Great ranking as usual. Looking forward to the GOTY version. Rainbow Unicorn Cat 1 is posting a video this coming Wednesday about ALL of the clues that Kirsten really is coming back this year. Looking forward to seeing what she found.
I did the bias sorter and here’s how my ranking turned out: 20. Isabel 19. Julie 18. Courtney 17. Nicki 16. Samantha 15. Marie-Grace 14. Maryellen 13. Kit 12. Josefina 11. Cecile 10. Rebecca 9. Nanea 8. Molly 7. Kirsten 6. Felicity 5. Claudie 4.Addy 3.Caroline 2. Melody 1. Kaya This turned out very differently than I thought it would. I loved the video, it was really interesting.
@@ilovekittens9987 i do too i wana fix my kayas hair i took her braids out when I was younger and i wanna fix her hair and i don't wanna send her to the Doll hospital because my Kayla is an older kaya. I wanna try using a straightener or something to fix her her hair up
Did you know that a lot of Rebecca’s clothing and bed is very similar to Samantha for example, her coat hat and mouth is completely similar to Samantha, including her bed
My Caroline does that too! Every doll I put her near falls over, even if she didn't fall over herself! I have tried to put her in a display with my other 1800's dolls so many times, but then when they're all lined up, of course, my Caroline starts the domino effect. Why does this happen?🤷♀🤣
My list would be Samantha, Felicity, Molly, and Kirsten. These were the dolls avail when I got my first (and only doll) Samantha. The others I don’t really know much about.
We have slot of parallel rankings many for the same reasons. I unfortunately don't have all historical dolls, but have handled, cleaned and repaired a lot when I was volunteering at a thriftstore.
20 Julie (Can't bond, and have fixed many) 19. Courtney (no fan of clothes) 18. Isabel (I think they should be reversed) 17. Nicki (ditto) 16. Kit 15. Molly (PC rescue so different wig) 14. Caroline (not for the going price, and yes she toppled other dolls at the store) 13. Josefina (needs more things) 12. Samantha (I have two rescues) 11. Rebecca (rescue I restored) 10. Melody (on my get list) 9. Cecile Rae (Its the curls, I paid 140) 8. Marie-Grace 7. MaryEllen (on my get list, my aunt had polio) 6. Felicity (surprise rescue) 5. Nanea 4. Addy (PC in box spelling bee that I unboxed.) 3. Claudie (on my get list) 2. Kaya (PC A friend sold her to me) 1. Kirsten (PC dire rescue I love to bits but is redone, I will buy a new one if they bring her back)
My top favorite historical is Samantha because she was my 2nd doll,then i love Kirsten and kit alot too i need to see about trying to flat iron my kaya doll hair she's a older kaya and i need her order her meet dress or get one of her other outfits to put her in.
@@americangirlbliss thanks for the tip my kaya along with my other AG dolls have been in storage for a while. I'll ask my mom to see if she'll let me iron and boil wash kaya hair when she gets out of storage
Lovely, lovely, lovely; I cannot say which is the best, as I like indiscriminately all of them; I have, in order of purchase: Rebecca, Samantha, Molly and Nanea which I madly love. Although I prefer the historical characters, I acknowledge that even the last girls of the year (Corinne, Kavi and Lila) are adorable; I like very much Joss and Kira too; There is only one A.G. doll which I don't like: it is the 50's Barbie inspired one.
I loved this video! I would say my top three historical dolls are Kaya, kit and felicity (not in any order I honestly love them all equally for different reasons)
Josefina and Addy need movies. And Kristen too. They are the only three of the original six that didn't get one.
Kirsten needs a comeback and a movie
Yes! She is coming back this summer! Her movie would be so depressing though lol...
@@americangirlbliss the first part of her meet book yes it was very sad when her best friend got sick and died on the journey to America.
Awesome video! Fun list and great reasoning! Small correction, Addy was first with earrings, not Josefina…
I love your videos so much. I love Kirsten too, she has a special place in my heart. my dream doll I don't own yet is Josefina 💖
I like Samantha, Kirsten, Felicity’s collection and outfits best
My name is Piper and my mom’s name is Alison and we like your channel!
Kerstin, was my first one, then Samantha, love them both ❤
Great ranking as usual. Looking forward to the GOTY version. Rainbow Unicorn Cat 1 is posting a video this coming Wednesday about ALL of the clues that Kirsten really is coming back this year. Looking forward to seeing what she found.
This video was absolutely needed today🤗
Love your list! The stories were adorable ❤
I did the bias sorter and here’s how my ranking turned out:
20. Isabel
19. Julie
18. Courtney
17. Nicki
16. Samantha
15. Marie-Grace
14. Maryellen
13. Kit
12. Josefina
11. Cecile
10. Rebecca
9. Nanea
8. Molly
7. Kirsten
6. Felicity
5. Claudie
4.Addy
3.Caroline
2. Melody
1. Kaya
This turned out very differently than I thought it would. I loved the video, it was really interesting.
Awlsome Ranking of your favorite
@@tinmanlover1994 I love Kaya! She just has the best thought out story and collection.
@@ilovekittens9987 i do too i wana fix my kayas hair i took her braids out when I was younger and i wanna fix her hair and i don't wanna send her to the Doll hospital because my Kayla is an older kaya. I wanna try using a straightener or something to fix her her hair up
Did you know that a lot of Rebecca’s clothing and bed is very similar to Samantha for example, her coat hat and mouth is completely similar to Samantha, including her bed
My Caroline does that too! Every doll I put her near falls over, even if she didn't fall over herself! I have tried to put her in a display with my other 1800's dolls so many times, but then when they're all lined up, of course, my Caroline starts the domino effect. Why does this happen?🤷♀🤣
My list would be Samantha, Felicity, Molly, and Kirsten. These were the dolls avail when I got my first (and only doll) Samantha. The others I don’t really know much about.
My Maryellen(Juniper) has full bangs and she looks amazing
I have alot of doll's with supper curly hair and I don't do anything with because of the super curly hair along
We have slot of parallel rankings many for the same reasons. I unfortunately don't have all historical dolls, but have handled, cleaned and repaired a lot when I was volunteering at a thriftstore.
20 Julie (Can't bond, and have fixed many)
19. Courtney (no fan of clothes)
18. Isabel (I think they should be reversed)
17. Nicki (ditto)
16. Kit
15. Molly (PC rescue so different wig)
14. Caroline (not for the going price, and yes she toppled other dolls at the store)
13. Josefina (needs more things)
12. Samantha (I have two rescues)
11. Rebecca (rescue I restored)
10. Melody (on my get list)
9. Cecile Rae (Its the curls, I paid 140)
8. Marie-Grace
7. MaryEllen (on my get list, my aunt had polio)
6. Felicity (surprise rescue)
5. Nanea
4. Addy (PC in box spelling bee that I unboxed.)
3. Claudie (on my get list)
2. Kaya (PC A friend sold her to me)
1. Kirsten (PC dire rescue I love to bits but is redone, I will buy a new one if they bring her back)
Claudie and Corrine are my two "must haves"
The courtney hair is why I don’t want to purchase the dolls with the curly hair!
I agree with you on your twins ranking because they just came out.
My top favorite historical is Samantha because she was my 2nd doll,then i love Kirsten and kit alot too i need to see about trying to flat iron my kaya doll hair she's a older kaya and i need her order her meet dress or get one of her other outfits to put her in.
You should flat Iron your Kaya's hair first, then braid & boil wash them in the braids! She would look so pretty with curly hair.
@@americangirlbliss thanks for the tip my kaya along with my other AG dolls have been in storage for a while. I'll ask my mom to see if she'll let me iron and boil wash kaya hair when she gets out of storage
I think American Girl is going to be releasing Historical kit
They are! It was just now confirmed at the Mattel meeting for 2023!
@@americangirlbliss how can i watch the Mattel meeting thing is it only UA-cam
@@tinmanlover1994 No, I don't think so. I found out from a source called American Girl News who has inside information.
@@americangirlbliss thanks i can't wait for kit to be rereleased in her original history outfit
If Julie's Beforever meet outfit has no haters I am dead
You should do a Best Friends one 😉.
American Girl has a historical Molly she's $115 vs the higher 3rd party price of a 35th anniversary Molly
Can you rank the truly mes?
Yes!!! Kirsten!!! ❤️ I just found mine and LOVE her.
Didn’t she have her Native American best friend? I thought you could buy her.
Samantha better be #1
I don't get how people don't like blonde haired blue eyed classic mold dolls. I think they are really pretty, nothing is wrong with them.
nothing wrong with them but it’s just the abundance of them- it can feel like a lack of creativity
I forget, don’t you make wigs yourself cause I love your channel, and I have a disability myself
Lovely, lovely, lovely; I cannot say which is the best, as I like indiscriminately all of them; I have, in order of purchase: Rebecca, Samantha, Molly and Nanea which I madly love. Although I prefer the historical characters, I acknowledge that even the last girls of the year (Corinne, Kavi and Lila) are adorable; I like very much Joss and Kira too; There is only one A.G. doll which I don't like: it is the 50's Barbie inspired one.
I loveee Julie
I never got into the american girls my first one was bitty baby then later on the bitty twins
nice
What sorter do you use?
Awlsome Ranking of historical's doll's have you considered sending Courtney to the Doll hospital for a new Head? That way you'll enjoy Courtney more.
Oh no I love her hair the way I restyled it
@@kylacollects cool that's good you need to do a video on her hair too show how you got her hair restyled
I loved this video! I would say my top three historical dolls are Kaya, kit and felicity (not in any order I honestly love them all equally for different reasons)
But I would love to have one! Is Rebecca considered historical?
Yes Rebecca is from 1914
very nice
I don’t have a historical doll
Samantha Molly Kit Kristen Addy Kaya Josefina Felicity