Very Useful material for beginners of Indian history. I have studied ancient India during my graduation. Mehargadh was new for me . We have many agrarian and Village civilization sites in India such as Ropar, rangpur, Kapurthala, lothal , kalibangan, Rakhi gadhi etc. Thank you for introducing me this new site. I am very curious to know about Sanskrit speaking tribes of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Please post a discussion on this topic in future . Have they also maintained or preserved other aspects of Aryan culture. ? Such as food habits , religious rituals, social customs and heirarchy ? If not what might be the reason for dropping all these accept their language ? This is very surprising .
Meluhha is the Sumerian name of a prominent trading partner of Sumer during the Middle Bronze Age. Its identification remains an open question, but most scholars associate it with the Indus Valley Civilization. Mesopotamian used to call people of Indus Valley Civilization as Meluhha. (Wikipedia, Professor Mark Kenoyer's lecture at University of Chicago available on UA-cam.
Dr Saheb koi naviyan videos nai upload kar rahey. I pray he is in good health. I greatly admire Dr Saab's research and dedication in unravelling the layers of history of our Punjab.
Sir, thanks for giving valuable information. Can you please discuss about Dravidian people and their language like whether they were the people who migrated to south after decline of harappan civilization or they had completely different civilization evolved in parallel or before harappan civilization. Also is it true that dravadian is older than vedic sanskrit.
Sir, please do try to discuss Baba Nanak and his synthesis of modern Rationality in line with your view that new Indic ideas have always blossomed from Punjab.
"SAPPAT-SINDHU" (7 RIVER'S LAND) OR HARRAP-PA MOHANJO-DARRO INDUS VALLEY CIVILIZATION & "PUNJNAD > PUNJAB" (5 RIVER'S LAND) Is The Land Of Love, Peace, Prosperity, Wealth, Power & Wisdom. I Am Multani Punjabi. I Love "Multan Civilization" (Oldest Living City In The World), "Punjabi Language" (Including Multani Punjabi Dialect All Dialects Of Punjabi Language), "Punjabi Culture" (Including Multani Punjabi Culture All Sub-Cultures Of Punjab), "Nationalism" (Patriotism) & Internationalism. Long Live Free Khalistan & Kashmir. Just Electocracy Is Not Democracy. Humanism, Secularism, Tolerance, Socio-Economic Justice & Socialist Democracy Is Our Creed. WE STAND FOR PAKISTAN FIRST. Iftikhar Fakhar "Chhavrri" (Gujjar) Advocate High Court, Multan, Punjab, Pakistan افتخار فخر "چھاوڑی" (گُجر) ایڈووکیٹ ہائی کورٹ، مُلتان، پنجاب، پاکستان
Great video, but Dr, Sahab makes few mistakes. One it is called Zag-rosian, not Zara-gosian. Also at 26.25 he says second branch went to Europe through Alaska, that is wrong. They originated in Eurasian Steppes (modern day Ukraine and adjacent Russian grasslands) and moved to West and North in Europe from there.
Minor errors. In fact the Indo-Iranians came from Central Russia of the modern times, NOT from Iran. That region was part of, at that time, what we today call the Andronovo culture. That is a different discussion altogether. Par Prof Sb oran di khaas domain knowledge South Asia te Punjab di ay.
Janab ik tan jedha banda tuhadi vedio bana reha ehs kaho moooh bandh rakhe vich hi awaaz sunayi deh rahi a nidhan kuch chaba reha aghe ton dhiyaaan rakhna
Dr. Sahib you give very detail and valuable information,however I have a question which is that if punjabi or Gurmukhi were taught, read or write in joint Punjab? , before partition and what happened, why it disappeared from Pakistani Punjab after partition? Although it’s spoken and even used in poetry. Thx
Punjabi Muslims poets used Shahmukhi script. Baba Farid, Shah Hussain, Sultan bahu, Bulleh Shah, Waris Shah, Ghulam Farid, Mian Mohammad Bakhs all used Shahmukhi script, not gurmukhi. So it made sense for Mulsims to use Shahmukhi.
@@ajeyklg Yep pretty much Urdu. Though Punjabi have some words/voices that Urdu doesn't have, so we can add some additional alphabets for those voices.
I have to protest at the use of incorrect language in describing history. You cannot use the terms India or hindustan because it implies an incorrect historical term. Historically it was a region, but now it refers to a country, you cannot use those terms to describe Pakistani history. We have to recognise ground realities, and apply correct terms. It is unfair and false. You can use the term Indus region/alaka, or any such fair terms. The history belongs to the modern day ground realities. There was no India or hindustan 5000 years ago. As Pakistani historians, it's your responsibility to create your own message, and not fall prey to intellectual laziness.
Baht gehri aur changi miyari malumaat galbaat. Thanks
Wah! Kya galbaat hai
ਵਾਹ! ਕਿੰਨੀ ਵਧੀਆ ਗੱਲਬਾਤ ਹੈ।
Very informative please continue this series.
Very very good information is great conversation
Dr Manzur Ejaz has a vast and rationale vision about Punjab. I admire his research.
Bhaut vadia jabardast
Nice ❤
ch Muhammad afzal
Bahawal Nagar
ਵਧੀਆ ਗੱਲਬਾਤ ਜੀ, ਧੰਨਵਾਦ
Love from abbotsford ( BC , CANADA )
Great 😢
Bohat Vadiya 🙏🏼
Very Useful material for beginners of Indian history. I have studied ancient India during my graduation. Mehargadh was new for me . We have many agrarian and Village civilization sites in India such as Ropar, rangpur, Kapurthala, lothal , kalibangan, Rakhi gadhi etc. Thank you for introducing me this new site.
I am very curious to know about Sanskrit speaking tribes of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Please post a discussion on this topic in future . Have they also maintained or preserved other aspects of Aryan culture. ? Such as food habits , religious rituals, social customs and heirarchy ?
If not what might be the reason for dropping all these accept their language ?
This is very surprising .
Meluhha is the Sumerian name of a prominent trading partner of Sumer during the Middle Bronze Age. Its identification remains an open question, but most scholars associate it with the Indus Valley Civilization. Mesopotamian used to call people of Indus Valley Civilization as Meluhha. (Wikipedia, Professor Mark Kenoyer's lecture at University of Chicago available on UA-cam.
Dr Saheb koi naviyan videos nai upload kar rahey. I pray he is in good health. I greatly admire Dr Saab's research and dedication in unravelling the layers of history of our Punjab.
great information
Sir, thanks for giving valuable information. Can you please discuss about Dravidian people and their language like whether they were the people who migrated to south after decline of harappan civilization or they had completely different civilization evolved in parallel or before harappan civilization. Also is it true that dravadian is older than vedic sanskrit.
Waheguruji
Thanks from East Punjab
Punjab could be 40 thousands years old, lot of work needed to be done.
Probably even older, when you consider the Soan Valley in Potohar.
❤
Dr Sab ney Bohat vadiya ty maloomati gal baat sanji kiti a,bohat wadiya ty qabil e tareef gaal baat kiti gayi aa
Sir, please do try to discuss Baba Nanak and his synthesis of modern Rationality in line with your view that new Indic ideas have always blossomed from Punjab.
Love listening to Dr Manzur. We appreciate you sharing your knowledge. 🙏🏽
❤❤🌾🌾🚜💪🙏🙏
Sir thank you for such an enlightening discussion on my dash Punjab specially in mania boli Punjabi
wonderful
You are giving a layman's view, reality is something else, dig deep to know Punjab's history.
"SAPPAT-SINDHU" (7 RIVER'S LAND) OR HARRAP-PA MOHANJO-DARRO INDUS VALLEY CIVILIZATION & "PUNJNAD > PUNJAB" (5 RIVER'S LAND) Is The Land Of Love, Peace, Prosperity, Wealth, Power & Wisdom.
I Am Multani Punjabi.
I Love "Multan Civilization" (Oldest Living City In The World), "Punjabi Language" (Including Multani Punjabi Dialect All Dialects Of Punjabi Language), "Punjabi Culture" (Including Multani Punjabi Culture All Sub-Cultures Of Punjab), "Nationalism" (Patriotism) & Internationalism.
Long Live Free Khalistan & Kashmir.
Just Electocracy Is Not Democracy.
Humanism, Secularism, Tolerance, Socio-Economic Justice & Socialist Democracy Is Our Creed.
WE STAND FOR PAKISTAN FIRST.
Iftikhar Fakhar "Chhavrri" (Gujjar) Advocate High Court, Multan, Punjab, Pakistan
افتخار فخر "چھاوڑی" (گُجر) ایڈووکیٹ ہائی کورٹ، مُلتان، پنجاب، پاکستان
بہت ساریاں باتاں رکھیاں وے تُساں نے پر ایہہ مینوں چنگی لگی کہ تسیں ملتان توں بیلونگ کرن دے باوجود اپنے آپ نوں پنجابی مندے ہو
Town, village, pind, chuk, Abad, poura , darou, nagar and ore ( Lahore, Kushore) etc was you use to define cities.
You mean to say that Lahore just symbolized the place as Pura, Chal aur Abad did?
respect for charda punjab sir
Can we connect on WhatsApp? I need to have some questions answered.
Can you please provide the names of books and authors you mentioned in the video? You can also drop links to other resources in the description.
If anyone ever does english captions for this video lmk, thanks!
English version?
Jatt , baman , baniye eh lok taa saare baharo aaye punjabi kom jindabaad ethe de moolnivasi rahe ne
کمال (فکر)دیتا جی
انگلش ساڈی پہنچ تو دور اے توسی پنجابی وچ سبق دے کے بڑا ای چنگا کیتا بہت چنگا لگیا
Great video, but Dr, Sahab makes few mistakes. One it is called Zag-rosian, not Zara-gosian. Also at 26.25 he says second branch went to Europe through Alaska, that is wrong. They originated in Eurasian Steppes (modern day Ukraine and adjacent Russian grasslands) and moved to West and North in Europe from there.
Minor errors. In fact the Indo-Iranians came from Central Russia of the modern times, NOT from Iran. That region was part of, at that time, what we today call the Andronovo culture. That is a different discussion altogether. Par Prof Sb oran di khaas domain knowledge South Asia te Punjab di ay.
how people shifted to Europe via alaska?
Plz Give Title to the Post. Thanks
Janab ik tan jedha banda tuhadi vedio bana reha ehs kaho moooh bandh rakhe vich hi awaaz sunayi deh rahi a nidhan kuch chaba reha aghe ton dhiyaaan rakhna
Sir ye confirm Kar do k Punjabi zuban sansikrat to nikli hy ya Darawar tu?
In which book , by which author this word Maluha has been referred may I know please ?
Maluha was found in Mesopotamian texts
Dr. Sahib you give very detail and valuable information,however I have a question which is that if punjabi or Gurmukhi were taught, read or write in joint Punjab? , before partition and what happened, why it disappeared from Pakistani Punjab after partition? Although it’s spoken and even used in poetry. Thx
Punjabi Muslims poets used Shahmukhi script. Baba Farid, Shah Hussain, Sultan bahu, Bulleh Shah, Waris Shah, Ghulam Farid, Mian Mohammad Bakhs all used Shahmukhi script, not gurmukhi. So it made sense for Mulsims to use Shahmukhi.
@@anasriaz1567 what does this sjahmukhi look like , is it similar to Arabic / Urdu ?
@@ajeyklg Yep pretty much Urdu. Though Punjabi have some words/voices that Urdu doesn't have, so we can add some additional alphabets for those voices.
@@ajeyklg its the Arabic script with minor additions
Aoa.Tada Facebook page kis nam to ay??
Can you please give the name of the books mentioned during the talk? It was hard to decipher the authors and the book names. Thank you
Early Indians by Tony Joseph, Ancient India by D. D. Kosambi, Civilized Demons of Regveda by Malti Shendge
@@madnsg can you please provide your email address? I have one of my Sri Lankan friend. He is very interested in history.
Bilal Maqbool manzurejaz@yahoo.com
Early indians is a very detailed book👍
Dr Sahib, I need authentic information on Nizamudeen Aulia Chishti please, I’ve sent you a message on facebook as well, please check... Regards
RAM DA YUG TRETA SE. JO KE KRISHAN DE YUG TON PEHLAN SE . OH VE SAAVNLE RANG DA SE.
River bed flats is always fertile
I have to protest at the use of incorrect language in describing history.
You cannot use the terms India or hindustan because it implies an incorrect historical term. Historically it was a region, but now it refers to a country, you cannot use those terms to describe Pakistani history. We have to recognise ground realities, and apply correct terms. It is unfair and false.
You can use the term Indus region/alaka, or any such fair terms. The history belongs to the modern day ground realities.
There was no India or hindustan 5000 years ago. As Pakistani historians, it's your responsibility to create your own message, and not fall prey to intellectual laziness.
Half knowledge is dangerous
Vedlok
bas eh video wekha do loka nu te ous to baad poojho ... tu kon a hindu , musalman ya sikh je koe ehna cho kise ek da naam lave ta ..
Budh di pali develop hoke sanskirt bani
Deceitful assumptions.