Himanshu obviously he is Indian so he must be the smartest person in any given room. Indians suffer from crippling overconfidence which render them almost deaf to a different point of view.
धन्यवाद सर,भसणानी सर,हासन निसार साहब, और ताहिर गोरा सर ऐसे विद्दवान लोगों से कुछ भारत के डिजाइनर पत्रकारों ने आतंकवाद बारे में कुछ सीखना चाहिए,ना की तुकडे तुकडे गैंग के साथ खड़ा हो ना चाहिए, जय हिन्द वन्दे मातरम 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I like mr. bhashani , he is telling the truth, I like to meet him some day, i started my education in kinder garden in 1952 in convent school in srinagar , now I am a doctor in usa, kashmiries gave me a good start.
My DNA brothers i am very glad to hear in this debate all of you have spoken with convictions and very truly have described that Pakistan live in denial this is absolutely the problem of Pakistan. But unfortunately a pathological denial and liars Pakistan will never change its ideologies in the future and that is the head truth 🙏 Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Mr. Bashani is the only sensible,honest and practical guy.Unless Pakistanis don't behave and understand like Mr. Basani their internal problems and relations with neighbors will never be over. It is in your own interest that you live like a good neighbor with India and see you will prosper like anything.This is a one and only solution to all your problems and existence.
You should invite guests who has knowledge about India and Indian constitution before making serious comments such as -- Indian secularism does not exist and there have been constitutional amendment to make it nonsecular. If you referring to cow ban, then it was part of Indian constitution, current government only tried to enforce an existing law that has been part of constitution. Dog eating is banned in US, that does not mean US is not secular!
Don’t compare India with Pakistan. You are a foolish person if you do that india is the only country in the whole world where people of every religion lives peacefully.its secular character can never change by some fanatic groups who are unarmed and not like Pakistan where in your country these groups roam freely with ak 47 rifles. You are a declared terrorist country who export terror all over the world. India is an epitome of unity integrity and peace. Hindus do not believe in killing like Muslims who believe in Jehad and killing. Pl be real and do not talk rubbish. Hamid bashani is a balanced person
There has been no terrorists activity in India since last four years.inspite of you country sending armed terrorists to India in hundreds.This is your status.And no confusion about it. World says it
Bashani sahib is a rare Kashmiri Pakistani who thinks like a global observer and his rationale is global. He is not scared to call a spade, a spade due to his attachment.
The common Indian is totally with the armed forces and totally against the separatists, terrorists sent by Pak army and their overground workers the stone-pelters. The guy with glasses is totally wrong in saying that there is a lot of sympathy for the Kashmiri and Pakistani jihadi. This sympathy is so minuscule it may be termed negligible. Only select intellectuals like Arundhati Roy and her ilk are with them.
Sukhar hai pakistan me aap jaise log mojud hai,isi wajah se aaj tak pakistan ka wajud bacha hai.nahi to pakistan ek kabargha ban gaya hota.God bless all of you.Best of luck.
J&K is already is free, they have their own Elected Govt, but it is being misguided by Pak agents. India only provide it financial & security protection. J&K gets the maximum financial aid, but it doesn't contribute anything to the center Govt. The main reason for them to be able to create problem is this financial aid. When they don't produce anything & contribute. The centre should not provide any financial help.
Secularism in India is deep rooted and stands like a Rock. Paid and sponsored rantings by pseudo intellectuals can not shake its foundations.. Very few unfortunate events do not the change the previlages enjoyed by all.
Muslmaan , sunni , shia , ahmedia , sufiyan , Bharath mein mahfoos hain , masjidon mein goliyan nahin chalti , duniya mein second largest muslim's Bharath mein rahte hain aur sub Bharath ke liye jaan nichavar kar denke .
Pakistan mein minorty 15% se ab 2% pe aa gayi hain... or India mein muslims 9.8% se ab 18% hon gayein hain.. And yeh sala bolte hain India mein secularism khatam hon gaya hain... kuch toh sharam kar jooth bolne.. walein..
A simple option for Pakistan is to accept the Line of Control as the permanent international border, and also giving up revanchist foreign policies. They must give up militancy as a part of their security policy. There is only one problematic state in the South-Central Asian region. All other countries in this region are constructive and sane countries.
At 15:08 the man lies that in India constitutional chnages in India. What constitutional amendment has happened? Its a lie. Religion plays no role in India's state affairs. It plays a role during elections as part of larger identity politics. But this notion that Muslims are oppressed is non sense. If they are so oppressed they would have migrated to Pakistna many years ago. The fact that they are here and are increasing in number is proof that they are safe here.
Excellent presentation by these three intellectuals if these people had to leave Pakistan and settle in Canada speaks volumes of the perceution & intolerance in Pakistan that is why the minorities in Pakistan decreased dramatically while in India it has increase. In terms of Governance in Pakistan it is ruled by Islamabad & Rawalpindi in tandem. Ever since Gen Zia’s tenure Civilians have been seen with suspicion that is why Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was hanged by the Pakistan Army. Today Pakistan is dependent on People’s Rep of China as the only Arms supplier while India has multiple including South Korea , Japan , Isreal ,France & Russia & USA. The US & India talk to Pakistan thru Saudi Arabia the money lender of Pakistan. Gawadhar gifted to PRC has created enmity with the Arab States & the US which has Strategic Naval partnership with Japan & US , India & Australia. India has a larger trade with India. China wants a proxy war with India & Pakistan fighting so it will have a weak India . This equation changed with Modi becoming Agressive & A hard Power not a Soft Power That is Reality. Nathan Sekhar Sydney Australia.
i m sikh aur main dava karta hoon k india secullor country ab agar aap ko lagta hai k muslims ko kuch b karnedene hi secullerism hai toh ab vo band ho gya hai
JIS COUNTRY MYE PM CHOR HAIN AUR MILITARY DAKU HAIN , AMAM KO KIA HAWLAT HAIN ? JINNAH KO SUKHRIA ADA KARNA CHAHYE PAKISTAN KO ALAG EK MULUK BANANYE KE LYE THANK YOU JINNAH SAHAB
India ne Secular Ban ke Kaun sa Nobel Prize le lena, especially Pakistan ki nazar mein. Nepal duniya mein India ke baare mein kya kya bolta hai, uss kaun sunta hai, Pakistan aur China ko chhod kar - jo ki har waqt afeem piye rehte hain.
Pakistan believes in fake narratives, victimhood, denial , terrorism and excuses. The whole mentality is known even to the OIC. Very soon Pakistan will be wiped off and in its place will emerge countries like Baluchistan, Sind, etc. POK and Gilghit Baltistan will also be with India because of the accession treaty signed by Raja Hari Singh. The treaty prevails in the eyes of the world and the ICJ. Don't make a mocking stock.......
Mere dashmesh pita ne kiha si ki agar ek baazu tel mein dubaa do aur fir til ki bori mein, jitne til baazu par lagey honge agar ye utni bhi kasam khaayein kuraan sharif ki to bhi in par yakeen mat karna.
अक्ल मंद बचसे खड़े होसकते है इर्शा अभिमान से अक्लके अंधे 100साल का भी होजाए दुनिया तो क्या देश तो क्या अवामका भला नहीं कर पाएगा ।इंसान अवाम का भला करसक्ता है।इस्लामी की सॉस से भला नहीं करपाए गा ।70सा सलगाए क्या पाया आजादी ओर इसलाम,,???,
Its simple if the Afghanistan problem ( Created & managed by Terroristan ) is sorted out, America has no interest in Terroristan. Terroristani Panjabi's know this hence they object to Indian investments in Afghanistan.
Bhasani Saheb, aapke guest koun si akhbar parhte hain, jahan unhen pata chala ki Indian Intellectual, Kashmir ko AZAd mulk bante dekhna chahte hain.Bakbas ki bhi had hoti hai. Pure Bharat ke log aaj se nahin, balki hamaeshe Kashmir to apna mante rahe hain. Bhala apni jamin ham kyon chhoren? I was a NIT Srinagar student. We had classmates who were Kashmiri Pandits, Musalman, Dogra. We spent 5 years together in hostel without any feeling of being an outsider. Pakistan Army exported terrorism in eightys and ninetys. Where there was no any issue in 70's. All Afgani indulged Talibans, were pushed in Kashmirs. But this will all change. Paid terrorist can not last too long.
Good analysis No doubt stable Hindustan and Pakistan are need of day for peace in region Kashmir agenda we are not able to solve from last 6 decades so keep aside this agenda and move forward in all other directions. China or America are selfish countries. Our sentimental philosophy will be not understood by them they are practical.
india will always secular for 10 thousand year and will be but one thing is clear islam law and secular never go together if u wan to secular ban Islam law and we will do in india
Tie Waale Mistair ... Amrika Hindustan Ko Kaunsa Paisa Bhejta Hai? Trump spoke about India enjoying Trade deficit with USA in her favor. Yaar, kuch pata na ho to chup baitha kato.
Bhai, Mera desh hai ya Secular ya Hindurashtra it is non of your business. India secular chahiye ta ke you get chance to do any kind of mischievous like in Congress govt.
bashani is better guy..this guy on far right ...i wanna ask you naapakistani..what has pakistan got to do with kashmir and please worry about freeing baluchistan which was an independent country before india and pakistan.
Mujahid Eshai types are reason why Pakistan is what it is today = Basket Case. These dudes simply don't get it. What will Pakistan gain from CPEC? What does Pakistan have to offer? Mujahid will give another typical Panjabi fib as an answer
सेकुलर सब्द लिखने मिटाने शांति की स्थापना नहीं होगी।अक्ल सही या गलत साबित करने से शांति होगी। जुठ ओर दुश्मनी से नहीं।स्वार्थ के बुनियाद लोभ,क्रोध,मोह,काम के लिए पाक नीव रखी है।
Bashani (the guy sitting in the middle) is the one who once again talks most sense.
Himanshu obviously he is Indian so he must be the smartest person in any given room. Indians suffer from crippling overconfidence which render them almost deaf to a different point of view.
Actually he is a Pakistani from Kashmir.
@@thesavage5992 he is from pok or your so called ajad kashmir
india and indian constutuion are still secular.
twitter.com/drsheikhRSS/status/902495240447131648
twitter.com/noconversion/status/903476006643785728
JEZ H And it must and shall always be.
Thank you Bashani ji aapne har baat ka jawab logical and straight forward answer diya...
धन्यवाद सर,भसणानी सर,हासन निसार साहब, और ताहिर गोरा सर ऐसे विद्दवान लोगों से कुछ भारत के डिजाइनर पत्रकारों ने आतंकवाद बारे में कुछ सीखना चाहिए,ना की तुकडे तुकडे गैंग के साथ खड़ा हो ना चाहिए, जय हिन्द वन्दे मातरम 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
BASHANI SAHEB THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ISHWAR AAPKO LAMBI UMRA DE.
I like mr. bhashani , he is telling the truth, I like to meet him some day, i started my education in kinder garden in 1952 in convent school in srinagar , now I am a doctor in usa, kashmiries gave me a good start.
My DNA brothers i am very glad to hear in this debate all of you have spoken with convictions and very truly have described that Pakistan live in denial this is absolutely the problem of Pakistan. But unfortunately a pathological denial and liars Pakistan will never change its ideologies in the future and that is the head truth 🙏 Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Mr. Bashani is the only sensible,honest and practical guy.Unless Pakistanis don't behave and understand like Mr. Basani their internal problems and relations with neighbors will never be over. It is in your own interest that you live like a good neighbor with India and see you will prosper like anything.This is a one and only solution to all your problems and existence.
Bashani ji ne sahi kaha "This is the deep psychological problem"
1962 mai veer Ahiro ke Balidan ko mt bhoolna bhaiyo💪💪Jai Hind,Jai Indian Army..
Excellent discussion.Paistanis are to be forced to do any good work.But will rush to evil with zeal and gusto.
HAMID BASHANI SHAHAB APKE PASS ISI KA OLD MAN BHOK RAHA HAI
bhasani saab is very practical.
Hahaha China is investing $ 350 Billion in Pakistan says Mujahid
Bashani Sr great man
You should invite guests who has knowledge about India and Indian constitution before making serious comments such as -- Indian secularism does not exist and there have been constitutional amendment to make it nonsecular. If you referring to cow ban, then it was part of Indian constitution, current government only tried to enforce an existing law that has been part of constitution. Dog eating is banned in US, that does not mean US is not secular!
Don’t compare India with Pakistan. You are a foolish person if you do that india is the only country in the whole world where people of every religion lives peacefully.its secular character can never change by some fanatic groups who are unarmed and not like Pakistan where in your country these groups roam freely with ak 47 rifles. You are a declared terrorist country who export terror all over the world. India is an epitome of unity integrity and peace. Hindus do not believe in killing like Muslims who believe in Jehad and killing. Pl be real and do not talk rubbish. Hamid bashani is a balanced person
PL upgrade your knowledge about India by visiting our holy Land which belongs to your ancestors.listen to Mr Tarek fatah about India.
There has been no terrorists activity in India since last four years.inspite of you country sending armed terrorists to India in hundreds.This is your status.And no confusion about it. World says it
This Mujahid fellow must tell us which Industry did India nationalize ? This dude is a piece of work.
He is vry honest person..
I would request the producers of these shows to have subtitles please for the people who cant understand !
This guys tell truth about Pakistan
A Sibling of Dr. Hamid Bhashani is in India. D.U professor Rakesh Sinha ... 😂😂
Bashani sahib is a rare Kashmiri Pakistani who thinks like a global observer and his rationale is global. He is not scared to call a spade, a spade due to his attachment.
بشک بشک حق ہے سچے ھے آپ سچے ئیں بھائی جان آپ کی عظمت کو اسلام کرتا ھو 🌷⚘🌹🏵💮🌺🌻💐🌼💐🏃☜🕊
Bashani Saheb knows ground reality. He talks a very sensibly and he should made member of think tank group of PM Imran Khan
The common Indian is totally with the armed forces and totally against the separatists, terrorists sent by Pak army and their overground workers the stone-pelters. The guy with glasses is totally wrong in saying that there is a lot of sympathy for the Kashmiri and Pakistani jihadi. This sympathy is so minuscule it may be termed negligible. Only select intellectuals like Arundhati Roy and her ilk are with them.
Sukhar hai pakistan me aap jaise log mojud hai,isi wajah se aaj tak pakistan ka wajud bacha hai.nahi to pakistan ek kabargha ban gaya hota.God bless all of you.Best of luck.
Hamid sirr aap ko bhot bhot salam bhai aap jaise samjhdar log pakistan me kaise ho
Bashani Saab at his best.... Too good.
Bashani is a legend!
Which constitutional changes is the omniscient expert talking about ?
Good program all presented well
Afghanistan does not recognise Durand line as the border hence they will never allow Pakistan to put a fence here
India is secular country.Not changed Constitution.your telling lies
bhashani sahab "Trapped between tow stupids" lol
nIsHaNt I think you are the most stupid person since you can't even spell "two". Learn to spell first before calling others stupid. Fucking moron
bashani sir u got courage to speak truth
Constitutional measures have ended secularism ? Which ? When ?
This person mujahid sahab with glasses has no any uderstanding. ... bashani sahab is nice...
India is a secular country and will remain because Hindus are in majority. This is the best country for muslims. Come out of your box.
Mr bashaani is great personality
Most countries would love to confer honorary citizenship to Mr . Bashani for his scholarship. You are welcome to India any time Sir.
Good analysis
Mr. Mujahid is having only paper knowledge .....when anyone is in discussions, should have a grass root knowledge like Mr. Behsani
J&K is already is free, they have their own Elected Govt, but it is being misguided by Pak agents. India only provide it financial & security protection. J&K gets the maximum financial aid, but it doesn't contribute anything to the center Govt. The main reason for them to be able to create problem is this financial aid. When they don't produce anything & contribute. The centre should not provide any financial help.
Bashani is a true intellectual
Thanks for Hindi title Tag TV
What idiocy. Chabhar is being operationalized in couple of months.
Mr. Bhasani u r genius....
Sorry no constitutional changes in India ..we want to get rid of couple of articles though to strengthen our democracy
Tie Waale Mistair... Which constitutional changes in India are against Secularism?
Secularism in India is deep rooted and stands like a Rock.
Paid and sponsored rantings by pseudo intellectuals can not shake its foundations..
Very few unfortunate events do not the change the previlages enjoyed by all.
the host is probably the son in law of someone important. the sooner he realizes that he is not cut out to be a host the better it is.
Tie Waale Mistair ... Chabahar will be operational in December 2018.
Nepal Ko Bharat Apne Yaha Se Supply Karta Hai.
Muslmaan , sunni , shia , ahmedia , sufiyan , Bharath mein mahfoos hain , masjidon mein goliyan nahin chalti , duniya mein second largest muslim's Bharath mein rahte hain aur sub Bharath ke liye jaan nichavar kar denke .
The expert 'Mujahid' with specs on right is very vogue , he's not much more than nukkad bahas. no real stuff in his talk.
Hahahaha Nepali kahe "muzahid Sahab " samajh aata hai Per Chaina Wale Kahe "Muzahid Sahab" hahahahaha ye gazab hai
Pakistan mein minorty 15% se ab 2% pe aa gayi hain... or India mein muslims 9.8% se ab 18% hon gayein hain.. And yeh sala bolte hain India mein secularism khatam hon gaya hain... kuch toh sharam kar jooth bolne.. walein..
A simple option for Pakistan is to accept the Line of Control as the permanent international border, and also giving up revanchist foreign policies. They must give up militancy as a part of their security policy. There is only one problematic state in the South-Central Asian region. All other countries in this region are constructive and sane countries.
At 15:08 the man lies that in India constitutional chnages in India. What constitutional amendment has happened? Its a lie. Religion plays no role in India's state affairs. It plays a role during elections as part of larger identity politics. But this notion that Muslims are oppressed is non sense. If they are so oppressed they would have migrated to Pakistna many years ago. The fact that they are here and are increasing in number is proof that they are safe here.
I love mr bashani..
Yarr Buddha zabardasti ka English bol raha hai lekin bol nahi paa raha hai
Excellent presentation by these three intellectuals if these people had to leave Pakistan and settle in Canada speaks volumes of the perceution & intolerance in Pakistan that is why the minorities in Pakistan decreased dramatically while in India it has increase. In terms of Governance in Pakistan it is ruled by Islamabad & Rawalpindi in tandem. Ever since Gen Zia’s tenure Civilians have been seen with suspicion that is why Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was hanged by the Pakistan Army. Today Pakistan is dependent on People’s Rep of China as the only Arms supplier while India has multiple including South Korea , Japan , Isreal ,France & Russia & USA. The US & India talk to Pakistan thru Saudi Arabia the money lender of Pakistan. Gawadhar gifted to PRC has created enmity with the Arab States & the US which has Strategic Naval partnership with Japan & US , India & Australia. India has a larger trade with India. China wants a proxy war with India & Pakistan fighting so it will have a weak India . This equation changed with Modi becoming Agressive & A hard Power not a Soft Power That is Reality. Nathan Sekhar Sydney Australia.
Bashani Sahab 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
i m sikh aur main dava karta hoon k india secullor country ab agar aap ko lagta hai k muslims ko kuch b karnedene hi secullerism hai toh ab vo band ho gya hai
Mithai to woh banate Hain jinka Dil meetha hota hai.apke yahan to terror sabse bari mithai hai
Bashani is the man
JIS COUNTRY MYE PM CHOR HAIN AUR MILITARY DAKU HAIN , AMAM KO KIA HAWLAT HAIN ? JINNAH KO SUKHRIA ADA KARNA CHAHYE PAKISTAN KO ALAG EK MULUK BANANYE KE LYE
THANK YOU JINNAH SAHAB
Mujjahid why are you still alive...!!
India ne Secular Ban ke Kaun sa Nobel Prize le lena, especially Pakistan ki nazar mein.
Nepal duniya mein India ke baare mein kya kya bolta hai, uss kaun sunta hai, Pakistan aur China ko chhod kar - jo ki har waqt afeem piye rehte hain.
Who is this" dimkana "guy!!!!!!
Pakistan believes in fake narratives, victimhood, denial , terrorism and excuses. The whole mentality is known even to the OIC. Very soon Pakistan will be wiped off and in its place will emerge countries like Baluchistan, Sind, etc. POK and Gilghit Baltistan will also be with India because of the accession treaty signed by Raja Hari Singh. The treaty prevails in the eyes of the world and the ICJ. Don't make a mocking stock.......
Mere dashmesh pita ne kiha si ki agar ek baazu tel mein dubaa do aur fir til ki bori mein, jitne til baazu par lagey honge agar ye utni bhi kasam khaayein kuraan sharif ki to bhi in par yakeen mat karna.
अक्ल मंद बचसे खड़े होसकते है इर्शा अभिमान से अक्लके अंधे 100साल का भी होजाए दुनिया तो क्या देश तो क्या अवामका भला नहीं कर पाएगा ।इंसान अवाम का भला करसक्ता है।इस्लामी की सॉस से भला नहीं करपाए गा ।70सा सलगाए क्या पाया आजादी ओर इसलाम,,???,
One person belong to Pakistan army's"ISSI"... In your debate
Another interesting Joker in red tie
Its simple if the Afghanistan problem ( Created & managed by Terroristan ) is sorted out, America has no interest in Terroristan. Terroristani Panjabi's know this hence they object to Indian investments in Afghanistan.
Your calculations are totally wrong.
yeh naam se hi nahi soch se bhi mujahid hai..
Bhasani Saheb, aapke guest koun si akhbar parhte hain, jahan unhen pata chala ki Indian Intellectual, Kashmir ko AZAd mulk bante dekhna chahte hain.Bakbas ki bhi had hoti hai. Pure Bharat ke log aaj se nahin, balki hamaeshe Kashmir to apna mante rahe hain. Bhala apni jamin ham kyon chhoren?
I was a NIT Srinagar student. We had classmates who were Kashmiri Pandits, Musalman, Dogra. We spent 5 years together in hostel without any feeling of being an outsider. Pakistan Army exported terrorism in eightys and ninetys. Where there was no any issue in 70's. All Afgani indulged Talibans, were pushed in Kashmirs. But this will all change. Paid terrorist can not last too long.
Chahabahar is already operative.
bashani saab sach bolan wale bande bulia kro sir
Good analysis
No doubt stable Hindustan and Pakistan are need of day for peace in region
Kashmir agenda we are not able to solve from last 6 decades so keep aside this agenda and move forward in all other directions.
China or America are selfish countries.
Our sentimental philosophy will be not understood by them they are practical.
love true saudia is problem
india will always secular for 10 thousand year and will be but one thing is clear islam law and secular never go together if u wan to secular ban Islam law and we will do in india
Tie Waale Mistair ... Amrika Hindustan Ko Kaunsa Paisa Bhejta Hai? Trump spoke about India enjoying Trade deficit with USA in her favor. Yaar, kuch pata na ho to chup baitha kato.
Bhai, Mera desh hai ya Secular ya Hindurashtra it is non of your business. India secular chahiye ta ke you get chance to do any kind of mischievous like in Congress govt.
bashani is better guy..this guy on far right ...i wanna ask you naapakistani..what has pakistan got to do with kashmir and please worry about freeing baluchistan which was an independent country before india and pakistan.
Mujahid Eshai types are reason why Pakistan is what it is today = Basket Case. These dudes simply don't get it. What will Pakistan gain from CPEC? What does Pakistan have to offer? Mujahid will give another typical Panjabi fib as an answer
Who is right side man?Never seen before,my advise to this man please first do home work before doing any discussion,dnt act like illiterate mulla's.
A fool person trying to prove himself sane person , this is the case here. I am not talking about mr. bashani , the other one is big P.
Abhi bhi akad nahi ja rahi hai. Abhi bhi yuddha ki bhashaa bol raha hai. Jihadiyon ka guru hai. Bashani sahab bas pak ka tamasha dekhate raho.
सर आप पाकिस्तान को डिफनेड ना करे
Pakistan Islamic automic country zindabaad
........do correct spelling :-atomic
Tayyab Bhai ap Mushahud jaise logon ki apne program mein na bulaya karo koft hoti hai
सेकुलर सब्द लिखने मिटाने शांति की स्थापना नहीं होगी।अक्ल सही या गलत साबित करने से शांति होगी। जुठ ओर दुश्मनी से नहीं।स्वार्थ के बुनियाद लोभ,क्रोध,मोह,काम के लिए पाक नीव रखी है।
Buddhe 😂😂 bak bak
Apne Azad Kashmir ki bat karo.jo kahin see Azad nahin hai. Ab tumhaeu akal mein ayee last mein bashani ko sun kar
Bashani Saab at his best.... Too good.