Irgazin Yellow PY129 Watercolor Comparison - Daniel Smith Rich Green Gold, VanGogh Azo Green Yellow
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- Scroll down for links to products.
PY129 mixes video - • Azomethine Green Yello...
----------
SUPPORT
★ Jackson's Art - Affiliate link
www.jacksonsar...
★ Rosemary&Co - Affiliate link
www.rosemaryan...?u=paintinhiding
or just put PAINTINHIDING in the affiliate/coupon box at check out.
(If you'd like to support my channel, please consider using the affiliate links above. I will receive a small commission that I can put towards funding this channel at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your consideration! :D)
----------
FOLLOW
instagram: / paintinhiding
blog: paintinhiding....
------------
PRODUCTS IN VID:
rosemary brush - www.rosemaryan...
daniel smith www.jacksonsar...
vangogh (rembrandt) www.jacksonsar...
Hi Vee. Just wanna share that I am so happy you're doing all these color comparisons and watercolor updates lately. I am a silent watcher but watch every single one of them. ☺️
aww thanks Allan! that means a lot :D and yeah, i feel you. i'm a silent watcher of many channels too. 🤣 i try to comment on some smaller channels though to help the algorithm
Denise Soden (her UA-cam channel is In Liquid Color) created a beautiful Sap Green in the paint set she collaborated on with DaVinci, using PB60 (Indanthrone Blue) and PY129 (Green Gold.) I haven't tried mixing those two myself, yet, but am anxious to since it's such a gorgeous version of Sap Green.
yes! i saw that one just recently. i think it’s so cool she found her own mix, especially after trying all the quin gold/PG7 mixes.
She wanted to avoid Nickel Azo Yellow since it was for her earth friendly palette and the nickel isn't so earth friendly. It creates a beautiful range of foliage greens, definitely try the mix!
How could people not like PY129???!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It’s at the top of my wishlist. At the very very top.
because the masstone isn't very appealing. but the midtone is a nice yellow :D
@@PaintinHiding Actually, I’d like to try the mass tone. It might be a useful shadow colour for yellows. Also, id like to try it as an alternative to earth hues such as raw umber and raw sienna. I think it would make a good raw umber substitute.
@@awatercolourist well that’s an interesting idea indeed!
awatercolorist, How do you not have it yet??? I have this in my M. Graham palette and when I had just 12 M. Grahams in the palette, I did a mixing chart. It has very high tinting strength for a yellow, and all of my mixes came out either a greenish color or (with the purples) a disgusting brown. For this reason, I'm not sure it will sub for raw umber like you think (I'm assuming you mean the greenish raw umbers here) but it might if you can darken it down. It definitely lowers the chroma of things, but then again it still retains that glowing brightness you see also in PY 150.
@@jennw6809 Thanks for the info. I did not know that PY129 had high tinting strength.
I just recently bought the MGraham version and I really love it. It really is hard to describe and an unusual pigment. It's interesting in mixes and serves as my cool yellow. It's very underappreciated!
PY129 is my ultimate colour for mixing skin tone. It has a permnant place in all of my palettes. Mix with any cool red(I mix with White Night's Carmine but PV19 works perfectly too) and you have a transparent non granulating skin tone hue with only two pigments. I also love using it as my cool yellow, mixing it with White Night PG8 or PG7 to paint the leaves with sunlight shone through.
That skin tone trick is brilliant! I never would have thought to use it for that!
wwwwooooahhh! that is awesome! i dont paint portraits but i'll definitely need to try those mixes :D thanks for sharing! and me toooo, i like mixing it with greens for foliage :D
Wow awesome I am going to try that right now!! I agree it makes awesome foliage greens that are already somewhat muted, but I didn't know what else to do with it. Not that I paint portraits but I have an aspiration to start someday :-)
@@jennw6809 i dont paint portraits because i dont know how to draw faces 🤣
@@PaintinHiding SAME. In college drawing class I did self portraits of my torso and I did try and include part of my face in one of them. I gave up and just left it a smear and my whole class gave me crap in my critique about it. I was like, "I TRIED!!"
I would describe this color as being two-tone or multichrome, similar to Nickel Azo Yellow, where the masstone is quite a different hue than the tint. The masstone is a low-chroma green (which is why we see it as brownish, because it is traveling towards the center of the color wheel). The tint has higher chroma and that distinctive glow. I'm gonna check out the mixing video now!
ooohh yesss! i need to learn all these fancy words you’re using. the high chroma and all that jazz. but thank u for teaching about that, that because of the low chroma we see it as brown. sooo cool!
@@PaintinHiding I learned most of what I know from reading Handprint, no lie. It really helped me to understand what I see when I am looking at color. Actually it would be a great subject for a video: The three dimensions of color.
1. Hue = the "shade" of a color. For example if we are discussing a red, is it orangey, purpley, or pure red? Where is it on the outside of the color wheel (2:00, 3:00, 4:00)
2. Chroma (aka Saturation) = how bright or muted the color is. PR 254 Pyrrol Red is high chroma, PR 179 Perelyne Maroon is lower chroma. Same with cobalt blue vs. indanthrone. Adding black to colors lowers the chroma.
3. Value (aka lightness): The intensity of the color. Straight paint from the tube has the deepest value, but adding water or white to the paint lightens the value.
@@jennw6809 ok i need to write all this down 🙈 i agree, it would be informational to many beginners. im not sure if im the best at explaining technical stuff though. maybe i’ll try it and see how it goes. thanks for the suggestion 👍🏻🥰
My favorite PY129 is Qor’s. I use it as a cool yellow in several palettes.
ohh i think that's in their high chroma set isn't it? bright indeed! and me too~ i use it as a cool yellow :D
Thank you Vee....for another great color review.
@@SuperExadidas haha~ are u binge watching? 😜 enjoy your weekend! 🥰
@@PaintinHiding always
it is indeed a complicated color. I only have the Van Gogh version to test it. I think it's hard to justify having both this and nickel azo yellow in my palette XD But it sure is nice for mixing greens. Maybe some nice olive greens as well, with a bit of warmth.
Originally, it was PG10 that was called Green Gold. Some paint manufactureres gave that name to PY129 when PG10 got discontinued.
ooohh that's cool info!
@@PaintinHiding I know!
Wow! Love the pigment trivia
I really enjoyed this video. Thank you!
thank you Jennifer! haven’t seen you comment in a long time, how are you? i hope you’re having a good week 😄🥰
thank you for this. I bought the van Gogh as one of my first not in a pallet colors. And it’s been a little over a year, and I’ve managed to whittle it down pretty far. I’m guessing it’s because it’s not as pigmented and long lasting and everything is the other ones. And I know I’m gonna have to replace it soon, because I love that color. I use it a lot in my drawings. But I wanted to upgrade, because then go is really good, but it’s a little more student quality and while I don’t consider myself a professional, I still like to use professional colors. So I might look into the Daniel Smith one instead, as I have a lot of his colors as well.
Hi, I know probably it is a bit too late for a reply now, but if you want to replace it for a professional Brand you could also try Rembrandt (same company as van Gogh). At least in Europe it is easy to find online and their 20ml tubes are really affordable.
In mass tone its like an intense raw umber.
ohhh now that you mention it, i can see that
Question for you (or anyone else who sees this) about this pigment: I made my own full pan (from American Journey’s PY129)…then I didn’t use it for awhile. The other day, when I took it out to use it, I noticed what appeared to be almost a duochrome-like sheen covering the surface of the paint in the dried pan. None of the other dried pans in the same tin had this. Have you ever had this happen with your PY129 in pans?
hmm... i dont have that with any of my PY129. maybe try emailing the company and ask them directly?
I actually didn't know that color was the oft-referenced green gold. Oops! But I do find the Van Goh one very useful for landscapes. 🙂
Hi J! Green gold was originally PG10. When it got discontinued, paint manufacturers started to call PY129 Green Gold. Some companies, such as Daniel Smith and Roman Szmal, mix a PG10-like hue and call it Green Gold; that is why they use a different name for PY129. I’d love to try PG10 one day.
That makes quite a bit of sense. Thanks for sharing that nugget of information!
@@j.s.elliot7121 Welcome!
yayyy!! you get a medal!🥇(for being the first to comment ;P) well, now you know! ooh yessss i agree with you that it's great for landscapes because it's not a lemon yellow type of colour but it's still a cool yellow.
@@PaintinHiding Also more muted, so it's more natural.
Oh totally off topic here but I received my Schmincke square palette, and to my surprise and delight, WITH the insert, you can fit an extra FULL pan in each row or two half pans. WITHOUT the insert (just got some magnetic tape too) you can fit 18 full pans!! I thought maybe you could fit in half pans sideways below the bottom row, but it's a hair too small for that. The tin itself is very well made -- it's a bit heavier weight and has nicer paint than my Meeden palettes. The insert can be a bit sharp I suppose, but it's not like a razor blade or anything!
woah that was pretty fast! thanks for updating us! ooh i bet with white nights’ smaller size full pans, maybe u can fit 5 in each row, just theorizing. awww sad it wont fit another row at the bottom. yeah i’ve heard about the sharpness of the palette. im pretty clumsy most of the time so that’s been one thing on the back of my mind. but then again im just waiting for a colourful schmincke palette. maybe they’ll put one out for christmas this year 😁
@@PaintinHiding It actually arrived Saturday but I wasn't at my office to receive my mail! I don't have any White Nights so I can't tell you about how those pans fit. The insert is only sharp on the edge of the bottom; there's no danger when it's inside the palette. You just need to be careful with it when you have removed it from the palette, say, for cleaning. I do hope they bring back the colorful ones. Oh and I think this palette is steel instead of aluminum; which explains the "better quality" feeling but it might also be a tad heavier to carry in one's bag.
@@jennw6809 dont worry about white nights, i was just speculating. oohhh can i ask how do u know if it’s steel or alu or other metals? i havent seen any manufacturer saying about what the metal palettes are made of. aaahh i need to save up for a colourful schmincke palette so when it comes out i can quicklu grab one 😂 but no long 24 pan palettes. i already have 4 of those. hopefully a square one like urs or the small 12 pan one. 😂
@@PaintinHiding I think they all must be steel or magnets wouldn't stick, however the Schmincke one seems to be heavy duty; should not be dented if carried in a bag. I think they release limited edition palettes several times per year - maybe as we approach the holidays if nothing else!
@@jennw6809 aahh that makes sense. you’re very knowledgeable 😆👍🏻 i guess it would make sense for schmincke, a german brand, to make their products for heavy duty
Wow the Daniel Smith really glows here. I still can't bring myself to like the PY129 color though 😂
it does~ d’awww i thought it was growing on you ;P
I HIGHLY recommend that you all watch Paint in Hiding’s PY129 mixing video; it is very informative. Another UA-camr, Tammy Newman, also made a PY129 mixing video.
who are you talking to with this comment? me? or just viewers in general 😂 but thank you! YESSS tammy's vids are great too! i don't think she's uploaded in a while though right? i'll need to go check.
@@PaintinHiding Everyone! Your PY129 video is one of my favourite videos on mixing paint. Here is the link, for those who want to watch it: ua-cam.com/video/Bstgzoj1LI4/v-deo.html.
Re Tammy, yes, she hasn’t uploaded in a while. I like her mixing and swatching videos, especially the PY129 mixing video.
@@awatercolourist aww thank you! i like those types of mixing vids too. that’s so weird, links to youtube vids are fine but links to other websites get deleted lol. youtube so biased. 😂
@@awatercolourist Thanks, I hadn't seen this one - I appreciate the recommendation!!
I like to call this the ugly yellow, i know its great for mixing green but since i have py150 with a similar glow like characteristics its kinda not justifiable to have this alongside it, and for cool yellow i like a bright clean one like py175 idk there’s is something about this color i just didn’t really like
i feel you~ i think in mass tone it can definitely look 'ugly' to many people. and yeah, i used to be a cool yellow super bright lemon yellow type of person, dont get me wrong, i still like lemon yellows, but i feel like all the available ones out there are semi-transparent whereas PY129 is completely transparent.
Second!
🥈 😜
@@PaintinHiding Oh, well! Better luck next tome 😂