Also, next you obviously need to do Satins. Then balm-type lipsticks. I just ordered that new formula from Suqqu. So I guess that would put it the Sheer category. I'd watch a show on that.
@@jessabeauty917I think most of us here are not after affordability, but luxury experience which you get with those brands. Affordable options usually don’t provide the luxury packaging/expensive ingredients etc.
Yes please! I would love other luxury lipstick formula comparisons! Also, I’m shocked that Chanel Rouge Allure was 10th on your list! It’s probably my all time favorite. But I think the aspects of its formula that you dinged it for are exactly why I love it so much. Anyway. I love your videos. Thanks so much for continuing to create content for us and giving us a special treat with this video since I know you’re in the middle of moving / had to film this for us in advance. Good luck with everything! ❤❤
I just had to pause after you explained your 5 reasons and I wanted to applaud you for this concept of this video. And now I'm going to finish watching and excited to explore new lipsticks 💄
At 72 I might be your oldest sub, and in my long experience of beauty influencers, nobody does these comparisons and reviews better than you. The only problem is that you have influenced me into some pricey purchases like my beloved Hermes prunoir. I'm not much of a matte wearer due to my chapped lips, but I do own and enjoy a Dior rouge. Thanks to you, I will now be experimenting with the Prada, Gucci, and Hermes! ❤
28.5 minutes of matte lipstick heaven! 🥰🥰🥰 I have all these formulations except RMS and Hermes. My top three would be Dior, Lisa Eldridge and Pat Macgrath. Color range and transfer resistance are my priorities 😊
This is the type of video I’ve been looking for! I love matte lipsticks, and I’m always looking for a not to drying matte lipstick for very dry lips😂 Thank you for doing this video, Sofia❤ If you don’t mind doing a satin lipsticks ranking, that would be wonderful 😀
I would also recommend Armani Beauty Lip Power Long Lasting lipsticks. It is so creamy and last so long. Shade range is good, maybe not as many as other brands.
For me, PML matte lipsticks apply super smoothly on my lips and stay quite comfortable throughout the day compared to some of the others that you ranked higher. Videos like this are always a good reminder how much preferences play a role and just how our different lips jive with different formulas. However, they're still entertaining nonetheless! Thanks for all the work and dedication you put into this. I'd love to see more ranking videos 💛 Edit: have the TF lipsticks been reformulated in recent years? Mine turned quite quickly, so I'd love to know if they're a more long lasting formula.
The Prada lipsticks are absolutely my favorite over Chanel, over Hermes, Guerlain, they are just superb, the color, the feel, the longevity, the packaging everything.💖💖
I haven’t tried the RMS lipsticks, but it does feel a bit like ‘one of these things is not like the others’ yanno? Like if you include those, you are opening the door to other high-end, but not luxury, like Makeup by Mario, or Fenty…. But, your ranking, your rules! And, I did love how you explained your criteria. The lip ranking I’d be most interested in is the long-wear mattes. If I’m going to wear a matte, those are the ones I go for, because I need something that is going to last through drinks and snacks. It’s hard to find ones that look good, wear well, and don’t crack off with pieces of my lips!
Hermes and Chanel are my favorites. I love Hermes for the colors and I love Chanel because it is more subtle for the times when I want a more subdued look. But I also like the brands you picked . Good review ❤❤
I love Lisa Eldridge lipsticks. The story-telling is fab and the colours are even more fab. My only issue is that shades sell out and it takes forever for them to come back in stock!
I am always here for lipstick rankings! Yay! I personally find the Charlotte Tilbury matte formula horrible, unfortunately. It's extremely uncomfortable on my lips and I think it dries down to a rather cheap look. I don't even have dry lips and my lips look more hydrated with liquid lipsticks than with her matte revolution. It's a pity, since I do like some of her limited edition packaging and it would have been nice to have them. I think that Hermès has a very particular shade range. While they present pinks, reds, etc. - so very normal colours - I find them all to have a little twist that makes them unique. I don't own their matte formula, just the satin, but I think I'll pick one up soon.
Thank you! I thought I was the only one thinking so, 'cause everyone likes it. I was surprised at that they disappeared wayyy too quickly (even my lip balms last longer 😢), and they're drying despite the moisturizing feel when first applied.
I love that you kept this video to mattes. So, so helpful! I’d love to see you do the same for satins formulas and for super glossy formulas! ❤ I like the CT Matte Revolution, too! It doesn’t get the hype anymore, but it deserves it. I can’t WAIT for RMS to put out some nudes in this formula. They are SO SURPRISINGLY GOOD!! I love, love, love these, but so far there’s only 3 shades I want/need. I’m shocked the Gucci was so low on your list! I LOVE this formula, and their shades are amazing and unique! I don’t find they dry out my lips at all. I do find the LE fairly drying over time on me and 2 of my bullets have broken. 😢 But my very, very favorite luxury matte lipstick is Prada. I’ve only tried the Hyper Matte formula so far but GAH! It’s so, so good! They are comfortable and they last in my lips! 😍 They were the only makeup items on my Christmas wish list. I want to try the soft matte soon! And I know they put more neutrals out recently!!
Satins and balmy lipsticks are my most worn! I really like the Sisley formula for a more matte finish. The color you are wearing in this video is absolutely stunning on you! $75 is step, even for a Sisley lover-but I’m tempted! So pretty! Hope everything is going well with your move!
I don’t have many Matt lipstick because of dryness of my lips. However I can use Prada and geurlain and they are comfortable , also Dior transfer proof. I had one TF Matt sample that made my lips dry , the same for Dior Matt, but velvet seems different 😊
Ok…that RMS packaging is awesome. I’m finding I don’t value fancy packaging as much; I sincerely love the fact you can tell what color the lipstick is by the case. ..truly helpful when you have multiple colors.
I agree! I only have 2 RMS products so far. The Super Natural Radiance Serum with SPF and an eyebrow pencil. I just got the Pencil & loved the design. The cap over the Pencil is much longer than the cap over the Spoolie, so no guesswork! Also there is a plastic 'stopper' that hits the cap over the pencil....so no matter how much you sharpen & shorten the pencil you're never going to jam the cover into the tip!! Love this design because it is unique & liked the lipstick serum review as well! 💕
I have tried all these matte lipsticks plus some and MY favorite matte formula is Dries Van Noten’s! Matte without feeling dry or drying. Also fades so so nicely! I’ve never tried anything like it. So good!
Thanks for taking the time to do this . Super useful . I would really appreciate a Satin ranking (including thoughts on smudge and transfer as this is where I personally struggle !) and a liquid lipstick . I like the way you explained thoroughly pro’s and con’s so I can consider what matters to me and what doesn’t .
I love this video 🤤🤤🤤 my absolute all time favorite lipsticks are Lisa Eldridge’s Velvets. MY GOD they are good. I own every single shade and I agree that Lisa’s artistic understanding of color is unmatched. I love the packaging and I just can’t say enough good things about them I’m a big fan
Thanks for the great ranking video, Sofia! I'm very tempted to get the Gucci and LIsa Eldrige's formula. RMS is absolutely amazing lipstick, got it as per your recommentation and left the same review on the website - "Great but need nude colors" :). Prada wears off too quickly on me and that's always discouraging me to use it as I don't like to reapply my lipstick often. But yes, comfortable on the lips and beautiful packaging.
9 місяців тому+1
Obsessed with you😍 I fell in love with hermes lipsticks😍 sadly, all 3 of my gucci lipsticks, that I got on seperate occasions , broke off all of the sudden! Like they melted🥲
Yay! I’m obsessed with Charlotte Tilbury lipsticks I’ve never liked a matte lipstick they are so creamy and taste so good LOL!!! My favs Pillow Talk Medium & Intense SuperModel and Wedding Bells I only wish they lasted longer ….. the Prada omg lasted all day and did not come off on a review I watched!
Hi Sofia! Thank you for this fun ranking. Valentino is #1 and Armani #2 for me. Have not tried Prada (I’m in Canada). Looking forward to other rankings.
Perfect ! You know what I would like to know ? What are your perfumes ?? Nice change and I want to see the new place. This is so fun ❤thank you for this I am only starting to build my “cheaper” lips to more higher end
I loved this video! The only 2 luxury lipsticks I have are Charlotte Tillbury and Lisa Eldridge and I love both of them. You have me curious to try some new luxury brands. ♥️
Hi dear Sofia, loved the video, although not a lipstick person here, only gloss or balm, but love your video's!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩 Hope you're doing well, when moving to Texas, to Dallas!!!! Sending you lots of love!!!😘😘😘😘
Dior is my #1 favorite luxury lipstick, and I love them all, from the Forever Mattes, to the Satin and to the Balm. My favorite everyday lipstick is Clinique Color Pop - Cherry Pop, Blush Pop, Bare Pop - really lovey lipstick too. Dior Forever is the best long wear lipstick on me and it doesn't dry out my lips.
Lisa Eldridge is my favourite. It's great concerning pigmentation, lasting (6-8h) and those lipsticks make all lips look amazing (velvet as promised!). Chanel has the worst pigmentation and don't last long. Tom Ford is too balm-y (not creamy exactly but balm-y) and don't last long too. A bit the same case with Victoria Beckham & Guerlain as Tom Ford. Gucci is really good concerning pigmentation and lasting but those colors don't look so natural (even more classic ones). Hermes has wonderful colors but the formula is a bit too rich/heavy for me (a bit like Makeup by Mario). Pat McGrath is good because it has great colors, lasts long and looks nice on the lips so I think you're a bit harsh about those. I have two Prada's matte formulas and they're both really good but there's something strange about them because they don't look good with every lip liner (for example with Charlotte Tilbury's it's fine but with Pat McGrath or Makeup by Mario no). I love Charlotte Tilbury's lipsticks because they apply and look so natural on the lips. That formula rocks. My favourite reds are Armani. Dior is overrated.
I have a lipstick addiction. I must buy them 😂. Some things I don’t like about certain brands….magnetized (hard to store together) and I really dislike when you have to buy the case separately. I just decluttered some Lisa Eldridge I had stored in my bathroom drawer in a lipstick holder. For whatever reason they had become very oily on the case causing the sticker on bottom of tube to disintegrate. It wrecked the plastic lipstick holder. I am not sure what to think of this……love your content. Edit: the lipstick holder cracking and breaking in 2 places may have been more related to storing a bunch of magnetized cases together. 🤷🏻♀️
Great video , Sofia! I bought several Dior and they were just ok! I like that they are refillable though! It’s great because I have used one shade up. That said I finally purchased some Charlotte Tilbury and fell in love with her matte revolution and the kissing formula, both! I tried ND lipsticks too - they weren’t in this video unless I missed it but the formula is great-they don’t seem to be talked about compared to her e/s
I would also recommend Givenchy cream velvet lipstick. It is a liquid mousse type, very comfortable on the lips, non drying at all! I like their Sheer velvet matte formula as well. I also looove soft matte tinted lip balm from NARS.
Wow! I did not expect Prada to come on top 😳 I've yet to try it, but I plan on swinging by Harrods on my trip to London next month, because I've loved their perfumes and I'm very curious to see what they've done with make-up.
So interesting as this is the opposite of my brand preferences (for the ones i have from your comparison)! CT seems to have zero lasting power on me which is a deal breaker! Cant wait to see your other formula rankings and thr shades you picked up from Dior! Thanks 😊
I am shocked PML is so low! I LOVE the mattetrance formula - it feels light but it does not move. If needed it almost lasts, but as long, with a balm of gloss over it. My second is Armani matte rouge which isn't sold anymore. Chanel, Charlotte Tilbury, Tom Ford, etc are okay but nothing memorable to me. I will say the Gucci packaging is the best!
Excellent video, Sofia. I have lipsticks lower in your ranking that are quite meh and I know I can rely on your suggestions so I plan to pick up some from your list. For me, Givenchy is my favorite.
Great video Sofia! Thank You! I would love to see ranking of other lipstick formulas. I don’t have some of the lipsticks that you mentioned, however I absolutely agree with PMG lowest ranking. I don’t have Chanel Rouge Allure Velvet, however love regular Rouge Allure. I love old Dior - I didn’t try the new formula yet. Gucci is one of my favourites too, however I’m not crazy about their shade range. I’m surprised about high ranking of Guerlain - while the formula is very comfortable they don’t last on me more than an hour. I would love to try Prada, but right now in Canada is practically impossible to get it.
I don't have many luxury lipstick. However I recently gotten the Dior premier lipstick and I love it. The shade range isn't the greatest, but everything from packaging, to formula and the shade (Rouge premier 1) is just perfection. The downside is the price, but it is just like a piece of art, the ceramic case. ❤. I don't know if it is because it's new in my collection and I just want to keep using it while its still fresh and exciting. But I am really enjoying it.
I would have ranked the rouge allure Chanel higher for me personally 😅🥰 but I love love milky beige by Guerlain thier rouge G lipsticks are so good. You have some good picks here. Can’t wait to try the Prada ones 🤩🤩💄
I was interested to see this I haven’t tried a few of these, but I’ve been using the Pat McGrath for a long time and do like it. It wouldn’t be the bottom of my list. I found the Dior ones to be drier and I have issues with Lisa Eldridge bullets dropping out of the inside of the container. I am looking forward to trying the Prada and I wish I could see it in store.
I have a few Prada lipsticks on my list for the Sephora sale, mainly based on your original review of them. They seem really lovely. My unpopular opinion for the Lisa Eldridge lipsticks is that while she has unique undertones, I wish that she had lipstick sample pack for some of them. I've had to give away some of her nudes (Velvet Muse, Affair) because they pulled so orange on my lips. I also find them more drying than the Guerlain so while I love the shades, I probably won't buy any more unless it's a very unique formula or the formula is changed more comfortable and less prone to breaking.
Well done. I agree about Charlotte Tilbury and I feel that Nars also makes great lipsticks. I have fave lippies by Charlotte Tilbury, Lise Watier, Lisa Eldridge and Clè be Peau (very expensive). You suit the Monica one by RMS Beauty and you left out Givenchy.
I think for luxury lipsticks, in addition to factoring in packaging, need for reapplying should be considered... Better longevity results in less cost per daily use.
I really like the lipstick color you are showing us today! Very complimentary on you. How did you do your eye makeup? What was the selection? Thank you Sofia! Good job!
Pat McGrath is beautiful!!! I am also enjoying the Gucci formulate❤❤I returned my Hermes lipsticks. The quality and pigmentation were not there for me.😢
I haven't tried all of the ones in this ranking, but I can say that I'm definitely Team RMS amongst the ones that I *have* tried! I do agree with the need for an expanded shade range for sure. They'd get a lot more of my money if that were the case 😂
Thank you for the ranking! I use Lisa Eldridges lipsticks exclusivly as I have not met a colour which doesn't work with my skintone. I do not understand how this magic works as I am fair and cool toned. Nevertheless I wear Velvet Morning, Decade, Muse, Fawn & Beauty (the two no brainers on me) and they are all stunning. I did not get the very warm ones like Cinnebar or Affair and the purples which won't flatter me. I own nine colours and not one did dissapoint. I will stick to her line.
Looking forward to trying the new Dior, I liked their previous formula. Pat lipsticks have great pigmentation but for me none of the colours I have look nice on me (I have 7 all purchased online mostly on sale) I haven’t found the gritty feel but the dimethicone feel is weirdly suffocating. I like the MAC powder kiss lipstick which in US aren’t luxury but in my country are the same price or more expensive than Charlotte tilbury in every category.
i love gucci's matte lipsticks [toni purple is my favourite, i wanted just a DARK purple that wasn't pink and they nailed it ] and I reuse the bullets a lot, so much sturdier than some others I have.
Hi friends! I hope you enjoyed my analysis of this lipsticks! Comment down below to let me know what ranking video you want next.
Products featured. In alphabetical order...
Chanel Rouge Allure Velvet Luminous Matte Lip Colour - Libre: go.shopmy.us/p-3415017
Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution Hydrating Lipstick - Catwalking: go.shopmy.us/p-3415119
Dior Rouge Dior Lipstick - Tendresse: go.shopmy.us/p-3415025
Gucci Rouge À Lèvres Mat Matte Lipstick - Janet Rust: go.shopmy.us/p-3415064
Guerlain Rouge G Luxurious Velvet Matte Lipstick - Milky Beige: go.shopmy.us/p-3415102
Hermès Rouge Hermès Matte Lipstick - Rose Indien: go.shopmy.us/p-3415069
Lisa Eldridge True Velvet Lip Colour - Affair : go.shopmy.us/p-3415079
Pat Mcgrath Labs Mattetrance Lipstick - Dream Lover: go.shopmy.us/p-3415009
Prada Beauty Soft Matte Monochrome Refillable Lipstick - Tiepolo: go.shopmy.us/p-3415123
RMS Beauty Legendary Serum Lipstick - Monica: go.shopmy.us/p-3415120 (Save 20% OFF with code SOFIASEESBEAUTY20)
Tom Ford Lip Color Matte - Chérie: go.shopmy.us/p-3415075
Also, next you obviously need to do Satins. Then balm-type lipsticks. I just ordered that new formula from Suqqu. So I guess that would put it the Sheer category. I'd watch a show on that.
It might be hard to do but I would love a ranking on color correcting and concealers.
Agreed on the satin/balm lip ranking and face powder (setting, finishing)if that hasn't been done already 😊
I appreciate your honesty with all your reviews! Very thoughtful and you’re never trying to push a product ❤
Yes to other rankings! I like more of a satin, balmy, shiny type😊
That look is so much easier to formulate and there are many low priced options.
@@jessabeauty917I think most of us here are not after affordability, but luxury experience which you get with those brands. Affordable options usually don’t provide the luxury packaging/expensive ingredients etc.
I'd love to see a comparison for sheer, moisturizing lipsticks. That's my absolute favorite formula to wear!
I agree, Melissa. I'm so disappointed NARS seems to be phasing out their original shades that included sheer formulas.
Would absolutely love a satin or balm formula ranking video. Agree on the Prada lipsticks, they are just so good!
Givenchy deep velvet is my absolute favorite. Blurs my lines, comfortable, and the colors are beautiful.
Yes please! I would love other luxury lipstick formula comparisons!
Also, I’m shocked that Chanel Rouge Allure was 10th on your list! It’s probably my all time favorite. But I think the aspects of its formula that you dinged it for are exactly why I love it so much. Anyway. I love your videos. Thanks so much for continuing to create content for us and giving us a special treat with this video since I know you’re in the middle of moving / had to film this for us in advance. Good luck with everything! ❤❤
A vote for Rouge Allure too. The entire lines.
Yes for Rouge Allure!
I just had to pause after you explained your 5 reasons and I wanted to applaud you for this concept of this video. And now I'm going to finish watching and excited to explore new lipsticks 💄
At 72 I might be your oldest sub, and in my long experience of beauty influencers, nobody does these comparisons and reviews better than you. The only problem is that you have influenced me into some pricey purchases like my beloved Hermes prunoir. I'm not much of a matte wearer due to my chapped lips, but I do own and enjoy a Dior rouge. Thanks to you, I will now be experimenting with the Prada, Gucci, and Hermes! ❤
Yes please re other rankings. Satin looks best on me, would love to see a ranking video on that!
Yes bring on those other comparisons for satin and sheer ones. Love to watch that too. Thanks for sharing 🤗😍
28.5 minutes of matte lipstick heaven! 🥰🥰🥰 I have all these formulations except RMS and Hermes. My top three would be Dior, Lisa Eldridge and Pat Macgrath. Color range and transfer resistance are my priorities 😊
This is the type of video I’ve been looking for! I love matte lipsticks, and I’m always looking for a not to drying matte lipstick for very dry lips😂 Thank you for doing this video, Sofia❤ If you don’t mind doing a satin lipsticks ranking, that would be wonderful 😀
I would also recommend Armani Beauty Lip Power Long Lasting lipsticks. It is so creamy and last so long. Shade range is good, maybe not as many as other brands.
Lancome ones too.
I love them. They also have no overbearing scent which I like them over many others .
For me, PML matte lipsticks apply super smoothly on my lips and stay quite comfortable throughout the day compared to some of the others that you ranked higher. Videos like this are always a good reminder how much preferences play a role and just how our different lips jive with different formulas. However, they're still entertaining nonetheless! Thanks for all the work and dedication you put into this. I'd love to see more ranking videos 💛 Edit: have the TF lipsticks been reformulated in recent years? Mine turned quite quickly, so I'd love to know if they're a more long lasting formula.
The Prada lipsticks are absolutely my favorite over Chanel, over Hermes, Guerlain, they are just superb, the color, the feel, the longevity, the packaging everything.💖💖
Yes please, I would love more rankings like this
I haven’t tried the RMS lipsticks, but it does feel a bit like ‘one of these things is not like the others’ yanno? Like if you include those, you are opening the door to other high-end, but not luxury, like Makeup by Mario, or Fenty…. But, your ranking, your rules! And, I did love how you explained your criteria. The lip ranking I’d be most interested in is the long-wear mattes. If I’m going to wear a matte, those are the ones I go for, because I need something that is going to last through drinks and snacks. It’s hard to find ones that look good, wear well, and don’t crack off with pieces of my lips!
I love lipstick so seeing all these brands I don't see at Sephora was fun. Please do a long wear lipstick comparison. Love your channel!
Hermes and Chanel are my favorites. I love Hermes for the colors and I love Chanel because it is more subtle for the times when I want a more subdued look. But I also like the brands you picked . Good review ❤❤
I love Lisa Eldridge lipsticks. The story-telling is fab and the colours are even more fab. My only issue is that shades sell out and it takes forever for them to come back in stock!
I am always here for lipstick rankings! Yay! I personally find the Charlotte Tilbury matte formula horrible, unfortunately. It's extremely uncomfortable on my lips and I think it dries down to a rather cheap look. I don't even have dry lips and my lips look more hydrated with liquid lipsticks than with her matte revolution. It's a pity, since I do like some of her limited edition packaging and it would have been nice to have them.
I think that Hermès has a very particular shade range. While they present pinks, reds, etc. - so very normal colours - I find them all to have a little twist that makes them unique. I don't own their matte formula, just the satin, but I think I'll pick one up soon.
Agree on CT, for me it looks terrible and also only seems to last an hour!
Thank you! I thought I was the only one thinking so, 'cause everyone likes it. I was surprised at that they disappeared wayyy too quickly (even my lip balms last longer 😢), and they're drying despite the moisturizing feel when first applied.
@@amisunshinefulI had the same experience with this lipstick as you did.
I don’t own any of her matte lippies, but her cream/satin ones are quite good! Hermes is on my list. ♡
Lisa Eldridge and Charlotte Tilbury are my absolute favs. I really want to try the Prada now though!
I love that you kept this video to mattes. So, so helpful! I’d love to see you do the same for satins formulas and for super glossy formulas! ❤
I like the CT Matte Revolution, too! It doesn’t get the hype anymore, but it deserves it.
I can’t WAIT for RMS to put out some nudes in this formula. They are SO SURPRISINGLY GOOD!! I love, love, love these, but so far there’s only 3 shades I want/need.
I’m shocked the Gucci was so low on your list! I LOVE this formula, and their shades are amazing and unique! I don’t find they dry out my lips at all. I do find the LE fairly drying over time on me and 2 of my bullets have broken. 😢
But my very, very favorite luxury matte lipstick is Prada. I’ve only tried the Hyper Matte formula so far but GAH! It’s so, so good! They are comfortable and they last in my lips! 😍 They were the only makeup items on my Christmas wish list. I want to try the soft matte soon! And I know they put more neutrals out recently!!
I heard Mac reformulated their lipsticks. I definitely want to try them. Love the rankings videos! ❤
Totally agree about PMG. Not my favorite formula, not bad. Love Lisa Eldridges. Some of my favorite formulas.
Satins and balmy lipsticks are my most worn! I really like the Sisley formula for a more matte finish. The color you are wearing in this video is absolutely stunning on you! $75 is step, even for a Sisley lover-but I’m tempted! So pretty! Hope everything is going well with your move!
Lisa Eldridge Fawn & PML 1995 are my favourites
I like Charlotte lipsticks but Chanel and Dior are pretty good too. I think we are going to try the Prada now. Loved this!! Thanks🥰
Hi Sofia! Yes, would definitely like to see more Lipstick ranking videos!! 💕
Ey Sofy, where is Givenchy Rouge Deep Velvet???? Simply the best (number 37 Rouge Graine) Try it!!!🎉
Agreed! Was surprised that it was not included! Possibly my favorite matte lipstick formula.
Same ! Givenchy is underrated !
You turned me onto RMS, & I love YSL, Valentino & Dior, but I’m still a loyal MAC girl too.
Give me a powder blush ranking, please! With priority given to a radiant, natural-looking formula that is kind to older skins xxxx
Yes! Great idea.
I don’t have many Matt lipstick because of dryness of my lips. However I can use Prada and geurlain and they are comfortable , also Dior transfer proof. I had one TF Matt sample that made my lips dry , the same for Dior Matt, but velvet seems different 😊
Loved this ranking! Thanks for all the work u put into researching all the ingredients, prices, etc…
Ok…that RMS packaging is awesome. I’m finding I don’t value fancy packaging as much; I sincerely love the fact you can tell what color the lipstick is by the case. ..truly helpful when you have multiple colors.
I agree! I only have 2 RMS products so far. The Super Natural Radiance Serum with SPF and an eyebrow pencil. I just got the Pencil & loved the design. The cap over the Pencil is much longer than the cap over the Spoolie, so no guesswork! Also there is a plastic 'stopper' that hits the cap over the pencil....so no matter how much you sharpen & shorten the pencil you're never going to jam the cover into the tip!! Love this design because it is unique & liked the lipstick serum review as well! 💕
When I have more than one color of a brand, I put an approximate nail polish color dab on top of the cap.
I have tried all these matte lipsticks plus some and MY favorite matte formula is Dries Van Noten’s! Matte without feeling dry or drying. Also fades so so nicely! I’ve never tried anything like it. So good!
Dries van Noten is still on my wishlist. Love to try one. What’s your favorite color?
Thanks for taking the time to do this . Super useful . I would really appreciate a Satin ranking (including thoughts on smudge and transfer as this is where I personally struggle !) and a liquid lipstick . I like the way you explained thoroughly pro’s and con’s so I can consider what matters to me and what doesn’t .
I love this video 🤤🤤🤤 my absolute all time favorite lipsticks are Lisa Eldridge’s Velvets. MY GOD they are good. I own every single shade and I agree that Lisa’s artistic understanding of color is unmatched. I love the packaging and I just can’t say enough good things about them I’m a big fan
Thanks for sharing!!
Thanks for the great ranking video, Sofia!
I'm very tempted to get the Gucci and LIsa Eldrige's formula.
RMS is absolutely amazing lipstick, got it as per your recommentation and left the same review on the website - "Great but need nude colors" :).
Prada wears off too quickly on me and that's always discouraging me to use it as I don't like to reapply my lipstick often. But yes, comfortable on the lips and beautiful packaging.
Obsessed with you😍 I fell in love with hermes lipsticks😍 sadly, all 3 of my gucci lipsticks, that I got on seperate occasions , broke off all of the sudden! Like they melted🥲
Oh no!
Brilliant video concept! Bravo! Xxxx
Amazing video Sofia 🔝🙌🏻 I totally agree with you the new Prada lipsticks are so good! They just released new nude shades that Im adding to cart now 🖤
Yeah I need to try!
Yay! I’m obsessed with Charlotte Tilbury lipsticks I’ve never liked a matte lipstick they are so creamy and taste so good LOL!!! My favs Pillow Talk Medium & Intense SuperModel and Wedding Bells I only wish they lasted longer ….. the Prada omg lasted all day and did not come off on a review I watched!
Hi Sofia! Thank you for this fun ranking. Valentino is #1 and Armani #2 for me. Have not tried Prada (I’m in Canada). Looking forward to other rankings.
Great video! Can you list your foundation, eyeshadow and blush you used in this video? Your skin looks amazing
Love a shiny balm...Chanel Winter glow is great. I also love Dior Addict!
Would love to see where the Givenchy deep velvets and sheer velvets would rank! Great video idea!
Yes, please - satin lipstick best of video would be highly appreciated 🙂
I just got the Prada lipstick in Tiepolo and love the color and texture! I also love Guerlain’s matte lipstick 💄
Love this video, it’s really helpful! If you’re ever inspired, I’d love another lipstick ranking for satins and/or balms! 😍
Perfect ! You know what I would like to know ? What are your perfumes ?? Nice change and I want to see the new place. This is so fun ❤thank you for this I am only starting to build my “cheaper” lips to more higher end
Obsessed with this style video!! Please do satin/cream lipsticks like CT Kissing, Armani Lip Power etc 💖💕
Yes please to other lipstick formula rankings!
I loved this video! The only 2 luxury lipsticks I have are Charlotte Tillbury and Lisa Eldridge and I love both of them. You have me curious to try some new luxury brands. ♥️
Great details, as always. Love all the info you provide.
Thank you for doing the work for us!!! 💄👏☺
5. Lisa Eldridge
4. Guerlain rouge g velvet
3. Charlotte Tilbury matte
2. RMS serum lipsticks
1. Prada soft matte🎉
Hi dear Sofia, loved the video, although not a lipstick person here, only gloss or balm, but love your video's!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩 Hope you're doing well, when moving to Texas, to Dallas!!!! Sending you lots of love!!!😘😘😘😘
Dior is my #1 favorite luxury lipstick, and I love them all, from the Forever Mattes, to the Satin and to the Balm. My favorite everyday lipstick is Clinique Color Pop - Cherry Pop, Blush Pop, Bare Pop - really lovey lipstick too. Dior Forever is the best long wear lipstick on me and it doesn't dry out my lips.
Great video. My absolute favourite so far is Lisa Eldridge because of my absolute favourite blue based pink shade Velvet Beauty 💕
Lisa Eldridge is my favourite. It's great concerning pigmentation, lasting (6-8h) and those lipsticks make all lips look amazing (velvet as promised!). Chanel has the worst pigmentation and don't last long. Tom Ford is too balm-y (not creamy exactly but balm-y) and don't last long too. A bit the same case with Victoria Beckham & Guerlain as Tom Ford. Gucci is really good concerning pigmentation and lasting but those colors don't look so natural (even more classic ones). Hermes has wonderful colors but the formula is a bit too rich/heavy for me (a bit like Makeup by Mario). Pat McGrath is good because it has great colors, lasts long and looks nice on the lips so I think you're a bit harsh about those. I have two Prada's matte formulas and they're both really good but there's something strange about them because they don't look good with every lip liner (for example with Charlotte Tilbury's it's fine but with Pat McGrath or Makeup by Mario no). I love Charlotte Tilbury's lipsticks because they apply and look so natural on the lips. That formula rocks. My favourite reds are Armani. Dior is overrated.
Thanks for your ranking. I love TF and CDP lipsticks. I will try your top 3 this year. ❤
Super helpful video, definitely want to try a Lisa Eldridge lipstick now
I love Them! ❤
I have a lipstick addiction. I must buy them 😂. Some things I don’t like about certain brands….magnetized (hard to store together) and I really dislike when you have to buy the case separately. I just decluttered some Lisa Eldridge I had stored in my bathroom drawer in a lipstick holder. For whatever reason they had become very oily on the case causing the sticker on bottom of tube to disintegrate. It wrecked the plastic lipstick holder. I am not sure what to think of this……love your content.
Edit: the lipstick holder cracking and breaking in 2 places may have been more related to storing a bunch of magnetized cases together. 🤷🏻♀️
I knew Prada would be number one!! I adore the Hyper Matte lipstick in shade Ultra Violet!!
Great video , Sofia! I bought several Dior and they were just ok! I like that they are refillable though! It’s great because I have used one shade up. That said I finally purchased some Charlotte Tilbury and fell in love with her matte revolution and the kissing formula, both! I tried ND lipsticks too - they weren’t in this video unless I missed it but the formula is great-they don’t seem to be talked about compared to her e/s
Thanks for the rec!
I ended up buying Guerlain lipstick and prada lipstick after this video ❤thank you for lovely suggestions
You're welcome!!
Great review, thank you! It’s hard to describe sometimes but the scent or no scent is something I personally care about a lot.
I’ve been patiently waiting for this one ❤
I would also recommend Givenchy cream velvet lipstick. It is a liquid mousse type, very comfortable on the lips, non drying at all! I like their Sheer velvet matte formula as well.
I also looove soft matte tinted lip balm from NARS.
Same ! Givenchy is stunning but since they’re sold out most of the time , lesser customers get to try them
Wow! I did not expect Prada to come on top 😳
I've yet to try it, but I plan on swinging by Harrods on my trip to London next month, because I've loved their perfumes and I'm very curious to see what they've done with make-up.
So interesting as this is the opposite of my brand preferences (for the ones i have from your comparison)! CT seems to have zero lasting power on me which is a deal breaker! Cant wait to see your other formula rankings and thr shades you picked up from Dior! Thanks 😊
I am shocked PML is so low! I LOVE the mattetrance formula - it feels light but it does not move. If needed it almost lasts, but as long, with a balm of gloss over it. My second is Armani matte rouge which isn't sold anymore.
Chanel, Charlotte Tilbury, Tom Ford, etc are okay but nothing memorable to me. I will say the Gucci packaging is the best!
Are you still moving to Texas? Saw you put your pictures back up? Looking forward to trying the Prada lipstick ..also their foundation
the ranking I was looking for! thanks!! ❤
Excellent video, Sofia. I have lipsticks lower in your ranking that are quite meh and I know I can rely on your suggestions so I plan to pick up some from your list. For me, Givenchy is my favorite.
I just bought Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Mat Lipstick 308 Lucy Dark Orange 🍊 omg i simply love ❤️ it soooooo much
Great video Sofia! Thank You! I would love to see ranking of other lipstick formulas.
I don’t have some of the lipsticks that you mentioned, however I absolutely agree with PMG lowest ranking. I don’t have Chanel Rouge Allure Velvet, however love regular Rouge Allure. I love old Dior - I didn’t try the new formula yet. Gucci is one of my favourites too, however I’m not crazy about their shade range. I’m surprised about high ranking of Guerlain - while the formula is very comfortable they don’t last on me more than an hour. I would love to try Prada, but right now in Canada is practically impossible to get it.
I don't have many luxury lipstick. However I recently gotten the Dior premier lipstick and I love it. The shade range isn't the greatest, but everything from packaging, to formula and the shade (Rouge premier 1) is just perfection. The downside is the price, but it is just like a piece of art, the ceramic case. ❤.
I don't know if it is because it's new in my collection and I just want to keep using it while its still fresh and exciting. But I am really enjoying it.
I would have ranked the rouge allure Chanel higher for me personally 😅🥰 but I love love milky beige by Guerlain thier rouge G lipsticks are so good. You have some good picks here. Can’t wait to try the Prada ones 🤩🤩💄
I was interested to see this I haven’t tried a few of these, but I’ve been using the Pat McGrath for a long time and do like it. It wouldn’t be the bottom of my list. I found the Dior ones to be drier and I have issues with Lisa Eldridge bullets dropping out of the inside of the container. I am looking forward to trying the Prada and I wish I could see it in store.
The 'best' one is the one that works the best for each individual. I love both Chanel and Revlon.
I have a few Prada lipsticks on my list for the Sephora sale, mainly based on your original review of them. They seem really lovely.
My unpopular opinion for the Lisa Eldridge lipsticks is that while she has unique undertones, I wish that she had lipstick sample pack for some of them. I've had to give away some of her nudes (Velvet Muse, Affair) because they pulled so orange on my lips. I also find them more drying than the Guerlain so while I love the shades, I probably won't buy any more unless it's a very unique formula or the formula is changed more comfortable and less prone to breaking.
Well done. I agree about Charlotte Tilbury and I feel that Nars also makes great lipsticks. I have fave lippies by Charlotte Tilbury, Lise Watier, Lisa Eldridge and Clè be Peau (very expensive). You suit the Monica one by RMS Beauty and you left out Givenchy.
i’m happy you did this video . i’m going to try this prada one.
This was a fabulous video! Rankings yes....Ty Sophia!!!🎉🎉🎉
Love the Prada matte lipstick too!lisa Eldridge has a good matte formula as well 😊
I sure do hope Sephora Canada gets Prada beauty as well! Thanks for the well wishes Sophia ☺️
I think for luxury lipsticks, in addition to factoring in packaging, need for reapplying should be considered... Better longevity results in less cost per daily use.
The colour you wear... Woooouwww... You're soooo prettyyyy
I love Killian and Dolce&Gabbana mat formula ❤ They are amazing!
I’m surprised you didn’t review the new hourglass matte lipsticks.
Probably filmed earlier as she was moving
This was sooo helpful as I'm considering adding a few matte lipsticks to my collection. Thank you so much!
I really like the lipstick color you are showing us today! Very complimentary on you. How did you do your eye makeup? What was the selection? Thank you Sofia! Good job!
Thanks Elizabeth! I think I just used an eyeshadow stick or something simple
I agree Prada is the best!
Pat McGrath is beautiful!!! I am also enjoying the Gucci formulate❤❤I returned my Hermes lipsticks. The quality and pigmentation were not there for me.😢
This video was so much fun as I love lipsticks!! My favorite ones are the ones from Lisa Eldridge
I haven't tried all of the ones in this ranking, but I can say that I'm definitely Team RMS amongst the ones that I *have* tried! I do agree with the need for an expanded shade range for sure. They'd get a lot more of my money if that were the case 😂
Thank you for the ranking! I use Lisa Eldridges lipsticks exclusivly as I have not met a colour which doesn't work with my skintone. I do not understand how this magic works as I am fair and cool toned. Nevertheless I wear Velvet Morning, Decade, Muse, Fawn & Beauty (the two no brainers on me) and they are all stunning. I did not get the very warm ones like Cinnebar or Affair and the purples which won't flatter me. I own nine colours and not one did dissapoint. I will stick to her line.
Looking forward to trying the new Dior, I liked their previous formula. Pat lipsticks have great pigmentation but for me none of the colours I have look nice on me (I have 7 all purchased online mostly on sale) I haven’t found the gritty feel but the dimethicone feel is weirdly suffocating. I like the MAC powder kiss lipstick which in US aren’t luxury but in my country are the same price or more expensive than Charlotte tilbury in every category.
i love gucci's matte lipsticks [toni purple is my favourite, i wanted just a DARK purple that wasn't pink and they nailed it ] and I reuse the bullets a lot, so much sturdier than some others I have.