Kip Thorne, who this movie was a tribute too and he was creative consultant on, himself said that the only way he could perceive of out of a black hole would be through an extra-dimensional space, which extends beyond the space-time we know of and hence wouldn't be confined to the restrictions of a Black Hole. The "Bulk Beings", those beings that created the wormhole near Saturn to being with (By the way they are referred to shortly later by Cooper as Bulk Beings because they live in the Bulk, the space between spaces as Doyle stated earlier), created this multi-dimensional structure in Gargantuan, the supermassive Black Hole, because of this idea presented by Kip Thorne. In fact the whole movie was deliberately written the way it was WITH this in mind from the beginning and the ending was NOT written as a last minute thing.
5:20 the earth and moon already are, its almost at the centre of earth but not really so, the earth and moon are a duo system going around the sun togheter ;)
That interstellar scene may not be scientifically accurate (maybe no one knows) but it's a beautiful blend between science fiction and emotions. This movie still inspires me to study more physics and work for the civilization. This movie also cured my depression and anxiety issues. It will always be the #1 movie in my mind
Haha yessss!! I love all three . And physics girl and vi Hart and Simone . Brain scoop . Up and atom .it's so cool to see all these cool girls. Alsoo Daahhhh I watch too much youtubeeee
The Melancholia scene is about a planet much bigger than the Earth aproaching Earth and is going to crash, but of course that's not what the film is really about, the planet is a methapor. The fillm is really about depression and anxiety and how a woman is affected by this planet like the literary "mood affected by the moon", and how depression and anxiety causes on her a distortion of time and space .Like the quote by Lao Tzu: “If you are depressed you are living in the past. If you are anxious you are living in the future. If you are at peace you are living in the present.”
Armageddon was dumb af but you totally missed what the f was happening in that scene. They were on the surface of an asteroid and while being held down with downward propulsion, they drove toward the edge of a cliff, wherein they deactivated the downward propulsion mechanism; thereby freeing them to fly off of the edge of the cliff at low gravity. You’re welcome
Think they missed the point on Interstellar. A species so advanced had constructed a way to use black holes to cross dimensions. It wasn't just going inside a black hole, the black hole was a "tool" for this advanced species to achieve a specific goal.
Great analysis and reaction👍🏻. There's just one scene in Interstellar(movie) that doesn't make sense and that is when Cooper approaches the event horizon of the blackhole. Because according to The Late physicist Stephen Hawking(one of the greatest minds that ever existed on earth), anything(basically information) that approaches the blackhole or falls into the rupture created in space - time continuum due to the infinite gravity of blackhole is never lost but accumulated on the side of a black hole(near the event horizon) in the form of threads or hairlike structures. Also, What are your thoughts about the feasibility of the Dyson sphere? And is it really possible to launch different parts of particle accelerator and assemble them in space?(reference taken from the cloverfield paradox). I'm just curious.
I think there's a book or a paper about how that scene was done, you can look for it online and there's the explanation of why they did it that way. Hope it helps.
Just a few tips for making the next reaction video even better- 1. Increase the volume of the video 2. When showing the scenes show it in full screen and then show yourself commenting on the scene
Didn'nt like you r opininion on Interstellars's scene, they tried their best and noone knows anything about it as noone has ever been through it, so Yeah. :)
Interstellar does not show time travel. It's a platform to illustrate higher dimensions onto our 3 dimensional plane. Which is why it's a tesseract. It wasn't showing what is in every black hole. It was a specific area created by beings who have transcended our dimension and can effect things outside of spacetime. They also created a stable wormhole to facilitate them getting there in the first place. I don't get how people don't understand what the movie was. Like, what did you think was happening there then?
The implication in the movie is that the beings are human beings from far in the future who are harnessing their knowledge of dimensions to ensure the survival of the human race. it's like thor says. Magic is science so advanced we can't even comprehend it. that concept in interstellar sounds out there to a lot of people because it involves so much theoretical physics it sounds unbelievable.
The issue that I have with the asteroid scene. Is that he would not have been able to calculate it’s orbit that quickly in reality. It would take a number of days measuring its location and trajectory in order to determine its orbit. It’s not something you can determine within a few seconds of discovering the asteroid.
Little jets on the space shuttle? You mean the RCS Reaction Control System? The movie at the 7:00 minute: wonder why he didnt just use a phone to call someone else/place with a good server or verbally inform. Armageddon scene was on the comet bearing down on Earth and the "road" was just a less bumpy part and they were in a microgravity place where even a person jumping up hard might reach escape velocity from such a small body and the thrust was to actually go a small bit "down" relatively speaking so they would not go into orbit around that comet they were trying to drill on. Ever see the Stargate SG1?Stargate Atlantis tv shows? If so, are you gals the real life versions of Samantha Carter? Or Jeannie McKay? Definitely have the GORGEOUS looks going on like they have.
09:09 why do... Like Miller's planet or docking, etc, or the slingshotting around Gargantua This is the 2nd time I've seen an expert now react to just the tesseract past-future scene
Yeah about the interstellar scene. Nobody knows what's inside a black hole. There are several theories about it and its agreed on that you would most likely die trying to enter one. However the concept of this movie is that humans far into the future managed to tap into other dimensions and used a black hole to place Cooper where they needed him to be to ensure the survival of the human race. What they were showing in the movie was a representation of a tesseract which is a concept in quantum physics. I don't think it breaks the immersion of the film at all because it is just outside the realm of believe-ability but not so far out that you can't suspend your disbelief. It's one of those things where they needed to stretch the bounds of believe ability to serve the drama. There's plenty of other movies that did a far worse job at this sort of thing.
The movie can't be accurate we all know that. Christopher nolan didn't actually travelled out of earth through the wormhole in the blackholes and other planets to see if this the actual case. But he drew concept base on real scientific theories and his imagination was quite showing the caliber how convincingly it might be to travel to some black hole or another planet. The crew did an amazing job in the movie
I enjoyed this video You two have a good connection and keep it fun. I'd like to see more. There are plenty of sci-fi movies waiting for your reviews. ;)
Hlw Jess man🙏🙏🙏may I get Mechanical final year major projects as innovative for my society. I am not getting as much innovative and I watched ur every video it was really beautiful projects....
Jess, Why is she still blocking me? Does she hate me or is this some sort of guessing game? Tell her I apologize for whatever I've done. I'm nice but this is upsetting. I just want to talk, so please ask her if she will talk. If so, how? Please.
Well you two girls came up on my recommendations list I have no interest in Physics but I do listen to the old coast to coast am episodes with Art Bell,I found this very interesting and just subbed thanks Jess!!!
Have you seen the reviews of shows and movies on YT? There is room for more with sci-fi, add in some jokes and clips from cartoons or whatever. They are very popular, esp with the popular tv shows. You two should give it a try.
Consider (TH) removing vids on quitting phd and regrets studying math due to how they might affect viewers seeking to hire video content creator. Look over other vids with this in mind. Just an idea...
Regarding the Interstellar scene, it's a fascinating look into the theories pertaining to black holes, civilizations that can truly harness them, and honestly has a bit of quantum gravity thrown in.
Just stumbled upon this and you two are great together! :) When it comes to the twin suns at the start we actually dont have to look very far: the closest starsystem to our sun, Alpha Centauri, has three stars in it, "only" 4,7 lightyears away.
4:16 I would think that it should be daylight, based on how the light is reflected on the moon. Also the two planets must be very close to eachother, cause the moon seems identical. How realistic is this?
Toby made a video on her channel too. Check it out: ua-cam.com/video/bMaAUIZCVUc/v-deo.html
Kip Thorne, who this movie was a tribute too and he was creative consultant on, himself said that the only way he could perceive of out of a black hole would be through an extra-dimensional space, which extends beyond the space-time we know of and hence wouldn't be confined to the restrictions of a Black Hole. The "Bulk Beings", those beings that created the wormhole near Saturn to being with (By the way they are referred to shortly later by Cooper as Bulk Beings because they live in the Bulk, the space between spaces as Doyle stated earlier), created this multi-dimensional structure in Gargantuan, the supermassive Black Hole, because of this idea presented by Kip Thorne. In fact the whole movie was deliberately written the way it was WITH this in mind from the beginning and the ending was NOT written as a last minute thing.
5:20 the earth and moon already are, its almost at the centre of earth but not really so, the earth and moon are a duo system going around the sun togheter ;)
This was fun, thanks for having me! :D
Thanks for coming on!
Your mic was too low.
This was a collab I was not anticipating. Fun to see you both on the same screen at the same time! :)
biggest crossover event since Infinity War
Ahahaha thanks so much! Didn't think we were on the same level as Marvel;)
Generic plot's with a bunch of cgi
@@RiverTechJess Not same , Better*!
That interstellar scene may not be scientifically accurate (maybe no one knows) but it's a beautiful blend between science fiction and emotions. This movie still inspires me to study more physics and work for the civilization. This movie also cured my depression and anxiety issues. It will always be the #1 movie in my mind
I think they asked a physicist the math of how a black hole works and then they put the math into a rendering machine that they made and that came out
Gotta admit I'm really enjoying this new wave of female science oriented channels. You, Tibby, Mithuna from the Looking Glass Universe channel.. It's pretty refreshing haha
Haha yessss!! I love all three . And physics girl and vi Hart and Simone . Brain scoop . Up and atom .it's so cool to see all these cool girls. Alsoo Daahhhh I watch too much youtubeeee
Thanks so much to both of you for naming all of these channels! I just subscribed to a bunch of them and am so excited to watch:D
Don´t forget Dr Becky (Rebecka Smethurst). Excellent channel.
@@Myth-zd6ko honestly
The Melancholia scene is about a planet much bigger than the Earth aproaching Earth and is going to crash, but of course that's not what the film is really about, the planet is a methapor.
The fillm is really about depression and anxiety and how a woman is affected by this planet like the literary "mood affected by the moon", and how depression and anxiety causes on her a distortion of time and space .Like the quote by Lao Tzu:
“If you are depressed you are living in the past.
If you are anxious you are living in the future.
If you are at peace you are living in the present.”
Kronen yo that quote is 🔥 most factual thing I’ve ever heard
Armageddon was dumb af but you totally missed what the f was happening in that scene. They were on the surface of an asteroid and while being held down with downward propulsion, they drove toward the edge of a cliff, wherein they deactivated the downward propulsion mechanism; thereby freeing them to fly off of the edge of the cliff at low gravity. You’re welcome
Someone looks like an apologetic Disney princess ! 😂
Xd
Good to see you together. I am subscriber for both of you
thanks so much! I'm glad you like the content:)
It wasn't an actual black hole, it was a human construction from the distant future.
Think they missed the point on Interstellar. A species so advanced had constructed a way to use black holes to cross dimensions. It wasn't just going inside a black hole, the black hole was a "tool" for this advanced species to achieve a specific goal.
Great analysis and reaction👍🏻.
There's just one scene in Interstellar(movie) that doesn't make sense and that is when Cooper approaches the event horizon of the blackhole.
Because according to The Late physicist Stephen Hawking(one of the greatest minds that ever existed on earth), anything(basically information) that approaches the blackhole or falls into the rupture created in space - time continuum due to the infinite gravity of blackhole is never lost but accumulated on the side of a black hole(near the event horizon) in the form of threads or hairlike structures.
Also,
What are your thoughts about the feasibility of the Dyson sphere?
And is it really possible to launch different parts of particle accelerator and assemble them in space?(reference taken from the cloverfield paradox).
I'm just curious.
I think there's a book or a paper about how that scene was done, you can look for it online and there's the explanation of why they did it that way. Hope it helps.
I thought the ending to Interstellar was awesome.
Just a few tips for making the next reaction video even better-
1. Increase the volume of the video
2. When showing the scenes show it in full screen and then show yourself commenting on the scene
Didn'nt like you r opininion on Interstellars's scene, they tried their best and noone knows anything about it as noone has ever been through it, so Yeah. :)
if i were astrophisicist i would pay attention on 'PARABOLIC 26 MI/SEC' at 6:02 ..))
9:57 its just imagination!
never felt smarter after watching a reaction video haha
I'm so glad to hear that!:)
Interstellar does not show time travel. It's a platform to illustrate higher dimensions onto our 3 dimensional plane. Which is why it's a tesseract. It wasn't showing what is in every black hole. It was a specific area created by beings who have transcended our dimension and can effect things outside of spacetime. They also created a stable wormhole to facilitate them getting there in the first place. I don't get how people don't understand what the movie was. Like, what did you think was happening there then?
The implication in the movie is that the beings are human beings from far in the future who are harnessing their knowledge of dimensions to ensure the survival of the human race. it's like thor says. Magic is science so advanced we can't even comprehend it. that concept in interstellar sounds out there to a lot of people because it involves so much theoretical physics it sounds unbelievable.
The issue that I have with the asteroid scene. Is that he would not have been able to calculate it’s orbit that quickly in reality. It would take a number of days measuring its location and trajectory in order to determine its orbit.
It’s not something you can determine within a few seconds of discovering the asteroid.
There could be a flux of gravitational waves that disperse throughout dimensions
The Martian movie review please! That one just screams out engineering movie!
Ahh! Good idea! I'm writing it down now:)
LOVE THIS, thank you for making this collab! You’re both very inspiring 😍
❤️💕From🇮🇳🇮🇳
Of all the scenes from Interstellar, you choose the one that made little sense at the end. There's so many better scenes!
Too much IQ in one room
Little jets on the space shuttle? You mean the RCS Reaction Control System?
The movie at the 7:00 minute: wonder why he didnt just use a phone to call someone else/place with a good server or verbally inform.
Armageddon scene was on the comet bearing down on Earth and the "road" was just a less bumpy part and they were in a microgravity place where even a person jumping up hard might reach escape velocity from such a small body and the thrust was to actually go a small bit "down" relatively speaking so they would not go into orbit around that comet they were trying to drill on.
Ever see the Stargate SG1?Stargate Atlantis tv shows? If so, are you gals the real life versions of Samantha Carter?
Or Jeannie McKay?
Definitely have the GORGEOUS looks going on like they have.
The question I have is that are these two single.
Just saying, Wall-E and EVA are both linked digitally seeing as they're both robots/androids?
09:09 why do...
Like Miller's planet or docking, etc, or the slingshotting around Gargantua
This is the 2nd time I've seen an expert now react to just the tesseract past-future scene
Yeah about the interstellar scene. Nobody knows what's inside a black hole. There are several theories about it and its agreed on that you would most likely die trying to enter one. However the concept of this movie is that humans far into the future managed to tap into other dimensions and used a black hole to place Cooper where they needed him to be to ensure the survival of the human race. What they were showing in the movie was a representation of a tesseract which is a concept in quantum physics. I don't think it breaks the immersion of the film at all because it is just outside the realm of believe-ability but not so far out that you can't suspend your disbelief. It's one of those things where they needed to stretch the bounds of believe ability to serve the drama. There's plenty of other movies that did a far worse job at this sort of thing.
The movie can't be accurate we all know that.
Christopher nolan didn't actually travelled out of earth through the wormhole in the blackholes and other planets to see if this the actual case.
But he drew concept base on real scientific theories and his imagination was quite showing the caliber how convincingly it might be to travel to some black hole or another planet.
The crew did an amazing job in the movie
Please make a video for the Martian, Gravity , Arrival and more about interstellar
I enjoyed this video You two have a good connection and keep it fun. I'd like to see more. There are plenty of sci-fi movies waiting for your reviews. ;)
Mumbling vs loud laughter. I got seriously annoyed with it.
Of what could have been a very good clip.
At least I had fun:)
@@RiverTechJess, no offence, quite sure you didn't notice when you recorded it, but it really annoyed me.
can't possibly simulate a black hole without a quantum computer !!
First
You two are very inspirational. Keep the content coming!
Tibees' reactions are pretty funny haha.
Im gratefully for her brain full of all of the facts she shared:D
Awsome video! Please do more videos like this :)
You are the most gorgeous astrophysicist I've ever seen
Acts 24 15
PS 37 29
John 11 25 26
John 5 28 29
2 Corinthians 4 18
Rev 21 4.
Really? I thought of something entirely different....
You should do a video comparing both majors cos I’m having such a hard time picking between both
How about Marketing Communications? You'll make more money.
Just stumbled upon your channel and I’ve been watching all day. Love the quality and effort you put in
Wow thank you so much!! I put in a lot of effort but I feel like my videos are still bad hahahaha
Who knows what's inside a black hole?
I was waiting for Arrival but...
Beauties with brains 😎😍
Sent her by my crush Toby 😆 Nice videos. You got a new sub
thanks so much for subscribing:) I'm glad you like the video!
Both are nice😍😍😍
Hlw Jess man🙏🙏🙏may I get Mechanical final year major projects as innovative for my society. I am not getting as much innovative and I watched ur every video it was really beautiful projects....
Interstellar 😍😍
Second
Jess, Why is she still blocking me? Does she hate me or is this some sort of guessing game? Tell her I apologize for whatever I've done. I'm nice but this is upsetting. I just want to talk, so please ask her if she will talk. If so, how? Please.
Well you two girls came up on my recommendations list I have no interest in Physics but I do listen to the old coast to coast am episodes with Art Bell,I found this very interesting and just subbed thanks Jess!!!
Toby is the best!
Perhaps Wall-E and EVA used electromagnetic waves (radio) to converse in space? Loved video! Toby was so apprehensive being in a reaction video ... 😄
Have you seen the reviews of shows and movies on YT? There is room for more with sci-fi, add in some jokes and clips from cartoons or whatever. They are very popular, esp with the popular tv shows. You two should give it a try.
Nice try to the title
Interstellar ❤️
Consider (TH) removing vids on quitting phd and regrets studying math due to how they might affect viewers seeking to hire video content creator. Look over other vids with this in mind. Just an idea...
Regarding the Interstellar scene, it's a fascinating look into the theories pertaining to black holes, civilizations that can truly harness them, and honestly has a bit of quantum gravity thrown in.
Just stumbled upon this and you two are great together! :)
When it comes to the twin suns at the start we actually dont have to look very far: the closest starsystem to our sun, Alpha Centauri, has three stars in it, "only" 4,7 lightyears away.
Let's get gravatationally bound! ...sorry, I couldn't resist! : D
when i saw the thumb i thougt you were sisters, you look so much alike, no offense
Speaking of binary star systems....😱😱😄
This is a fun video to watch. You two should be film critics for real!
Hoi ich bi au vo züri
What does Toby think of The Martian?
OMG is that twosetphysicist ?
also, ben affleck can totally achieve escape velocity! e.g. escape velocity on martian moon phobos is 41 km/h
Its a crazy coincidence that I was thinking about the same thing 30 minutes ago.
4:16 I would think that it should be daylight, based on how the light is reflected on the moon. Also the two planets must be very close to eachother, cause the moon seems identical. How realistic is this?
I think maybe the sun is probably behind the earth and shinning at an angle onto Melancholia?
It was funny :D
Keep up the great videos :)
Thanks for the enouragement:)
this was a really great idea
I'm glad you like it:)
She’s cool. Would like to see you too do more vids.
Cool video Jess! You are probably the prettiest engineer I have seen, I couldn't help it lol. Like always keep up the great work!
Expanding of universe already explained in the Qur'an,you know that?
this video was the best of two