@@Rains_fairy look im not gonna lie,but I just recently broke up with my bf,and hearing her sing this in live,all the emotions came crawling back to me like,I’m just bawling my eyes out😭
@@yukiichan4685 omg I'm going through the same thing but it's a friendship situation it ended in the worst way possible after 6 years so I can relate and kinda feel what you're feeling but I've just started a relationship recently it's helping me go through it, hope it lasts Breakups are never easy, and I hope you find healing and peace soon. And sometimes music is the best way to let out those emotions. Take your time, and remember, better days are ahead. You’ve got this! 🌸
@@thomasche Korean makeup techniques are so advanced that they can create a nose bridge that looks like it's been surgically enhanced. However, Rosé and Jennie don’t wear heavy makeup. Many idols look the same as when they were young without makeup, but with makeup, they are often misunderstood as having had plastic surgery. Korean makeup is truly the best.
I’m really glad she is going solo, her potential was so locked up under YG. We never got to hear this much emotions in her voice before. So much vulnerability yet strength… I’m shook.
These days in kpop it is very rare to see an idol who is an artist,It's all about visuals and dancing and they forget the most important part which is SINGING and live congratulations Rosé your efforts are bearing fruit, I wish you all the success you deserve and more.
It's still hard to surpass IU's success as a soloist. But I'm pretty sure Rosé will make her own mark, her music reaching to those who need it. A great artist of her own merit.
She's an amazing live singer. This is one of those iconic performances that will be memorable and people will come after years to watch and listen to this.
I listened to the studio version of this and I thought it's a pretty nice song. but man this live version HITS DIFFERENT. You can feel the raw emotions in her voice. This version made me want to curl up on the floor and just cry.
she did recommend listening to the album at 3 AM in bed with ice cream, and this is the first track on there. If she releases a stripped/live/raw version, it's gonna wreck a lot of people.
There is auto tune. Everybody use sit, but it’s very minimal. You can only hear if does a sustain note or she goes into her head voice. Like a lot singers who use they could do just as well without like rose
@@khokho6423 it’s sad you had to take things way out of context. Please chill and focus on Rosé. I hope you’re ok with your life and not going through any mental abuse in any ways.
@@yvliew i get what @khokho6423 means, Its like @Wallmartartists said that the other 3 does not have any passion in music. and the 4 of them are on a match with each other for who is the best among the 4 when it comes to music based on what you just commented. we could have just said we love Rose genre or route shes doing when it comes to music. all of them are talented and have passion individually its just that they have different genres and vocal range when it comes to music. that's why we stan black pink each members are different but it works
@@xoxo_wonniee Idk how it was translated tho.. The first commenter said Rosé's throat wasn't in good condition, but her husky voice was more audible, making her attractive..
Unlike English, Korean can omit some words in sentence . When the subject person is omitted, Google/UA-cam often tranlates the missing subject to 'He' in Enlish
Rosè is awesome,really.....but saying no one is above her is disrespectful to many other artists who are more talented and work hard. I hope you understand that and just to clarify,I mean no hate to Rosè
@@Yumin_Choiwork hard for what? That doesn’t mean anything. She’s doing better than the entire K-pop industry right now. if you want to support those hard workers maybe go stream their music !
The lyrics itself makes me tear up. But witnessing her live performance, with all her heart and raw emotion, made me cry. Rosie, I love you and I'm so proud of you.
It’s too good to our ears how this live version is way better than the original version. Rosé feelings is overwhelming through this number one live version.
The lyrics of this song is just too painful. Imagine needing validation, to be told that you're loved, pretty, and relevant, just to feel good. Who hurt you rosieeee :(
@@himaririku9254 the fact no one mentioned any group and still you wanted to bring them in…. I literally said rosé is the golden voice of korea but whatever makes you sleep at night🥱🥱
She feels so comfortable, so confident, so vulnerable at the same time, the feeling she is projecting through this song is too much, AND YES ROSIE YOU ARE THE ONE AND ONLY GIRL IN OUR EYES!!!
This is soooo good. You can really hear her voice, and for those who say this is lip-synch - we can actually see her diaphragm contracting with that tank top she is wearing. People say the song is plain and repetitive - we don’t care. This is the kind of song that showcases the voice that true fans love. This song is a hit for us, just like Gone was. And it’s not that Rosé has the highest voice,nor can she sustain notes the longest - but it’s her vocal color, her vulnerability, her dynamics that we love. This voice has been hidden in many Blackpink songs, and even in their ballads (which they rarely perform live), there is so much microphone effects. But here it is raw and beautiful - you could hear every breath, every tremble, every crack in her voice - and the flaws are part of what makes her storytelling so beautiful.
Rose is so much bigger than idol life now. She’s a world class artist. The way she performs is like someone that has lived 1000 lives and you can hear it with every note she sings. She is a true artist and I’m glad that she broke free from the K-pop industry. It was the best thing that could’ve ever happened to her.
broke free from kpop? you make it sound like Rosé has always been that way before she joined YG. Don't skip steps. Kpop was how she got to where she is now. Don't make it sound like kpop is nothing.
This is incredibly emotional. The tiny breaks in her voice make it more vulnerable than it already is. I love this better than APT. She’s awesome. So glad she’s getting the recognition she deserves.
Letting her take her own creative direction was the best decision that Black Label could make. Now Rosie shines because she is singing songs that come from her heart.
![[ENG SUB] Why on earth BLACKPINK ROSÉ thought debuting in Korea was impossible? #youquizontheblock](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uBZdzGhFC7E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] Why on earth BLACKPINK ROSÉ thought debuting in Korea was impossible? #youquizontheblock](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG/IND] ROSÉ TALK & STAGE (The Seasons) | KBS WORLD TV 241212](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RBiPnCp7ENw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[가로] ROSÉ(로제) - number one girl [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241129 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HvEFaGl0PdY/mqdefault.jpg)
It’s crazy how the live version is even better than the original one
Ikrrrrrr😭😭😭
You can feel the emotions even more 😭
@@Rains_fairy look im not gonna lie,but I just recently broke up with my bf,and hearing her sing this in live,all the emotions came crawling back to me like,I’m just bawling my eyes out😭
@@yukiichan4685noo don’t cry😭🥲here take this “🎁💝”
@@yukiichan4685 omg I'm going through the same thing but it's a friendship situation it ended in the worst way possible after 6 years so I can relate and kinda feel what you're feeling but I've just started a relationship recently it's helping me go through it, hope it lasts
Breakups are never easy, and I hope you find healing and peace soon. And sometimes music is the best way to let out those emotions. Take your time, and remember, better days are ahead. You’ve got this! 🌸
HER LIVE VOCALS ARE INSANE OMGGGGG
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
@@himaririku9254 ok
@@himaririku9254bro go back and sleep, these is blink zone
@@himaririku9254weirdo
@@ngzhengman7546 It's like the "G DRAGON KING OF KPOP" account, they're just commenting about it everywhere. Annoying.
No back drop, no decoration, just stage, lamp, a piano, and rose's voices 🥺
Keep well. God bless her soul 👼🙌✨💫
And no make up…
@@thomasche she def has makeup on
because she already is a star, a member of the biggest kpop group. Her presence alone is enough
@@thomasche Korean makeup techniques are so advanced that they can create a nose bridge that looks like it's been surgically enhanced. However, Rosé and Jennie don’t wear heavy makeup. Many idols look the same as when they were young without makeup, but with makeup, they are often misunderstood as having had plastic surgery. Korean makeup is truly the best.
The way she sings it full of emotions :') Makes me tears up a little too
Same
😢
Same 😭
저도요..
Full lip sing! 😂She even got away with it, I can show you where! And the trolls won't save her from the truth
this is our rosie's era
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,
@@himaririku9254 who ask?
@@danenghia That person is deranged they come to every video doing this
@@himaririku9254 actually I'm king of kpop and Rosé is queen of kpop..
@@himaririku9254I love stray kids but now is not the time for that. Let queen rosie sing her soul out 😅🥺💖
Her live singing abilities are incredible
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,,
@@himaririku9254 can you shut up please? This is about Rosé!
@@himaririku9254 Then why aren't you watching them?
I love that she's able to sing in her natural vocal tone now. She's so talented 🥹
Same @@TJRhea
I’m really glad she is going solo, her potential was so locked up under YG. We never got to hear this much emotions in her voice before. So much vulnerability yet strength… I’m shook.
I literally cried listening to this live, her potential finally broke out and she is rocking it ❤
Everyone okay? Anyone need more tissues? Rosé really came for all our emotions with this one
omg fellow Arcane (specifically Vi) lover??!!! lol glad to see you here too ;)
sameee... Why am I crying? 😭😭😭
Me! Also need a Vi edit using this song cause her character was ruined in Season 2 but she's forever number one girl in Arcane
I'll admit, I wiped away two full tears. Going to wash my face right now. This was incredibly good.
I hate the Arcane writers for ruining the goat to uplift Jinx and Caitlyn. Worst season ever @@roseandnumberones
These days in kpop it is very rare to see an idol who is an artist,It's all about visuals and dancing and they forget the most important part which is SINGING and live congratulations Rosé your efforts are bearing fruit, I wish you all the success you deserve and more.
Facts
Our queen
❤
Kpop has been like this mostly tho its all about idols persona , u will find musicians as main vocalists usually.
But rosé can do everything lol even since debut she have so much incredible covers so famous 😍😍😍 not new talented at all she born with talent 😭🎉
It's crazy how I enjoyed this live version better than the studio version. I LOVE her so much!
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,
@@himaririku9254this isnt abt stray kids
@@himaririku9254 you're so weird bro
@@himaririku9254 stop acting like a child and grow up!
@@himaririku9254??
Live versions did hit deeper.... That emotion in her voice, girl, hope to see you shines brighter for a long long time...
Please protect this precious and vulnerable girl at all cost
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,,
Can I sleep with her 😊
@@himaririku9254 i love stray kids, but this is a comment about Rosé, why do you have to say something of stray kids??
She has an amazing voice.bravo Queen Rose represents pop and KPop
Can you imagine being Bruno Mars and hearing this as one of her demo tracks?
Now you know why people are saying that Bruno views her as his protege.
Rosé will be the most successful Kpop female soloist
Not only female most famous and succesful kpop soloist
@@Sabrinaukk true
It's still hard to surpass IU's success as a soloist. But I'm pretty sure Rosé will make her own mark, her music reaching to those who need it. A great artist of her own merit.
I have the same feeling; there is something about her that shines bright
With that voice and talent obviously she is.❤
Rose`'s vocals are always TOP NOTCH!!!!!!!
She's an amazing live singer. This is one of those iconic performances that will be memorable and people will come after years to watch and listen to this.
Yes 1000 percent agree! Rose 🤍
No loud backtrack, no lip sync and her mic is always on. Rosé looked stunning live, my full respect for her.
There is no backtrack in general
No backtrack tho
Loud 📢📢📢📢📢 real talent
No backtracks ❤❤
Do you mention to someone that have Manobang and use loud backing track and lip sync and unnatural sound right?
I listened to the studio version of this and I thought it's a pretty nice song. but man this live version HITS DIFFERENT. You can feel the raw emotions in her voice. This version made me want to curl up on the floor and just cry.
Live version show her emotional voice... Very nice
I don't know how she managed to not bawl her eyes out with tears while singing, like that felt so raw
@ Rightttt? because me? I was fighting for my dear life not to let the tears fall because I’m at work 🥲
this slaps. I'm crying right now. The emotion is so so so raw....
she did recommend listening to the album at 3 AM in bed with ice cream, and this is the first track on there. If she releases a stripped/live/raw version, it's gonna wreck a lot of people.
She is Real GOLDEN VOICE OF Kpop💎
Correction its in korea not just kpop❤
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
@@himaririku9254who are they ?
the best vocalist
@@user-nu5fx6en9h a kpop boy group but idk why he found it relevant to mention them here when it doesn't concern them😊
Rosé is killing it with her raw vocal!!!
How come this is better than the studio version (studio version was awesome, i don't have words for this)
the original doesn't really click with me, like this version does.
@sporehux8344 yes i get ur pov, but for me original one was also good, it's just live is better
no autotune, no lip syncing, no backtrack, just pure live vocals thank you ROSÉ for showing everyone what’s it’s like to be a real vocalist
And no make up…
@@thomascheshe probably has a minimum amount of makeup but looks flawless w and w/o makeup
@@thomasche I think she had a light makeup
@@thomasche I can see her eyeliner and blush from a mile away. of course she's beautiful with or without make up but she definitely has make up on lol
There is auto tune. Everybody use sit, but it’s very minimal. You can only hear if does a sustain note or she goes into her head voice. Like a lot singers who use they could do just as well without like rose
one thing about rose is that her mic wil always be ON
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
@@himaririku9254stray kids is the gay of kpop
Gay 🏳️🌈@@himaririku9254
That mic gonna be on EVRYTIME 😂❤
로제 목소리가 이렇게 좋은줄 몰랐는데 정말 좋구나
진짜 정규앨범 초대박 나겠다...
❤12월 6일 앨범 발매 예정이니 많은 사랑과 응원 부탁드립니다.
더블랙이 일만 잘하면 근데 일을 너무 안함; 일주일전인데 어떻게 아무것도 안올릴수가 너무 심함
@@user-ph2kg9tz6d미야오 이번 컴백도 홍보 ㅈㄴ안했음..
@@user-ph2kg9tz6d??? Wtf
@@니나브그래도 미야오는 컴백후에 ㅈㄴ 해주잖
Honestly, this live version hits way harder than the original. Rose’s voice is on a whole other level, and the energy she brings is unreal!
Please viral it.. It's so rare in this era of kpop ... No backtrack. I am proud of you Rose , I hope you will shine like this 💕
Im not brokenhearted or anything but listening to this song and to her voice just make me want to cry
로제가 노래 잘하는건 알았지만 이정도일줄이야.. 너무좋네요ㅠ
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
Waji는 그녀에게 메인 밴드에서 보컬로 노래할 권리를 주지 않았습니다.
이정도가 아니라 이정도입니다
이 정도가 아니라 그 정도입니다.
테일러 스위프트 보고있나? ㅎㅎ
Already said this but i gonna said it again... Outta 4 members, rosie's passion for music is unmatched
same thoughts here. It's been a sign way back. Finally she can be free with her very own music.
you men cant go a single day without pitting women against each other, learn to praise someone without dragging on the others
@@khokho6423 it’s sad you had to take things way out of context. Please chill and focus on Rosé. I hope you’re ok with your life and not going through any mental abuse in any ways.
@@yvliew i get what @khokho6423 means, Its like @Wallmartartists said that the other 3 does not have any passion in music. and the 4 of them are on a match with each other for who is the best among the 4 when it comes to music based on what you just commented. we could have just said we love Rose genre or route shes doing when it comes to music. all of them are talented and have passion individually its just that they have different genres and vocal range when it comes to music. that's why we stan black pink each members are different but it works
Praise her without including other members omg
I'm not even surprised that the live version is even better and sadder than the studio version
Her voice makes me cry. So emotional so heart touching
She's really Golden Voice. She's our number one girl
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,
@@himaririku9254 STOP SAYING THAT, NOBODY CARES
@@Caramelokpoperop reply 🤣
목 상태 안좋았다고 들었는데 허스키해서 오히려 매력적임...라이브가 더 좋아 갓 채 영
He? Or she
@@xoxo_wonnieeits just the translation is wrong
@@xoxo_wonniee Idk how it was translated tho..
The first commenter said Rosé's throat wasn't in good condition, but her husky voice was more audible, making her attractive..
제2의 백지영
Unlike English, Korean can omit some words in sentence . When the subject person is omitted, Google/UA-cam often tranlates the missing subject to 'He' in Enlish
She’s one of the most talented in kpop. Rosé, there is no one above you. ♥️🥹
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
@@himaririku9254calm down, you bark too loud
@@himaririku9254 Are you freaking crazy?
Rosè is awesome,really.....but saying no one is above her is disrespectful to many other artists who are more talented and work hard. I hope you understand that and just to clarify,I mean no hate to Rosè
@@Yumin_Choiwork hard for what? That doesn’t mean anything. She’s doing better than the entire K-pop industry right now. if you want to support those hard workers maybe go stream their music !
My bias from 2016 until now is Queen Rose, her aura is always energetic in every MV performance, dance practice, and live performance. musiciaa
The Live version carries so much emotion it's even better than the audio.
She perfected the singing for this one. It’s so beautiful to listen live and feel stronger emotion than studio version. The girl is so talented 😢❤
Ohh gosh...she is singing along with a violin and piano guyss... Magical😭
The lyrics itself makes me tear up. But witnessing her live performance, with all her heart and raw emotion, made me cry. Rosie, I love you and I'm so proud of you.
The fact that it sounds better live is insane, I didn’t know Rosé was like that! 🔥
The reason is that she'll outshine all her members if YG showed her true talent earlier.
She the main vocalist of blackpink ofc she sounds better
@@maiamaius830 he was afraid of that ... that's why he didn't show us what rosè has for music
YG tried to hide her talent. Now she's out and we've only just realized how extremely talented she is 🌹🙌
채영아 진짜 전세계 넘버원 걸이라는 사실 잊지마 ㅜㅜㅂ
채영이가 로제 본명인가요? 우와~~술게임에서 채영이가 누군지 궁금했는데..미쳤다.
@@ksok315😊
@@ksok315네 박채영이에요
@@user-x093xkl 감사^^~ 좋은 밤 되세요.
호들갑좀 떨지마세요 잘부르는애들이 얼마나많은데 뭔 넘버원
Rose proving that she is more than just an idol, she indeed is an artist!!!
My dad started crying after hearing this i am not lying❤
ROSÉ live vocal is heaven. She's the real ace
It’s too good to our ears how this live version is way better than the original version. Rosé feelings is overwhelming through this number one live version.
The lyrics of this song is just too painful. Imagine needing validation, to be told that you're loved, pretty, and relevant, just to feel good. Who hurt you rosieeee :(
She said that she'd been through a toxic relationship
She wrote this song after reading the hate comments online.
Toxic fans and haters
@@noorkim7017 but this song is because of toxic comments online
@@heygellybaee also Abt her toxic bf she talked Abt how she will not forgive him for not giving her Tiffany rings back
Not gonna lie, but this live is clearer than the studio one
로제 목소리가 뭔가 허스키해진거 같아서 더 좋네
목 상태가 안좋은 날이었어요 근데 너무 너무 듣기 좋음ㅠㅠ 그 허스키함이
첫 공연이 아니어서 목소리가 많이 지쳤던 것 같아요.
로제는 두가지 창법을 가지고있어요 지디의 결국 피처링할때와 블랙핑크 노래할때 완전 달라요
그건 그냥 곡 음역대가 다른거 같은데 @@user-tl6nu2ft6p
확실히 목 쉬엇음
근데도 미쳣 ㄷㄷ
how is she even better live this is insane
in a world full of loud flashy performances, Rose stood and simply sang with her beautiful voice.That is crazy talent(i love her)
I mean, this show is like that, you're not going to bring a flashy performance on a show like this and for a sad song
Rose's voice is so peaceful
고음지른다고 노래 잘하는게 아니라 이렇게 진정성이 느껴지고 감성 잘 살리는게 노래잘하는 겁니다. 라이브가 음원을 능가하네요.
맞아요 특유의 감성이있는 분들이 결국 오래가더라구요..
블핑 로제, 방탄 정국, 버스커 장범준 전 이분들 너무 좋음 ❤
그래도 기본은 가창력이에요.그걸전제로.나머지
@@쿵쿵-y9fㅇㅈ 가창력,음색은 기본인거고 감정까지 잘 살려야지 노래 잘한다고 볼 수 있겠죠
@@쿵쿵-y9f 가창력 음색 테크닉 감성잡는거 다 보는게 맞아요. 가창력은 고음 대결일뿐입니다. 어떻게 보면 가수에게 가창력보다 더 중요한게 음색입니다.
아는척하지마세요 다 아는 사실입니다
Rosé is my Number One Girl. I love her so much
채영이 노래하면서 살짝 울컥 한것 같은데🥲팬들 앞에서 자기 얘기를 노래할 수 있어서 그런듯.. 한 아티스트를 이렇게 까지 응원해 본적이 없는데 로제는 마음으로 빌게 되네요. 앞으로 더더 행복했으면 좋겠다 채영아❤
same❤
목소리가 넘 좋네요..
독특해요.약간 허스키하면서 미소년 목소리 같기도 하고..~
역시 가수는 가창력... 그것만이 롱런을 보장할 듯...
아파트도 좋지만 난 이 노래가 너무 좋다,,,, ㅠㅠㅠ 로제가 악플러들한테 하는 말이라는데 가사랑 노래가 너무 마음 아프고, 누구한테나 사랑받고 싶어하는 마음이 나도 공감이 가서... 진짜 라이브 너무 잘한다
와...진짜 음색 장난아니네요...소울이 깃들여진 음색~~~~
진짜 넘버 원 걸이네 음색 감정 모든게 완벽하다 노래에 그냥 빠져든다
아니 라이브가 진짜 훨씬 좋은데….?? 음원보다 훨씬 깊고 섬세한 느낌임
나는 처음부터 로제였다 .... 솔로로 터져서 너무 좋아
진짜 라이브 개잘함...인급동1위 가자
ㄹㅇ...이거 1위 올리고 브루노커버 2위 올려야됨 진짜 전세계 사람들 다들어야함...
@@수수수-n1q사랑하기 때문에도 진짜 잘불렀는데 그것도 올라가서 모두가 들어야됨ㅠㅠ
가수 잖아여..🤭
@@fewgoodgirl 저 정도 되는 "가수" 가 얼마 없음 특히 아이돌 바닥에서
썡 라이브를 저 수준으로 부르는 애들이 얼마나 된다고 ㅋㅋ
르세라핌이랑 아일릿은 이거보고 무슨생각이 들까...
로제 팬 됐네요 너무 잘하는데요
the way she singing the emotion in her voice... man this is korea's GOLDEN VOICE! she only needed a mic and that's it.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,,
@@himaririku9254umm .......no they're not
@@himaririku9254 the fact no one mentioned any group and still you wanted to bring them in…. I literally said rosé is the golden voice of korea but whatever makes you sleep at night🥱🥱
I had seen this bot EVERYWHERE@@himaririku9254
@@YourSecretFan4 they always spam everywhere, just ignore their comments 😊
평소보다 목소리가 약간 허스키한 것 같은데 오히려 그게 더 매력적이네.. 라이브 진짜 잘한다
이때 몸도 목도 안 좋았다는데 그래서 더 애절한 느낌이 ㅠㅜ
No more lip syncing. The rare treasure of Korea. My favorite member in Blackpink 🌹
ROSEの声好きすぎて泣く… such a beautiful angelic voice❤
It sounds so much better than than the studio version, you can hear the raw emotion in her voice, good job rosé!!
She feels so comfortable, so confident, so vulnerable at the same time, the feeling she is projecting through this song is too much, AND YES ROSIE YOU ARE THE ONE AND ONLY GIRL IN OUR EYES!!!
This is soooo good. You can really hear her voice, and for those who say this is lip-synch - we can actually see her diaphragm contracting with that tank top she is wearing. People say the song is plain and repetitive - we don’t care. This is the kind of song that showcases the voice that true fans love. This song is a hit for us, just like Gone was. And it’s not that Rosé has the highest voice,nor can she sustain notes the longest - but it’s her vocal color, her vulnerability, her dynamics that we love. This voice has been hidden in many Blackpink songs, and even in their ballads (which they rarely perform live), there is so much microphone effects. But here it is raw and beautiful - you could hear every breath, every tremble, every crack in her voice - and the flaws are part of what makes her storytelling so beautiful.
tidak ada lipsync dalam kamus Rose
penned down so perfectly💯
로제라는 사람을 이 노래도 다시 봄.. 매일을 듣고 울컥함..
로제가 월클인 이유가 너무 많지만
그 중 보컬 하나만으로도 납득이 감..진짜 지린다
라이브가 녹화방송보다 더 좋은적은 내생에 손꼽을정도네요. 로제는 내 행복이다
저도 그 생각 했어요. 라이브 목소리가 더 울림이 있네요
녹화방송이 아니라 녹화방송입니다
음원보다 라이브가 더 고퀄❤
Trust Rosé to make the live performance even BETTER than the studio version
나 요즘 이노래 계속 듣고 있음... 이번 앨범중에 젤 꽂힘.
음색은 진짜 세계 탑급이다...
이미 탑이지ㅎ
이정도음색가진가수개만음저정돈탑안애못듬
로제는 음악적 재능이 있으면서 또 열심히 성실하게 음악작업하는 것을 좋아하니까 앞으로 더
빛나고 잘 될 것 같음😊
케이 팦이 확장된 것 같아서 더 대견함👍👍👍
아니...음색이 아니구요.....
하..,이게 모르시겠지만 치밀하게 짜여진 보컬이에요.....
그걸 능가하는 디테일과 표현,감정...
제발알아줬으면 좋겠습니다, 그런한마디는 너무부족함 이ㄴ아
세계탑급은 아니죠
노래는잘하지 메보인데
저정도못하면
로제 감정선 대박인듯..울부짖는 느낌 ㅜㅜ
음원보다 더 음원같은 라이브.. 요즘 케이팝 가수들 전부 다 영어로 노래내는 거 진짜 싫은데.. 이 노래는 예외임....... 가사 딕션도 미쳤고 진짜 다 전달됨 감정이 ㅠㅠ
로제는 걍 보여주기식 아니고 직접 작사작곡 하니까 감정전달이 잘되는 듯…
억지로 남의 언어를 부르는 느낌이 아닌 그냥 원어민 느낌이라 그런듯. 실제 뉴질랜드에서 태어나 호주에서 생활했기도 하구요
@@Unknown_Guest1942 so true
로제는 아직 한국어로 노래 쓰는것보다 영어로 쓰는게 편하다고 함
이건 케이팝이 아니라 팝인듯
목소리가 너무 좋은데 영어로 하니까 더 좋다
로제가 스스로 꽃을 피우고 있습니다.
가장 아름다운 꽃을.
최고의 찬사군요
She's getting praised for her beautiful raw vocals on every social media platform. AS SHE SHOULD!
솔로 활동하니 여기저기 자신이 원하는곳 나가고 팬들위해 라이브도 해주고 진짜 이뻐죽것다.채영이 솔로활동 오래하자.
블핑으로 활동할 때는 몰랐는데..
각자 솔로로 활동하는걸 보니 ..
결국 블핑의 근본은 로제였었네!!!!!!
로제 본이름이 채영이?인가여
맞아요 박채영
노래를 어쩜 이래 잘해...
아파트하고 또다른 로제만의 애절한감성이 느껴져서
목소리가
팔색조
감정담아서 부르는 노래가 이렇게 멋지구나..
블핑 넷플릭스 다큐에서 새벽까지 연습하고도 혼자 기타 껴안고 연습실에 앉아있던 그 아이기 ㅠ 이렇게 디바가 됐음
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ❤❤
노력은 배신하지 않는다는 걸 직접 보여준 사례 ㅋㅋㅋ
로제는 대성할줄알았음..
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@iridscentcersent277 배신당한 사람은 말해봣자 묻힘
노력은 사람 가려서 배신 밥먹듯이함
노래도 너무 잘하지만 목소리가 진짜 너무좋다.
진짜 로제는 케이팝을 뛰어넘어서 너무 멋진 아티스트로 성장한것 같다,,
김나박이처럼 실력은 그들과 동급레벨의 영어잘하는 글로벌한 뮤지션이라고 생각됨..
Rose is so much bigger than idol life now. She’s a world class artist. The way she performs is like someone that has lived 1000 lives and you can hear it with every note she sings. She is a true artist and I’m glad that she broke free from the K-pop industry. It was the best thing that could’ve ever happened to her.
broke free from kpop? you make it sound like Rosé has always been that way before she joined YG. Don't skip steps. Kpop was how she got to where she is now. Don't make it sound like kpop is nothing.
그냥 음색이 미쳤고 팝적인 감성이 👍 👍 👍 👍
라이브 미쳤다.... 라이브로 들으니까 더 슬픈곡 같음....ㅠㅠ
아파트도 좋은데 이 노래가 찐임
정규앨범 너무 기대된다 진짜로......
아니 라이브잘하는거 알았는데 이정도일줄은...... 허스키해서ㅜ더 좋다......ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
디즈니 공주 실사판이야 너무 예뻐 노래도 잘불러 넘버원 걸 박채영
허스키해지니까 엄청 애절하게들림
This is such a beautiful song. She is so talented and loveable. How can anyone hate her 😭
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
whatever you say it's not true so it's better to give up @@himaririku9254
@@himaririku9254 and then you woke up
Nobody hates her
@@Bozzzzzz007armys are hating her like crazy js bc she surpassed their oppars
로제는 진짜 솔로활동 해야됨.. 이 목소리를 3-4분 꽉 채워 들을 수 있다는게 행볻하다 ㅠㅠ
This is incredibly emotional. The tiny breaks in her voice make it more vulnerable than it already is. I love this better than APT. She’s awesome. So glad she’s getting the recognition she deserves.
눈물을 꾹꾹참고 부른것같이 들리네 슬프고 감미로워요
로제 노래 잘하는건 알았지만 라이브 미쳤다! ㅠ 순수하게 목소리만으로도 무대를 꽉 채워주네 월클이야~ 살짝 허스키한 보이스도 매력적이야~❤
Letting her take her own creative direction was the best decision that Black Label could make. Now Rosie shines because she is singing songs that come from her heart.