I'm here for BoA and she sounds as amazing as she did back then. Debuting at 13 and took Asia & America by storm? Ain't nothing to sleep on in still sounding amazing as she did here.
Wendy's vocals are so clear like water, no wonder she debuted as a soloist with the song "Like Water" for the title track. Her voice clear and flows like water. 🥹
@@hihihihi1339 Why are you so free commenting on every video of Ning ning, Wendy and Boa? Lipsync or not, fans HAS ALWAYS KNEW that they are capable of singing live so your comment is rather irrelevant
@@suzaxnne9411 tldr: they are not singing live The audio you hear from this performance is the studio version or a pre recorded version that they heavily edited. People are saying they sang live when they recorded this performance though, which you can see at times, like with wendy at 1:47 and boa at 2:03. They actually change their expression when singing a note that usually is more difficult to hit, and their mouth shape matches what they should be singing . I dont know why sm feels the need to slap a clean, flawless version of the song on when these girls have no problem singing live. Its okay to sound breathy, uneven and not perfect while singing live, thats what make live singing live. Its ironic how sm produces the best vocalists in kpop, but doesnt let their artists show those skills.
Wendy is surely one of the best vocalist in K-pop and she is showing off her amazing talent. BoA is queen of kpop for a reason she is ace. Our Maknae Ning nailed it too her lower registers was my favourite but she didn't disappoint in upper too.
Ningning is really born to be a performer! The stance, the facial expression, the gaze, the way she moves his hand while singing. Can't believe Ningning who just graduated from being a rookie can now stand with vocal legends, BoA and Wendy!
After the accident, i'm happy to see Wendy able to stand on stage with this much confidence. The combination of Boa, Wendy, and Ningning is so amazing. SM should release another ballad unit and album. They have a lot of amazing vocalist now.
@@haruka.h560Wendy fell while rehearsing for a Christmas performance for SBS Gayo Daejeon (the stage/set was allegedly not yet finished and was very dangerous). She broke her cheekbone, pelvis and wrist.
There's truly something special about Wendy. She has a way of conveying emotions without having to try hard. It's just so natural and beautiful.A true artist
BoA's voice has so many raw emotions, NingNings high range is so pretty and Wendy's voice is literally perfect in every way. Their harmony is heavenly bro and their skills are insane 😻
@@11stem-ralphjonasbarbosa77 thats true but its crazy to me because we know boa and wendy have been in the industry longer than her yet shes already on their level
@@tanyaapollos7404 not really, they’re in different levels still, ningning still has no resonance, im sure the two singers singing with ningning are closely resonance. except for ningning, her range is developed, support is developed but she hasn’t caught the bottom of resonances
I'm really glad BoA was in this unit because she brought that flavor and emotion that this song called for. Her "time after time" in the chorus just pulls the heartstrings and makes one long for nonexistent boyfriends
As Wendy matured vocally, I’ve grown an appreciation for her voice! There is something so distinctive with her voice that I absolutely love! It’s rich yet airy but also clear but not nasally! The flavour she has vocally 🫶🏼
Tbh I haven't really found a fourth gen vocalist who impressed me, BUT when I first listened to Ningning my jaw dropped. Her voice esp at lower registers is sooo sultry and sensual. Omg ❤️
Wendy’s vocals always got me by surprise. Her voice is amazingly pretty. Not gonna even start with Ningning about SM giving her the stage she deserves to have. That girl is insane! BoA is also another level of vocalist.
보아는 이미 레전드라 춤 노래 모두 만렙.. 더 말할것도 없고 닝닝이는 감히 말할수있는데...걸그룹 외국인 멤버들중 가장 노래잘하고 닝닝이보다 못하는 한국인 메인보컬도 넘쳐나지 웬디는 차세대 태연이야..태연같이 노래에따라 창법을바꾸는게 뛰어나서 여러 장르를 소화할수있어 거기에 간드러짐이 대단해 트로트를해도 엄청잘할듯
Ningning is a singer since she was 9-12 years old, shes a performer already on stage at such young age, so some wonder how come she can stand on her own with these legends, BoA and Wendy. It's because Ningning is already a pro singer since predebut. She is very experience! Mind yall shes the youngest here, but her stage presence and vocals manage to standout. SM hits a jackpot on Ningning, they better give her more singing gigs like this!!!
I dont know what would male someone think that someone can sing like that if they have not been doing it since early childhood. Its not like All of the sudden Wendy foumd out she could sing when she was 13, she knew and everyone knew long before that
because the insane notes are lip synced not live (not saying she cant sing it, just more risky to do live), so they do a wide shot so its less obvious and harder to tell
@@SC-hi6tp sorry for saying this but wendy sing it live! She even noticed why heard like a lipsync. And she even mentioned about why camera took it for far away.
Ningning going full of chest for her low register is just 🔥 Development on all vocal registers, great agility, know exactly how to fit in with different vocalists and different genres, all at the age of 20.
I'm here for BoA and she sounds as amazing as she did back then. Debuting at 13 and took Asia & America by storm? Ain't nothing to sleep on in still sounding amazing as she did here.
💛
Boais the best vocal in this trio.
@@timothy0011000dont set Boa up like that
@@timothy0011000thay are all the best vocalists with diferrent color of voice. Dont compare
보아 보컬 진짜 짱짱하고 듣기 편하다
boa's emotion through the song oh gof
Ningning's adlib is out of this world.
Wendy is the best vocal quality and dynamics I'd ever heard.
Wendy and Ningnings adlibs during the last chorus are actually INSANE
Exactlyyyy
SO TRUE
favvvv
Yes
frfr its actually deadly… I’m still in a chokehold
Wendy controls her voice better than the way I control my life
=)))))))
LOL😂
Hahahaahaha,...,,
haha so funny
Wendy's voice is higher than my future haha
Wendy's voice always gives me goosebumpsㅠㅠㅠ Queen of Vocal!!
Our Finest Vocalist. Wendy Shon
Goosebumps don't lie
👑👑👑
보아 진짜 음색 짱이다 미쳤어요
Wendy’s singing has such a soul that touches your heart
Yesss
I got goosebumps by Wendy's vocals. Best voice literally.
Wendy's vocals are so clear like water, no wonder she debuted as a soloist with the song "Like Water" for the title track. Her voice clear and flows like water. 🥹
Kalau begitu segera kan wendy rilis album berikutnya
보아 이 분위기 너무 좋아 미칠거같음
Wendy's vocals never disappoint it was so clear.......
Tentu saja
wendy's voice is amazing
@hihihihi this is NOT Lipsync
@hihihihi post-production maybe. But wendy herself said that they sang live that's why she's confused as to why they look like they're lipsyncimg
@hihihihi lol it's not
@@hihihihi1339 Why are you so free commenting on every video of Ning ning, Wendy and Boa? Lipsync or not, fans HAS ALWAYS KNEW that they are capable of singing live so your comment is rather irrelevant
@hihihihi OK??? we all know you hate talented women
Boa's raspy voice, Ningning's mature voice and Wendy's crystal clear voice 💓
Well put!
is the performance live or are they lip syncing?
@@suzaxnne9411 live
@@suzaxnne9411 tldr: they are not singing live
The audio you hear from this performance is the studio version or a pre recorded version that they heavily edited. People are saying they sang live when they recorded this performance though, which you can see at times, like with wendy at 1:47 and boa at 2:03. They actually change their expression when singing a note that usually is more difficult to hit, and their mouth shape matches what they should be singing . I dont know why sm feels the need to slap a clean, flawless version of the song on when these girls have no problem singing live. Its okay to sound breathy, uneven and not perfect while singing live, thats what make live singing live.
Its ironic how sm produces the best vocalists in kpop, but doesnt let their artists show those skills.
@@suzaxnne9411 this live voice
숏츠로 부른거 보고 보아목소리 너무 좋아서 찾아옴;;;
저도요 보아 미쳤음 ..
저도요 웬디... 크리스마송 하나 내자 ...
야 나두
웬디가 돋보적이다 노래를 이끌어가네 그다음 보아 닝닝
저두요❤ 완전 반했어욥
Wendy is surely one of the best vocalist in K-pop and she is showing off her amazing talent. BoA is queen of kpop for a reason she is ace. Our Maknae Ning nailed it too her lower registers was my favourite but she didn't disappoint in upper too.
Wendy is technically the best 3rd gen kpop female vocalist, no one from her generation is at her level
@@Elvsianmamamo solar is ahead of wendy if not the same level
@@liibanboojo1673 Nope Wendy Is Still Better Than Mamamoo Solar, Mamamoo Solar And Red Velvet Wendy Aren’t Not Close In Vocals
@@hannavang1594 nah solar is away ahead of wendy thats fact
Its your opinion @@liibanboojo1673but wendy is ahead solar 😂😂😂
드디어 공식영상이!!!! ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 보아 목소리 미쳐버려 감정이 다 느껴지는 저 먹먹하고 힘있는 진성과 청아한 가성 그걸 자유자재로 넘나들며 노래를 갖고노는 보컬 사랑합니다
Ningning impresses me more and more every day.
In the future this girl will make history, and will have an incredible future as a soloist
BoA unnie
From 1st gen to 4th gen, SM will never disappoint on the vocal department ♥️
@@hihihihi1339 attention seeker
@hihihihi ....? This is a live singing.... and other aespa's performances in this concert are live singing too...
@@iffabashir Wendy said SM put the pre recorded one even they performed live in the video.
@hihihihi Don’t asking, because you’re deaf.
@hihihihi เป็นเหี้ยไร
3 VOCAL QUEENS TOGETHER!!
@@hihihihi1339 heres the attention u want
@@hihihihi1339no lol, ningning already sang in live and her vocal is amazing, wake uppp
@@hihihihi1339 "you just want attentiooon"
@hihihihi keep hating 😝
@hihihihi keep on hating kiddo, we got another stream lmao
Ningning is really born to be a performer! The stance, the facial expression, the gaze, the way she moves his hand while singing. Can't believe Ningning who just graduated from being a rookie can now stand with vocal legends, BoA and Wendy!
보아 진짜 분위기 개치임ㅠㅠㅠ
Wendy proving why she's the best main vocalist of the 3rd generation k-pop.
After the accident, i'm happy to see Wendy able to stand on stage with this much confidence. The combination of Boa, Wendy, and Ningning is so amazing. SM should release another ballad unit and album. They have a lot of amazing vocalist now.
sorry for my ignorance.. can I ask what accident ?
she fell off an 8(?) meter high stage and fractured many bones including face bones. Search "Wendy redvelvet stage accident"@@haruka.h560
@@haruka.h560Wendy fell while rehearsing for a Christmas performance for SBS Gayo Daejeon (the stage/set was allegedly not yet finished and was very dangerous). She broke her cheekbone, pelvis and wrist.
There's truly something special about Wendy. She has a way of conveying emotions without having to try hard. It's just so natural and beautiful.A true artist
음색에서 감정의 깊이가 느껴지고 애드리브가 작위적이지 않고 대사 처럼 들림. 보아 목소리 너무 좋다
BoA's voice has so many raw emotions, NingNings high range is so pretty and Wendy's voice is literally perfect in every way. Their harmony is heavenly bro and their skills are insane 😻
Yup. Boa voice was colorful
ong
Yea, boa's vocal texture is very unique
Wendy deserves a song like this for her solo album!
Ningning's voice is literally disney princess type of voice
보아 목소리는 마음 어디 한구석에 처박혀 있던 어린 시절 기억 한 줌을 소생시키는 마성의 힘이 있음... 롱런하는 곡이 많은 게 그것 때문이 아닐지
Really like Ning's lows. Boa's voice is so full. Wendy has ascended. Wendy is beast mode.
Wendy's vocal techniques 🤩 she's sooooo incredible
Like an international singer Wendy you slay as always
셋 목소리 다 다르고 넘 어울려서 조합이 좋다☺️ 보아 코로나 걸리고 계속 목 회복 안 될 때였을텐데 이정도라니ㅠㅠ 실제로 들어보고싶다 흑ㅠㅠ
It's crazy how NINGNING can keep up with SM's two top tier vocalists.
that's the reason she's aespa's main vocal
😍😍😍
she’s also top tier
@@11stem-ralphjonasbarbosa77 thats true but its crazy to me because we know boa and wendy have been in the industry longer than her yet shes already on their level
@@tanyaapollos7404 not really, they’re in different levels still, ningning still has no resonance, im sure the two singers singing with ningning are closely resonance. except for ningning, her range is developed, support is developed but she hasn’t caught the bottom of resonances
wendy's vocals always stand out to me, no matter who she's singing with.
yessssss
Spitting facts🔥💯
The best vocalist in 3rd Gen indeed😊👍
Our finest vocalist 💙
🌼🌼🌼
Wendy's voice is so beautiful and soulful... wow.. also im glad ningning was included i think i barely get to hear her sing
첨에 셋 조합 듣고 웬디가 제일 돋보일줄 알았는데 보아가 너무 잘해서 할말을 잃음... 깊이가 다른 느낌
She's so amazing, she can add so many different flavors to her voice and vocals, she extracts emotions out of a song you didn't even know were there!
상상 이상으로 차이가 많이나네... 이정도였나
난 닝닝이 진짜 잘하는듯,,,
진짜 마자요 나도 할말을잃음
와인에 버터 녹인 느낌
WENDY YOU MAKE ME SMILE
Wendy, You make me smile with your beautiful vocal 💙
Wendy's vocal range, I think it's getting wider and wider, she's Awesome
If I remember correctly, she has either a 3 or 4 octave range. Wendy has a massive amount of power in that tiny body of hers.
@@McKavian it's 4-octave 🤗
Boa voice is so deep then so high then deep then high wtf she sing so fking amazing.
For new sm Stans
0:09 BoA-Solo(saved SM from bankrupt at the age of 14)
0:28 NingNing-æspa(maknae at SM)
0:39 Wendy-Red Velvet(SM‘s vocal weapon)
I loved BoA’s description
BoA ❤️❤️❤️
@@Factsaintdefamationn cuz it’s true 💅🏻
Boa also sold over 10M albums when kpop wasn't even global like now.
@@hihi-po2tb BoA is an icon
I'm really glad BoA was in this unit because she brought that flavor and emotion that this song called for. Her "time after time" in the chorus just pulls the heartstrings and makes one long for nonexistent boyfriends
HER VOICE IT'S SO FULL OF FEELING I LOVE IT IT'S UNREAL
Well-said 😊
High note Wendy make addictive , so proud of you Wendy best singer gen 3💙💙💙💙
보아 레드와인 웬디 화이트와인 닝닝 샴페인 같음 셋 목소리에 오지게 취한다
표현 미쳣다 ㅋㅎ 이거지예………….
ㅠㅠ 진짜 셋다최고임😢
레드와인이 ㄹㅇ
The VOCALS wow and Wendy tho 🔥🔥
The vocal strength and power of Wendy is really something 💙😱
As Wendy matured vocally, I’ve grown an appreciation for her voice! There is something so distinctive with her voice that I absolutely love! It’s rich yet airy but also clear but not nasally! The flavour she has vocally 🫶🏼
보아 목소리 진짜 미쳤다 요새 이런 보컬 없나? 잘하는 사람들은 많은대 이런 허스키하면서 고음 시원하게 뽑는게 몇번씩 들어도 소름돋는다
개인적으로 가창력은 몰라도 음색은 카리나랑 비슷한듯
@@gaeppoppo카리나는 더 쨍해요 비슷한 음색은 없는듯
손승완 진짜 명창이다... 보컬 너무 탄탄하고 라이브 너무 잘해ㅠㅠㅠ💙💙💙💙💙
wendy's voice has that western singers influence she sounds so soulful and clear i love it
I mean she is Canadian-Korean but I agree
@@farahahmedkarim377 she's korean but she studied in Canada a couple of years
@@ShadowUpOnePiece yeah, that's what I meant lol. She also lived in the US for a little bit
@@farahahmedkarim377Canada is in the west?
@@cosmosisrose yup, makes up north 'murica alongside the USA and Mexico lol
웬디 보컬 무슨 일이야ㅠㅜ 무작정 고음 잘하는게 아니라 노래 분위기에 맞게 톤이며 창법까지 조절하며 부른다는게 너무 대단하고 대견하고💙💙
보아언니 노래 더 듣고 싶어요 나무, 바보같죠, 에버라스팅, 등등 댄스 곡도 좋지만 이렇게 노래 부르는 언니 모습도 그리워요
wendy has just proved again why she is the best vocalist of the DECADE
Love Ningning's lower range with deep tone.
Wendy is true singer.
BoA has been always special part in my heart since she debuted in Japan.
Tbh I haven't really found a fourth gen vocalist who impressed me, BUT when I first listened to Ningning my jaw dropped. Her voice esp at lower registers is sooo sultry and sensual. Omg ❤️
@@sleepingpanda467 true ningning can make a high rage and make it low at the same time, she is amazing
Love wendy voice in this song,,
really addicted to listening to wendy's part💙
2:25 내 기준 극락 파트
허스키한 건가? 싶으면서도 깔끔한 호소력 짙은 고음 정확한 피치
2:10 WENDY'S ADLIBS JUST GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS
보아목소리는 참 꿈결같다. 고음이 이렇게 따뜻하고 포근할수가 있다니ㅜㅜ 웬디의 청량한 고음과 닝닝의 맑은 음색이 더해져서 무대 찢음👍
Wendy OMG Queen ❤
다 너무 잘하는데
보아 미쳤다….
Ning ning and BoA's voice: seductive and entrancing
Wendy's voice: Absolute Royalty
Wendy’s voice has so much power, such stability and emotions !!! It give me chills !!!! ❤
Wendy surprises me every time she sings
how can wendy sings really highnotes without changing in her facial expressions !! she hits them comfortably!! wow queen
NINGNING WE ARE SO PROUD OF YOU
WENDY I CAN LISTEN TO U ALL DAYYYY
The goosebumps....... After WENDY starts singing ... ACE
Boa’s voice is angelic.. wow!
Ah, my favorite track from the album. I love Wendy so so so much 🤧💙
Wendy’s vocals are on another level! That’s my queen! 💙
wendy vocal is no joke! her voice so flexible 🤩
와 보아 목소리 존재감 뭐냐? 미쳤네 진짜........
Wendy’s vocals always got me by surprise. Her voice is amazingly pretty. Not gonna even start with Ningning about SM giving her the stage she deserves to have. That girl is insane! BoA is also another level of vocalist.
웬디 진짜 노래 넘 잘 부른다...rnb노래에 목소리도 넘 잘 어울리고 잘 부르고 진짜 최고야...
닝닝이는 손짓부터 목소리까지 다 너무 우아하다..
보아가 노래를 너무 잘하네....
Wendy's vocals never fail! I am in awe! specially her adlibs starting 2:10 💙
Wendy Vocal so so amazing
보아는 이미 레전드라 춤 노래 모두 만렙.. 더 말할것도 없고
닝닝이는 감히 말할수있는데...걸그룹 외국인 멤버들중 가장 노래잘하고
닝닝이보다 못하는 한국인 메인보컬도 넘쳐나지
웬디는 차세대 태연이야..태연같이 노래에따라 창법을바꾸는게 뛰어나서 여러 장르를 소화할수있어
거기에 간드러짐이 대단해 트로트를해도 엄청잘할듯
외국인 보컬 1등은 릴황아닌가요?ㄷㄷ
@@박기연-j9y 닝닝 릴리 이 둘을 놓고 누가 더 실력이 좋다 뭐 이런 걸 따질 수 있는
영역에 있는 아이돌들이 아닌 거 같아요. 둘 다 너무 잘해서
보아 진짜 대박 혼자만 주파수가 다른 느낌
I LOVE BOA VOCAL COLOUR
Wendy is just so beautiful and her voice, omg. I feel like im in heaven when I listen to her
Wendy's voice is clearer than my future i don't know what to say i'm speechless
BoA is the best.I love you so much.Thats the great honest for me to be your fan over 20 years.
Ningning is a singer since she was 9-12 years old, shes a performer already on stage at such young age, so some wonder how come she can stand on her own with these legends, BoA and Wendy. It's because Ningning is already a pro singer since predebut. She is very experience! Mind yall shes the youngest here, but her stage presence and vocals manage to standout. SM hits a jackpot on Ningning, they better give her more singing gigs like this!!!
So, do you think Wendy did not start singing when she was probably 3 years old and her parents did not already know she was special.
I dont know what would male someone think that someone can sing like that if they have not been doing it since early childhood. Its not like All of the sudden Wendy foumd out she could sing when she was 13, she knew and everyone knew long before that
SM artists really never disappoint when it comes to vocals damn 🥵
You know Wendy’s belting high notes and doing insane adlibs when there’s a wide group shot 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
FR!!! Why do they always do that?!? Let Wendy be on the spotlight when it's her, belting hmmp
because the insane notes are lip synced not live (not saying she cant sing it, just more risky to do live), so they do a wide shot so its less obvious and harder to tell
@@SC-hi6tp actually wendy said on bubble this was live and was complaining how bad the camera work was…
@@SC-hi6tp Your faves lipsync but Wendy does not. Do not associate a real singer like Wendy to their level.
@@SC-hi6tp sorry for saying this but wendy sing it live! She even noticed why heard like a lipsync. And she even mentioned about why camera took it for far away.
보아는 진짜 올타임레전드다,,
Ningning can hit both low and high notes so well. Our 4th gen main vocalist 🫶🏻
she is 4th gen friend
Better not let other 4th gen fans see this
Low regist!!!!!!❤
@@vixarts4114 heavy on nswers
@@szathebaddie5272 why you're mentioning them
Ningning effortlessly hitting high notes I get goosebumps, This trio we never asked for omg
Fr I need them to release and album asap
Ningning going full of chest for her low register is just 🔥 Development on all vocal registers, great agility, know exactly how to fit in with different vocalists and different genres, all at the age of 20.
Yeah low register nice
이 여자들도 또 보컬 차력쑈 하네... 미쳤네.... 진짜 SM에는 매미들이 왤케 많냐 다들 체구는 요정사이즌데 성량이 장군님이셔...
SM artists truly hold their ground in the industry when it comes to having godly vocals
How could Wendy voice sound like heaven ? 😩✨💞
정말 몇 번을 돌려봤는지 모르겠어요.. 매번 새롭고 매번 좋고.. 이런거 많이많이 내주세요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Let's appreciate NINGIE'S visual too,looked so classy and gorgeous....Really main visual material!!! 😻🦋🔥