You are so brave to try a Neutrogena sunscreen around the eyes! After a few miserable experiences with their sunscreens just burning my eyes all day and even after I removed them, I swore them off forever. I love your sunscreens reviews, though, and can't wait to see what asian sunscreens you try out. Have a great week!
I had the same issue with Neutrogena! So disappointing because their sunscreen is an amazing deal at Costco…I was hoping I’d found my HG, but alas it was not to be
I gave in and tried the hydro boost one, (recommended by a good friend of mine) I still regret trying it to this day, I had to pull over and wash my face.
Yes to Asian sunscreen video, can't wait. Personally, I have stopped using any tinted sunscreens bc they stain my shirts. Yes, I can use two different products, one for face and one for neck and chest but who has time for such things? I switch around from the Canmake, CosRx and Skin Aqua. Thanks for yet another amazing video!
@@AbbeyYung It's nice to see that you didn't ruin your beautiful skin with tattoos. Have you noticed alot of people where you live getting tattoos? I was in walmart the other day and it looked like a biker convention lol.
Can’t wait to see the Asian sunscreen video!! I have four tried and true Asian sunscreens that never let me down --BOJ / Scinic super mild in the teal and white tube /Skin 1004 /and my favorite which is the Canmake mermaid gel clear.
Do you find a scinic spf more hydrating that skin 1004? I hate BOJ cause it’s drying on me. Love skin 1004. But looking for something a bit more hydrating
@@clisaa6974 BofJ is perfect for me in terms of hydration as I use toner n antioxidant serums underneath n I found the scinic too dewy for me so I think since u found the BofJ drying you will like the scinic!! it's way more hydrating even too much for me for spring/early summer but it might be perfect for u!
I actually LOVEEEEE the UV reflect by Naturium. To me it feels so silky and then completely disappears. This actually the only sunscreen that I don't dread reapplying at all, even over makeup. It literally fully disappears and feels like nothing on my face and it doesn't run into my eyes, it stays put. I was so excited to see you reviewing, I'm sorry you don't love it.
This is SUCH a helpful video. I really love the way you test sunscreens and talk about them. Not just sunscreens - everything, basically. I’ve found that 100% of the time so far, your reviews and recs work for me. I’m looking forward to the Asian sunscreen review!!! Thanks for all the work you put into this longer-form content!!
Thanks for your review of these sunscreens, Abbey. It just helped to convince me against using ANY American chemical sunscreens because of the eye-stinging factor as well as the fact that most of them will stain your clothes (not talking about the tinted ones). I anxiously await your video on Asian sunscreens as they are my absolute favorite! ❤
I haven't found Asian tinted sunscreens though? I really like a one and done as far as sunscreen with light or med coverage and not greasy. Even the colorsciene one has great coverage but to me is sooo greasy if using the correct amount.
The new la Roche Posay UVMUNE oil control sunscreens are my new holy grail! A bit annoying to get a hold of, but just so much easier to use in the summer it's worth it!
I love the First Aid Beauty sunscreen! It’s odd that it’s so greasy on you. I have extremely oily skin and this is one of the only sunscreens I’ve found that doesn’t leave me shiny and oily.
Please note like the last Asian spf review which ones are water resistant, contain fragrance or denatured alcohol!!! That was really helpful when choosing an spf!
Everyone raves about the Neutrogena Purscreen Mineral Tint, but I tried it and hated it. It never dried down and felt tacky all day. I couldn’t wait to wash it off. It could be the weather here right now. It’s extremely hot and humid right now. I may just wait until it cools down to try it again.
I am SO happy I watched this! I was so close to ordering the First Aid Beauty SPF after watching Angie/Hot & Flashy b/c she loved it so much! Um no, not if it's oily feeling or that just doesn't dry down matte. Why is it so difficult to find a matte sunscreen??!? Thanks for testing all of these!!
Yeah Asian sunscreens are so wonderful!!!! My current fav is HaruHaru Wonder Moisture fit airy sunscreen I think lol the names are so long 🤣🤣🤣☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️🤍🤍🤍🤍
It's so interesting how products differ from skin to skin. I personally love the FAB weightless mineral - it's my new favorite - the only thing is the texture feels almost too dry to the touch / matte for me. 🤷♀
@@pajamamama5965 on my skin the fab one doesn't get drier during the day. I happen to like that but it could mean it doesn't absorb oils throughout the day.
Would love for you to post what makeup you're wearing in your videos. Like foundation, blush etc. Sometimes I'm just in love with how your makeup looks in some videos and wish I knew.
Shiseido is the only high brand I really find working on my skin. I use to have oily skin, but it has changed over the years, I have dry skin now. So, I find the Shiseido to be a good choice for me. No allergies or whatsoever, it’s actually very smooth, and no white cast.
The First Aid Beauty sunscreen is my holy grail. It replaced my tinted moisturizer in my makeup routine. Just evens out my complexion super nicely and makes me look awake.
I had been considering the FAB and the Naturium sunscreens. I also lean oily, and was finding some mixed reviews for both of them. Sooo many people seemed to love them, but then I would find some reviewers strongly dislike them. You just confirmed it for me, I’m going to pass on both! Thanks for all your work in these reviews, and I definitely look forward to seeing some new Asian sunscreen finds! ❤
Love sunscreen reviews, thanks for the video. You review them in depth and it’s very helpful. Looking forward to the Asian sunscreen video! I use a lesser known sunscreen, the Kroger Shimmer Sunscreen, a dupe for the Supergoop Glowscreen. It’s a chemical tinted sunscreen. Dr Dray recommended it. It’s not too glowy for me, but I use a powder foundation on top. But I’m 63 and my skin is more dull and I need some oomph! I have combination skin and it’s not too oily for me.
My sunscreen pills on my temples too!!! I thought I was the only one!! And I too experience random eye burning! I got the La Roche Posay Double Repair and I couldn’t believe the burn; especially since my skin enjoyed the formula. I now use the EltaMD UV Clear and enjoy that just as much with no burn. Looking forward to the next review in the Korean sunscreens!!
I would LOVE for you to do a video where you list callout ingredients to look for in hair products! I find myself looking through ingredients lists WAY more since following you :)
I adooooore the shiseido one for a dewy look. It can sting my eyes if I rub them, but it’s still so good. It also wears great under makeup. I have dehydrated combo skin and I wear this primarily in the winters or when I’m in San Francisco. I actually love the facial oil feel. If you have oily skin you might love the bliss blockstar spf 30. It’s a matte finish without being super drying and it’s slightly blurring
I don’t know what it is but I swear you have the same thought process, or ways of thinking as me. When you were saying the sunscreens were making your eyes water more then usual I thought, it may be allergies because I suspected that with myself. So many things you have recommended have become my favorites. I always know you have my back. Take care Abbey❤
The new Naturium UV reflect sunscreen I also had problems of my concealer looking very dry and cakey when it usually doesnt with other sunscreens…I thought it was because my skin is dry and the formula is for more oily skin. However when I wear the sunscreen alone without makeup it looks fine…so I will just use on my no-makeup days or whenever I go to gym. However The Naturium Dew-Glow I never have issues under my makeup!
I have oily skin and my favorite continues to be the Australian Gold Botanical SPF 50 Tinted Sunscreen for Face in the lightest shade. Recently I started mixing my second layer of SPF with the Elf Halo Glow Liquid Filter in Tan/Deep to make it a little darker and add coverage, then I add concealer, set with translucent powder, and it’s gorgeous all day.
Would you ever consider reviewing some more “innovative” SPF’s from Europe & Australia. Like the weird Swedish Evy SPF 50 waterproof foam? It’s supposed to be effective for 6hours, lightweight, broad spectrum, great under makeup, etc.
I would love to try EVY but no one wants to ship to the US as it's an aerosol :( cult beauty cancelled my order. there is one site but you have to order over 5 or 7 bottles of it sooo expensive so haven't been able to try it.
Loved the video! I'm looking forward to the Asian sunscreen video, I always have so much irritation with American sunscreens. I'd love to see a video from you on expired products and knowing when to throw them away.
"Rubbing in" the streaks/white cast rubs off the sunscreen, AKA disrupts the film AKA decreases its protection. Same goes for putting it on in two layers. One is proven to provide better protection
Thanks for the reviews! I cried for you when you had the eye stinging at the salon! Yesterday I was using up an old fave from Peter Thomas Roth and it got in my eye and it hurt so much! GAH! I really wish the FDA would allow more of the ingredients in Euro/Asia/Australia over here, imagine how great the products we like could be if they didn't sting the heck out of our eyes! I tried mineral but my dry skin and mineral don't get along well (except Bliss and UltraMD,). Looking forward to your Korean suncreen review :)
I just ordered the numbuzin 1 to try. Cant wait for your asian sunscreen review! I wish the us would just get on board with more filters. I cant wear any american chemical sunscreen 😢 because of irritation
Love this channel, thanks for all the time and research you put into your recommendations. I feel obligated to mention that these products should not be rubbed over your eyes. As someone who sees dry eye disease all the time, that burning is your eyes telling you to stop. You only get one set of eyes. Take care.
Love if when you do mineral spf review if u mentioned which ones are very hydrating, sinks in fast and works great with makeup. Finding a mineral one is a nightmare for me
I'm curious if your first application is the whole quarter teaspoon recommendation and then a second quarter teaspoon or if you split the quarter teaspoon into first and then second application. Love all your videos!
Just want to highlight that the Shiseido sunscreen comes in different formulas/UV-filter depending on what region it’s sold in! For example, the US version differs in texture and filters from the European, and the Asian version differs from the other two. So anyone watching this review should have this in mind. I personally love the European version (needs to be shaken well), it’s perhaps one of the best sunscreens for both face and body I’ve used. ❤️ Does not dry oily at all, fels very juice on the skin and gives a perfect base for makeup. I just wish it came in an unscented version. ☺️
I was really looking forward to trying the new Naturium sunscreen because I thought it would be a more matte finish and not oily, but now I think I’d rather save my money. How unfortunate.
I subscribe to Consumer Reports, they take no advertising, so their reviews are not biased. They actually test the sunscreens to see if they live up to their SPFs. This years winner is Coppertone Waterbabies SPF 50. It's $10 for 8 ounces. The Super Goops got low marks😢
Thanks you for your review ! I will try the Paula's choice sunscreen for sure ! I'm glad you added it to your video, because had a hard time finding review of it. You should try the Shiseido Urban Environment Vita-Clear Sunscreen SPF 42. I love love looove this Sunscreen ! I don't feel it on my skin at all !
I've tried countless Neutrogena sunscreens. They ALL sting my eyes/make them water -- even the mineral ones!! (And, even though I have skin on the drier side, I can't wear non-organic susncreens; they feel heavy on my skin, which causes me to flush up and get hives; my skin just doesn't like the zinc, maybe -- ?) I've tried nearly all (if not all) of the sunscreens at target, Walgreens, Ulta, and Kroger. The only one that I can always count on -- no pilling or stinging eyes or feeling too dry on my skin -- is the Milani SPF BFF.
you have beautiful skin and your reviews are very straightforward while entertaining - good camera presence! suggestion: it would be helpful to know which of these sunscreens (if any) are water resistant (and how long) to give us an idea of what situations they would be most applicable too (e.g. sports, etc.) thanks!
GREAT CONTENT! As usual! I have yet to find a chemical sunscreen that doesn't sting my eyes! I have been hooked on Isdin for over 3 years now and not planning on switching anytime soon.
Thank you so much for testing chemical sunscreens (I'm allergic to zinc oxide) and for calling out lavender oil, which I'm also allergic to. Looking forward to your next video - I love Asian sunscreens.
Shiseido is dewy and I can deal with that to a degree, especially under a matte foundation. What I cannot handle is the fragrance. It is overwhelming and gives me a headache. I put it on my body and I can still smell it. And I don’t mean my neck, I am rubbing it into my legs and feet.
The Shiseido is the only one I ever used and I quite liked it. I wanted to try Glow Recipe as I like the brand overall, but its so expensive for a not so great sunscreen
You aren’t supposed to apply the shishedo twice. The claim that it gets strong water resistance as you sweat is valid - it actually becomes more blocking when you sweat or get wet! It’s extremely hard to remove (but of course comes off with cleansing oil).
Sunscreen is supposed to coat your skin as the more spf the denser the protective coating. So if you don’t feel the coating chances are it isn’t concentrating the avobenzone, octinoxate and oxybenzone enough to actually protect your skin well or it is filled with vitamin e oil or other oils. The perfumes that a lot of these sunscreens pack are horrible for your skin in direct sunlight.
Have you tried the summer Fridays sunscreen? I am an oily gal and I love it so much, especially under makeup! I actually feel like my makeup held up better with it underneath 🤍🤎
surprised to not see any k or j beauty sunscreens. I cannot stand 1st gen chemical filters as they sting. I only stick to 2nd gen chemical filters only. edit: just saw you're testing them for an upcoming vid! glad to hear. my favs/ones I've tried are BofJ, skin aqua uv mild milk in blue packaging with no fragrance n ethanol at the very bottom, purito soft touch daily go to (the "matte" version imo it's not matte but not shiny), scinic in blue/white packaging is just too greasy for me maybe I'll try in the winter again wasn't good for spring/early summer. I just ordered the Kaine sweat resistant in lovely mint green packaging and the new Pcalm water barrier sunscreen excited to try them.
@AbbeyYung thanks for the video! Just wanted to comment that I’ve heard pilling around the temple/hairline could be due to under-exfoliating those areas which most of us tend to do. Love your content!
Super excited to see a sunscreen review. Not a fan of dewy/radiant/glowy finishes. Thanks for testing these out and letting us know whether they burn, sting, and/ or make your eyes water. I avoid chemical sunscreens for this very reason. I’ve never tried Asian sunscreens because most are not water resistant. Many also do not have much product in them. When you test out the Asian sunscreens will you also let us know whether they burn, sting or make your eyes water? Thanks a lot Abbey😊💗
Rohto Mentholatum - Skin Aqua UV Super Moisture Milk SPF50+ in blue packaging is water resistant. it is also fragrance free n has ethanol at the bottom of the ingredient list compared to the other skin aquas by that brand. and the new Kaine green fit pro sun spf 50+ is sweat resistant. both are great! I also only use water resistant only in the summer n have found these 2 to be fragrance n drying alcohol free (for the most part with the exception of the skin aqua but it's at the bottom of the ingredient list so I took a chance). also kand J beauty have the same amount of product as western sunscreens 1.7oz or sometimes even more. don't let the small packaging fool you. neither of the above 2 water resistant sunscreen sting my eyes.
Ooo I’m glad you made this video, because I have been wanting the Glow Recipe spf, but I absolutely hate spf that leaves a white ring by my hairline. Nope no I will not be getting that one 😆. I noticed you never put your spf down on your neck? Do you apply spf on your neck? 😲 I always pull mine way down to my neck and decollate. I’m also glad you posted this video because Charlotte Holdcroft says she absolutely loves the Shisedo spf you tried, so I have been so curious and wanting to get it. But she never mentioned it being an oily type spf. So…I’m not curious about that spf anymore either lol. I’m currently using the Belif Aqua Bomb spf, and meh, it’s ok. It’s a little pilly around the hair line. I’ve come to the conclusion nothing compares to Asian sunscreen. They just are the best, period.
I have figured out that some of my seemingly random sunscreen irritation was not the sunscreen itself so much but disrupted skin barrier from getting chemical exfoliants or retinol too close to my eyes overnight making the skin super sensitive.
While none of these sunscreens would work for me, I want to say how much I love the way you review sunscreen. I don't like a glowy finish, and for some reason, almost all sunscreens look extra-glowy on my skin. Even "natural finish" makes me look like I have oily skin - my skin is on the dry side. Abbey's reviews show how much glow the sunscreen has when fully dry ... so I can judge how it would look on my skin. Most reviewers don't show this ... they'll show a drop on their hand, nothing else. [Angie at Hot & Flashy does a good review - but she prefers all mineral sunscreens.] I'm very much looking forward to the Asian sunscreen review! The Asian sunscreens show promise, but I don't want to order things I will never use because they make me look like a disco ball.
As a dry-skinned girl, I found that the Sheisido doesn’t leave the wet look on me, though I thought it might the first time I applied it because it is quite watery/oily looking. It does sting my eyes a little but only the left eye, which makes me wonder if it is a seasonal allergy thing.
We just went to the beach, put on so much sunscreen and still got so burnt. Would to love the efficacy of sunblocks in addition to how they feel, smell and wear under makeup. If anyone know of any they love that truly work. Please let me know. Thanks so much.
sunscreen is just one step in avoiding sun damage. it is not a guarantee to 100% prevent it. very generous and continuous application is required. at the beach reapplication is recommended every hour or every time you get wet. using a water resistant higher spf 50+ is also crucial. but that's just one step. wearing protective clothing (spf certified swimsuits, rash guards n shirts n pants), sun hats/visors that are spf certified as well as seeking shade and avoiding direct sun exposure are all very important steps as well. look into EVY sunscreens for beach/high sun exposure times. but even if u don't use EVY using other water resistant sunscreens (reapplying often n generously) n wearing protective clothing n sunhats, seeking shade etc will all add up.
Loved this review! A tinted mineral sunscreen that I love is the newer Hero Cosmetics one. It gives the prettiest glow without feeling sticky or greasy after drying down.
I thought the same thing about the first aid beauty one. What a disappointment, I was second-guessing, whether I shook the bottle long enough at Sephora because it was so oily. I would love a video comparing tinted Asian sunscreens. I feel like there is an abundance of videos on regular Asian sunscreens, but I’d love to see how the tinted ones compare.
I agree about the naturium one. I am more dry/sensitive and even then, my bb cream slid around during the day. I didnt feel like the sunscreen ever actually settled down. Terrible formulation.
Hi Abbey, I stopped using all US sunscreens. They're just not great. Can you do a review of European sunscreens? I think I like European sunscreens more than I do Asian sunscreens. Have a great week, Abbey! And hope you had a fabulous birthday!
Ughh I felt the exact same way about the FAB sunscreen. People were raving about it so I ran out and got it thinking it could be my new holy grail. As soon as I put it on I wanted to wash my face and get it off. It felt awful and the finish was not flattering. I returned it right away. I'm sticking with my australian gold.
Super excited for the Asian sunscreen video. I literally gasped when you put these near and on your eyes. I could feel the burn/sting through the screen. Ouch. I cannot wear any "American" chemical sunscreen on my face. I actually had chemical burns. Side note, the doctor was funny and said "well you will have a nice chemical peel." *Note it was not from the sun. The burning started before I went outside and I could not get it off my face fast enough.
Banana Boat Light As Air Sunscreen Lotion - SPF 50 --- the best body sunscreen imo. water resistant incredibly light weight to the point can't even tell it's on! not much in asian beauty in terms of body sunscreens as many rely on protective clothing n sun hats n avoiding sun in general. u won't see many at the beach etc. but I can't live like that so I use body sunscreen n seek shade when possible.
@@vanessarose9692 it's the best! hope u like it. also I can use LOTS of it n it will all rub in n still be 'light as air' even after multiple applications through the day. idk how they do it! wish there was a fragrance free option for the face.
I keep trying american suncreens only to dislike them. the eye sting is real and i have waterey eyes anyway but add a lot of the filters used here and the faucet is running. I also know I don't like tinted sunscreens because of how they color the very light hair on my hairline. For some unknown reason I keep forgetting this and will buy one and then remember why I shy away from them. I currently have the new FAB one. I have to force myself to use it just to use it up. I much, much prefer the asian ones and buy them in bulk when I order. I search for the unicorn sunscreen continues but the asian ones are far and away the best. If we could get the Aussie and more European ones to try I would love it.
Have you tried the R&R tinted sun serum by Undefined? It’s 50+++ all mineral with niacinimide and lots of other great ingredients. Just a little leery because it has rosemary leaf extract, and raspberry seed. A lot of positive reviews though. Would love to get your thoughts.
Dang- still hoping for that perfect Asian tinted sunscreen that's like the Beauty of Joseon but w a little blurring coverage and not glowy. Too much to ask? Probably. (basically Bliss Block Star but a bit more elegant under makeup) Also I have dry skin but also mature skin, so I definitely don't want a big glow to highlight my texture. Thanks for all the work on sunscreens! Most important! xx from Oregon
I think your right about seasonal allergies and eye stinging. Another reason i love asian sunscreens over US ones...my faves NEVER sting my eyes😊 Scinic and skin1004❤
I think you might like the Cetaphil pro AC dermacontrol moisturizing lotion spf 30, which is for oily skin but feels like a very light lotion and has a very watery texture. Technically it is a moisturizer with ceramides that allows you to apply two fingers of protection without a greasy finish. 🥰
The First Aid Beauty SPF felt so disgusting on my skin. Same thing! Super greasy and oily feeling. I was shining like a disco ball. I returned it after the first use.
Can’t wait for the Asian sunscreen video!!
Same!
SAME.
Love Asian sunscreens haven’t bought 1 that has failed me yet
I do love the shisheido sunscreen, but haven't tried either
Guess I have tried all Paula's choice
You are so brave to try a Neutrogena sunscreen around the eyes! After a few miserable experiences with their sunscreens just burning my eyes all day and even after I removed them, I swore them off forever. I love your sunscreens reviews, though, and can't wait to see what asian sunscreens you try out. Have a great week!
I had the same issue with Neutrogena! So disappointing because their sunscreen is an amazing deal at Costco…I was hoping I’d found my HG, but alas it was not to be
@@caitroseco6752 yes, I bought it at Costco!! I can use it on my body at least but it's a no-go for face 😥
I gave in and tried the hydro boost one, (recommended by a good friend of mine) I still regret trying it to this day, I had to pull over and wash my face.
Me too!😢
Yes to Asian sunscreen video, can't wait. Personally, I have stopped using any tinted sunscreens bc they stain my shirts. Yes, I can use two different products, one for face and one for neck and chest but who has time for such things? I switch around from the Canmake, CosRx and Skin Aqua. Thanks for yet another amazing video!
Filming it next week! Some amazing options coming in that video
@@AbbeyYung can't wait!
@@AbbeyYung It's nice to see that you didn't ruin your beautiful skin with tattoos. Have you noticed alot of people where you live getting tattoos? I was in walmart the other day and it looked like a biker convention lol.
Can’t wait to see the Asian sunscreen video!! I have four tried and true Asian sunscreens that never let me down --BOJ / Scinic super mild in the teal and white tube /Skin 1004 /and my favorite which is the Canmake mermaid gel clear.
I love Canmake mermaid sunscreen !
Do you find a scinic spf more hydrating that skin 1004? I hate BOJ cause it’s drying on me. Love skin 1004. But looking for something a bit more hydrating
@@clisaa6974 BofJ is perfect for me in terms of hydration as I use toner n antioxidant serums underneath n I found the scinic too dewy for me so I think since u found the BofJ drying you will like the scinic!! it's way more hydrating even too much for me for spring/early summer but it might be perfect for u!
@@clisaa6974 no I think the Skin1004 is more hydrating than the Scinic. Have you tried something like Laneige cream toner underneath?
@@clisaa6974my skin is dry as a desert, and I felt that boj is very moisturizing. Skin1004 feels identical to boj.
I actually LOVEEEEE the UV reflect by Naturium. To me it feels so silky and then completely disappears. This actually the only sunscreen that I don't dread reapplying at all, even over makeup. It literally fully disappears and feels like nothing on my face and it doesn't run into my eyes, it stays put. I was so excited to see you reviewing, I'm sorry you don't love it.
I agree! I found that it felt like nothing! I also blot it to give it a matte finish and it is incredible!
This is SUCH a helpful video. I really love the way you test sunscreens and talk about them. Not just sunscreens - everything, basically. I’ve found that 100% of the time so far, your reviews and recs work for me. I’m looking forward to the Asian sunscreen review!!! Thanks for all the work you put into this longer-form content!!
Thanks for your review of these sunscreens, Abbey. It just helped to convince me against using ANY American chemical sunscreens because of the eye-stinging factor as well as the fact that most of them will stain your clothes (not talking about the tinted ones). I anxiously await your video on Asian sunscreens as they are my absolute favorite! ❤
Filming it next week!!
I haven't found Asian tinted sunscreens though? I really like a one and done as far as sunscreen with light or med coverage and not greasy. Even the colorsciene one has great coverage but to me is sooo greasy if using the correct amount.
@lydia125 I don't know if a BB cream would work for you, but I've heard good things about the Missha one, although I haven't tried it.
@@rosej9686 I'm usually pretty happy with a bb cream. Great! Thanks so much for the recommendation!
@@lydia125 you're welcome 😊
Please never stop these!! I love that we’re getting so many new sunscreens to choose from here in the US
The new la Roche Posay UVMUNE oil control sunscreens are my new holy grail! A bit annoying to get a hold of, but just so much easier to use in the summer it's worth it!
I looked into it last summer but it was so difficult to find... thanks for the reminder to check again!
@@AbbeyYung I offered from cocooncenter uk and caretobeauty
I love the First Aid Beauty sunscreen! It’s odd that it’s so greasy on you. I have extremely oily skin and this is one of the only sunscreens I’ve found that doesn’t leave me shiny and oily.
Please note like the last Asian spf review which ones are water resistant, contain fragrance or denatured alcohol!!! That was really helpful when choosing an spf!
Everyone raves about the Neutrogena Purscreen Mineral Tint, but I tried it and hated it. It never dried down and felt tacky all day. I couldn’t wait to wash it off. It could be the weather here right now. It’s extremely hot and humid right now. I may just wait until it cools down to try it again.
I am SO happy I watched this! I was so close to ordering the First Aid Beauty SPF after watching Angie/Hot & Flashy b/c she loved it so much! Um no, not if it's oily feeling or that just doesn't dry down matte. Why is it so difficult to find a matte sunscreen??!? Thanks for testing all of these!!
I watched Angie too and was thinking about getting that sunscreen as well, now its a pass. I have oily skin .
I have combo skin -- I got a sample from Sephora and tried this, totally dried out my skin! Hard pass for me since I need something more moisturizing.
I love the Shiseido! I wear it under make up all the time and it is beautiful! IF you have normal to dry skin; I believe you’ll love it too!
It is great and doesn’t sting my eyes.
Yeah Asian sunscreens are so wonderful!!!! My current fav is HaruHaru Wonder Moisture fit airy sunscreen I think lol the names are so long 🤣🤣🤣☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️🤍🤍🤍🤍
It's so interesting how products differ from skin to skin. I personally love the FAB weightless mineral - it's my new favorite - the only thing is the texture feels almost too dry to the touch / matte for me. 🤷♀
Totally agree! That's why I was so confused by the reviews- very much depends on your skin :)
I have super oily skin. I like mattifying ones that absorb my oils throughout the day Like The Australian gold tinted. Does the fab one do that?
@@pajamamama5965 on my skin the fab one doesn't get drier during the day. I happen to like that but it could mean it doesn't absorb oils throughout the day.
The neutrogena one I loved when I put it on but the avobenzone KILLED my eyes. I had to give it away
Can’t wait for the European sunscreens review. I just know you would love several of the la roche possay, heliocare, and eucerin just to name a few.
Would love for you to post what makeup you're wearing in your videos. Like foundation, blush etc. Sometimes I'm just in love with how your makeup looks in some videos and wish I knew.
Shiseido is the only high brand I really find working on my skin. I use to have oily skin, but it has changed over the years, I have dry skin now. So, I find the Shiseido to be a good choice for me. No allergies or whatsoever, it’s actually very smooth, and no white cast.
The First Aid Beauty sunscreen is my holy grail. It replaced my tinted moisturizer in my makeup routine. Just evens out my complexion super nicely and makes me look awake.
I had been considering the FAB and the Naturium sunscreens. I also lean oily, and was finding some mixed reviews for both of them. Sooo many people seemed to love them, but then I would find some reviewers strongly dislike them. You just confirmed it for me, I’m going to pass on both! Thanks for all your work in these reviews, and I definitely look forward to seeing some new Asian sunscreen finds! ❤
I was wondering about the Naturium sunscreen as well but I’m going to pass on it too now ♥️
So glad to help!! And same... the Asian ones are so much better!
Love sunscreen reviews, thanks for the video. You review them in depth and it’s very helpful. Looking forward to the Asian sunscreen video! I use a lesser known sunscreen, the Kroger Shimmer Sunscreen, a dupe for the Supergoop Glowscreen. It’s a chemical tinted sunscreen. Dr Dray recommended it. It’s not too glowy for me, but I use a powder foundation on top. But I’m 63 and my skin is more dull and I need some oomph! I have combination skin and it’s not too oily for me.
My sunscreen pills on my temples too!!! I thought I was the only one!!
And I too experience random eye burning!
I got the La Roche Posay Double Repair and I couldn’t believe the burn; especially since my skin enjoyed the formula. I now use the EltaMD UV Clear and enjoy that just as much with no burn.
Looking forward to the next review in the Korean sunscreens!!
I would LOVE for you to do a video where you list callout ingredients to look for in hair products! I find myself looking through ingredients lists WAY more since following you :)
I adooooore the shiseido one for a dewy look. It can sting my eyes if I rub them, but it’s still so good. It also wears great under makeup. I have dehydrated combo skin and I wear this primarily in the winters or when I’m in San Francisco. I actually love the facial oil feel. If you have oily skin you might love the bliss blockstar spf 30. It’s a matte finish without being super drying and it’s slightly blurring
Could totally see those with dry skin loving Shiseido!
Same I mainly use it in the winter and supergoop unseen in the summer
I don’t know what it is but I swear you have the same thought process, or ways of thinking as me. When you were saying the sunscreens were making your eyes water more then usual I thought, it may be allergies because I suspected that with myself. So many things you have recommended have become my favorites. I always know you have my back. Take care Abbey❤
SO excited for your Asian sunscreen review! I have a Stylevana cart started but I'll wait until I hear from you!
The new Naturium UV reflect sunscreen I also had problems of my concealer looking very dry and cakey when it usually doesnt with other sunscreens…I thought it was because my skin is dry and the formula is for more oily skin. However when I wear the sunscreen alone without makeup it looks fine…so I will just use on my no-makeup days or whenever I go to gym. However The Naturium Dew-Glow I never have issues under my makeup!
Hooray! I’m so excited for that asian sunscreen review!
I have oily skin and my favorite continues to be the Australian Gold Botanical SPF 50 Tinted Sunscreen for Face in the lightest shade. Recently I started mixing my second layer of SPF with the Elf Halo Glow Liquid Filter in Tan/Deep to make it a little darker and add coverage, then I add concealer, set with translucent powder, and it’s gorgeous all day.
Would you ever consider reviewing some more “innovative” SPF’s from Europe & Australia. Like the weird Swedish Evy SPF 50 waterproof foam? It’s supposed to be effective for 6hours, lightweight, broad spectrum, great under makeup, etc.
Yes! Been using Avene. And love it! Staying away from all chemical sunscreen filters used in the US.
I would love to try EVY but no one wants to ship to the US as it's an aerosol :( cult beauty cancelled my order. there is one site but you have to order over 5 or 7 bottles of it sooo expensive so haven't been able to try it.
Would love the Asian sunscreen version of this!
Loved the video! I'm looking forward to the Asian sunscreen video, I always have so much irritation with American sunscreens. I'd love to see a video from you on expired products and knowing when to throw them away.
I got the skinaqua sunscreen a while ago on your recommendation and I’m obsessed. I will never go back to US sunscreens
"Rubbing in" the streaks/white cast rubs off the sunscreen, AKA disrupts the film AKA decreases its protection. Same goes for putting it on in two layers. One is proven to provide better protection
I really like the Neutrogena sunscreens. And they are adorable too
Thanks for the reviews! I cried for you when you had the eye stinging at the salon! Yesterday I was using up an old fave from Peter Thomas Roth and it got in my eye and it hurt so much! GAH! I really wish the FDA would allow more of the ingredients in Euro/Asia/Australia over here, imagine how great the products we like could be if they didn't sting the heck out of our eyes! I tried mineral but my dry skin and mineral don't get along well (except Bliss and UltraMD,). Looking forward to your Korean suncreen review :)
I just ordered the numbuzin 1 to try. Cant wait for your asian sunscreen review! I wish the us would just get on board with more filters. I cant wear any american chemical sunscreen 😢 because of irritation
Always had issues with sunscreens burning my eyes including LRP. Then started using Asian sunscreens and no longer have issues with eye burning.
Love this channel, thanks for all the time and research you put into your recommendations.
I feel obligated to mention that these products should not be rubbed over your eyes. As someone who sees dry eye disease all the time, that burning is your eyes telling you to stop. You only get one set of eyes. Take care.
Love if when you do mineral spf review if u mentioned which ones are very hydrating, sinks in fast and works great with makeup. Finding a mineral one is a nightmare for me
I'm curious if your first application is the whole quarter teaspoon recommendation and then a second quarter teaspoon or if you split the quarter teaspoon into first and then second application. Love all your videos!
Just want to highlight that the Shiseido sunscreen comes in different formulas/UV-filter depending on what region it’s sold in! For example, the US version differs in texture and filters from the European, and the Asian version differs from the other two. So anyone watching this review should have this in mind. I personally love the European version (needs to be shaken well), it’s perhaps one of the best sunscreens for both face and body I’ve used. ❤️ Does not dry oily at all, fels very juice on the skin and gives a perfect base for makeup. I just wish it came in an unscented version. ☺️
I was really looking forward to trying the new Naturium sunscreen because I thought it would be a more matte finish and not oily, but now I think I’d rather save my money. How unfortunate.
Two besy sunscreens ive found... Mad about dkin sunscreen.... Skin 2004 hylu cica sunscreen serum ... Can't beat them
I subscribe to Consumer Reports, they take no advertising, so their reviews are not biased. They actually test the sunscreens to see if they live up to their SPFs. This years winner is Coppertone Waterbabies SPF 50. It's $10 for 8 ounces. The Super Goops got low marks😢
Thanks you for your review ! I will try the Paula's choice sunscreen for sure ! I'm glad you added it to your video, because had a hard time finding review of it. You should try the Shiseido Urban Environment Vita-Clear Sunscreen SPF 42. I love love looove this Sunscreen ! I don't feel it on my skin at all !
I've tried countless Neutrogena sunscreens. They ALL sting my eyes/make them water -- even the mineral ones!! (And, even though I have skin on the drier side, I can't wear non-organic susncreens; they feel heavy on my skin, which causes me to flush up and get hives; my skin just doesn't like the zinc, maybe -- ?) I've tried nearly all (if not all) of the sunscreens at target, Walgreens, Ulta, and Kroger. The only one that I can always count on -- no pilling or stinging eyes or feeling too dry on my skin -- is the Milani SPF BFF.
you have beautiful skin and your reviews are very straightforward while entertaining - good camera presence!
suggestion: it would be helpful to know which of these sunscreens (if any) are water resistant (and how long) to give us an idea of what situations they would be most applicable too (e.g. sports, etc.) thanks!
thank you abbey!!!
when is the hair repair comparison video dropping!?
GREAT CONTENT! As usual! I have yet to find a chemical sunscreen that doesn't sting my eyes! I have been hooked on Isdin for over 3 years now and not planning on switching anytime soon.
Thank you so much for testing chemical sunscreens (I'm allergic to zinc oxide) and for calling out lavender oil, which I'm also allergic to. Looking forward to your next video - I love Asian sunscreens.
Shiseido is dewy and I can deal with that to a degree, especially under a matte foundation. What I cannot handle is the fragrance. It is overwhelming and gives me a headache. I put it on my body and I can still smell it. And I don’t mean my neck, I am rubbing it into my legs and feet.
The Shiseido is the only one I ever used and I quite liked it. I wanted to try Glow Recipe as I like the brand overall, but its so expensive for a not so great sunscreen
You aren’t supposed to apply the shishedo twice. The claim that it gets strong water resistance as you sweat is valid - it actually becomes more blocking when you sweat or get wet! It’s extremely hard to remove (but of course comes off with cleansing oil).
Sunscreen is supposed to coat your skin as the more spf the denser the protective coating. So if you don’t feel the coating chances are it isn’t concentrating the avobenzone, octinoxate and oxybenzone enough to actually protect your skin well or it is filled with vitamin e oil or other oils. The perfumes that a lot of these sunscreens pack are horrible for your skin in direct sunlight.
Have you tried the summer Fridays sunscreen? I am an oily gal and I love it so much, especially under makeup! I actually feel like my makeup held up better with it underneath 🤍🤎
surprised to not see any k or j beauty sunscreens. I cannot stand 1st gen chemical filters as they sting. I only stick to 2nd gen chemical filters only.
edit: just saw you're testing them for an upcoming vid! glad to hear. my favs/ones I've tried are BofJ, skin aqua uv mild milk in blue packaging with no fragrance n ethanol at the very bottom, purito soft touch daily go to (the "matte" version imo it's not matte but not shiny), scinic in blue/white packaging is just too greasy for me maybe I'll try in the winter again wasn't good for spring/early summer. I just ordered the Kaine sweat resistant in lovely mint green packaging and the new Pcalm water barrier sunscreen excited to try them.
The haircolor is gorgeous 🫶🏻♥️
@AbbeyYung thanks for the video! Just wanted to comment that I’ve heard pilling around the temple/hairline could be due to under-exfoliating those areas which most of us tend to do. Love your content!
I use Dr Dennis Gross's sunscreen - it's the best sunscreen I've used to date. It's really great to keep dark spots at bay.
Super excited to see a sunscreen review. Not a fan of dewy/radiant/glowy finishes. Thanks for testing these out and letting us know whether they burn, sting, and/ or make your eyes water. I avoid chemical sunscreens for this very reason. I’ve never tried Asian sunscreens because most are not water resistant. Many also do not have much product in them. When you test out the Asian sunscreens will you also let us know whether they burn, sting or make your eyes water? Thanks a lot Abbey😊💗
Rohto Mentholatum - Skin Aqua UV Super Moisture Milk SPF50+ in blue packaging is water resistant. it is also fragrance free n has ethanol at the bottom of the ingredient list compared to the other skin aquas by that brand. and the new Kaine green fit pro sun spf 50+ is sweat resistant. both are great! I also only use water resistant only in the summer n have found these 2 to be fragrance n drying alcohol free (for the most part with the exception of the skin aqua but it's at the bottom of the ingredient list so I took a chance). also kand J beauty have the same amount of product as western sunscreens 1.7oz or sometimes even more. don't let the small packaging fool you. neither of the above 2 water resistant sunscreen sting my eyes.
@@ninjaturtles12121 Thanks for the recommendations. I’ll check them out 😊
I’ve really grown to like the Kosas Dream Beam. It wasn’t a favorite at first, but I took it on a road trip recently and used it quite a bit.
Ooo I’m glad you made this video, because I have been wanting the Glow Recipe spf, but I absolutely hate spf that leaves a white ring by my hairline. Nope no I will not be getting that one 😆.
I noticed you never put your spf down on your neck? Do you apply spf on your neck? 😲 I always pull mine way down to my neck and decollate.
I’m also glad you posted this video because Charlotte Holdcroft says she absolutely loves the Shisedo spf you tried, so I have been so curious and wanting to get it. But she never mentioned it being an oily type spf. So…I’m not curious about that spf anymore either lol.
I’m currently using the Belif Aqua Bomb spf, and meh, it’s ok. It’s a little pilly around the hair line.
I’ve come to the conclusion nothing compares to Asian sunscreen. They just are the best, period.
The Isdin tinted version has become “the ultimate sunscreen” for an oilier gal like me. It feels so light and doesn’t irritate my eyes.
I have figured out that some of my seemingly random sunscreen irritation was not the sunscreen itself so much but disrupted skin barrier from getting chemical exfoliants or retinol too close to my eyes overnight making the skin super sensitive.
While none of these sunscreens would work for me, I want to say how much I love the way you review sunscreen.
I don't like a glowy finish, and for some reason, almost all sunscreens look extra-glowy on my skin. Even "natural finish" makes me look like I have oily skin - my skin is on the dry side.
Abbey's reviews show how much glow the sunscreen has when fully dry ... so I can judge how it would look on my skin. Most reviewers don't show this ... they'll show a drop on their hand, nothing else. [Angie at Hot & Flashy does a good review - but she prefers all mineral sunscreens.]
I'm very much looking forward to the Asian sunscreen review! The Asian sunscreens show promise, but I don't want to order things I will never use because they make me look like a disco ball.
As a dry-skinned girl, I found that the Sheisido doesn’t leave the wet look on me, though I thought it might the first time I applied it because it is quite watery/oily looking. It does sting my eyes a little but only the left eye, which makes me wonder if it is a seasonal allergy thing.
Shiseido Urban Environment is pretty good they have for normal and oil free. Works great under makeup too.
QUEEEEN i have been eying a few of these! so exciting
So funny about the First Aid Beauty sunscreen. I completely agree with your review. I hated it so much! Love your honesty
We just went to the beach, put on so much sunscreen and still got so burnt. Would to love the efficacy of sunblocks in addition to how they feel, smell and wear under makeup. If anyone know of any they love that truly work. Please let me know. Thanks so much.
sunscreen is just one step in avoiding sun damage. it is not a guarantee to 100% prevent it. very generous and continuous application is required. at the beach reapplication is recommended every hour or every time you get wet. using a water resistant higher spf 50+ is also crucial. but that's just one step. wearing protective clothing (spf certified swimsuits, rash guards n shirts n pants), sun hats/visors that are spf certified as well as seeking shade and avoiding direct sun exposure are all very important steps as well. look into EVY sunscreens for beach/high sun exposure times. but even if u don't use EVY using other water resistant sunscreens (reapplying often n generously) n wearing protective clothing n sunhats, seeking shade etc will all add up.
Loved this review! A tinted mineral sunscreen that I love is the newer Hero Cosmetics one. It gives the prettiest glow without feeling sticky or greasy after drying down.
you must be quite pale, on my skintone it leaves a noticeable whitecast
I thought the same thing about the first aid beauty one. What a disappointment, I was second-guessing, whether I shook the bottle long enough at Sephora because it was so oily. I would love a video comparing tinted Asian sunscreens. I feel like there is an abundance of videos on regular Asian sunscreens, but I’d love to see how the tinted ones compare.
I agree about the naturium one. I am more dry/sensitive and even then, my bb cream slid around during the day. I didnt feel like the sunscreen ever actually settled down. Terrible formulation.
My eyes irritation stopped when I started to use asian sunscreen for my face. Thanks for the great review
Hi Abbey, I stopped using all US sunscreens. They're just not great. Can you do a review of European sunscreens? I think I like European sunscreens more than I do Asian sunscreens. Have a great week, Abbey! And hope you had a fabulous birthday!
You have to try Dr. Dennis Gross mineral sunscreen. It’s gorgeous!
When my sunscreen peels it’s on my temples too! You’re not the only one.
I wear cetaphil mineral sunscreen mixed with La roche posay lipikar daily repair lotion normal to dry skin and my skin feels amazing
Ughh I felt the exact same way about the FAB sunscreen. People were raving about it so I ran out and got it thinking it could be my new holy grail. As soon as I put it on I wanted to wash my face and get it off. It felt awful and the finish was not flattering. I returned it right away. I'm sticking with my australian gold.
UGH right! Wanted to love it so bad
Super excited for the Asian sunscreen video. I literally gasped when you put these near and on your eyes. I could feel the burn/sting through the screen. Ouch. I cannot wear any "American" chemical sunscreen on my face. I actually had chemical burns. Side note, the doctor was funny and said "well you will have a nice chemical peel."
*Note it was not from the sun. The burning started before I went outside and I could not get it off my face fast enough.
Stunning job, Abbey!❤❤
Could you a video on the best body sunscreen? Would love some Asian sunscreen recommendations for that too and ones to wear when you are active!
i second this! especially some good affordable options since wearing/reapplying body sunscreens all summer can get expensive!
Banana Boat Light As Air Sunscreen Lotion - SPF 50 --- the best body sunscreen imo. water resistant incredibly light weight to the point can't even tell it's on! not much in asian beauty in terms of body sunscreens as many rely on protective clothing n sun hats n avoiding sun in general. u won't see many at the beach etc. but I can't live like that so I use body sunscreen n seek shade when possible.
@@ninjaturtles12121 I’ve heard that one was good but haven’t tried it yet! Thank you for your recommendation, will definitely try it now(:
@@vanessarose9692 it's the best! hope u like it. also I can use LOTS of it n it will all rub in n still be 'light as air' even after multiple applications through the day. idk how they do it! wish there was a fragrance free option for the face.
I keep trying american suncreens only to dislike them. the eye sting is real and i have waterey
eyes anyway but add a lot of the filters used here and the faucet is running. I also know I don't like tinted sunscreens because of how they color the very light hair on my hairline. For some unknown reason I keep forgetting this and will buy one and then remember why I shy away from them. I currently have the new FAB one. I have to force myself to use it just to use it up. I much, much prefer the asian ones and buy them in bulk when I order. I search for the unicorn sunscreen continues but the asian ones are far and away the best. If we could get the Aussie and more European ones to try I would love it.
Have you tried the R&R tinted sun serum by Undefined? It’s 50+++ all mineral with niacinimide and lots of other great ingredients. Just a little leery because it has rosemary leaf extract, and raspberry seed. A lot of positive reviews though. Would love to get your thoughts.
Dang- still hoping for that perfect Asian tinted sunscreen that's like the Beauty of Joseon but w a little blurring coverage and not glowy. Too much to ask? Probably. (basically Bliss Block Star but a bit more elegant under makeup) Also I have dry skin but also mature skin, so I definitely don't want a big glow to highlight my texture. Thanks for all the work on sunscreens! Most important! xx from Oregon
I think your right about seasonal allergies and eye stinging. Another reason i love asian sunscreens over US ones...my faves NEVER sting my eyes😊 Scinic and skin1004❤
Exactly!! Never have that issue with Asian sunscreens
Beauty of Josean Sunscreen is the best!
It is SOOOO good !!! I’m so glad I got mine off Amazon before all the counterfeit ones appeared. I bought a back up too.
I’m so excited to hear what you think of the Evy Technology Daily Mouse SPF 50!
I think you might like the Cetaphil pro AC dermacontrol moisturizing lotion spf 30, which is for oily skin but feels like a very light lotion and has a very watery texture. Technically it is a moisturizer with ceramides that allows you to apply two fingers of protection without a greasy finish. 🥰
I really wanted to try it, but heard it burns the eyes. Does it not burn yours?
@@lanadavis5820 Yeah
The First Aid Beauty SPF felt so disgusting on my skin. Same thing! Super greasy and oily feeling. I was shining like a disco ball. I returned it after the first use.
It's such a challenge to find any American sunscreens I like since I've tried Japanese and Korean ones.
How about a vid with the sunscreens in CVS, Target or Walmart?
many of these she reviewed here are available at cvs, target n Walmart.
Great review! What are your current favorite SPFs?
Thank you for mentioning eye sting this time!!
Abby, have you tried the Trader Joe's facial sunscreen? It is the absolute best! 🎉❤
heyy Abbey , so exited to see ur reviews
Thank you Abbey!!
I need you to try all the Supergoop dupes