gumroad gum.co/tfxwd (only donate if you have the means to) patreon and stuff / cg_matter website www.cgmatter.com business inquiries etc cgmatterofficial@gmail.com
Well, every pixel has 3 dimensions, one for each color, that with some times an alpha channel, and the video's 3 dimensions, it actually has 6-7 dimensions
@@TheShadesOfBlack everyone does, bro. but you'd probably have to engineer that shit on a quantum level and it'd make no sense and would be very hard and boring
@@pvs_np i like to think in minecraft anvil logic so this man be seeing in the 4th dimension (the actual reason being because adding length, width, and height with length, width, and time only gives you length, width, height, and time)
Still 2d since it's still on a screen. Heck, all 3d objects on a screen are 2d, we merely make a projection to get the idea of 3d, but they're still 2d. Time is not a dimension, it can be "dimensioned", but when we try to "tridimensionalize" or "bidimensionalize" they are still projections or just new representations of something naturaly intangible to our compreension. Another thing to point out is just that he did not specify if he's talking about spatial dimensions or physical dimensions (both will be mostly misconceptualized, but it's just arguably wrong) or maths conception of dimension which it seems to have a very less important meaning and could be used in his explanation, but it that way we can only be talking about projections. It's a nice gimmick tough.
@@louisalex98 No dude. "Dimensions" is a college topic, and the explanation made by the video was right bro. You can search for "Calculus Vol. 3" and you'll find the material that explains why everything in the video was correct, even if it's simplified. But you'll NEED to know the concepts of INTEGRAL and DIFERENCIATION first.
Sure, you can extrapolate a 3D “object” from the frames and the time component, but as a viewer you can only experience one frame at a time - you can only experience two of the dimensions. Just like an MRI scan can only scan in two dimensions at a time. So the video itself can be described as 3D as described in the video, which I guess is indeed what the title says, but we can only experience it two dimensions at a time.
@ if you're counting time as a visual dimension, then in life you are experiencing four dimensions, but generally people doesn't count time as a dimension. Visually you can only see in 2 dimensions anyway, with depth perception helping you perceive the third
@ In addition to what Professor Xwing said, I believe the argument in the video was that if you take the frames over time and “stack” them, then the video is actually a static 3D object that we are experiencing one layer at a time, moving through it as time progresses. So yes, we experience time, but that’s not one of the 3 spacial dimensions the video is talking about; it only USES time to extrapolate the third spacial dimension. But yeah, if you count time as equal to the two obvious spacial dimensions, then you could say we experience those 3 dimensions, aka “3D” even though it’s still missing a spacial dimension as we experience it
@@DarthPlagueisDaily yeah but he wrote 3d not 3 spacial dimentions. that's why i suppose he meant to say that videos are 3d for the time component, even though time is just a passive perception. he uses that editing trick to convert time into depth.
@@BobRossCat **music continues in the background** What if what you're seeing here was in fact me. That's right it was me Michael Stevens all along, bet you didn't know about that. How you ask? Well if you're so keen on finding it out then come with me on a journey to the wonderful world of technology... and beard shaving.
I have below average IQ and I think I understood; individual photos of a video are flat two dimensional slices of a three dimensional object like chunks in a Minecraft world. Therefore a whole video can be turned into a map. The MRI example was used so you see the similarities, where a 3d photo of a head was sliced into many different parts so people can go through and check if there are any problems and determine what it is.
No, the video is in the negative z demintion, and we are in the positive z demintion. So, it's still three demintions. Just like the 3D video games. The point 0 of the z demintion is your screen.
why? cause time should be a dimension? I suppose so. Because the universe as an entire system is deterministic, a viewer of it could fast forward/rewind it. And so put the universe in some 4D graph, and voila! Also, pretty sure there are many super complex and interesting theories about the dimensions of the universe and what-not.
@@jamsanator0511 it's actual excuses explaining 3D videos to distract you from realizing this video is 2D. There is 3D 360° videos on UA-cam. This isn't one tho
"Hey Vsauce, Micheal here. " "Right now, this video you are watching is in 2d. Or is it?" (Vsauce music plays) "Every pixel on your screen right now has the x and y coordinates, no suprise there. But there's a third coordinate. TIME. You see, this video is moving, right? Wrong! If you pause and unpause really quickly, you will find that this video is made from frames. It only gives the ILLUSION of motion. The faster your frames per second, the stronger the illusion. The slower your frame rate, the weaker the illusion." ".............................." ."..........................." And as all ways, thanks for watching.
@PizzaLover42Q No. We are mere shadows of time. Allow me to explain further We are 3D and our shadows are 2D. Our shadows move when we do. In the same way Time is 4D and we are 3D. We move when time moves. So we are shadows of a 4D being
So a 5th-dimensional being would see our universe as a 4D "block" of temporal continuum with one side of it being the past and the other the future, much like how the 2D plane of the video was displayed as a 3D object with the dimensions of x, yand t.
Beyond the joke, nope. The 3 other dimensions are changing over time. As a result the 3 dimensions we see are kind of a "function" of time. Time however is unaffected by these 3 other dimensions. As such we can't really say the universe is 4D IMO. However we could store history as a 4D data, definitely. Same for the video really. The video is 2D, only its raw data is 3D! These are all my personal take on it at least.
By this logic virtual reality is 19 dimensional you have your standard x y and z coordinates for the head set and both controllers which we will call x y and z for the headset rx ry and rz for the right controller and lx ly and lz for the left controller but we’re still not done we then have the angle for each of these we will call it xa ya and za for the headset rxa rya and rza for the right controller lxa lay and lza for the left controller then finally we have time which we will call t so an ordered pair for this will look like (x, y, z, rx, ry, rz, lx, ly, lz, xa, ya, za, rxa, rya, rza, lxa, lya, lza, t) P.S. this took way more time than it should’ve
It's fascinating that you point this out. In the research done in my group, we study how light propagates through a non-linear medium. The math of this system is equivalent to that of how a two dimensional gas of photons behaves as a function of time. The ideas you present in this video are a super cool way of popularizing that concept!
Because treating time as a dimension is not common sense when we are used to only talk about spatial dimensions. We live in 4D by the way. xyzt. But t is not spatial. So no one except scientists care about that much.
It was time as fourth and gravitation as fifth, right? Don't remember it that clearly. Hell, I'm going to re-watch Interstellar now, the movie is so good
@@zd3945 Since time = changing 3d space (changing over time), changing those spaces (at a moment in time) changes the past. In the movie it's just the bookshelf room and its various 'points' through time.
Each pixel has 3 dimensions itself, (red/green/blue values), and then you have the 2 dimensions of a single frame, then a single temporal dimension, then 3 dimensions for the cross section of the video in a 3d space, so in total we have 9 dimensions for a single video.
I agree and I think this is an important thought to follow. I think the time warp he demonstrated is an extremely intuitive way to depict it in the real world. I can imagine the grain of wood rippling through the surface for the same reason
In other words, imagine printing out every single frame of a video and stacking them up by their order. Next, instead of looking at each frame at a time like a reasonable person, you can cut through the stack at any angle and when you look at it from top (Or wherever the frames are facing) you will see a bit of each frame you just cut through. From proper perspective it'll look like one frame merged from many different frames. That's what he's talking about but in more abstract way.
Do you remember the Matrix effect? Where they built an array of cameras and shot a scene from different directions at the same time. Then put the images into a movieclip with the result of a flight around an image from one specific timestamp? Well, this is pretty much the same but in the other direction. You can see in one image information from different timestamps. And you can do this for a bunch of images and put them in a movieclip as well.
When I saw the title I thought "Hm. I have an idea what he would say, but I don't actually think he will say this" Cgmatter: *says what I thought* Me: You know, I'm something of a scientist myself
I've been thinking about doing this for two decades. Rainbow on their Bent Out of Shape album had some photography like this and LightWave has the ability to render over the last frame rendered (like pointing a camera at the screen diplaying it's output) and so having a moving strip could render one frame very slowly. Blender makes this WAY quicker!!!
Thats sort of a lame cop out though, as we live in a 3D reality, all things have depth on some level, even paper. What we consider “2D” is more so reffering to objects which we do not observe depth as a factor towards the observation of said thing
I think it's only considered 2.5 D if you can travel in only 1 temporal direction. Since you can travel forwards and backwards time-wise in a video, ig it's still technically 3 D
The dimensions define position of a point. X and y are dimensions because they define a position between 0% and 100% of the width/height. Time makes sense of as a dimension because it is between 0% and 100% of the video length. Color channel doesn't make sense as a dimension because its not a sequential value that defines a position. A color might represent a position in a color wheel but this is not the same as saying it represents a position in the video.
Dont be fooled people. What makes something trully 3D is width, length and height. (This man does have a point tho, that time is a variable in the 3D plane we reside in, but he is missing one thing). Just like a still image a video gives you the illusion of a 3D environment by projecting to our eyes contrast which fools our eyes into thinking about shadows "which are one of the primordial attributes of the way we percieve a 3D world through our eyes", then unlike a still image video also gives us movement in "recorded" time "which fools our brain to think that things are happening and moving", you see, what is really happening in a video is that things already happened and already moved (typically with only the expetion of streaming a live video, then are you experiencing movement as it happens in real time "but still in a 2D plane"). This man is confused about the fact that video also creates the illusion of time by recording movement across time in frames, we can prove this is a recording and not true time because we can pause it, play it, reverse it, and also edit it in many ways. Unlike the real 3D plane we live in, where time is not recorded and it moves infinitely forward and never backwards, we can never rewind past events nor we can edit true time, it just happens and we cannot do anything about it but record it and utilize tools to edit those recordings. You cannot reach in and touch the person in the video, not you can smell them or even hear them if the video has no audio recorded as well.
@@TheTruthIsFire I legit thought that as well and almost didnt even post this comment because I hate having to write so much to try and express what I'm thinking. Which half of the time I dont even know.
Nope, dimensions don't have to be spatial, just measurable (and preferably correlate). You can even translate them into different dimensions. Such as a graph being a 2d representation where 2 values are expressed and projected along 2 spatial axes.
Really thought this was gonna be a "technicality" video, something along the lines of "pixels and screens have depth, therefore videos are 3d" Pleasantly surprised to the contrary
video is 5d not 4d
7D chess.
9d
No d
Well, every pixel has 3 dimensions, one for each color, that with some times an alpha channel, and the video's 3 dimensions, it actually has 6-7 dimensions
this video is xD
Came for a Blender tutorial, left with a PHD in Space Engineering.
Sadman Naqueeb true
True
I wish I knew how to engineer space...
@@TheShadesOfBlack everyone does, bro. but you'd probably have to engineer that shit on a quantum level and it'd make no sense and would be very hard and boring
Right
This guy: video is 3D
Me: “puts on 3D glasses”
Imma leave it at 69 likes
so.....is it 3D?
3D + 3D = 6D ? :0, How looks the 6th Dimension?
@@pvs_np i like to think in minecraft anvil logic so this man be seeing in the 4th dimension (the actual reason being because adding length, width, and height with length, width, and time only gives you length, width, height, and time)
HAHA I THOUGHT EXACTLY THAT xD
I thought he was talking about the "Pulfrich effect" which was explained by Tom Scott in some video
In all the languages in the universe , he chose to speak facts
underrated
overused
OVERRULED
Stfu
@@Hritik9000 who? and also 1st amendment over rules sooo
i thought this was an april joke until i looked at the day release
:C
Yeah, 8 months ago make us think it's april. UA-cam time is confusing.
@@VlidOnTheLead Not really, technically the day release is correct
Boi this is three minutes long
are you dumb
he was a week early
He sounds like both a conspiracy theorist and motivational speaker..
Yes you're right
And the funny thing is that he is just talking about calculus
conapiracy theory is 3D not 2D
Lol
Thats pretty much vsauce
my brain during math exam: "how do i delete cube?"
my brain when iam trying to sleep:
2D math class
Cube*0 = deleted. There.
Sounds like a surreal meme
*How to delete çübê*
@@nuclearshorts1243 it is an everyday thing if you use blender
I am*
My brain hurts
Same
Ur brain is too small
First song name anyone knows please?
@@dictater4506 yes, i thought it too 😬
Me too
1:45 WHY DOES HE SOUND LIKE HE'S RAPPING TO THE BEAT EXPLAINING TIME DISPLACEMENT
anyone know the name of the beat?
Now I can't not hear it anymore
Bro
It’s on beat but it isn’t, like when you try to fit two beats in one
@@thundergaming1719 I cannot forget you yet - SLYRAX
*It's official. CGMatt has trascended our narrow dimensions of time and space*
Einstein: *this boy deserves a medal*
He basically became MCU Dr. Strange 1:39
This is like calculus for people who don't wanna learn calculus lol
More like linear algebra
@@metalenergy1998 Idk, it's in calculus vol 3 (James Stewart)
The transformation seems to be very simple to be linear algebra
Still 2d since it's still on a screen. Heck, all 3d objects on a screen are 2d, we merely make a projection to get the idea of 3d, but they're still 2d. Time is not a dimension, it can be "dimensioned", but when we try to "tridimensionalize" or "bidimensionalize" they are still projections or just new representations of something naturaly intangible to our compreension. Another thing to point out is just that he did not specify if he's talking about spatial dimensions or physical dimensions (both will be mostly misconceptualized, but it's just arguably wrong) or maths conception of dimension which it seems to have a very less important meaning and could be used in his explanation, but it that way we can only be talking about projections. It's a nice gimmick tough.
@@louisalex98 No dude. "Dimensions" is a college topic, and the explanation made by the video was right bro.
You can search for "Calculus Vol. 3" and you'll find the material that explains why everything in the video was correct, even if it's simplified. But you'll NEED to know the concepts of INTEGRAL and DIFERENCIATION first.
@@louisalex98 What happens in a frame of a video is called "Level set"
Sure, you can extrapolate a 3D “object” from the frames and the time component, but as a viewer you can only experience one frame at a time - you can only experience two of the dimensions. Just like an MRI scan can only scan in two dimensions at a time. So the video itself can be described as 3D as described in the video, which I guess is indeed what the title says, but we can only experience it two dimensions at a time.
But aren't we experiencing time tho
@ if you're counting time as a visual dimension, then in life you are experiencing four dimensions, but generally people doesn't count time as a dimension. Visually you can only see in 2 dimensions anyway, with depth perception helping you perceive the third
@ In addition to what Professor Xwing said, I believe the argument in the video was that if you take the frames over time and “stack” them, then the video is actually a static 3D object that we are experiencing one layer at a time, moving through it as time progresses. So yes, we experience time, but that’s not one of the 3 spacial dimensions the video is talking about; it only USES time to extrapolate the third spacial dimension. But yeah, if you count time as equal to the two obvious spacial dimensions, then you could say we experience those 3 dimensions, aka “3D” even though it’s still missing a spacial dimension as we experience it
@@DarthPlagueisDaily yeah but he wrote 3d not 3 spacial dimentions. that's why i suppose he meant to say that videos are 3d for the time component, even though time is just a passive perception. he uses that editing trick to convert time into depth.
Not necessarily. We experience the flow of time ourselves as well.
I almost thought this was a vsauce video.
Until he insults us.
... Or is it?
@@ParodieHecker-mobile *music*
@@BobRossCat
**music continues in the background**
What if what you're seeing here was in fact me. That's right it was me Michael Stevens all along, bet you didn't know about that. How you ask? Well if you're so keen on finding it out then come with me on a journey to the wonderful world of technology... and beard shaving.
He's too fast talker
I don't know why tf this got recommended and wtf is he talking about, but I watched it till the end
This is super relatable
I have below average IQ and I think I understood;
individual photos of a video are flat two dimensional slices of a three dimensional object like chunks in a Minecraft world. Therefore a whole video can be turned into a map. The MRI example was used so you see the similarities, where a 3d photo of a head was sliced into many different parts so people can go through and check if there are any problems and determine what it is.
@@ruller8901 okay so a video is more like a object
@@finleyisraarfraser8579 I think thats what the guy in the video meant
Same
He sounds like he's saying something really important & saying absolutely nothing at the same time.
He just meant we are potato.
Filmschool: *Video is 2D*
CGMatter: *I am 4 parallel universes ahead of you!*
"school" is a general education facility for 1-11 class students.
@@brutal6129 nobody asked
Time to build up some speed by backwards long jumping to achieve this great amount of knowledge
@@mauricestardddude8317 sm64 best game ever lowkey
I don’t even do editing. This was in my recommended.
I am satisfied.
Same
Afcourse not, how would you fit a computer in the kitchen with all those fancy electronics you have there?
@@zejdland 🤣🤣
Same
I thought this was a fun fact video not an editing video
Ok sure
Here before 12 likes
Checkmark
Hello verified dude
Ok why?
0:27 moving your phone with him is so trippy
I think you gave me a seizure
My head hurts now
Ok
Day 12 of quarantine :
Haha
True
@Syko you don't need to be infected to respect the quarantine lol
Day 104 and time is already meaningless
Noob. Month 7 of quarrntine
tHiS iS wHeRe It StArTs GeTtInG rEaLlY rEaLlY tRiPpY
as if it wasnt before
With that logic, we are living in the fourth dimension
well most the time when people speak about dimensions in real life they dont consider temporal dimensions
No, the video is in the negative z demintion, and we are in the positive z demintion.
So, it's still three demintions.
Just like the 3D video games.
The point 0 of the z demintion is your screen.
Agreed.
His logic makes no sense at all.
He's calling The Space-Time forth dimension!
We are indeed
why? cause time should be a dimension?
I suppose so. Because the universe as an entire system is deterministic, a viewer of it could fast forward/rewind it. And so put the universe in some 4D graph, and voila!
Also, pretty sure there are many super complex and interesting theories about the dimensions of the universe and what-not.
I understand literally none of anything that was said.
Yea same
I am far too stupid to understand what he’s even talking about.
I only understand that were seeing a 2d images to make 3d video as shown on demonstration but yeah im at loss aswell
@@jamsanator0511 it's actual excuses explaining 3D videos to distract you from realizing this video is 2D.
There is 3D 360° videos on UA-cam. This isn't one tho
Yea I'm too stupid to understand
Summary: This video is 3d which is being watched on a 2d screen
you're the blender community's equivalent to VSauce
Yeah this right here
Song name?
First one
😂😂 u are right
"Hey Vsauce, Micheal here. "
"Right now, this video you are watching is in 2d. Or is it?"
(Vsauce music plays)
"Every pixel on your screen right now has the x and y coordinates, no suprise there. But there's a third coordinate. TIME. You see, this video is moving, right? Wrong! If you pause and unpause really quickly, you will find that this video is made from frames. It only gives the ILLUSION of motion. The faster your frames per second, the stronger the illusion. The slower your frame rate, the weaker the illusion."
".............................."
."..........................."
And as all ways, thanks for watching.
Captain Disillusion has been really quiet since this came out...
Vsauce has been real quiet since this dropped...
Sike you thought
Never doubt me
@@captaindisillusion1549 you created an account just to find this comment and reply, that is commitment
@@captaindisillusion1549 did they really think we weren't gonna Show up
@@vsauce607 we ain't gonna miss out on this
Me :"So is this video 2d?"
Cgmatter:"Well yes but also no"
I feel the illusion
hello
hello
Why do people like this guy's comment its not even that funny
@@danendraaryadewa5455 he tries to comment as much as he can so people will check hid channel
WHY ARE YOU EVERYWHERE
*Passes blunt*
CGMatter: You know there's that dimension of time
The 4th dimension is time
@PizzaLover42Q No. We are mere shadows of time. Allow me to explain further
We are 3D and our shadows are 2D. Our shadows move when we do. In the same way
Time is 4D and we are 3D. We move when time moves. So we are shadows of a 4D being
@PizzaLover42Q we are affected by it but can only ever see one part of it like if you were 2 dimensional you'd see things as 1 dimension
i can actually understand what youre saying lmao
So a 5th-dimensional being would see our universe as a 4D "block" of temporal continuum with one side of it being the past and the other the future, much like how the 2D plane of the video was displayed as a 3D object with the dimensions of x, yand t.
no
Repdo Derpo yes
Beyond the joke, nope. The 3 other dimensions are changing over time. As a result the 3 dimensions we see are kind of a "function" of time. Time however is unaffected by these 3 other dimensions. As such we can't really say the universe is 4D IMO. However we could store history as a 4D data, definitely. Same for the video really. The video is 2D, only its raw data is 3D! These are all my personal take on it at least.
By this logic virtual reality is 19 dimensional you have your standard x y and z coordinates for the head set and both controllers which we will call x y and z for the headset rx ry and rz for the right controller and lx ly and lz for the left controller but we’re still not done we then have the angle for each of these we will call it xa ya and za for the headset rxa rya and rza for the right controller lxa lay and lza for the left controller then finally we have time which we will call t so an ordered pair for this will look like (x, y, z, rx, ry, rz, lx, ly, lz, xa, ya, za, rxa, rya, rza, lxa, lya, lza, t)
P.S. this took way more time than it should’ve
@@person4119 Pretty much fully agree with this demonstration by thought experiment ;)
It's fascinating that you point this out. In the research done in my group, we study how light propagates through a non-linear medium. The math of this system is equivalent to that of how a two dimensional gas of photons behaves as a function of time. The ideas you present in this video are a super cool way of popularizing that concept!
That's so cool. I understood everything you said.
@@dizzypear I cant tell if you're sarcastic or genuinely being nice.😂
The concept of 3D time is fascinating, baffles me it isn't considered more seriously. Hopefully this sparks a few conversations.
I also completely understood everything you said
Maybe just me but i didnt understand anything
This guy turned what could have been a whole 10 minute long vsauce video, into a 3 minute speedrun of explaining that time is basically width.
True, but vsauce would be far less condescending
Vsauce would be like DO YOU HAVE EYES?
I love how condescending this is, it's great!
You caught that too...
2D, 3D, 4D, 5D.....
They all are temporary
*INITIAL D* IS FOREVER
Will of D. Is forever
AND DOOM IS *ETERNAL*
@@lon34ngel20 **sigh**
@@sooryan_1018 I feel you bro 😪
@@TecheyyXD you do?!
Wait why do I genuinely understand this I feel like the odd one out
Because treating time as a dimension is not common sense when we are used to only talk about spatial dimensions. We live in 4D by the way. xyzt. But t is not spatial. So no one except scientists care about that much.
@@Supernoxus Probably a lot more intuitive for also math-inclined people and programmers too
math teacher: the exam isn't that complicated!
the exam:
2:09 a default cube was saved.
Not saved. Spared. Spared so that it can explain to its creators that the end has come. That the Blenderers are coming to *all of them.*
No, it was brought to the REAL third dimension
The Weighted Default Cube will never threaten to delete you.
Default Cube: Salvation
2021.04.20
I have deleted the default cube so many times I've lost count.
Then I typically add in a new one and delete it later anyways.
"Other people didn't know this?" - A physicist, probably
This man turned the whole universe to 4d era by just deleting default cube in Blender...
p.s. 5d era
*Adds NurbsCube* M U R P H
this video is going to blow up and be in my recommended in let’s say 7 years
Is it back in your recomended yet?
although its just been 7 months-
Nah, 7 months.
Yes and its 1:10 am for me now
Nah, its just 5 years. Why does everything on the Internet here seem like before COVID-23?
Yep lol
Finally a video where he crams as much useful info as possible in 3min
When that one smart kinda guy in engineering college blasts through the fattest blunt in the dorm
In case noone understood interstellar, this is what mcconaughey was experiencing in the black hole - time as a fourth spatial dimension
It was time as fourth and gravitation as fifth, right? Don't remember it that clearly. Hell, I'm going to re-watch Interstellar now, the movie is so good
@@crankletsplay1 you are right
I STILL DONT UNDERSTAND
@@crankletsplay1 Im not sure about gravitation, dont remember aha. But time would still have to exist so theres got to be at least 5.
@@zd3945 Since time = changing 3d space (changing over time), changing those spaces (at a moment in time) changes the past. In the movie it's just the bookshelf room and its various 'points' through time.
Each pixel has 3 dimensions itself, (red/green/blue values), and then you have the 2 dimensions of a single frame, then a single temporal dimension, then 3 dimensions for the cross section of the video in a 3d space, so in total we have 9 dimensions for a single video.
0:00 music name is called
Puresonique - Midnight (Original Version)
Thanks
Oh you know the music to this video?
Name the music at 1:36
@@crucifiedbread.mp371 i'm looking for it too
Спасибо тебе от всего беларуского народа!🙌
Thank you from all the Belarusian people!
@@TheSlowPokeGuy32 ОР
Me trying to explain why you should round my 27 percent grade to 60 percent
😂
this video is two multiverses ahead of us not one
My brain whenever I’m on the toilet:
Edit: 1k likes? Seriously? This is insane! Ty guys :D
Shower*
Funeral*
I'm shitting rn
*Math class
Night*
Why does this feel like it's uploaded 10 years ago?
Because it has! This 3d video just appeared in my recommended. Its older than Covid-28!
I have no idea what emotion to feel other than mind blown and it infuriates me
Legend has it we live in a simulation created by this man in the node editor of Blender.
in less than 50 seconds of course
He should bring our favorite video game things to life
Bruh
Instructions unclear: .etc file didn't work. Still stuck in 3d...
Fun fact: Everything you are capable of seeing is actually just a set of extremely fast frames.
I mean kinda but also not at all
I agree and I think this is an important thought to follow. I think the time warp he demonstrated is an extremely intuitive way to depict it in the real world. I can imagine the grain of wood rippling through the surface for the same reason
well, actually no... not at all infact
This is probably one of the best standards I've seen for what a UA-cam video should be.
CG Matt in next video: How to create a Time machine inside blender without any third party plugin.
its been 8 months im still waiting
this man would literally say anything, and everyone would believe him
No idea wtf he tried to explain in the whole video.
Felt like my university class.
In other words, imagine printing out every single frame of a video and stacking them up by their order. Next, instead of looking at each frame at a time like a reasonable person, you can cut through the stack at any angle and when you look at it from top (Or wherever the frames are facing) you will see a bit of each frame you just cut through. From proper perspective it'll look like one frame merged from many different frames. That's what he's talking about but in more abstract way.
Do you remember the Matrix effect? Where they built an array of cameras and shot a scene from different directions at the same time. Then put the images into a movieclip with the result of a flight around an image from one specific timestamp?
Well, this is pretty much the same but in the other direction. You can see in one image information from different timestamps. And you can do this for a bunch of images and put them in a movieclip as well.
@@fittersitter ah man...I'm trying to pull off a Matrix type slow mo around the body shot...almost got it...
It is like eating a kit kat without splitting it in half.
Kakss good explanation👍
My brain almost melted when taking in the amount of compressed knowledge this 3 minute video contained.
Technically the pixel is a 3D object but your viewing the object in 2d since you see in 2d with everything.
When I saw the title I thought "Hm. I have an idea what he would say, but I don't actually think he will say this"
Cgmatter: *says what I thought*
Me: You know, I'm something of a scientist myself
I've been thinking about doing this for two decades. Rainbow on their Bent Out of Shape album had some photography like this and LightWave has the ability to render over the last frame rendered (like pointing a camera at the screen diplaying it's output) and so having a moving strip could render one frame very slowly. Blender makes this WAY quicker!!!
Underrated album.
A temporal dimension is not like a spatial dimension
2:46 You're very welcome.
Me: hearing displacement
My brain: IT'S BLENDER TIME
YAAAAAAA
When someone says time is a spacial axis I already know they are just trying to sound smart.
Oh my god, what was that amazing music used here???
Tetrini it’s called strange stuff it’s by matt harris
did the "well yes,but actually no" meme die?
0:58
@@cameron5567 You didn't get the joke
Yes, it is no longer a meme
It is apart of my vocabulary now
@@cameron5567 bruh.
@@odeixx im so sorry i was stupid 8 months ago 😭😭😭
@@cameron5567 samee 😭
When someone states the dimensions of an object, temporal dimension is occluded and only spatial dimensions are considered
thank you cgmatter for another quality moving picture
"Video is 3d. Not 2d"
People who watch with hologram: [Laugh in 4d]
Time is seperate from spacial dimensions. Yes, video does have two dimensions with another, but it is two spacial and one time dimension.
Actually video is 3D, every led in your screen has a depth. Sooo...
Yeah I was gonna say that
Thats sort of a lame cop out though, as we live in a 3D reality, all things have depth on some level, even paper. What we consider “2D” is more so reffering to objects which we do not observe depth as a factor towards the observation of said thing
@@prop3297 yeah man I really meant that. We can't even imagine D and we are talking about understanding 4D ;)
@@doguzkaan fair enou
1:16 this is what you would see if you traveled at the speed of light.
I finally understand "Tenet"
Is this 3D
Me: *no, but actually yes.*
did you get the meme right?
me:yes, but actually no
@@coma_flotante Did YOU get the meme right?
me: Well yes, but actually no.
It's 2.5 D
I think it's only considered 2.5 D if you can travel in only 1 temporal direction. Since you can travel forwards and backwards time-wise in a video, ig it's still technically 3 D
@@bobbill7879 So real life is 3.5D
@@d9zirable Yup!
@@bobbill7879 nope.
Just because you can't move back in time doesn't mean that that direction doesn't exist.
@@d9zirable Edit: Nope!
Quiet kid has grown-up so fast
2:04 Great, i'll just donate -1dollar.
You owe me a dollar now...
I didn't understand half of what this guy is saying
The entire time i was like: i like ur funny words magic man 👁👄👁
I thought it would be a silly gimmick, and it was, but cooler than I thought.
I thought you were gonna talk about how light has to travel to your eyes
I lost it when he started speaking Chinese!
what
He really gave a 2D video a Z coordinate
This actually taught me shit wow
Can't wait for this to get recommended to everyone
How did you know ?
(I asked stupidly)
@@samito8742 How did he know?
(You asked stupidly)
Same with our physical reality. 3 spatial co-ordinates and 1 temporal co-ordinate
Video is 4D. Frames, Color Channels, Height, Width.
Eric Engelhart Frames ARE Color Channels.... without Frames there are no color channels and vice versa
@@kunemann static images have color channels but no frames, black-and-white video has frames but (arguably) no color channels
The dimensions define position of a point. X and y are dimensions because they define a position between 0% and 100% of the width/height. Time makes sense of as a dimension because it is between 0% and 100% of the video length. Color channel doesn't make sense as a dimension because its not a sequential value that defines a position. A color might represent a position in a color wheel but this is not the same as saying it represents a position in the video.
Dont be fooled people.
What makes something trully 3D is width, length and height.
(This man does have a point tho, that time is a variable in the 3D plane we reside in, but he is missing one thing).
Just like a still image a video gives you the illusion of a 3D environment by projecting to our eyes contrast which fools our eyes into thinking about shadows "which are one of the primordial attributes of the way we percieve a 3D world through our eyes", then unlike a still image video also gives us movement in "recorded" time "which fools our brain to think that things are happening and moving", you see, what is really happening in a video is that things already happened and already moved (typically with only the expetion of streaming a live video, then are you experiencing movement as it happens in real time "but still in a 2D plane").
This man is confused about the fact that video also creates the illusion of time by recording movement across time in frames, we can prove this is a recording and not true time because we can pause it, play it, reverse it, and also edit it in many ways.
Unlike the real 3D plane we live in, where time is not recorded and it moves infinitely forward and never backwards, we can never rewind past events nor we can edit true time, it just happens and we cannot do anything about it but record it and utilize tools to edit those recordings.
You cannot reach in and touch the person in the video, not you can smell them or even hear them if the video has no audio recorded as well.
This long as hell
@@TheTruthIsFire I legit thought that as well and almost didnt even post this comment because I hate having to write so much to try and express what I'm thinking. Which half of the time I dont even know.
Nope, dimensions don't have to be spatial, just measurable (and preferably correlate). You can even translate them into different dimensions. Such as a graph being a 2d representation where 2 values are expressed and projected along 2 spatial axes.
This is one of those videos that are like wow what a journey after watching and then you just sit back and think
"10D = X × Y × T × Z × Time × Weather × Color"
-Me
Well I’m blind in one eye so that makes everything in my life two dimensional I have a disorder called Arctic nerve hypoplasia
Guess you'll have to substitute with time displacement
That sucks
This video is too smart, I can't even skip it.
Don't worry guys, we'll come back here in 7 years.
2:37 - flashbang alert
Encoding-wise, yeah. The programs try their best to treat a video content as 3D
UA-cam recommended is a very weird thing
This 3d is actually 2d
You're 2D, this is real 3D.
lol.
Really thought this was gonna be a "technicality" video, something along the lines of "pixels and screens have depth, therefore videos are 3d"
Pleasantly surprised to the contrary
Whats the name of the music? I love it!
DifficultIns1de it’s called strange stuff it’s by matt harris
@@Star-tr3vd thankssss