Suspension Trainer Vs Gymnastics Rings Which is Best?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @caiusscipio6390
    @caiusscipio6390 4 роки тому +37

    The biggest mistake in getting fit is listening to VShred. Whyyy does he appear before people with actual information? 😢

  • @INTEGRATEPerformanceFitness
    @INTEGRATEPerformanceFitness 4 роки тому +5

    I love the rings for push and pull movements, monkii bars for everything else. Can’t beat a rotating handle for everything else.

  • @kallebuchholz2156
    @kallebuchholz2156 4 роки тому +8

    I’ve both and use them for different exercises but my TRX is definitely my companion on every trip.

    • @Xero-23
      @Xero-23 Рік тому

      I would like to ask you a question, is there a way to stop the TRX from rotating?

  • @c.wallacehume5625
    @c.wallacehume5625 4 роки тому +14

    I started training on rings about a year ago. I absolutely love them!
    Great for building shoulder stability and they force you to use your scapula properly. Great for building your biceps and forearms. You can learn the false grip on rings which is imperative for getting a muscle up. Finally I think rings are much safer than a fixed bar because they allow you to move in all planes of motion. Oh and I almost forgot, I traveled around Europe for two months with my rings and was able to use them everywhere! Very portable.
    I got mine at Rep Fitness for $39. Each strap is numbered making it really easy to set them up evenly. If you want to develop more strength and see huge gains in your calisthenics, buy yourself some rings!

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +10

      I agree, the movement and instability certainly makes these a win either way.
      And you're right, those numbered straps make the adjustments so much easier. They should be mandatory in all designs.

    • @c.wallacehume5625
      @c.wallacehume5625 4 роки тому

      @@RedDeltaProject thanks for all your great content Matt!

    • @Fahad-369
      @Fahad-369 2 роки тому

      @@c.wallacehume5625 and buh for legs? Any advice and suggestion warrior?

    • @c.wallacehume5625
      @c.wallacehume5625 2 роки тому

      @@Fahad-369 Rings are really for upper body. You could use them to assist you with learning some more difficult sqats like the pistol sqat. For legs I would recommend running, jumping, squats, lunges, ladder drills. Good luck!

    • @Fahad-369
      @Fahad-369 2 роки тому +1

      @@c.wallacehume5625 Thank You for the pointers. Taken into consideration and gonna kill it. much appreciated. May God bless you and your family with a happy,healthy,long, fulfilling and successful life.

  • @harvestblades
    @harvestblades Рік тому +2

    I made a DIY trainer using cam straps, PVC, & paranoid for foot loops as well as cargo tie down anchors & lag screws for mounting to floor joists. I hope you have a video onnthe Bowline as I was considering making something similar for an even smaller & lighter trainer for traveling or as you said throwing in a pocket or such for training outside! I don't leave my wooden rings outside so a cheap PVC & straps/rope are perfect for hanging from a tree & using for me & my kids to train & play w outside!

  • @garryraine4630
    @garryraine4630 4 роки тому

    Personal preference is the key. I don't got to park or train away from home and if I occasionally do train away from home I just go basic body weight training. I've got a set of rings permanently setup, I've got a bag of resistance bands. I've even got a Fortress Power Tower (which is pretty good, I must say), Swiss balls etc. But rings are my jam at my age and circumstance. So, what do you like? Go with that! Great video as always Matt. PS I'm 60 years old, so I just do what I want as I feel it and not stress the rest!

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому

      Best game plan every there Garry! How we feel about what we're doing and using is so very important.

  • @benben3210
    @benben3210 4 роки тому +5

    I do leg curls with my rings it works perfectly!

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +2

      I always had trouble with the width o the rings since i like keepin my feet close together, that and the rings were hard against my Achilles. Maybe padding them with towels?

  • @Greg_Chock
    @Greg_Chock 4 роки тому +1

    Both! DIY suspension trainers can be very cost effective.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +3

      Very true espcially if you already have parts on hand.

  • @rabeelsyed9683
    @rabeelsyed9683 4 роки тому +2

    TRX Duo are the best of both; rings and suspension trainer.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому

      Finally got my hands on a set of those a few months ago. Like the wooden handles. I like wood handles, which is another potential win for rings and I don't know why straps don't use them more. Maybe because they are a more expensive build.

  • @Begkan
    @Begkan 4 роки тому

    Hi! I first saw about your video on reddit bwf about hamstring curls and subscribed and watched some of your videos!
    I bought a cheap suspension trainer and it comes with the attachment so it can be used with a closed door inside the house which made my setup easier and cheaper than buying rings (rings are less popular, hard to find and more expensive in my country). Since we are all stuck home because of coronavirus, I like that I can finally do rows, upper back exercises, hamstring curls with my suspension trainer!
    I would appreciate more suspension trainer content!

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому

      Way to take action there MertBegkan. I have a decent amount of suspension stuff, if you look under my Grind Style Calisthenics playlist.
      But you're right, there's a lot we can do on a door so I'll be sure to post some stuff in the near future for ya

  • @kimberly6014
    @kimberly6014 4 роки тому +1

    I use my rings for hamstring curls, no problem. And rings are best because all the amazing gymnasts use them so even though I can't do much, they inspire me of what my potential could be so I'm more likely to want to use them. :-)

  • @FeldyMohrisar
    @FeldyMohrisar 4 роки тому +9

    Gymnastics rings always superior!
    You can use it at beginner until elite level.

  • @blackpurple9163
    @blackpurple9163 6 місяців тому

    Buy both, and you're set
    While rings may add slightly more stability demands due to not being straight handle, they seem (to me) more sturdier and stronger than plastic handles in suspension syraps

  • @wesleyangel777
    @wesleyangel777 4 роки тому +1

    I'm glad you made this video. I was wondering about your thoughts on the rings but it was never really important in comparison to other questions I had, so I always forgot to simply ask. Also, since many folks will be buying into s. trainers for the temp sessions away from the gym, they would be best served by the info in this video. Personally, since I've been working with your DIY Prussik trainer 2.0, I've never bothered moving away from it. Though, I am thinking of upgrading to the cam trainer and building one for my mom to send to her, since she is finally getting back into fitness again. As for costs, when one thinks about the up front cost, it really depends on a few variables: do they like DIY, do they expect to use these only a few times, do they expect these could be a great addition to their gym routine, and finally, how much would each month at the gym cost in comparison to a complete, portable gym like either of these options?

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +1

      You're so very right Wesley, always thinking of all of the angles I miss. You've got one hell of an analytical mind there my friend!

    • @wesleyangel777
      @wesleyangel777 4 роки тому +1

      @@RedDeltaProject I am but a humble servant in hopes to help grow this channel, these ideas, and the fitness community, if I can. Thanks.

  • @fareedingram4626
    @fareedingram4626 2 роки тому +1

    @ RedDelta .. running 6miles 5 days a week an doing lots of calisthenics and still don’t look ripped !! But have lost an maintenance the 49lb lost .. What am I doing wrong .. I have been at it since February ??

  • @marcelloantoniodreier4795
    @marcelloantoniodreier4795 4 роки тому

    Matt can you make a series of videos with the FOCUS of fixing body posture??!
    Many people are away from there desk job or working a lot less so it's the perfect time to fix posture imbalances!

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +3

      not a bad idea Marcello, let me do some more research on this one and get back to ya

    • @marcelloantoniodreier4795
      @marcelloantoniodreier4795 4 роки тому +1

      @@RedDeltaProject perfect!
      Looking forward to it as always!

  • @regprofant6984
    @regprofant6984 3 роки тому

    I have both but like my NOSSK straps best but both are great.

  • @blackbird7864
    @blackbird7864 4 роки тому

    I have the Monkii Bars 2. I mainly bought them for rows but my current living situation has me using them for pull-ups and chin-ups because the ceiling is too low to use the bar (my head hits the ceiling). I don’t really enjoy using anything other than a solid bar for vertical pulling but it gets the job done for now.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому

      I have those too, imo, best designed handles on the market for sure. Dan and the monkii crew did a great job in their design.

  • @rayvincyful1
    @rayvincyful1 4 роки тому +7

    With gymnastic rings we don't need foot straps. Just ignore the rings and hang your feet on the straps.

    • @DOUBLE0SEVUN
      @DOUBLE0SEVUN 3 роки тому

      I feel so dumb for not thinking of that!! hahaha thanks!

    • @rayvincyful1
      @rayvincyful1 3 роки тому

      @@DOUBLE0SEVUN I appreciate a reply to my 1 year old comment. Lol

    • @DOUBLE0SEVUN
      @DOUBLE0SEVUN 3 роки тому

      @@rayvincyful1 LOL are you still using rings or have you changed things up 1 year later??

    • @rayvincyful1
      @rayvincyful1 3 роки тому

      @@DOUBLE0SEVUN I lost motivation for a whole year. My straps and rings are filled with dust right now

    • @rayvincyful1
      @rayvincyful1 3 роки тому

      @@DOUBLE0SEVUN and I look like a freaking weakling right now. 😆😆😭😭

  • @dbds7292
    @dbds7292 Рік тому

    ring
    I haven't tried it, but it might be more comfortable to rest your foot on the strap itself instead of the ring when using your foot Also, it may be good to attach a strap to the end of the strap

  • @alexandruradudragos1434
    @alexandruradudragos1434 4 роки тому +1

    Can you do a review on Angles 90 training grips please?

  • @john1987805
    @john1987805 4 роки тому +27

    Gymnastic rings > any training apparatus

    • @brolyui4484
      @brolyui4484 3 роки тому +2

      Homeade rope gym trainer

  • @dropweightdaddy
    @dropweightdaddy 4 роки тому +1

    Ring diameter for my larger hands are much too small. My rule of thumb if you wear x-large size gloves then the standard G ring will be uncomfortable.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +2

      I know what you mean, I've used some small rings and it's been mighty harsh on the hands. Wrapping some towels around them can help though

  • @justelynnnjoelle
    @justelynnnjoelle 4 роки тому

    Hi Matt, great video quality as always. Will you be reviewing the T2 Iso-Trainer anytime soon? I got an early bird special on mine and am excited for it to arrive.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому

      You'll probably be able to do a review before I do in that case. Would love to hear what you think of it

  • @nohayaghmour5090
    @nohayaghmour5090 11 місяців тому

    thanks dude !!! cheers yo

  • @BD90..
    @BD90.. 4 роки тому +1

    I like rings but the suspension trainer seem better in my own opinion. I hate the rubbing of straps on the arms. Definitely wear long sleeves if doing dips and push ups with rings to avoid burning your arms.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +1

      Yea, that's why I just keep my arms pressed into the rings when doing dips. I figure it's best to keep the pressure on so the arms don't rub and just stay still on them

  • @janrump6766
    @janrump6766 4 роки тому

    Rings for push exercises and TRX for pull exercises

  • @jaimemendez2150
    @jaimemendez2150 2 роки тому

    Hey Matt, I bought a ring long time ago and love it. I would like to convert to a suspension trainer (handles). I see a few products online but not sure which one is good. Do you have a recommendation for those suspension handles with carabine?

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  2 роки тому +1

      This is a super old video but this is how I built my own with a more ergonomic strap and carabeaner set up. cutt.ly/YZpuGa2

  • @milangra1404
    @milangra1404 4 роки тому

    great, thanx

  • @epicwarzonenoobs6336
    @epicwarzonenoobs6336 4 роки тому +3

    I tried suspension trainers in the gym but somehow it did not make me feel like I am in control. With the rings there is a great satisfaction for me to master every movement. And post workout I feel like Yuri van Gelder. Check him out 😎

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +5

      lol!
      Is it wrong to imagine the olympic judges are watching when I would use rings :)
      That extra control may very well be due to that contact on the forearm I was mentioning before, that and the lack of the rotating handle. You wouldn't think a rotating handle would make that much difference, but it is a moving part which can feel a bit less connected through the motion.

  • @benjaminwetscher9614
    @benjaminwetscher9614 4 роки тому +6

    Rings are my weapon of choice

  • @amoghpratapsingh4938
    @amoghpratapsingh4938 4 роки тому +1

    But why i feel my forearm during bicep curl on these instead of biceps.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +2

      Simple, that's your weakest muscle in your pull-chain. So just stick with it and your forearms will catch up with the rest of your pulling moves.

    • @MrChochichon
      @MrChochichon 4 роки тому +2

      Maybe you're doing a too strong wrist flexion during your biceps curl (something like a false grip), which activates your forearm even before your first rep.
      Try to have less flexed wrists, or try a neutral grip (hammer curl for example)

  • @mokyan7
    @mokyan7 4 роки тому

    I have used both and I like rings a bit better. A couple months back I got some wood rings, 1.25” thick and they feel much better than the various plastics.
    I like that the ring straps are separate for pull ups, dips, holds and body rows, and other things. And 1.25” diameter rings feel better than 1” and build grip strength.
    The suspension trainers are more compact for travel.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +1

      I agree, you wouldn't think that .25' would make that much of a difference but they do, especially for guys like me with longer fingers

  • @regprofant8609
    @regprofant8609 3 роки тому

    So is there a ring set you recommend? I already have Nossk products you recommended.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  3 роки тому

      not too much, Ring training.com was a nice design but not sure if they are still in business. Rogue rings are also quality, but you can't go wrong out there.

  • @e.e.8589
    @e.e.8589 4 роки тому +1

    Nothing beats a good DIY Suspension Trainer. Only thing you need rings for are muscle ups.

    • @Zeddicus1976
      @Zeddicus1976 4 роки тому +5

      Muscle ups and all things you do without contact to the ground, such as handstands, skin the cat, even dips etc. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, it depends on what you are going to do. Why should I limit myself ? For ground work and leg training, I mostly prefer ST, for all things in the air, I prefer rings, as they easily allow changes in grip and direction. If I only could chose one however, I would go with rings, as they are more versatile overall. There is a reason why rings are one of the oldest training devices and still exist.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +1

      I've had folks do muscle ups on my Grind Straps in the past, but not sure if that's more possible with that model because the handles lock in place under load.

  • @dailydoseofleftpill3458
    @dailydoseofleftpill3458 4 роки тому

    I would prefer to train dips using gymnastic rings, just my personal preference.

  • @SomeKidFromBritain
    @SomeKidFromBritain 4 роки тому

    Whats that you are wearing at 0:14?

  • @obaolori
    @obaolori 4 роки тому

    i carry both when i go out

  • @xCorvus7x
    @xCorvus7x 3 роки тому

    One advantage of rings is that you can do press-ups on them without being suspended. They can be used as essentially unstable parallettes.
    ua-cam.com/video/Kjaa1OOxAtE/v-deo.html

  • @mirabilej
    @mirabilej 4 роки тому

    You need gymnastics rings if you are going to use a false grip.

  • @goblinknife1465
    @goblinknife1465 4 роки тому

    Sure is ring

  • @brekerr
    @brekerr 4 роки тому

    Don't buy cheap on suspension trainers, had a nasty suprise doing incline rows last week, suddenly found my self in the for with a thump.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +1

      I used to have the same attitude, and it is probably mostly true. In fact, i used to get a ton of questions from people asking me about NOSSK and I would tell them they must be crap at that price. But as I always say, an opinion that's not based on experience is just a guess. Lesson learned

  • @rorysstuff5129
    @rorysstuff5129 4 роки тому +2

    TRX is the toy version of the rings

    • @user-iw9ul2wn7r
      @user-iw9ul2wn7r Рік тому

      I've been thinking the similar: kids' version of the rings

  • @djpuplex
    @djpuplex 4 роки тому +1

    Amazon: 1. Door anchor 2. Yoga's strap

  • @abuzohaifa1066
    @abuzohaifa1066 4 роки тому +1

    Does this video Ring a bell about the training you suspended?
    I know I am not funny. No need to go crazy.

    • @RedDeltaProject
      @RedDeltaProject  4 роки тому +1

      lol, that was a strapping good one 'ol chap!

  • @grantsmith505
    @grantsmith505 11 місяців тому

    Both
    They pretty cheap