Which is the Best 3D-Printed Dungeon?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 тра 2020
  • I compare these five different dungeon systems to see which one is the best!
    Patreon: / gaminggeekgiveaway
    Open Forge: www.thingiverse.com/devonjone...
    DragonLock: www.fatdragongames.com/fdgfile...
    Printable Scenery: www.printablescenery.com/prod...
    True Tiles: www.heroshoard.com/true-tiles
    The Dragon's Rest: dragons.rest/collections/patreon
    Dragon's Rest Patreon Page: / thedragonsrest
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 196

  • @RetroMaticGamer
    @RetroMaticGamer 3 місяці тому +6

    Printing in black so you don't worry about scratching the paint is easily alleviated by just spraying your painted terrain with a clear coat when you're done painting them. Use gloss to make dank dungeons look wet, matte to keep wood buildings looking dry and cozy. I've been doing that to minis and terrain for decades, absolutely beat the hell out of them and never a single scratch.

    • @Uncle-Jay
      @Uncle-Jay 3 місяці тому

      I just throw a coat of mod podge on everything I finish.

  • @nobody342
    @nobody342 2 роки тому +24

    the price of magnets adds up, BUT... in my mind, its what makes having dungeon tiles worthwhile. Having to clip together beforehand makes the tiles not so fun, but with Magnets, they are great. and what he says about low walls is correct. I have gone mostly thingiverse, openlock with magnets.

  • @Bikkusu
    @Bikkusu 4 роки тому +34

    The low walls of the True Tiles system is meant to allow for other clip on wall pieces that the creator has tutorials on how to build. Worth checking out what clip-on doodads he has created on his channel.

    • @-Ravenscroft-
      @-Ravenscroft- 3 роки тому +3

      Having followed the creator for a long time, I'm more likely to be on-board with True Tiles, knowing the design philosophy behind it. I need to see if TT has options for tall walls, though, for the occasional multi-level setup.

  • @waza987
    @waza987 4 роки тому +34

    The reason for the dragonlock/rampage full height walls of 2 inches is to allow for multi level setups. I guess not so much for dungeons but if doing buildings, maybe a castle or watchtower you can build each level, stack them and add or remove as you move through them.

    • @tsukasaoftheazuresky
      @tsukasaoftheazuresky 8 місяців тому +3

      I use foam dividers for extra support, and the last campaign that I did had a 5 tier dungeon where I could peel away the layers as the party got further in. For lore, they received a map of the first level, and subsequent maps were either found, or I used a foam sheet to hide areas they hadn't mapped yet.

    • @tradtke101
      @tradtke101 5 місяців тому

      ​@@tsukasaoftheazureskythats dope yo

  • @shaneflickinger
    @shaneflickinger 4 роки тому +16

    Wow! A very densely packed video with a ton of info on these sets. Thanks so much for sharing to help your fellow gamers make informed decisions!

  • @mrfordf3508
    @mrfordf3508 4 роки тому +8

    Thanks for the video. I tested many of the systems you discussed. For me, the most versatile system is true tiles by far. The low walls allow everyone around the table to see the board. The multitude of clips makes for great doors, double doors, traps, secret doors, etc. The half clip magnetic barrel system is really easy to put together and much less expensive than the ball magnets. Storage is easier as well. The two most common tiles are the no wall and single wall. The single wall tiles lay face to face for easy storage. I have printed over 100 tiles and they store easily and neatly in small amazon shipping boxes.

  • @chalkboy8
    @chalkboy8 4 роки тому +1

    Great vid! Awesome recommendations!!! I like your previous vid about mounting the tiles onto the magnetic bases.

  • @veerkillerx
    @veerkillerx 2 роки тому +4

    I love that the test you used was Hero Quest. Such an awesome and nestalgic game.

  • @sotho9789
    @sotho9789 4 роки тому +8

    Thank you for leading me to Dragon´s Rest, great tiles, large amount of shapes for a very, very fair price, exactly what I was looking for.

  • @JacopoSkydweller
    @JacopoSkydweller 10 місяців тому +6

    One of the bonuses of truetiles is the 1.25" grid makes it so your minis are less tightly packed and easier to move. Most minis don't stay over top of their 1"x1" base, they're usually sticking cloaks or weapons over the edges in 1 or more directions.

    • @tradtke101
      @tradtke101 5 місяців тому

      I don't know why people don't use 1.25"... if you're spending all this time and money for the best dungeon tiles possible, why do you want to deal with pieces always knocking in to each other and getting tangled up?
      And you cant even see the tiles that are occupied with 1".
      Seems like a total no-brainer to me but idk

  • @jesternario
    @jesternario 2 роки тому +4

    Wyloch, the creator of True Tiles, based it on his method for homemade dungeon tiles. He has a large selection of videos about making tiles and terrain. The very first video gives his philosophy and either that or the second gives exact measurements for what he is working with. The 3D printed tile line he made is all based on that earlier design.

  • @Sleeper_6875
    @Sleeper_6875 2 роки тому

    Such a great, helpful video. I will absolutely be using openforge to print terrain for my DM

  • @patrickgrey5322
    @patrickgrey5322 4 роки тому +1

    Mystic Realms has a tile system using the open lock connector. What makes the system great in my opinion is that the tile top connects to the base via press fit. It means that you only need to print a certain number of bases but can have as many different tops as you want. Currently there is not much variety though. I’ve been toying around with using his tile tops on Dragon Rests bases to get the best of both worlds

  • @phillipwills8686
    @phillipwills8686 10 місяців тому

    Love the video. Been playing D&D for 41 years??? Just missed its debut. I teach everyone that plays with my group how to draw out your own dungeons and I've played with groups all over the world. I have been a player in a 200 player adventure as well as having 10+ ppl playing more times than I can count. I'm new to 3d printing so this helps with options. as one of my best dungeon floors has 711 rooms in it, no hallways, seeing the different tiles side by side helps me decide what might work for me. Sadly I'm thinking I might have to make my own system. The small wall debate is kind of funny to me, as for some reason D&D players love to argue line of sight and believe it or not full walls cut way down on that. Great vid, love your back ground in it.

  • @the_doc_webb
    @the_doc_webb 2 роки тому +5

    This video was HUGELY helpful - exactly the sort of info I was trying to find out. Thanks so much!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      Glad it was helpful!

    • @the_doc_webb
      @the_doc_webb 2 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 If I may ask: does Dragon's Rest make non-stone walls, such as tavern walls or that sort of thing? I couldn't tell from their website. I'm sure you're busy, so no worries if you don't have a chance to respond. Thanks again so much for the great videos!

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому +1

      @@the_doc_webb They don't have non-stone walls, although Ian did just release a bunch more variety with the stone walls. I created a video though of how you can use any other 3D printed wall that you like and adapt it for Dragon's Rest: ua-cam.com/video/h2Ept7pH2bY/v-deo.html

    • @the_doc_webb
      @the_doc_webb 2 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thank you again! I really appreciate the time and effort you’ve put into this - checking out that video now!

  • @StephenGrosHouston
    @StephenGrosHouston 3 роки тому

    Great video! This really helped me a lot with my decision making. I primarily build in Hirst Arts, but I'm looking to get into 3d printing.

  • @Mayouri
    @Mayouri Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the great video. It really helpt me in deciding on a dungeon system I want to go with in my Home Game of D&D. I will give Drangons Rest a try.

  • @worlds-in-conflict
    @worlds-in-conflict 2 роки тому

    Terrific comparison thank you very much! Obviously I get that the comparison was printable tiles but the Warlock Tiles by WizKids (in my opinion) do a great job of addressing the problem of wall footprints. They use Openlock style walls for exterior walls but have thinner walls on metal tabs that fit between floor sections for interior walls.

  • @CaptainHat12
    @CaptainHat12 4 роки тому +8

    OpenForge does have a spacer floor piece, it's the AS

  • @joaobabler1584
    @joaobabler1584 3 роки тому +1

    Hi man, I'm from Brazil, first time on your channel and I have to thank you a LOT......I'm trying to make my Hero Quest board and I was really lost until this video. Thanks, Great channel.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      I'm glad that my video helped you! Make sure to see my video on the HeroQuest build: ua-cam.com/video/zbzPkeEMrV0/v-deo.html Also, I am going to make a third follow-up video in about two weeks with some further suggestions (Dragon's Rest came out with an easier to print version that I am recommending).

    • @joaobabler1584
      @joaobabler1584 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 thanks bro

  • @DiceandDungeons
    @DiceandDungeons 2 роки тому

    Love Devon Jones and Open Forge!!!! We make and paint them on our channel. Great fun and quality from Devon.

  • @mathewcoppola8622
    @mathewcoppola8622 4 роки тому +1

    Great video. I've been watching a bunch of your scenery painting vids lately, also very good.
    I am getting my first printer in August and will start printing dungeon tiles as soon as I can in hopes of having a good stock built up by the time my D&D group can start meeting face to face again.
    I also backed a Building Creation Kickstarter (Townbuilder) so that I can start designing and then printing my own buildings.
    Pretty excited to get started.

  • @richie2685
    @richie2685 Рік тому +1

    Great video! I just subscribed to your channel after finding the table build video. Considering time and cost, would you say 3D printing these is worth it compared to Hirst Arts molds? That’s my current options.

  • @jetsers
    @jetsers 3 роки тому

    I just ordered a 3d printer like 2 hours ago. Then found your video. Very excited!

  • @MrBrad9
    @MrBrad9 3 роки тому +2

    Printable scenery with low walls (they have a variety of walls and floor styles. Sewer, crypt, necro, wood, gothic etc....) a bit more pricey but well worth it.

  • @deanm375
    @deanm375 3 роки тому +1

    the heroquest map was created during a time when the square grids were considered 10' across not 5'. so you need to take that into consideration with your maps. Basically double the needed squares.

  • @duckforceone
    @duckforceone 4 роки тому +4

    it looks like the dragons rest dungeon can also be converted to normal full tiles. going to print some out and give it a try... i'd rather add the extra movement spaces, than having half tiles..

  • @dabunnisher29
    @dabunnisher29 5 місяців тому

    Great video and so informative. Got me subscribed and liked.

  • @igordekiparis
    @igordekiparis 4 роки тому

    Great video, thank you! Small question - how strong is the magnetic linkage? Is it possible to lift the assembled 8x8 dungeon?

  • @ProfessorCharlesPorterfield
    @ProfessorCharlesPorterfield 4 роки тому

    A very detailed breakdown. Thank you.

  • @inaudableyeh
    @inaudableyeh 7 місяців тому +1

    Would love an updated video including some of the new options out there, like Dungeon Blocks and the new system from dragons rest probably others out there I'm unaware of.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  7 місяців тому

      Since this video, I still like Dragon's Rest the best, although I have a full set of Dungeon Blocks. Dragon's Rest came out with their own block system too. Are there others that you know of?

  • @aarondawkins9845
    @aarondawkins9845 4 роки тому

    Great content. Really appreciate you taking the time to provide your feedback and opinion.

  • @TheMerrox
    @TheMerrox Рік тому

    @Gaminggeek which dungeon tiles would be quickest to print of those you showed here or any that you found since then? I'm running a game next week and have to print me a big "end boss room".

  • @Quijanos1
    @Quijanos1 3 роки тому

    Superlative analysis. It shows the attentiveness to detail necessary to engineering a flawless game.

  • @exodous02
    @exodous02 3 роки тому +1

    I remember just giving up on the HQ board when I was a kid because I started to buy miniatures that were 4 bases together and they couldn't even fit on the board.

  • @RocktCityTim
    @RocktCityTim Рік тому

    Great info, but time for an update for new comers in 2023 👶. That beep at 16:02 had me checking my Wash and Cure station. Had to play it a second time to make sure it was in the video!
    As an "olde tyme" DM (starting circa 1978 with Traveller), I never used game maps as gospel, but rather as design guidance. Since we were all playing physically together, and by the same settings, it always worked. But, we did use things like corrugated box walls with magic marker scenery to create the "environment".

  • @joshuapicaro8726
    @joshuapicaro8726 3 роки тому +1

    You inspired me to go with Dragon Rest. The beige and grey looks awesome. Could you please share the material you used? Also, is the did you paint the floor?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I have a painting tutorial in this video: ua-cam.com/video/zbzPkeEMrV0/v-deo.html

  • @alecconn4123
    @alecconn4123 Рік тому +1

    I'm slightly confused with Devon Jone's open forge system. I get that you print the top and the bottom separate and use magnets to connect tiles, is the only way to connect the top and bottom of the tile with glue?

  • @lars-arlewallin3959
    @lars-arlewallin3959 2 роки тому +1

    Where did you get the files for the furniture shown at 34:59? I've been searching for "Wizard's Store" put can't seem to find the exact set. Great video!

    • @jerkchickenblog
      @jerkchickenblog 2 роки тому

      i think i saw some similar from loot studios, a set of mage room type stuff

  • @Prototheca
    @Prototheca 2 роки тому

    What strength magnets did you need for the Dragons Rest tiles? N35, N40?

  • @TheStonehammerFiles
    @TheStonehammerFiles 7 місяців тому

    I'm going with the openforge but I will create walls with the 1x whatever sized tiles so I can put the walls in the middle of said tiles. so that there is only a quarter inch on either side of the wall.

  • @connortremeer1966
    @connortremeer1966 3 роки тому +3

    Devon John's tiles are OP in my eyes. Love em so much

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +2

      Yeah, especially since they are free! I wish he had a better categorized system since there are so many files.

    • @connortremeer1966
      @connortremeer1966 3 роки тому +3

      @@gaminggeek241 yes I agree it would make things easier if they were grouped based on room types like taverns bits and dongeoun bits. But that's just the website as far as I know.

    • @brandielee7971
      @brandielee7971 3 роки тому

      @@connortremeer1966 agreed. Ive been slowly downloading then and carefully organizing them

    • @terixa
      @terixa 3 роки тому

      @@brandielee7971 You should share those libraries!

    • @soulcatcher521
      @soulcatcher521 3 роки тому +4

      @@gaminggeek241 Working on it

  • @WouterLievens
    @WouterLievens 4 роки тому

    Are there any collections of D&D style maps which do account for the extra half tile width walls? I have a hefty OpenLock collection but I'm having trouble finding premade dungeon maps for inspiration that don't have this "walls as thick as paper" problem.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому +1

      I don't know of any publishers that specifically make maps that take the wider walls into account. I've played mostly the published D&D modules for 5th edition and just fudged the map and added more tiles to accommodate the walls. Like I mentioned in the video, it really doesn't matter for D&D since it isn't super tactical. I've found as long as you approximate the room size, you are fine.

  • @danielf.6162
    @danielf.6162 4 роки тому +1

    Dungeonworks by Game Decor is my personal fav! None of the walls are attached so you don't need to print out a bunch of different pieces since it is very modular

    • @KevinRank
      @KevinRank 4 роки тому

      I was going to mention this one as well.

  • @salsa2k
    @salsa2k 3 роки тому

    Hey, thanks for the video... I'm kind of new using my 3d printer (ender 3 v2), and I bought the dragonclick dungeon set... but, when I print the model, looks small (really small), defiantly is not the same size as yours. Do you know what I'm doing wrong?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Can you measure one of the squares? It should be close to 1" on one side (or about 25mm). Just one of the squares, not the set of 4.

  • @piroksenlol
    @piroksenlol 4 роки тому

    Nice video! Thanks a lot for all this information. Can Dragons Rest in any way be combined with printable scenery? I like Dragons Rest, but I'd love to have some cavern and ship (I.e. wooden) walls too.. a bit concerned about the scale and compatibility..

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому

      Absolutely. If you watch this video, I show you how to adapt other system walls to Dragon's Rest: ua-cam.com/video/h2Ept7pH2bY/v-deo.html

    • @piroksenlol
      @piroksenlol 4 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thanks a lot!

  • @AllBrainsNoSoul
    @AllBrainsNoSoul 4 роки тому

    What PLA is being used?

  • @SvyatoyVitaliy
    @SvyatoyVitaliy 10 місяців тому

    It would be enough to make the tiles 1.25" wide, the walls 0.25" wide, and offset the walls 0.125" outside the tile. At the same time, leave 0.125 inches flat around each tile. Then the walls would be located half on one, half on an adjacent tile. It would be possible to build even a narrow corridor one inch wide, with walls on both sides.

  • @colinmelchior
    @colinmelchior 2 роки тому

    Not sure why none of them have magnetic connectors on top in the intersection between squares. Seems like the easy spot to connect internal walls. Make the squares slightly bigger and centre the walls on them 1/2" thick walls...1-1/4" squares, etc. Could centre magnetic columns on them too. Then outer walls that magnetize to the outside squares. Easy.
    Could make adjustable buildings and roofs too.

  • @stephenkane304
    @stephenkane304 4 роки тому

    Can you suggest where to purchase the magnetic balls needed for the Dragon Rest tiles?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому +1

      If you are in the US, this is a good vendor: tinyurl.com/ya4585wx I had bad luck with a Chinese supplier that never arrived.

  • @pirtrom11
    @pirtrom11 4 роки тому

    Hi just wanted to know have you modified the Dragons rest walls I see you have L shaped walls and when you lifted one up the magnets were only on one side of the L.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому

      Yes, when I combined the two walls to make the corner, you can't fit a clip in the corner where the walls meet. So I put magnets in both the far ends. Even though only one magnet is connecting to the floor, it is still strong enough to hold the piece there.

  • @Shadi109
    @Shadi109 4 роки тому

    Great vid! Couldn't you just print the other lines a higher percent to achieve the 1.5" grid?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому +1

      Yes, in the video I show the Printable Scenery stuff printed at 125% to create 1.25" squares. The bigger issue is dealing with the wall spaces.

  • @soulside
    @soulside 4 роки тому

    Have you had a chance to play test the Wizkids Warlock tiles? I don’t own a 3D printer and was hoping their system would also be Hero Quest compatible.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому +2

      No, I haven't. But I do know that Warlock doesn't have single square pieces which is a requirement if you want to recreate the HeroQuest board exactly. Otherwise, I've seen other boards that use the 2x2 base systems and have fudged a little to adapt to HeroQuest. Also, check out Dungeons and Lasers as a cheaper option: ua-cam.com/video/aqly57YzNT8/v-deo.html

  • @itismee18
    @itismee18 2 роки тому +1

    Do you know Dungeon Blox? May be another good option if you are looking for a printable dungeon building system.

  • @davethemanstanley
    @davethemanstanley 3 роки тому

    I'm not very familiar with how Patreon works. If I sign up for one month of the dragonsrest Patreon, do I get access to all their dungeon tile stl files? Is that how I can get all their dungeon files or is there another way?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      Typically most Patreon accounts limit when you can get the files but with Dragon's Rest, you gain access to all the files which you can download onto your computer. Ian should really charge more because $6 is a steal for all those files, which is why I encourage patrons to support him for a couple months and not just one.

  • @brandonthomas502
    @brandonthomas502 3 роки тому

    where did you find the furniture you printed. You say wizards but im not finding it. Looks AWESOME

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      It's the in 003 Guild of Understanding folder, assuming you are a Dragon's Rest patron.

  • @ryankubryn763
    @ryankubryn763 Рік тому

    What about an update video with all the sets that have come up since? Kraken, Dungeonlab etc..

  • @jinlau3395
    @jinlau3395 3 роки тому

    what is the infill percentage and layering height for open forge printing?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Everyone has their own preferences but my go-to settings are 10% infill at .2mm height.

  • @CowallTV
    @CowallTV 3 роки тому

    So is there anywhere we can see your settings for the “the dragons rest” printing? Mine doesnt look nearly as good as yours 😊

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I print at .2mm height on both my Prusa and Ender 5 to get those results. Everything else is stock settings. Hope that helps!

    • @CowallTV
      @CowallTV 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Ah cool! Mabye its just Because of the painting then, because i print at 0.2mm also 😊

  • @xavierdoesntmatter
    @xavierdoesntmatter 8 місяців тому

    Anyone know if Dragons Rest dungeon is still available? I don't see it in their shop and patreon simply says you get a discount in the shop.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  8 місяців тому

      Yes, it's available. When you become a patreon supporter, you use the code to access the Dropbox files.

    • @xavierdoesntmatter
      @xavierdoesntmatter 8 місяців тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thanks, just trying to find some quality module tiles and it seems like the best for what I'm desiring.

  • @Eman-qv4kv
    @Eman-qv4kv 3 роки тому

    ive had issues with the true tiles warping, do you have any suggestion on why that would be? Im using water washable elegoo resin on a eleggo mars 2 pro

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      You mean warping after or during the print? If after, you might want to add some layers to the tile. If you don't know how to do that, watch my video on how to use Microsoft 3D Builder to modify STL files.

    • @Eman-qv4kv
      @Eman-qv4kv 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 would you be able link that video or the playlist its in i'm having trouble finding it

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      @@Eman-qv4kv Yup, ua-cam.com/video/h2Ept7pH2bY/v-deo.html

  • @williammcdowell3718
    @williammcdowell3718 4 роки тому

    I can to the same conclusions you did with TrueTiles being the best for a HeroQuest board. I modified the clips that come with it to work with clip on walls. I have videos showing how it works.
    I got into 3D printing after watching your videos, and thats what lead to the Heroquest 3D board project I did.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому

      Do you have any photos/video of your project? I would love to see it!

    • @williammcdowell3718
      @williammcdowell3718 4 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 ua-cam.com/video/B0C5LTDBW-E/v-deo.html

    • @chrisesposito5530
      @chrisesposito5530 4 роки тому

      Have you checked out the new Wizkids Warlock tiles with the walls that slide in between the tiles?

    • @tinaprice4948
      @tinaprice4948 3 роки тому +1

      I also went with the True Tiles and love them. If you are a DM that uses premade campaigns then this is the best to recreate maps exactly, if you are a DM that makes up your own dungeons than choose the tiles you like the most because it wont matter :)

  • @miguelangelpicazo7130
    @miguelangelpicazo7130 3 роки тому

    hi, one question, is it possible to magnetize the pieces of hirst arts? thanks

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      It is possible and I've done it but you have to place the magnets into the plaster while it is still wet. You also have to pay attention to polarity whereas with ball magnets, you don't need to worry about it since they swivel in place.

    • @miguelangelpicazo7130
      @miguelangelpicazo7130 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 many thanks

  • @LeonardoLacchini
    @LeonardoLacchini 2 роки тому

    what do you think about terrain tinker / openlock tiles ?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому +1

      I've never used it but the concept seems cool. The ability to create your layout and print exactly what you need is a good concept. I still like how Dragon Rest's 1.5" tile is the most versatile with the walls.

  • @robbie_g8308
    @robbie_g8308 3 роки тому

    What is the average time to print a wall or floor section?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      I usually print a dozen walls at the same time and it takes about 8 hours on my Prusa MK3S printing at .2mm height and with 10% infill. Your mileage will vary based on your printer, settings, etc.

  • @chrisesposito5530
    @chrisesposito5530 4 роки тому

    Great video! Which under-$1,000 3D printer would you recommend for printing great quality dungeon terrain?

    • @jaradsneed22
      @jaradsneed22 4 роки тому

      I recommend the Prusa.

    • @bachconneshon7809
      @bachconneshon7809 3 роки тому

      FlashForge 3D Printer Creator Pro

    • @cristiaolson7327
      @cristiaolson7327 3 роки тому

      I know this is an old post, but for the benefit of new viewers: I actually get pretty good terrain quality out of my regular Creality Ender 3. You just have to play with the settings a little in the slicer program. The Ender 3 has a z-axis that is based on a 0.8 rotation step, so keeping your layers as either multiples of 0.8 or of the half-step of 0.4 actually helps because it's easier for the machine to achieve accurate z-motion.
      I found 0.8 layer height gives really clean detail on most terrain, but you can go to 0.4 layer height for small stuff. For tiles and walls though I usually print at a 1.6 layer height or 2.0 layer height for speed, otherwise it takes forever to print, and simple shapes with limited detail don't need the same level of layer control to look decent after painting. On items with very straight surfaces, I will even go to 2.4 layer height when churning out big things like castle walls or building frames.
      Very detailed scatter that is tiny or thin, like candelabras, goes on my Photon though, because while FDM is a lot cheaper to print and more durable if dropped in a storage bin, you just can't quite achieve the same ultrafine details as you can get in resin. If you watch for sales, you can get a Photon Zero for about $100. It's has a pretty small build plate, especially compared to my Ender 3, but does a super job on minis and those itty bitty scatter pieces.

  • @Battlelurker
    @Battlelurker 4 роки тому

    you mentioned a clip adapter for openlock and dragons rest. I cant find it. Does anyone know where to find it?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  4 роки тому

      There isn't a clip that has Openlock on one side and Dragon's Rest on the other. It would be possible though to create your own--check out my tutorial on how to use Microsoft 3D Builder, a free program that lets you modify and create STL files.

    • @Battlelurker
      @Battlelurker 4 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thanks. I misunderstood you then. Thanks for the tip

    • @cristiaolson7327
      @cristiaolson7327 3 роки тому

      It does exist. I found it on thingiverse, and I'm pretty sure Fat Dragon Games actually released a version too to help folks integrate new purchases from their Dragonlock sets into existing tile collections. I think Devon Jones, the guy behind Openlock 2.0, also has a version.

  • @snactimusmaximus
    @snactimusmaximus 4 місяці тому

    My family was watching this, and wondering why there was that most replayed hill towards the end, lol. Sounds like you got hit in the groin at some point there.

  • @dirkvandereyken2312
    @dirkvandereyken2312 2 роки тому

    One other thing that's really important to me: which of these is fully compatible with Dwarven Forge? It's still THE terrain standard for people with a little less time on their hands who want great scenery, but it's very expensive, so adding to it with 3D-printed scenery always is a great option.

    • @mereakfirmaxe-1988
      @mereakfirmaxe-1988 Рік тому +1

      Does anyone know the answer to Driks question? I would like to know as well.

  • @tonyosborne666
    @tonyosborne666 3 роки тому

    Does anyone have the site for the "Wizards" scenery items please? (Bookcases, etc)

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      You mean at the 6:20 mark of the video? That is part of Dragon's Rest patreon rewards - "Adventurer." Link in the descriptions.

    • @tonyosborne666
      @tonyosborne666 3 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Brilliant - Thank you. I've paid for Patreon, but failed to spot them. Thanks for the heads-up :) (Edit: Doh - Just looked in the 'GoU' section and found all the desks, bookcases etc - I need to learn to look.)

  • @Schyzofrenic87
    @Schyzofrenic87 8 місяців тому

    took me way to long to realise the sound in the background was a 3D printer working and not morse code....

  • @njco78
    @njco78 Рік тому

    For something like League of Dungoneers I would like to print Printable Scenery apart from the free sample what do you suggest I should purchase? Also is there a video on how to use magnets with Printable Scenary. Thanks

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому +1

      Really depends on what you want out of the options from Printable Scenery--do you want half-height walls or full? Curved walls? Styles? Yes, you can magnetize the clip but it requires two barrel magnets into each clip which will require a LOT of work. I would opt to just use the clips at that point, or only magnetize some of them. I would also meld pieces together so the tiles match with Dungeoneers, that way you are reducing the number of clips you need to use.

    • @njco78
      @njco78 Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 ok so what I might do then is start printing the starter set. I guess I can then re print just tiles and Walls to extend the footprint as ai wish. As you say I will then use mostly clips and magnetise some parts. I also took a look and Dragon Rest but just didn’t find any help guides to get started. Maybe I need to sign up first to get further access. Thanks for your help

    • @njco78
      @njco78 Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 I just seen your review of Dungeoneers and I have picked the tile set of Kraken Studios. Would be great if you can create a tutorial of which tiles you suggest to print for Dungeoneers . Thank you

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому

      @@njco78 Yeah, if you look at my video showcasing the Kraken tiles, you can see the ones I printed out to start off. Since the dungeon is randomly generated, if you draw a section you don't have, just redraw until you do and slowly build up your set. I would suggest starting off with printing 3 of each of the base rooms and hallways and then go from there.

    • @njco78
      @njco78 Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 I think the tricky part here is the Objectiver room 12x6 and the 6x6. I tried looking in the customer room files but I cannot see how these pieces could help.
      For now I am doing Hallways 2x6 and a few 4x4 rooms which are available

  • @brushhammerdice4438
    @brushhammerdice4438 3 роки тому

    should i still use black pla even if i vanished the printed tiles?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому +1

      No, you don't have to use black, especially if you have a coat of varnish to protect the paint.

  • @TheTheronal
    @TheTheronal 2 роки тому

    you should really check the smoke alarm! lol

  • @abelkok2391
    @abelkok2391 2 роки тому

    Just wondering how much will it cost to print the Heroquest board (partial magnetised will do) Im thinking of investing in a 3D printer u c.... but need advise on the cost before diving in. Thanks for such a GREAT GREAT GREAT GGG channel! :)

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      If you watch Part 3 of my HeroQuest video, I share all the options for printing the board, from the cheapest to most expensive. My board cost about $300 to make, fully magnetized. Half of that was magnets.

    • @abelkok2391
      @abelkok2391 2 роки тому

      @@gaminggeek241 USD right? just wanna get the estimate correct. :P

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      @@abelkok2391 Yes, USD.

    • @abelkok2391
      @abelkok2391 2 роки тому

      looks quite COOL

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      @@abelkok2391 Your other comment with the Blitz Bowl board didn't post for some reason. I looked at Myth and Goal but passed because I feel like I don't need another football game. And I can't use my Blitz Bowl board with the game since the field is different--otherwise, I probably would have backed it.

  • @twincast2005
    @twincast2005 3 роки тому

    Not seeing Game Decor InfinityLock Dungeonworks in this video saddens me. On the flip side, I hadn't heard of Dragon's Rest before. Decisions, decisions.

  • @lidarman2
    @lidarman2 2 роки тому

    Have you tried to print the tru-tiles with a larger 'Z' value to bring those walls up? I feel like they are also kinda bland. Obviously painting and dry brushing can make them look better.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      No I haven't tried that although you propose a good solution. I found the tiles that work for me so no use for me to mod the Tru-Tiles.

  • @SamBalducci
    @SamBalducci 4 роки тому

    I know this comment is late. But does anyone make a multi-level dungeon? I want to use it to make a shelf to display my miniatures and I want it to look like the cut out of castle or dungeon.

  • @Nightscape_
    @Nightscape_ Рік тому

    Is The Dragon's Rest still the best after all these years? I just got into printing and was wondering if there are others that are better now.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому +1

      I think so because it is super flexible and for $9, one of the cheapest options for a ridiculous amount of files. I like how you can configure any room and print it as one to lessen setup time. I just did a video on Dungeon Blocks, which is also a good system but takes a lot more filament to print and is harder to customize for fast setup.

    • @Nightscape_
      @Nightscape_ Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 Thanks for the info! I think I will go with Dragon's Rest then. I only have a Photon Mono 2 resin printer. I am going to be printing out dungeon tiles for months!

  • @recowabunga7200
    @recowabunga7200 4 роки тому +1

    open forge is free. You got me right there.

  • @2Bachlors1house
    @2Bachlors1house 3 роки тому

    why not just get the stl files then pull them in to a program to change them back in to a step file or other file type that you can edit and make more types of tiles with corners? Also too open forge has a github that has the master file where it has everything in it.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yep, I posted this video afterwards showing how to edit files easily: ua-cam.com/video/h2Ept7pH2bY/v-deo.html

  • @philippeimbs1864
    @philippeimbs1864 2 роки тому

    and now Kraken 3D Studio Dungeon Tiles (KSD) les modular than dragon'rest but with a lot of charm, combine large tiles and low wall but with something more evocating than TrueTile

  • @AbyssallAberrant
    @AbyssallAberrant 2 роки тому

    I didn't really have time to watch the whole vid, but does he mention what printer he uses?

  • @davidelfpunsher50
    @davidelfpunsher50 3 роки тому

    Hi. Very good video, many thanks for sharing this. Cheers from France

  • @Munkman
    @Munkman Рік тому

    so... there was a whole lot of words just for me to learn to just make sure to compensate for the extra tile space

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому

      My recommendation is to avoid needing to compensate for the space which is why I suggested Dragon's Rest.

    • @Munkman
      @Munkman Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 I get that. But I find if you find a tile set you like than it is easy enough to just compensate, but thank you for bringing this issue to our attention.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому

      @@Munkman Definitely! What is your favorite set so far?

    • @Munkman
      @Munkman Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 I'm trying to design my own :)

  • @omegaomtv
    @omegaomtv 2 роки тому +3

    Be nice if all the creators of dungeon maps, just made the walls the same thickness as a floor space to begin with. What I do is usually redraw the map to do this, but it is time consuming.

  • @DerekMurawsky
    @DerekMurawsky 5 місяців тому

    So three years later, what would you change? How would you get started in 2024?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  5 місяців тому +1

      Dragon's Rest is still my favorite but I also like Dungeon Blocks too.

  • @JacobOphir
    @JacobOphir 3 місяці тому

    It’s unrealistic for walls to be that thin, so you deal with the realism of having the thickness of walls or deal with play mats

  • @LysolPionex
    @LysolPionex 2 роки тому

    What is the purpose of these sets? D&D?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      D&D, HeroQuest, Middara, Descent--basically any dungeon crawler.

  • @AbyssallAberrant
    @AbyssallAberrant 2 роки тому

    Another method is dropping the grid system and turning movement and ranges to measured distances and using facing rules. When it comes to using physical terrain you're never going to get a 1 for 1 from the maps in the books.

  • @benjaminnoble9565
    @benjaminnoble9565 6 місяців тому

    Do you think this video is still all true today? Or has another tile system came out that you like more?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  5 місяців тому +1

      The only one I would add to this list is Dungeon Blocks, which I've made a few videos about. But my favorite is still Dragon's Rest because of the sheer number of options and how cheap it is compared to Dungeon Blocks.

    • @benjaminnoble9565
      @benjaminnoble9565 5 місяців тому

      @gaminggeek241 awesome thank you! Love all your videos!

  • @jefffisher1297
    @jefffisher1297 11 місяців тому

    Who says you need to use a grid, the average gamer can tell what 6 inches is and if they can't get a 6 inch pencil.

  • @firefishable
    @firefishable 2 роки тому

    On the whole I agree, but OpenForge has long since muscled up and said goodbye to the ugly brick monotony. Maybe it's time for a reconsideration?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  2 роки тому

      I haven't looked at their stuff in a while--did they make a lot stylistic of changes?

  • @Nishe77
    @Nishe77 3 роки тому

    dungeons and lazer ?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      That's a great option if you don't have a 3D printer. I know they are going to have another Kickstarter next month.

  • @sopi2
    @sopi2 3 роки тому

    So basically, if you print Open Forge in 125% it is pretty much the best of all?

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  3 роки тому

      Yes, that is a good option since it allows for more space for miniatures.

  • @mmkm78aaa
    @mmkm78aaa 4 роки тому +1

    OpenForge seems cool but it's a real mess. The "tutorial" is so badly written it just complicate things, after 1 hour I'm still not sure what i should print between 25 different combination of connection styles and magnets.

  • @ericcxxxx
    @ericcxxxx Рік тому

    your over thinking it.
    tiles first than wall. wall are not important tiles are.

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому

      Then at that point, you might as well use cardboard tiles or a digital map and forego 3D printing all together. The whole point of a 3D map is the walls. That's why I don't like the True Tiles system--not enough wall. But different strokes for different folks.

    • @ericcxxxx
      @ericcxxxx Рік тому

      @@gaminggeek241 luck for me, i have tinkercad, so i can fix thing for me

  • @dirkvandereyken2312
    @dirkvandereyken2312 2 роки тому

    Great video, but I do feel you're putting a little too much emphasis on measure-by-square systems like 'D&D'. I think the 'D&D' Level-based system is one of the most flawed rules systems out there, there's way better available - from 'RuneQuest: Glorantha' to 'HârnMaster', 'HERO System/Fantasy Hero', 'GURPS', 'Battlelords of the 23rd Century', 'Mutants & Masterminds' and so many other RPGs. Most of them allow you to measure by inch. Once you pull out a ruler, squares that measure more than the standard 1" become a problem...

  • @RetroMaticGamer
    @RetroMaticGamer 3 місяці тому +1

    Dude. The tile-size of a 3D-printable dungeon tile set is an irrelevant topic of discussion. You can easily re-size anything in your slicer before printing. so if we want OpenLock tiles to be 1.25" across, or 1.5" or 2" or whatever, we can adjust that in seconds. That literally defeats any concern of wall tiles not leaving enough room on the space.

  • @Schwift3D
    @Schwift3D Рік тому

    sure you might not see this, but im having a really hard time flinding the clips for the slim tiles... any suggestions on where it might be? you'd think it would just be included with the slim tiles EDIT- found them on myminifactory. looked everywhere in the paid files and couldn't find them anywhere

    • @gaminggeek241
      @gaminggeek241  Рік тому

      I can't remember the name of the folder, but all of the clips are together. I'll have to wait until I get home to check the name of it.