War between U.S. and China ‘would be disastrous’
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 тра 2024
- In his new book “World On The Brink: How America Can Beat China In The Race For The Twenty-First Century,” Dmitri Alperovich details a hypothetical Chinese invasion of Taiwan. He and Adm. James Stavridis join Andrea Mitchell to explain why China poses a threat to Taiwan and how the U.S. should prepare.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
War between U.S. and China ‘would be disastrous’
#China #ForeignPolicy #Taiwan
Certainly China’s recent history of illegal wars, occupations, regime change, and proxy wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, etc, are cause for concern.
subtle
Unlike the United States of warmongers and weapons manufacturers.
and also chinas use of nukes on hiroshima and nagasaki, and support of genocide in gaza
Yeah, because there really is no reason for the US to have invaded Afghanistan (harboring OBL), Syria (chemical weapons against it's own people and subjugating the Kurds and the SDF), and Libya (Muammar Gaddafi was a great guy, after all).
I mean, the US is just bad to the bone, am I right, fellow America haters?!?!
Hahaha... the sarcasm.... 🤣😂
I thought we weren't allowed to criticize war anymore.
?
@@Muttinchopsforeverandalways MAGA
@@only2genders02 Maga d u m b? I agree if its a yes
@@Muttinchopsforeverandalways Everything will be fine. After Trump wins, I mean. All this fighting will end.
@@Matt-1147 I never said that. If voting mattered they wouldn't let us do it.
Andrea Mitchell, please retire and give a younger person a chance. You can hardly speak...you're easily out of breath. Please rest and take care of yourself.
Agreed
You may be correct, but if you’ve noticed, a lot of the news anchors are leaning younger. Let her live her work till she wants…it won’t be much longer.
More like 'Country On The Brink.' Our greatest adversary is the multiple divides in our own country.
They will start a world war for unity. Nothing unites a country like a common enemy.
Black Kids Even Don't Know What a Computer Is 😂
New York Gov. Hochul
Leftists just can't get enough of that low-key racism from their elected Democrats.
Black people cant figure out how to get an I.D. Stacey Abrams.
I saw that ? What ????
You don't know China, but we know why the United States is so powerful. There have only been two wars in the United States, the War of Independence and the Civil War Our history teacher told me the most about this The Chinese have experienced too many wars in modern times and know the cruelty and serious consequences of war We will not start a war easily I hope that Americans and Chinese can interact more with each other to increase mutual trust If China and the United States start a war, it may have disastrous consequences for the whole world.
How come overcapacity is a issue now? Look like everyone is parroting the same narrative.
Also the phrase “At what cost ? "
They are all trained in the same “central kitchen”
@@happymelon7129 "Let me be clear!" I agreed eveyone is talking the same language in the Western media
@@yaucharles91 They need to follow the same agenda from the “central kitchen”
Training camp with paychecks, industry way to make Lies from US.
The United States is facing the biggest strategic nightmare (confronting China, Russia and Iran at the same time) and is unaware of the danger. Is it only when it faces China alone that it knows to be anxious and panic?
Biggest strategic nightmare is those 3 basket case countries facing the combined West whose economic and military might dwarfs them.
Don’t worry ! The U.S. has over 750 Overseas Military Bases around the World , with 313 Military Bases surrounding
China w/ Warships & Missiles . China should be the one who worried .
From my personal experience, Chinese prefer shopping, sightseeing, good food, and bettering their lives. They don't make money from wars, so they don't make wars.
But make no mistake, if you push them too far, they will chew you up and spit you out.
Nah...no those namby-pamby one-child-policy soldiers.
The US are war mongers, china hasn't been in a war in 50 years, they would get wrecked. China can't even cross the strait with their second hand me down air craft carrier. The US has 7 air craft carriers. The US is the number one arms supplier in the world. Multiple military bases all over Asia and Europe. China wouldn't stand a chance against the US.
They have zero modern day, real world combined arms experience. Those little boarder skirmishes with India don't even compare. They aren't chewing up as much as you think unless you are speaking about third world opponents.
@@ShawnHall And even in those little border skirmishes, they got their butts whupped.
MSNBC deletes my post because I talk bad about the US and then youtube highlights my post, Why even bother. They going to do what they want and censor what they want, this is as bad as china censoring their people.
the world needs peace and cooperation to solve climate change, pollution and other problems, not war
Her voice is becoming more difficult to listen to for me. Maybe smoking or over tired. Retirement.
Let a younger woman with talent take o over. We all have to face it sooner or later. Just saying.
when you accuse people with the things you’ve done before😂
American propaganda 😂
It would be disastrous tho. How is it propaganda
@@StrikeBolteafc disasterous for china
@StrikeBolteafc because it's news that is made to instill fear in the American people
Oh Adrian Greenspan please retire . You’re a billionaire. The voice is not so nice to listen to.
She sounds like she’s dying lol
Funny that here in China we never talk about these “inevitable wars” looming over. Ppl are just living their lives, minding their own business. But Americans and American media are always be “WAR WAR WAR WAR WAR” 😂
Yep, they never talk, but they do things to provoke a war. Chinese media will never oppose the CCP because we all know what the consequences would be. Still waiting for the new 12 dash line that the CCP will draw soon.
The Almighty Warmongers States of America !!!!
no they have been talking about war over in china. In russia, calling the invasion of ukraine a war can get you thrown in prison by the kremlin. Do some proper research next time.
Because the US makes tons of money talking about China. Everyone in the US is crazy about China!
indeed，no media talks about war with America within China currently.
yes, US can't win in Vietnam or Afghanistan....yet talking about a war with China😂
US lost Vietnam because the political leaders of the US pulled out of the war and enacted egregious rules of engagement to appease the US populace in order to get re-elected. The US was actually winning before foot soldiers were removed and the air strikes continued. Also Afghanistan was a war against an ideology. The populace lost desire to continue a war that was worthless due to being 20 year conflict. During that time only 2,000 US casualties vs many many thousand insurgents killed. Statistically a militaristic domination held back by strict ROE and cowardice in politics
Couldn't tell the difference between a weather balloon and a spy balloon, they can predict when China will invade Taiwan? American fortune teller?
lnspired by Gordon Chang 😅
In my opinion, there is only one thing with overcapacity, and that is U.S. debt😂
"Here at MSDNC we firmly believe that having only one candidate on the ballot is
...
The Very Definition of Democracy."
That's not how the Dems acted post-2016.
Don't be naive enough to think this is about voting red or blue. Its about not voting for Scumbaggery, a sociapathic, narcissist that only wants to be in the white house to save his own skin and not go to prison. It makes ZERO difference what party captain clementine was in, voting for him is suicidal to the USA
It aint Biden.
@@Matt-1147 She "conceded" and then has spent the next almost decade denying his administration.
@@Matt-1147 How can you forget the four years of impeachment based on false evidence and lies that you idiots still cry Russia interference over. Trump won 2016 fair and square but you can't accept it and still claim he lost.
Donald Trump's trade wars with China resulted in a U.S. trade deficit of $679 billion. To compensate farmers for their losses, Trump authorized $109 billion in direct federal payments. Additionally, 202,543 jobs were offshored, 1,800 factories closed, and the U.S. national debt increased by 40.43%.
Joe has kept the trade wars going. And even increased it. Do you really think reshoring is cheap? The trade war isn't about a political party anymore its a necessity because the world has changed.
Trump: trade war easy to win 😂
That’s it? Biden adds 1 trillion every 100 days. Biden debt is higher than trumps
STANDING STRONG is what turned a grass roots movement of AMERICAN PATRIOTS into an INTERNATIONAL POWERHOUSE! They OWN the MAJORITY VOTE here at home with the rest of the WORLD on standby and they will NOT forget how the PEOPLE OF GAZA or themselves were treated! Ya'll BEST show RESPECT!
Man, all these wars going on. Escalations and threats? Under a democratic rule? You don't say.
Gotta check my spelling, first. Because this is the internet and that matters.
More than life itself.
🤣
@@basketballman1854don’t u think that’s strange? Especially with the border deal they tanked
@@basketballman1854 That's interesting, because by my tally, we aren't involved in any war, there are no American troops involved in a direct conflict, and Biden ended our longest military engagement.
But please, tell me about how bIdEn Is MaKiNg ThE wOrLd MoRe ChAoTiC.
Not like the great Trump, you know, the guy who wanted to start a war to avoid leaving office.
But hey, what's a fact to a MAGA besides an inconvenience?
All these wars going on? What in the Russian bot is this comment? The video is literally a speculation, in the very title.
What's next, every video that talks about the 2024 election is going to have a MAGA comment saying: "Man, all these elections going on!"
MAGA comments give me a headache.
@NikosZaidGomez Russia, Russia, Russia. What in the heavy assumption is this comment?
Let's bring it down to Sesame Street difficulty. Just for you, Nikos.
Russia - Ukraine. That's one.
Israel - Palestine. That's two.
Why would they bring this speculation if it weren't considered an even 1% risk?
It's not hard to figure out, Nikos.
Four years ago, this wasn't even a question.
Welcome to earth.
Edit* Ooh I forgot to add:
Spineless cultists give me such a headache.
Also the phrase “At what cost ? "
They are all trained in the same “central kitchen”
Suddenly, America became an authoritarian regime.
I really like Andrea Mitchell. She's very savvy, intelligent, and empathetic. She also has a cute way about her. Don't know if cute is the right word, but along those lines.
Yeah especially when chinese military are trained, while it seems our military is busy checking one another’s pp for gender inclusion compliance 🥴.
war never changes
The show Fallout was released with perfect timing with what’s happening around the world.
I rather watch these two talking instead of FoxNews with intoxicated Maria and anti China Gordon
Any war is disastrous especially now. Worst time in history for a,war.
Yes it would so don't even think about it!!!! We know how you just gotta have a war. Leave those people alone!!!!!!!!!
.. Don't like to look for enemies if you want to live a long and peaceful life
For how many decades has China been providing practically all domestic goods purchased in the US? What is the financial ‘debt’ (as proportion of US GDP) that is annually, still owed to Chinese manufacturers ? What is the trade imbalance between the US and China? How much Chinese investment has been permitted in the US ? Conventional military conflict isn’t necessary; China already, it seems, one the commercial campaign! 🤷🏻♂️.
and it's not just here in the states. China is everywhere, family's with businesses' in almost every country on this planet. To think of the 2 most powerful military powers going to war is not a pleasant thought. I hope we can find a peaceful resolution to our issues.
They don't have oil or steel.
The US is China's biggest market. Corporate America imports Billions of dollars worth of poor quality Chinese goods because it's cheaper than making them in America, so the profit margin is higher.
American citizens buy this crap because it's cheaper and because many of them can't afford better stuff owing to 40 years of stagnant disposable income when adjusted for inflation. If corporate America didn't import it, Americans wouldn't be able to buy it and they would have to support American goods and jobs instead. Meanwhile, China's GDP goes through the roof and they build one of the world's largest militaries to threaten their neighbours. So who is to blame?
What a shambolic interview. Serious matters deserve better.
Its time to negotiate!!!!
About what? Taiwan?
Welcome to another deadly pandemic. Did you forget how many of us lost our loved ones?😢
Disastrous but profitable. If you can’t profit, you’re just further down the pecking order.
Only one side spokesperson invited? I want to hear all sides, that would be better jounalism n watch
If you think this channel will ever invite an opposing view on, you're dreaming.
the good americans who exports wars all over the world
China continue to open for business and seek cooperation with other countries. It's up to USA if it refuse to trade with China or wants to block whatsoever. China will continue to trade and benefits from world cooperation while USA can add all the additional cost in their goods due to its market intervention.
Draft everyone working at MSNBC
cant believe the stuff Americas will believe lol welcome to the matrix
So stop supporting foreign wars
Next 5 years. ? It would be too late till then. Time is now.
Good old american propaganda 😂😂😂😂
Have you consider China overcapacity in missile and military lethal hardware?
Modern war no need much experience. All new equipment technology calculators can close your eyes by press red button only. Old war already out of date.
No kidding.
🌎If the nations of the world had even half a functioning brain between them, they would have been able to perceive the steep environmental cost of yet another global war, in our already severely damaged planetary biosphere.
Bet the politicians kids won't be drafted
OBVIOUSLY!?
"Will be"**
No worries about war.. We have foreign policy expert *"shrimp and grits"* Kamala Harris to resolve matters.
Wonder if that reporter was fired for not asking Kamala the pre-set approved question.
Lots of racism in the ether today
@@jjhpor Where? I'm not seeing it.
LOL!!!!!
USA number one
Three stooges! : D
It's time to ban TikTok.
Ban YT as well because they're erasing all comments about the war
It's time to ban you. 😂
Then you can live in a world of lies. BBC CNN.....
Not really... the Fallout universe is the aftermath of a war between the US and China, and that seems like a fun world to live in.
From history record , the "P" need 45% appr;;;0va1 rate,
==>to get
==>re-e1e;;;;;cted.
But ==> "B" now only left 36%
Europe is the one paying the price on the Ukraine war. US is the beneficiary
America can’t do anything
Great advertisement for FALLOUT!
Utter BS..... What about speaking to your friends about helping Russia, say India.
Book should be retitled "How America can CHEAT China in the race for the 21st century"
China wont allow Intel chips.
China can't GET Intel chips, nor can they manufacture their equivalents.
@@judewarner1536 Just for now
Registered Independent and something I noticed is the MSM seem to be sacrificing the Mexicans and Asians for the Jews and Blacks. Certainly been fascinating to watch!
An important message from Biden....Don't! Lol
it would be disastrous. disastrous for china
For america.
🤣🤣
grand ma better quite job. form msnbc plz😃😃😃😃😃
🙏✌️🙏
Nato is strongest military & yet keep saying next 5 year, next 5 year. What's the point of delaying ? Delaying means waiting for enemy to become stronger than yourself.
The United States always talks about Taiwan and asks a question: Is Taiwan a territory of the United States? Perhaps the United States will say that Taiwan is related to U.S. interests, and the People's Republic of China's position is that Taiwan is China's territory. So using a point of view to discuss is related to sovereignty for China and interests for the United States. So China has two choices: peace or war. China cannot give in on the issue of sovereignty. In the United States, are you ready for a conflict or even a nuclear war with China?
No one was talking about this under the Trump presidency!!!
Trump (himself, not as a representative of the U.S.) was cozy with China then.
New A B C National Poll #'s Trump 46% Brandon 38% RFK jr 12% undecided 4%
Lets go Brandon
So those polls are not fake and rigged anymore?? 😂
Here in California Im enjoying my $25.38 McDonalds value meal, Bidenomics is really working for American families
Told you before the dumpster out back has all kinds of free food
@@Muttinchopsforeverandalways Help your self then.
Why didn’t you get the McDonald Trump special?
These Yankees have no shame
Yellow Peril rhetoric is a given.
You’re thinking of the Rebs. The Yankees have to constantly save the Union from the Rebs trying to destroy it.
Yankees 😂 ?are you from a old history book? GOOD Lord.
‘
We got more problems here on our southern border
NOT UKRAINE
NOT ISRAEL
NOT CHINA
2 days old account....😂😂😂😂 Learn English first 😂😂😂
China is behind the border crisis, don’t be simple
lol you must be nuts huh lol
@@walterbo7687lol literally
Secure our BORDER!!!
They've a lovely term for it, and we call 'DOUBLE STANDARDS'
Axis of Evil events: February 20, 2022 vs February 24, 2022. October 8, 2023 vs October 7, 2023. Beijing Winter Olympics Games concluded on February 20, 2022. February 4, 2022 : Xi and Putin met in Beijing prior to the opening ceremony. February 24, 2022: Putin ordered the invasion of Ukraine- laying waste to its land and cities with thousands of lives lost ! October 7, 2023 was the conclusion of the ASIAN Games in Hangzhou, China! A major participant was Iran. PRC government supports IRAN-BACKED HAMAS! This emboldened the Iran-backed HAMAS! A Gestapo style attack with armed paragliders and modified armed land vehicles will not win the battle but may win the propaganda war with hatred generated towards Israel as a consequence of deaths to thousands of Palestinian civilians! October 7, 2023 a day before conclusion of the 2023 ASIAN Games in China! Hitler had to WAIT for three years after the 1936 Berlin Summer Olympic Games to invade Poland and start World War II. Three years, not four days after, not one day before the conclusion of a prestigious sporting event ! Putin ordered the invasion of Ukraine only four days after the conclusion of the 2022 Beijing Olympic Games! Iran-backed HAMAS could not even wait for the ASIAN Games 2023 to conclude ! Coincidence or collusion! Two prestigious sports events hosted by Xi, both followed by death and destruction! One in Europe and one in Asia! Tik Tok that!
Takes about all my say have what you belongs my not wants but my say donald trump elections drops not ready me works noticed worlds
There was so much world peace with djt, then joe came along....
Yet another one of Trump's favorites "the poorly educated".
Russia is peaceful right comrade?
@@sg0771 Ukraine was Safe, COMRADE.
@@jjhporsome people in blue states have been poorly educated, and Trump loves them. So what's the problem?
@@michaelbrigantiok Russian, tell me how it was safe in 2014 too when Crimea was annexed. Or did you not know about that. Glad to see the kkk-elper krew is out and drinking today.
Propaganda
The Chinese were quite as a church mouse when Trump was president but not anymore!
They’re sneaky, is all. Their agenda to behead and replace the U.S. has never changed.
Where they really lol you must’ve forgotten when the Chinese realized trumps more mouth than actual actions they moved Into southern America directly helping up root American influence and spreading and funding fentanyl makers that makes its way to our border we are undergoing an information, cold and economic war with the Chinese in every part of the globe if we pull back that could directly in danger us which we have seen since trump’s ignorance in pulling back in some areas of the globe opening up a power vacuum the Chinese and the Russians have filled which directly lead it harming our economy ,troops and citizens around the globe
Oh come on man China's not going to eat our lunch they even gave Joey a balloon. Let's take this time to appreciate our first amendment, FJB
@@stephendmccormickjr8200
@@PaloDuro1021: I liked his comment. And so what if people like their own comments. If you don’t like the things you post then you shouldn’t be posting them.
Joe Biden and his supporters remind me of Germany in the early 1940's
That qualifies you as uneducated and gullible.
I thought Matt was straight
@@Muttinchopsforeverandalways "Keep the Juden out" - Harvard students
Source: you just made it up
Do you also say "you al?"
Trump 2024 🇺🇸
World Peace over World War
The Dems are hiding out today. That Judge Cannon hits differently.😂😂
LGB FJB
The 21st century will be the AMERICAN century. Don't forget it.
Yeah? What kind of American though?
@@BatCountryAdventures There's only one kind of American-- American.
USA lose already.
Trump 2024 Save America 🇺🇸
Secure borders
Strong economy and military
Energy independence
Brings jobs back to America
Pro bill of rights
Pro small business
Pro democracy
Pro freedom
Pro America First
Pro equality
Pro world peace
Helps our veterans
Affordable housing
Low inflation and interest rates for all Americans
Lower taxes
Supports poor and middle class Americans for success
Tell your friends and family.
Back Don't Trump🤡🔨🔪🔫🥊🔴👹🐘😈🤡
FDT
if your worker can accept $5 an hour , your job will back
Black Donald J Trump back okay work vote 2024
Omar... You don't make sense 😂😂😂
Not back Trump🤡👹🔪🔫🔨🥊🐘🔴😈🤡
I agree no Trump second term
lol CCP bot it’s always best to learn English first before an misinformation campaign lol
@@omarfierros4973 God. Learn english.
I stand with China
why US always talk about war!
cuz they are not weak like china and Russia
@@reds1122Or may be they understand world war 3 means nobody will win
Erase my comment. You are violating my FIRST AMENDMENT. Is wrong I will be back.