@@markieffmorris9263 first of all it's not an analysis. It's a fact. Most of the time people just want to go home. They're not robots they're just humans. And we all know how humans are lol. 😅 And my name has nothing to do with Nas trust me. I just like the word. 👌👌😁
@@illmatixx_5346 a fact that does not matter, the fact that he lied about being at the kennel is evidence of his lies, the fact that he said he was shot on the roadside shows his lies, he killed them.
Harpoop-lian will continue appealing and filing bullshit. It's what he does. Let's be clear here, I think the clerk was inappropriate and celebrity obsessed. The jury However, regardless of the clerk's wrongs, came to the ONLY conclusion possible. If there were another trial and another jury , Harpoop-lian would just start whining that there's no way to get an untainted jury at this point. HE is the one who KEEPS it in the public eye. He went to the jury members questioning and pressing until one juror said what he wanted to hear.
Justice Toal is impressive. She owned that courtroom. It was messy but she cut through the nonsense and made a good decision. Hats off to Justice Toal.
Thank you for not wasting tax payer resources on this waste of oxygen. Appellate court better uphold this ruling and that foolish, greedy Clerk better never ever profit off a paragraph, let alone a book on this trial.
The evidence was overwhelming. I will never understand why he killed Maggie, but I know that Paul was costing AM money. With a man so willing to do anything for money, murder wasn't a stretch.
A “Motion for a New Trial” was going to be necessary before an appeal of this could be filed, and the State would have appealed her decision had she granted the motion. Bye Alec.😅
Just know we all don't play by the same rules. If you get found guilty of something and you try to appeal trust me it's either going 2 B YEARS or NO period... But If the D.A. loses and you get found not guilty though they can RE Try you like within a month LOL...imagine🤦🤦😅😅👌
This judge is amazing. Her dedication in reading the trial transcripts and her ability to see through Becky Hill’s testimony is admirable. She reached the only conclusion possible.
I don't think that clerk of court will ever work again. How shameful to end your career that way. Also, I feel she may be looking at lawsuit(s) coming her way.
Can’t believe this lady made a book out of a very sensitive and emotional case! And i can’t believe AM is still the only one that believes he didn’t kill his wife and son!!
I like this Judge, thought she was fair. Hill didnt get away entirely unscathered, she made comments and the judge called her out on it. I believe AM is guilty and decision of no new trial is the correct one.
In 'Tangled Vines', bestselling true crime author John Glatt reconstructs the rise of the prestigious Murdaugh family and the shocking double murder that led to the downfall of its patriarch, Alex Murdaugh.
Its all ao confusing, so she did tamper with the jurors but they dont care. And not that i care but they called the judge ma'am and sir? Was their confusion there?
He has the same eyes as Jodi Arias. Those are the eyes of a killer whose soul has been peeled out behind those same eyes. That's why they look so schizophrenic and empty. It's like you look into the eyes of a dead person. They are not dead. But their soul is dead. 12:18
Is that a man or a woman? In all honesty, I can't decide. I personally think Alec is innocent of the murders. But guilty of all the financial crimes. F that clerk of courts!
Harpootlian isn't done yet. He'll get it overturned. The judge tipped her hand that she was biased in her decision by her editorial comments at the end.
No she didn’t. What she stated is that she’s never seen a case this and that theirs conflicting standards as to how to go about it. She went by the South Carolina standard but said that some federal courts use a different.
let them waste more time and take more of AMs money. he will not be found innocent. As the judge said the evidence was overwhelming and the verdict was not a surprise.
Remember that she is now the trial judge. Her comments regarding the weight of the evidence are completely appropriate given her role. She was agreeing with the comments by the first trial judge who made the same comment after the verdict.
From the start the Judge has seemed to be so hostile against Murdaugh. It's unusual to give a new trial unless the other side consents. But this Judge's dislike for Murdaugh is evident.
@@emjaydark2811 the most unbiased Judge was Ted Bundy's judge in Florida and Oscar Pistorius's judge in So Africa ... they both convicted but not a speck of bias, if they disliked the defendants (Bundy or Pistorius), they hid it well. that's how a Court should be!
@@UFCtrumpsboxing I imagine one would form an opinion as the facts rolled out, but I think any judge should avoid the appearance of bias. When the first judge, Neuman read his scolding, humiliating, excoriation of Murdaugh at the first trial, I really lost respect for him as a judge and actually as a person. It seemed cruel and unnecessary to kick a man when he had just been locked up away forever.
Saw nothing wrong with the judges closing statements before sentencing of Alex after all, he had been convicted and we all must accept the jury's decision. The judge therefore has a right to address him according to his new status of being a convicted double murderer. @@emjaydark2811
They all know that the dirt's gonna come out. In the fact that murdoch's not guilty , it just goes to show how our justice system treats everybody guilty before proving innocent
So the jurors are lying and we just believe this lady who already lied and plagiarized. He's guilty but Gimme a break! How can you measure what was said by her at that time?? I think he most certainly should be granted new trial if the statements are true by jurors
@@Elegant_Sausage You can thank Beck Hill nobody else..Take the murders out of it for a sec and ask yourself if you would be satisfied with the results knowing and hearing everything that was said..I think Becky blinked a million times and did not sound believable at all. He's gonna get a new trial regardless just may take while longer
Intelligent, fair and good Judge. May God bless you Mrs Judge Toal ❤
""""Retrial Denied ""; again truth with fact ...comes to the light....🙏🏽
AMEN. You are a very very wise woman. Thank you, Judge.
Hell NO the naw naw. He is guilty as sin.
Guilty
You know you don't know that. There was really no evidence to convict him but sometimes the jury doesn't care. They just want to go home 👌👌😅😅
@@illmatixx_5346 I may not agree with you but thankfully your taste in music is better than your jury analysis
@@markieffmorris9263 first of all it's not an analysis. It's a fact.
Most of the time people just want to go home. They're not robots they're just humans. And we all know how humans are lol. 😅
And my name has nothing to do with Nas trust me. I just like the word. 👌👌😁
@@illmatixx_5346 a fact that does not matter, the fact that he lied about being at the kennel is evidence of his lies, the fact that he said he was shot on the roadside shows his lies, he killed them.
Harpootlian. Big reputation, but should have retired after the trial.
Too Right!
Jim Griffin is also uniquely bad at closing. The judge was holding eye contact because she wasn’t taking any notes 😂
He is so creepy 😢
Black as Smut eyes scares me
We were not their. We dont know all the facts. I am convinced he is innocent and was framd by a rogue prosecutor and out of control police.
@@chucksurgeonertribute2113 At this point you really have to be an idiot
Great judge, endorsing the jury🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thank you Judge!
Justice again 😊
She's no yoke !!! She threw the book at him and at Harput there lol !!
This guy is living it up inside, what else does he need?
Thank you Excellent Judge Toal!
Harpoop-lian will continue appealing and filing bullshit. It's what he does. Let's be clear here, I think the clerk was inappropriate and celebrity obsessed. The jury However, regardless of the clerk's wrongs, came to the ONLY conclusion possible. If there were another trial and another jury , Harpoop-lian would just start whining that there's no way to get an untainted jury at this point. HE is the one who KEEPS it in the public eye. He went to the jury members questioning and pressing until one juror said what he wanted to hear.
good comment. the jury did their job and ruled on the case presented by lawyers not gossip presented by the clerk
100%
The Judge got it right.
Justice Toal is impressive. She owned that courtroom. It was messy but she cut through the nonsense and made a good decision. Hats off to Justice Toal.
What a great judge. Every single person should follow her example in integrity and professionalism.
Ha Ha Ha! He loses again and deserves to rot in prison....😂😂😂
Thank you judge!
I thought we might see some more snot run out of Alex nose today! WTH
Give it up Big red ! Paul & Maggie , Mrs Satterwhite tons of many more people didn’t deserve the horror you caused !
Thank you for not wasting tax payer resources on this waste of oxygen. Appellate court better uphold this ruling and that foolish, greedy Clerk better never ever profit off a paragraph, let alone a book on this trial.
Great job judge!!! You know your stuff and we appreciate you. It now time to celebrate!!
Singing to the angels.. once again guilty as charged. The snurk on his face was stunning, he just wanted another day out. I can't stand him.
The evidence was overwhelming. I will never understand why he killed Maggie, but I know that Paul was costing AM money. With a man so willing to do anything for money, murder wasn't a stretch.
She was speaking to divorce lawyers 6 weeks before the murders.
bye bye Alex.
I like she doesn’t mince her words. 👍🏻
This Judge is so Polished. She’s wonderful ❤
Bravo! One of the best judges I've seen
Thank heaven.
GOOD!!!!
"The court clerk was called by the siren of wanting celebrity status" fleeting,foolish comments, she let that clerk have it
don't forget Alex's voice on Buster's cell right before ...
You mean Paul
👏🏼 ... oops hang on🤔😟... thats not it?! More to come !?!..wth...
😊
hahah his bribe failed.
Great decision indeed!
Boy that poor judge sure can't speak
A “Motion for a New Trial” was going to be necessary before an appeal of this could be filed, and the State would have appealed her decision had she granted the motion. Bye Alec.😅
YEAH ! EVIDENCE OVERWHELMING.
Back to jail. He was reaching at straws.
Is it just me or does he look a bit like a great value Nick Nolte
the Clerk is a pro ... a pro liar
Yep I agree. She def a liar .... But he guilty as sin
@@jamiehoover9348same she's a liar but he's still a thief and murderer.
I could not believe he did not get a new trial. He should have! I would love to have to observe another trial and see him get convicted again.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Just know we all don't play by the same rules.
If you get found guilty of something and you try to appeal trust me it's either going 2 B YEARS or NO period...
But If the D.A. loses and you get found not guilty though they can
RE Try you like within a month LOL...imagine🤦🤦😅😅👌
This judge is amazing. Her dedication in reading the trial transcripts and her ability to see through Becky Hill’s testimony is admirable. She reached the only conclusion possible.
I don't think that clerk of court will ever work again. How shameful to end your career that way. Also, I feel she may be looking at lawsuit(s) coming her way.
Very Intelligent Judge👍🏻
Way to go judge
He is guilty. No more trials!
Her book gives her sway. And the tone she intimates.
Can’t believe this lady made a book out of a very sensitive and emotional case! And i can’t believe AM is still the only one that believes he didn’t kill his wife and son!!
Liar, liar, pants on fire...
He'll no
I like this Judge, thought she was fair. Hill didnt get away entirely unscathered, she made comments and the judge called her out on it. I believe AM is guilty and decision of no new trial is the correct one.
I'm so happy he will never be free,!!!!!
Now go back to your cell an wait for big bubba
Sucks to be him
Cool smirk Alex. Bye bye
Good Riddance!
He killed Paw paw 😨.
I really like this judge
You are not aging gracefully Alec, guess that prison food sucks huh?
This judge is totally pissed. Dont blame her. That clerk was just wrong. Sure shes due a early retirement.
In 'Tangled Vines', bestselling true crime author John Glatt reconstructs the rise of the prestigious Murdaugh family and the shocking double murder that led to the downfall of its patriarch, Alex Murdaugh.
Beef sticks for life big red
Its all ao confusing, so she did tamper with the jurors but they dont care. And not that i care but they called the judge ma'am and sir? Was their confusion there?
He has the same eyes as Jodi Arias. Those are the eyes of a killer whose soul has been peeled out behind those same eyes. That's why they look so schizophrenic and empty. It's like you look into the eyes of a dead person. They are not dead. But their soul is dead. 12:18
Is it a boy or girl
He/she lol
😂 👏 👏 👏
🥳🥂🎂🥳
Is that a man or a woman? In all honesty, I can't decide. I personally think Alec is innocent of the murders. But guilty of all the financial crimes. F that clerk of courts!
Crooked system. Just because the trial was lengthly You don't want to grant a new one this is someone's life on the line
This it outrageous. If a jurors verdict was affected by the actions of court clerk regardless of what he’s been convicted of, he deserves a new trial.
Harpootlian isn't done yet. He'll get it overturned. The judge tipped her hand that she was biased in her decision by her editorial comments at the end.
No she didn’t. What she stated is that she’s never seen a case this and that theirs conflicting standards as to how to go about it. She went by the South Carolina standard but said that some federal courts use a different.
let them waste more time and take more of AMs money. he will not be found innocent. As the judge said the evidence was overwhelming and the verdict was not a surprise.
🤣
Remember that she is now the trial judge. Her comments regarding the weight of the evidence are completely appropriate given her role. She was agreeing with the comments by the first trial judge who made the same comment after the verdict.
From the start the Judge has seemed to be so hostile against Murdaugh. It's unusual to give a new trial unless the other side consents. But this Judge's dislike for Murdaugh is evident.
If she didn’t like Murdaugh then she wouldn’t have let their 2 witnesses in. She let in the other clerk and the alternate juror.
I had the same feeling about her as I did about the Neuman in the first trial. He may be guilty, but the trials were not unbiased.
@@emjaydark2811 the most unbiased Judge was Ted Bundy's judge in Florida and Oscar Pistorius's judge in So Africa ... they both convicted but not a speck of bias, if they disliked the defendants (Bundy or Pistorius), they hid it well. that's how a Court should be!
@@UFCtrumpsboxing I imagine one would form an opinion as the facts rolled out, but I think any judge should avoid the appearance of bias. When the first judge, Neuman read his scolding, humiliating, excoriation of Murdaugh at the first trial, I really lost respect for him as a judge and actually as a person. It seemed cruel and unnecessary to kick a man when he had just been locked up away forever.
Saw nothing wrong with the judges closing statements before sentencing of Alex after all, he had been convicted and we all must accept the jury's decision. The judge therefore has a right to address him according to his new status of being a convicted double murderer. @@emjaydark2811
They all know that the dirt's gonna come out. In the fact that murdoch's not guilty , it just goes to show how our justice system treats everybody guilty before proving innocent
Haha. That dude is guilty as sin. What are u sayin
@@jamiehoover9348 they sendin money to AMS commissary
So the jurors are lying and we just believe this lady who already lied and plagiarized. He's guilty but Gimme a break! How can you measure what was said by her at that time?? I think he most certainly should be granted new trial if the statements are true by jurors
Taxpayers should waste their dollars on a trial that you know will have the same outcome? Not cool bro
Nope ! Jurors have free will retrial denied !
I agree. If The clerk said this he should receive new trial. How can they just throw out what juror said?!
9:30 - 9:52 🛎🛎🛎
@@Elegant_Sausage You can thank Beck Hill nobody else..Take the murders out of it for a sec and ask yourself if you would be satisfied with the results knowing and hearing everything that was said..I think Becky blinked a million times and did not sound believable at all. He's gonna get a new trial regardless just may take while longer
What happened was horrible. But Alex was treated unfairly and prosecuted by media.
#freealexmurdaugh