I picked up the ELF liquid eyeliner not too long ago, and I found there's some sort of glitter in the formula that makes it shine so much. I was only able to notice the glitter on the cotton balls I used to clean it off at night.. Anyway, I don't like glitter being so close to my eyes, so I thought I'd let everyone else here know about it, in case glitter bothers them too.
girl what?? i came across this video looking for a drugstore liquid eyeliner and when i went to subscribe i couldnt believe you only had 2000 subs!! i thought you would have at least 1 mill! you're going to blow up soon, so helpful and professional! going out to buy NYX matte liquid liner now! :)
awww thanks that is soo sweet of you! I'm pretty new to UA-cam and i'm just getting started honestly. Hope to get there one day! Thanks for watching! And yes hope you like the NYX matte liner!!! it's bomb!
I’m here 2 years later and she’s only got 8000! Whaaat! Well I have no idea what I’m doing so help me ma’am! New subscriber! But thanks for this, I now know what not too buy.. then I gotta figure out how to use it 😂
the black radiance eyeliner. I had gotten it a few months back and when I opened it it explode onto my face and went it to my mouth 😂 don't mess with that stuff
The milani 24 hr. eyeliner is my go to stuff. It doesn’t budge and I got used to the goopy formula and it has lasted me so many workout sessions without running at all. I’m obsessed with it.
I'm so sad that NYC eyeliner is no longer at my local drug store!!! The only store has it is far from where I live and they're always sold out😭 I only go for it cause its very cheap. But I will definitely try the ELF and NYX. Thanks to you ☺️
I'm so glad you showed yourself applying every eyeliner and describing what was good/bad about them! It really helped! I'm going to have to go shopping for that NYX one to see how I like it lol. Thanks for the video!
It's really really easy to build up a precise eyeliner.The LA Girl eyeliner is gonna be perfect for thin wings so I would definitely look into that if I find it!
you must try the Jordana's color envy liquid liner its exact dupe to nyx matte liquid liner Its my holy grail I have like 8 backups o yea and it's only $3
how do you only have 4k ahh you deserve so much more!! your videos are really professional, well put together and you're informative (btw your makeup looks so good)
i have no idea why but my liners always dry up a little after about a month and they don't work the same as they did at first, so the tip was useless :(
A terrible eyeliner is the physician's formula eye booster pen. It's not opaque it only stays on for like 4 hours if that if you touch your eye at all the eyeliner just disappears all in all its terrible
Thank you Sasha, I've been wearing Revlon liquid liner for YEARS and looking for reviews on drugstore eyeliner and came upon your channel . Now I don't have to go and waste my money. New sub.🌷
I got the Milani liner and it was very goopy too. I found that the brush tip applicator was hard to create a wing for me. It's was also very scratchy on my eyes.
I actually like the milani eyeliner. It STAYS ON! Like scrub hardddd and it'll still be there. Even w makeup remover! I just take a bit of the access on the side of the liner.
I always come back to the NYC eyeliner, I love it. Since it stopped selling in stores, I order a multiple amount from amazon cause it’s just that good.
Rimmel glam eyes is my go to eyeliner ... has been for like 10+ yrs iv really wanted to try others coz I also love brush tip applicators. Find the Rimmel glam eyes can tend to crack after a while of being applied and the tails of your wings can slowly disappear. Very tempted to try the Nyx one. Very helpful video thankyou - I have subscribed x
I have been using that NYX one for ever. I love it, but i hate the packageing because the rubber thingy on the rim comes loose and when i open it i have to be very careful or it will get everywhere and the brush gets too soaked i have to use a different brush because i love the formula and still want to use it. I chalk it up to the price being so low, which i also love. Id rather cost go to product over the packaging, oh well.
The milani liquid eyeliner use to be my favorite one years ago before all these new eyeliners came out to the market. That thing is waterproof and wouldnt go no where. The only thing i hated was that its too shiny and doesnt dry matte. And no you didnt get a defected one. Thats just how it is and will dry up fast with even if you have it close and dont use it.
I use the NYX eyeliner and it's great but I feel like it comes off easily. I also have issues with my eyes watering after I apply it and my wing just goes away but that might be because my eyes are sensitive or something. Another thing with this liner I'm not a huge fan of is that the formula dried out fast in the bottle and got clumpy. After two weeks I have to buy a new one and it's just frustrating
Every time I'm looking for a new liquid eyeliner I keep coming back to this video. My problem with the felt tip pen liners is that the tip seems to dry out quite quickly so after a while and I'm unable to do my cat eye. Do you have any recommendations for drugstore felt tip pens that don't dry out quickly?
I have the superstar loreal (it's the first one I've ever bought and the only one I have) and it skips every time I wing it! I thought it was normal but now I understand why. Thank you!
Just going to throw in there!!!! Rimmel glam eyes liner doesn't sting or burn for me guys so it might just be something that effects everyone differently, I've been using it for years and haven't found anything I like more
I have been waiting for this video! Thank you for your opinion. I will definitely check your favorites out and I hope I really love them too. You look gorgeous btw. ❤
It's hard because it's a felt tip applicator hun. I prefer felt tip because it allows for more precision. When you lay it on its side it guarantees a straight perfect line.
funny enough I just bought the Nyx eyeliner before watching this video. any wait to try out bevause I'm defo in love with this brand I own most of their amazing and affordable liquid lipstick. Love it x
Jordana can be found at Walgreens. I paid $2.89 for it. I'm wearing it now for the first time and the one thing I noticed that wasn't mentioned is that this liner doesn't dry matte :( It's not super shiny but there is a slight shine that I'm noticing.
Can you do a video on eyeliners you use to tightline and for your water lines? I have a similar eye shape as yours and I find that the eyeliners I use have a tendency to droop down to my under eyes.
My milani one did the same thing! I was so bummed bc I Love Mac’s Liquid last but not the price...also my applicator was like a weird hard plastic too thick
I've been using Maybelline for like ever and I'm honestly watching this video to find a new kind of eyeliner to use. It doesn't last long and is HORRIBLE for oily skin people!
You just gained a new sub❣️also, what would you say would be the best eyeliner for me? I have hooded, watery eyes with oily lids and I want something long wearing and smudgeproof. I hope you can help me, keep up the good work💗💗
Beautiful! Thanks for the great review! I found the clicking throughout really distracting though. I thought it was a fluke, but when it kept going it kiiinda drove me nuts, n' overall seemed to detract from your wonderful, otherwise polished vid. TSM! ♥
Yl'luria WaterSong I'm so sorry about that! My camera lens is actually broken and that sound is from when it's trying to focus :( it drives me absolutely insane also! I'm getting that fixed. I really appreciate the feedback! And glad you liked the video ❤️
I had the NYC one and LOVED how pigmented it was. Howeever, I didn't love the intense burning sensation it gave me after application and redness at the site of application :
The good eyeliners start at 9:25
Jeje Eudue thanks so much!
best comments gawd they should do this
Jeje Eudue thanks sis
Thanks
Wow thank you
Watching her apply eyeliners perfectly is so satisfying
Aparana Sharan could it BE any more satisfying?
I picked up the ELF liquid eyeliner not too long ago, and I found there's some sort of glitter in the formula that makes it shine so much. I was only able to notice the glitter on the cotton balls I used to clean it off at night.. Anyway, I don't like glitter being so close to my eyes, so I thought I'd let everyone else here know about it, in case glitter bothers them too.
girl what?? i came across this video looking for a drugstore liquid eyeliner and when i went to subscribe i couldnt believe you only had 2000 subs!! i thought you would have at least 1 mill! you're going to blow up soon, so helpful and professional! going out to buy NYX matte liquid liner now! :)
awww thanks that is soo sweet of you! I'm pretty new to UA-cam and i'm just getting started honestly. Hope to get there one day! Thanks for watching! And yes hope you like the NYX matte liner!!! it's bomb!
I’m here 2 years later and she’s only got 8000! Whaaat! Well I have no idea what I’m doing so help me ma’am! New subscriber! But thanks for this, I now know what not too buy.. then I gotta figure out how to use it 😂
@@jennadyan I'm here another 2 years later and now she has 22.700 :D lmaoo
the black radiance eyeliner. I had gotten it a few months back and when I opened it it explode onto my face and went it to my mouth 😂 don't mess with that stuff
lol! I hated that eyeliner the minute I tried it!!!!
bwahah 😂
The milani 24 hr. eyeliner is my go to stuff. It doesn’t budge and I got used to the goopy formula and it has lasted me so many workout sessions without running at all. I’m obsessed with it.
Girl yes ! I loveeee this eyeliner ! I use it on my eyebrows cause I can’t ever find a good “brow product” for my nonexistent eyebrows
the milani one is gloopy. buuuut I sure can swim with that on and it never budges lol
I seriously thought I was the only one that experienced the burning sensation with the Rimmel liquid liner. lol
Nope! You're not alone :)
Lol..
Same!!!
I was crying when I applied it it was sooo bad
I'm so sad that NYC eyeliner is no longer at my local drug store!!! The only store has it is far from where I live and they're always sold out😭 I only go for it cause its very cheap. But I will definitely try the ELF and NYX. Thanks to you ☺️
For NYC, check Amazon! They have it :)
I think the NYC one is being discontinued ;(((( that's how I found your video because I was looking for one to replace it.
Nicole Sweiss me too😭
Jasmine V chrisspy just made a video about it!
Nicole Sweiss thanks girl i just watched it ... so sad. i'm literally running out of eyeliner, like great timing. but i'm gonna try the nyx liner 🙏
i tried nyx i didnt like it was too watery. I like the wet and wild megalast eyeliner, but i really enjoyed this video. Thanks
I'm so glad you showed yourself applying every eyeliner and describing what was good/bad about them! It really helped! I'm going to have to go shopping for that NYX one to see how I like it lol. Thanks for the video!
It's really really easy to build up a precise eyeliner.The LA Girl eyeliner is gonna be perfect for thin wings so I would definitely look into that if I find it!
Thanks for your review. I found Jordana cat eye liner in my Local CVS . It's a bomb. The best liner ever
you must try the Jordana's color envy liquid liner its exact dupe to nyx matte liquid liner Its my holy grail I have like 8 backups o yea and it's only $3
Oooh thanks! gotta check that out
conceitedminaj Is it matte?
Yes
Where is it sold?
is that the brand they sell at target
how do you only have 4k ahh you deserve so much more!! your videos are really professional, well put together and you're informative (btw your makeup looks so good)
Thank you for watching! That means so much to me. :)
Thank you for doing this review on all the different drugstore eyeliners!! Saved me so much $$
i have no idea why but my liners always dry up a little after about a month and they don't work the same as they did at first, so the tip was useless :(
Maria Marquez use rimmel liquid eye linear
A terrible eyeliner is the physician's formula eye booster pen. It's not opaque it only stays on for like 4 hours if that if you touch your eye at all the eyeliner just disappears all in all its terrible
I liked how it applied but it gave me a really bad allergy reaction :(
Love this vid! 💕 I was wondering you have an updated version of this? I looked, but I might’ve missed it!
Thank you Sasha, I've been wearing Revlon liquid liner for YEARS and looking for reviews on drugstore eyeliner and came upon your channel . Now I don't have to go and waste my money. New sub.🌷
I got the Milani liner and it was very goopy too. I found that the brush tip applicator was hard to create a wing for me. It's was also very scratchy on my eyes.
because I heard NYC cosmetics will be discontinued I bought the last 4 NYC liner left at my Duane Reade
I use the NYX matte liquid eyeliner, I absolutely love it.
I use the Milani eyeliner and it's just like that. What I love about it is that it lasts and doesn't fade at all
I actually like the milani eyeliner.
It STAYS ON! Like scrub hardddd and it'll still be there. Even w makeup remover! I just take a bit of the access on the side of the liner.
You are the reason why I love the NYC liquid liner! I've been using it since you posted about it on your instagram!
Yay! Love that eyeliner, still one of my go-tos!
The LA Girl liner looked so good though
I use the Jordana cat eyeliner and I can confirm, as someone with oily eyelids, it doesn't smudge or run and stays on so well.
What eyeshadow and liquid (I'm guessing liquid) lipstick are you wearing because you slaying the game girl
Thank you! I think I'm wearing colors from the ABH Modern Renaissance Palette. And I forget what nude lipstick I'm wearing :(
I always come back to the NYC eyeliner, I love it. Since it stopped selling in stores, I order a multiple amount from amazon cause it’s just that good.
Jafra is my fav. The liquid inkwell eyeliners to me is really good when I do wing and other style I want to style.
You got a new subbie right here! Loved how you applied every eyeliner so we could actually see what you’re talking about. Thank you for that. 🙏🏻💗
Watched this video as I needed a new eyeliner. Bought the NYX one you recommended and I'M IN LOVE WITH IT!
RIP NYC
Ve Zapata i've had multiple NYC brushes end up like that lmao "one time thing"
Rimmel glam eyes is my go to eyeliner ... has been for like 10+ yrs iv really wanted to try others coz I also love brush tip applicators. Find the Rimmel glam eyes can tend to crack after a while of being applied and the tails of your wings can slowly disappear. Very tempted to try the Nyx one. Very helpful video thankyou - I have subscribed x
can you make a water proof version of this video
Hi! I just stumbled upon your channel and now you have another subscriber! Your videos are nice and pretty and your makeup is on point!
Thank you for subscribing! Really appreciate it :)
I have been using that NYX one for ever. I love it, but i hate the packageing because the rubber thingy on the rim comes loose and when i open it i have to be very careful or it will get everywhere and the brush gets too soaked i have to use a different brush because i love the formula and still want to use it. I chalk it up to the price being so low, which i also love. Id rather cost go to product over the packaging, oh well.
I haven't had any issues with the packaging yet. Hopefully they can improve that because you're right, it is such a great product!
The milani liquid eyeliner use to be my favorite one years ago before all these new eyeliners came out to the market. That thing is waterproof and wouldnt go no where. The only thing i hated was that its too shiny and doesnt dry matte. And no you didnt get a defected one. Thats just how it is and will dry up fast with even if you have it close and dont use it.
Glad to know I wasn't the only one who had that problem! You're right though, it is completely waterproof.
I use the NYX eyeliner and it's great but I feel like it comes off easily. I also have issues with my eyes watering after I apply it and my wing just goes away but that might be because my eyes are sensitive or something. Another thing with this liner I'm not a huge fan of is that the formula dried out fast in the bottle and got clumpy. After two weeks I have to buy a new one and it's just frustrating
You can find Jordana in Sally Beauty stores.
Thanks! Listened to this on the way to the drug store, bought the NYX, I LOVE IT!
I love this video. It focuses on just eyeliner.
Thank you for this awesome review! Just bought my NYX Matte black! Can't wait to try it.
Every time I'm looking for a new liquid eyeliner I keep coming back to this video. My problem with the felt tip pen liners is that the tip seems to dry out quite quickly so after a while and I'm unable to do my cat eye. Do you have any recommendations for drugstore felt tip pens that don't dry out quickly?
I have the maybelline liquid liner , I love it I’ve been using it for years but the only thing I don’t like is that it’s not water proof 😭
I have the superstar loreal (it's the first one I've ever bought and the only one I have) and it skips every time I wing it! I thought it was normal but now I understand why. Thank you!
Best eyeliner review on UA-cam!
Just going to throw in there!!!! Rimmel glam eyes liner doesn't sting or burn for me guys so it might just be something that effects everyone differently, I've been using it for years and haven't found anything I like more
The Nyx also has a felt tip.. I didn't know they had a brush tip. My fav is the elf one.
Black radiance is at one of my local Walmart and they have awesome matte liquid lipsticks!
Also the stiletto eyeliner is one of my holy grails, I've been using it for years
I have the milani waterproof eyeliner. The formula is just that way.
Yeah I had a feeling it was! Thanks for letting me know!
I'm really glad I found this video it was very helpful definitely going to buy the Jordana and NYx liquid liner
Glad you found it helpful!
I have the eyeliner by nyx and stiletto as well and love them too!!great video girl
Awesome video. So professional and great information! Getting the NYX liner today. :)
Thanks sweetie. Grabbing the May stiletto now be of your recommendation. ❤️
Bc I'm sorta a beginner
Oh my gosh i was so shook when you said it was 2 in the morning haha!!! 2 am and still lighting goals? What is this sorcery? 😱
+Carolyn Grace Marie lots of lights! Haha 3 in front of me and one to light my background
I love brush tip eyeliners 👍🏼
What kind of eyeshadow do you have on in this video? I love the color! Great video, thanks!!! 😃
Thanks for watching! I used colors from the Anastasia Beverly Hills Master Palette by Mario
My current favorite is the Essence Superfine Eyeliner Pen.
Are felt tips or brush tips easier to use? I always struggle with liquid eyeliner. My lines aren't straight and my wings never match.
Which one do you think is the best for creating thick line?? I just hate fine tips
Just bought the elf one so I'm glad not much shade was thrown. Also it was $4!
The black radiance brand has a pretty decent brush tip eyeliner, the only issue with it is the longevity but for 3/4 dollars its no biggie to me
Jordana i love it i get it at food maxx for 2.99 it last a long time
I have been waiting for this video! Thank you for your opinion. I will definitely check your favorites out and I hope I really love them too. You look gorgeous btw. ❤
Thanks for watching! Hope you like some of my faves! :)
It's hard because it's a felt tip applicator hun. I prefer felt tip because it allows for more precision. When you lay it on its side it guarantees a straight perfect line.
funny enough I just bought the Nyx eyeliner before watching this video. any wait to try out bevause I'm defo in love with this brand I own most of their amazing and affordable liquid lipstick. Love it x
Jordana can be found at Walgreens. I paid $2.89 for it. I'm wearing it now for the first time and the one thing I noticed that wasn't mentioned is that this liner doesn't dry matte :( It's not super shiny but there is a slight shine that I'm noticing.
Yeah there's definitely a slight shine! Forgot to mention that :)
Love this review! It is very thorough! I really like the NYX matte black eyeliner and I recently bought the Rimmel one but I haven't tried it yet.
Can you do a video on eyeliners you use to tightline and for your water lines? I have a similar eye shape as yours and I find that the eyeliners I use have a tendency to droop down to my under eyes.
+Justine R such a great idea! I will keep that one in mind
Lots of great info!! Going to get the Jordana and nyx right now lol
Do you use primer and setting spray? A lack of that might be what's causing the transfer?
I tried NYX and I hate it... Maybe my lid is too oily. It breaks into small black dots and get everywhere around my eyes
Love the NyX matte one but it flakes on me at the end of the day.
ugh I looovvveeeddd the nyc eyeliner when I was younger & then they stopped carrying it at my local drugstore :(
+melon it’s hard to find nowadays!
What are you wearing on your lips ? Looks great
I bought that NYC eyeliner and the brush looked like that too! I didn't dare put it on my eye
I've been buying this eyeliner for over 2 years and this was the first one I got with a brush like that! don't give up :)
amazing quality videos, something I lack. This really helped
Can you do an updated list 20/20? Thanks
the milani eyeliner you got isn't a bad one- i've bought it multiple times and it's just the formula :(
I am satisfy with liquid rimmel eyeliner its really good..
I used the stiletto eyeliner for a long time before I knew better. Applies beautifully, but it cracks
Which one would you say is more longwearing/waterproof, the jordana one or the nyx one?
They both are the same to me. The finishes are totally different though, the Jordana has a shiny finish and the NYX has a matte finish
what are u wearing on your lips??😍
Yolanda Vergara i think its nyx lingerie
Yolanda Vergara in exotic
My milani one did the same thing! I was so bummed bc I Love Mac’s Liquid last but not the price...also my applicator was like a weird hard plastic too thick
What is more long wearing? Jordana or NYX?
Jordana!!!!
I used to use milani a lot and it's usually that goopy. you just learn to put to with it cause it's just like Mac liquid last minus the price tag.
theplainest is it easy to work with it?
Thanks for the video but which eyeliner would you recommend for oily eyelids that is long lasting and doesn't transfer xx
NYX!
I've been using Maybelline for like ever and I'm honestly watching this video to find a new kind of eyeliner to use. It doesn't last long and is HORRIBLE for oily skin people!
You just gained a new sub❣️also, what would you say would be the best eyeliner for me? I have hooded, watery eyes with oily lids and I want something long wearing and smudgeproof. I hope you can help me, keep up the good work💗💗
Thank you for watching! I would recommend the NYX or the Jordana eyeliner for long-lasting and smudge proof :)
I had the same problem with the Milani. After a while it gets really thick from oxidation, I think. Almost impossible to do a nice thin line anymore.
The nyx one is the first liquid eyeliner i discovered lol
I have the Jordana Cat liner and for some reason it chips on me 😢 but I love how I can draw precise lines with it it's just the formula 😫
thank for making this video. I've been searching for the right liquid eyeliner
Try malani gupy eyeliner on ur waterline n wait till its dry.....omg believe me 12 hours it will not go anywhere...
Beautiful! Thanks for the great review!
I found the clicking throughout really distracting though. I thought it was a fluke, but when it kept going it kiiinda drove me nuts, n' overall seemed to detract from your wonderful, otherwise polished vid. TSM! ♥
Yl'luria WaterSong I'm so sorry about that! My camera lens is actually broken and that sound is from when it's trying to focus :( it drives me absolutely insane also! I'm getting that fixed. I really appreciate the feedback! And glad you liked the video ❤️
Such an awesome job with this video! if I could compile a perfect comparison video this would be it! Thank you
I had the NYC one and LOVED how pigmented it was. Howeever, I didn't love the intense burning sensation it gave me after application and redness at the site of application :
Such a good video! Thanks