I wouldn’t trade Dobson or Barzal for Petterson. It’s it that I don’t think that Petterson isn’t a good player it’s that I can just picture myself screaming at the tv for him to do something for that $11.6m. I know he’s having a down year but he’s just not worth that kind of money. He doesn’t drive play.
At this point as a Vancouver fan I’d gladly do Miller for Horvat. We could even throw Raty on top to sweeten the deal. lol But Horvat will never waive to go back to a management team who turned him away… I think the management team in Vancouver has to go after this fiasco.
I wouldn’t even trade Horvat for Petterson never mind Miller. At least Miller is worth his contact. Sure Petterson is more talented than Horvat but he also costs $3.1 m per season more.
No way we can spend that much for someone who has won nothing. Why bring on a player from a dysfunctional team? If we’re paying anyone over $10 million… they need to have a ring. Bo, Kyle, JG… all came from not good franchises. Time to add some Cup Culture outside of management.
Agreed. Barzal wouldn't be the player I'd want to trade either, but I feel the two are our only true bargaining chips in a deal that could land Pettersson.
Do not trade for Elias Peterson. I'd rather swap Dobson for some other young package from them. Seriously, Nelson and Eiserman have great chemistry as seen in WJr Championship. We could conceivably trade Nelson to the Avs for Calum Ritchie. And We could if we keep losing be in running for Scheaffer. If we trade Nelson to MN we could ask for Zev Buium which would be awesome. Peterson seems like Yashin to me - inconsistent and moody. We could be very young and dynamic with these kids. I'd rather go this route. I want nothing to do Peterson or Miller. Hughes is a different story, I just don't want to give up the youth we could potentially have and build around.
@jamiepike6909 NY Islanders scouting dept is one of the worst in the league. Dacolle,bellows, Wahlstrom, wilde,jhs, dufour,maggiore Durand. To rebuild our scouting dept we need 16 months. Hence the need for young and established players
No trading nelson.no way. We need eisernan and nelson big time!. I would send dobson,Brock nelson,and palms with a second rs pick for Petterson and boeser.
I wouldn’t trade Dobson or Barzal for Petterson. It’s it that I don’t think that Petterson isn’t a good player it’s that I can just picture myself screaming at the tv for him to do something for that $11.6m. I know he’s having a down year but he’s just not worth that kind of money. He doesn’t drive play.
If the Islanders decide to trade Dobson, they should call me. I am available to drive him to the airport.
I think a move on Pettersson would be based solely on a conversation between Lou and Horvath. I can't imagine any would know EP40 better than Bo.
There is no cap space. Send Dobson, Nelson and a pick (not 1st rd).
Dobson will not be traded while injured. So the opportunity to trade him this year is pretty much gone.
@skiinggator we don't even know what the injury is. A team that is about to blow up the locker room may just want Dobson for next year anyway.
Dobson and a first with Nelson for Petterson and Hughes. One can dream I suppose.
At this point as a Vancouver fan I’d gladly do Miller for Horvat. We could even throw Raty on top to sweeten the deal. lol But Horvat will never waive to go back to a management team who turned him away… I think the management team in Vancouver has to go after this fiasco.
I wouldn’t even trade Horvat for Petterson never mind Miller. At least Miller is worth his contact. Sure Petterson is more talented than Horvat but he also costs $3.1 m per season more.
Islanders are not trading Barzal.
No way we can spend that much for someone who has won nothing. Why bring on a player from a dysfunctional team? If we’re paying anyone over $10 million… they need to have a ring. Bo, Kyle, JG… all came from not good franchises. Time to add some Cup Culture outside of management.
Is that an 80's AI generated Ken Morrow? 😯
dobson shouldbe traded in a deal for petterson mabey ad some other forawrd and a pick but not barzal
Agreed. Barzal wouldn't be the player I'd want to trade either, but I feel the two are our only true bargaining chips in a deal that could land Pettersson.
@@uptheturnpike- Dobson is injured. He's not getting traded until he's healthy again. Which means off-season.
Ill do Barzal, Dobson, Nelson 50% retained, Pageau 50% retained for Pettersson, Hronek, Hoglander, 1st 2025, a bit of OEL cap hit
Do not trade for Elias Peterson. I'd rather swap Dobson for some other young package from them.
Seriously, Nelson and Eiserman have great chemistry as seen in WJr Championship. We could conceivably trade Nelson to the Avs for Calum Ritchie. And We could if we keep losing be in running for Scheaffer.
If we trade Nelson to MN we could ask for Zev Buium which would be awesome. Peterson seems like Yashin to me - inconsistent and moody.
We could be very young and dynamic with these kids. I'd rather go this route. I want nothing to do Peterson or Miller. Hughes is a different story, I just don't want to give up the youth we could potentially have and build around.
I just dont see it happening
Getting worse for us as well as we seem to can’t loose of late 🤦🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
We went from losing to never losing again. Wild!
Buyer beware Elias Petterson
Isles fans don't need or want him. Y'all gotta look at Isles CAP it's not good
You think so? I get his skating has taken a hit this year, is that the concern Joe?
@uptheturnpike he disappeared in playoffs vs Oilers last year. Soft player. Not Islander material
@@lilacjoeThey’d do better with Miller.
@@LeonExile05 @uptheturnpike Isles cap is to the limit. Need to offload #29 #21 and more
I don’t want JT because he’s too old for what we need and EP could be the problem at Vancouver and he’s earning too much. Just my view.
Bo Horvarth indicated in an interview in so, many words that the problem is JT
@ fair enough, but I still think the wages are a problem. We need prospects and picks.
@jamiepike6909 NY Islanders scouting dept is one of the worst in the league. Dacolle,bellows, Wahlstrom, wilde,jhs, dufour,maggiore Durand. To rebuild our scouting dept we need 16 months. Hence the need for young and established players
@ not disagreeing, but EP is addition by subtraction and also hogging your cap.
@jamiepike6909 Well when the ship be sinking you can't get too picky
Dobson, Danny Nelson, our 1st round 2025 pick, plus one (Kyle MacLean, or Pierre Engvall or ? someone else).
No trading nelson.no way. We need eisernan and nelson big time!. I would send dobson,Brock nelson,and palms with a second rs pick for Petterson and boeser.
first ahahahahahaha
I'd trade Dobson in a second.