The Making Of The Western Mind | Tom Holland

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 чер 2024
  • In this conversation, John joins Tom Holland in his London home to discuss Christianity’s role in shaping Western civilisation. Holland prompts us to reflect on the intricate moral web our society still upholds today and consider the intertwined history of the Western imagination and Christianity. John and Tom also discuss cyclical patterns seen through the historical record, the notable decline of Christian faith and the impact of increasing secularisation.
    Tom Holland is an award-winning historian, author and broadcaster. He is the author of many award-winning books on topics ranging from Ancient Rome and the Persian Empire to the origins of the Islamic faith. Despite his non-belief, Holland’s most recent book, Dominion, is a sweeping account of the impact of Christianity on foundational Western institutions, constitutional norms, morality and social outlooks. It is one of the most compelling histories of Christendom yet written.
    Tom Holland served two years as the Chair of the Society of Authors and is Chair of the British Library’s PLR Advisory Committee. Holland is the presenter of BBC Radio 4’s Making History. He has written and presented a number of TV documentaries, for the BBC and Channel 4, on subjects ranging from ISIS to dinosaurs. He is also the host of a widely popular history podcast called The Rest Is History.
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    00:00 Intro
    0:45 Introducing Tom Holland
    2:19 Appeal of History, and human nature
    6:59 History as facts and fiction
    12:04 The decline of Christian faith
    18:35 How has Christianity changed over time
    28:43 Importance of The Cross
    33:53 Foundation of Western moral judgements
    37:17 Secularisation of Christian ideas
    43:02 Deconstructing symbols and embodiments
    48:43 Cycles of Western History
    58:20 Alternate views
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Conversations feature John Anderson, former Deputy Prime Minister of Australia, interviewing the world's foremost thought leaders about today's pressing social, cultural and political issues.
    John believes proper, robust dialogue is necessary if we are to maintain our social strength and cohesion. As he puts it; "You cannot get good public policy out of a bad public debate."
    If you value this discussion and want to see more like it, make sure you subscribe to the channel here: / @johnandersonconversat...
    And stay right up to date with all the conversations by subscribing to the newsletter here: johnanderson.net.au/contact/
    Follow John on Twitter: / johnandersonac
    Follow John on Facebook: / johnandersonac
    Support the channel: johnanderson.net.au/support/
    Website: johnanderson.net.au/
    Podcast: johnanderson.net.au/podcasts/
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Follow Tom Holland
    Twitter: holland_tom?ref_s...
    The Rest Is History Podcast
    Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/7Cvsbcj...
    Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 375

  • @GhostPrefix
    @GhostPrefix 11 місяців тому +30

    Tom fast becoming one of my favourite thinkers. Great discussion.

  • @petesmith9472
    @petesmith9472 Рік тому +34

    Tom’s podcast with Dominic is the most entertaining, dare I say addictive, podcasts available. It’s called “The Rest is History” and it will have you literally laughing out loud.

  • @StanEby1
    @StanEby1 Рік тому +31

    "Literature adds to reality, it does not simply describe it. It enriches the necessary competencies that daily life requires and provides; and in this respect, it irrigates the deserts that our lives have already become." C. S. LEWIS

  • @hazchemel
    @hazchemel Рік тому +37

    Thank you so much. In a non-religious setting, a free and public discourse, with respect and carefully chosen words, a significant mind addresses the actual root of civilisation, the very mansion of our culture.

  • @chadjohns6955
    @chadjohns6955 Рік тому +67

    I've read 3 of Tom's books: In the Shadow of the Sword, Persian Fire, and Rubicon: Last Days of the Roman Empire, he's got such a talent for bringing history to life. Great author of our time

    • @starcapture3040
      @starcapture3040 Рік тому

      yeah but he is apologetic i can't wait for his next book the sword of christianity

    • @kafon6368
      @kafon6368 Рік тому

      *WHAAAT?!* he wrote that book? I have it! And he disparaged God (of Israel and by extension the God of Israel in Christ after the New Testament) many times. This man is a Christian?!
      I am so shocked right now...

    • @hempenasphalt1587
      @hempenasphalt1587 Рік тому +1

      @@kafon6368 he's not Christian. I think he says in this very video that he drifted out of the faith gradually.

    • @willr4849
      @willr4849 Рік тому

      You should read his Dominion book. It’s really good.

    • @voz805
      @voz805 Рік тому

      @@kafon6368 It's amazing you own that book since neither in Amazon nor Wiki, does it mention Mr. Holland wrote of book of that title.

  • @felicityhenderson6290
    @felicityhenderson6290 2 місяці тому +2

    Tom Holland is an amazingly articulate speaker, which makes his talks and interviews even more enjoyable.

  • @reneeshort2049
    @reneeshort2049 11 місяців тому +5

    Any educated person instinctively knows these things but it takes courage to stand up for your intellectual position. It broadens you and when shared can broaden others.

  • @williamhyman9213
    @williamhyman9213 9 місяців тому +9

    "The cross is such an odd thing to have as a focus of veneration", says Tom. I couldn't agree more. This is my introduction to Tom and I'm beginning to Tom and I'm beginning to like what he says very much.

    • @anomietoponymie2140
      @anomietoponymie2140 9 місяців тому +1

      Yes, it's what founded my feelings as a teen that there was something evil and sadistic about Christianity, seeing as how it worships a bloody tortured body. As an old woman, with a tortured body and an understanding that this is the common fate, I no longer see the cross as diabolic.

    • @rontimus
      @rontimus 5 місяців тому

      His writings have changed my life, I couldn't be more grateful

    • @marylut6077
      @marylut6077 4 місяці тому

      @@anomietoponymie2140you missed the point…god is worshipped for loving us, living among us to model how we should treat each other. As your body fails you, you may want to pray for life after death

  • @kaylenehousego8929
    @kaylenehousego8929 Рік тому +19

    You are such a fast learner John.
    I have been learning from you, for two years now, many thanks to you both.

    • @anomietoponymie2140
      @anomietoponymie2140 9 місяців тому

      And how was he as a politician? Very curious as to what you might think.

    • @kaylenehousego8929
      @kaylenehousego8929 9 місяців тому

      Not perfect like you n me .@@anomietoponymie2140

  • @gracegiven5093
    @gracegiven5093 Рік тому +15

    Excellent interview! I really enjoy listening to Tom Holland. He has a magnificent mind. Kudos to you, John, as well, for the inspiring dialogue.

    • @2msvalkyrie529
      @2msvalkyrie529 9 місяців тому

      Unfortunately his voice is irritating.!

  • @xophermc
    @xophermc Рік тому +25

    Great interview! Tom was at his sharpest.

  • @isabelhernaez4617
    @isabelhernaez4617 Рік тому +9

    Always learning with you John, forever grateful.

  • @JeansiByxan
    @JeansiByxan Рік тому +16

    Dominion is a brilliant book, both sophisticated and easy to read. Even if you don't like reading history you might want to give it a try. But take it slow if you want to get something out of it.

  • @kbeetles
    @kbeetles Рік тому +9

    Interesting times! Non-religious people from various walks of life are beginning to lament on how a desacralised way of life and ideologies are a dead end. For the onlooker it appears to be almost synchronised... - the Lord is a great master of timing!

    • @daneumurianpiano7822
      @daneumurianpiano7822 Рік тому +1

      If you'll pardon the US football analogy, one of my songs goes, "'Keep running, Donald [Donald Driver, the former Green Bay Packer wide receiver]. 'I can't see the football.' 'Keep running anyhow.'" Brett Favre's pass would be so accurate and the planned play would be so beautiful that Driver, on a dead run, would simply have to look up and reach up, and the ball would be there, synchroniz/sing two separate "walks" of life.

  • @thagreatadante
    @thagreatadante Рік тому +11

    Bought the book last year... No stone unturned. Great read.

  • @b.alexanderjohnstone9774
    @b.alexanderjohnstone9774 Рік тому +54

    This fellow writes excellent history, especially ancient history. So entertaining, yet scholarly.

    • @hazchemel
      @hazchemel Рік тому +1

      Interesting that some proportion of atheists are simply more inclined to think of God in ways that are not popularly or publicly represented; and thus can easily misidentify himself.

    • @dobbersanchez1185
      @dobbersanchez1185 5 місяців тому

      Probably entertaining, but hardly scholarly. As you could plausibly expect from an actual history scholar.

    • @dobbersanchez1185
      @dobbersanchez1185 5 місяців тому

      38:05 hahaha repudiated what Christians have enshrined? Hahah then why did the Catholic church enshrine the Nazis?
      Hahahah😂 oh please

  • @michaelrush6083
    @michaelrush6083 Рік тому +5

    Such a wonderful conversation. I love it thank you again

  • @zgobermn6895
    @zgobermn6895 Рік тому +3

    Loved Dominion. Always a pleasures listening to Tom H. Thanks!

  • @bfree2speak_freely48
    @bfree2speak_freely48 Рік тому +3

    Best discussion yet. So much food for thought.

  • @bill8784
    @bill8784 Рік тому +8

    Another great interview. Great fan of Tom Holland and his history podcast with Dominic Sandbrook. Bought several of his books over the years. Nice bookshelves.

    • @rhmendelson
      @rhmendelson Рік тому +1

      Thanks for mentioning this! I just looked it up. I listen to podcasts when I run, it sounds really interesting.

  • @thomassimmons1950
    @thomassimmons1950 Рік тому +3

    Absolutely, Profoundly Brilliant...thank you gentlemen!!

  • @das3841
    @das3841 Рік тому +1

    Wonderful conversation, thank you John

  • @womensrights3108
    @womensrights3108 Рік тому +2

    Brilliant, prophetic...Christian! 🔥🔥🔥
    Many Thanks John, Many Thanks Tom

  • @notlimey
    @notlimey Рік тому +7

    Tolkien had a very sophisticated idea of 'myth' which rejected the word as indicating something false, but rather as something intrinsically true but presented in a different fashion than that of science.

    • @daneumurianpiano7822
      @daneumurianpiano7822 Рік тому +1

      I believe he helped Lewis understand that Christianity is a myth that is true. The late Dr. H. Wilbert "Will" Norton of Wheaton College Graduate School translated John 14:6 as Jesus saying, "I am the Way, _both_ [Greek _kai_] the Truth and the Life."

    • @notlimey
      @notlimey Рік тому

      @@daneumurianpiano7822 I think I recall this point from the Carpenter biography of Tolkien

  • @aaronhanlon772
    @aaronhanlon772 Рік тому +5

    It is a fabulous book. Very well written and a very enjoyable read.

  • @davidvirtue139
    @davidvirtue139 Рік тому +11

    This is a great interview. Most appreciated. The triumph of the Christian Faith despite its cultured despisers comes across clearly. Love it.

  • @anjjincubus2913
    @anjjincubus2913 Рік тому +5

    Really enjoyed this and thank you for it. Can I just add it was made more enjoyable by there being no irritating adverts insane adverts.

  • @davidmackie8552
    @davidmackie8552 Рік тому +1

    Great respect for both speakers

  • @binyusuf4181
    @binyusuf4181 Рік тому +11

    This is a thought stimulating discussion.

  • @TheIceyeddy
    @TheIceyeddy Рік тому +13

    Be kind to one another. You never know what a person is going through unless you speak to them and try to understand their situation.✝

  • @pavelpergl7735
    @pavelpergl7735 Рік тому

    Great interview with my favorite writer TH.

  • @patrickselden5747
    @patrickselden5747 Рік тому

    Thanks for this fascinating and important conversation, gents.
    ☝️😎

  • @patriciaanderson3761
    @patriciaanderson3761 Рік тому +5

    We really appreciate your guests and topics John, but sometimes cannot hear, especially deep male voices. Can you alter your sound system to pick up the volume somehow.

  • @michaelfalsia6062
    @michaelfalsia6062 Рік тому +2

    Tom Holland I a very erudite and competent scholar. His books are all gems.

  • @seekerout
    @seekerout 7 місяців тому

    There are so many nuggets of insight here my mind is whirling.

  • @nathanngumi8467
    @nathanngumi8467 Рік тому +1

    A great discussion! I look forward to reading the book.

  • @nicksibly526
    @nicksibly526 Рік тому +4

    What Tom is really saying is that no matter how much the atheist/humanist types try to distance themselves from Christ, their efforts will be for naught as their very assumptions about human rights stem from Jesus. It's hilarious when you sit back and see it through Tom"s eyes.

    • @tambam7340
      @tambam7340 10 місяців тому

      Our Father has given us this joy 🙏💪😀

  • @MilkShake
    @MilkShake Рік тому +1

    Great talk!

  • @marylut6077
    @marylut6077 4 місяці тому

    Thought-provoking points, I will need to consider them before deciding if I agree

  • @dartharpy9404
    @dartharpy9404 Рік тому

    Great book and discussion

  • @hyweldda56
    @hyweldda56 Рік тому +51

    Superb interview. Tom is a first class historian but he misses the point re the resurrection and the power of the cross is not it’s ideal but its power to change people.

    • @linkes28
      @linkes28 Рік тому

      YES! you can operate from a Christian value system, but without Christ leading you, you are doomed to fail. That is why western civilization is failing. It's not enough to have Christian values you must submit your whole life to Christ. You must have a relationship with Him. You must repent. You must believe and have faith in him.
      We love because He loved us first. We give because He gave His life for us. Otherwise we're back at the old testament living under the law.

    • @jmy106
      @jmy106 10 місяців тому +2

      I think the distinction you make is more about what makes a Christian religious. You might be right tho.

    • @tambam7340
      @tambam7340 10 місяців тому

      His law will be written in their gentile hearts (whether ‘they’ know it or not) 🥰
      And Jesus comes with a sword next time… ⚔️

    • @kevwhufc8640
      @kevwhufc8640 9 місяців тому

      A sword of fire , like beric dondarian ( spelling?) in thrones.

    • @havefunbesafe
      @havefunbesafe Місяць тому

      Ideals are literally the agents of change.

  • @marcoaslan
    @marcoaslan 11 місяців тому +1

    Thank you Tom Holland for the effort and sacrifice.

  • @chopincam-robertpark6857
    @chopincam-robertpark6857 Рік тому +1

    excellent as usual

  • @bastiatintheandes4958
    @bastiatintheandes4958 9 місяців тому

    Brilliant interviewer!

  • @hgostos
    @hgostos Рік тому +2

    This is sooo good

  • @cloverkitkat6917
    @cloverkitkat6917 Рік тому

    Excellent, just ordered the book

  • @eleventeendogs
    @eleventeendogs Рік тому

    Fantastic interview. Technical point, turn up John's sound.

  • @robertmize327
    @robertmize327 Рік тому +1

    Thank you, gentleman. Our Creator is mighty indeed.

  • @leonboois5414
    @leonboois5414 9 місяців тому +1

    I may be 60, but I am not deaf, yet! I had no trouble hearing Tom, but Anderson, unlike in Triggernometry, for instance, he seemed to be mumbling here, talking to himself. I had to turn up the volume of my speakers to their maximum in order to hear him!

  • @rowlandharryweston6037
    @rowlandharryweston6037 Рік тому +2

    Tom Holland is wonderful

  • @jamespercy8506
    @jamespercy8506 Рік тому +1

    distributed cognition has flourished beyond measure in Christian grammar based societies. Enough of us think in terms of mutual benefit projects and embedding ourselves in projects larger than ourselves which, in turn are embedded in even greater projects, ultimately embedded in an inclusive, good faith open future infused with a generative benign spirit. Many are reluctant to see that sprit as God shining through the culmination of sufficient goodness.but it is most assuredly related to Christian grammar, whatever you chose to call it, and it is glorious.

  • @williamhyman9213
    @williamhyman9213 9 місяців тому +2

    Brilliant. A friend of mine has written a book called 'The Rebirthing of God', in which the current image and reality of the Christian Church is dying a death, only to be reborn in a far more mature form that is no longer fearful and small minded, locking out other wisdom traditions, and is no longer obsessed with original sin, but recognises original blessing and also recognises the sacredness of the Earth and the natural realm.

  • @andysamet4554
    @andysamet4554 Рік тому +1

    What a fascinating lense with which to look at the world. The bit about the WWII Germans was very intriguing. I had always accepted them as evil, but now knowing, thanks to Tom Holland, that this is simply because I was indoctrinated into a Christian way of thinking is going to force me to take a de novo look at the Germans, and reexamine what I think about them. I think we all must.

  • @frereM
    @frereM 8 місяців тому

    Mr. Anderson does us all a service through his open-mindedness. Tom Holland does us an even greater service by stimulating independent thought on the ideas he discusses without militancy.

  • @aaronhanlon772
    @aaronhanlon772 Рік тому +1

    I would love to see a long discussion between Holland and Peterson

  • @rivolinho
    @rivolinho Рік тому +2

    Oh look! It's the guy who guest's on top, top, top historian Dominic Sandbrook's podcast!

  • @BradZook
    @BradZook Рік тому +2

    Spider Man has been his best work to date.

  • @jimluebke3869
    @jimluebke3869 Рік тому +3

    Wedgewood's political slogan "Am I not a man and a brother?" is lifted directly from Paul's letter to Philemon (a slaveowner) about what to do with his escaped slave Onesimus who Paul had found.
    "12 I am sending him-who is my very heart-back to you. 13 I would have liked to keep him with me so that he could take your place in helping me while I am in chains for the gospel. 14 But I did not want to do anything without your consent, so that any favor you do would not seem forced but would be voluntary. 15 Perhaps the reason he was separated from you for a little while was that you might have him back forever- 16 no longer as a slave, but better than a slave, as a dear brother. He is very dear to me but even dearer to you, both *as a fellow man and as a brother* in the Lord."
    This is another example of just how radical Christianity is. Imagine if America's Fugitive Slave Act had been written on this actual Christian basis.

  • @tonyfrench2574
    @tonyfrench2574 Рік тому +2

    But to discriminate means to exercise judgement. To exercise judgement of good snd evil means to accept responsibility, yet, as a Christisn to admit one's imperfection. To admit one's imperfection while facing reality is to embrace the duality : awareness of God and God's grace.

  • @rogeralsop3479
    @rogeralsop3479 Рік тому +4

    I like and admire both these men.

  • @blairhakamies4132
    @blairhakamies4132 Рік тому

    Top! 🌹

  • @FreeAnalyst
    @FreeAnalyst Рік тому +4

    Interesting point made by Tom Holland about the idea of access to food being a fundamental human right coming from Christianity. He is nevertheless somewhat selective as to what he quotes from the Apostle Paul. After all, it was Paul who said “if a man does not choose to work, neither shall he eat.” 2 Thess 3:10.

    • @SidekickSam24
      @SidekickSam24 Рік тому +1

      Sounds like we shouldnt give people stuff just so they can continue to lay around and be lazy. We all need to strive toward a better version of ourselves, even the poor people.

    • @gianlucarossi5672
      @gianlucarossi5672 Рік тому +2

      He was also dead wrong and blasphemous for comparing Floyd to Jesus Christ.

    • @daneumurianpiano7822
      @daneumurianpiano7822 Рік тому

      ​@@SidekickSam24 It's called theistic evolution, or in the words of Francis Collins and his BioLogos Foundation, evolutionary creation. God instituted the beautiful system of evolution/"survival of the fittest," yet "occasionally" calls us to override it with unconditional love. Someone has put it, "Work as if it all depended on you. Pray as if it all depended on God." It does, and it does.

  • @eliteakm
    @eliteakm Рік тому

    I'm so glad u're meeting in person again. This webcam stuff was awful.

  • @CSUnger
    @CSUnger Рік тому +1

    “He who walks with wise men becomes wise
    but the companion of fools suffers harm” Proverbs 13:20

  • @craigwillms61
    @craigwillms61 Рік тому +14

    I was here in Minneapolis when G. Floyd died. I was struck by the Christ-like veneration and reaction supporting Floyd across the country and western world. Here a criminal tortured into submission by the all-powerful state, replayed the Crucifixion story before our eyes. However, Floyd was not a facsimile of Jesus, but rather an actual criminal many times in his life, nonetheless deserving mercy.

    • @ron88303
      @ron88303 Рік тому

      Daniel Shaver deserved mercy, too. Perhaps even more so since he appeared to try to comply with the all-powerful state's orders. But he was white, so who really cares.

    • @tatianasoto9828
      @tatianasoto9828 Рік тому

      The only people who would make a marter out of a man who at one point held a gun to a pregnant womans stomach our the reprobate minded Democrat/Socialist Americans the rest of us didnt agree w/ the knee on the neck but arent crying either cause its less of our tax payer money to feed and house a career criminal /drug addict...

    • @Romans8-9
      @Romans8-9 Рік тому

      Deserving mercy? He died in his sins. He is under condemnation/judgment from God as we speak.

    • @daneumurianpiano7822
      @daneumurianpiano7822 Рік тому

      Christianity Today magazine ran a piece titled "The Faith of George Floyd." Thomas Sowell, and Magatte Wade interviewed by Jordan Peterson, are among the black voices calling for, if I may borrow the words of Bill Milliken, "tough love."

    • @themsmloveswar3985
      @themsmloveswar3985 Рік тому

      Floyd was a hopeless sinner.
      The policeman who squeezed the life of him was a paranoid amateur, living in fear, and wrecking retribution on the moral enemy.
      Regarding race, one of the o the cops was Asian. The shopkeeper who reported Floyd was Asian.
      They were attempting to maintain order in an extremely violent, and confused society.

  • @Andrew-mv2qb
    @Andrew-mv2qb Рік тому +2

    I also have a problem when ‘human nature’ is thrown up in conversations to explain any particular thing. Human Nature: Anything that a human can do is human nature. Be it extremely harmful or extremely good, and everything in between. What is never discussed is that it is a choice what particular thing manifests. What you must recognise is that when you do not share a thought system, you are weakening it. Those who believe in it therefor perceive this as an attack on them. This is because everyone identifies them-self with there thought system, and every thought system centres on what you believe you are. If the centre of the thought system is true, only truth extends from it. But if a lie is at its centre, only deception proceeds from it. I Believe JC said this

  • @jimluebke3869
    @jimluebke3869 Рік тому +3

    "The king is subject to the same law as the lowest person in the land, and that we get from Christianity"
    Are you sure? It seems like the story of Brutus and Tarquin also reflects it, although Suetonius reports a certain backsliding that is the opposite of David's trajectory in his story with Uriah and Bathsheba.

  • @williamhyman9213
    @williamhyman9213 9 місяців тому

    What would would the fundamentalist Christians within the The Kings School and the other GPS schools think I wonder, John? Is there not still an arrogance exhibited amongst these elite schools that we no longer see in British schools of the genre. they have moved on. They are not bound by the limitations we here in Australia continue to impose on ourselves. It's time we grew up, and and became a little more sophisticated and aware of the how we fit into the world beyond trade. The depth of Tom's analysis and his breadth of knowledge seem to lead the way. His analysis is fresh, takes risks and is fearless, a quality Australians once had about 150 - 50 years ago. A great choice for an interview, John, but he's not answering your questions. He's moved beyond the questions.

  • @johndecker2987
    @johndecker2987 Рік тому +1

    BLM supporters would do well to listen to this fantastic interview.

  • @arielteixeira4306
    @arielteixeira4306 Рік тому +2

    Gosh! The world needs so much a talk between tom holland and Jordan Peterson

  • @user-vs6eb2zw2s
    @user-vs6eb2zw2s 10 місяців тому

    I listened to your podcast on Oppenheimer, and watched the movie yesterday, they did not make the scene of Oppenheimer forceful of kissing one young lady in the train when her fiancé out for smoking.

  • @corinaijac4381
    @corinaijac4381 11 місяців тому

    It's wonderfull to have a little device, so, despite of a poor knowlidge of the spoken, it's possible to see and listen diferent personalities. The one has his watch hidden, time does not exist, the other has his thin watch like the walk on a thin cord, visible, time has no patience.

  • @takeoischi4156
    @takeoischi4156 9 місяців тому

    having listened to every single episode of his podcast it's really weird seeing video of Tom. He doesn't look like what I thought he would

  • @nickvassiliou9340
    @nickvassiliou9340 9 місяців тому

    Prometheus created humans in the physical image of Gods before the Christian God ! A marvel to hear Mr Tom Holland anyway !

  • @stanphipps1650
    @stanphipps1650 Рік тому +1

    Good, humility and sacrifice that were characteristics of Wilberforce is so foreign to this current generation of moralists

  • @Jargonaut1159
    @Jargonaut1159 Рік тому +3

    Great interview and most interesting but I believe Tom makes a fundamental category error: 1. Jesus was not a 'victim' - He went to the cross willingly as a substitute for sinners, thereby defeating and making a spectacle of the forces of evil (vindicated by the resurrection, which if not true makes our faith futile and useless, as the Apostle says in 1 Corinthians 15:12-18); and 2. "The last shall be first" is not a political statement or mandate. It describes the voluntary attitude of Christ's followers to themselves and others. It is fundamentally a personal stance. Yes, it transforms society, but not because kings are de-throned and peasants made rulers (in fact, Proverbs warns against such a course) but because Christians and churches bless those around them, which was dramatically true from the very first days of the church, even when it had no power at all and was ruthlessly persecuted in both Palestine (first) and by the Romans (later).

  • @leebarry5686
    @leebarry5686 3 місяці тому

    A secular mindset can never understand the spirituality of Islam which is purely revealed but it accepts the function of human intellect within the domain of experience

  • @MaryEllenBryngelson
    @MaryEllenBryngelson Місяць тому

    Loved this...As for any changes of society, ideas can only go so far. Only the human heart, each heart--that has been given the freedom to 'say' yes to God (the Yes latent or blatant)--can participate in transforming and 'saving' the world....The No-sayers who choose to Be Like God in self-exalting rather than 'merely' human, made in God's image, are the self-deifiers...
    Superhumanism is all over the place, inside or outside of religions.
    The streak to individual power that resides in each heart--in its refusal of own creatureliness--is forever 'the problem'. Thanks to Life happening, that can bring one to hitting bottom, Dark Night of the soul, we each, sooner or later, have the occasion to turn our eyes to Something Transcendant 'up there'.....or close the heart, in a fist. God doesn't crash parties, but awaits invitation, or a simple 'Help!'...to come in, and galvanize with the power of the Cross, stronger than death and empires: Love!

  • @danieltodd1750
    @danieltodd1750 10 місяців тому +1

    Had anyone but Nietzsche and Žižek understood Hegel, they could have drawn the correct lessons which most people still don't appear to notice: to social animals, the primary impulse of empathy is directed toward individuals who display the greatest signals of neoteny, ie children and women. The mechanism of power is not physical force or threat of tyranny - that is a temporary power, and those who live by the sword shall die by the sword. Rather the lasting power is in him or her who can inspire the greatest empathy in the group and no one can do that better than the noble righteous victim. The Church had only one story - the story of an innocent man tortured and killed. And look at the power it wielded with that story. This is the power of wokeism, and the sooner people understand it, maybe we can have some hope in dealing with it. The pursuit of justice, the instinctive sense humans have to protect the weak, stems from our empathy towards children and those displaying neoteny; it is regulated by a social demand to fall in line in protecting children, then women, then the disabled and the weak, etc, and its author is not Christ. It's author is nature. But its weaponization is Christ. Gandhi took down the British Empire in a sack. MLK ended the American apartheid in the South. No story is more powerful than the woman who was unjustly assaulted sexually by her abusers. Entire rooms full of people fall silent when a survivor speaks. The brilliance of Christianity is to recognize that you can use psychological warfare against the biggest and most powerful army with a story of injustice. the moment you fight back when someone strikes you on one cheek you no longer retain your position of the noble victim and you are now someone capable of defending themselves losing immediately the sympathy that the group had instinctively to protect you. In other words it is our social impulses and instincts towards helping one another that is weaponized when the victim is so obviously and transparently displayed before us which is why icons and Christianity are so important and why the image of a tortured Christ is so important because our empathy and morality stems from our visual cortex instincts of seeing something suffer or seeing something display neotenous features.

    • @patrickmcloughlin6108
      @patrickmcloughlin6108 8 місяців тому

      Interesting- can woke be defeated or are we the Romans and they, a new radical Christian movement?

  • @anomietoponymie2140
    @anomietoponymie2140 9 місяців тому

    Forty-eight minutes in, I'm wondering how to describe the moral foundations of non-Christian civilisations and in particular, Islam. My hunch is that it is has something to do with the individual (Christian) vs. the group (Islamic, the Umma), but it is just a hunch and could be totally wrong. Would like to know how the different moral foundations lead to a different status of women. Though the difference in that status is clear to all of us who live with Islam in the West, ie the results of the difference are manifest, it is not clear to me how or if that comes about from first principles (ie individual vs group?). Does anyone know if TH addresses this question anywhere?

  • @012345family
    @012345family 4 місяці тому

    “There is nothing more traditional than questioning tradition in the west”
    “Errm - ha ha all right mate”

  • @Zarghaam12
    @Zarghaam12 Рік тому +1

    I've read many books by Tom Holland, his book on the rise of Islam is a cop out! Not knowing the necessary languages to tap into original sources i a big handicap, and it showed!

  • @andrewthomas6312
    @andrewthomas6312 Рік тому +2

    I'm sure Dawkins, Dennett and Harris are thrilled to hear they're Christians 🤣🤣🤣

  • @big1boston
    @big1boston Рік тому +3

    Not all of us agree.

  • @dannyarcher6370
    @dannyarcher6370 Рік тому +2

    This isn't the Tom Holland you were looking for.
    But stick around. You'll learn something the one you _were_ looking for couldn't teach you.

  • @jimluebke3869
    @jimluebke3869 Рік тому +6

    "The fact that there is power in being the victim..."
    No. Christianity is about there being power in being the SERVANT. Christ was *serving*, when He was on that cross.
    The idea that Christianity is worshiping something pitiful for its pitifulness, is a heresy. Probably the heresy of our time.

    • @thadtuiol1717
      @thadtuiol1717 Рік тому

      Catholics already know this and have known it for 1,900 years. It's you idiotic protestants and your laughable 'reformation' that have lead to fools like Nietzsche spreading that victim interpretation of Christianity.

    • @pemcortes9467
      @pemcortes9467 10 місяців тому

      True, it is not victimhood that is exalted in the first will be last precept, it is servanthood service.

  • @tombrunila2695
    @tombrunila2695 10 місяців тому

    At about 23:20! The Russian revolution was about implementing socialism which at is root is the same as fascism! Socialism is NOT about "rising up the victim", it is about crushing the individual. Socialism is the pure anathema of Christianity. Socialism hates freedom and free will! I can recommend "The Socialist Phenomenon" by Igor Shafarevich. Shafarevich was a Soviet mathematician and analyzed socialism as a phenomenon by looking at its history. It can be found in PDF by googling.

  • @throughhumaneyes7648
    @throughhumaneyes7648 Рік тому

    Sweet chat, wish more people had the tickle to question their own assumptions we might not get tricked so ez pz.

  • @johnjustice8478
    @johnjustice8478 Рік тому +1

    The West is wholly Christian, it is true, but Christian in a super-Jesus way. That Christianity has become religious from philosophical is such a wonderful development.
    The Christ figure, the Redeemer, the one, who takes YOUR burden on HIS own shoulders and rids it from you and for you, that truly is THE WESTERN raison d'etre.

  • @andrewmakin8151
    @andrewmakin8151 Рік тому

    perhaps the core is not what various people believe, but that anyone believes in anything at all?
    our species has become fundamentally distracted.

  • @marion4549
    @marion4549 11 місяців тому

    We have/had great foundations in Western society that worked for a long time. Those fiundations have been corrupted by the worst of our nature. Is it possible to keep those tried and trusted foundations, identify and root out the villians, and restore with upgrades of course, the structures here in the West that have been the envy of the world. The current approach of destroying everything and heading into a future with no guardrails or solid fiundations is frightening and will not end well.

  • @thomassimmons1950
    @thomassimmons1950 Рік тому

    Two Mensch just workin it out

  • @knightsrepose9448
    @knightsrepose9448 Рік тому +1

    The arc of desacrilizing what has gone before is interesting though a very incomplete picture. The Christian/Catholic church desacralized paganism but retained the supernatural by ascribing such things to demons. The Protestant reformation desacralized the sacraments of the Church but also marginalized the supernatural. The Enlightenment (and eventual rise of scientism) then eliminated the supernatural entirely. Nietzsche was just the final nail in the proverbial coffin. Modern manifestations are only superficially Christian but are in fact heavily influenced by paganism, gnosticism, and Nominalism. I mean, seriously, we already sacrifice our children on the alter of self convenience - at least the Aztecs were worried about the World ending.

    • @knightsrepose9448
      @knightsrepose9448 Рік тому

      PS the separation of church and state is modernist myth of convenience for a secular state that pretends to be neutral.

    • @knightsrepose9448
      @knightsrepose9448 Рік тому

      Ok. This is quite fascinating. Holland claims he's "Christianized" but he's clearly "Protestantized".

    • @daneumurianpiano7822
      @daneumurianpiano7822 Рік тому

      The evangelical world has plenty of the supernatural, sometimes taken to excess. George Muller, who founded an orphanage in Bristol, England in the 19th century, told of suppertime without food. He instructed the children to thank God for the food. There was a knock on the door. A food wagon had just broken an axle. Don Richardson said that the Greek _musterion_ meant "mystery," not just "sacrament". Jesus refused to flaunt the supernatural, but used it (Greek _semeion_, or "sign", in the Gospel of John) to prove who he was, help people, and glorify the Father. I could cite a clear personal experience of the supernatural and many compelling experiences.

  • @leebarry5686
    @leebarry5686 3 місяці тому

    Right, a wrong thing further distorted

  • @steveflorida8699
    @steveflorida8699 Рік тому

    The redeeming and uplifting value of the cross is FORGIVENESS.
    Jesus said, whilst suffering on the cross, "forgive them for they know not what they do".

  • @t3br00k35
    @t3br00k35 Місяць тому

    *various reasons

  • @CatharineBurke
    @CatharineBurke Рік тому +3

    HOPE, they do it for HOPE! HOPE that there is more than just life here on earth, that there is an eternal life in the new Jerusalem. To have this HOPE for the wedding banquet in heaven allows me and others the ability to look past the distractions of life that may consume us otherwise. In this HOPE I am called to not just me get to heaven but my spouse my children my family and friends through serving the other and that other is a child of God who is loved by God and God calls me to love his children. Serving through the corporal works of mercy, feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, sheltering the homeless, visiting the sick, visiting the imprisoned, burying the dead and giving alms to the poor. Yes, it's radical compared to the secular culture. Once I was one way and now I am radically different. Yes I am a poor rotten sinner, God have mercy on me. May I strive to be Jesus to all of God's children and may I see Jesus in them.

  • @kennypeterson2615
    @kennypeterson2615 Рік тому +1

    Wow all those Marvel movies really aged him

  • @TheWhitehiker
    @TheWhitehiker Рік тому +7

    Tom seems to have missed the gross inaccuracies of the main BLM media hypes--in fact police racist incidents are extremely low; these are statistical realities, not media realities.
    Still his main points here are important.

  • @randygault4564
    @randygault4564 Рік тому

    Skepticism IS neutrality. It simply requires that claims be backed up with evidence. If that's a myth, it is the smallest myth, and that's what you want.