@@MsThatstuff By "who and what" they meant you can choose which players and which permanents, but you have to do all the counters on those players/permanents
I don't think it necessarily would have mattered besides preventing one of Airball's card draws, possibly? But yeah, it was sad seeing him sac the bog, haha.
24:27 When you proliferate, you have to proliferate all of the counters on the chosen permanents or players, not just some of them, so for DSchultz to proliferate his experience counters, he had to also proliferate his poison counters. Also, it would proliferate Airball's experience counters too.
It's a may or choose effect. 701.27a To proliferate means to choose any number of permanents and/or players that have a counter, then give each one additional counter of each kind that permanent or player already has. *Edit* Boy I didn't understand the original comment, I'm with you now. It's a may and choose on targets but both poison and experience are on the player and should have been proliferated. Nice catch!
@@SchulzCubed Was confused about this for awhile in my own pod, our understanding is while you MAY choose the permanent or player, you cannot choose which counters on that permanent / player to proliferate. So if a creature had a +1/+1 AND a -1/-1 counter, choosing to proliferate it would leave it with two +1/+1 and two -1/-1. Can't seem to nitpick which counter you are proliferating.
@@NezNine Pretty much! Although +1/+1 counters and -1/-1 counters cancel each other out. If a creature has a +1/+1 counter and a slime counter and an indestructible counter then if you proliferate then you get 2 of each.
I was so confused at first at 12:30 when he said that the eiganjo was stopped by the sword, because lands are colourless after all, until I realized that the sword made the creature too big.
Ah right, the Minthara deck. The deck that's built around Minthara. The deck specifically designed to use Minthara, Minthara's deck... That Minthara deck?
Great game. Nice seeing Airball on stream once in a while. I should have suggested my mizzix deck for this one. Add even more poison and proliferate. lol
I don't know why but i've never seen a Kalemne deck perform well. I think its one of those commanders that works well in theory but never actually delivers.
I think it's less a question of the ability being blocked, and more a question of the +2/+2 from the sword taking Bloated Contaminator out of the 4 damage range from Eiganjo
u could've won veggie if u didnt make the deal. but i guess a longer game is better for content? idk...i would've just gone for the proliferate kill....but Goodgame.
God damn this ceaseless snooze alarm music. Please, if you are going to include it, just switch the track up every ten minutes or something. I am begging you, please. I can't watch these episodes where the same lofi song just drones on and on.
Interesting interaction, you can choose who and what to proliferate, but you must proliferate all types of counters on those permanents/players.
Not true you must proliferate all the counters on the player you do not get to choose
@@MsThatstuff By "who and what" they meant you can choose which players and which permanents, but you have to do all the counters on those players/permanents
Veggie why didn’t you proliferate your peatbog when you hit airball the first time :(
Was just about to comment this lol
My soul was in pain to see this!
I don't think it necessarily would have mattered besides preventing one of Airball's card draws, possibly? But yeah, it was sad seeing him sac the bog, haha.
It's so tilting seeing Vegi sack his Peat Bog the turn after he swumg with a proliferating creature!
Yes, it's really bad misplay. He could've used this land for so long!
It's the point of that land in the deck lol
I know right? I was so proud to see him use the first counter off peatbog to play a proliferator, then so sad to see him neglect his poor bog.
Loved that bowling champion from the 1980's. Mr. Peat Bog
yep, yikes
24:27 When you proliferate, you have to proliferate all of the counters on the chosen permanents or players, not just some of them, so for DSchultz to proliferate his experience counters, he had to also proliferate his poison counters. Also, it would proliferate Airball's experience counters too.
It's a may or choose effect.
701.27a To proliferate means to choose any number of permanents and/or players that have a counter, then give each one additional counter of each kind that permanent or player already has.
*Edit* Boy I didn't understand the original comment, I'm with you now. It's a may and choose on targets but both poison and experience are on the player and should have been proliferated. Nice catch!
@@SchulzCubed yeah, he chose each player, including himself. They would all get more experience and poison at the same time.
@@SchulzCubed Was confused about this for awhile in my own pod, our understanding is while you MAY choose the permanent or player, you cannot choose which counters on that permanent / player to proliferate. So if a creature had a +1/+1 AND a -1/-1 counter, choosing to proliferate it would leave it with two +1/+1 and two -1/-1. Can't seem to nitpick which counter you are proliferating.
@@NezNine Pretty much! Although +1/+1 counters and -1/-1 counters cancel each other out. If a creature has a +1/+1 counter and a slime counter and an indestructible counter then if you proliferate then you get 2 of each.
@@SchulzCubed I had to learn all the ins and outs of Proliferate for Atraxa, the first deck I built from scratch.
Look at that fancy top down camera! ALSO LETS GO ORZHOV!!!
Would be cool to see a...
Partner vs. Partner With vs. Choose a Background vs. Friends Forever game.
I really enjoy the titles you give your videos. Pretty dope stuff.
I was so confused at first at 12:30 when he said that the eiganjo was stopped by the sword, because lands are colourless after all, until I realized that the sword made the creature too big.
I adore this show and I can't quite put my finger on why. Maybe the vibes are just immaculate?
Ah right, the Minthara deck. The deck that's built around Minthara. The deck specifically designed to use Minthara, Minthara's deck... That Minthara deck?
Should of done Otharri, incredible experience counter commander
Love the ultimate guard mats. Honestly had better quality than dragonshield lately with ultimate guard sleeves
An Infect episode masquerading as an experience episode.
Great game. Nice seeing Airball on stream once in a while. I should have suggested my mizzix deck for this one. Add even more poison and proliferate. lol
Great game! Very fun to watch, experience counters are really undervalued imo
Nothing beats experience
Ezuri is my first commander deck and still sees play
You can't proliferate your exp without your poisen
Yall did airball dirty with those poison counters😂 kinda wish we got to see more of hes deck. Gg tho
cultivator collossus or cultivator of blades?
Veggie going out on his own terms :D
When you proliferate a player they gain 1 additional of all counters they have. You cannot pick and choose
I wish you all would do a homebrew episode.
Weehoo another episode ❤
4K Resolution!
Fun game, beautifully presented (your lighting is awesome!). The music is very pleasant but maybe a touch too loud.
Can we please get a Princess Bride cosplay edition with ZBexx
We for sure have Princess Bride on the books to record, but not sure we will be able to make cosplay happen. But we will try!
@@DeckedOutEDH y’all are awesome!
Hope you're feeling better NG.
I don't know why but i've never seen a Kalemne deck perform well. I think its one of those commanders that works well in theory but never actually delivers.
That's kind of how it felt in the seat. Juice not even close to worth the squeeze.
All hail Phyrexia!
Meren babyyyyyy
I dont think Eiganjo is stoped by the sword...
I think it's less a question of the ability being blocked, and more a question of the +2/+2 from the sword taking Bloated Contaminator out of the 4 damage range from Eiganjo
u could've won veggie if u didnt make the deal. but i guess a longer game is better for content? idk...i would've just gone for the proliferate kill....but Goodgame.
music too loud..
He looks like an asian Ezra Miller
Guys Britt's so amazing i love binge watching this
Another game another VW loss.. 😢
God damn this ceaseless snooze alarm music. Please, if you are going to include it, just switch the track up every ten minutes or something. I am begging you, please. I can't watch these episodes where the same lofi song just drones on and on.
I love your channel but i feel theres too much of an emphasis on a theme of the day instead people just bringing a deck they like or just made.
Agree everything is samey
i really love your videos but i dislike this, 2 of the players didnt even cast their commanders.
Playing infect in commander... bye.