As someone whose childhood was mostly spent playing Halo 3, I can without a doubt say this is 100% what Arrival would have sounded like had it been in the game. I have chills right now.
@Pharaoh Productions Yeah...hence why the description says "IF Arrival were on H3's soundtrack". I’m very aware that 343’s goal wasn’t to imitate the musical style of the Bungie games. This video was a fun experiment to see how a song from Halo 4 would sound in the style of H3 with more choir, piano, etc. Your comment is extremely redundant, idk what you're trying to say lmao
Totally disagree. That's not a shot at the OP or your comment, just that there's absolutely no way this would be compatible with Halo 3, especially compared to its other tracks.
i could see this being played on a whole new form of a warthog run, instead of it being all action and a race to a finish, its a fight for your life as halfway through maybe youd have to finish the rest on foot while being bombarded with flood and sentinels, a sort of nod of halo CE mixed in with a last stand that makes you truly wonder, "Are we gonna make it?"
Arrival was always my favorite song in the whole franchise, i've been listening to this master piece since the game came out. You just took it to next level, congrats.
In fact, the promethean knight prototypes in this halo 3 engine version of halo 4, rolled into a ball and rolled towards the player instead of teleporting. Prometheans would be a lot less controversial if they put that into release instead of the teleport!
Hey guys, for anyone wondering why there weren’t a ton of changes to the arrangement, this song is actually pretty close to the sound of the classic Halo soundtracks already. The strings are leading the charge, with pounding war drums and large strings/brass sections in the background. I just figured a few minor alterations would bring it even closer to Marty and Michaels style of composition :) I hope you guys enjoy, feel free to let me know what you think in the comments :)
I can't exactly lay my finger on precisely what it was you did. but I tell you you turned an already good track from Halo 4 that just didn't have the distinct Halo style in it, and made it sound like it could have fit right into the original trilogy. Hats off to 'ya, keep up the good work!
Peanutgallery4 Thank you so much for the kind words! I would’ve done this arrangement much differently if I was doing it today, but I think the greater emphasis on piano and choirs are all this song needs to fit the sound of the original trilogy (I personally think Arrival is pretty close to the original Halo sound, just needs some tweaks in instrumentation). Thank you again for listening and for the comment :)
Its basically less electronic sounds overall. You can make a style that's remniscent to the original trilogy, not the Halo style, because the style literally changes with every game.
I can’t decide on what part of the game this would go with. There’s so many to choose from, either making your way through the desert fighting the scarab then moving into the giant forerunner structure on The Ark or making your way to truth with the arbiter and the flood on The Covenant. There’s so many others to choose from though
My man, this is simply one of the best Halo arrangements I’ve ever heard. It feels a lot more… I guess simple than the original? I dunno but my goodness, it’s some top tier stuff. With your permission (and me learning some coding skills) would you allow me to make a mod for Halo 3 on MCC that adds this song? I’m thinking it plays when you’re fighting down the bridge when you’re allied with the Flood.
Thank you so much! Sorry for the late reply-you can absolutely use it in your mod! If you don’t mind crediting me (and Neil Davidge, of course), that would be great!
That's a great question--I had to think about this one for a while lol :P the part where I think it would fit best tonally would be fighting your way to Truth during the final mission. I always saw Arrival as a very melancholic piece, it's upbeat, but it always had this solemn atmosphere around it, which I always figured was the dual emotions of Chief fighting the Didact and losing Cortana at the same time. So I think it would have to play during a scenario that has a sense of action, as well as a small tinge of sadness, which is why I think "Halo" would be the best fit for it. That's the best answer I could come up with off the top of my head lol :P
Maybe floodgate when you charge with the elites to find the crashed ship or while you have to pass across the flood to activate halo in the last mission.
Just imagine, you're playing Halo 3 - The Covenant mission, you're with the Scorpion destroying every enemy vehicle in your way to the Citadel, 2 Hornets arrive, then the 2 Scarabs land, One Final Effort starts playing, you destroy the first Scarab, Miranda orders to focus fire on the second Scarab and this soundtrack starts playing... Just amazing
Can imagine that this version of Arrival from Halo 4 can be either playing in either the mission called The Covenant or in the final mission called Halo of Halo 3’s campaign.
I could totally see fitting over the fight with the two Scarabs! Brilliantly done all round! Upon hearing this, part of me's now curious of what if you did the opposite? Take a track from any of Bungie's Halo titles & reconstruct it to fit with one of 343's.
I’m kinda being put on the spot here, lol. I hadn’t given it much thought, but “From the Ashes”; the opening section of “Bits & Pieces” from ODST perhaps? As for what direction to turn it into? I haven’t thought that far ahead. Maybe in the style of “Aliens” from Halo 4, or “Warrior World” from Halo 5?
@@nathanlangloismusic What I really, really would like to hear is what the "Halo 4" version of the Halo theme would sound like. I absolutely love the Halo 4 soundtrack, but it doesn't have its own version of the Halo theme.
@@DarkLordDeimos Ooh this is an interesting idea! I plan to resurrect this channel this spring; I think that would be a fun piece to start with! If I can make it happen I will absolutely be posting that to this channel :)
@nathanlangloismusic ok, so I did it with the warthog run from 3 as well. I have to say that it almost made me want to cry. (I don't cry to games or anything like it)
This music is perfect by itself. While listening this, I have a feeling, like I'm bleeding and about to die, but happily flying through the clouds. Upd: 117 comments. Perfect.
All right, as someone who isn't a Bungie shill and actually likes all the Halo games, I'll be the one to say it. The track does not suit what the original trilogy meant, because you cannot compare Halo 1, 2 or 3 to Halo 4. That's not bad thing. Halo's 4 soundtrack, especially Arrival is a fucking fantastic soundtrack. It is it's own thing, and thank god
I agree. Honestly in retrospect it was the smart choice to make. Marty and Michael’s musical landscape for the original trilogy was extremely unique and it was the safe choice to not imitate it and pursue an original sound. I do love Halo 4’s soundtrack too. It may not sound exactly like Halo 1-3 but it’s beautiful in its own right
Thank you! This isn't necessarily in the style of Halo 2, but this guy did a great cover of Arrival on guitar, which I don't know if I could ever top :P ua-cam.com/video/jFeLenKUy2E/v-deo.html
Ah yes, Rise of Iron's best track lol :P if you've never heard Forged in Flame from Destiny, definitely give it a listen, if you don't understand my reference lol. It's a great name though
I don't think it sounds as strong as the original did but this is a pretty good cover nice work and can you keep working on this song I think it could use more work done to it and it would be very much obliged 😇
Haha thank you! Yeah, this was made a while ago when I was still very new at composing and there's definitely things I'd improve and tweak. Maybe one day I'll do a better version of it with better instrumentation and higher production quality :)
@@nathanlangloismusic don't get me wrong it's good but I just don't think it sounds very strong and different than the original and I can't wait to see the improvements you'll make to this song.
@@Elitesolider1023 Yeah, I think when I made this I wasn't really trying to deviate too much from the original anyways. I think I put that in the original version's description. Honestly this is my favorite piece of music and if I remade it again, I'd probably just recreate the original and add some small changes to it
soo just a worse version of arrival? context: i am not at all bashing this rendition that you made and spent time on. its super awesome and i see the intention behind it. in my opinion, simply palette swapping the instrumentation isn't enough to make it sound more like legacy halo. It's missing key elements like more overarching melodic passages, frequent leit motifs (like the halo 3 piano queue, or simply the halo chant). here the intention muddies the beauty of the piece due to the palette swap. making it primarily strings leads to the tone being flat and empty, despite the intention aiming for the opposite. the difference with legacy halo is martin's superb composition skills carefully placing instrumentation where its needed. there were a few chord changes you made that i don't agree with as well, but of course all this is just opinion. i see a lot of people here like this one even more which is great to see, it is more akin to the grand and lush strings orchestration of halo 3. but as a final thought, i believe a track like this cannot be made to sound marty-esque, because it is far too different and unique i comparison. it focuses mainly on a repetitive progression with dynamic mood changes and triumphant melody. for these reasons, neil has created an instrumentation that complements this very well, incorporating not just strings but brass, bells, and heavy percussion Edit: I heard your alt mix, definitely an improvement! the increased piano and bells gives it a more legacy touch
@@sebastianmoscoso9404 Haha I made this when I was a teenager and before I went to school for music. Definitely could’ve been better 😊 You did a good job of breaking down some of the things that gives Halo’s music it’s unique identity. You must be a musician yourself or at the very least you have a good analytical mind for music. I appreciate you taking the time to write such an insightful comment, though I think I’ve changed quite a bit as a composer since I posted this 😅
@@nathanlangloismusic i see that makes sense! Yes i do have a love for music as well! In hindsight maybe i shouldnt have used those words at the beginning as it was obviously from many years ago, i think i am just very passionate about the original track lol! And felt it was too different haha Thanks for your response! Do you have other arrangements from games or other media? Would love to listen!
This, but playing as you fight your way through the Arks control room to truth.
That would be awesome!
That would actually be really cool.
It will play so nice in the part when you side with the Flood to stop truth, yeah I like your idea.
Hell to the yeah my dude.
Holy fuck imagin that :O
As someone whose childhood was mostly spent playing Halo 3, I can without a doubt say this is 100% what Arrival would have sounded like had it been in the game. I have chills right now.
Thank you so much for the kind words! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Well this is what it would’ve sounded like if halo 4’s goal to to copy halo 3, halo 4 isn’t halo 3 my guy
@Pharaoh Productions Yeah...hence why the description says "IF Arrival were on H3's soundtrack". I’m very aware that 343’s goal wasn’t to imitate the musical style of the Bungie games. This video was a fun experiment to see how a song from Halo 4 would sound in the style of H3 with more choir, piano, etc. Your comment is extremely redundant, idk what you're trying to say lmao
Totally disagree. That's not a shot at the OP or your comment, just that there's absolutely no way this would be compatible with Halo 3, especially compared to its other tracks.
i could see this being played on a whole new form of a warthog run, instead of it being all action and a race to a finish, its a fight for your life as halfway through maybe youd have to finish the rest on foot while being bombarded with flood and sentinels, a sort of nod of halo CE mixed in with a last stand that makes you truly wonder, "Are we gonna make it?"
That would be awesome!
This comment really made me think about it, and that would be COMPLETELY AWESOME!
Oh like a lone wolf version dan dude thats crazy 😋
Arrival was always my favorite song in the whole franchise, i've been listening to this master piece since the game came out. You just took it to next level, congrats.
Thank you so much Sergio, that means a lot to me!
Yess definately the best song in the franchise still listening to it today
It is funny to See both Chiefs watching each other.
But hey man, excellent piece of art! Sounds amazing!
I honestly didn't even think about that lol :P I dig it though :P I'm glad you like it, thank you :)
4:24 - 4:41 The way you hear the choir in the background... That small detail is so freaking amazing, it stands out! You are magnificent, my friend!👌
Thank you so much! I really appreciate that :)
Fun Fact: Halo 4 was originally built on the Halo 3 engine before switching to the Reach one
I didn't actually know that; I knew it was based on the Reach engine but I didn't know about it using the H3 one. Thank you for sharing!
In fact, the promethean knight prototypes in this halo 3 engine version of halo 4, rolled into a ball and rolled towards the player instead of teleporting. Prometheans would be a lot less controversial if they put that into release instead of the teleport!
@@HughS-kp1fv Makes me think of the Droidekas from Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Menace.
Hey guys, for anyone wondering why there weren’t a ton of changes to the arrangement, this song is actually pretty close to the sound of the classic Halo soundtracks already. The strings are leading the charge, with pounding war drums and large strings/brass sections in the background. I just figured a few minor alterations would bring it even closer to Marty and Michaels style of composition :) I hope you guys enjoy, feel free to let me know what you think in the comments :)
I can't exactly lay my finger on precisely what it was you did. but I tell you you turned an already good track from Halo 4 that just didn't have the distinct Halo style in it, and made it sound like it could have fit right into the original trilogy.
Hats off to 'ya, keep up the good work!
Peanutgallery4 Thank you so much for the kind words! I would’ve done this arrangement much differently if I was doing it today, but I think the greater emphasis on piano and choirs are all this song needs to fit the sound of the original trilogy (I personally think Arrival is pretty close to the original Halo sound, just needs some tweaks in instrumentation).
Thank you again for listening and for the comment :)
Its basically less electronic sounds overall. You can make a style that's remniscent to the original trilogy, not the Halo style, because the style literally changes with every game.
shuuut your dumbass up "oh it's so different from the original trilogy it's so bad" cringe ass
Fucking beautiful, put chills down my spine. Added to my "Epic Halo Music" playlist.
This-
This is beautiful
Thank you so much!
I love the original arrival but i have to admit this one sounds a bit better for me this one definitely goes to my favus 10/10 amazing work
Thank you so much!
halo 4 really did have good soundtrack. It really was the last "Hurrah" in the series. Here's hoping infinite is good.
I'm sure it will be! The music we've heard so far is amazing for the most part
I can’t decide on what part of the game this would go with. There’s so many to choose from, either making your way through the desert fighting the scarab then moving into the giant forerunner structure on The Ark or making your way to truth with the arbiter and the flood on The Covenant. There’s so many others to choose from though
Those are good choices! H3 has a ton of good encounters to choose from
Simply... Breathtaking!
I can't believe it took me 3 whole years to stumble onto this!!! Wtf this is amazing! I subbed to you in after kess than 10 seconds into it.
Wow! Thank you so much! I really appreciate the support :)
Now this is some tunes that I could listen to when I kick my friends @$$ In multiplayer
Dat kazoo Guy Haha I’m glad you dig it!
thanks for this audio mapping youtubers would really like this.
If the epilogue was a playable mission for Halo 3, this should play.
That would be awesome!
YO its doktor myth!
This brought a tear to my eye. Beautiful.
Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it :)
My man, this is simply one of the best Halo arrangements I’ve ever heard. It feels a lot more… I guess simple than the original? I dunno but my goodness, it’s some top tier stuff. With your permission (and me learning some coding skills) would you allow me to make a mod for Halo 3 on MCC that adds this song? I’m thinking it plays when you’re fighting down the bridge when you’re allied with the Flood.
Thank you so much! Sorry for the late reply-you can absolutely use it in your mod! If you don’t mind crediting me (and Neil Davidge, of course), that would be great!
@@nathanlangloismusic thanks for your permission!!!
This deserves more views; it's really good!
Thank you so much!
love the way the video starts
Thank you!
Legendary
Thank you!
This is heavily underrated. This guy only has 125 subs? Christ, you should be up there with samuelkimmusic.
Thank you so much for the kind words! :)
Agreed
This is just so nostalgic. I grew up on the legendary Halo 3, and this completely suits the game. Another excellent work, keep it up!!!
Thank you much!
Of course! Glad to support one of my favorite music-makers!
Not gonna lie, this feels as powerful as the original
Thank you so much!
No it doesn't 😂
@@volrogue No, it doesn’t. Nothing ever beats the original, especially when it’s recorded at Abbey Road :p this was just my take on it
Now the big question, which level in Halo 3 would this fit?
That's a great question--I had to think about this one for a while lol :P the part where I think it would fit best tonally would be fighting your way to Truth during the final mission. I always saw Arrival as a very melancholic piece, it's upbeat, but it always had this solemn atmosphere around it, which I always figured was the dual emotions of Chief fighting the Didact and losing Cortana at the same time. So I think it would have to play during a scenario that has a sense of action, as well as a small tinge of sadness, which is why I think "Halo" would be the best fit for it. That's the best answer I could come up with off the top of my head lol :P
@@eamontdmas Definitely!
Maybe floodgate when you charge with the elites to find the crashed ship or while you have to pass across the flood to activate halo in the last mission.
@@randomhaloplayer918 Maybe! That would be cool
Probably the warhog run.
Bloody oath mate this is awesome. Good on yah champion.
Thank you! I appreciate it :)
I really love this version! I honestly believe this is 100 times better than the original or even more, I subbed!
Little Matzwood Knight Thank you so much for the kind words :) I really appreciate it :)
@@nathanlangloismusic You are welcome friend!
Something about the strings starting at 2:22 makes it sound a lot like a song from Marathon. Maybe the song, "Rushing" from Marathon 1.
That's so cool! I'll have to check it out!
Just imagine, you're playing Halo 3 - The Covenant mission, you're with the Scorpion destroying every enemy vehicle in your way to the Citadel, 2 Hornets arrive, then the 2 Scarabs land, One Final Effort starts playing, you destroy the first Scarab, Miranda orders to focus fire on the second Scarab and this soundtrack starts playing... Just amazing
That would be pretty cool!
Can imagine that this version of Arrival from Halo 4 can be either playing in either the mission called The Covenant or in the final mission called Halo of Halo 3’s campaign.
Pretty good!
Markster Thank you very much :)
Epic
Thank you!
I could totally see fitting over the fight with the two Scarabs! Brilliantly done all round!
Upon hearing this, part of me's now curious of what if you did the opposite? Take a track from any of Bungie's Halo titles & reconstruct it to fit with one of 343's.
Thank you! I've certainly thought about it. Any suggestions on which track I should do?
I’m kinda being put on the spot here, lol. I hadn’t given it much thought, but “From the Ashes”; the opening section of “Bits & Pieces” from ODST perhaps?
As for what direction to turn it into? I haven’t thought that far ahead. Maybe in the style of “Aliens” from Halo 4, or “Warrior World” from Halo 5?
@@nathanlangloismusic What I really, really would like to hear is what the "Halo 4" version of the Halo theme would sound like. I absolutely love the Halo 4 soundtrack, but it doesn't have its own version of the Halo theme.
@@DarkLordDeimos Ooh this is an interesting idea! I plan to resurrect this channel this spring; I think that would be a fun piece to start with! If I can make it happen I will absolutely be posting that to this channel :)
@@nathanlangloismusic I cannot wait to hear it!
Im getting some john murphy sunshine vibes at 3:00 and i love it
Haha awesome :P
That sound cool
Thank you!
I prefer the original but this is also very well done
Thank you, nothing ever beats the original :P
This is better than the original, dont ever remove this video!
Playing this while rescuing Cortana
That's awesome!
@@nathanlangloismusicIt worked surprisingly well
@nathanlangloismusic ok, so I did it with the warthog run from 3 as well. I have to say that it almost made me want to cry. (I don't cry to games or anything like it)
Beautiful 😍👏
Thank you :)
2:22 this part never gets old 🥲
How it feels when you kill the guy with hayabusa, recon and the flaming helmet and tbag his body
Lol that's always a satisfying feeling!
This is actually pretty good nlg. I was worried that halo 3fying it would loose the charm Midnight has, but I was wrong
I'm glad you liked it, thank you :)
@@nathanlangloismusic
Arrival is my favorite Halo 4 track, but I love this version too
@@Cameron088 Arrival is my favorite Halo 4 track too. I always get hit with a ton of nostalgia when I hear it :P
That's actually pretty good indeed what it would've sounded if Marty'O Donnel and Michael Salvatori wrote it in halo 3
Thank you! I appreciate that :)
This music is perfect by itself.
While listening this, I have a feeling, like I'm bleeding and about to die, but happily flying through the clouds.
Upd: 117 comments.
Perfect.
The 5 dislikes are covenant sympathisers
Their slander offends all who walk the path :( :P
Oml lmao
All right, as someone who isn't a Bungie shill and actually likes all the Halo games, I'll be the one to say it. The track does not suit what the original trilogy meant, because you cannot compare Halo 1, 2 or 3 to Halo 4. That's not bad thing. Halo's 4 soundtrack, especially Arrival is a fucking fantastic soundtrack. It is it's own thing, and thank god
I agree. Honestly in retrospect it was the smart choice to make. Marty and Michael’s musical landscape for the original trilogy was extremely unique and it was the safe choice to not imitate it and pursue an original sound. I do love Halo 4’s soundtrack too. It may not sound exactly like Halo 1-3 but it’s beautiful in its own right
Nailed it. Now on electric guitar for 2?
Thank you! This isn't necessarily in the style of Halo 2, but this guy did a great cover of Arrival on guitar, which I don't know if I could ever top :P ua-cam.com/video/jFeLenKUy2E/v-deo.html
@@nathanlangloismusic wow, thanks man.
halo 3 version of wreckage when
Hmm I'll have to give that one some thought! Maybe I'll try it out soon :)
@@nathanlangloismusic I cant wait to hear it, wreckage is like my favorite halo 4 song lol
sin duda arrival es de los mejores soundtracks de la saga
Estoy de acuerdo contigo!
really cool, expected a bit of the halo 3 piano tho.
Thank you. I totally agree. It would've been really cool to hear that E octave somewhere in this piece
Ngl the originals brass/wind sounding instrument around 2:40 is better imo.
I like this version though.
Durision Nothing ever beats the original ;) I’m glad you enjoyed the video
Do you have audio file for people to use (followed by credit of course)?
Yes I do! drive.google.com/file/d/1GxK4Ri6T_N3vPnoyUy6HYqEveWjReUJd/view?usp=share_link
@@nathanlangloismusic a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
If this music was in Halo 3 renamed like how Perilous Journey changed to Furthest Outpost,
I would change it to Forged in Flames.
Ah yes, Rise of Iron's best track lol :P if you've never heard Forged in Flame from Destiny, definitely give it a listen, if you don't understand my reference lol. It's a great name though
Halo 4 had beautiful music. All of 4 can really be described as 'good, but not Halo'. This song is definitely good. But it is Halo.
100% agree with you!
Awuebooo xd
I don't think it sounds as strong as the original did but this is a pretty good cover nice work and can you keep working on this song I think it could use more work done to it and it would be very much obliged 😇
Haha thank you! Yeah, this was made a while ago when I was still very new at composing and there's definitely things I'd improve and tweak. Maybe one day I'll do a better version of it with better instrumentation and higher production quality :)
@@nathanlangloismusic don't get me wrong it's good but I just don't think it sounds very strong and different than the original and I can't wait to see the improvements you'll make to this song.
@@Elitesolider1023 Yeah, I think when I made this I wasn't really trying to deviate too much from the original anyways. I think I put that in the original version's description. Honestly this is my favorite piece of music and if I remade it again, I'd probably just recreate the original and add some small changes to it
@@nathanlangloismusic that could work.
It needs more piano
Need an Infinite version.
We'll have to see!
The final fight but its halo 4 swapped with halo 3
Hmmm...that might be worth testing out..;)
Is this really from h3
No, it's fan-made. There is a piece that has the name "Arrival" from Halo 3 though, it's in the opening cinematic
117th like :)
Good work, Spartan!
Halo 3 anniversary
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🎧🎧🎧🎶🎼
Edgar Alejandro Ortiz ☺️☺️☺️👍
soo just a worse version of arrival?
context: i am not at all bashing this rendition that you made and spent time on. its super awesome and i see the intention behind it. in my opinion, simply palette swapping the instrumentation isn't enough to make it sound more like legacy halo. It's missing key elements like more overarching melodic passages, frequent leit motifs (like the halo 3 piano queue, or simply the halo chant). here the intention muddies the beauty of the piece due to the palette swap. making it primarily strings leads to the tone being flat and empty, despite the intention aiming for the opposite. the difference with legacy halo is martin's superb composition skills carefully placing instrumentation where its needed. there were a few chord changes you made that i don't agree with as well, but of course all this is just opinion. i see a lot of people here like this one even more which is great to see, it is more akin to the grand and lush strings orchestration of halo 3. but as a final thought, i believe a track like this cannot be made to sound marty-esque, because it is far too different and unique i comparison. it focuses mainly on a repetitive progression with dynamic mood changes and triumphant melody. for these reasons, neil has created an instrumentation that complements this very well, incorporating not just strings but brass, bells, and heavy percussion
Edit: I heard your alt mix, definitely an improvement! the increased piano and bells gives it a more legacy touch
@@sebastianmoscoso9404 Haha I made this when I was a teenager and before I went to school for music. Definitely could’ve been better 😊
You did a good job of breaking down some of the things that gives Halo’s music it’s unique identity. You must be a musician yourself or at the very least you have a good analytical mind for music.
I appreciate you taking the time to write such an insightful comment, though I think I’ve changed quite a bit as a composer since I posted this 😅
@@nathanlangloismusic i see that makes sense! Yes i do have a love for music as well! In hindsight maybe i shouldnt have used those words at the beginning as it was obviously from many years ago, i think i am just very passionate about the original track lol! And felt it was too different haha
Thanks for your response! Do you have other arrangements from games or other media? Would love to listen!
wtf