Fresh Kills: From Landfill to Park on Staten Island

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 гру 2012
  • The once notorious Fresh Kills Landfill on Staten Island is being developed into an urban park. Michael Kimmelman, architecture critic, tours the site.
    Related article: nyti.ms/U4HJ1I
    Please visit nyti.ms/T2RKvl in order to embed this video
    Watch more videos at nytimes.com/video
    Follow on Twitter: / nytimesvideo

КОМЕНТАРІ • 53

  • @michaelcafaro4022
    @michaelcafaro4022 2 роки тому +11

    But it’s still leaking from the bottom. They talk of a slurry wall to capture the leachate but you would have to go down over 100ft in spots and encompass each mound. I find that hard to believe that it was done. You can find old pictures from the 40’s on line and they were filling in fresh water ponds with garbage , truly heart breaking.

  • @turkrane12
    @turkrane12 6 років тому +5

    My memory of the area goes back 70 years, an uncle lived in Travis, Al Deppes and the farms, an airport, an auction ,great memories

  • @ValenteAdventures
    @ValenteAdventures 9 місяців тому +3

    Remarkable I say. At least it's a park where wildlife can flourish and not a stinky dump site. I applaud the efforts of the people involved 👏 Here in Florida, we have massive landfills 100s of feet high. Grass overtakes it with lots of birds, and they harness the gas from it.

  • @pfeilsusan
    @pfeilsusan 3 роки тому +4

    I'm wondering when the trash decomposes will those mounds shrink. Not everything decomposes but much of the waste will deteriorate eventually.

  • @EpicThe112
    @EpicThe112 Рік тому +2

    I wonder if they found the process to use landfill gas when fresh kills landfill was operational if so there could have been a bus depot basically the Staten Island equivalent of Brooklyn Spring Creek & Jackie Gleason Queens College Point and Bronx 180th street West Farms depots However it Burns natural gas from landfills unlike the Brooklyn Bronx and Queens CNG depots which use pipe natural gas.

  • @intorpere
    @intorpere 11 років тому +8

    What happens when there's flooding, like during a major hurricane?

  • @sarthakjaiswal5864
    @sarthakjaiswal5864 3 роки тому +2

    Wow nice use of tech & knowledge. Hope world learn something from it.

  • @TrajanaFortis
    @TrajanaFortis 11 років тому +3

    Beautiful borough; lived there for 4 years. I hope when I return one day it will be even more beautiful.

  • @coletanner5193
    @coletanner5193 3 роки тому +3

    In the 1990s if you would have told anyone that fresh kills would be a beautiful Park in 25 years they would have a laughed and said why don't you go play in it!.. there should be enough methane under those hills to supply free gas to all SI homes!That black woman was not kidding about the stinky summertime..it's SO IGNORANT for leaders and engineers to chose such a beautiful area to be a dump in 1948..1848 would be more plausible, but in 1948 they turned a beautiful area with fresh water into NYC's dump

  • @robin5380
    @robin5380 2 роки тому +3

    Was looking to see what the 9/11 debris fields looked like today. Thank YoU

  • @maureenwilson6031
    @maureenwilson6031 Рік тому +1

    😂when the wind blew in the wrong direction, the stink was terrible near our house.

  • @12comrades
    @12comrades 11 років тому +10

    Who came up with that name "Fresh" Kills. Really peaceful; no people that's the reason.

    • @Robconnors7253
      @Robconnors7253 6 років тому +3

      R Tirado Fresh Kills in Dutch is Fresh Stream. .

  • @jeremyfowler1519
    @jeremyfowler1519 3 роки тому +1

    Heard it’s super haunted. Any seen anything? I even heard of WWII nurse ghosts being there helping victims of 9/11.

  • @micholli
    @micholli 2 роки тому +1

    I googled. The park is still closed in 2022.

  • @Teddy_Bass
    @Teddy_Bass 6 років тому +4

    The O&K Rh120, the blue excavators where the only ones in the world ever to be fitted with Clamshell attachment. And the only ones that where blue

  • @ethanmackler1892
    @ethanmackler1892 5 років тому +5

    where does the garbage go now?

    • @wesfishcare
      @wesfishcare 4 роки тому +1

      A different landfill/dump

    • @coletanner5193
      @coletanner5193 3 роки тому

      The ocean.. no really it goes to China who claims to recycle it but let's be real! In Indonesia they throw their trash into the river empties it out into the ocean!

    • @michaeldaquino481
      @michaeldaquino481 3 роки тому

      The garbage continues to go to Fresh Kills, but it's compacted and put into steel containers and transported by rail to Virginia

    • @justinwallace390
      @justinwallace390 3 роки тому

      Garbage heaven...

  • @3Kalman
    @3Kalman 11 років тому +7

    It willl never go away for human's sake. It is clear that a conflagration will be required to eradicate this creeping infection so that future beings whatever they may be can evolve. Perhaps an insect species who may actually live upon this pollution. This is mere ostrich behavior for humans. Two and 1/2 feet of dirt that is cleaner than"what is found in back yards" is of no consolation.

  • @fbi.7121
    @fbi.7121 4 роки тому +4

    Now it's a grave site ☹️

  • @intorpere
    @intorpere 11 років тому +4

    I was just wondering if the soil and barrier material ever gets washed away, exposing the garbage. and if not, just curious how they managed to make it so effective.

    • @jasonbladzinski5336
      @jasonbladzinski5336 5 років тому +4

      It can, very easily. Most landfills are capped with a thick mostly dry layer of clay and a liner. Then soil is placed on top of the liner. If the soil on top of the liner washes away, the liner will be exposed making it easy to damage. Usually, landfills have to be monitored to prevent this. Soil and grass placed on top as supposed to help mitigate this problem. This is why grasses are usually planted while trees and shrubbery are not, even going as far as removing any such plants if they do manage to spring up. Roots of trees and woody shrubs can easily damage the liner, causing more water to enter and increase leachate production and methane escaping into the atmosphere. Landfills are tombs for garbage, because of the anaerobic conditions very little happens to the waste. People who have done studies have dug up hotdogs from decades ago that looked almost completely the same as when they went in, and newspapers from 100 years ago that could be read clear as crystals. Landfills will exist likely unchanged and only slightly decomposed probably long after humanity has gone extinct.

  • @Junksaint
    @Junksaint 2 роки тому

    Fresh Kills.

  • @michaeldaquino481
    @michaeldaquino481 3 роки тому +3

    Who you kidding? This place still smells in the early mornings from April to September. They want to convert this place into a park? Give me a break! There is so much radiation buried in that ground that in glows from space. Please!

    • @jasonsimms4238
      @jasonsimms4238 3 роки тому +1

      you just made all that up

    • @michaeldaquino481
      @michaeldaquino481 3 роки тому

      @@jasonsimms4238 Then go enjoy it and have fun whenever it opens.

    • @jasonsimms4238
      @jasonsimms4238 3 роки тому +1

      @@michaeldaquino481 there are literally thousands of people who go to ski resorts, parks and beaches that used to be landfills. its no big deal.

    • @michaeldaquino481
      @michaeldaquino481 3 роки тому

      @@jasonsimms4238 Ok Enjoy.

    • @coletanner5193
      @coletanner5193 3 роки тому +2

      Have you been there since 2008 when they opened it? I was there in the late 80s and the stench was so bad I thought 3 point something million people have to smell this all summer long!

  • @ryanOGab
    @ryanOGab 11 місяців тому +1

    Why do they always gloss over it’s 9/11 history isn’t there human remains still their.

  • @Inkulabi
    @Inkulabi 4 роки тому +1

    4:03 they told the firefighters the air was safe to breath after 9/11 too which was false

    • @jasonsimms4238
      @jasonsimms4238 3 роки тому

      are you saying that the air did not get better after words

    • @Inkulabi
      @Inkulabi 3 роки тому

      @@jasonsimms4238 yes, it wasn't safe but I can't remember the ladys name who said it was safe to go back even after suggestions to her from specialists, been years now

  • @applecounty
    @applecounty 11 років тому

    So?

    • @applecounty
      @applecounty 2 роки тому

      @Freline Actually I am not there, I live in the disunited Kingdom (UK). But I do subscribe to the NYT.

  • @TheNeedlefactory
    @TheNeedlefactory 11 років тому

    what a pile of crap. nice video

  • @allenjohnson7686
    @allenjohnson7686 7 років тому +8

    nice trees and grass on top of billions of tons of rubbish under it, gasses and contaminants leaking out of it. .... nice place for a day out with a gas mask

    • @daviderenda9211
      @daviderenda9211 6 років тому

      Allen Johnson not how it works

    • @allenjohnson7686
      @allenjohnson7686 6 років тому

      have you ever seen a landfill after they have grassed it over? there are pipes coming out the ground to vent off the gas that is being made under it from all the rubbish. but hey if thats not how it works go ask if you can build a home on it and see how your health works out.

    • @jasonbladzinski5336
      @jasonbladzinski5336 6 років тому

      Davide Renda Yes, that is how it works. It's an aerobic environment in landfills, meaning no oxygen gets into the layers of trash. The decomposition is slowed, and it's the perfect environment for major greenhouse gasses like methane. Without the collection pipes, explosions are a hazard.

    • @AlexLopez-rx8lw
      @AlexLopez-rx8lw 5 років тому

      It's all contained.

  • @user-qu9ev6pv8e
    @user-qu9ev6pv8e 6 місяців тому

    Needs trees and shrubbery.