Party Screen Animation Tier List | Genshin Impact
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
- With new party screen animations comes a new inconsequential thing for me to put into a tier list...and upset people by doing so. As is tradition.
Big thank-you to Stefan D, Madeleine R, Cris M, Runemori, Chaos Era, Trinity Series, Eggy, Andres A, Stovn, Sean T, MerkataBrat, Daniel M, Dairy, Arei, Microwaive on Patreon.
CreativeName, zzz and yoimiyafan46 for supporting me with UA-cam Membership! Y'all da best!
MapleStory Channel: / @rathgms
Channel of indeterminate content: / @ratheil2
𝗣𝗔𝗧𝗥𝗘𝗢𝗡 | / ratheil
𝗬𝗢𝗨𝗧𝗨𝗕𝗘 𝗠𝗘𝗠𝗕𝗘𝗥𝗦𝗛𝗜𝗣 | / ratheil
𝗧𝗪𝗜𝗧𝗧𝗘𝗥 | / ratheil
𝗗𝗜𝗦𝗖𝗢𝗥𝗗 | / discord
Contact me through my e-mail in my channel's about me section for business inquiries or DM me through Discord.
#genshinimpact
#genshin
#tierlist
I can't wait to see what they do for Furina's.
Hopefully a smug look just like diona's and especially water effects
Also:
Favourite 5 star:Tartaglia
Favourite 4 star:Xiangling or Layla
Least favourite 5 star:Yae miko
Least favourite 4 star:Beidou
I get the impression that some arebiased, like Diluc, Kirara, or Fischl. Like I really like Fischl pose a lot...
I am very expecting Furina to get hit by character development like a brakeloosen truck
-can't stand that bratty gaki attitude of her, even addressing herself with Boku which is masculine pronoun to use.
It would be epic if she strikes the pose with the sword that she's doing in her statue lol
@@chiarasuperFischl without Oz is a PBJ sandwich without a top bread. The feeling is bad
Aloy is debatably S tier just for getting an animation in the first place
Tbh I’m not sure what else they could’ve done with the animation
And besides, the idle pose after the animation I really like so that’s what matters
real
I'll make this my signature, don't play lmao
Hello
Hey kekevin
"This is on brand for Alhaitham, but I'm not giving him points for that"
Literally described his whole character
and he will be satisfied if ratheil doesnt giving him points for his "why am i included in this bs" pose lmao
i think if itto buckled a little when he shouldered his kanabo itd make it look WAY better, it doesnt have any sense of weight to it.
17:29 as a Yae main
I agree
I wanted a totem, or idk a whole tree grown behind her
you didn't mention ayaka flashing us
I like zhonglis final pose, but the animation is dissapointing. As a scara main, i am incredibly biased, and his is my favourite
cant believe you put amber on C
disappointed me the most has to be Diluc,
the one that surprised me the most was Guoba/Xiangling
and my favourite overrall has to be Albedo or Comrade
Klee has the cutest animation 🥹🥹🥰🥰
Al Haitham looking like he forces himself to be there is the most on brand Al Haitham can be
I think alhaitham's would be better if just stood there reading and didn't acknoledge you
Seeing how each Archon's animation reflects their personality, it makes sense for Zhongli's animation to be simple and stoic, just like the CEO of GEO
Yeah but its literally the same like Beidou difference being the balls
yeah but still boring as sh*t
@spidebot3045You better prepare yourself my guy,the simps are coming 💀
@spidebot3045 Agree to disagree on that front but do agree with the animation.
@spidebot3045 Fair enough,that's your opinion. But I'm just saying that(Previous reply) because there's a lot of Zhongli simps out there that would literally write a 20-page essay for you of "Why Zhongli's (Insert Topic) are/is good and the other characters's (Insert Topic) are)is bad" 💀🤣
I actually find Zhongli's animation very fitting his personality. He's not a flashy archon, why should he have a flashy animation.
Someone should make a tierlist of how much the animation fits the character rather than how much of a show they put up. Because in two to three days, most of us forget about these animations altogether. You don't even get to see them if you use the quick setup.
That's what i felt too! I just can't see him showing off much now but maybe when he was in his prime he would've done something cool like the other archons :D
Fitting but still boring. Just like alhaitham and xingqiu
Trueee. I guess that's why I like the more simplistic animations like Noelle's little bow. I mean yes it's not all that but it does fit their character and it is still cute which is all that I care for so
Zhongli fights with spears the size of mountains and pulls meteors from the sky
he’s quite flashy
If theres a "flashy" burst in this game, it belongs to him
If Furina's animation isn't her sitting on a Water Throne giving the most snobbish Ojou-sama laugh possible I would be extremely disappointed.
Omg I need that now
Well I have some (bad) news for you
Justice for Beidou, she's WAY TOO COOL AND CONFIDENT only to receive a simple sidestep twirl 😭
I think simpler animations fit some of these characters better. Just like other people have also added, Alhaitham is a good example of this. Are his ingame animations flashy? Yes. But is he a flashy person? Not so much. In fact I think it was very in character for him to put aside his book and stand there looking ready to ask you "So when are we going?"(considering one of his party joining lines is "How long will this require, exactly?" I find it somewhat funny). I could make the same case for Diluc and Zhongli(though I understand why people wanted flashier stuff in Zhongli's case)
I will say though, if I were to change one, I'd make Itto's have Ushi in it, simply because Ushi is too adorable to leave out. Otherwise, I think most of them fit well enough.
Yeah, I think Itto's was the only one that was both a little underwhelming *and* didn't fit the character.
Alhaitham fans: yeah go on give us nothing!!! 🎉🎉🎉
(It’s me. I’m Alhaitham fan.)
Cmon, now yall can't be this delusional? I'm a hard-core alhaitham fan, and I was extremely disappointed with his idle animation... like he can do so much more than that..
“Almost like Archons get special treatment”
The whole Archon squad so far have their element representation in their poses after the animation, so there’s that- 😂
Yes surprised he metioned it in zhongli but not the other archons, everyone gets an aura element like they are stronger and Nahida flowers on the floor
a “what if albedo released today” would be cool. i feel like he’d be dendro if he was
If only...
I don't wanna imagine a green haired albedo 😭😭
@@slayhida i feel like his hair would be black or dark green like tighnaris
@@slayhidawhy would he be green
If anything he would be a better connection between geo and dendro, to make him much more compatible with hyperbloom or other teams
Surprised the most by Diona, Disapponted the most by Alhaitham, Favourite one is Kokomi.
Also I would definitely love to see "what if Venti were released today?"
As you noticed with Bennett, most of the animations are currently idles or skills.
Why? Because Hoyo did only introduce a few fresh animations and hopefully will update at least all 5* stars in the future as well to have their own animations.
Or just care more about future 5 stars to sell them more
Have Xinqiu drop a huge ton of books off screen and as he attempts to pick them up he notices you and tries to save face by striking a pose.
My favorite part of Xiangling's animation is Guoba ready to throw hands Kung Fu Panda style
Xiao's is, by far, my favorite animation. It's very fitting for his character, and the pose is also similar to the drip artwork. He doesn't need a flashy entrance, he's never _had_ a flashy entrance; he just shows up, and he's all business (except for when it's not business and it's just us asking him to taste-test Xiangling's cooking). We also don't get enough love for his left side, we tend to see his right side a lot, but not so much his left.
It's also why I don't have a least favorite animation, everyone's animations are spot on for their characters, and some of them reference their respective drip artworks.
It was only mentioned that Ayaka used a modified version of her skill but theres a few characters who used modified versions of pre existing animations like Tighnari reusing his idle for example
So I’m biased bc my favorite character has a super cool animation, but I kinda like that there are some shorter, simpler ones too. I feel like if every character had a Hu Tao or a Childe, it would just be a bit much
At least they should make every character with a summon or transformation show it, sad that Sara doesn't show her wings, fischl oz, kokomi jellyfish, itto cow etc
@@asoretthis! they totally could have used more creativity, even if it wasn't super crazy
I really wished zhonglis rock thing flew around him after his animation ended it would be so cool
the spirit clone's pose in Shenhe's entry:
-that is exactly how Shenhe would look in unrestricted, killer instinct mode 💀
Tbf I think Alhaitham pose suits him, yea it's boring because he is bored, he is totally not interested in picking him up for any task the guy wants to be kept in the shadows unbothered and reading some books.
yeah hoyo was also fking bored they made alhaitham animation lmao🤣
It's like go ahead king give us absolutely nothing ✨️
@@yamz8831He's giving us the absolute best nothing, king shit ✨
instead of Zhongli just standing there menacingly, I'd love for his animation to be him using his hold skill but instead of a pillar spawning, a throne rises behind him and he sits there with his Statue of the Seven pose
Bruh you interrupted my tcg to put me in your party so of course i aint gonna try look to cool for you😒
Venti’s animation has to be my favorite! You’re right, it just captures his essence so perfectly. Also, I’d love to watch a video on “if the anemo archon was released today”
+ this video also made me notice Klee’s name bounce up and down when she shows off dodoco and that’s undebatably THE cutest thing i’ve ever seen
As an animator, all of them are atleast an A or B, each of them are unique to their character's personality.
Flashy/"wow" animation =/= good animation
To me, the movements and flows are great
I don't understand why people are getting mad over these. Like they're party entry animation for crying out loud like an action equivalent would walking into a crowd or entering a room, you're not gonna get a whole animated cutscene for it and all of them are perfectly tailored to the characters
The Yae Miko rant was so perfect
Can we just appreciate that the party screen background matches each character's region? It's these small things that really make your amazing editing shine, Ratheil.
As for your question,
Most surprising: Xiangling
Most disappointing: Zhongli
Favorite overall: Wanderer
How bad did the Yae Miko mains hurt you dude
It would be a lot more fun if Bennett "bursted in". Oz could be flying into frame and then turn into Fischl, while he stays behind her. Xiangling's is perfect, 100/10. Although is unlikely, I hope they add more animations in the future
1. I was expecting more from Dehya give her something TT^TT.
2. Xianling jumping in with a side flip was cool af.
3. I love Nahida she just jumps in ready for action.
5:52 It's a Jitte, which translates as "ten hands" and was a standard issue police baton used mainly during the Edo-period
Nobody wants to admit it but Gouba and Xiangling takes the crown
i'd love to see "what if venti was released today"
It's such a bummer and as the anemo archon he couldve had a wayyy cooler kit!
I'm thinking onmatched world exploration like floating and superjumping, a kit that actually revolves around music (like HoS from honkai but with instruments?) and swirlllll!!!
(and cons that arent horrible)
Travelers was def underwhelming wish their was more to them
I do rlly love Xianglings and Sayu doing flips BC its satisfying and smooth to me
I can't say I hate any but if I had a least favorite it would have to be yunjins BC its just one of her attack animations
Love the vid tho, u do have very valid points have a good day/night!~
The most disappointing is Chongyun's cause it is just his idle,most surprising is Yoimiya's cause she finally got good treatment and overall favorite is Raiden's
my personal opinion:
as long as the animation is ON BRAND with the character's personality and how they behave story-wise (not lore-wise e.g: beidou defeating haishan or sumthin), it's great. and some of them don't even need to do anything to look elegant. i get what alot of ppl expected, like flashy animation, alot of movements, and a use of props. but the thing is... this is not apex legends, guys. get over it 🙏
and also....
Surprised the most: xiao (finally hoyo can make his mask stay, and goddamn it looked awesome)
Disappointed the most: Yoimiya (haha wow fireworks yippie :))) seriously tho, i'd be more happy if they just bring her idle animation where she's playing a little firework)
Favourite: Ayato (the elegance of slow sword-flexing move always got me)
0:10 Traveler
0:27 Albedo
0:41 Xingqui
0:46 Alhaithm
1:09 Aloy
1:17 Amber
1:27 Ayaka
1:41 Ayato
1:52 Baizhu
2:02 Barbara
2:30 Beidou
2:50 Bennett
3:00 Candace
3:10 Childe
3:23 Chongyun
3:35 Collei
3:48 Cyno
4:05 Dehya
4:15 Diluc
4:27 Diona
4:45 Dori
5:03 Eula
5:16 Faruzan
5:23 Fischl
5:37 Ganyu
5:47 Gorou
5:53 Heizou
6:02 Hu Tao
6:14 Itto
6:35 Jean
6:44 Kaeya
6:49 Kaveh
6:59 Kazuha
7:16 Keqing
7:28 Kirara
7:40 Klee
7:55 Kokomi
8:06 Kuki Shinobu
8:23 Layla
8:41 Lisa
8:53 Lynette
9:05 Lyney
9:32 Mika
9:46 Mona
9:54 Nahida
10:04 Nilou
10:20 Ningguang
10:26 Noelle
10:44 Qiqi
10:49 Raiden
10:59 Razor
11:12 Rosaria
11:24 Kujou Sara
11:42 Sayu
11:54 Shenhe
12:11 Sucrose
12:28 Thoma
12:48 Tighnari
12:56 Venti
13:22 Wanderer
13:38 Xiangling
13:56 Xiao
14:13 Xinyan
14:25 Yae Miko
14:59 Yanfei
15:08 Yaoyao
15:22 Yelan
15:34 Yoimiya
15:59 Yunjin
16:12 Zhongli
I think Zhongli's animation is a perfect fit for his personality, how elegant slow turn and being the oldest, it makes him look very wise too.
I would say that Zhongli is disappointing even though I know it fits his personality. Even his trailer shows his cool side.
Xiangling is the most surprising because of her back flip so she's in the top 3 for me.
My favourite is definitely the cute and graceful Nahida, followed by Raiden Shogun.
-Aether's disappointed me, I get that they're the first character we get but.. idk
-I think that Sayu's surprised me the most, not really in a good or bad way I just was expecting her to yawn like Layla but she actually had a cool animation
-Overall my favorite is Lyney's, I didn't manage to pull him this time around but he's just *chef kiss*
Wanderers is my favorite (paired with his "this had better be important" voice line), with Zhongli, Raiden and Beidou tied for last (it's all the same animation just with different attitudes). I got the impression Lynney, Lynette, Wanderer, Xangling, Nahida, Kokomi, Hu Tao, and Yao Yao had the most amount of effort in designing them. I wouldn't be surprised if they were some of the first ones they worked on and then ran out of steam as they went. There is an adage "done is better than perfect" that was drilled into my brain in art school and I sorta get that impression with the new animations.
i really wish that for some of them, they kept their cool pose within the animation instead of switching into a more generic one. i would’ve loved to see gorou keep that pose having thrown out the doggy general, and have yao yao keep the adorable pose with yuegui and have her wobble a little trying to stay balanced. i think some characters benefit from having something more simple, but a lot of them feel like they just lacked the time to come up with new, fun animations (which is likely the case).
I noticed Beidou’s pose is from the cutscene where we ride on her ship.
my brain tricked me, i was read "where we ride her on ship" 💀🙏
This is funny
Half the “bad ones” just fit the character
Not like I can see it in my game
It doesn’t show in mobile
Sadge 😢
I’m wondering how one would rate how the characters in honkai impact 3rd drop in at the start of the levels
That would be fun
Kazuha's animation disappointed me the most ngl... it was as if they forgot to actually give him an animation ☠️
I was pretty dissapointed with Ninguangs, Lisas suprised me (in how much I liked it)
And my overall favourite..... probably Keqings, (but Raidens and Yelans are pretty sick too)
I will never not say this.
FISCHL IS NOT FISCHL WITHOUT OZ
I actually like beidou's a lot.
It looks really intimidating because she's minimalistic. She's not gonna do things for you, no no, you're gonna do things for HER
The one that really disappointed me was Zhongli. You see if it was any other character i wouldn't have minded but Zhongli is a character that is known for having the best animations and cutscenes in the game. They could have done so much with him like perhaps he comes in with his charged attack or something like that.
The one that surprised me the most was XL. I didn't expect Guoba to be there but I like the creativity.
My favourite animation has to be Nahida. The way she comes in a swing and does a twirl while her eyes were gleaming was so good.
"That is known for having the best animations and cutscenes"........who tf is in the known? Cuz i know a lot of ppl ain't, including me.
@@saad_5151 it is a known fact.
Most dissapointing for me were Alhaitham and Xingqiu. Their animation is so boring and even if you couod say well Xingqiu is a 4 star that isn't an excuse cause most 4 stars have a good one. Most surprising was Xiangling. The flip was really unexpected. My favourite is without a doubt Ventis. When he plays the lyre it's just so relaxing and satisfying. When you said you find kazuhas a little awkward cause it feels like an animation is missing, that's my feeling with Mikas one. Idkw but the way he just abruptly pulls out his crossbow after he was just sereningly reading really feels like I missed a part.
Alhaitham. I actually wanted him to pop his pocket book *as idle animation*
we have it now, folks. as a lame party entry animation 💀
Kirara’s animation could’ve been her running up and entering the screen in her cat box form then popping out and doing her pose
Look, Alhaitham absolutely deserves to be low. It's a boring, unimpressive animation.
But it is *so* on brand for him that it's kind of obviously purposeful (even after the animation he just stands there like). It just amuses me??
It would have been nice if they'd (like they could have with Yelan & the dice) given him a couple other book covers so it looks like he's reading a few different books whenever you put him in the team.
My fav was obviously wanderer it just "fighter jet reporting in"😂
The bast for me is yaoyao i can't stop thinking about it it's just soo cute to see little radish bunny on her shoulder its sooo cuuuute
And the most disappointing was eula i felt like they could've done so much with her but eh
Top tier editing as usual!
Also I would love to see a venti remake video!
Eula’s animation just feels weird to me
She does a spin… without taking any step
It’s a hard floor, not an ice floor, and she shouldn’t be spinning weightlessly like that, holding a claymore
You don't actually need a step to spin: the force that makes you spin comes from your torso's torsion. The step comes in if you are already moving so that you can transfer your momentum from your motion to your torsion, just like when you jump after a sprint to go higher.
@@Dr_Nig to spin, yes
To not get your legs twisted while both are pinned down the ground? Nah
Just to add, when eula attacks she's really fast and elegant with the claymore so the weightlessness fits.
@@zencaia3064 her NA animation actually shows a small jump/step and you can feel the inertia
All the budget than should went into xingqiu and alhaitham went to our 6 star xiangling (and guoba)
I really hope Furinas is her rushing in with a crate and quickly standing on it to strike a proud confident pose.
ps. Biggest Disagree has got to be Chongyun. Think the character love brought up there... somehow.
My only feelings about how you placed Yae Miko was "okay I GET IT place her and move on holy crap wait she does what with her hands???"
I saw someone say they wish Traveler had different entrances for each element, and I agree! Like for Anemo she, sorry, They do the knights of favonius salute like in the Klee event.
Idk why you don't like Diona but I love to see you recodnizing that it looks nice!
Tho shes my favorite character, i didn't really know what to expect. But I was so happy when I saw her just shaking her cocktail and getting mad for being interrupted, suits her so well 😂
I find her general personality to be unpleasant but that pose is on point lol
I'm Surprised they didn't do this prior to 4.0
razor not having wolf dad, fischl not having oz, sara not having wings is all very dissapointing.
bro doesnt even consider the character's personality when it come to their pose💀
Like what can Zhongli do? hes a calm boring a** gramp and you expect he to do flip?💀💀💀
Dehya you said shes not good but maybe you just spam space too much while do Sumeru archon quest💀
I'm a little disappointed because some character animation is just idle their animation. Don't get me wrong they're fine, but they could be better.
albedo on c I put a dislike cya bro
SO GLAD YOU'RE APPRECIATING VENTI!! LYNETTE'S IS ALSO SO, SO COOL
The Miko rant went from funny to worn to my cheeks hurt with how quietly you kept ramping it up.
The DKR music was so unbelievably fitting like whoa
My absolute favorite was Xiao becuase i'm biased as hell. (but i liked Albedo, Lyney, and Nahida a lot too)
Zhonlgi was incredibly disappointing, i don't really know what they could've done different but like.. come on.
I was most surprised by Kuki, i didn't think i'd like it so much.
You really should have made criterias and have a checkbox mindset. Animation, end pose, props (weapon/element), and personality for example as checkboxes. This is so that even if you have a bias (which you will of course) you can explain why. Like Cyno is very meh, only electric fist pump, should be D with meh Deyha.. if you had consistent reasonings. Also, waving the character around like you really don't know where to put them just tells me that your tier list in not well thought up at all.
Im not mad about your placements. I just find it frustrating how actually low effort this is. Tierlist don't normally make people upset when the creator states their reasonings and stick with it. Maybe that's why people get upset. Be consistent and stay on track with your bias atleast.
Alternative title: Hating on every Introverted Characters' Party Screen Animation and somewhat being semi-hyped for the Extroverted ones'.
Like dude, my boy Xingqiu's animation is so elegant and you just straight up put him in the F tier for not jumping from the top of the Everest mountain then does a Spiderman pose while carrying his own Mary Janes? Really.
Diluc and Kaeya's dissapointed me So much... I Love them both to pieces but it's so incredibly dissapointing because both of their Party screen animations are so similar to their idle animations.
Diluc could do something cool with calling his bird and having it perch on his arm or something like a "Dark night hero" entrance or ready his Claymore.
Kaeya could do a cool sword trick since his sword work is so pretty, or have one of his icicles surround him, or adjusting his eyepatch or doing other coin tricks like rolling it between his fingers, or just any other movement that wasnt the same as his idle animation.
Okay, I think it's a bad sign when I keep disagreeing with more than half of what you say, so I'm unsubscribing. But still, good luck with your channel, hope you do well.
I respect all tier lists with tartags in S
10:47 Now I permanently hear "you should kill yourself NOW" with Raiden's animation and honestly they kinda make it better for me - she's a high tier god after all.
youre shifting all over the place with your way grading and rating poses and animation
nope, at least 30% are wrong considering the "preevaluation" youve given us with the first few characters
Actually venti being released today is a very interesting video idea, i’d be cool to see that happen!
alhaitham would've been S-tier if he came with the chair.
Wow I didn't even think of that as a possibility, would have been great lol
Klee could have also done the thing from her demo where she runs and tosses handfuls of bombs behind her
Most disappointing: Dehya. She just never gets a W, does she? Also I personally hate Xiangling's. I get why everyone thinks its good, but Guoba's the only good thing about it imho
Most surprising: Xingqiu's is really damn good and the fact everyone puts it in F tier is what I find most surprising. It's subtle, in character and best of all ends on a pose that's both elegant and you won't mistake for someone else. I hate the little bastard, too. Why am I the only one who sees this?
Favorite: Xiao's. I think a lot of people don't really get that lots of animation doesn't make it better intros, and Xiao's subtle movements and ending pose is just the best. I'm not going to get mad at you for putting him in D, tho. I just accept that I'm basically the "they hated him for he told the truth" meme
Not gonna lie Noelle's animation is so humble and loveable definitely my favorite 4* animation
1:39 minutes in and i'm already facepalming. Brother how is Amber worse than Ayaka?
Can i just say, as simple as Albedo's was, the way he looked at you at the end spoke to me. Just wanted to point that oki byeeee! 👀✨
As a Razor main for so long and an enjoyer of all animations, I have to say that this Tierlist is accurate, sadly. So many wasted potentials...
Most disappointing for me was Kirara, she could had jumped on screen from her box form. Most surprising would be Keqing's as the teleport is actually really satisfying to see, not to mention you can actually see her throw the thing before she teleports. And my favorite is Hu Tao's, she simply had the best animation in my opinion lol.
I would really like to see a "what if Venti released today"!
Video idea: characters skills and how useful they would be in day to day life
xiangling the pyro, polearm and party screen animation archon all at the same time
Klee be like ->
Can I offer you a bomb in these trying times
THEY COULD'VE DONE SO MUCH MORE with Alhaitham, let him do cool shit with his light mirror or something!
hoyo favourite child xiangling everything about her is rigged
YESSSSSS PLEAAASE, do the what if Venti was released now
Chongyun's is exactly like Benny: it's an idle animation. Honestly his is the only one I've seen in my roster that disappoints me, and I don't even play Chongyun. Feelsbad for the Chongyun mains 😔
At the end of everything, though, these are party select animations and I think the short succinct animations are the best. We don't need to spend 84 years in party select. I actually like how they've taken animations for certain people from their character trailers. Like, animations that otherwise wouldn't be used in game via idle/attack kit animations.
IMO Keqing's is among the best. It's SO smooth 10/10