That proposal!! I’m willing to bet that she told him no in the car, tried to spare his feelings on camera 🤦🏾♀️ 😂 There was nothing romantic about any of this 🥴🥴🥴
There is a place and time for everything, and this wasn't the place or the time. Plus it just shows how little he cared about the plaintiff's injury and his dog attacking him. Plus I don't think she really wanted to marry him after being embarrassed on national television from losing the case.
#AGREED I'm petrified of dogs even thou I recognize it's not the animals' fault (regardless of it being friendly) because of their natural impulses; furthermore my friend's chihuahua bit me & was utter negligence of owner. 30' some yrs.later, I'm overanalyzing every encounter with "domestic pets"🤪🎭
Lmao. Theirs a episode about a coy fish pond and the person lost. He said "good luck with the fish and stuff". He really is so shady and I don't think half of the people realize it. The other older guy says some funny stuff too. 😂
The husband understood and said it was his fault and kind of laughed and his wife kept a straight face the whole time. That proposal gotta be fake lmao
Cynical much ? The defendant was just a nice guy who was ready to admit responsibility. The Plaintiff coming up with loss wages was prob the sticking point all along. Def was just happy too cause he knew what he was gonna do after.
Milian was kind of rude considering the language barrier. I was a bit disappointed as it was apparent and she could’ve behaved more sensitive towards both sides.
The constant smiling and laughing of the defendant is beyond me. Then he proceeds to propose after being sued? He would have lost twice that day because “get up...no”
Well, unlike other tv judges who would have awarded it just to make a point and put the AH dog owner in his place, with Judge Milian, she didn't award it cuz he didn't ask for it. He should have ..... a dog like that coming after you and biting, definitely pain should be recompensible, and then the there is the emotional toll from an attack. The dog owner got off easy on this one.
Depends on the state the case was filed in. Some states don't have pain and suffering as an option. Some, the person has to prove it, not just claim it.
It isn’t the “cuts” that likely kept him from working. It’s the bone-crushing jaws. I can’t believe she would be as nonchalant as the defendants were about damages.
The defendant knew that they were in the wrong the entire time. All he cared about was being on camera and proposing to his significant other. Definitely explains why she was taking things much more seriously the entire time.
You never get over a dog attack on you or on your dog. EVER! It damages you psychologically and takes a long time to try to get over. Oh and that laughable proposal. With that pursed up angry looking face of hers, she def had to say yes to someone.
I find it both funny & disgusting th@ when it comes to her relatives let alone her extended family all being pit bulls... that Judge Judy is quick to be so abusive & judgemental against them & their owners.... did you know th@ when judge judy is not being abusive towards those standing in front of her she likes to take it up the backdoor doggy style & gives it back to her pitbull husband a million times harder..... now there's something horrible isn't it.
In 2015 my neighbor who was 85 years old, was walking his little Terrier (Gus) near his home. A red pitbull came out of no-where and attacked my neighbor and his little dog. My neighbor sustained multiple bites on his body and Gus received more than 100 stitches. Gus had multiple bites extending from the back of his neck, to the length of his belly. The Police and Paramedics arrived on scene. The dog and his owner were located and Spokane Animal Control took custody of the Pitbull. My neighbor sued for all damages and won his case. The Pitbull was euthanized. ***ALL PET OWNER''S are RESPONSIBLE for their PET"S behavior and restraint. No excuses....
The judge is a bit impatient with non-native speakers. She could try a tad more empathy as a bilingual person. I don't think she realizes how she comes off when people are speaking pretty clearly considering English is not their native language. I know language needs to be precise in court, but just wanted to share this observation.
She her self is Cuban so she should be more patient, I am also Cuban and I came when I was 2 years old now I am 60 but living in Miami like she also does we all have to be patient with people here in our wonderful multicultural state maybe she forgot where she came from I find it rude maybe she is trying to teach them the correct way to say it but she does it in a rude way.
She asked basic direct questions. They weren't hard to understand even if English is your second or third language. The problem is people need to listen. She herself speaks multiple languages and probably has plenty of empathy. Because she's done it.
@@davidt5200 I think they were nervous, but also it was more about their replies. She knew what they meant, but was rude about the way she corrected them.
Worst proposal ever! Not only did she not hold out her hand for him to put the ring 💍 on it, she said it was embarrassing 😳 he better run 🏃♂️ and run fast
I mean really he would have been humiliated on national TV had she said no. "How embarrassing" it's pretty damn close to "no" Who knows she might have been polite in the view of the camera but after the camera was off she said "hell no" 🤣🤣🤣 Hey wait a minute, he didn't even put the ring on her hand I think it was all just an act! What a bunch of losers!
Absolutely DISGUSTING. To propose marriage after being SUED -- those 2 defendants really deserve each other! Anyone associated with them won't have a good life!
Exactly! She can’t impose onto him what she kept working through. We don’t know the extent of his pain and after effects. And she wasn’t cooking thanksgiving meals every day for 2 weeks. He does handy man work and computer work which requires active use of his fingers 🤷🏽♀️
I feel bad for the plaintiff, he wasn’t awarded enough for what he went through. I wonder if Judge Milian gets more money if she awards lower judgment amount because she rarely awards what they truly deserve, makes me so sad.
Ok.. what if I give you leash failure as an out... what plan does an owner need to have in case of leash failure with aggressive dogs in public? Is leash failure an out for responsibility?
Judge is so rude and arrogant does she not understand that there is a language barrier and that English is not the first language of the plaintiff or defendant?? I can't stand to watch her anymore I'm sorry.
It’s bizarre to me that Judge Milian is so rude when correcting people’s English. We all know that when the plaintiff says, “dog’s friend,” he means, “friend’s dog.” Just ask clarifying questions in a respectful way. Like sorry that not everyone can speak two languages as fluently as Milian can. That’s not a reason to act like they’re stupid on National TV.
I completely agree. She is someone who is of Cuban descent she should be more aware. If someone corrected my Haitian parent’s English in that tone I’d had to straighten them out.
I agreed. She was really rude as if she doesn't have family members who have had to learn English as a second language. Her behavior was very elitist and condescending. I really like her, but I didn't like the way she treated her kinsman. It's as if she was embarrassed by them...
Correcting someone doesn't mean you are condescending or talking down to them 😑 it helps. My husband and I correct each other all the time doesn't mean we are talking down to each other .
@@jennross6466 displays most prominent traits: - ZERO empathy. - JM says "it's NOT funny!" Defendant "...yeh it is" (wtf? 🥺) And laughs!! smirks, (mugging for the camera whole time 🙄) - took ZERO responsibility throughout. ....after all that, he comes right out and says "In front of the cameras" Proposes💍 😳 After being sued. About his Pit Bull attacking. Laughs it off. 🤦. 🤦. 🤦. 🤦
Wow, I’ve always appreciated the Judge’s patience with native Spanish speakers and now I’m realizing her empathy and willingness to work around the language barrier stops at Spanish. I know my country’s accent anywhere and this native Portuguese speaker, while Latino (Brazilian) was not extended the same courtesy. The man was obviously trying his best - being respectful and as clear as he could; even humbly correcting himself. This left such a bad taste in my mouth and I haven’t even gotten to the proposal everyone is mentioning.
Edit: Any and Every litigant deserves patience when they are obviously trying their best, it’s just that Portuguese is so similar to Spanish that It wasn’t so much of a barrier or hassle as she painted.
My husband has put his fingers back together (so to speak) several times with the medical glue, called "Nu Skin". Of course you REALLY need to clean the wounds first & without painkillers that a Dr. might use, so it hurts like crazy but an ER visit costs thousands. He's figures if it stops bleeding he can fix it 😉
Yes I thought I was going crazy! I agree I love the accent. Something intriguing about it. It’s the same as a Spaniard-Mexican forcing an American English accent
The judge must have been in a bad mood. I have seen many episodes where there are multiple language barriers (many different languages as well) and she is patient and takes her time with them. However, in this case she was borderline making fun of them.
I agree I don't like how she was talking to them like if they were stupid. I see it as her mocking them. I was a fan of the judge but after watching her talk to my Latin people like that she is a sorry lover for that.
@Eman Barnawi I’ve seen her try to get people to be more clear so that everyone follows the story before and this just wasn’t one of those times. There was so many different times that her attitude and demeanor showed that she was just being an ass. But ofc we’re all entitled to our own opinions 🤷🏽♀️
@Eman Barnawi Its also an educational thing. if no one corrects you then you don't know and continue to make mistakes, also she needs to clarify what they mean. Avoid misinterpretation.
@Eman Barnawi honey Ik a lot of humans that don’t act like that because of language barrier. Me being one & I work in healthcare. Imagine being responsible for someone’s health and struggling with what needs they need met because either they don’t speak English fluently or they don’t speak it at all. Im human as well but wrong is wrong. That’s the job she signed up for. Ofc you’re entitled to your own opinion as I am mine.
If you are going to adopt or buy a PitBull, start a savings account because your dog will attack someone and you will be responsible. Usually around the age of 5-6 pitbulls tend to start to lash out No matter how loving their environment is.
She says he doesn’t get money for pain and suffering because she had a similar cut, but that’s completely different than a bite. Bites throb for days, sometimes longer.
The defendants in this case were reprehensible for making this dude come to court over something that they are clearly responsible for. I would make them pay three times the amount he is owed on principle alone.
Obviously he kept saying "my dog's friend" becuz English is not his first language. Considering the judge us Spanish speaking, she should understand that.... 😡😠🤬
I loved the People’s court and was so sad when it went off the air. It was filmed in Stanford Connecticut and I live in Connecticut. I live 45 minutes from where it was filmed, so I went to watch the People’s court between 35 to 40 times and what was really nice is while you were in the waiting room to go into the courtroom, they had tons of pizza and a full size refrigerator, full of soda and other drinks for free. What was really nice was after each case, judge Milian would come out and talk to us, and she would ask if anybody had any questions. You could ask her about her life or legal questions, and I learned so much about the law, watching the cases and asking her questions and she is one of the nicest, down to earth, people I’ve ever talked to, and she’s extremely funny, but I do love her new show Justice for the People with Judge Milian but sadly, that one is filmed in California now.
What is wrong with most Pit owners, especially on these Court shows?? they never take responsibility; it's always the victim's fault somehow 🤔 My sweet Springer has been attacked three times by 2 different dogs including a 20 lb poodle, 100 lb Rottweiler - that bit me as well - and a "feral" cat (conveniently the gal/owner claimed, she was "letting it live on her patio and that it had just had kittens" my dog and I strolled by to go for her walk in broad daylight and the cat came flying out of the bushes. As she dug her claws into Bella's flesh you've never heard a dog scream til that scenario 😢😢😢..) In each instance we were far off, minding our own business; my dog was ON her leash and both attacks, the dogs were off leash! only one of those three pet owners took responsibility and apologized. By a miracle my dog wasn't injured even though the Rott bit her in the hindquarters twice, while I was holding Bella as high in the air as I could and then it jumped up and bit my arm; the massive bruise took 3 weeks to heal & I still have puncture marks but thank God it didn't get infected 😔
💜 SO SORRY TO HEAR YOU & YOUR SWEET BELLA WERE INJURED 😥 OMGOSH, HOW FRIGHTENING, I'M GRATEFUL THAT ROTTWEILER DIDN'T HURT YOU & BELLA WORSE! YES, IT'S SO TRUE. IT'S ALWAYS THESE BAD OWNER'S WHOSE DOG BITES ANOTHER POOR DOG, A CHILD OR AN ADULT. YET THEY NEVER WANT TO APOLOGIZE, PAY FOR VET BILLS OR HOSPITAL BILLS. I THINK THAT THEY SHOULD BE GIVEN THE WORST PUNISHMENT! ALSO HAVE THEIR DOG REMOVED FROM THEM. THEY'RE IRRESPONSIBLE & SHOULDN'T OWN ANY DOG THAT ATTACKS SOMEONE SO VICIOUSLY. THESE DOG'S COULD KILL SOMEONE OR THEIR BELOVED ANIMALS. HOPE THAT YOU STAY SAFE & STAY BLESSED ☺🐶🐕🙏💜
@@katymcginn4644 thank you so much for your concern and kind words 💗💗💗 (When I saw I had a reply, was hesitant, certain a troll attacked (no pun intended) my statement. Pit owners bash us dog owners who know how most Pit owners don't take responsibility 😞 when their "sweet" Pit attacks. 🤦 99% court cases of dog attacks are Pitbulls. Facts don't lie. Defendants do).
This judge is lacking in knowledge here! We don't suture a wound like that as they tend to pull through the skin on a joint and heal poorly . We use a special medical glue. She's making assumptions about things she clearly knows nothing about. Being bitten by a dog is stressful, it needs a deep clean, shots and wound dressed. He should have been awarded more.
What is the judge's issue, these litigants clearly don't speak English properly, from their accents you can tell english is not their first language, she comes from a cuban family, i would think she would be more understanding of there being a language barrier and have more patience with them!
Judge Millian kind of got on my nerves here constantly correcting the way they talk. We hear clearly they speak a bit of broken English. What is she the Grammer police 🙄 Now I know she has to be sure of what they mean but once they've been corrected the first time she should know what they mean after that. especially with the plaintiff stating "dog's friend". Come on judge!!!
being attacked by any dog leaves desperate emotional fear afterwards sometimes for life. I think he should have been compensated for loss of wages and for pain and suffering...his injury is NOT the same as what the judge got cutting up food...absolutely not...
Watched 2 yesterday where she awarded the limit $5000. It’s not about getting a big payout, it’s about justice. If something happens and your are only out $250, she’s not going to give you $3000. She’s going to give you $250.
@Colleen O'Brien I agree, she’s a fair judge. However, this show has a budget. I’ve noticed that they don’t pick many of the larger cases that are “winnable”. The $5,000 judgement must have been a very interesting case that likely superseded the limit.
@@GMAMEC As I understand it, the way the show’s money works is whoever win’s the judgement gets that amount from the show. It’s subtracted from $5000. The remaining amount is then split between both parties. For example, the plaintiff wins a judgment of $1000 which they get from the show and the remaining $4000 is split between plaintiff and defendant. Plaintiff gets a total of $3000 and defendant gets $2000.
I’m shocked the plaintiff didn’t get pain and suffering or something. I got attacked by a bull mastiff. I still have a scar on my knee and elbow but what’s worse it the memory. I was super nervous around big dogs for a while after that and I had to see that dog one more time since then. Even his barks caused me so much anxiousness.
Y’all the Judge is Cuban. She is fluent in English and Spanish she was correcting like a bougie Spanish Tia that can pass for white. Like she did it out of love but she’s a lil uppity. 😂 unfortunately I know from experience.
What's that got to do with anything. If your going to have one of the worse breeds for causing problems and injuries and death a judge will be a be terse and some what uppity as you put it, especially if you walk into the court with any kind of attitude except the right one . I sure would dish it at right back with all the trimmings I could.
I have a pitbull. She’s pretty big. 94 pounds of muscle. She’s the sweetest thing. Never ever had an incident where she acted up with a human or another dog. That being said, I understand how powerful of a dog she is. I also acknowledge that some people are afraid of her breed. I go above and beyond to make sure she’s secured at all times. I have an 8 foot iron fence around my front yard and an 8 foot concrete fence around the backyard. I double check that latch every time I open and close it. When I take her out she has her collar (and harness) on. I’ve seen too many dogs wiggle out of their collar. As dog owners (especially of dogs so large that they can cause a lot of damage) we really need to be more careful. Also, these defendants act like it’s no big deal. That’s pretty messed up. I’ve had rabies and tetanus shots. That wasn’t a pleasant experience. I hope that little dog was okay. I saw the picture of him bleeding.😬
I love that she said it’s not the pit bulls fault. It’s the owners. People give pits a bad rep but they are just really strong dogs. If you train them properly they won’t be a problem. If you neglect them and keep them tied outside and don’t teach them restrain you’ll have a bite machine on your hands.!
It makes me so mad when pits get all the hate. Any pit owner knows they are the sweetest dogs. All dogs have the capability of being vicious. Check out the list of dog bites very year and chihuahuas are always #1. I’ve never been bite worse than by one of those shifty little bitches.
There’s nothing like proposing right after being sued for negligence that could’ve killed someone
Lol
Kicking off that marriage right! Or...? 🤣
She looked traumatized
Pretty sick actually. It really says something about the character of that man and woman
Straight CRINGE 🙈🙉🙊
“Have a good life… and keep your dog contained” 🤣 Doug remains undefeated.
They are getting rid of dog 🐕 and then fronts of proposing to his GF like it's no biggie
@@josedaniel4725 I did not hear them say that.
That proposal was cringy af!! Why didn't I remember this. Ugh I accidentally watched it again and died.
😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
thanks for the warning, I will skip that part. I have a weak heart and cringe is a danger to my health
@@Ay0ubM lmao!!
You must be a cat and have 9 lives and just took two ^.~.^
That proposal!! I’m willing to bet that she told him no in the car, tried to spare his feelings on camera 🤦🏾♀️ 😂 There was nothing romantic about any of this 🥴🥴🥴
THE WAY THE DEFENDANT “PROPOSED TO HIS GIRLFRIEND”.. 😂 THAT WAS CHEESY…. SHE EVEN SAID HOW EMBARRASSING..
@Lilly Smalls...😂I just deleted my SIMILAR post when I seen yours !Great MINDS
do think a like!😯🤔😂👌👍✌️
@@STEYFOKISED365 Lol 😂
that was very chessy! having to be reminded that He proposed after losing a case in Court!? WOW
There is a place and time for everything, and this wasn't the place or the time. Plus it just shows how little he cared about the plaintiff's injury and his dog attacking him. Plus I don't think she really wanted to marry him after being embarrassed on national television from losing the case.
Super weird but I found it cute
So embarrassing, why would you propose in a court you're being sued in?
Was the Judge having a bad day? She didn't even give the Plaintiff ANYTHING for pain and suffering.. ridiculous!
You nailed it.😮
Yeah prob she shouldn’t go to work if she did have bad day she seemed very upset and snotty
He didn’t sue for pain and suffering
And he couldn’t prove the lost wages. If he could have proved the lost wages, he would have gotten it.
Where's the pain and suffering 💰?? 😳 A dog bite is traumatic 😤
Yes, I agree.
If that dog really grabbed into his hand it wouldn't look like that, he probably got caught by a tooth , the small dog got the worst out of it
Victim shouldve gone to a therapist and brought the receipts.
#AGREED I'm petrified of dogs even thou I recognize it's not the animals' fault (regardless of it being friendly) because of their natural impulses; furthermore my friend's chihuahua bit me & was utter negligence of owner. 30' some yrs.later, I'm overanalyzing every encounter with "domestic pets"🤪🎭
@@marymonte9438 My friends small dog bit someone's ankle twice, my German shepherd never bit anyone and he's almost 11.
“Have a good life, and keep your dog contained.” 😂😂😂
He's so fucking shady 😂
Straight savage
Lmao. Theirs a episode about a coy fish pond and the person lost. He said "good luck with the fish and stuff". He really is so shady and I don't think half of the people realize it. The other older guy says some funny stuff too. 😂
@@cassandra6710 🤣🤣🤣like when he says “why are you smiling? You lost.” LOL
Scummy person has a pit bull? No way! Quelle suprise!
The defendant is kind of a jerk.
I heard he just tried to sue them again recently because he still can't get over his trauma
The husband understood and said it was his fault and kind of laughed and his wife kept a straight face the whole time. That proposal gotta be fake lmao
Yeah I was under the impression that they were already married.
Judge M: What’s your defense?
Defendant: What do you mean? 😬
I don't get why the defendant is smiling and laughing. I strive to be this clueless and ignorantly happy.
Listen!! So detached
Because he already knew how the case was going to come out
Cynical much ? The defendant was just a nice guy who was ready to admit responsibility. The Plaintiff coming up with loss wages was prob the sticking point all along. Def was just happy too cause he knew what he was gonna do after.
He got money
My thoughts exactly- Its apparently a gift ,lmao he was completely tunnel vision for that proposal he pulled off😅🤦♀️
The fact that the defendant kept joking when he CLEARLY lost and then tried to counter it with a proposal eeeek I say eeek 🙃
The law doesn't say you have to make an attempt to control your dog, but that you have to control it.
Hey, you remember when we got sued for having a vicious pit bull?
Yes, it was so romantic.
Right? 😂🤣😅
Lol
Lol your funny
4:47 When the Judge said is it me… I died laughing because I thought I was tripping too! They didn’t understand nothing she was asking 🤣
She should have just spoke to them in Spanish! 🤷🏾♀️
@@chaycesmom1212 right! Clearly there was a language barrier.
@@chaycesmom1212 i didn't speak Spanish.
They understood some questions, some things.
@@emersonduarte9671 Is your language Portuguese?
Milian was kind of rude considering the language barrier. I was a bit disappointed as it was apparent and she could’ve behaved more sensitive towards both sides.
Not the first time I've seen this. She seems to have so much empathy normally, but not for non-native speakers.
Ive literally seen her speak spanish to a litigant before and translate for the cameras, she was definitely being a bi--- to this guy.
I was thinking the same thing. Lort lady give them a freaking break
Agreed
I would blame it on PMS but i'm pretty sure she's reached menopause.
The constant smiling and laughing of the defendant is beyond me. Then he proceeds to propose after being sued? He would have lost twice that day because “get up...no”
he should have gotten pain and suffering for that dog bite as well. Why should he have to suffer when he did nothing wrong.
Well, unlike other tv judges who would have awarded it just to make a point and put the AH dog owner in his place, with Judge Milian, she didn't award it cuz he didn't ask for it. He should have ..... a dog like that coming after you and biting, definitely pain should be recompensible, and then the there is the emotional toll from an attack. The dog owner got off easy on this one.
Depends on the state the case was filed in. Some states don't have pain and suffering as an option. Some, the person has to prove it, not just claim it.
He didn't sure for P&S.
I live for Doug being a straight shade thrower savage!🤣😅😂😂😂🤣
He is a complete savage! He kills me with the way he talks to the losers LOL....
If he gave classes in Savagery, I would sign up.
Savageeee
I don’t like the way the judge was talking to him and he had a language barrier. 😔😞 she knew what he meant.
Me too
Leading the plaintiff! lol
How many times is he going to say “ my dogs friend “ I would be annoyed as well
She had to clarify for the benefit of the audience. Also, there should be as little ambiguity as possible in a court of law.
I wouldn’t be shock if the lady’s husband sleeps on the couch after all the laughing he’s doing 😂🤣🤣
It isn’t the “cuts” that likely kept him from working. It’s the bone-crushing jaws. I can’t believe she would be as nonchalant as the defendants were about damages.
Exactly. And dog bites hurt differently than knife cuts that may look the same on the surface.
@@NubianP6 agreed.
Yeah dog bite plus the trauma of being bitten
AGREE, thank you !!!! It's NOTHING like a knife cut!! Plus the psychological trauma... dog attacks are absolutely terrifying and debilitating!!
His bones weren’t crushed what are you talking about.? 😊
The defendant knew that they were in the wrong the entire time. All he cared about was being on camera and proposing to his significant other. Definitely explains why she was taking things much more seriously the entire time.
You never get over a dog attack on you or on your dog. EVER! It damages you psychologically and takes a long time to try to get over. Oh and that laughable proposal. With that pursed up angry looking face of hers, she def had to say yes to someone.
I find it both funny & disgusting th@ when it comes to her relatives let alone her extended family all being pit bulls... that Judge Judy is quick to be so abusive & judgemental against them & their owners.... did you know th@ when judge judy is not being abusive towards those standing in front of her she likes to take it up the backdoor doggy style & gives it back to her pitbull husband a million times harder..... now there's something horrible isn't it.
that's a blanket statement that's not true
In 2015 my neighbor who was 85 years old, was walking his little Terrier (Gus) near his home. A red pitbull came out of no-where and attacked my neighbor and his little dog. My neighbor sustained multiple bites on his body and Gus received more than 100 stitches. Gus had multiple bites extending from the back of his neck, to the length of his belly. The Police and Paramedics arrived on scene. The dog and his owner were located and Spokane Animal Control took custody of the Pitbull.
My neighbor sued for all damages and won his case. The Pitbull was euthanized. ***ALL PET OWNER''S are RESPONSIBLE for their PET"S behavior and restraint. No excuses....
Omg That's terrible..
Oh no! How is your neighbor and his dog doing? I am so sorry to hear that
This man really proposed after losing in peoples court lmaoooo I am crying rn
I think he went on the People's Court JUST to propose. He already knew he was in the wrong lol...
I have a sneaky suspicion he did that to appease his girlfriend knowing that she was going to be in a bad mood for losing the case.
“No, …. Well whaddya want??”. My guy at the end is always hilarious.
Lol that man at the end that does the interviews is too funny and he be rude sometimes to those defendants.
How does she think she’s not responsible for her pit bull attacking a man and a puppy? These defendants are delusional.
The plaintiff should've been awarded the full amount for pain and suffering.
and that was just for that proposal🤮
Damn Judge you gotta ease up English is not their first language.
And she Mexican herself 🙄
That’s what I was thinking. She was so rude for that.
@@BrownBamaGirl8 she's Cuban but yeah I agree
Thank you for saying something
Right lol
The judge is a bit impatient with non-native speakers. She could try a tad more empathy as a bilingual person. I don't think she realizes how she comes off when people are speaking pretty clearly considering English is not their native language. I know language needs to be precise in court, but just wanted to share this observation.
I was thinking the same and I’ve seen her do that before
I agree. I wouldn't be able to be that good in a second language.
She her self is Cuban so she should be more patient, I am also Cuban and I came when I was 2 years old now I am 60 but living in Miami like she also does we all have to be patient with people here in our wonderful multicultural state maybe she forgot where she came from I find it rude maybe she is trying to teach them the correct way to say it but she does it in a rude way.
She asked basic direct questions. They weren't hard to understand even if English is your second or third language. The problem is people need to listen. She herself speaks multiple languages and probably has plenty of empathy. Because she's done it.
@@davidt5200 I think they were nervous, but also it was more about their replies. She knew what they meant, but was rude about the way she corrected them.
Worst proposal ever! Not only did she not hold out her hand for him to put the ring 💍 on it, she said it was embarrassing 😳 he better run 🏃♂️ and run fast
I highly doubt that the Pit Bull never attacked before.
There's an obvious language barrier here, she knows what he's trying to say and she's being snappy. Like he's trying to deceive her.
I mean really he would have been humiliated on national TV had she said no.
"How embarrassing" it's pretty damn close to "no"
Who knows she might have been polite in the view of the camera but after the camera was off she said "hell no"
🤣🤣🤣
Hey wait a minute, he didn't even put the ring on her hand I think it was all just an act!
What a bunch of losers!
Lol he did that for attention
@@shamaoliver7989
🤣
Would have been the second dog bite of the case! 😲
Its not our fault, our dog is friendly. We tied him up, so its not our fault he got loose.
Absolutely DISGUSTING. To propose marriage after being SUED -- those 2 defendants really deserve each other! Anyone associated with them won't have a good life!
I was hoping she'd give him another couple of thousand in lost wages - then get a great shot of the smiling defendant & the wife
Yeah, maybe it would have wiped the smile off the defendants face.
Pain and suffering compensation at the very least!
Double Standards at its finest
Exactly! She can’t impose onto him what she kept working through. We don’t know the extent of his pain and after effects. And she wasn’t cooking thanksgiving meals every day for 2 weeks. He does handy man work and computer work which requires active use of his fingers 🤷🏽♀️
He's a con artist!
I feel bad for the plaintiff, he wasn’t awarded enough for what he went through. I wonder if Judge Milian gets more money if she awards lower judgment amount because she rarely awards what they truly deserve, makes me so sad.
I think the same thing. Her rulings sometimes make no sense!
If people had to go to prison when their dogs attacked,I wonder how many people would be careless about keeping them under control.
Obviously wasn’t careless sometimes leashes fail get real
@@tmanwheeler8270 a failed leash is the ultimate in careless...
Ok.. what if I give you leash failure as an out... what plan does an owner need to have in case of leash failure with aggressive dogs in public? Is leash failure an out for responsibility?
Judge is so rude and arrogant does she not understand that there is a language barrier and that English is not the first language of the plaintiff or defendant?? I can't stand to watch her anymore I'm sorry.
Right. She used to speak Spanish for people when they didn't understand certain things... her personality has hardened over the years
What did I just watch at the end? Like dude that’s not romantic! Smh 🤦🏻♀️ anything for clout
The random proposal at the end 😹
The plaintiff is a fine looking man with a charming accent and way of speaking.
I agree he is fine as hell
Yes he is
And he's a dog lover, that's a bonus point too! Shows he's a caring guy, and he's a nice guy for taking care of his friend's dog too 😉
Great biceps too!
@@williamslatasha60lw he is 😍
Yaaaayyy a proposal !!! Now yu get to share his debts frm this law suit lmao
😂😂
Lolololololol
“Can I have a minute of your TV time?” “No.” Lmao
It’s bizarre to me that Judge Milian is so rude when correcting people’s English. We all know that when the plaintiff says, “dog’s friend,” he means, “friend’s dog.” Just ask clarifying questions in a respectful way. Like sorry that not everyone can speak two languages as fluently as Milian can. That’s not a reason to act like they’re stupid on National TV.
Ya I agree, it was rude and totally unnecessary
You know secretely I felt the same way.
I completely agree. She is someone who is of Cuban descent she should be more aware. If someone corrected my Haitian parent’s English in that tone I’d had to straighten them out.
Indeed
I agreed. She was really rude as if she doesn't have family members who have had to learn English as a second language. Her behavior was very elitist and condescending. I really like her, but I didn't like the way she treated her kinsman. It's as if she was embarrassed by them...
Correcting someone doesn't mean you are condescending or talking down to them 😑 it helps. My husband and I correct each other all the time doesn't mean we are talking down to each other .
It does in this age where everybody feels like nobody has the right to tell them they are wrong...sad state of society.
Tell them! We do too. As I do to my kids too. I’m a stickler for being grammatically correct.
Correcting one another ''all the time'' is absurd.
@@marilynwillett804 girl you tried lol 😏
@@marilynwillett804 no it’s not! At the end of the day you’ll eventually know what’s right and wrong… correct!
Maybe thats why he was smiling, he was only thinking about the proposal. I think it was sweet 💛
The Plaintiff's dog friend.
Esl love his accent
Does anyone know were he is from has a nice accent
@@mokkamellb6811 Thank you 😊
I LOVE it too!!! He is either Brazilian or Mexican
@@donnahinkle5421 Well you can ask him because he's in the comment section. :-)
The defendant is a narcissist...what's funny @ a Pit bite😳 and then the on-camera proposal 🙄
How do you get narcissist?
@@jennross6466 displays most prominent traits:
- ZERO empathy.
- JM says "it's NOT funny!"
Defendant "...yeh it is" (wtf? 🥺) And laughs!! smirks, (mugging for the camera whole time 🙄)
- took ZERO responsibility throughout.
....after all that, he comes right out and says "In front of the cameras"
Proposes💍 😳 After being sued. About his Pit Bull attacking. Laughs it off.
🤦. 🤦. 🤦. 🤦
Wow, I’ve always appreciated the Judge’s patience with native Spanish speakers and now I’m realizing her empathy and willingness to work around the language barrier stops at Spanish. I know my country’s accent anywhere and this native Portuguese speaker, while Latino (Brazilian) was not extended the same courtesy. The man was obviously trying his best - being respectful and as clear as he could; even humbly correcting himself. This left such a bad taste in my mouth and I haven’t even gotten to the proposal everyone is mentioning.
Edit: Any and Every litigant deserves patience when they are obviously trying their best, it’s just that Portuguese is so similar to Spanish that It wasn’t so much of a barrier or hassle as she painted.
it looks like rather than stitches, they used glue. I've had that instead of stitches for surgery and can be used to non-invasively reattach skin.
My husband has put his fingers back together (so to speak) several times with the medical glue, called "Nu Skin". Of course you REALLY need to clean the wounds first & without painkillers that a Dr. might use, so it hurts like crazy but an ER visit costs thousands. He's figures if it stops bleeding he can fix it 😉
They used stitches, steristrips my first C Section.
2nd time Glue & staples
@@stephaniehowe0973 Mine was the opposite staples the first time 😩 glue the next. I prefer the glue whew.
@@KPbouj its years ago now but staples for maybe 55 hrs then out w a 40 miles ride home?
I was all 1 big pot hole I will snap in half
@@CuriousGoodsJessica I clean the wound well and use super glue. LOL
The plantiff, I believe speaks Portuguese, based on his accent. I could be wrong.
I think so as well…All Portuguese/Brazilian people I know have that type of accent..
You right
Yes I thought I was going crazy! I agree I love the accent. Something intriguing about it. It’s the same as a Spaniard-Mexican forcing an American English accent
@@M_inTheNetherlands the fact that the judge didn't ask him/ try to translate suggests it wasnt Spanish.
The judge must have been in a bad mood. I have seen many episodes where there are multiple language barriers (many different languages as well) and she is patient and takes her time with them. However, in this case she was borderline making fun of them.
I agree I don't like how she was talking to them like if they were stupid. I see it as her mocking them. I was a fan of the judge but after watching her talk to my Latin people like that she is a sorry lover for that.
@@chicanamexcooking Mocking? I could hardly understand the case because of their language barriers. No one could.
With the judge being Cuban, you would think she would have more patience or be more kind to both parties. Very disappointing. 😒
Cubans can be very racist especially towards other Hispanics
@@Di_777 Is that a fact or your opinion?
Judge is rude... no patience for someone whose second language is english...
It's tv. She has to get her views🤷
The defendants, husband and wife appear to use the same box dye! 😒
As a judge you must know as bright as day English isn’t their first language .. why so rude & aggressive..
I said the same thing! Insensitive af
@Eman Barnawi I’ve seen her try to get people to be more clear so that everyone follows the story before and this just wasn’t one of those times. There was so many different times that her attitude and demeanor showed that she was just being an ass. But ofc we’re all entitled to our own opinions 🤷🏽♀️
@Eman Barnawi Its also an educational thing. if no one corrects you then you don't know and continue to make mistakes, also she needs to clarify what they mean. Avoid misinterpretation.
@Eman Barnawi honey Ik a lot of humans that don’t act like that because of language barrier. Me being one & I work in healthcare. Imagine being responsible for someone’s health and struggling with what needs they need met because either they don’t speak English fluently or they don’t speak it at all. Im human as well but wrong is wrong. That’s the job she signed up for. Ofc you’re entitled to your own opinion as I am mine.
@@lisaparrey1343 It's* ;-)
He came on tv to propose. He knew he would lose. He had that sparkle in his eyes. The whole time. 😊
The defendant woman looks like a nasty person. I would be very weary of her and her partner.
I don't think so.. she went with him to the doctor .... Also someone wants to marry her ..she can't be that awful lol
If you are going to adopt or buy a PitBull, start a savings account because your dog will attack someone and you will be responsible. Usually around the age of 5-6 pitbulls tend to start to lash out No matter how loving their environment is.
She says he doesn’t get money for pain and suffering because she had a similar cut, but that’s completely different than a bite. Bites throb for days, sometimes longer.
The defendants in this case were reprehensible for making this dude come to court over something that they are clearly responsible for. I would make them pay three times the amount he is owed on principle alone.
The language barrier is killing me in this case 😩
Obviously he kept saying "my dog's friend" becuz English is not his first language. Considering the judge us Spanish speaking, she should understand that.... 😡😠🤬
The ending was fantastic and keep your dog contained.
I loved the People’s court and was so sad when it went off the air. It was filmed in Stanford Connecticut and I live in Connecticut. I live 45 minutes from where it was filmed, so I went to watch the People’s court between 35 to 40 times and what was really nice is while you were in the waiting room to go into the courtroom, they had tons of pizza and a full size refrigerator, full of soda and other drinks for free.
What was really nice was after each case, judge Milian would come out and talk to us, and she would ask if anybody had any questions. You could ask her about her life or legal questions, and I learned so much about the law, watching the cases and asking her questions and she is one of the nicest, down to earth, people I’ve ever talked to, and she’s extremely funny, but I do love her new show Justice for the People with Judge Milian but sadly, that one is filmed in California now.
What is wrong with most Pit owners, especially on these Court shows?? they never take responsibility; it's always the victim's fault somehow 🤔
My sweet Springer has been attacked three times by 2 different dogs including a 20 lb poodle, 100 lb Rottweiler - that bit me as well - and a "feral" cat (conveniently the gal/owner claimed, she was "letting it live on her patio and that it had just had kittens" my dog and I strolled by to go for her walk in broad daylight and the cat came flying out of the bushes. As she dug her claws into Bella's flesh you've never heard a dog scream til that scenario 😢😢😢..)
In each instance we were far off, minding our own business; my dog was ON her leash and both attacks, the dogs were off leash! only one of those three pet owners took responsibility and apologized.
By a miracle my dog wasn't injured even though the Rott bit her in the hindquarters twice, while I was holding Bella as high in the air as I could and then it jumped up and bit my arm; the massive bruise took 3 weeks to heal & I still have puncture marks but thank God it didn't get infected 😔
💜 SO SORRY TO HEAR YOU & YOUR SWEET BELLA WERE INJURED 😥 OMGOSH, HOW FRIGHTENING, I'M GRATEFUL THAT ROTTWEILER DIDN'T HURT YOU & BELLA WORSE!
YES, IT'S SO TRUE. IT'S ALWAYS THESE BAD OWNER'S WHOSE DOG BITES ANOTHER POOR DOG, A CHILD OR AN ADULT. YET THEY NEVER WANT TO APOLOGIZE, PAY FOR VET BILLS OR HOSPITAL BILLS. I THINK THAT THEY SHOULD BE GIVEN THE WORST PUNISHMENT! ALSO HAVE THEIR DOG REMOVED FROM THEM. THEY'RE IRRESPONSIBLE & SHOULDN'T OWN ANY DOG THAT ATTACKS SOMEONE SO VICIOUSLY. THESE DOG'S COULD KILL SOMEONE OR THEIR BELOVED ANIMALS. HOPE THAT YOU STAY SAFE & STAY BLESSED ☺🐶🐕🙏💜
@@katymcginn4644 thank you so much for your concern and kind words 💗💗💗
(When I saw I had a reply, was hesitant, certain a troll attacked (no pun intended) my statement. Pit owners bash us dog owners who know how most Pit owners don't take responsibility 😞 when their "sweet" Pit attacks. 🤦
99% court cases of dog attacks are Pitbulls. Facts don't lie. Defendants do).
They never stitch up dog bites if they are smaller, because of infection. I've had several. If possible they keep them open
"I lost but I gain"💖💖good one!👍
Omg how embarrassing was that proposal?
How many stitches did the dog receive.. a thousand dollars!!!
Plaintiff should have been paid atleast 5 days of work for pain and suffering due to the defendants negligence. Not too happy with the verdict.
Definitely a language barrier in this case.
OMG a PITBILL ATTACKED??! Noooooo watyyyyyyy I’m FLABBERGASTED
I’m very upset at how the judge acted in this case, she was so rude 😡
It's tv. She has to get her views 🤷
Completely agree, clearly their first language isn’t english, she had no tolerance or understanding.
"Pitbull has NEVER done this before" LMAO
Yeah the defendant almost slipped up there.
This judge is lacking in knowledge here! We don't suture a wound like that as they tend to pull through the skin on a joint and heal poorly . We use a special medical glue. She's making assumptions about things she clearly knows nothing about. Being bitten by a dog is stressful, it needs a deep clean, shots and wound dressed. He should have been awarded more.
I was just about to say this. I worked in the ER for 4 years and OR for 6. Dogs bites on humans don’t necessarily get stitches.
I totally agree. Punctures , flaps, and bites are not sutured. Pain suffering and lost wages should of been awarded
She's lawyer not a doctor
What is the judge's issue, these litigants clearly don't speak English properly, from their accents you can tell english is not their first language, she comes from a cuban family, i would think she would be more understanding of there being a language barrier and have more patience with them!
thank u
Minutes in and I completely agree. Smh.
She's something else something serious. Nasty, rude, obnoxious, interrupting litigants. She's a piece of work.
I said before it seems like she makes fun of people's accents..always correcting them or whatever
Yeah she’s just super annoying in this episode.
Most Karen I have ever seen the judge. She clearly did not like the plaintiff.
It must be tough for the judge because the plaintiff and the defendant cannot CLEARLY explain their case
Did judge Milan over condition her hair today?
Judge Millian kind of got on my nerves here constantly correcting the way they talk. We hear clearly they speak a bit of broken English. What is she the Grammer police 🙄
Now I know she has to be sure of what they mean but once they've been corrected the first time she should know what they mean after that. especially with the plaintiff stating "dog's friend". Come on judge!!!
Totally agree
It was condescending
Yea, I’m bilingual n I HATE when my adopted mom does this ALL THE TIME
being attacked by any dog leaves desperate emotional fear afterwards sometimes for life. I think he should have been compensated for loss of wages and for pain and suffering...his injury is NOT the same as what the judge got cutting up food...absolutely not...
that first lady on the street being like “i could hear him breathing he must have been aggressive!!!” he was probably excited jumping on the fence
"my dog's friend" X2 LMAO!
I’m not at the end, but this show never awards large judgements. The plaintiff will not win or will get less.
It’s small claims court. The limit is $5000.
@Colleen O'Brien I’ve noticed that she rarely awards large judgements.
Watched 2 yesterday where she awarded the limit $5000. It’s not about getting a big payout, it’s about justice. If something happens and your are only out $250, she’s not going to give you $3000. She’s going to give you $250.
@Colleen O'Brien I agree, she’s a fair judge. However, this show has a budget. I’ve noticed that they don’t pick many of the larger cases that are “winnable”. The $5,000 judgement must have been a very interesting case that likely superseded the limit.
@@GMAMEC As I understand it, the way the show’s money works is whoever win’s the judgement gets that amount from the show. It’s subtracted from $5000. The remaining amount is then split between both parties. For example, the plaintiff wins a judgment of $1000 which they get from the show and the remaining $4000 is split between plaintiff and defendant. Plaintiff gets a total of $3000 and defendant gets $2000.
I’m shocked the plaintiff didn’t get pain and suffering or something. I got attacked by a bull mastiff. I still have a scar on my knee and elbow but what’s worse it the memory. I was super nervous around big dogs for a while after that and I had to see that dog one more time since then. Even his barks caused me so much anxiousness.
I'm not. It was just a little cut.
I'm so sorry.
Y’all the Judge is Cuban. She is fluent in English and Spanish she was correcting like a bougie Spanish Tia that can pass for white. Like she did it out of love but she’s a lil uppity. 😂 unfortunately I know from experience.
What's that got to do with anything. If your going to have one of the worse breeds for causing problems and injuries and death a judge will be a be terse and some what uppity as you put it, especially if you walk into the court with any kind of attitude except the right one . I sure would dish it at right back with all the trimmings I could.
I have a pitbull. She’s pretty big. 94 pounds of muscle. She’s the sweetest thing. Never ever had an incident where she acted up with a human or another dog. That being said, I understand how powerful of a dog she is. I also acknowledge that some people are afraid of her breed. I go above and beyond to make sure she’s secured at all times. I have an 8 foot iron fence around my front yard and an 8 foot concrete fence around the backyard. I double check that latch every time I open and close it. When I take her out she has her collar (and harness) on. I’ve seen too many dogs wiggle out of their collar. As dog owners (especially of dogs so large that they can cause a lot of damage) we really need to be more careful. Also, these defendants act like it’s no big deal. That’s pretty messed up. I’ve had rabies and tetanus shots. That wasn’t a pleasant experience. I hope that little dog was okay. I saw the picture of him bleeding.😬
He was so happy he didn’t even care he lose but he gain !!! 💪🏾💯❤️
Defendant: "I lost but I gained... YEeeSsSssS!!!!" 💍
Really sir!?!? 😂😂🤣😂😭
I loved the plaintiff’s Brazilian accent .
People who can’t train/won’t train their dogs to at least not attack people shouldn’t own pets.
I love that she said it’s not the pit bulls fault. It’s the owners.
People give pits a bad rep but they are just really strong dogs. If you train them properly they won’t be a problem. If you neglect them and keep them tied outside and don’t teach them restrain you’ll have a bite machine on your hands.!
It makes me so mad when pits get all the hate. Any pit owner knows they are the sweetest dogs. All dogs have the capability of being vicious. Check out the list of dog bites very year and chihuahuas are always #1. I’ve never been bite worse than by one of those shifty little bitches.
Seems like no pitbull owner can train them since there’s multiple attacks every year…lmao
He screamed for minutes and owner didn’t come. Sounds like every pitbull owner in existence.
I swear they seek out these pit cases. You would think that no other breed bit or attacked anyone.