Criticism of Prophet due to enslaving, haz. Maria, Why prophet did not free her, Javed Ahmad Ghamidi

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 66

  • @wazeerahmad6920
    @wazeerahmad6920 5 років тому +10

    14 ویں صدی میں ان کی علمی سطح بہت اونچی ہے اور علماء سے بعض اختلفات کے باوجود آپ بہت بڑی نعمت ہیں ۔

  • @kshah2923
    @kshah2923 6 років тому +18

    This is how a real scholar of Islam give answers

  • @syedhassan233
    @syedhassan233 5 років тому

    جزک اللہ

  • @umarhameed9250
    @umarhameed9250 5 років тому

    Ma sha Allah. ghamdi saab u r great

  • @umarjan821
    @umarjan821 2 роки тому +1

    Not a satisfied answer

    • @redarrow-hyhy
      @redarrow-hyhy Рік тому

      Bhai Maria Qibtia Hazoor e Pak Muhammad e Mustafa ﷺ ki biwi thi.

  • @VIKASSHARMA970
    @VIKASSHARMA970 2 роки тому +1

    India ka naam sune ho tau.

  • @jawadali5050
    @jawadali5050 5 років тому

    Phir islam jang main kiun lundiyan bnany ka hukam deta hay?

    • @tinytales-studio
      @tinytales-studio 5 років тому +3

      Ap ko Kisi ny Ghalt Information de hai .. Islam Aesa koi Hukm nahi deta .. Bal k Is Fazol Rasm ki Muzammat krta hai

    • @jawadali5050
      @jawadali5050 5 років тому

      islam ijazat deta h main khud confuse hun k aisa kiun h

    • @tinytales-studio
      @tinytales-studio 5 років тому +1

      @@jawadali5050 kiya aap koi reffernce dy skty hain ? k wo kahn hukm deta hai ?

    • @gulamanekhadim5166
      @gulamanekhadim5166 2 роки тому

      @@jawadali5050 gulam banane ki nhi qaidi banane ka huqm hai. Fir unhe chhodne ka bhi huqm hai. Gulami aur qaidi me fark samjho aap

  • @mohammadshadab3364
    @mohammadshadab3364 6 років тому +37

    Pahli Bar Kisi aaleem ne ye masla sahi Samjhaya he . Islam me gulam ko le kr hamesha Dil me tees chubhti thi ki islam ise kyu Qubul krta he. Thanks Ghamidi Sahab .

    • @dharmender3248
      @dharmender3248 5 років тому +1

      Wo tees sahi thi islam kutta hai

    • @TECHINTIMACY
      @TECHINTIMACY 5 років тому +1

      @@dharmender3248 Ur so insecure so u bark in every comment

  • @mohammadmujeeb275
    @mohammadmujeeb275 6 років тому +14

    You may agree or disagree with him but javed sahab is a scholar

  • @ask6920
    @ask6920 Рік тому +1

    Original question not answered. This was not questions. Kindly ask him to reply Original question.

  • @arifnazir6370
    @arifnazir6370 2 роки тому +2

    Islam pe jo eitirazaat ho rahe hai unka jawaab dene mai ghaamdi sahab is d best..

  • @robanio100
    @robanio100 6 років тому +6

    Brilliant

  • @behtereen4187
    @behtereen4187 8 місяців тому

    MashaAllah ❤❤❤
    A great spin doctor defending the indefensible 😂😂😂😂

  • @saleemraja62
    @saleemraja62 5 років тому +2

    Jazakallaha!!!! Aise sawalo ke answers app hi jese log de sakte hain, appko hi Allaha ne wo khaas salahiyat de hai ki aise maslo ko sahi reply kar sake..

  • @mdaashu-em3wf
    @mdaashu-em3wf Рік тому

    Sir tho shadi q nhi ki Rasool Allah ne Maria se ..unke pass hadiye m aayi thi wo tho usse nikaah krke whi bandiya system khtm kr Dena chahiye that....

  • @mreza84
    @mreza84 Рік тому

    There is a lot of shame and embedment in Islam, this is only one of them.

  • @redarrow-hyhy
    @redarrow-hyhy Рік тому

    Hazrat Maria Qibtia hamare Nabi ﷺ ki biwi thi. Ghamidi sahab zra Sahih Muslim aur Hakim utha k dekhein.

  • @tanolimehmood2472
    @tanolimehmood2472 6 років тому +4

    بھت اعلی

  • @syedhussain693
    @syedhussain693 2 роки тому +1

    He had quoted the Quran ayat from surah 47 verse 4. But he never mentions the surah and ayat number.

  • @mushirzahir250
    @mushirzahir250 5 років тому +1

    Jo kaam nabi kiya wahi chngej temoor lng sikndar sabne wahi kiya ji

  • @AliKhawer-o9e
    @AliKhawer-o9e 5 років тому +1

    آپ نے کہا مجھے کوئی تُحفہ دے اور میں کسی کو دے دوں آپ نے ایک عورت کسی صحابی کو دے دی

  • @khalidcompany7717
    @khalidcompany7717 5 років тому +1

    A great scholar
    Stay bless all

  • @mushirzahir250
    @mushirzahir250 5 років тому +1

    Is duniya allah se mkkar na howa na hoga ji

  • @syedhassan233
    @syedhassan233 5 років тому +1

    سبحان اللہ

  • @bdu6624
    @bdu6624 2 роки тому

    Justifying every bullshit

  • @danishrehmanzai
    @danishrehmanzai 5 років тому

    Love you ghamdi saab want to meet you

  • @photopoint9651
    @photopoint9651 5 років тому

    fine explanation
    yeh pehla masla hay jiss main ghamdi sahib nay boht acha samjaya
    aur mujay koi gussa nahi aya........

  • @islamhashibul4471
    @islamhashibul4471 2 роки тому

    yY

  • @husseinali3401
    @husseinali3401 5 років тому

    Kyahi gariga

  • @khalidmeyyameyya4636
    @khalidmeyyameyya4636 5 років тому

    Good job! GOD bless you

  • @umor5280
    @umor5280 5 років тому

    War, prisoners of war, taking responsibilities of women from enemies, etc etc to be the reality to have women slaves or right hand possessions as per the Quranic law.
    If that situation comes in, Muslims have war against their enemies, taking people as prisoners of war, Muslims have to take the responsibilities of the women of the enemies too. Either they can marry or take them as their right hand possessions to stop spreading social crimes related to women and sex.
    But again, they have to give full right to the women in their possession as per Quran. Women will have similar social right, protection and treatment like their wives. Born children will have similar right of their wives' children. Born children of their wives and the women in your possessions must have similar right, similar protection, similar treatment.
    It’s a huge challenge for the believers. May Allah guide us in right way. Ameen, summa Ameen
    By the by, Hazrat Maria (peace and mercy be upon her) reverted to Islam before her death.

    • @nitie_bridging_the_gap4916
      @nitie_bridging_the_gap4916  5 років тому +1

      There is no slave concept after Quran specifically mentioned it that you have to free them, at the best you can take a compensation of them from your war enemies...this is what Ghamidi sb has explained in many lectures on slavery in Islam... in this case also it was explained that in that time of the world it was a slow gradual process as recommended by Quran and prophet also followed this and instructed for this, in case of Haz Maria every muslim accept her as ummuhatul maumeenin, prophet gave the best treatment to her as per the traditions of those times.

    • @umor5280
      @umor5280 5 років тому

      @@nitie_bridging_the_gap4916
      Assalamu Alaikum.
      I don't understand Hindi & Urdu, hence failed to read the speakers!!
      Anyway, if you kindly give me the reference related to omission of the Quranic law on Right Hand Possessions please. Slavery is no more allowed in Islam that I know. Islam is the only religion that made the way to stop slavery.
      But the concept of Right Hand Possessions is still in vogue.
      Zazakallah Khairan

    • @nitie_bridging_the_gap4916
      @nitie_bridging_the_gap4916  5 років тому

      Mohammad Aminul Haque the only door of slave beginning was war prisoners... Islam did not initiated slavery... it was there since centuries when prophet Muhammad was received Quran. At one hand Quran addresses the problem of existing slave by providing them rights and opening their way of freedom by many ways.....on the other hand in Surah Muhammad 47:4 it declares war of
      Prisoners will always be freed either by taking a ransom or by giving favors to them.. this was the gradual process of eradicating slavery... Quran never sanctioned it infect it gave laws to treat existing slaves and closed the door of making of new slaves...

  • @MsSonal12
    @MsSonal12 2 роки тому

    Wah wah kya baat h ye to pehle se tha to jb ek ideal personality kahe Jane wala insaan bhi wahi kr rha h jo kehta h ki use Allah ne bheja h to usme or dusre logo me kya fark h uske under itna bhi consciousness nhi jitna sanatan ke aam logo ke under 5000 saal pehle ta

    • @maxarcr903
      @maxarcr903 Рік тому

      Pata he brahma..ke vare me krishna ke baare me vedvyas ki maa ke baare me Ashvedhyagya ke baare me ...uifaao ke baare me....Ramcharit manas ke baare me pata he ..Mohini or Shiva Ke baare me....

    • @MsSonal12
      @MsSonal12 Рік тому

      @@maxarcr903 mujhe pta h bahot achhe se mere dharm ke baare me kuch ulta seedha Bola to soch bhi nhi paoge wo haal karenge mere dharm ke baare me kisi are gare se sunne ki zarurat nhi mujhe apne dharm ko jano pehle kis jahil, balatkari, jhoote aur dhhokhebaaj insaan ko Nabi mante ho jo insaan kehlane ke bhi layek nhi

    • @zeeshansyed6290
      @zeeshansyed6290 Рік тому

      @@MsSonal12 kya matlab kay ham kalboshan ko chor day? Nahi janab ham nay on ka sar mondwa diya hay😂😂😂 same situation may ab 1500 saal peachay jawo to aqal kol jayaygi.

  • @AliKhawer-o9e
    @AliKhawer-o9e 5 років тому +1

    میں آپ کی بہت سی باتیں سُنتا ہوں عقل پرتی ہیں
    لیکن پلیز اس بات کو واضح کر دیں
    جنگوں میں پکرے ہوے قیدیوں کے بارے میں آزاد کر نکاح کرنے کا رجحان کہ لونڈی کو ختم کرنے کے کئے آپ محمد نے حضرت صفیہ سے نکاح کیا آزاد کر کے جو کہ جنگ خیبر میں قیدی بن کر آئی تھیں
    پھر اُن کے بعد ماریہ قطبیہ کے بارے میں ایسا خیال نہ کرنا عدل ہے ؟؟؟

    • @tinytales-studio
      @tinytales-studio 5 років тому +1

      In Dono tareeqo sy Ghulaami Khatm ki ja skti th .. Ap (S.A.W) ny wo Dono Tareeqy Ummat ko kr k Amli toor pr dikha diey

    • @gulamanekhadim5166
      @gulamanekhadim5166 2 роки тому

      Unse bhi nikah huyi thi.... Kuch logo ki mistake hai ki wo log nhi samjh paye hai.... ua-cam.com/video/XYm_Gndyubo/v-deo.html ye aap dekh lo

  • @ashwinivalrchha4457
    @ashwinivalrchha4457 5 років тому

    Badi Safai se Gandhi Ko chhipaya bhai ne...😀😀