If Prophet Muhammad Never Spoke to God, How Could He Be a Prophet? | Dr. Shabir Ally
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 сер 2024
- Dr. Shabir Ally discusses the criteria for prophets according to Christianity, focusing on Deuteronomy 18:14-18 which mentions a prophet like Moses. Dr. Shabir explains that while Moses spoke directly to God, it's not a universal criterion for prophets. He elaborates on the Islamic perspective, stating that Prophet Muhammad did speak to God through revelation. The conversation also explores interpretations from both the Old and New Testaments regarding the awaited prophet, with Dr. Shabir suggesting that Muhammad fulfills the criteria outlined in Deuteronomy. He concludes by highlighting similarities between Jesus, Moses, and Muhammad, indicating that Muslims have valid reasons to believe in Muhammad as a prophet.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website www.QuranSpeaks.com OR
Sending an etransfer to iGive@QuranSpeaks.com OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: ua-cam.com/users/subscription_...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
Thanks so much for your brodcast. I look so forward to it. I have been following Islam for over a year now. Im convinced this is the way. Your show has helped me a lot.
Masha Allah brother ❤
Ma shaa'Allah. My husband's been a convert for nearly 20 years, and his love for Allah is so moving. I love my husband so much. I pray the best for you, brother.
There is not one scripture about Muhammad. Lol.
Run from Allah, Jibril, Muhammad, Islam, the quran, and Islam. RUN!.Repent and believe the gospel (Mark 1:15) while you still have breath in your body.
@@hudsonbartley2493galilatians 3:13 Jesus became a curse for us
I listened the video to the end, and rewinded and relistened to parts,
this was a very insightfull, another very educational video, thank you!
What parts of the New Testament are true?
Shabir,a muslim trying to explain bibles??? Is Shabir knows his quran critically???? Mohd during night journey come close to,hi hi....how close shabir??? Facts are mohd lied about night journey...aisha never confirm it. Shabir ,better learn quran carefully....no point reading bibles just to debunk it.
John 1 verse 25 is referring to John the Baptist being asked why are you baptizing. John the Baptist is referring to the coming of Jesus not Muhammad.
Thanks for the information.. ❤❤
Thank you for this video by reminding and providing more reflections about this topic
As a Christian, I’ve always respected Shabir Ally but Acts 3:11-26 is about Peter preaching to his fellow Israelites and claiming that Jesus is the One the prophets talked about including Deuteronomy 18:18.
Peter is NOT saying that they should wait for another prophet but rather Jesus is the One Moses prophesied about so they should accept Him.
Let's reason together. God Almighty commands that in the very scriptures which you profess to uphold and believe in.
Be humble. Be honest.
Acts 3:21-23
👉 🚩 Jesus is *not* the Prophet of Deuteronomy 18 V 18. The Bible testifies.
Jesus MUST remain in heaven UNTIL *The Prophet* who is foretold in the scriptures, to come after Jesus, Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon them both) has arrived and delivered his message of *all truth* to the people. Only after that can Jesus be sent back for his second coming.
ACTS 3
20 that times of refreshing may come from the presence of the Lord, and that he may send the Christ appointed for you, Jesus,
21 *whom heaven must receive until the time for restoring all the things about which God spoke by the mouth of his holy prophets long ago* . 22 Moses said, ‘The Lord God will raise up for you a prophet like me from YOUR (The Is-ra-el-ites') brothers. You shall listen to him in whatever he tells you.
23 Then Moses said, ‘Anyone who will not listen to that Prophet will be completely cut off from God’s people.’
***********
ISR-AELI-TES = THE NA-TIO-N OF I-SR-AE-L
ISR-AE-LI-TES' BROTHERS = THE BROTHER NATION OF THE NATION OF I-SR-AE-L
👉 *THE ISH-MAE-LIT-ES*
Thank you, so was that the only thing he got wrong? So the point still stands.
@user-lp9bw1fp7l I think the bigger question is how can we confirm any relationship with God, he was talking to a being who claimed to be a angel, remeber satan was an angel as well
Ma'sha'Allah! Dr. Shabbir, I wanna be like you. I'm genuinely interested in studying _Comparative Religion_ and being as informed as I can to benefit not just myself but also others (as you are). I'd be indebted to you if you can guide me from where & how to begin. Jazak Allah! May Allah reward you 🙏🏻
While you are looking to study sir try and answer the absences of God in the religion of Muhammad. Can you and your teachers prove me wrong that God was totally absent when reveling the Quran to Muhammad. Not once did God spoke to Muhammad in the dark cave.
Dr. Shabil, you said that there's a veil that keeps human from God but in Quran Allah says he took Jesus unto himself. Does this make Jesus different from other human? Because not even Muhammad who went beyond the veil. Please adress this
"He took Jesus unto himself" nothing more, your words are not needed.
And the verse didn't say what you think it said😂
I love you this beautiful dad and daughter team for the sake of Allah! :) Thank you!
I like the clear answers, I like your knowledge of Torrah & NT
God thought his prophets to read and write, how comes Muhammed didn't write the koran if god had talked to Muhammed?
Is it haram to think of the night journey as merely spiritual rather than physical?
There is no night journey, its all made up
There are Holes in the standard Islamic Narrative
@@tapiwachasumba4992 Jay Smith is a zealot
Can someone explain me Sahih al-Bukhari 1285?
11:34 minute that can prove Prophet Muhammad(S.A.W.) and Alhamdulillah nobody can disprove it in the whole world ❤❤❤
Jesus Christ the Messiah (peace be upon him) was taken to Heaven by Lord/God/TheCreator because some wanted him dead, so God saved him (be patient, continue reading, you will see ''the matrix'', upto you to escape it).
The word christ comes from the Greek word 'christos' meaning chosen/annointed (annointment is the act of chosing)
the word messiah comes from the Arabic/Hebrew word 'messiach', again meaning chosen.
Jesus did not speak Greek or Arabic or Hebrew, he spoke Aramaic.
John 14:28
“I go to the Father, for the Father is greater than I”
John 20:17
'‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’”
John 5:30
"I cannot do anything on my own."
Mark 10:18
''Why do you call me good? No one is good, except God alone.''
(that ''father'' does not mean flesh and bone father, rather TheGuide/God,
worship TheCreator/TheGuide/TheGod and not the prophets, peace be upon them all)
So, Who chose Jesus?
TheCreator/TheGod/TheLord did.
To do what?
To convey that there is TheCreator/TheGod/TheLord and only ThatSupreme power should be worshipped and prayed to and NO idols/conjured up god/s by human kind,
be it a man, a spirit of a man, a sun, a star, a moon, a tree, an animal etc etc be worshipped in any way.
Anything that is worshipped besides TheGod is a god, that is false god, hence with a small ''g''.
There is one Creator, hence why TheGod, the only One deserving of worship.
What does Allah mean as a word?
It means TheCreator/TheGod/TheLord.
What does ''elaah'' mean as a word?
It means any idol or conjured up god or gods that are false and do not deserve worship of any kind, hence why Islam rejects all gods but TheGod/TheCreator/TheLord/Allah.
Why are all religions in opposition of Islam?
Because they have a god or many gods but TheGod that is worshipped in someway or another.
Have you ever read a Quran from start to finish?
That you can answer for your self.
(I recommend the Sahih International english translation, it's good).
Best wishes.
-------------------------------
.....btw.....
Jesus did preach to worship the OneGod/TheCreator and not anything else, and so did his followers, peace be upon them all.
This unsettled the Roman Empire because this idea of Monotheism went against their pagan beliefs where the emperor was both emperor and god. They persecuted the followers of Jesus and even attempted to kill Jesus, even a Roman Empire servant Saul of Tarsus was out to kill Jesus.
Saul never managed to meet Jesus in real life but after Jesus was taken up to Heaven Saul said he saw a dream and said he will now preach the teachings of Jesus. Saul of Tarsus is also known in todays christianity as Saint Paul, so todays christians are actually on the teaching of ''Saint'' Paul which brings in trinity and godhead figure of Jesus and rejects Monotheism.
-Jesus was commanded to preach Monotheism, which he did and early followers were Monotheistic (Islamic) believing people, which later changed with the Roman Empires paganism spreading
-Jesus was commanded to preach ONLY to the Israelites, which he did, but after him Saul of Tarsus aka ''saint Paul'' started to preach to the Gentiles, which is the foundation of todays christiandom.
-Jesus was commanded to rule for the circumsicion which he did, but it was taken out after he left
-Roman Empire in 325 AD held a council, with empire alligned 'scholars'' to decide and VOTE on whether Jesus was to be worshipped or not, they VOTED that Jesus be accepted as god (in aliagn with the pagan beliefs of the Roman traditions) and ever since the trinity became the 'christian way' (not what Jesus preached), and sinc that time the Church has chronicled how many times the ''Bible'' has been changed, verses removed and verses added to SUIT this altered idea of trinity!
Didn't the prophet SWT speak to allah during the Isra' and Mi'raj when Djibril brough him up the heavens?
Yes, so? This is already addressed in the video, did you even watch it? Also, what do you mean by. "prophet SWT"? What does SWT mean here?
There was no night journey; its all made up; The quran is referring to Moses not Muhammad
Why god was speaking to all these so-called messengers so frequently back then? And now he/she is silent. Why the god is silent/hiding when the world needs him/her the most! There's so much suffering and killing in the name of religion. I think god must come now to stop all this chaos.
This is not how muslim view the current situation, whatever suffering and killing is been predestined by god, every life of human on earth is a test. Some tested by wealth, some tested by greed, some tested via suffering.
And say not of those who are slain in God's cause, "They are dead": nay, they are alive, but you perceive it not [2.154].
And it may be that you dislike a thing which is good for you and that you like a thing which is bad for you. Allah knows but you do not know. [2:216].
Nowadays, God is busy.. earlier there wasn't much work for him. So, he was speaking
@@SajalChakravartyno.
@@user-lp9bw1fp7l oh yes. When did he speak last and to whom?
Moses didn't see God on their meeting but he heard God speaking.
God has no image and any image that comes to mind then that is not God.
That also would be for the prophet because no one speak to God but there is a shield that no one can see God.
Moses requested to see God on their meeting with God but God told him that you can't see me but look at that rock and when God reveals would see . But because of the light intensity the rock shuttered and Moses falls bowing to the ground asking God forgiveness.
No one will see God.
I always thought Islam is a religion not a tradition. Can you explain this?
Best explanation JazakAllah
What is the Chrisain scholars' interpretation pertaining the pronoun (him) cited in Isaiah 29:12?!
King James Bible
And the book is delivered to him that is not learned, saying, Read this, I pray thee: and he saith, I am not learned.
New King James Version
Then the book is delivered to one who is illiterate, saying, “Read this, please.” And he says, “I am not literate.”
American Standard Version
and the book is delivered to him that is not learned, saying, Read this, I pray thee; and he saith, I am not learned.
Berean Study Bible
Or if the scroll is handed to one unable to read, he will say, “I cannot read.”
Douay-Rheims Bible
And the book shall be given to one that knoweth no letters, and it shall be said to him: Read: and he shall answer: I know no letters.
English Revised Version
and the book is delivered to *him* that is not learned, saying, Read this, I pray thee: and he saith, I am not learned.
John13:13 "You call me teacher and Lord, and it is right that you do so because that is what l am.Amen. God bless to Dr, Shabir Ally.
It is so very "christian" to continually focus on a single answer being the one and only truth and everything else is wrong. Further, there is always contention about who and what a prophet is. I am so very grateful to a Merciful God that I was exposed to a faith where the final determination is between myself and God. What makes this an even greater blessing is that there are intelligent and gifted folks here that can help me with my progress with light touches rather than heavy-handedness.
May Allah grant you ease.
With love, this is typically where Idolatry begins. With a "god" who understands that you differ with what has be established by Him. I mean, it would have been no issue to consider Muhammad a true prophet by the biblical requirements that God give to His true prophet - Moses.
@rayj8704 Thank you for your thoughts. It is a core belief of my faith that nothing happens other than what is determined by God. When all is written, said and done....I know that Allah is enough for me.
yup. christian dogma. my imam says we shouldn't be like the christians and refrain from dogma.
Show me any prophet of Yahweh that was deceived by Satan, yet Allah allowed momo to be deceived by Satan into revealing false revelations with the satanic versus.. Jesus himself rebuked Satan three times while fasting 40 days in the wilderness, but not momo, this proves that momo is not a prophet of the god of the bible Yahweh, but is a prophet of Allah the pagan moon 🌙 god of Arabia.... momo was also a black stone kisser like the pagans of arabia...
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
That is because he isn't a prophet. No prophet affirmed his message variants from the prior message that the Quran itself claims it affirms.
And according to authentic Muslims sources, Muhammad gave the satanic verses which Deuteronomy says comes with a dead penalty if a prophet does such behavior Deut. 18:20. The Quran 22:52 confesses that this happened.
The person to come after Jesus is the Holy Spirit. It can't be Muhammad as it clearly calls the comforter the Holy Spirit.
Hahaha
Again the grass must be blue.
You didn't watch the video and stop posting fake shii 😂
@@user-lp9bw1fp7l What did I miss?
@@user-lp9bw1fp7l I watched again and picked up something new. Shabi claims God can't speak like a man, but he ignores the multiple theophanies in the Old Testament.
Dr Shabir please debate Christian Prince
D guy is slippery . Not accepting any challenges, debates nor discourse .
God put me here to test me but knows what I will do already. Why test me then? I don't get it. Makes no sense
Would you be happy if you were punished for what you didn't do? Would you have agreed to be punished if you were told that you were going to do this bad thing in the future, so have to be punished now? Wouldn't you claim that you wouldn't never do that even though you will? Wouldn't you also claim that the one punishing you is unjust?
Answer this question truthfully, because Islamically those who do evil deeds things in this world and died without repentance, during the day of judgment they will say that they should be sent back to try again and they won't do it again, but God will say even if he were to send them back, they will still not believe. Etc...
@@Fx_Explains Being happy about something I didn't do does not matter. When I die, my soul will probably not even recognise my mind anyway. Why would God create me mentality prone to doubting and not believing? How can a test be made on somebody where the creator already knows the outcome? I think most Muslims do not really believe but it is their identity of culture and nationalism. They are hardly known for their good behaviour or manners which is strange if they thought they were being judged. As it says in the Quran, almost all Muslims will never go to Paradise anyway.
@@Bb-pw1zi so do you believe you have a soul? God created you so that you may think, if God wanted to create beings that will obey him 100% he can and has already, they are called Angels, they have no free will like that of humans. The purpose of life for us humans is to recognize our lord with the intelligence that was giving to us. In schools why do teachers put wrong answers in the questions? To give you chance to choose the right one from the wrong one, isn't it? Yes we are prone to doubt and it is because of this doubt that allow us to chose the right path, from the wrong path, we doubt and we look for evidence and evidence of the true path is very clear.
Most of us Muslim have cleared our doubts and follow worship God willing, I think you are projecting because since you have doubts you think everyone else have doubts like you, but that is not the case and actually Muslims are known more for their good behaviour and not hardly. I think you should stop consuming the media that only highlights Muslims doing bad deeds and keep showing it as if it were the standard, of course anyone who consumes such media will have a perverted opinion.
That last statement you said is a clear lie, it was never stated that "almost all Muslims will never go to paradise", actually it's the best contrary, All Muslims (those who actually believe in on true God) will eventually go heaven and yes not every Muslim will go to heaven at first some Muslims have committed crimes and for their crimes they might be punished for a certain time.
Quran 4:124 But those who do good-whether male or female-and have faith will enter Paradise and will never be wronged ˹even as much as˺ the speck on a date stone.
At-Tirmidhi (1999), Abu Dawood (4091) and Ibn Maajah (59) narrated from ‘Abdullah ibn Mas‘ood that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “No one will enter Paradise in whose heart is an atom’s weight of arrogance and no one will enter Hell in whose heart is an atom’s weight of faith.” A man said: What if I like my clothes to look nice and my shoes to look nice? He said: “Verily Allah loves beauty; rather arrogance means rejecting the truth and looking down on people.”
Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh at-Tirmidhi. (saheeh meaning authentic)
@@Bb-pw1zi so do you believe you have a soul? God created you so that you may think, if God wanted to create beings that will obey him 100% he can and has already, they are called Angels, they have no free will like that of humans. The purpose of life for us humans is to recognize our lord with the intelligence that was giving to us. In schools why do teachers put wrong answers in the questions? To give you chance to choose the right one from the wrong one, isn't it? Yes we are prone to doubt and it is because of this doubt that allow us to chose the right path, from the wrong path, we doubt and we look for evidence and evidence of the true path is very clear.
Most of us Muslim have cleared our doubts and follow worship God willing, I think you are projecting because since you have doubts you think everyone else have doubts like you, but that is not the case and actually Muslims are known more for their good behaviour and not hardly. I think you should stop consuming the media that only highlights Muslims doing bad deeds and keep showing it as if it were the standard, of course anyone who consumes such media will have a perverted opinion.
That last statement you said is a clear lie, it was never stated that "almost all Muslims will never go to paradise", actually it's the best contrary, All Muslims (those who actually believe in on true God) will eventually go heaven and yes not every Muslim will go to heaven at first some Muslims have committed crimes and for their crimes they might be punished for a certain time.
Quran 4:124 But those who do good-whether male or female-and have faith will enter Paradise and will never be wronged ˹even as much as˺ the speck on a date stone.
At-Tirmidhi (1999), Abu Dawood (4091) and Ibn Maajah (59) narrated from ‘Abdullah ibn Mas‘ood that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “No one will enter Paradise in whose heart is an atom’s weight of arrogance and no one will enter Hell in whose heart is an atom’s weight of faith.” A man said: What if I like my clothes to look nice and my shoes to look nice? He said: “Verily Allah loves beauty; rather arrogance means rejecting the truth and looking down on people.”
Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh at-Tirmidhi. (saheeh meaning authentic)
John 16.7 John 16:7 Nevertheless I tell you the truth; It is expedient for you that I go away: for if I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you; but if I depart, I will send him unto you.
This comforter,who is the spirit of truth is being sent to us by Jesus Christ once he ascends to Heaven, question to Muslims did Jesus send Muhammad? If you agree then you have to accept that Jesus is God?
Clear statement:
And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Helper,
Whatever jesus did is will of father,with father's assurance..that's why father is almighty not jesus
@@Saima18914" I will send Him unto you." Read it carefully who well send the comforter God or Jesus ? What kind of authority does Jesus have that He would send the comforter😮
Asalaamu Walykum Jazak Allah that was a comforting listen in difficult times.
Firstly, Jesus cannot come back as a giver of the Law because He already said that not one jot nor one tattle will be changed. (Matthew 5:18) End argument. What you are therefore unquestionably dealing with is a new religion with different Laws.
The quote you gave there from Deuteronomy is different from the version that I have had since I was born. Mine says:- "The Lord thy God will raise up unto thee a Prophet from the midst of thee, of thy brethren, like unto me; unto him ye shall hearken;"
I note that it is assumed or stated that the Prophet will come from amongst the Israelites in many modern translations of the original. However, I refer back to the answer I gave above that, as far as Israel was concerned, Jesus was the final word so I am not sure when the idea of the brethren specifically being Israelites came into things? The word brethren can also mean spiritual brothers since both peoples were descendant from Abraham (as).
We know that Prophet had not appeared at the time of John The Baptist and Jesus since John was asked if He was that Prophet and He said that He was not. (John 1:21)
I know there are a great number of people who do not want Prophet Muhammad (saw) to be that Prophet but it is literally the only thing that makes sense and especially considering the promise made to Hagar of a nation too numerous to count through her son, Ishmael (as). They would not be Jews and they cannot be Christians who have no claim to be descendant from His line. I have a question mark about why God claimed to be the God of Abraham (as), the God of Isaac(as) and the God of Jacob(as) but didn't mention Ishmael (as) despite the promise He made through the angel to Hagar (pbuh). I have various thoughts going through my head on that one but the main one is because Islam was specifically meant to be an entirely separate people. Any comments on that would be welcome.
So we have a new argument that it was the Law itself which proves Islam is a true religion through the line of Ismael (as)
Let's see if the Bible passages change because of that! 🙄
Asalaam
pick one
bismAllah
۞ وَمَا كَانَ لِبَشَرٍ أَن يُكَلِّمَهُ ٱللَّهُ إِلَّا وَحۡيًا أَوۡ مِن وَرَآيِٕ حِجَابٍ أَوۡ يُرۡسِلَ رَسُولٗا فَيُوحِيَ بِإِذۡنِهِۦ مَا يَشَآءُۚ إِنَّهُۥ عَلِيٌّ حَكِيمٞ
(51) And it is not for any human being that Allāh should speak to him
except
- by revelation or
- from behind a partition or
- that He sends a messenger
to reveal,
by His permission,
what He wills.
Indeed,
He is Most High and Wise.
42:51
salamun alaikum
You didnt answer pls
Shabir is quoting from quran that Muhammad spoke to Allah. But the quran was given to Muhammad through jibrial. Muhammad itself was shocked when he saw the Quran because he found the Verse saying he spoke to Allah.
If moses talked directly to god and is just as holy as the other prophet muhammad then why do muslims say peace be upon him to muhammad but not Moses?
@HH-pv9ex he didn't say it after he mentioned Moses name.
@@joelthemole6562cause the guy is explaining soenthing. We have 25 proohets. When i pray, i ask peace be upon all of them!! And that's always when im talking about verses that refers to Moses (peace be upon him).
@user-lp9bw1fp7l all of your prophets with the exception of Muhammed, were Jewish including Moses
@HH-pv9ex The biblical narrative gets going with Abraham in Genesis chapter 12. Abraham in turn Isaac, in turn Jacob, in turn Joseph and the twelve tribes, this brings us directly to the people of Israel and the covenant at Sinai. So Abraham is thought of as the first Jew, the archetype.
@HH-pv9ex then why do muslims all claim Abraham and Moses were muslims, when Islam didn't exist during their time. That also doesn't make sense
It’ says some where along the lines of in the Quran, that god made it seem like they crucified Jesus but really he was taken up and not harmed.
Why go through the trouble of making it seem like they did kill him though? What’s the point of that?
Because an entire religion/faith came out of that supposed false crucifixion, it seems so counter productive. it did way more harm than good for people to believe in something that’s supposed to be false.
🎉❤ very good explanation ماشاءاللہ ۔۔۔۔ .... We should rather focus upon wants of almighty Allah & his final prophet saydina Muhammad,,,,we need not probe conversations
John 16:7 is talk about holly spirit and it shown to them on pentecostal day...noting about mohammed coming...thanks dc.shabir
God through Jesus warn you a messenger will come after him by the name of Mohammad.
Unfortunately,you guys translated the name “ the beloved one”.
Don’t blame us.
But question still remains is how the father of al laat, manaat and uzza becomes one and only true god..
Blue grass.
😂😂 Fathered 3 daughters
😂Shabir please help 😂😂
Quran 2 144: We have certainly seen the turning of your face, [O Muhammad], toward the heaven, and We will surely turn you to a qiblah with which you will be pleased. So turn your face toward al-Masjid al-Haram. And wherever you [believers] are, turn your faces toward it [in prayer]. Indeed, those who have been given the Scripture well know that it is the truth from their Lord. And Allah is not unaware of what they do.
Is this not a direct speech of Prophet Muhammad to Allah (swt). If not, then you are a .......
May the Great Omnipotent God always grant the prophet Muhammad peace and blessings.
How can he be omnipotent when he can't even have a son without a girlfriend?
In the grave or where?
This elderly man is always confusing thd young hearts!
Nevertheless, many shall come to the real omni God Almighty through His Son.. JESUS!
Very interesting and illumination questions but answer is not right
Hi all, love the channel. It is a criterion for this passage as shown in scripture *Deuteronomy* 18. 16-18 For this is what you asked of the Lord your God at Horeb on the day of the assembly when you said, “Let us not hear the voice of the Lord our God nor see this great fire anymore, or we will die.”
17 The Lord said to me: “What they say is good. 18 I will raise up for them a prophet like you from among their fellow Israelites, and I will put my words in his mouth. He will tell them everything I command him. 19 I myself will call to account anyone who does not listen to my words *that the prophet* (singular) speaks in my name.
The above can only be in Jesus 🙏
So, was Jesus a prophet or God??
@@quadraoq4478 both. God is a title like King, Queen, Prince, Pharaoh, Emperor etc not a name.
@@HH-pv9ex You're right, in the Hebrew it doesn't say Israelites. It says from your midst, same phase elsewhere translated as from among you. Ishmaelites not included.
The birth or his age, or his town or his hair colour weren't the criteria. I've given the context.
@@daveyofyeshua 'prophet' is also a title, not a name. Can't be both. If by Gnosticism, god went down and walk with the people, then he can't be a prophet. Or vice versa. it's an oxymoron.
@@HH-pv9ex Please explain how Isaiah 42:11 relates to a prophet like me?
Does God speak to Muslim? As the christians believe
❤Whose mouth the words Moses heard where coming from
I will raise a Prophet like you....
Jehovah God
To understand why Jesus is the prophet spoken of by Moses, you have to go back to Deuteronomy 6 verse 4 where Moses said "hear o' Israel the Lord our God is one" and the word "one" is "echad" and it's a term of compound unity in that verse, the same way a sports team made up of more than one player says they are "one". That verse was not fully brought to light in the earth until Jesus, the Light of the world (John 8 verse 12) said "I and the Father are one" (John 10 verse 30). Jesus was known as "the Word" and "the Light" in scripture because He is not simply a messenger, He is THE MESSAGE of the Father. The true Word of God is a person, Jesus, and the true written word is the book that contains the prophecies of Jesus, the word who became flesh and dwelt among us (John chapter 1). The Bible is the word of God, my friends.
@@jeremycrawford4004
Why do you believe bible is true?
We don't need the bible
@@uthman2281we don’t need the Bible yet we use it to prove our point.
Choose one..
Either you need it to prove it or you don’t use ot to find answers of your Quran..
Ramadan Mubarak to Dr. Shabir and Safiyyah Ally - keep up the good work!
Dr Shabir is so incredibly knowledgeable, and his composure is exemplary.
A prophet is anyone who sees the future, you dont need to talk to God or God talk to you.
who sees the future???what??🤣
in religion, a prophet is an individual who is regarded as being in contact with a divine being and is said to speak on behalf of that being, serving as an intermediary with humanity by delivering messages or teachings from the supernatural source to other people..educate urself
It is difficult to understand this explanation. The Prophet (S) came to God. Does it mean that God is localised. He has a shape and size. Is God anthropomorphic? The Quran says God is everywhere. These must be allegorical statements. Why do we fail to understand this? Because in our mind, we are unable to get rid of a human like God.
You mean John the Baptist and John 1
10:30 I have so many questions, in Islam is Muhammad thought to be the spirit of truth?
John 16:13 But when he, *the Spirit of truth* comes, he will guide you into all the truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears, and he will tell you what is yet to come.
He fits d boots ..
@@TheWitnessss Then I'm even more confused as in the next verse it says Jesus gave the revelation to Muhammad?
14 He will glorify me because it is from me that he will receive what he will make known to you.
@@HH-pv9ex Then I'm even more confused as in the next verse it says Jesus gave the revelation to Muhammad?
14 He will glorify me because it is from me that he will receive what he will make known to you.
@@daveyofyeshua Sorry cant help u . Sounds like d Bible jumbled up when Jesus speaks n when God speaks .
D Bible is not definitive to muslims cos of what we regard as made up parts .
In fact some parts are not even accepted by christians until much later .
@@daveyofyeshua Why is my response deleted?
The Messenger of Allah Prophet Muhammad s.a.w.s spoke directly with the Lord of the Worlds in his journey to "Isra & Miraj" "Blemishless is He who carried His servant (Muhammad) by night from the holy mosque (the Kaaba) to the distant mosque (the Al-Quds mosque in Palestine), the surroundings of which We have blessed, to show you him some of our miracles. He (Allah), indeed, hears everything and sees everything." (Captain El Israë - 1) Israh is: The journey that was made to Muhammad s.a.v.s. from the Kaaba Mosque to the Quds Mosque in Palestine. Mirajji is: The journey that was made to Muhammad, peace be upon him. from the mosque of Quds, in the seven heavens to the highest spheres and to sidretul munteha (outside the seven heavens). He talked to the Great God where he received the 5 prayers that we Muslims pray every day
Maa Shaa Allah may Allah bless you both.
If he was a prophet! How come he married a little 9 years old child! I don't understand that? If you're a prophet, how come you will have that character! It's hard to believe he was a prophet.
Dear Dr. Ally, I don't know if that was your intention but you are taking Peter out of context (watch from 8:30). Anyone reading Acts 3 cannot help but to conclude that Peter was showing the fulfilment of that prophesy by Jesus' coming to the earth. Wow. Is this Islam?
Every muslim believe prophet isa coming down to earth later on. Muslim dont make any distinction between the prophets, those were all god chosen. God ask them, they shall do.
Who ever saying muhammad is higher than isa, or isa higher than moses is haram, forbidden
We do not need too much
On media be sensible , no point discussing it will come
back to you with disaster later
It is the greatest of ironies that the enemies of Israel should claim to follow the "prophet like unto Moses", who loved Israel, pleaded for Israel, and even offered his life as a sacrifice for Israel. Exodus 32-33. Of course there is only One who is the perfect fulfillment of all Moses desired and prayed for.
Come on! Love and pleading for "Israel" (i.e. for the Jews) by those who believe that all those rejecting Jesus - including "Israel" (i.e. the Jews) - will suffer in Hell forever is the greatest irony ever.
God grants mercy to some but not to all. Not sure what you find ironic here.@@edvincami3890
John 16 7 is talking about the Holy Spirit, not Muhammad
This is what they tell you nowadays, but the early Christians were expecting "the Paraclete" of John 16:7 to be a human being and not simply a "spirit". That's why many Christians of the 2nd century believed to Montanus, a man born in Arbadau, Asia Minor, that claimed to be exactly that "Paraclete". Only after him, the Church felt it necessary for its war against "heresies" to support the interpretation of the Paraclete's being a spirit.
@@edvincami3890
Stop the LIE you read from those Dawah boys.
John 16:7
“But very truly I tell you, it is for your good that I am going away. Unless I go away, the Advocate will not come to you; but if I go, I will send him to YOU.”
Jesus was talking to His DISCIPLES and He told them that He would send the Advocate/Comforter to them.
1. Was Muhammed a disciple of Jesus?
2. Did Jesus send Muhammed?
Every person has his own thougts
In each decade
If everybody thinks he is correct and trying to grab new generation's attention and estabbilishing his empire has become fashion
Moses was the only prophet that I know of who spoke to God directly!
@bleish if i prove you God spoke to many prophets directly in Bible will you leave Islam.
@@HH-pv9ex Not only that guy many of the Muslims, to support Muhammad they are making such a false claim that God spoke directly only to Moses. In quran there is no evidence Muhammad talking to gibrail or Muhammad met jibrial. Can you prove me from the Qur'an Muhammad talking to angel jibrial?
@@HH-pv9ex why should he leave Islam because he is not able to prove his claim.
@@HH-pv9ex ok brother can you prove Muhammad spoke to Allah and brought the Qur'an to mankind. Because many claim Allah revealed the Qur'an to Muhammad. Can you prove it.
@@HH-pv9ex In Sura Al-Najm there is no verses showing Muhammad talking to Allah. Can you provide me the specific Verse.
…
Did Moses marry a child?
He received a gift from Allah on that occasion (speaking to Allah).
Jeremiah 23:16
Thus says the Lord of hosts,
“Do not listen to the words of the prophets who are prophesying to you.
They are leading you into futility;
They speak a vision of their own imagination,
Not from the mouth of the Lord.
Matthew 7:15-16
“Beware of the false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly are ravenous wolves. You will know them by their fruits. Grapes are not gathered from thorn bushes nor figs from thistles, are they?
I have a doubt about that.....did God really take Muhammad Nabi across the heavens????....he says he took him to the further masjid ....that's it right????
The night journey is about Moses and the Children of Israel.
Mohammad spoke to Angela
Period read
No one witness Md speaking to God.
0:36 They (Bible people) changed this, that is not what it says, it says amongst your brethren, not Israelites.
Facepalm. Who was Moses and who was he addressing again???
@@rayj8704 Facepalm harder because modern versions changed it to Israelites, others have always said brethren, brothers, and so forth. This was understood as nations ( peoples ).
Their brethren, brothers would be Ishmaelite's, not Israelites. You can't be a brethren or brother to yourself.
Isrealite not yet there during that time i think
@@danielhariri I don't think by the name but it's understood that it's meaning the tribe of Israel.
John 14-16 speaks of the Spirit of truth who would come, whom the disciples already knew, who lived with them and in them. John 14:17. This is clearly not Muhammad.
where said Muhammad in the Quran that he is a Prophet ?
33:40
@@ducsh when messenger means prophet than is ok
Why moslem uses old testament to justify moh's prophethood? Very two different thing
Nobody knows what happened to Jesus better than his 12 apostles and friends, Paul Peter John Mathew etc....
Anybody can say in medieval times that has spoken with angels and invent fables and tales.There are many false medieval prophets, not only one
So the answer is No,,, God never spoke directly to Prophet Mohammed. Jibril spoke to him. And in the Quran it's not even mentioned Archangel Jibril, but only as Jibril which it separates Jibring from the angels and Archangels which is very strange.
Heres a big difference between Idolatry and Devotion
Mosses spoke to God and we speak to God all the time. I tell God every thing to my creator.does God speak. No ☝️God send angles to guide us. Be realistic. ❤✌🏽✅
A true prophet doesn't poop 💩💩
Basing on the tanakh with genesis as the core information
Moreover God daid he dpoke to his prophets by dreams and visions but spoke to Moses face to face
1.Gen 12 God makes a covenant with Abraham and has a promise in Abraham ALL families of the earth will be blessed.
In his seed which is in sarah and eventually isaac to jacob on to, David Mary then yehashua the final one.
Gen 49 the law and scepter will mot depart from yudah unhil he comes to whom it belongs.
So prophet hood and kings will come from Abraham but that seed will
1.go to a foreign land and deliver them mightly
2.given the land from nile to euphrates.
This is isaac jacob lineage.
The desert dwellers of northern arabia petras are the hagar ketruah and Edom descendants not southern arabs of mohamed yemenis felix
Quran is clear
We gave Abraham isaac jacob and gave them prophet hood and the scripture and authority
Then we prefered israel above all nations
So messiah a ruler..king dshies thus
Mary most blessed woman
Yehashua born pure/holy
These are the line of yacov thro yudah.
Mohamed in wuran days more than was iam a olain warner.
Even i do not know what will be done to me nor you who follow me.
Si he only warned was never given any shariah
Recitiing pray is not of Gid eapically having to confesss Muhammad is the messenger of God how is that praying 🤔
Shabir the book of Deuteronomy doesn't talk about Muhammad, even the verse you have mentioned i.e.Acts 3 ,Peter is explaining that it is Jesus Christ Acts 3:21-24 Whom the heaven must receive until the times of restitution of all things, which God hath spoken by the mouth of all his holy prophets since the world began.
For Moses truly said unto the fathers, A prophet shall the Lord your God raise up unto you of your brethren, like unto me; him shall ye hear in all things whatsoever he shall say unto you.
And it shall come to pass, that every soul, which will not hear that prophet, shall be destroyed from among the people.
Yea, and all the prophets from Samuel and those that follow after, as many as have spoken, have likewise foretold of these days.
GOD spoke directly to Joshua, read Joshua chapter one💯, 😮, kindly let be truthful. Anyone can quote it
Humbly, "a prophet" are not "prophets", it actually means what it says, "an individual." The new Jarome biblical commentary is a "commentary", not the words of the prophesy. Just be honest and deal with the text as it is written.
When you convert to Islam, why do you say “there is no god but Allah”?? When you’re really just saying “there is no god but god.”
As if Allah is his personal name?
It means your are proclaiming true monotheism. And do not accept idols or any equals to God.
The “comforter” is the Holy Spirit! God lives in our hearts.
Spamming this won't help. You didn't watch the video just spanming. May Allah Guide You.
Night journey! Prove to us
The Ulema has so much free time to address what has been proven over and over. Hardworking Muslims yearn for some more free time b
We are the indian largest muslim in the world 🌎
God never spoke to Your claimed Prophet
"جھوٹا کون ہے، اگر وہ نہیں جو انکار کرتا ہے کہ یسوع مسیح ہے؟ یہ دجال ہے: وہ جو باپ اور بیٹے کا انکار کرتا ہے، جو بیٹے کا بھی انکار کرتا ہے اس کا باپ نہیں ہے؛ جو کھلے عام بیٹے کا اقرار کرتا ہے، اس کے پاس بھی باپ نہیں ہے۔ باپ۔" (1 یوحنا 2:22، 23)
Muhammad pbuh talked directly with Allah at time of his Meraj, not only talked he was allowed to get to Allah's house. No other prophet was allowed to fo it.
Muhammad pbuh was mercy for whole universe, all other prophets were prophets of their own community.
Prophet Muhammad pbuh was final and last prophet whose Sunday will be official law upto day of judgement, no other prophet's message is valid anymore.
Prophet Muhammad pbuh is prophet of prophets, he was the imam of all prophets in a Salah before miraj.
Anchor's question is so opposite to the fact that anchors faith ir Iman vanished evenif she wears a nice hijab, she is no Muslim.
Muhammad pbuh speak to allah but allah never reply so who does muhammad speak
DR. SHABBIR. , MY DONKY. ASK ME THIS QUESTION MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED TIME . I TRIED TO UNDERSTAND HIM. BUT PROBLEM IS. HE IS. DEFF.
Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him did speak to Allah SWT on his night journey, he was given direct five times daily prayer from Allah SWT directly . Initially he was given fifty times daily prayer but went back to Allah SWT and asked him to reduce it and Allah SWT eventually reduced to five daily prayers from fifty daily prayers. Drutonomy 18:18 perfectly matches with Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. For example Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and Prophet Moses peace be upon him, both of them had natural birth (Jesus peace be upon him had miraculous birth). Secondly Prophet Muhammad and Moses peace be upon them both had mother and father but Jesus had mother only. Prophet Muhammad and Moses peace be upon them were able to establish divine laws and lead their nations successfully but Jesus peace be upon him were not able to do that. Prophet Muhammad and Moses peace be upon them, both of them had natural death but Prophet Jesus peace be upon him will be sent back on earth and after forty years of reign he will have natural death (narrated by the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him). Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him never said anything out of his own desire or will, he uttered the words only when he was asked to utter . And he uttered everything in the name of Allah SWT (mind you that is the criteria in Drutonomy 18:18) and Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him perfectly matches the criterion set out in Drutonomy 18: 18. Let me give you some advice to all our Christian and Jewish brothers and sisters, since the Advent of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and the revelation revealed to him from the God all the teachings of the previous Prophets have simply become null and void. You have to follow the Prophet of your time and Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is the last and final Prophet, he is the Prophet of our time and his teachings have to be followed to attain salvation. There's no other way to get Paradise. I must also tell you brothers Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and Prophet Moses peace be upon him were cousins, both of them were descendants from the Prophet Abraham peace be upon him. Which is why Islamic faith is also called the Abramic faith. Therefore brothers think seriously before it's too late. Jazakumullah Khairan
The evidence for the existence of God is zero. It is, therefore, not warranted to assume the existence of a being called "God". Those who do it nonetheless are outside of scholarly exchange.
When God's angels are sent to earth to speak with a chosen person it is God who is speaking with through the angel. Revelation 1:1 is a revelation by Yehoshua Christ that God gave to him..... and he sent forth his angel and presented what was to come in signs given to John the Apostle. The Angel Gabriel spoke with the Prophet Muhammad and asked what will be the sign of the end. ... the Prophet Muhammad replied.. It will be when a slave 'lady' gives birth to her Master. An ancient parchment claiming to be an original has these worlds written. If a woman did not give birth to her Master being the King and Anointed of Yahuveh God then there is no hope.
All religion teach no hope because all religions refuse to accept the truth that this proclamation is what is true and I am that woman who gave birth to a Son a Male who wil Shepherd the earth with an iron rod. That Son was caught up to Heaven as foretold in Revelation 12:5 exactly as written. But religious bureaucrats refuse to see truth that must be made known to the world before the world is saved from destruction ... etc..
A PROPHET IS ONE WHO DO GOD WILL AS ABRAHAM THE FIRST JEW
Certainly he was not a prophet of God of Abraham, the One True Creator God.
Why looking for ur prophet in a book that is "corrupt "!
You need not dance round the table of confusions!!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You don't answer the question.
As Dr Shabir Ally has told us on past debate shows, Mohammed used whatever information he had at his disposal (knew about from Jewish and Christians scripture including apocryphal material) as his source for verses (later known as Quran). Consequently, Shabir Ally knows the Quran is not from God but it is a shame why he is holding onto the false religion Islam.
Then what about the Bibles why are all the Bibles different from each other and some Bibles have missing verses
@user-hq1bj9yc6l yes it did you have so many variants of Bibles that it's not even funny
@user-hq1bj9yc6l even the Torah makes more sense
Burak From Mecca to Jerusalem, met Allah The Almighty,using Burak fuel to energize the journey
Nowhere in the quran does it say Muhammad took a night journey on a winged animal; all this is made up stories in the hadiths. Surah Al Isra is about Moses not Muhammad lol Why are muslims the last to know?
Juan 16:7?
Pero yo os digo la verda:
Os conviene que yo me vaya; Porque si yo me voy el consolador no vendra a vosotros;pero si yo me voy, os lo enviaré.
¿Que quiere decir Juan en 16:8
El Espiritu Santo demuestra que todo el mundo es culpable delante de Dios.
El convence al Mundo de Justicia que Jesús de Nazaret era ese Justo.
Adema, la justicia de Cristo, impartida a nosotros para la justicia y salvación.
El consolador,es el Espiritu de la verdad, Os iluminara para que podais entender la verdad completa.
Mahoma no era un Espiritu, que se quedaria para siempre, Mahoma era mortal y no el Espiritu Santo, que se quedaria para siempre.
El Isa de el Corán, no es el Jesucristo de la santa biblia, ni Maria es la madre santa de la biblia.
Isa del Corán en arabe derriba la palabra griega Iso . Jesús en hebreo Yeshua, que esto esta en Arameo por lo que Isa en arabe fue tomado de la palabra griega Isos Jesús, pero ese Isa en el Corán no es el Jesús de la santa biblia. Maria en el Corán se la conoce como hermana de Aaron, el hermano de Moises, como puede ser hemanos , Aaron y Maria, sabe la diferencia entre Aaron y Maria ,1500 años, el Corán es copia de las escrituras bíblicas.
Jesús de la biblia es el Hijo de Dios, y Dios, fue crucificado y él es el Redentor del Mundo, vendra para juzgar vivos y muertos. Solo Dios puede juzgar vivos y muerto, porque Dios su trabajo a un profeta. Entonces ¿Dios esta desempleado?
Ningún profeta tiene autoridad de venir a juzgar a la humanidad, y juzgar vivos y muerto. Solo Dios es quien puede hacer eso. Jesucristo vendrá para juzgar vivos es muertos.
Jesucristo es Dios mismo.
Revelations from Allah made him the Prophet and as Chosen as Prophet from Allah.
Mohd only said he got revelations from An Angel Gabril... in a Cave again... wonder how long he stay in the cave? not logic...Never from Allah.. strange
What is wrong with getting a revelation from Angel Gabriel? Don’t you know that the Angel Gabriel visited every single Prophet from Adam to Mohamed (PBH)?
And the cave? What is wrong with cave? A cave is place in the universe and was created by the Almighty, so what is wrong with a cave?
@@lionking2424 Sure if you consider a purported Angel Gabril is Allah or Antoot or Satain. Good Luck to your god of peaces
@@Pgan803No Gabriel is an Angel. He was also sent to the saint Mary (RTA) to deliver the news about the prophet Jesus (PBH). He was also sent to Prophet Ibrahim (PBH). And he is not a god, he is an Angel. There is only one true god, and one of his name is Allah.
May Allah bless you ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Dr. Shabir, You say God is not like a man. Yet your explanation of Prophet Muhammad talking to God depics God as human who seated somewhere in a location. By saying humans can't speak to God unless behind a veil, it simply means God is a physical being located somewhere. I disagree with that.