Wow! Finally to see more and more fans gathering together for Anette! That's so great! I love her - she's so sweet! Brings such a nice spirit to the songs of Nightwish. But on the other hand I think that we need not talk negatively of Tarja - she was great for her era. Now Anette is the one for the new era. Somethings we just need let go and enjoy the presence ;) Levae past for the past. The present rocks! So does Anette! Doesn't she!? HUH :)
Well-said HellsAngi. It's been three years since Tarja has gone, and yet the river of tears still flows from the eyes of devout Tarja fans. Tarja is still going strong with her solo album, and she even performs a handful of the old Nightwish songs at her concerts, and yet Tarja zealots still feel the need to leave snarky comments about Annette on every Nightwish video. I miss Tarja too, but that doesn't mean Nightwish isn't churning out amazing music anymore.
A true nightwish fan would respect their decisions, because they only do whats best for the band and their fans. Yes, I miss Tarja, but that is no reason to insult the woman who was chosen to be the new singer. Anette is doing her best. I am proud that Nightwish was able to preservere and make great music after one of their members, who was with them for years, left. So for the guys who keep complaining, just stop watching Nightwish if you hate it so much, and let the rest of us watch in peace.
too right.. i don't know why people are still bitching about tarja leaving.. i mean.. songs from her solo era are spreaded on youtube.. if they miss tarja so much that they are going to ruin the pleasure for other people? then why not listen to her solo era and give the others some slack to listen to what is now and not to dwell in the past
@ComaLies225 I miss Tarja in Nightwish, but She's doing an amazing job in her solo carreer and Now Nightwish is going into a new sound and that's cool too ^^ I like both, Tarja and Anette ^^
Agreed, everyone on here STILL bitchin about Tarja being kicked out and hoping for a 1,000,000,000/1 chance of her coming back are just sad that their idol had gone diva on them. Just give it up everyone. Anette Rocks!
if metal is for you only screaming into microphone than you are right, Nigtwish always plays music based on symphony, Anette has different voice than Tarja, so u cant expect same music. And this is metal!
Lusomaster i actually really agree with u. Tarja was just like dead on stage rarely did anything and the song were well ok performed but Anette really does put offph in them soooo better, i mean dont get me wrong i love Tarja but i prefer Anette :D
i like this song and anette n i liked tarja as well. you can either sit and mope about what was or start dealing with what is. anette is the singer for nightwish, tarja was both of them are brilliant different but equal
Well I have always loved Nightwish and actually I appreciate Anette. Yeah, probably Tarja's voice created a more interesting atmosphere in Nightwish' songs, but anyway Anette is a good singer. Plus she puts a lot of passion when singing live... probably she's not as good as Tarja for what concerns the voice, but you can see and feel that she likes being on the stage and singing. Sometimes instead it seemed to me that Tarja performed really good but just because she had to... personal opinion!
i agree with you, Anette just doesn't have that voice that tarja had. I like both of them the same. I'm just used to see and hear tarja preform there old songs. I have nothing against Anette!!!!!! I must say that some of there old songs have turned popish. But they are still number one in my heart and that's what really maters
if you are younger than 16 you just need a permission of your parents ^^ but no one will ask you how old you are :D everyone gets everything there, no matter if you are 15 or younger :D
@scooterkid That is EXACTLY my point bottomline is.. people give anette no chance because they got used to tarja.. then they shall listen to tarja right? why bugging our pleasure by telling that anette sucks? if she does she will get booted by the band in no time
@NightWhiteFantasy Anette is a good singer, but she needs to relax and feel the songs on live sets, specially when she sings old Nightwish songs... It's just another opinion. However I'm still thinking that Tarja is a better singer because she's more older and she had found her inner voice, her style, Anette is young she needs to relax and feel the music, as you said She rocks, but she can be even better! ^^
it could be the video, and i hope it is, this sounds like crap but i still love the studio albums from Nightwish, those with Tarja and with Anette. And i hope their new album will be good, like we all expect from Nightwish.
adesso i nw sono questi e penso che rimanganano un gruppo di eccellente livello. quando li sentirai dal vivo dimmi se ti sono piaciuti. l'audio su youtube inganna...
I really like this song! Yes I think Tarja is the better singer but Nightwish is still great with Anette, she does her best, she just can't sing that high like Tarja!
i love old nightwish and tarja`s solo band i olso like the new nightwish but i dont want them to play old songs the dont fit with her voice both singers is awesome!
@takoje0 sorry about that but i'm a musican too, and can sing so beautiful in the studio, but there is differences between the disk and the concerts, i said my oppinion, you said yours thats all
yeah me too...she's not as good as taja, but she's still good. in music bands it's normal for singers to leave after a while, i wud hav thought pple wud get accustomed to it by now. the problem i guess is that tarja left some really big shoes to fill...
I saw her live at W:O:A O8 and i must say: great! But... the poor speakers xD it was so fucking loud that you cant understand anything xD 3 days after that my ears still... not bleeding but.. ahh fu... it was so fucking great!
I wonder what people would think if Tarja sang Anette songs? Actually I don't wonder, I KNOW they'd hate it as much as they hate Anette singing Ever Dream.
In just this live video there are a LOT of off key notes. If comparing to a Sarah Brightmans live concert this is a huge difference. She is so accurate in singing live, you have to be Sherlock Holmes to find even 1 off key note.
i guess cause nightwish and tarja were such powerful force in the metal industry, seeing her leaving was like a stab to the heart..but life goes on. I like Annette but i think she was a poor choice to replace Tarja.
OMG guys stop talking about the new singer and enjoy the live!It's Nightwish FFS!!OMG.If u don't like her or Nightwish go listen to some Britney Spears!
oh damn just get over it will u..i'm honestly getting so sick n tired of reading comments like this on EVERY nightwish vid on youtube..tarja would have left the band anyway so what's the difference..she's happy doing her solo thing so the least u can do is support her and quit whining.
No, it wouldn't be better.. Tuomas said the reason. If he had chosen an operatic voice the woman would have been even more compared with Tarja than Anette. Not so much women have got a voice like Tarja so it would have been more difficult to accept an operatic voice that cant reach the high notes that a normal voice that sings the songs in a different way. It impossible to stop comparing the voices, but if the voices were similar, there would be more comparisons even
she's very sweet, i like her, she does sounds better on the album... but ... i don't have a live album either ... this is not very well recorded ... at least not with the quality of End of an Era
I believe that with the departure of the stripe, the whole has completely lost its identity, it's nothing personal against the new singer, she simply does not own voice enough to keep up .....
Same with me, but unlike all the other idiot fans here, I didn't go around bashing Anette. I did the reasonable thing and didn't bother to listen. It wasn't until I saw her Live at Lowlands performance that she truly impressed me. I still like Tarja but she isn't as great as everyone makes her out to be. Yeah she sings Opera but so does Leontyne Price and Diana Damrau and anyone who listens to Opera religiously will tell you that Tarja has her faults
Well... 2 meter or not, she can actually sing! And with a great technique. If men are afraid of such a woman they should go and check their heads!She looks great and sings great. If you want to look at 165 cm women whom lives of their beauty, and maybe secondarily can sing somewhat, you should look for them in the pop or the porn business.
Wow! Finally to see more and more fans gathering together for Anette! That's so great! I love her - she's so sweet! Brings such a nice spirit to the songs of Nightwish.
But on the other hand I think that we need not talk negatively of Tarja - she was great for her era. Now Anette is the one for the new era. Somethings we just need let go and enjoy the presence ;) Levae past for the past. The present rocks! So does Anette! Doesn't she!? HUH :)
Man, tuomas just writes the best songs in the world... each one is an anthem! Great Work Maestro!
I've only just discovered Nightwish. Love this song. Never seen a keyboard player rock out so well :D Damn easy on the eye too!
The best Amaranth performance ever ! Anette !!! GO GO GO GO !!!!
Well-said HellsAngi. It's been three years since Tarja has gone, and yet the river of tears still flows from the eyes of devout Tarja fans. Tarja is still going strong with her solo album, and she even performs a handful of the old Nightwish songs at her concerts, and yet Tarja zealots still feel the need to leave snarky comments about Annette on every Nightwish video. I miss Tarja too, but that doesn't mean Nightwish isn't churning out amazing music anymore.
this is AWESOOOOOOMEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!! NIGHTWISH ROCKS!
amazing!
this is music! this is NIGHTWISH!!!
ladies and gentleman, i just have to say, long live to nightwish !!!!
A true nightwish fan would respect their decisions, because they only do whats best for the band and their fans. Yes, I miss Tarja, but that is no reason to insult the woman who was chosen to be the new singer. Anette is doing her best. I am proud that Nightwish was able to preservere and make great music after one of their members, who was with them for years, left. So for the guys who keep complaining, just stop watching Nightwish if you hate it so much, and let the rest of us watch in peace.
love how she sings the chorus
que estrutura!! que palco!! que efeitos!!
I only can say that the band is amazing.. I like them... and Annete is a good singer.. WAHTEVER WHAT THEY SAY.. OR YOU SAY...
there is nothing to add :D
just awesome!
finally someone who tells the true
that's very true, until now, none album has been made by Tuomas thinking of her voice ...
i already got my tickets :D and ive been there 2008 ^^
I totally agree!
@Shadowsilas I so totally agree with you. Thank you.
too right.. i don't know why people are still bitching about tarja leaving.. i mean.. songs from her solo era are spreaded on youtube.. if they miss tarja so much that they are going to ruin the pleasure for other people? then why not listen to her solo era and give the others some slack to listen to what is now and not to dwell in the past
Humm... Thank you, i love you too :)
this is one of those videos I really like to watch... because no one can say "Oh, Tarja did it much more better" lol
Yeah!! Anette rocks!!!!!!!!!!!! totally agree =D
Pour une fois, Anette réussie une belle performance vocale^^ sa s'est super bien!!!!!!!!!!!!
Their drummer is insane=)
Agreed, Tuomas is a genius songwriter...
@Lusomaster I agree with everything you just said! :) The only exception is the part about "Gospel" ;D I don't think gospel is dead music.
WOW, awesome :p
@ComaLies225 I miss Tarja in Nightwish, but She's doing an amazing job in her solo carreer and Now Nightwish is going into a new sound and that's cool too ^^
I like both, Tarja and Anette ^^
I have the same opinion.
THEY are the musicians,
THEY perform for US
THEY have a good time for US, so!!!
We need 2 have a f!@#ing good time TOO.
It was nice!
Agreed, everyone on here STILL bitchin about Tarja being kicked out and hoping for a 1,000,000,000/1 chance of her coming back are just sad that their idol had gone diva on them.
Just give it up everyone. Anette Rocks!
@Shadowsilas I know. She and her band are great.
if metal is for you only screaming into microphone than you are right, Nigtwish always plays music based on symphony, Anette has different voice than Tarja, so u cant expect same music.
And this is metal!
Lusomaster i actually really agree with u. Tarja was just like dead on stage rarely did anything and the song were well ok performed but Anette really does put offph in them soooo better, i mean dont get me wrong i love Tarja but i prefer Anette :D
@PaulBeauregard1979 Tarja has a solo career now, my favorite song by her is "I walk alone" Check into that if you havent already they're really good
i like this song and anette n i liked tarja as well. you can either sit and mope about what was or start dealing with what is. anette is the singer for nightwish, tarja was both of them are brilliant different but equal
Anette and Tarja both good singers..And fuckin beautiful
@Shadowsilas You need to hear "Dark Star" that song rocks the hell out too!! ^^ Tarja's Solo carreer is amazing!
Well I have always loved Nightwish and actually I appreciate Anette. Yeah, probably Tarja's voice created a more interesting atmosphere in Nightwish' songs, but anyway Anette is a good singer. Plus she puts a lot of passion when singing live... probably she's not as good as Tarja for what concerns the voice, but you can see and feel that she likes being on the stage and singing. Sometimes instead it seemed to me that Tarja performed really good but just because she had to... personal opinion!
totally agree.. Nightwish where the band that maked me love metal. and anette should stay to her songs. sad but true.
"There is no way to replace Chris Barnes - this is end of Cannibal Corpse" - someone in 1995.
marcooooo! hahah nice chorus
That's what The old Gathering fans said when Anneke Joined....
and i was only 16 when i was in wacken for the first time ^^
your right, but with "sold out" i just meant, that there are no tickets left ^^
ye i noticed it after the post :)
Tuomas really gets intense with that keyboard. :P
i agree with you, Anette just doesn't have that voice that tarja had. I like both of them the same. I'm just used to see and hear tarja preform there old songs. I have nothing against Anette!!!!!! I must say that some of there old songs have turned popish. But they are still number one in my heart and that's what really maters
@NightWhiteFantasy I agree :D
Yes, the "Tarja sucks" comments need to stop as well. But the "Annette sucks!" comments are much more common.
if you are younger than 16 you just need a permission of your parents ^^ but no one will ask you how old you are :D everyone gets everything there, no matter if you are 15 or younger :D
HEP HEP!!!
i wanna join the hep heeeep!! x3
and the final was :D !!
wacken 09... SOLD OUT ^^
I saw that :D
agreed
@scooterkid That is EXACTLY my point bottomline is.. people give anette no chance because they got used to tarja.. then they shall listen to tarja right? why bugging our pleasure by telling that anette sucks? if she does she will get booted by the band in no time
I love Tarja, yeah. But Anette this performance is just fuckin' awesome!!!
Hahahahhaa, was about to write the same thing xD
@jefroxslayer91
yeah, he dumped her out of the tourbus in motion.
@NightWhiteFantasy Anette is a good singer, but she needs to relax and feel the songs on live sets, specially when she sings old Nightwish songs... It's just another opinion. However I'm still thinking that Tarja is a better singer because she's more older and she had found her inner voice, her style, Anette is young she needs to relax and feel the music, as you said She rocks, but she can be even better! ^^
it could be the video, and i hope it is, this sounds like crap
but i still love the studio albums from Nightwish, those with Tarja and with Anette.
And i hope their new album will be good, like we all expect from Nightwish.
the biggest band in the world? ftw
adesso i nw sono questi e penso che rimanganano un gruppo di eccellente livello. quando li sentirai dal vivo dimmi se ti sono piaciuti. l'audio su youtube inganna...
I really like this song! Yes I think Tarja is the better singer but Nightwish is still great with Anette, she does her best, she just can't sing that high like Tarja!
i love old nightwish and tarja`s solo band i olso like the new nightwish but i dont want them to play old songs the dont fit with her voice both singers is awesome!
@takoje0 sorry about that but i'm a musican too, and can sing so beautiful in the studio, but there is differences between the disk and the concerts, i said my oppinion, you said yours thats all
yeah me too...she's not as good as taja, but she's still good. in music bands it's normal for singers to leave after a while, i wud hav thought pple wud get accustomed to it by now. the problem i guess is that tarja left some really big shoes to fill...
aslong as they don't change their name, their being and their music..
NO ...........
Lowlands and Birmingham were her best performances ever.
I saw her live at W:O:A O8 and i must say: great! But... the poor speakers xD it was so fucking loud that you cant understand anything xD 3 days after that my ears still... not bleeding but.. ahh fu... it was so fucking great!
Pracowita dziewczyna ale sztandarowy utwór w wykonaniu Tarii był moim ulubionym a to wykonanie to takie sobie
I heared them in Stuttgart and there , they were worlds better than it sounds there, but maybe its the record or the sound mix. Greetings
@lfaktore -
Amen.
I agree with you Shadowsilas. I won't listen anymore. I'll go listen to Tarja. :)
I wonder what people would think if Tarja sang Anette songs? Actually I don't wonder, I KNOW they'd hate it as much as they hate Anette singing Ever Dream.
In just this live video there are a LOT of off key notes. If comparing to a Sarah Brightmans live concert this is a huge difference. She is so accurate in singing live, you have to be Sherlock Holmes to find even 1 off key note.
I prefer Tarja singing style, but this song is great with Anette voice.
YOU ARE WROOOONGGGG she's a fucken great singer, live or estudio she sings very very good...so why don't you stop saying bull shit and listen...
@Crimson0089 In studio her voice is quite good, but on live concerts she screaming!
i guess cause nightwish and tarja were such powerful force in the metal industry, seeing her leaving was like a stab to the heart..but life goes on. I like Annette but i think she was a poor choice to replace Tarja.
pffff... every Nightwish's video's top comments are about tarja and annette... Ok! It's understood! Now, STOP! Please!
OMG guys stop talking about the new singer and enjoy the live!It's Nightwish FFS!!OMG.If u don't like her or Nightwish go listen to some Britney Spears!
oh damn just get over it will u..i'm honestly getting so sick n tired of reading comments like this on EVERY nightwish vid on youtube..tarja would have left the band anyway so what's the difference..she's happy doing her solo thing so the least u can do is support her and quit whining.
No, it wouldn't be better.. Tuomas said the reason. If he had chosen an operatic voice the woman would have been even more compared with Tarja than Anette. Not so much women have got a voice like Tarja so it would have been more difficult to accept an operatic voice that cant reach the high notes that a normal voice that sings the songs in a different way. It impossible to stop comparing the voices, but if the voices were similar, there would be more comparisons even
Wow, anette rocks it live! Tarja was a lump with opera vocals.
What do you mean everything there?
Now only some people to go with lol :P
She does it on purpose, she probably finds it boring to sing the same thing each time, and varies it.
@PaulBeauregard1979 Then dont listen to it, its really not that complicated, if you dont like her voice, dont listen to her songs
she's very sweet, i like her, she does sounds better on the album... but ... i don't have a live album either ... this is not very well recorded ... at least not with the quality of End of an Era
Prove any of those assumptions correct.
I believe that with the departure of the stripe, the whole has completely lost its identity, it's nothing personal against the new singer, she simply does not own voice enough to keep up .....
Same with me, but unlike all the other idiot fans here, I didn't go around bashing Anette. I did the reasonable thing and didn't bother to listen. It wasn't until I saw her Live at Lowlands performance that she truly impressed me. I still like Tarja but she isn't as great as everyone makes her out to be. Yeah she sings Opera but so does Leontyne Price and Diana Damrau and anyone who listens to Opera religiously will tell you that Tarja has her faults
Anette is a pop singer, not a classical soprano.
Do you have to be 16+ ?
Is it me or do the band look happier with annette?
Well... 2 meter or not, she can actually sing! And with a great technique. If men are afraid of such a woman they should go and check their heads!She looks great and sings great. If you want to look at 165 cm women whom lives of their beauty, and maybe secondarily can sing somewhat, you should look for them in the pop or the porn business.
ye i love pyros to, but why they started using it all the time when anette joined *happyface*
i miss vibratos in her voice...
i just dont like that, but apparently shes the only female vocalist at nightwish