804 4200s and am very happy with them.
Love my redwing 4499. Fit perfect right out of the box. I've had them for about 2 years now with no issues
I just recently found your channel while looking for solid work boots and your content along with information is amazing. If you could make a video on the best steel toed boots that would be awesome.
Love the content, watched a lot of theses moc toe videos you have done learn something every time. Im in the restaurant industry and the slip resistance is never talked about when it comes to the sole. Show some love to the burger flipping drink slingers wearing good boots. After a10 hour day on your feet on wet tile I appreciate the segments on comfort it pays to do the research on a good pair so thanks for making my life a ;little easier
Great review, I’m personally over Redwings as Brooklyn hipsters glommed onto them quite some time ago, Its cool to look like you actually work.
I think an aspect that we might be wondering about is water. How do they both compare keeping feet dry in water/snow? I don’t see you mention that in tests.
when buying boots my purchase points are Protection, Comfort, keep feet dry, and so on down the line.
I have redwing wingshooters but damn,those thorogoods look awesome!
Ok, I’m a union sprinkler fitter putting up schedule 40 6” all the time. If you don’t know that is-look it up. I’m on ladders, lifts, cat walks. You name it. I do only industrial and commercial. I wore red wings for ten years, then I found thorogoods. Red wing soles last 6 months tops and then it costs a pretty Penney to resole them. My thorogoods lasted over 2 years before I had to resole them and when I did bought two extra pairs. The ankle support is phenomenal with the waterproof models and I’ll never buy another pair of red wings as kind as I live, although maybe a pair of Irish setter steel toe slip one. That’s another thing, all my boots are steel toe.
I ordered both, and I really wanted to keep the red wings but my wife hated them lol. I needed black and thorogood had black on black soles. Thorogood was definitely more comfy out of the box but the wings were better made.
My union rep got into a fight with the red wing supplier so we kinda had to switch to thorogood to get a deal.. but after my third pair of high hour welding abuse over the last 7 years the thorogoods have actually lasted longer and been more comfortable, I never can make it to a resole anyways because of toe dragging on grating crawling around but I would recommend them to anyone over redwings having the two brands being my only boots over ten years (besides a pair of caterpillar boots that were horrifyingly bad and got trashed within a couple months)
I’ve had a pair of thorogood moc toe boots I wear as casual shoes. They’ve lasted 4 years plus. Just throwing that out there.
Awesome job on summing all that up! Quick concise and easy to remember and understand. Awesome video keep it up!
I wear the 8" thorogood with steel toe. Fantastic boots. Work maintenance and usually get 2 years out of a pair. Wear the toes out before the souls. First factory was a bakery, dry environment, boots were great. Current factory is a cannery, wet environment, boots not so great. Getting wet regularly I had the welt fail, that was the boots I transitioned jobs in so had a year on them. Current boots had stitching come apart under the lacing area behind my big toe. Never had that style of Redwing but I shy away from stiff boots. Hate spending 2 weeks with sore feet/legs while they break in. Spend 8hrs on my feet on concrete, thorogoods super comfortable right out the box.
I feel like I fall with a majority of the comments. I have both, and have owned and worn redwings for the last 10 years. The last 3 of which I have worn my Thorogood Mocs for work, and now for casual wear as well. Despite the Oro leather being higher quality, the boot just doesn’t cut it as a true work boot. It’s also no the most comfortable for long hours on your feet. Other than the heritage line, redwing has a lot of overseas production and overseas parts assembled in USA. USA union made Thorogood was my choice as a union worker myself. More comfortable and more durable at a better price point. Don’t get me wrong I love my redwing 877’s but you’ll never catch me wearing them on the job.