The Prisons of Pakistani Society | Cricle of Control Exposed | Syed Muzammil Official

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 бер 2024
  • In the video we have discussed the context of Pakistani education through Foucauldian lens, which shed light on the power dynamics and disciplinary mechanisms at play. Foucault's analysis emphasizes how power is exercised in modern institutions like prisons and schools to maximize control and utility.
    This analysis also shows the ways in which educational institutions, including prison schools, function as sites where power and knowledge intersect to regulate behavior, communication, and learning processes.
    Instagram: /realsyedmuzammil
    Twitter: /syedmuzammilofl
    Facebook: /syedmuzammilofficial
    TikTok: /realsyedmuzammil
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    #school #educationsystem #prison #foucault

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @soniajamal3800
    @soniajamal3800 Місяць тому +141

    This guy is too intelligent. Pakistan is blessed to have him in their country.

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 Місяць тому +4

      A person with one eye is always a king in a nation of blind people…
      Before you conclude that Muzzamle is the most intelligent..Please understand the fact that he is just merely stating the facts, saying truth and telling the reality to brainwashed zombies.

    • @mohsinayub5556
      @mohsinayub5556 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@chaitanyakada1341💯 agree

    • @krisgray1957
      @krisgray1957 Місяць тому +1

      Wish some one is there in India also. Under Modi...India also becoming like Pakistan.

    • @Arjun080
      @Arjun080 Місяць тому

      @@krisgray1957 chamcha spotted

    • @zoeyanaqvi-zn7482
      @zoeyanaqvi-zn7482 Місяць тому

      ​@@krisgray1957 India is much better than us. India Pak Bangladesh is the most blessed land and it was divided by goras on the basis of divide and conquer.

  • @nevus_flammeus
    @nevus_flammeus Місяць тому +53

    Few years back I had argue with friends and I told them we're living in an open air prison and finally Syed Muzamil spoke blatantly. You're amazing.

  • @shamaparekh9380
    @shamaparekh9380 Місяць тому +250

    Talking like this while living in Pakistan. it's an act of bravery

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому +11

      Bhai dar lagta hai isko koi mar na de. Ye kitni critical thinking par bolta hai. He is among the best youtubers I have seen.

    • @groot9026
      @groot9026 Місяць тому

      I think he live in USA.. but i am not sure

    • @m.g.6575
      @m.g.6575 Місяць тому

      Be cautious of trusting any Pakistani; their patterns remain consistent. Most of them are just talk without any meaningful action. Figures like Hasan Nisar, Pervez Hoodbhoy, and Najam Sethi have followed the same script: pandering to "unpopular" sentiments to sound different , more intelligent than the masses, with a Messiah complex - without an overt anti-India rhetoric, only to abandon their facade when convenient. Moreover, they conveniently sidestep addressing the fundamental issues because of Islam.

    • @m.g.6575
      @m.g.6575 Місяць тому

      Be cautious of trusting any Pakistani; their patterns remain consistent. Most of them are just talk without any meaningful action. Figures like Hasan Nisar, Pervez Hoodbhoy, and Najam Sethi have followed the same script: pandering to "unpopular" sentiments to sound different , more intelligent than the masses, with a Messiah complex - without an overt anti-India rhetoric, only to abandon their facade when convenient. Moreover, they conveniently sidestep addressing the fundamental issues because of Islam.

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому +6

      @@groot9026 No bro he lives inside pak

  • @mohammadasim9525
    @mohammadasim9525 Місяць тому +160

    He is absolutely right. Even religious teachings are taught with Fear instead with inspiration.

    • @exfriend6667
      @exfriend6667 Місяць тому +13

      don't take otherwise but that's why I think Hinduism is better because it teaches us to love God rather than fear him

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому +15

      ​@@exfriend6667 ek baat bolu, One more thing, Hinduism is something that you perceive by yourself. It's your path to take , No one has rules on you to only follow that path. That is what is unbelievable. All rules change for the person you are. That's why Hinduism is very personal. When someone reads Srimad Bhagavad Gita , the understanding is personal. Like Madhav(krishna) has come to tell the meaning of karma(work) and dharma (duty) . Why work is necessary even when you feel it is morally questionable and you feel sad after doing it. That's why even Oppenheimer was a fan of the book.

    • @AF-yq9es
      @AF-yq9es Місяць тому +2

      Tumara religion. Don't talk about others.

    • @bhediaking1989
      @bhediaking1989 Місяць тому +2

      zahuam mean jalega tu😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @itzAyush7z
      @itzAyush7z Місяць тому

      In hinduism there's nothing like fear of God We even have a full fledged book on atheistism in sanatan dharm you are allowed to question the existence of God by logical thinking but we have the concept of karma it's the same as every action has an equal and opposite reaction

  • @rajendrashinde586
    @rajendrashinde586 Місяць тому +306

    Pakistan required 1 million muzammil to recover country & put it on a progressive path .

    • @iwanttodie7199
      @iwanttodie7199 Місяць тому +2

      change is slow.

    • @janamfedaehadrii3833
      @janamfedaehadrii3833 Місяць тому +6

      A person like muzamil is hope

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому +3

      ​@@iwanttodie7199 India took 76 years to get good in education. Today we produce the most powerful graduates who are in a race with themselves. Finally critical thinking is coming. Pakistan went back while we were racing ahead. Atleast pak needs 100 years to get this far.

    • @chi4829
      @chi4829 Місяць тому +6

      India needs more of Muzammils as well. The commercialisation of health and education in Indian society is sickening.

    • @RiseShineRevel
      @RiseShineRevel Місяць тому +2

      @@chi4829everything should be privatized a country should be capitalist ... see what happens with russai and all communist country .. people cant be socialist greed will always be there this is kali yug

  • @riffataligohar8415
    @riffataligohar8415 Місяць тому +80

    Born in 1995 and admitted in PAF school at the age of 5. Discremenation in these schools over ranks & designation is still on the peak. Pressure of reputation and completion of course is on teachers is very strange rather than grooming. Computer as a subject came for me when I was in grade 7 but there was no proper teacher in 7 & 8...we enjoyed the computer periods at that time and marked as grade A. Then in Matric & FSC opted science and pre engineering as there is is still no variety of subjects in Army & PAF schools...only science, pre eng & pre medical but for our juniors now they have computer science as well. In Addition I was good in Arts subjects not in Sciences but there comes Family & Society pressure...I opted Maths as a BS in Universty. Now I'm totally devastated with the Education Industry. My whole life is destroyed & still I'm taking the blame that I was not a hardworking students thats why I have such bad grades....!

    • @as-rx9xn
      @as-rx9xn Місяць тому +1

      Can i ask you to share your story with me on a different social media platform? Would like to hear more

    • @riffataligohar8415
      @riffataligohar8415 Місяць тому +5

      @@as-rx9xn Social Media??? From above lines didn't you get that...why do you want intolerance between me and my family especially my father...! Impossible...! I feel free to express my words on youtube comments...

    • @sameerhussain2579
      @sameerhussain2579 Місяць тому

      @@riffataligohar8415 He wanted to merely empathize with you. Look at his offer from that pov.

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому

      ​@@riffataligohar8415 Bhai 🫂.
      I am from India. I am so sorry for what you are facing right now. Career is tough and even tougher when you're in a country like Pakistan. Don't worry things will be alright. First of all see the opportunity in the world around you. There is at least something you need to do. Focus on at least getting food on the table. It is a very necessary thing. Times will be tough, You have to wait for them to get better. This is the way nature works.
      Krishna says in Srimad Bhagavad Gita:
      the nonpermanent appearance of happiness and distress, and their disappearance in due course, are like the appearance and disappearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perception, O scion of Bharata, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed.
      Conclusion
      The times will change. Nature only sees your patience when you have nothing and your attitude when you have everything.
      Fill yourself with wisdom as a hobby. God will himself come to you to guide you. Wait for him, till then do what is necessary.

    • @as-rx9xn
      @as-rx9xn Місяць тому +2

      @@riffataligohar8415 relax lady, no ones trying to harm you, youre a bit triggered

  • @Sheetalpawar01
    @Sheetalpawar01 Місяць тому +111

    Syed muzammil is a new hope and a great gift for pakistan ♥️♥️

    • @nikhilv4499
      @nikhilv4499 Місяць тому

      bymistake he is born in pakistan
      he never suits pakistan he is highly secular not like pakistani jihadist people

    • @rinkujain4356
      @rinkujain4356 Місяць тому +8

      Agar aiso ki kadar karte to Pakistan Banta hi nahi 😂😂😂

    • @rinkujain4356
      @rinkujain4356 Місяць тому +3

      Agar aiso ki kadar karte to ye mulk Banta hi nahi

    • @vimalpandey6122
      @vimalpandey6122 Місяць тому

      ये सैयद पैगम्बर के वंशज है इकबाल रहमत अली लियाकत अली खान Dr इसरार अहमद अग्रवाल जन्म से हिन्दू​@@rinkujain4356

    • @khaneditz6561
      @khaneditz6561 Місяць тому

      ​@@rinkujain4356Gg tab Gandhi g ki tarah Jinnah sahb bhi jail mein hotay😂😂

  • @WhiteFii2212
    @WhiteFii2212 Місяць тому +16

    From Jammu Kashmir, India ... sir u are gem of a person, the task which you are doing will definately yield results in coming years❤

  • @rajatsubhradas
    @rajatsubhradas Місяць тому +105

    I am from West Bengal, India and here left parties had 35 years rule. Intially they strarted with snatching lands from Bourgeois and distribution to landless but later on the kept the land docs in their party office. From dictatorship of Pro literiate class they themselves became dictators. They kicked away industrialists, they rejected computers , stopped English education which gradually led to total mess. Bengali medium students couldn't compete in nation level exams, there were no jobs as most of the industries were closed as they hated industrialists. Bangla bandh was a bi weekly or monthly phenomenon. Gherao, lock out , bandh became a tradition of the students. Universities started dis regarding the propfessors and later on they kept on humiliating the VCs. With the help of Muslim and vote bank politics they ruled for 35 years and destroyed the states back bone.
    In short what is perceived to be ideal is not always ideal.
    Take love from Kolkata, India, aka Kalkatta.

    • @NikhilSharma-tp9ut
      @NikhilSharma-tp9ut Місяць тому

      communism is cancer

    • @monasharma2612
      @monasharma2612 Місяць тому +23

      TMC won all the 100 assembly seats from Calcutta region it's all because of so called Bhadlok Bangalis Hindus.
      Only state where upper cast votes for islamic parties and lower class vote for MODI, BJP so called upper class party.
      Bengalis at present think 20 years later than rest of India not vise-versa.

    • @sirat-al-mustaqimbyshahabs1418
      @sirat-al-mustaqimbyshahabs1418 Місяць тому +2

      True

    • @parveensundriyal3270
      @parveensundriyal3270 Місяць тому +3

      It was same Bengal which produced scientists like Jyoti Basu & attracted chinese for livelihood.

    • @puneetmishra4726
      @puneetmishra4726 Місяць тому +12

      ​@@monasharma2612 So true. And people have made the Bengalis believe that "what Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow". That was true when Tagore was alive, not after that.

  • @nareshkatyal8677
    @nareshkatyal8677 Місяць тому +30

    Bete aapki bahut himmat hai.
    Badi hi samajhdari wali bate hame aap se milti hai.
    Salute bate from India.

    • @tusharbishnoi6844
      @tusharbishnoi6844 Місяць тому +1

      Koi himmat nai h ye ISI ka banda h, Indian ko chutiya banane ka, agar ye unka banda nahi hota to abhi tak Gayab Ho gaya hota. iske 90% views Indian hn, Pakistan me Koi nahi sunta.

    • @abubakeryounas2323
      @abubakeryounas2323 28 днів тому

      Yar ap koi 70 saal ka budha ho Jo usko bete kaha raha ho Sharam karo thori si

  • @user-kq8sk6og7f
    @user-kq8sk6og7f Місяць тому +21

    یہ تجربات کتابوں میں تھوڑا ہی لکھے تھے
    بہت سے سال لگے ، سال بھی جوانی کے
    When muzamil said "schoolon sy koi dimagh salamat wapis ajaye tou mojza ha"😢

  • @sadiqzaman3971
    @sadiqzaman3971 Місяць тому +9

    Proud to have such a genius and unorthodox thinker in our society. Heads down ✨

  • @ruin9
    @ruin9 Місяць тому +14

    I have been a fan of this guy , the moment i saw him.Speaks so clearly of things that modern society believes to be taboo.Never thought country like Pakistan can have a guy a like him.Respect

  • @baloch091
    @baloch091 Місяць тому +48

    Bro your something else
    You deserve more fan following but our youngsters are busy in watching tik tok
    Big fan bro ❤❤❤

  • @BalbirSingh-hw5ts
    @BalbirSingh-hw5ts Місяць тому +27

    This boy has a highly rational mind. He will have a great influence in future

    • @chhatrapatishivajimaharaj98
      @chhatrapatishivajimaharaj98 Місяць тому

      The rational minds always die by the masses . Eg - Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietche. Only some do successful rebellions, other die by the hands of powerful people.

    • @PJ-yp3vb
      @PJ-yp3vb Місяць тому +1

      He will not be allowed to live long

  • @manishchandragandhi8642
    @manishchandragandhi8642 Місяць тому +5

    Mr. Muzammil, I have gone through your speech. I have never ever heard such a superb, dynamic, motivational, philosophical but practical, transforming, brilliant, excellent etc. etc. My heartiest salute to your profound knowledge and intellect. May God, bless you a life century and century for transforming the upcoming generation. 🙏🙏

  • @subhanbasit6389
    @subhanbasit6389 Місяць тому +9

    Pakistan is lucky to have you bro. Allah bless the work you are doing.

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Місяць тому +5

    I appreciate making small clip out of it, it makes your content really inclusive for all kinds of audience. I am not someone who shies away from long talks but sometimes people have already seen other long videos so it makes it super easy for them.

  • @surajeetpaul2008
    @surajeetpaul2008 Місяць тому +37

    Lots of love from India. Big fan of yours. All issues raised by you pertaining to both India and Pakistan.... Love you Sir❤

    • @nikhilv4499
      @nikhilv4499 Місяць тому

      same here

    • @ART_INDIA
      @ART_INDIA Місяць тому

      No not at all... So pl go to pakistan Bangladesh and Afghanistan and give the comment 🤷‍♀️

  • @ravindersaini3747
    @ravindersaini3747 Місяць тому +19

    Great thinker and new hope for his country.

  • @BiswajitBorah-tp2yt
    @BiswajitBorah-tp2yt Місяць тому +38

    Iam frm arunachal India we proud to be an indian.i luv to see ur taught.

    • @antifragile01
      @antifragile01 Місяць тому

      Welcome brother. We are all humans.

  • @user-bp4rz7kh2v
    @user-bp4rz7kh2v Місяць тому +22

    Jail ke zinda misal University of Balochistan hai . Road aur blockades b bilkul Quetta cantt ke tarah hai. Students say ziyada fouji hain

  • @ShailendraSingh-ir1js
    @ShailendraSingh-ir1js Місяць тому +7

    Thank Internet that voices like Muzzamil can reach a huge crowd.
    Internet is the wonder cure for closed societies like Pakistan... and slowly it's bringing some awareness to think critically.

  • @raghbirrajan3671
    @raghbirrajan3671 Місяць тому +7

    Really Pakistan needs innumerable Muzamil to be righteous and genuine human being. Great Muzamil ji.

  • @a.chauhan
    @a.chauhan Місяць тому +11

    I can't even imagine how long it's take to collect all data knowledge and deliver in one video, you deserve hat's off...keep it Sir ❤

  • @KhanBhai-tt8cm
    @KhanBhai-tt8cm Місяць тому +10

    Well explained Muzammil sab. Such thinkers are limited in Pakistan

  • @souravyadav7562
    @souravyadav7562 Місяць тому +8

    Thanks Muzammil!
    Keep sharing your content. Its always insightful to listen.

  • @zaheeramraz9462
    @zaheeramraz9462 Місяць тому +5

    Love and respect for you from Balochistan, Sir❤❤

  • @rensoyphil
    @rensoyphil Місяць тому +17

    I am from Kerala state of India; I used to listen your logical, sensible talk &. rational views. I like your rational mindset and inquisitive nature. Keep it up brother your reformative and informative endeavour.
    Education system is a catalystic force for the society and should be free from biases, superstitious beliefs and false notions. A good education, especially education of women is a game changer that can redefine the future destiny and will create an enlightened society.
    My state Kerala had better educational facilities in the latter half of 19th century itself, that is what is the reason for it's higher Social Development Index. (My grandmother secured 10th class pass in 1912 and grandfather passed graduation in 1917 from prestigious Madrass Christian College, Chennai)

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому

      We all Indians are in the same race of education. :)

    • @NizarAlvi90
      @NizarAlvi90 Місяць тому

      But Karella is at top in the list.​@@TheEnigmaticPoet

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому +1

      @@NizarAlvi90 It maybe true but the race is everywhere. Look at streets in India. People are running towards colleges

  • @OnePlanetAllAreOne
    @OnePlanetAllAreOne Місяць тому +44

    Seeing so many pak students seriously listening to Muzamil gives us hope for our neighbouring country to come out of fanaticism . God bless Muzamil 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

    • @fatimabibi7664
      @fatimabibi7664 Місяць тому +4

      Our neighboring country can also learn from Muzammil to come out of fanaticism.

    • @mukeshsinha848
      @mukeshsinha848 Місяць тому +1

      Syed Muzamil saheb your stature does not suit to Pakistan. Leave Pakistan as soon as possible settled in West or India

    • @mukeshsinha848
      @mukeshsinha848 Місяць тому +1

      Muzamil saheb although you are so small in age but u come into the category of mahatma welcome in India ❤

    • @Raj-nh3fc
      @Raj-nh3fc Місяць тому +2

      Just a room full is "so many"? In a country with 20 crore people!

    • @IbrahimIsmail95
      @IbrahimIsmail95 Місяць тому +1

      Lol look into your own matters first. No doubt we are fucked but fanaticism is on the rise in India and it won't take long for all your economic progress to be reversed if you don't come to your senses.

  • @bittoochatterjee2661
    @bittoochatterjee2661 Місяць тому +2

    Even I from India and as a son of Indian Air Force Officer ( Fighter Pilot ) born in 1969 had a very disciplined upbringing. During my schooling days ( 1975 -1986 )
    As of today I am so much thankful towards my parents and teachers of those year because of them and their disciplined way of upbringing me has yielded me to hold a senior management level position in a Multinational Company out here in Gurgaon India
    TODAY
    I too am a hard core believer in the value of strict discipline for character development of my child ( Daughter ).
    Even today I maintained the same approach that i went through with my child " Spare the Rod", and " Spoil the Child", and due to this believe and approach of mine has Yielded positive results for her
    As she has achieved many accomplishments.
    Consistently ranking in the top three positions in her class of 40 students.😊

  • @maheshpant518
    @maheshpant518 Місяць тому +5

    I listen to your podcasts with interest and hope Muzammil! Firaq Gorakhpuri wrote: Ek na ek shamma andhere men jalaye rakhiye; subah hone ko hai mahol banaye rakhiye! Carry on Muzammil.

  • @sangi2971
    @sangi2971 Місяць тому +5

    First time you have raised the core issues of Pakistani society. Thanks Syed.

  • @SaifAli-qw3zx
    @SaifAli-qw3zx Місяць тому +3

    I'm a doctor and whatever he's saying is 100 percent accurate. My family members got treated in Aga Khan and south city hospitals while paying millions for diseases like fracture and malaria. What a pity

  • @bhaskerl.shukla6722
    @bhaskerl.shukla6722 Місяць тому +9

    You are bold enough to give this type of blog

  • @rabiatabassum5632
    @rabiatabassum5632 Місяць тому +4

    How to broadly express the views which we have faced in our past time .... the school... Their staff likely behave to the innocent children... Everywhere was fear ... Each and everything you reminded me... Hats to you brave Muzamil Bhai🙌

  • @sharipn8348
    @sharipn8348 Місяць тому +20

    Im a doctor in India, the situation of healthcare in Government hospitals in India is very bad... not sanitary, long lines, overworked doctors ect.. especially in Northern states. I worked in Karnataka where atleast its better than other states.. A lot of improvement has to be done in these hospitals...

    • @shraddhagupta7045
      @shraddhagupta7045 Місяць тому +1

      My teachers are doctors in Ranchi vo bhi yhi btate hai. And work ke according salary bhi nhi milti hai, Bahut overwork krna padta hai

    • @sureshdewan5350
      @sureshdewan5350 Місяць тому +1

      It is partially true. The situation has changed after Covid 19. A lot of improvement is clearly visible. My nephew who works in Indonesia visited recently and went to Safdarjung Hospital for some treatment and was surprised to see improvement in services.

    • @docav4005
      @docav4005 Місяць тому +2

      Doctors in government hospitals are overworked. So many suffer from depression and anxiety. The private sector doesn't permit ethical practice as the management is from MBA or finance. They don't pay the doctors well. At many places, the ward boy gets more money than a fresh medical graduate

    • @Ashishkumar-ks6uo
      @Ashishkumar-ks6uo Місяць тому +1

      I agree with you.... But ye only doctor le sath nhi hota hai...... Every field mai hota hai... Yes improvement ki jarurat hai... But 140 crore population hai india ki... Uske according ye hona normal hai......... Or salary or others ki bat... Doctors ki salary fir be better hai... Go & check every state... Normal person average salary... Or work time....... Issue sbko hai...... Hum bhut easily bol dete ye wrong hai... Wo wrong hai..... But uske liye kuch nhi krte...... Jin facilitiy ko bat ap kar rhe... Bo phle usse be low thi......... Ab thodi better ho rhi hai..... So pls ye be understand kre. .... Or 140 crore population ko manage krna this is not joke...... Ap apne village ya one hospital ya others ko correct way mai manage nhi kar pate... But blame dusro par why....

  • @SP.05
    @SP.05 Місяць тому +8

    Much Anticipated Bro 👍👍👍
    Clip from your Black Hole Talk... Nevertheless an upload

  • @trance4me875
    @trance4me875 Місяць тому +4

    What an amazing lecture ❤ the way you described about "print media and its importance" is absolutely phenomenal...

  • @AshokSharma-nb2gl
    @AshokSharma-nb2gl 4 дні тому

    The more I listen to you, the more I am convinced that we need a lot many Muzammil in this subcontinent. Keep it up, Beta.

  • @janamfedaehadrii3833
    @janamfedaehadrii3833 Місяць тому +7

    Muzamil needs millions of Suscribers

  • @donbrad6011
    @donbrad6011 Місяць тому +5

    Well read ,free thinker- this man

  • @tys6430
    @tys6430 Місяць тому

    He is such a powerful speaker!! A strong, bold and much-needed honest voice for our times.

  • @RoarMaddy
    @RoarMaddy Місяць тому +2

    The same things are happening here in India. Congress had the chance to remove religion from politics, but they missed it. Now we are facing extremism in our country.

  • @aslam8899
    @aslam8899 Місяць тому +7

    جو بچے پڑھ کر آتے ہیں اسکولوں میں امتحان کے ٹائم پر انہیں فیل کر دیا جاتا ہے، حال ہی میں اسکینڈل آیا تھا سندھ سے بہت بڑا، درست 👍

    • @hunk3891
      @hunk3891 Місяць тому

      So they should go to Madrassa.

  • @muhammadwaheed9228
    @muhammadwaheed9228 Місяць тому +13

    سر مزمل اپ بہت شکریہ ہمیں صحیح معنوں میں شعور دینے کیلئے❤

  • @omaisahsan8882
    @omaisahsan8882 Місяць тому

    Love the way he speaks, not full rhetoric, we need more people like him

  • @jiqbalg
    @jiqbalg Місяць тому +2

    SM is a great reformist. I always love to listen his videos. Very insightful and enlightening conversation. I salute you❤❤❤❤

  • @sumitdhar6621
    @sumitdhar6621 Місяць тому +11

    Born in 69 in Kolkata India. What you say about schooling and position of women in society was very similar to what I experienced. But we did not want that for our children, friends, sisters and even our mom’s. How things changed I do not know but they did - I guess each one wanting something better for themselves, their families and the people around them starts a silent revolution. We still have some way to go but when I look back, partly thanks to your video, I think we have come a long long way. I hope you folks discover your path.

  • @user-fc1hk5eu1k
    @user-fc1hk5eu1k Місяць тому +12

    Sir your working very well

  • @SuvaMukherjee
    @SuvaMukherjee Місяць тому +1

    ❤Amazing analysis ... God bless you !!

  • @adilshah2554
    @adilshah2554 Місяць тому

    Truly, a well needed podcast.

  • @montainlovers2534
    @montainlovers2534 Місяць тому +3

    Great sir.
    Love and respect from Skardu.

  • @vinvin4001
    @vinvin4001 Місяць тому +8

    Thank you Syed. Why are you so different? You are not a typical pakistani is any sense. So my question is how is it possible that your thought process is so independent while having been brought up in a society with such a rigid mindset. I wish you well and pray that you can help people of that region.

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 Місяць тому

      The simple answer: Independent thinking process and constant learning and analysis.
      It is not a big deal.
      Every human being is supposed to do this - not be a brainwashed fanatic zombies

  • @varunkachella6333
    @varunkachella6333 Місяць тому

    Thankyou so much for bringing some light on real issues.👍❤🙏

  • @jiteshsharma8542
    @jiteshsharma8542 Місяць тому +1

    I am from India and i watched your complete video brother and i am sure people like you definitely change the current situation of Pakistan lagay rho bhai best of luck

  • @Piscesxxx
    @Piscesxxx Місяць тому +6

    9:07 he's absolutely right.... Girls' biggest wish is to be free and freely walk outside without any fear

    • @TheEnigmaticPoet
      @TheEnigmaticPoet Місяць тому +2

      I don't think so it will happen in my lifetime but I hope it happens . I am a feminist myself

    • @starsandbeyond8947
      @starsandbeyond8947 Місяць тому +1

      Literally I have so much love for running since childhood but as I grow its less and less feasible to the point I wanna leave

    • @truthloversseekers
      @truthloversseekers Місяць тому +1

      @@TheEnigmaticPoet Same.

    • @Piscesxxx
      @Piscesxxx Місяць тому

      ​@@starsandbeyond8947 i can totally understand😢

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Місяць тому +5

    Thank you 🥺

  • @abhipratik7414
    @abhipratik7414 Місяць тому

    Excellent. I am so happy to hear this example by you Sir. I/we have used/adopted the theory of Discipline and Punishment in one of my article published in BMC Health Services Research. We highlight how the concept of discipline and punishment are embedded in the governance policy documents of health departments to control/govern medical practitioners and create docile bodies.

  • @fatihanehal7092
    @fatihanehal7092 Місяць тому +1

    You are new hope for this generation, I'm really amazed

  • @ruin9
    @ruin9 Місяць тому +12

    I really like the fact that ,he's teaching all these things to Pakistanis but Indians are the ones who are learning from his videos.Awesome Teacher Mr. Muzammil

    • @dreamingaboutjungkook3930
      @dreamingaboutjungkook3930 Місяць тому

      These all are faltu ki baaten. Hospital mai laakho insaan ke saath empathy show aap khud nahi karoge jis din aap uska hissa honge.

  • @Don-fm9ok
    @Don-fm9ok Місяць тому +3

    Bro u r phenomenal. Keep up the good work.

  • @muqaddashanif6401
    @muqaddashanif6401 Місяць тому

    I knew it from the very first day that you are different. More power to you gentleman!

  • @biologistsaima6084
    @biologistsaima6084 Місяць тому

    Im a teacher and 100% agreed with muzammil, he is so vocal, we need such journalists, appreciated 👏,

  • @ProudMurtad
    @ProudMurtad Місяць тому +12

    Ya Allah mere mulk to secular democracy bana 🇵🇰

    • @nitinakuch4973
      @nitinakuch4973 Місяць тому +5

      😂

    • @ProudMurtad
      @ProudMurtad Місяць тому +1

      @@nitinakuch4973 Are you lindouz?

    • @mrknownothing2470
      @mrknownothing2470 Місяць тому +1

      To become a secular country, it first needs accept that there are other beliefs in "God" than Islam and to accept that people do not have to believe in Allah or any other God.

    • @ProudMurtad
      @ProudMurtad Місяць тому +1

      @@mrknownothing2470 Inshallah we will get the heart and mental capacity to understand that Allah is not the only God. As well as the fact that some people love Dog more than God. All deserve equality under the law.

    • @Coolboy-if1rr
      @Coolboy-if1rr Місяць тому +3

      Shariya nahi chahiye???😅​@@ProudMurtad

  • @soniaatta2418
    @soniaatta2418 Місяць тому

    What a brilliant speaker,his profound insights and wisdom-filled talks captivate and enlighten us leaving inspired and enriched with valuable perspectives.stay safe ❤

  • @MuhammadUsama_Xd
    @MuhammadUsama_Xd Місяць тому +1

    I am glad you've quoted Michel Foucault's work on prisons , i hope you will make videos on the critique of the filth he did with children in tunisia... Thank you

  • @kiranmoghe3716
    @kiranmoghe3716 Місяць тому +4

    Great guy with lot of logical thoughts!!!!
    Unfortunately pak is in such a reverse gear that nothing is going to change but good efforts by this guy!!!! Kudos!!!!

    • @Xmagneto11
      @Xmagneto11 Місяць тому

      Unfortunately our country is also pulling that gear

    • @kiranmoghe3716
      @kiranmoghe3716 Місяць тому

      @@Xmagneto11
      Our country is liberal only because hindu majority........Kashmir when touched 50% Muslims then Hindus where slaughtered and forced out of Kashmir!!!!!
      Lebanon was secular because of Christens but 30% Muslim population made sure that they are driven out and made it 100% Islamic country in a decade!!!!!
      Egypt was Christian country......today its Islamic country.
      I can give many many more examples!!!!! And in Islamic countries their is no secularism!!!!! Period!¡!!!!
      So if India is changing........that is required Because of above examples!!!!! Isn't it?

    • @Xmagneto11
      @Xmagneto11 Місяць тому

      Yeah I see . I would like you to note this comment and come after four years. The way you treated foreign students is perfect example. There is no secularism in India either don't fool it's only in constitution. It's liberal because of constitution not Hindus. What you are doing to Manipur and muslims in India everyone sees it.. that's what I want to explain extremism in any religion leads to destruction. Europe is secular without Hindu population so don't brag@@kiranmoghe3716

  • @user-cu9jv4rq3l
    @user-cu9jv4rq3l Місяць тому +4

    Humary school system bahut stress or fear sy bhary hoye han. Ma khud school system ka baaghi hon. Critical thinking or abilities ko grow nhi kiya ja skta stress k mahol ma.

  • @deepster8731
    @deepster8731 Місяць тому

    so refreshing to listen to sir and his thoughts, if i take anything from him it is the importance of reading

  • @truelines202
    @truelines202 Місяць тому +7

    Big fan of you sir

  • @RAJENDRASINGH-os1vw
    @RAJENDRASINGH-os1vw Місяць тому +22

    Seeing the situation in Pakistan today, I will say just one line. Well done Jinnah

    • @satpalbatra8065
      @satpalbatra8065 Місяць тому

      If Jinnah were alive a few more years he would have demanded a demerger. He had no social philosophy. Wanted to be leader solely in religious bigotary, without any plan for public welfare.

    • @akashvalsan6609
      @akashvalsan6609 Місяць тому

      😂😂😂

    • @yasyr95
      @yasyr95 Місяць тому +1

      Not mistake of Jinnah dear.

    • @imransuhail82
      @imransuhail82 Місяць тому +1

      enjoying the suffering of others is a sign of sickness.

    • @akashvalsan6609
      @akashvalsan6609 Місяць тому

      @@imransuhail82 we are kafirs, I think that's what your Pak studies have taught you. Then why deny?

  • @pranabeshchowdhury7993
    @pranabeshchowdhury7993 Місяць тому +2

    Lots of love for you. May god bless you. Kolkata, India.

  • @zygirl7666
    @zygirl7666 2 дні тому

    Golden words by Shah G.
    JazakAllah.

  • @TechnologyTubes
    @TechnologyTubes Місяць тому +4

    4:56 میں نے بھی اسی لیے سکول چھوڑ دیا تھا۔مجھے کوئی سمجھ ہی نہیں سکا۔سہی ٹیچر مل جاتے تو شاہد آج کے سٹوذنٹ میری شخصیت پر بھی لوگ پی ایچ ڈی کرتے۔

  • @humaraisani7137
    @humaraisani7137 Місяць тому +5

    Muzamil u know i am.daughter in law of Late Sardar Attullah khan mengal and was put inside a Fort for 15 years and having no right to speak even when i started to teach those kids whom fathers were killed bcz of being BNP mengals members then my Brother in law Sardar Akhtar mengal gave a fatwa against me and my husband was akh by Akhtar mengal same at time Ryasat said ur father was member of BLA but i fought against both of them and i am satisfied today at least i raise my voice against voilence but lose my faith in oper wala during my struggle

  • @santanuc05
    @santanuc05 Місяць тому

    I wish people like you are present in India as well. You have guts, courage and conviction. Hats off to you Sir.

  • @deepakkalro5405
    @deepakkalro5405 Місяць тому +1

    Very well explained Syed Muzamil,hopefully such good speeches do effect the minds of dominating males,hopefully the society brings the change and give a girl child to live a life of freedom and she takes decisions on her own without being suppressed.
    I’m proud of you that there are good thinkers like you and we need more of people like you not only in Pakistan but in some parts of India as well.
    Hats off to you brother

  • @Getlearn01
    @Getlearn01 Місяць тому +3

    Muzammal bhi ❤

  • @Professor63752
    @Professor63752 Місяць тому +4

    CPEC pe ek video banao Sir.

  • @amnagrewal5197
    @amnagrewal5197 Місяць тому

    Till now I haven’t seen a person like him in pakistan. Salute to you man for bringing truth infront of people! Only men like you can change this society. 💫

  • @user-zm5pf4ju4t
    @user-zm5pf4ju4t Місяць тому +1

    I tried to see all of your videos.
    You are a hope of good people of Pakistan.

  • @Aloksheoran
    @Aloksheoran Місяць тому +6

    Best speaker of Indian subcontinent

  • @shanu7uday
    @shanu7uday Місяць тому +40

    Hit like if you are NOT an Indian watching it 😜

    • @Ramkrishna-2023
      @Ramkrishna-2023 Місяць тому +1

      Not much different than India

    • @himalaziz5529
      @himalaziz5529 Місяць тому +1

      India walay apna haal deikh lein pehle 🤡 hamein kam se kam apni aukat toh pta hai.

    • @bavaal4614
      @bavaal4614 23 дні тому

      😂​@@himalaziz5529

    • @ArjunSingh-gv1jd
      @ArjunSingh-gv1jd 20 днів тому +4

      ​@@himalaziz5529 bhai India kii ranking kisi bhi cheez mein jaa kr check le from export to economy to ppp... Aur fhir Pakistan ka kr le. .
      Tu khud uske baad aise comment nhi karega....

    • @UzairAshrafj
      @UzairAshrafj 20 днів тому +1

      ​Per Capita Pakistan se ACHA zarroor hai Lekin world level pe it a ACHA ni ​@@ArjunSingh-gv1jd

  • @sabih_hm
    @sabih_hm Місяць тому

    Bro keep it up thank u so much❤

  • @meerosman9696
    @meerosman9696 Місяць тому

    Each word spoken in this video absolute truth. This is exactly how things around us works. I use to be those nive,Docile students. Although a little late but ever since I have learn this truth I have learnt to live with it. It is highly important to be cautious and skeptic towards people are us.

  • @abhishekdjain1080
    @abhishekdjain1080 Місяць тому +18

    RATIONAL VIEWER FROM INDIA

    • @abc_cba
      @abc_cba Місяць тому +3

      Bhai, Zara apne Desh ka haal dekh, kya chal Raha Hain apne yaha.
      Yaha bhi bolna seekh. Pakistan se kya ho kar lenge hum?

    • @arunkdhar756
      @arunkdhar756 Місяць тому

      Excellent presentation & thoughts

    • @user-zk5md7gm9k
      @user-zk5md7gm9k Місяць тому

      ​@@abc_cbatu jawab spde azadi ke time ke 20 percent hindu kaha gye ? Pakistan se

  • @sagarmeena0210
    @sagarmeena0210 Місяць тому +3

    Twitter has been blocked for 1 month by establishment 😢

  • @shabanariaz1491
    @shabanariaz1491 Місяць тому

    Thank you for sharing wisdom and having the courage to spread awareness 🙏.
    Every common man having some wisdom is being killed by the powerful .......

  • @zaheeranwar12
    @zaheeranwar12 Місяць тому

    Appreciate it ❤

  • @fuaadashraf9743
    @fuaadashraf9743 Місяць тому +3

    yr m b pakistan m rehta hn mje nhi pta k pakistan m women ko kon shameful kehta hy, mene to ye dekha hy women ko line m nhi lgny dety women ko respect dety hn

  • @brijsingh7740
    @brijsingh7740 Місяць тому +3

    After listening you in your most podcasts I am sure there is no solution for Pakistan to come out from this prison period, seems like born in prison will die in prison.

  • @zakirali992
    @zakirali992 Місяць тому

    What a talk on our schooling system we also bearing this all what you have gone through it . Sir you always aware of us to something new.

  • @raoadnan1649
    @raoadnan1649 Місяць тому +2

    Fantastic analysis 👍

  • @neutral258
    @neutral258 Місяць тому +14

    मिश्र के एक मुस्लिम नेता के शब्दों में: इस्लाम ने महिला पर हिनता की मोहर लगा दी हैं तथा सामाजिक प्रथाओं को धर्म की स्वीकृति देकर उसे आत्म-अभिव्याक्ती और व्याक्तीत्व के विकास के सभी अवसरों से वंचित कर दिया हैं।

    • @yasirhussain9107
      @yasirhussain9107 Місяць тому

      Your creative potential is limited to hate

    • @ajaykumarpal3357
      @ajaykumarpal3357 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@yasirhussain9107He is saying right. You open your eyes.

    • @THEeaternalpeople
      @THEeaternalpeople Місяць тому

      ​@@yasirhussain9107Bro broaden your thinking to become rational

  • @santoshmhaisne
    @santoshmhaisne Місяць тому +7

    You are not believe in Allah and it's i think 💯

  • @sant.76
    @sant.76 Місяць тому

    Kya baat hai bhai. I have started to listen to you more and more.

  • @manjeetkocchar2662
    @manjeetkocchar2662 Місяць тому +2

    Thanks Muzamiljee it is too good

  • @sanatani8706
    @sanatani8706 Місяць тому +3

    Exmuslim Sahil and Adam jindabad 🎉❤
    Exmuslim movement Jindabad 🎉❤

    • @ProudMurtad
      @ProudMurtad Місяць тому +2

      Ex-Hindu ko bhe Zindabad bol do yaar

  • @vikashramrakhiani3888
    @vikashramrakhiani3888 Місяць тому +3

    Great analysis 👍