These tests are not scientific at all. This video was made strictly for fun. Both of these are great and very fun to shoot. For the 25 yard accuracy test with the MP5, I pulled high left a few times. That was 100% on me and not the gun's fault. Thank you for watching.
ahh you pulled high left with the mp5, hummm i already thought THATS ALMOST NOT POSSIBLE SO FAR LEFT AT 25 YARD. because i own a mp5 and its accuracy is very very good. but i understand that its just for fun. GREAT VIDEO BTW. AND I MUST SAY THE SOUND OF THE PS90 IS REALY AWESOME. GREETS CHARLY FROM THE NETHERLANDS.
A Stargate special episode? The accuracy on the PS90 is very nice, I think both are excellent weapons and it is a shame the P90 didn't really take off as it is a very forward thinking design. The MP5 is certainly a tried and true gun that has been nigh impossible to supplant in its class. Difficult choice but 50 rounds of armour piercing ammo with a shorter overall length (with the short barrel) is something you can't get anywhere else.
Oh I loove the MP5-SD, you gotta say tho that its the supressed version and thus a little heavier. Maybe a comparison between the unsupressed MP5 and P90 would make more sense but tbh idc :D Lovely guns, lovely video. Two of my all time favorites
I do want to make one note. The MP5 fell out of favor due to difficulties penetrating body armor. The P90 has the ability to go through an engine block in one mag. I love both SMG's but I figured I'd let it be known.
Wait what? There's no way the 5.7 is doing anything to an engine block, where did you see that demonstrated? 5.56 round and 7.62 rounds can't even go through an engine block. Is this one of those A.I. bot accounts?
@Shademastermcc it's something I've heard about. I think it has a lot to do with velocity of round which plays a huge part in damage, and size with structural integrity (small, well structured, high velocity rounds work best in penetration i believe). I will say I haven't seen it tho, so it could be just word of mouth to word of mouth
Both are nice, it’s a shame that 5.7 is price-gouged so much; certain ballistic performance along with price is why the 9mm edges out the 5.7 in my eyes, that’s just me.
I'll take the MP5 over the PS90 simply because I've been that good with one since I was active duty Marine Corps. I noticed you have some sort of optic on the PS90 where you do not on the MP5. I also noticed you compared it with the naturally heavier integrally suppressed MP5SD also with heavier straight mags and NOT the lighter MP5 which would have lighter mags as well. I don't get anything out of cola devastation. And also, if that MP5SD is a little heavy for you, more frequent gym visits may be in order. Semper Fi.🇺🇲
5.7 rounds pack way bigger punch then 9mil so the p90 is hitting harder penetration and it’s lighter in weight and holds a 50 clip over mp5 30 clip p90 is a all around better gun
Military role: P90. Due to more rounds, lighter recoil, less weight, And superior armor penetrating capabilities). As a Civillian: MP5. Since the 5.7 is purposefully underpowered and severely overpriced (I'm not paying a $1 per round. I'll stick with 9mm, 10mm, and 22 TCM).
Seeing as the stack of soda was only 4 deep (ish) in any direction, it wasn’t a great way to show it. Maybe a long line ( 8x3 bottles ) or maybe slabs of timber ( assuming u don’t wanna buy ballistic gel )
Both really good guns, but the P90 is just better imo : lighter, much more mag capacity, more accurate ... also a caliber that is better for dealing with armored targets
@clveronez Love roller delayed blowback, for a number of reasons. And your assessment is pretty accurate. 9mm is great... within the constraints of it's limitations. What 5.7x28mm does is extend those limitations to a large degree, almost exactly halfway between 9mm and 5.56x45mm. Specifically out of the P90/PS90 platform. So, regardless of ammunition availability, price, and other logistics... for what it was designed to do, within the parameters of cqb, room clearing, inside vehicles, as a pdw, and ppd weapon... the P90 design outshines every 9mm platform in terms of accuracy, recoil, ergonomics, compactness, terminal effectiveness, one handed manipulation, barrier blind performance, fragmenting rounds that do in fact produce hydrostatic shock, and capacity large enough to literally offer suppressive fire if necessary. It's good kit. All depends on the shooter's needs.
Found a p90 original with limited fire time so I’m going with that beauty. Old design but so well done and it’s a classic. Not cheap bullets but that’s not a concern. 50 rounds in a few seconds will be so much fun at the range. And hopefully no one breaks in.
@XXXOD, so I wasn't wrong. Thanks for clarifying that. By your own words the main one is 9MM. I never said the MP40 didn't fire other sizes, did I? Thanks for playing.
Late comment: Both gun roles are different, and they perform different results. P90 (PS90 for civilians) is PDW which using HV PDW cartridges and required to Penetrate body armor (but there's some trade-off is wounding issues) while MP5 is a balanced Sub-Machine Gun that good for precise and CQC roles (however, pistol cartridges lack anti-armour capability).
The MP5 SD is subsonic, the P90 is not, and still the penetration test was the same??? The muzzle speed is, P90 715 m/s or (2,350 ft/s) vs MP5SD 330 m/s or 1082.68 ft/s, so P90 is more than double the muzzle speed.
Recoil impulse. It’s roller delayed blowback operating system is unmatched in terms of softness. The only gun I’ve shot that comes close to it is the mpx. Also the gun has been used so long now it has built up quite the reputation and is battle proven. Mpx is still very new and has some growing pains.
Once you shoot an MP5 (or the civilian semi auto version by HK the SP5) you will never want to shoot another pistol caliber carbine (PCC) again. The recoil impulse is unbelievably light due to the roller delayed blow back system. It makes shooting the 9mm a joy, you barely feel the recoil as if you were shooting a .22. Plus who doesn't like doing the HK slap? It's iconic.
It's a proven system that has seen uniform service for over 60 years by this point and still sees service with military and law enforcement to this day. It's roller delayed blowback system reduces the felt recoil and makes full auto fire exceptionally controllable and semi auto fire accurate as well, with good ammo and adequate training. It's also pretty easy to train on. Similar to the AK, the MP5 has very straightforward controls. One charging handle, one mag release, one safety selector. No frills, no fuss, no fumbly bits. While it does take additional training to run the sub gun fast, the reliability of the large controls that mostly require no fine motor skills means that the gun won't fail you when you're doing your job. And while the base MP5 doesn't have much modularity out the box for attachments, the commercial aftermarket has tons of means to fit optics, illumination devices, handguards, and what have you to keep the system relevant today. If anything, the gun just works. Sure it doesn't do everything some of its competition can, but it doesn't have to. The MP5 is weapon that won't let you down, and that's all it needs to be great.
Because it was built in the 60s and still used to this day. I normally am not one to buy slight variations of one particular platform, but do so with ARs and MP5s. Roller delayed makes it kinda hop up a tad evenly and predictable with each round fired. The recoil impulse is unique for sure.
so... the fact that the MP5 is the MP5SD variant and has an integral suppressor doesn't that make it so that you need a lot more paperwork and background checks to go with it?
Yes correct. Also the barrel is less than 16 inches with a collapsible stock which classifies it as an SBR. That also required a tax stamp along with the stamp for the suppressor. I had to wait 14 months before everything was approved.
@@GunsOfTheWorld tbh the p90 would have much more penetrating power than a 9mm or 45acp mp5 because its a faster and smaller round. The purpose of the p90 was to make a compact weapon that didnt have much kick but could still pass through body amour. The MP7 also was in the same trials as the p90 for the same reasons both are very good And tbh... I prefer the p90 over the mp7 but i cannot deny the roller delayed blowback godliness of the mp5.
Now, is likely the best time to stock up on complex consumables. Then, not even 9mm may be available... as stores will no longer exist. Finite supplies will become that much more finite. Every caliber will become scarce. Bartering will become a thing again. Get ready...
@@kenstewart7700 Maybe. Hopefully. But less than two years ago we this thing... And by the third week of January, county wide, every store was completely empty of canned food, boxed food, paper products, toiletries, any form of fresh meat, rice and potatoes, and water. There was a certain feral quality about shopping in those days, a sort of scavenging nightmare. Lots of open hostility. And I'm talking about otherwise docile soccer moms... That only lasted a few months. But it was a beautifully poignant wake up call. I'm not advocating building bunkers. I'm advocating buying batteries.
@@BeingFireRetardant I hear ya I think it’s got a lot more to do with the leadership groceries are up cause of some stupid meat virus gas is up cause of supply and demand same with housing. Factory workers for cars are going back to work now so car prices should drop within the next year or so hopefully when that does other things follow alot of what’s going on now too seems like a bunch of political bullshit.
These tests are not scientific at all. This video was made strictly for fun. Both of these are great and very fun to shoot.
For the 25 yard accuracy test with the MP5, I pulled high left a few times. That was 100% on me and not the gun's fault.
Thank you for watching.
The bottle test should be lined up in one line
ahh you pulled high left with the mp5, hummm i already thought THATS ALMOST NOT POSSIBLE SO FAR LEFT AT 25 YARD. because i own a mp5 and its accuracy is very very good. but i understand that its just for fun. GREAT VIDEO BTW. AND I MUST SAY THE SOUND OF THE PS90 IS REALY AWESOME. GREETS CHARLY FROM THE NETHERLANDS.
Li
@@gimmibodigoi7899 ??? Li what ??
@@charlybabbet9362 Li
How can a weapons channel be so attractive and satisfying to watch? This channel is the answer.
Yea it is cause he gets right to the point doesn’t talk forever. 🤘😁
No bullshid, only g u n
yes
+ efficiency
HK and FN... My two favorite firearms manufacturers.
P90 is my go too hands down. Something about the cool top mag and design is just so cool.
Compact
I like both
Facts💯
The P90 is going to have way better penetration, range and accuracy juse because the 5.7 is just designed perfectly, especially those SS190's.
Allow me to introduce you to 22 TCM. What 5.7 x 28 should be!
But it takes more time to reload
Correct 🔰
More penetration less stopping power
A Stargate special episode? The accuracy on the PS90 is very nice, I think both are excellent weapons and it is a shame the P90 didn't really take off as it is a very forward thinking design. The MP5 is certainly a tried and true gun that has been nigh impossible to supplant in its class. Difficult choice but 50 rounds of armour piercing ammo with a shorter overall length (with the short barrel) is something you can't get anywhere else.
Oh I loove the MP5-SD, you gotta say tho that its the supressed version and thus a little heavier.
Maybe a comparison between the unsupressed MP5 and P90 would make more sense but tbh idc :D
Lovely guns, lovely video. Two of my all time favorites
For Penetrating power test, Ballistic gel block is the best choice, you'll see the length of cavity of the bullet made through.
I do want to make one note. The MP5 fell out of favor due to difficulties penetrating body armor. The P90 has the ability to go through an engine block in one mag. I love both SMG's but I figured I'd let it be known.
Wait what? There's no way the 5.7 is doing anything to an engine block, where did you see that demonstrated? 5.56 round and 7.62 rounds can't even go through an engine block. Is this one of those A.I. bot accounts?
@Shademastermcc it's something I've heard about. I think it has a lot to do with velocity of round which plays a huge part in damage, and size with structural integrity (small, well structured, high velocity rounds work best in penetration i believe). I will say I haven't seen it tho, so it could be just word of mouth to word of mouth
Nice guns and Great vid!
Both are nice, it’s a shame that 5.7 is price-gouged so much; certain ballistic performance along with price is why the 9mm edges out the 5.7 in my eyes, that’s just me.
It’s really easy to source Ap ammo for it at least
@@201hastings which one?
I appreciate the unit conversion.
Bruhme
I'll take the MP5 over the PS90 simply because I've been that good with one since I was active duty Marine Corps. I noticed you have some sort of optic on the PS90 where you do not on the MP5. I also noticed you compared it with the naturally heavier integrally suppressed MP5SD also with heavier straight mags and NOT the lighter MP5 which would have lighter mags as well. I don't get anything out of cola devastation. And also, if that MP5SD is a little heavy for you, more frequent gym visits may be in order. Semper Fi.🇺🇲
two awesome submachine guns
Reloads Mp, Sets glasses.
Reloads P90, Sets glasses.
WOW my favourites weapons p90 & mp5 in one video, love 😍👌
I need something like this. "Resident evil" days incoming...🤦From Russia with love. And yes, my first top1 in Warzone was with P90))
I’ve been watching since 2020 and ur the Goat
I love this channel
MOST BEST VIDEO!!!!!!!!! EXCELLENT COMPARISON NOBODY DID IT BEFORE YOU. I REALLY LIKE IT TO SEE THESE GUNS COMPARED
I don't own either, but if forced to choose...I don't know what I'd do!
Both of them are great guns but I still prefer the MP
Do you will do a video on p90?
Yes, I will be posting it in a few weeks.
You’re the bomb love your vid’s
Thanks man I appreciate it!
@@GunsOfTheWorld
Author, when will the next video be?
5.7 rounds pack way bigger punch then 9mil so the p90 is hitting harder penetration and it’s lighter in weight and holds a 50 clip over mp5 30 clip p90 is a all around better gun
Cool vid! Was that red dot made specifically for p90?
Yes it is
it should've been MP7 vs P90. MP5 is much older, has different ammo and it's even suppressed. But yeah, didn't knew it was heavier than an M4.
The PS90 wins for sure, the 5.7×28 rounds pack more of a punch and the barrel is longer than that MP5SD barrel.
nice video keep it up
Thank you will do!
I like FN P90
Can you tell me where you get all these guns?
Military role: P90. Due to more rounds, lighter recoil, less weight, And superior armor penetrating capabilities).
As a Civillian: MP5. Since the 5.7 is purposefully underpowered and severely overpriced (I'm not paying a $1 per round. I'll stick with 9mm, 10mm, and 22 TCM).
Both are great guns but for sheer simplicity and practically I would pic the p90 every time.
1:23
Where's the iron sight on the P90?
It's already attached with a small scope😁
P-90 hands down lighter,faster ,more accurate not to mention the 50 round clips 🤷♂️
mag
Clips what is this 1940
PS90 лучше, но 9мм распространеннее
1:14 oh hes goona do the thing
you are the winner if you own both jack o neill
Nice vid
I think P90 is super cool so P90 WINS.
Seeing as the stack of soda was only 4 deep (ish) in any direction, it wasn’t a great way to show it. Maybe a long line ( 8x3 bottles ) or maybe slabs of timber ( assuming u don’t wanna buy ballistic gel )
Both really good guns, but the P90 is just better imo : lighter, much more mag capacity, more accurate ... also a caliber that is better for dealing with armored targets
@clveronez That however cannot be argued with, P90 has a rare and expensive ammo ...
@clveronez
Love roller delayed blowback, for a number of reasons.
And your assessment is pretty accurate. 9mm is great... within the constraints of it's limitations. What 5.7x28mm does is extend those limitations to a large degree, almost exactly halfway between 9mm and 5.56x45mm. Specifically out of the P90/PS90 platform.
So, regardless of ammunition availability, price, and other logistics... for what it was designed to do, within the parameters of cqb, room clearing, inside vehicles, as a pdw, and ppd weapon... the P90 design outshines every 9mm platform in terms of accuracy, recoil, ergonomics, compactness, terminal effectiveness, one handed manipulation, barrier blind performance, fragmenting rounds that do in fact produce hydrostatic shock, and capacity large enough to literally offer suppressive fire if necessary.
It's good kit.
All depends on the shooter's needs.
@clveronez Less ammunition capacity is not an advantage you ldiot lmao
Next do Mp5 vs Mp40
Awesome vid!
Thank you very much!
MP5SD just on cool looks alone WINS!
Can you make an Video in which you reload your weapons
Great video bro love it
Thanks man!
THANK YOU for switching to kilograms.
I used MP5 on range (50m) hit 45 from 50 points. Like it very much, like any other HK gun.
Obviously the winner is p90. But for me it alway is mp5
Found a p90 original with limited fire time so I’m going with that beauty. Old design but so well done and it’s a classic. Not cheap bullets but that’s not a concern. 50 rounds in a few seconds will be so much fun at the range. And hopefully no one breaks in.
PS90. Tighter group, lighter, more ease of use in close quarters. Overall better ergonomics. My choice for bug-out even on semi-only.
Ah yes the Russian Rush B.
You should do P90 vs MP7
Wich one had worst trigger pull
Keep reminding point one…. Weight. 👊🏻💫
Gimme the little slappadacharginghandle man any day of the week.
By your demonstration, p90 had closer group, even at farther range.
Those toys look and sound so real! Does it take a long time to add the muzzle flashes and sounds in your video edit program?
How about use .45 acp for MP5 and P90
both of the smgs are not designed to fire that type of ammunition
Likely the ps90 because of the accuracy
Iron sight vs holographic sight?
After watching the entire video, still don't who which is MP5 and which PS90. Label them in the video please.
MP5 is the more standard looking Firearm whilst the P90 is the Weird one with the Magazine on top.
Ohhh, those guns.
I literally like the MP5 is equipped with 10mm rounds^^
Actually MP 5 uses 9MM parabellum rounds.
@XXXOD, so I wasn't wrong. Thanks for clarifying that. By your own words the main one is 9MM. I never said the MP40 didn't fire other sizes, did I? Thanks for playing.
Late comment:
Both gun roles are different, and they perform different results.
P90 (PS90 for civilians) is PDW which using HV PDW cartridges and required to Penetrate body armor (but there's some trade-off is wounding issues) while MP5 is a balanced Sub-Machine Gun that good for precise and CQC roles (however, pistol cartridges lack anti-armour capability).
The MP5 SD is subsonic, the P90 is not, and still the penetration test was the same??? The muzzle speed is, P90 715 m/s or (2,350 ft/s) vs MP5SD 330 m/s or 1082.68 ft/s, so P90 is more than double the muzzle speed.
Not a gun guy, could someone explain to me why the MP5 is still considered the king of SMGs even though it has better counterparts?
Recoil impulse. It’s roller delayed blowback operating system is unmatched in terms of softness. The only gun I’ve
shot that comes close to it is the mpx. Also the gun has been used so long now it has built up quite the reputation and is battle proven. Mpx is still very new and has some growing pains.
Once you shoot an MP5 (or the civilian semi auto version by HK the SP5) you will never want to shoot another pistol caliber carbine (PCC) again. The recoil impulse is unbelievably light due to the roller delayed blow back system. It makes shooting the 9mm a joy, you barely feel the recoil as if you were shooting a .22. Plus who doesn't like doing the HK slap? It's iconic.
It's a proven system that has seen uniform service for over 60 years by this point and still sees service with military and law enforcement to this day. It's roller delayed blowback system reduces the felt recoil and makes full auto fire exceptionally controllable and semi auto fire accurate as well, with good ammo and adequate training.
It's also pretty easy to train on. Similar to the AK, the MP5 has very straightforward controls. One charging handle, one mag release, one safety selector. No frills, no fuss, no fumbly bits. While it does take additional training to run the sub gun fast, the reliability of the large controls that mostly require no fine motor skills means that the gun won't fail you when you're doing your job. And while the base MP5 doesn't have much modularity out the box for attachments, the commercial aftermarket has tons of means to fit optics, illumination devices, handguards, and what have you to keep the system relevant today.
If anything, the gun just works. Sure it doesn't do everything some of its competition can, but it doesn't have to. The MP5 is weapon that won't let you down, and that's all it needs to be great.
Because it was built in the 60s and still used to this day.
I normally am not one to buy slight variations of one particular platform, but do so with ARs and MP5s. Roller delayed makes it kinda hop up a tad evenly and predictable with each round fired. The recoil impulse is unique for sure.
so... the fact that the MP5 is the MP5SD variant and has an integral suppressor doesn't that make it so that you need a lot more paperwork and background checks to go with it?
Yes correct. Also the barrel is less than 16 inches with a collapsible stock which classifies it as an SBR. That also required a tax stamp along with the stamp for the suppressor. I had to wait 14 months before everything was approved.
@@GunsOfTheWorld tbh the p90 would have much more penetrating power than a 9mm or 45acp mp5 because its a faster and smaller round. The purpose of the p90 was to make a compact weapon that didnt have much kick but could still pass through body amour. The MP7 also was in the same trials as the p90 for the same reasons both are very good
And tbh... I prefer the p90 over the mp7 but i cannot deny the roller delayed blowback godliness of the mp5.
The bottle test was a bit weird, because the way the bottles were stacked meant they could only hit up to 4 bottles.
I feel like it's not really for the same role, and it doesn't come to the same price, but yeah the p90 is superior in almost every way
Both systems are only as effective as their operator.
literally doc and rooks primarys
I Love M82B
Que bueno que lo puso también kg ja.
Good to see this comparison. Might also want to compare the PS90 to the HK 33 with green tips for penetration.
It should be “ps90 vs mp7 “
P90 comes with the little scope, and the MP5... it's not. So aiming with the P90 is easier than do it with the MP5
I prefer the mp5k the p90 looks awesome but the ammo is kinda expensive and hard to come by in a apocalyptic situation 9mm is everywhere though
Now, is likely the best time to stock up on complex consumables. Then, not even 9mm may be available... as stores will no longer exist.
Finite supplies will become that much more finite. Every caliber will become scarce. Bartering will become a thing again. Get ready...
@@BeingFireRetardant I don’t think it’s gonna be that serious dude lol a few more years things will go back to some sort of normalcy
@@kenstewart7700
Maybe. Hopefully.
But less than two years ago we this thing... And by the third week of January, county wide, every store was completely empty of canned food, boxed food, paper products, toiletries, any form of fresh meat, rice and potatoes, and water. There was a certain feral quality about shopping in those days, a sort of scavenging nightmare. Lots of open hostility. And I'm talking about otherwise docile soccer moms...
That only lasted a few months. But it was a beautifully poignant wake up call.
I'm not advocating building bunkers. I'm advocating buying batteries.
@@BeingFireRetardant I hear ya I think it’s got a lot more to do with the leadership groceries are up cause of some stupid meat virus gas is up cause of supply and demand same with housing. Factory workers for cars are going back to work now so car prices should drop within the next year or so hopefully when that does other things follow alot of what’s going on now too seems like a bunch of political bullshit.
the p90
PS90 ist wahrscheinlich besser, obwohl beide gut sind, also ein Unentschieden.
Wooow ..guns.
I like it..
Greets from indonesia
should be MP5 vs APC9
Go FN P90
Im a 9mm and 5.7 guy but 5.7 wins here.
Germany vs Belgium
Team MP5, all the way.
It looks like the MP5SD here is a real select-fire version but the PS90 (of course, because of the S) is not. Do you own the MP5? Is it transferrable?
P90 more quick and fast but mp5 more accuracy
No? P90 is more accurate
Why are you using the mp5sd for this test and not the "normal" mp5? You are distorting the test somewhat.
P90, absolutely
P90 🇧🇪
straight mag mp5 very good
MP5
power wise: p90
the more iconic one: mp5
MP5 is so silent!
Thats bot just your ordinary mp5, its an mp5 SD!
That's CBR-4
That is PS90 and MP5-SD
Р90 Cool gun.. But... Plastic for gun P90.. Crack.. Sorry my anglish))) hello from Russian