Is Coraline Jones Alive? | The Fangirl Coraline Counter Theory

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 жов 2019
  • It's well past time that I talk about a dreaded coma theory, because The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror XXVIII made an interesting Coraline movie reference.
    Shop Coraline on Amazon: amzn.to/2PgJpJx
    The Fangirl merch: www.teepublic.com/user/thefan...
    See my vlogging equipment: kit.com/sayhalogoodbye/vloggi...
    My favorites on Amazon: www.amazon.com/shop/thefangirl
    Find me elsewhere:
    Twitch - / sayhalogoodbye
    Instagram - / sayhalogoodbye
    Twitter - / the_fanily
    Facebook - / sayhalogoodbye
    The FANily - / thefanily
    SayHaloGoodbye Gaming - / sayhalogoodbye
    Fan mail? Mailing address is in the "About" section of the channel - / @thefangirlwatches
    This video and description may contain affiliate links, which means that, if you click on one of the product links, I'll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows us to continue to make videos like this. Thank you for the support!
    All views expressed are opinions.
    This video is Fair Use under U.S. copyright law (Section 107 of the Copyright Act) because it is transformative in nature, uses no more of the original work than necessary, and has no negative effect on the market for the original work. Furthermore, this video is protected speech as outlined by the first amendment of the United States Constitution.
    #coraline #coraline10 #simpsons #treehouseofhorror #laikastudios #TheFangirl
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 434

  • @Sparrow9612
    @Sparrow9612 4 роки тому +276

    What if the reason Wybie looks so guilty, is because he caused the Joneses car crash? He might have crossed the road on his motorcycle at the wrong time. That mask of his might have obstructed his view and he didn't see them in time?

    • @unknown-qk1dy
      @unknown-qk1dy 4 роки тому +13

      Deep

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +75

      That would be an interesting way to better connect Wybie in the story.

    • @Sparrow9612
      @Sparrow9612 4 роки тому +30

      @@TheFangirlWatches Though that begs the question: if Coraline and her parents are in purgatory and none of them met Wybie while alive, did he die as well after them (bike crash?) and that's how he ends up in purgatory with them? The very end of the film, where everything is now colorful and peaceful as opposed to foggy and gloomy) could be the afterlife, with everyone able to move on.

    • @Alastorsimp1933
      @Alastorsimp1933 4 роки тому +6

      That does explain it because, the mask might be his hiding place. To hide to show he is the one tomake them crash. But, i am sure she would know by now. But, what if he has powers. Think about it, he always apears randomly! From a therioe of him being a fariy!? Idk... Might be true! But, i like to think he is a good person! Cause, maybe he is nervous because, he is scaredfor coraline! Cause, he didn't believe coraline and called her "CRAZY!" Or he could be faking or he could not be, and scaredfor her.

    • @Sparrow9612
      @Sparrow9612 4 роки тому +9

      @@Alastorsimp1933 Could also be that he needs to help Coraline to free himself of guilt, redeem himself and move on to the other side. Unfinished business is what causes a soul to be bound to the world of the living.

  • @theboundingman1598
    @theboundingman1598 4 роки тому +110

    This is definitely a different take on Coraline. And who knows if this is what the creators intended, maybe the celebration at the end of the film is the jones celebrating that Coriline remarkably recovered from her injuries

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +9

      It's totally possible!

    • @Wruegg0420
      @Wruegg0420 3 роки тому +1

      @@Cristina.557 I don’t think people would be very happy about that, and why would there be sweets at a funeral?

    • @Kaii2456
      @Kaii2456 3 роки тому

      @@Wruegg0420 SHE RECOVERS not dies

    • @superstar4662
      @superstar4662 3 роки тому +2

      @@Kaii2456 They replied to a now-deleted comment :) But even if it was a funeral, sweets wouldn't be uncommon! My family brings things like coffee and candy to keep our energy up to make room for the mourning. It's a common practice around the world :).

  • @tineboes2726
    @tineboes2726 4 роки тому +28

    This actually also explains the behaviour of Coraline’s parents. In Coraline’s comastate, she subconsciously blames them and makes them into these horrible, neglectful parents to rationalize her ideas. When she comes back home at the end of the movie her parents are happy and doing the things she always wanted to do and enjoying their time with her. This would be something parents would do after their child almost lost their life and is finally back home from the hospital.
    I also think the Beldam’s face in the garden could be a metaphor for the fact that what happened (the car crash and coma) will always be a part of the Jones’ lives even if everything passed a long time ago.
    The ghost children could be acual ghosts in the afterlife or they could be a distorted view of other children in the hospital Coraline’s in. This explains their speech at the end. “It’s over forever. For us.” Their probably going home or they woke up from a coma themselves, therefor leaving the world Coraline has created.

  • @freedo-gangjaesouth
    @freedo-gangjaesouth 4 роки тому +162

    i do want more & more Coraline theories lol

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +11

      You are not alone 🤣

    • @freedo-gangjaesouth
      @freedo-gangjaesouth 4 роки тому +3

      @@TheFangirlWatches i still want to know the EXACT type of fairy or demon the other mother is

    • @constantine9142
      @constantine9142 4 роки тому

      @@freedo-gangjaesouth I think Jon solo touches on that since fairytale origins is his thing while fan girls are theorys.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +4

      Actually I did a video like that in 2017 with Phil from All Monsters Go To Space - he makes a really good case for a changeling fairy!

    • @freedo-gangjaesouth
      @freedo-gangjaesouth 4 роки тому

      @@TheFangirlWatches okay i will go check that out (:

  • @deserievaux5058
    @deserievaux5058 4 роки тому +6

    Don’t make this even more creepier.
    I already have childhood trauma from looking at the other mothers button eyes.

  • @BBMacsWorld
    @BBMacsWorld 4 роки тому +72

    Wow, you made this movie even more creepier 😱.
    Also, this doesn't have anything to do with the video but I love your Detective Pikachu poster 😃

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +7

      Yay! I was worried that poster was too hard to make out. I have got a horde of movie posters so I'm trying to switch them around in the background.

  • @johntrevino4992
    @johntrevino4992 4 роки тому +18

    The cat voice actor was in his 50s most cats live between 19 and 30

    • @oofsadof5076
      @oofsadof5076 4 роки тому +2

      30? I always thought it was more like 20...

  • @luckyshamrock9955
    @luckyshamrock9955 4 роки тому +66

    Maybe Wybie accidentally pushed her down the well and she died. Maybe that's why he looks guilty

  • @ifloridawarriorcatfan9918
    @ifloridawarriorcatfan9918 4 роки тому +20

    The tunnel is a monster so she was technically slowly dying since she was in its belly.

  • @Saikoraba2001
    @Saikoraba2001 4 роки тому +35

    I actually like this idea! It makes sense, I did always think the neck brace was a weird detail, so I really like this version! BTW, love your channel!

  • @lexi3183
    @lexi3183 4 роки тому +26

    I read that "Coraline" was just a typo and that Neil just stuck with it because he liked it. That could be wrong tho

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +6

      It is actually a real name in Europe!

    • @swankoceanman
      @swankoceanman 4 роки тому +3

      @@TheFangirlWatches Yes, but it was a typo and he stuck with it. He was going to name her Caroline.

    • @psychosislove
      @psychosislove 4 роки тому

      @@swankoceanman That's true.

  • @amberklaire9419
    @amberklaire9419 4 роки тому +18

    Yes! I love this theory. It makes a lot of sense. Especially if you go and watch Claire Wineland's video of her experience in a coma, what Coraline experiences would make sense combined with a child's imagination.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +2

      You know, it never occurred to me that people might have videos after they wake up from a coma. Darn, that would have been excellent research!

    • @amberklaire9419
      @amberklaire9419 4 роки тому +1

      Here is the video I was talking about ua-cam.com/video/xrT9XRyDDaE/v-deo.html
      Unfortunately she passed away recently from her illness, but it is a very informative video nonetheless

  • @spyro2002
    @spyro2002 4 роки тому +38

    While I don't like coma theories in general, yours aee actually really good, you actually back them up well, people don't like them cause most of them are just like "magic isn't real! Must be in a comma!". Like between thid theory and your don't hug me I'm scared one, you have really made me reconsider what a comma theory can be and that it's the maker's fault for being bad not the theory type's.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +4

      Well thank you! I try to back it up, but until I put out a coma theory with Don't Hug Me I'm Scared I had no idea how unpopular they were. But that video went over well so I did one for Coco (the evidence is really there imo) and people reacted so negatively to that I swore I'd never do another. The script for this video sat for 2 years before I finally made it lol

  • @meganmarchionda1165
    @meganmarchionda1165 4 роки тому +7

    Don't know what I love more, the theory or the itty bitty kitty.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      lol he's starting to get big with a big attitude. "No, I OWN YOU, sit down and make a warm lap!"

    • @meganmarchionda1165
      @meganmarchionda1165 4 роки тому +1

      @@TheFangirlWatches Oh I understand my cats are the same way

  • @freedo-gangjaesouth
    @freedo-gangjaesouth 4 роки тому +82

    i still want to know why the other mother makes everybody pray to God where the other Charlie Jones goes "we give our thanks & all our bless to mother's golden chicken breast."

    • @constantine9142
      @constantine9142 4 роки тому +1

      Ha now I want to know

    • @taylorist8665
      @taylorist8665 4 роки тому +1

      I think it was just a joke tbh

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +9

      I mean... do they SAY God directly? I can't remember. But I know Satanic prayers can sound nearly identical.

    • @freedo-gangjaesouth
      @freedo-gangjaesouth 4 роки тому +4

      @@TheFangirlWatches no they don't say god directly but that's still weird that IF the other mother is a fairy that she chose to pray very similar to how others pray to God. i think maybe she's a demon. i think you said she might have been human @ one point in time but offered her own body & soul to the magic place of the pink palace to live forever (by feeding on humans). i just think it's weird.

    • @constantine9142
      @constantine9142 4 роки тому

      @@freedo-gangjaesouth well too it could be making fun of it of prayers. I can't think of what movie or whatever makes me think of that but it's common in lots of demonic or satanic stuff where they have their version of what Christian's do like the holy sabath and etc.
      Sorry if not making sense but I just got sick so my head is in such a fog.

  • @mariacoan3979
    @mariacoan3979 4 роки тому +16

    I love the blue streaks!

  • @TheStormBolt-gf8qi
    @TheStormBolt-gf8qi 4 роки тому +13

    That actually like makes since

  • @ACCastell-737
    @ACCastell-737 4 роки тому +5

    The moment she mentioned the car crash, I realised how much sense it made

  • @ughh4670
    @ughh4670 4 роки тому +19

    This is the newest and most unique way that showed Coraline could be dead. Thank you for makin this! Finally, a new person that sees other reasons for her to possibly be dead! 🙏🙏🙏

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      Yeah I sat on this script for 2 years because I knew coma theories are so widely hated, so I'm sorry I didn't support this possibility sooner lol

  • @leegarlick6032
    @leegarlick6032 4 роки тому +93

    Omg fan girl, Hi it’s me again I just want to say I’m sorry for this but I almost feel like I peer pressured you into making this video because of my last comment on your videos ,but I also want to give a huge thank you for making this ,I love coraline and I hope you are doing well, how are you?

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +23

      Lol I actually had this one made 2 years ago and never recorded it. I had to start spacing Coraline videos out so I didn't run out, but now with the letters trickling in it was time to let this coma theory go into the workd 😂
      I'm doing okay, it's my birthday so I'm just trying to relax. And you?

    • @leegarlick6032
      @leegarlick6032 4 роки тому +6

      The Fangirl omg Happy birthday
      well my bday is in a month then I’ll be 16 🙏 EXCITING, in the current moment I’m doing okay except that I am kinda stressed for exams and life in general ,glad to hear you are doing well

    • @constantine9142
      @constantine9142 4 роки тому +1

      @@TheFangirlWatches it feels like when your birthday is in October it's always someone's birthday, funeral, partys, anniversarys and etc. My birthday this month was especially exhausting lol doesn't help my kids birthday and my dad's birthday is the same day either

    • @leegarlick6032
      @leegarlick6032 4 роки тому

      Laver constantine well I share my birthday with my youngest nephew and he is adorable and every time we go to my fav restaurant and celebrate 🎉 also it can’t be that awful with your son sharing a birthday with your dad as your dad was gifted the best gift of all on his birthday, a grandson

    • @animefairy8822
      @animefairy8822 4 роки тому

      The Fangirl happy birthday !! ☀️🌸😘

  • @DaddyOfTheSugarVariety
    @DaddyOfTheSugarVariety 4 роки тому +8

    I had a cat that looked like him, and his brother looked totally different. I miss them.

  • @madera_51
    @madera_51 3 роки тому +3

    I still can’t stop laughing about the cat from simpsons says “oOoOoO sHinY” XD

  • @suneblommie4549
    @suneblommie4549 4 роки тому +10

    All of your Coraline theories are soo good

  • @flamin_aesthetic9769
    @flamin_aesthetic9769 3 роки тому +4

    The scene where the other mother puts Coraline in the mirror where she meets the 3 ghost children really reminds me of Bloody Mary......hmmm...

  • @Sparrow9612
    @Sparrow9612 4 роки тому +6

    Also, the Cat could be Death/Grim Reaper.

  • @dracomalfoysimp8591
    @dracomalfoysimp8591 Рік тому +3

    I found another point to support this theory- At the end of the movie, in the garden, we see that a white balloon is attached to one of miss spink's and forcible's dog..and from what I know,white is a symbol for the afterlife or death

  • @denisejeffries2675
    @denisejeffries2675 4 роки тому +37

    Loving all the Coraline. So, since I have subscribed and watched literally every video on your channel, emailed you and watched your Coraline playlist 4 times through can I make a request? Would you be open to making videos on all of the movies by Studio Ghibli? Please....🙏...., just think about it 😉

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +5

      I did a few Ghibli's before and ended up fighting copyright strikes, so I've been afraid to touch them again. But, now that I have the live-action format and barely show any images from the movies, it might actually more doable now! And I did just order The Wind Rises. I may just have to start making space for Ghibli again, thanks for the recommendation! :)

    • @denisejeffries2675
      @denisejeffries2675 4 роки тому +1

      Thank you so much for considering it! Now I understand the reason why if you decide not to try it again. All the same I'm really enjoying your channel :-)

  • @lexi3183
    @lexi3183 4 роки тому +4

    Also yes I personally never noticed it before but the last time I watched Coraline, Wybie specifically caught my eye. Something's up with him

  • @gracekim25
    @gracekim25 4 роки тому +4

    This is probably the most detailed and interesting coma theory video I’ve ever seen

  • @firegirl1901
    @firegirl1901 4 роки тому +4

    The way you talk and act with your cat is litarlly me

  • @berrisfueller6221
    @berrisfueller6221 4 роки тому +24

    I have a theory: Is it possible that when Coraline’’s parents go missing, could she be transitioning into the other world and maybe she’s a spirit going back and forth? The beldam might possibly be like the grim reaper in a way.

  • @ashleymartinsonforever3131
    @ashleymartinsonforever3131 4 роки тому +14

    This theory is interesting. Would make sense. Your theories are always fascinating. Awesome video. ♥️💟. Excellent job.

  • @theecourtofmadness
    @theecourtofmadness 4 роки тому +12

    You got 'guilty' from the way Wybie acted? I had the feeling that he was abused. Possibly mentally and emotionally, since he doesn't have any visible physical marks on him.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +5

      Wringing your hands and neck is more of a nervous reaction. Abuse could be in there too, but I doubt Wybie would be brave enough to steal the doll if it was an abuse situation.

    • @theecourtofmadness
      @theecourtofmadness 4 роки тому +4

      @@TheFangirlWatches Do you think there's enough information to do a theory on whether or not Wybie was abused, either during the movie or maybe his parents were abusive and CPS placed him with his grandma? All I'm saying for sure is that parents who love their kids do not name them Wyborne or allow the other parent to name them that.

    • @swankoceanman
      @swankoceanman 4 роки тому +1

      @@theecourtofmadness Exactly!

    • @frankieverona5353
      @frankieverona5353 3 роки тому +1

      or could completely be autism or adhd, cause be all of those things but i always thought of him as autistic with the stimming(sounds,motions, gestures ex:excessive rubbing, scratching head, holding hands together) and also his hard time with eye contact ( not in the other world), unique interest in slugs/his bike motorcycle thingy,or his social awkardness and anxiety talking to coraline.

  • @alanaw4489
    @alanaw4489 4 роки тому +4

    Cute seal point kitty I love his mask

  • @musicINme013
    @musicINme013 4 роки тому +5

    We will NEVER be tired of Coraline theories!
    Have you thought about evaluating monster house? It’s pretty spelled out by the end, but maybe you can squeeze a theory out of it!

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +2

      I have had Monster House recommended to me a lot, and I just recently uncovered my old DVD (finally bought a new media shelf so things have been in boxes FOREVER!) so I need to sit down and watch it again.

  • @dawnchance1475
    @dawnchance1475 4 роки тому +3

    The cat could be an god trying to get Coraline to be a follower.

  • @micaylab1
    @micaylab1 4 роки тому +4

    You're reminding me of Dante's Inferno again.

  • @AnastasiaTheCat24
    @AnastasiaTheCat24 4 роки тому +13

    This is actually an amazing theory 🤩😍

  • @jadepeppermint2734
    @jadepeppermint2734 4 роки тому +6

    this made me rethink everything theory I came up with and now I really need to go re-watch the movies because this theory is just that good

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому

      Let me know how it holds up after you watch Coraline again! 😘

    • @jadepeppermint2734
      @jadepeppermint2734 4 роки тому

      @@TheFangirlWatches it holds up way better then mine you out did yourself

  • @shathamohamed112
    @shathamohamed112 4 роки тому +2

    👍 I recommend that theory the most for 2 main reasons 1️⃣. Tunnels are known to bee seen by all people who have been in a comma 2️⃣. She keeps waking up in her original room even when she falls asleep elsewhere❗

  • @ashlash2612
    @ashlash2612 4 роки тому +3

    Yay coraline ! Yay kitty derp!♥️and small person creeping in at the end 😂

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      Lol they all just do as they please. My official title is small creature wrangler. 😂

  • @Silentgrace11
    @Silentgrace11 4 роки тому +1

    Glorious theory aside, the fact that they got Gaiman to voice the cat in that Simpson’s episode is glorious

  • @karenmoreno7727
    @karenmoreno7727 2 роки тому +1

    when both parents said" welcome home Coraline we've been waiting for you" to her that means something and she's thinking hard about the car crash and being a coma still Coraline gets curious about the house and the place is new to her and is scared to go near the well.

  • @daisygreen5889
    @daisygreen5889 4 роки тому +5

    Always glad to hear from you. Much love darling. I used to have a kitten that looked just like yours. She was very vocal.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      This kitten is VERY vocal too. He'll wake up the whole house when he's not happy lol

  • @bluecheeseproduction
    @bluecheeseproduction Рік тому +2

    I love this theory and despite the fact that I haven’t watched Coraline in a while, something I do remember is that (correct me if I’m wrong) but Coraline parents are always seen in the same clothes, except for the suit that Charlie is seen in when they go to town. Yea, it would be difficult to change their clothes every once in a while. but if Laika was willing to put Henry Selicks face on a dollar bill, as well as make separate outfits for Coraline, then I don’t see why they wouldn’t for her parents. What if her parents are never seen in different clothes because the clothes we see them in, are the same clothes that Coraline last saw them in. I mean, the clothes they wear aren’t exactly clothes I would think someone would wear repeatedly.
    And if this theory doesn’t hold up, then it could work in with the theory that the Jones family is extremely broke. If your a parent and you can barely afford clothes, then I would think you would spend any money for clothes, on your kids clothes. But that’s just me.

  • @cyrusthelizardking
    @cyrusthelizardking 4 роки тому +5

    This is an amazing theories haha! I love Coraline, happy 10th anniversary Coraline

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +2

      I know it's crazy that's she's 10 this year and now all this merchandise is hitting stores. Coraline didn't have this much stuff when the movie came out! lol

    • @cyrusthelizardking
      @cyrusthelizardking 4 роки тому

      The Fangirl OML! Yeah I agree it was a tragedy but at least we now have it all! Thank you

  • @musicaltheatrefan4504
    @musicaltheatrefan4504 4 роки тому +2

    Happy birthday!!! Hope it’s great! I’ve always loved your Coraline theories:)

  • @johnhayward998
    @johnhayward998 4 роки тому +4

    Please more coraline videos and I love that mogi statue in the background

  • @verifiedfangirl6107
    @verifiedfangirl6107 4 роки тому +2

    That siamese kitten is adorable!

  • @Papyrus_Basket
    @Papyrus_Basket 4 роки тому +1

    Honestly I could listen to you talk about this movie forever.

  • @Jasminejupiterjuice
    @Jasminejupiterjuice 4 роки тому +1

    i love these Coraline videos!! its the whole reason i found yiur channel!

  • @ramenqueen4811
    @ramenqueen4811 4 роки тому +4

    Now that I finished video great job! You put alot of work into your theories

  • @magsd8300
    @magsd8300 4 роки тому +1

    This was pretty awesome, Fangirl😱 great job!!

  • @rissaver5199
    @rissaver5199 4 роки тому +2

    I have even scarier theory I think. What if Coraline was a schizophrenic? Look. Her parents drive her to the Pink Palace, in theory - psychiatric hospital. Coraline is so alone. That why she imagine her parents as bad parents, to not feel so sad. Beldam is a nurse. She really loves Coraline, because she is just a kid and she needs love. But when Coraline discovers that she can't leave Pink Palace, she starts to imagine Beldam as horrifying witch. Cat is just a cat, door to the other world are the door made for children (they lead to the Beldam's office) to have more fun. Other Father is a nice doctor, Other People are just other patiens of the hospital. Ghost Children are the previous patiens that Coraline saw on the picture somewhere. Grandma and W-B are neighbours, W-B is a volunteer, who helps with "safe patiens" like Coraline. I would write more, but this comment is long enough 😂
    PS. Sorry for mistakes, I'm from Poland 😉

  • @rennemarie
    @rennemarie 4 роки тому +3

    Yay a new Coraline Theory!

  • @MrAdryan1603
    @MrAdryan1603 4 роки тому +1

    YASSSSSS!!! Thank you :)
    And Happy birthday

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      You're welcome and thank you! Wait... that turned into Maui's song 😂

  • @anilin6353
    @anilin6353 4 роки тому +1

    A cure all that was popular is coloridal silver, which if taking in large volume, turns your skin blue.

  • @amandacarnelison2157
    @amandacarnelison2157 4 роки тому +1

    Your Coraline videos are my favorite

  • @meganmansfield2363
    @meganmansfield2363 4 роки тому +2

    Thank you for another awesome theory. At some point I also wondered if Coraline was in a coma Or even dead. ❤️😭

  • @ravenblack1369
    @ravenblack1369 4 роки тому +2

    Awwwww what a cute kitty!!!

  • @eye63
    @eye63 4 роки тому +1

    I REALLY WANT ANOTHER MOVIE BECAUSE THESE THEORIES ARE MAKING ME QUESTION EVERYTHING BUT AHHH

  • @CarlyJun
    @CarlyJun 4 роки тому +2

    I hadn’t thought of this before, but it’s a very interesting theory!

  • @GumballMachine05
    @GumballMachine05 9 місяців тому

    The coma idea is pretty good. There was once a guy who got hit on the head at his graduation but for like 5 seconds lived a whole life and got married and had a kid and he still remembers it all today and has therapy because he genuinely believed it happened. Time works funny when you're asleep

  • @zeniomozara1280
    @zeniomozara1280 4 роки тому +1

    THIS MAKES SO MUCH SENSE!!!! Love you!!!YOU 👏 ALWAYS👏 DO👏SUCH👏GREAT👏VIDEOS!!! Thank you for creating this video😁

  • @maree8770
    @maree8770 4 роки тому +3

    I've noticed when Coraline plays the game of finding the ghost children's eyes, and her parents with the other mother. Coraline
    looks into the middle of the triangle It shows an gray color in the garden, & Then shows the color of the ghost children's eye.
    Could that mean the Other world
    where the Other-Mother lives in,
    Is some kind of Dead-World, Cause this was the place where The lost children was at Before they died, And they got trapped there forever, And they died with the buttons in their eyes. Is that Triangle stone Coraline got from The Old ladies In the basement
    An Planchet? That triangle game piece that is included with the Ouija Board? Cause an person Can't play with the Ouija Board without that triangle planchet.
    Thanks for Reading. 😎

  • @halloween3627
    @halloween3627 3 роки тому

    this is a really good theory it explains so much of it

  • @elphieb3538
    @elphieb3538 4 роки тому

    Aww your kitten is so cute! We have four cats, two of which we rescued as strays. The first one is a Siamese my parents found literally in the middle of the road (he wasn't hit by a car, he just got stuck there for a minute because he was trying to cross the road) that we named Hedwig, and the other is a Tabby/possible Tabby-Serenghetti or Bobcat mix we found outside our house about two weeks ago, and we are currently stuck between Echo and Shira for a name.

  • @whostony
    @whostony 3 роки тому +2

    I would call the other world, the beldams spiderweb

  • @NessaTheBat1
    @NessaTheBat1 4 роки тому +1

    I like this theory.. It kinda explains why there are the big time gaps and other things. I don't know if we will ever find the solution to this film's mystery, but it's fun to think about these many possibilities. And if we never have the real answer or don't know it, everyone can have their own theory to be true. c:

  • @ravenbarker00
    @ravenbarker00 4 роки тому

    Favorite theory so far!

  • @leamberpendergrass6134
    @leamberpendergrass6134 4 роки тому +6

    Happy birthday megan sorry if i didnt spell your name right by the way love your kitty he so cute.

  • @MrAdryan1603
    @MrAdryan1603 4 роки тому

    I think this is your most compelling Coraline theory yet. It's so darkly fascinating. Brava
    This theory kinda brought me to tears. I don't know whether it's just the thought of a child dealing with a situation so devastating our what, but wow. Your videos have completely changed the way I look at any movie. The Don't Hug Me I'm Scared video gave me somewhat the same reaction. That was very rough. Cheers

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      Apparently I've been doing UA-cam wrong. People want to be depressed or freaked out, so I guess I should work more in that direction lol. Really though, I'm so glad you're getting such a response from this video. I wrote it 2 years ago and was so afraid of another backlash from a coma theory that I've just sat on it. It almost never saw the light of day 😂

    • @MrAdryan1603
      @MrAdryan1603 4 роки тому

      @@TheFangirlWatches I don't get it either. Everyone l loves happy and mind-bending ideas and theories... But these darkly themed videos tear at my heart, yet I keep coming back for more.

  • @berrisfueller6221
    @berrisfueller6221 4 роки тому +1

    I have another theory, maybe Coraline’s imagining everything about the other world, out of boredom, and since she is interested in going on adventures. Maybe that’s why her parents didn’t remember anything, because none it happened possibly. Coraline could’ve imagined this for months, so that could be why fall suddenly turns into spring in what seems like a few days have gone by at the end of the movie.

    • @jessicarichard9358
      @jessicarichard9358 4 роки тому +1

      I can go with that cuz when i was sick once when i was 2 years old i thought up things that passed the time

  • @noelialynn8714
    @noelialynn8714 4 роки тому +2

    Love it

  • @LouiseBrooks-vt7jh
    @LouiseBrooks-vt7jh 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the awesome video! The kitty is so precious. 🐱😀

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      Thanks! lol that cat is such a booty. It's his way or a screaming fit!

  • @SunHeaven
    @SunHeaven 4 роки тому +2

    Actually I don't think a coma theory is lazy in this case because it makes sense and there more evidence for this one than compaired to other coma theories. I really liked this theory! It also reminds me of the theories on Over the Garden Wall.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому

      Well, thank you! I thought one of my Coco theories had some strong evidence for a coma too, but WHEW the backlash on that got insane with angry viewers, lol.

  • @michellepinnick5622
    @michellepinnick5622 2 роки тому +1

    So the Beldam could be Coraline's doctor. And Coraline is picturing her as something scary instead.

  • @musicINme013
    @musicINme013 4 роки тому +3

    I vote Avocado or Little Cado for the kitty! LOVE FINAL SPACE!

  • @mini_mew775
    @mini_mew775 2 роки тому +1

    Omg Leon KITTITI! LOVE IT

  • @hexalynn9434
    @hexalynn9434 2 роки тому +1

    I always love your hair!

  • @kenyasamba4045
    @kenyasamba4045 4 роки тому +1

    Hi fan girl,
    I subscribe to your channel for some time now and your honestly by far one of the best channel on youtube in my opinion, i ABSOLUTLY LOVE the way your theories uncover so much more than meets the eye in movies and animated movies, and i came today wondering if i might make a request. Would you please consider doing a theorie on Little nightmares ? The second opus is coming out in 2020 (january if i recall correctly) and yet there's so few we know about six's history (the protagonist of the game) and the hole Little nightmares universe in general. There's so many details and pieces of informations to pick up that i figured you'l like digging into it, and i'v been dying for some time now to hear your thoughts and theories on it.
    Hoping you will catch my comment and looking forward to your next video.
    Much love and support from France.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      That is actually on my list to cover early-ish into next year. 🤫😁

    • @kenyasamba4045
      @kenyasamba4045 4 роки тому

      Awesome !! Can't wait to see it, and thanks for answering my comment 😊

  • @rfreeman334
    @rfreeman334 4 роки тому +1

    so it was probably just coraline's dream the hole time

  • @ramenqueen4811
    @ramenqueen4811 4 роки тому +1

    Before I get any further with the video just want to say I love your hair!!

  • @ultimatedanganronpafan8226
    @ultimatedanganronpafan8226 4 роки тому +1

    Actually coma theory’s are really hard to prove because you need a lot of evidence

  • @zimnenoski3154
    @zimnenoski3154 4 роки тому +2

    My book arrived! Im so happy. When i read it, ill buy comic book, i love coraline so much

  • @orleansartist6095
    @orleansartist6095 6 місяців тому +1

    Have you ever noticed the "small detail" that Wyborns head is cranked to the side so far? Did he get his neck broken? Maybe on that motorcycle?

  • @bellerosecrafts8014
    @bellerosecrafts8014 4 роки тому +4

    your vids are so awesome the fangirl i would like to point something out, ok so remember how the water is brown?, well i think i know why that is i have read about cases where if someone hides a body/bodies in a water tank the water has a brownish tint to in depending on how long the body/bodies have been rotting away for, think about it we never get to see what happens to the bodies of the 3 ghost children.....and if u look at the room they are in when Coraline, is in the mirror the bed that they are on has dark water on it sooooo maybe another portal to the real world?

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +1

      Holy crap I thought it was old pipes but omg that would make a lot of sense too! Isn't that the room the Beldam kept them in too?!

    • @bellerosecrafts8014
      @bellerosecrafts8014 4 роки тому +1

      @@TheFangirlWatchesFangirl yes it is they said she locked them away there and ate up there lives. also, I think you can hear dripping water witch always seemed like a random thing to add unless it was a clue

  • @DawnzeenaMcGill
    @DawnzeenaMcGill 4 роки тому

    Made it to the end! Cool theory you brought up a lot of solid points. I don’t remember what car my dad had when I was 8 I just remember it was a blue ford and you had to push the seats forward to get in the backseat because there were only two doors. Anyway he let someone barrow it to get their kids and they got in a car reck on their way after a drunk hit them head on by driving in the wrong lane and according to my dad the damage was so bad that if the kids had been in the car they would likely be dead or in the hospital fighting for their life. He refuses to get any type of car with limited backseat space because of that, which given how many times me or my brother needed to be picked up from school for various reasons I can understand the logic of it now instead of pitching hissy fits because he wouldn’t get another cool looking car like when he had to replace the one his friend wrecked.
    Also your kitten is adorable! 😍

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому

      Yeah some cars are just super dangerous for more than 2 passengers. I think that's improved a lot in recent years, but my Beatle was a 2002 and not fit at all for a car seat.

  • @eatyourvegetables226
    @eatyourvegetables226 4 роки тому +1

    Actually, Her name was gonna be Caroline, but Neil made a typo and ended liking Coraline more, which is a big coincidence

  • @vikingqueenjada4143
    @vikingqueenjada4143 4 роки тому

    I just love you and these theories of yours!! Keep up the great work❤️💙💛💜💚💕💖💗💘🖤 *Also I....love your hair!!* 💙💛💙💛😍😆😆😆💇💁

  • @RWAC685
    @RWAC685 2 роки тому +1

    They Are All Dead, Which Explains Why She Is Stuck In The “Other World”. AWESOME!!!

  • @queendsheena1
    @queendsheena1 4 роки тому

    First off, Happy Birthday Fangirl/Megan. Coma theories are great when done right and you were fantastic. I have always theorized that Coraline made it out but not because she moved on. Instead, I believe there's a deeper destiny in play. I have my theories but most recently I had a huge parallel between Gotham (Fox) final season Bruce Wayne and Coraline. The Other Mother is Rahs Al Ghul, Coraline is Bruce but instead of pushing Coraline towards a said destiny, Other Mother is trying to stop it. Just a thought to add.

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому

      And here I am, having never watched Gotham, really wanting to go binge it right now! lol

  • @karenmoreno7727
    @karenmoreno7727 2 роки тому +1

    what if Coraline is dead and Wybie is in fact her guardian angel trying to get Coraline on the other side so that she could be reunited with her parents again even Coraline's father says " we just want to keep you safe and not lose you again".

  • @jessieg5414
    @jessieg5414 4 роки тому +1

    What if when the Charlie and Mel are captured by the Beldame, they have actually tried to make a deal to save their daughter’s life, but instead become another reason for Coraline to “play the game”. I love your videos ❤️❤️

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому +2

      It's possible but I would expect them to remember something from a deal. 🤔

    • @jessieg5414
      @jessieg5414 4 роки тому +1

      The Fangirl maybe it was erased when coraline “won” but yeah it’s a stretch 😂

  • @laurajanco2i
    @laurajanco2i 3 роки тому

    maybe the other world is like a trial, like a purgatory/limbo that she has to go through before dying. Otherwise, it could be like a comatose state and maybe the Beldam trying to keep her her locked up in the fake world and saying "don't leave me or I'll die without you", was the mother that was telling a dying Coraline to not die, otherwise she would have been lonely without her.

  • @MiyuSawai
    @MiyuSawai 4 роки тому +1

    That sounds like the first season of American Horror Story

  • @monty_best
    @monty_best 3 роки тому

    I want more I love your videos its gives me entertainment

  • @unorthodoxparadox2339
    @unorthodoxparadox2339 4 роки тому

    Been waiting for this theory for almost 3 years

    • @TheFangirlWatches
      @TheFangirlWatches  4 роки тому

      Lol I've been avoiding it for about that long. People hate coma theories so much 🤣

    • @unorthodoxparadox2339
      @unorthodoxparadox2339 4 роки тому

      @@TheFangirlWatches I really enjoyed the video

  • @kimdoogleouo4521
    @kimdoogleouo4521 4 роки тому +3

    He could be part ragdoll cat. He looks a lot like mine. Just not as fluffy.

  • @Jade_West2010
    @Jade_West2010 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting theory. I've always thought that everything was kinda off. The movie felt like a bad dream or something. Also, I know this is probably different but in The Flash tv show, The speed force takes form of his dead mother. And the speed force is kind of an afterlife for speedsters. I don't know how to word it but, maybe the Beldam taking the form of Coraline's mother is kinda doing what the speed force is trying to do. I'm probably thinking too deep and I know this video was a long time ago, but it just seemed weird to me.