@Nintendoman15 You have no idea how many times I've seen Signs. From what I remember, the biggest problem is the alien vs water thing. But, that is NOT what the film is really about.
Fargo over Trainspotting, The Departed over Signs for sure, Pulp Fiction is one of the greatest films of all time, but 40 Year Old Virgin is a great comedy. Return of the King over District 9, Finding Nemo is the 2nd best animated film of all time next to Toy Story. American Beauty over Inside Man, Star Wars should win all the time.
I might be asking a noob question here since I haven't been following this channel that long.....but why in the hell are they comparing movies that are COMPLETELY different genres??
@3Axy10Est13 What is it with everyone's hatred for Signs? I've never seen a more powerful moment of a family, clinging to each other as I saw Mel Gibson's character clinging to Joaquin and his children.
Star Wars is Star Wars. why do so many people get confused by that. The Empire Strikes Back is Empire, and Return of the Jedi is Jedi- The prequels were all known as Episode I, II, III or their subtitles Phantom Menace, Clones, Revenge od the Sith-
Usually I agree with you guys on a lot of things and rarely just totally disagree (about movies). I don't understand how all three of you think Signs is great. It's honestly (not hyperbole) one of the worst movies I have ever seen among "real movies that were in theaters" and not straight to DVD shit.
Princess Bride over Bourne Identity? The Bourne Identity is one of the best action movies ever, and Signs is a terrible movie, . .. Pulp Fiction wins over any other movie mentioned here, except maybe Trainspotting
@3Axy10Est13 I agree. Signs is a great film, but I don't think it's THAT great. I personally think M. Night's first big film, The Sixth Sense was better.
@Ha1frican Ok. Everything M. Night made AFTER Signs, was TERRIBLE. No one is going to disagree with you there. But, Signs was a damn good movie. Almost on par with Sixth Sense.
Am I the only one who loves Batman Forever? There's something about the atmosphere of that movie that just gets me.
No definitely not
i can come back and watch these vids over and over :D
"That's man-seed .... That's what i'm going to do to your older sister later..." - Jeff, You a had me in hysterics.
God I miss this channel. These guys felt like my only friends for years
thank you for uploading it early
@haroof awesome website called flickchart....it randomly picks 2 movies you choose which is better and make an ultimate list of your fav movies.
@Nintendoman15
How was Signs illogical or hilarious (in a bad way)?
are they going to review the animated Pirate movie?
the most common arguement Alex and Dan have is spaceballs is spaceballs, gremlins is gremlins :-)
I wanna see the discussion that was skipped when it was between LotR and District 9
@Nintendoman15
You have no idea how many times I've seen Signs. From what I remember, the biggest problem is the alien vs water thing. But, that is NOT what the film is really about.
So when do we finally figure out which movie is the best?
Im so glad all the haters have opinions. Guess what? Dan, Jeff and Alex do too.
What's with all their hard-ons for Signs?
jeff is like this again. "against everything u digging" attitude
They should use the Flickchart option to rate things they haven't already, so they same movies don't keep coming up.
Fargo over Trainspotting, The Departed over Signs for sure, Pulp Fiction is one of the greatest films of all time, but 40 Year Old Virgin is a great comedy. Return of the King over District 9, Finding Nemo is the 2nd best animated film of all time next to Toy Story. American Beauty over Inside Man, Star Wars should win all the time.
Pulp Fiction an "OK" movie? You are dead to me sir!!!
12:57 pause for Jeff's face! haha!
"Signs" over "The Departed"!? I can't believe it... Jeff, wtf?
I might be asking a noob question here since I haven't been following this channel that long.....but why in the hell are they comparing movies that are COMPLETELY different genres??
Best matchup in this movie was Catch me if you Can vs Apollo 13
Space Balls almost won over Trainspotting? Are you kidding me?... :O
I have a lot of the same preferences as Dan: Signs, Magnolia are in my top 5
CATCH ME IF YOU CAN,
come on.
One of my favorites.
I may love Chicken Run, but it is not even close to Finding Nemo.
@3Axy10Est13
What is it with everyone's hatred for Signs?
I've never seen a more powerful moment of a family, clinging to each other as I saw Mel Gibson's character clinging to Joaquin and his children.
Star Wars is Star Wars. why do so many people get confused by that. The Empire Strikes Back is Empire, and Return of the Jedi is Jedi- The prequels were all known as Episode I, II, III or their subtitles Phantom Menace, Clones, Revenge od the Sith-
I agree with Jeff, its always the same 10 movies.
Aww...Jeff. Your feelings on "nerd" make me so sad. I'm glad that you and the guys conquered it!
Spike Lee joint lol
ah Drew Struzan shoutout, very nice
Usually I agree with you guys on a lot of things and rarely just totally disagree (about movies). I don't understand how all three of you think Signs is great. It's honestly (not hyperbole) one of the worst movies I have ever seen among "real movies that were in theaters" and not straight to DVD shit.
Damn Alex has bad taste in movies, I always feel like he's playing catch up in these VS eps. Back to the Future anyone?
@xVancha I love it as well I think Jim Carrey was also very good in it
Dan chose Signs? He hates those kind of movies!
I LOVE SIGNS!
And I freaking hate Amelie!
The cosmos has alligned!
I love this show but i cant never understand that all of them loves signs!!!??
Princess Bride over Bourne Identity? The Bourne Identity is one of the best action movies ever, and Signs is a terrible movie, . .. Pulp Fiction wins over any other movie mentioned here, except maybe Trainspotting
Gremlins?! you guys rely on Nostalgia too much...
Romeo+Juliet was actually a decent movie.
omg u guys choose signs over the departed?!?!?! wake up!!!
@3Axy10Est13
I agree. Signs is a great film, but I don't think it's THAT great. I personally think M. Night's first big film, The Sixth Sense was better.
@3Axy10Est13
At this point, I don't really care what some snobbish film critic, posting on UA-cam has to say about three of MY favorite films.
Jeff really needs to go back and watch Signs. The movie is completely illogical and hiliarious (in a bad way).
why Jeff doesn't like Gladiator?
@gl3bm I'd have picked LOTR too. But District 9 IS fucking awesome.
Signs is a good movie. Screw the haters.
signs over the departed? wat is this? i dont even...
@xVancha Val Kilmer as Batman, man, Val Kilmer.
THE FUCKING DEPARTED!!!!!! Signs is the most boring, if you can call it, 'Sci-Fi' film EVER!!!
@Ha1frican thank you.
the departed was 100 times the movie that signs was!!!
Amelie is Brilliant!!!!!!
I'm with Jeff Fellowship is better!
@Ha1frican
Ok. Everything M. Night made AFTER Signs, was TERRIBLE. No one is going to disagree with you there.
But, Signs was a damn good movie. Almost on par with Sixth Sense.
scarface vs training
Hey, Dan, I just wanna let you know that you have a gay fan.
ip man vs the forbidden kingdom
Not an American Beauty fan???.....!!!
ya buddy
the purse of the black girl
signs is a decent movie
princessbride over bourne identity hahahahahah is this a joke?
@FAWKSH0UND THE DEPARTED SUCKED????? who are you, Micheal Bay?
It's a trap!
the opening song makes me not want to watch your videos... very annoying.
yeah, it's better
signs sucks so much, why the hell do they think it is good? horrible taste........
There Will Be Blood... also terrible
signs is just ok dont love it that much! the ending is terribleee...
@LukeLovesRose Go back and watch it, you'll understand/
AMÉLIEEEEEE
@rzr82 ....I am disappoint
@rzr82 the departed sucked as well.
The Lord of the Rings talk is just BS. LOTR all of the way.
Totally Gay Show..
Okay signs isn't THAT good
Painful to watch
Signs is a terrible movie...
that was lame
LOTR vs district 9 isn't even close, district 9 sucked.