Sir you started with explaining ibn arabi’a conception of knowledge and diverted to sufi understanding of knowledge. I found this “straying from path” for subject at hand. Stay blessed
The question is if Western scholars have disputed or criticized the ideas of Ibn Arabi, a renowned Islamic mystic and philosopher. Yes, some Western scholars have engaged with and critiqued Ibn Arabi's ideas, particularly his metaphysical and theological concepts. While some have appreciated his mystical and poetic insights, others have raised philosophical and theological objections. Some criticisms include: 1. Pantheism: Some scholars have accused Ibn Arabi of promoting pantheistic views, which they see as incompatible with traditional Islamic theology. 2. Monism: His concept of wahdat al-wujud (unity of existence) has been criticized for potentially blurring the distinction between God and creation. 3. Determinism: Ibn Arabi's ideas on fate and destiny have been seen as overly deterministic by some scholars. 4. Mystical interpretations: Some have questioned his mystical interpretations of Quranic verses and Hadith, seeing them as overly allegorical or subjective.. سر اپنے مطالعے کی روشنی میں مغربی اوبجیکشنز کا جواب دیں
Javaid Sahib please apny khud jo Ilm li tashree fermai hy, jis per apka aek lecture apny Al-Moarad myn dia tha, us per mazeed programs ker dyn, shidat sy intizar hy apki waza kerda theory of knowledge ka. Apka Buhat Shukria
Aapky lectures bohat mufeed hty hain lakin aik darkhawast hai aap easy aam feham urdu mai beyan kia krein aur English words jo use krty hain unky meaning b btaya krein
اللھم ارنی حقیقۃ الاشیاء کما ھی ۔۔۔۔
اے اللہ مجھے تمام چیزوں کی حقیقت اسی طرح دکھا دے ، جس طرح وہ ہیں
حضرت کا سایہ تادیر ہمارے سروں پر قائم رکھے آمین ثمہ آمین
آمین ثم آمین
Excellent
Sir you started with explaining ibn arabi’a conception of knowledge and diverted to sufi understanding of knowledge. I found this “straying from path” for subject at hand. Stay blessed
Hazrat aapka terze bayan bahut moassar hai MashaAllah
Bahut hi Daqiq Bataan.
I cannot even begin to describe how insightful and satisfying this lecture is for me , just finished watching it
jazakallah asan zuban ma batany ka boht acha laga sun k
I wish I had a teacher like this explaining "Mantiq" (Logic) to me, in my formative years.
ماشاءاللہ ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب ❣️
Masha Allah
Jazak Allah
Thank you
زبردست۔
The question is if Western scholars have disputed or criticized the ideas of Ibn Arabi, a renowned Islamic mystic and philosopher.
Yes, some Western scholars have engaged with and critiqued Ibn Arabi's ideas, particularly his metaphysical and theological concepts. While some have appreciated his mystical and poetic insights, others have raised philosophical and theological objections.
Some criticisms include:
1. Pantheism: Some scholars have accused Ibn Arabi of promoting pantheistic views, which they see as incompatible with traditional Islamic theology.
2. Monism: His concept of wahdat al-wujud (unity of existence) has been criticized for potentially blurring the distinction between God and creation.
3. Determinism: Ibn Arabi's ideas on fate and destiny have been seen as overly deterministic by some scholars.
4. Mystical interpretations: Some have questioned his mystical interpretations of Quranic verses and Hadith, seeing them as overly allegorical or subjective..
سر اپنے مطالعے کی روشنی میں مغربی اوبجیکشنز کا جواب دیں
Javaid Sahib please apny khud jo Ilm li tashree fermai hy, jis per apka aek lecture apny Al-Moarad myn dia tha, us per mazeed programs ker dyn, shidat sy intizar hy apki waza kerda theory of knowledge ka. Apka Buhat Shukria
دم مست قلندر مست پر لاکھوں سلام
آمین ۔۔۔جزاک اللہ۔۔
Excellent analysis
ان کی اس سلسلے کی باقی ویڈیو ریکارڈنگ کہاں ہیں ؟
Aapky lectures bohat mufeed hty hain lakin aik darkhawast hai aap easy aam feham urdu mai beyan kia krein aur English words jo use krty hain unky meaning b btaya krein
Hazrat Ibne Arabi aur Shahaubbin Umar Suharawardi main jo ikhtilaf/difference tha uss par baat kar saktey hain ?
❤️❤️
حضرت کا جھومتے ہوےارشاد فرمانا۔۔۔۔۔کیا رمزھے آہا
Ma sha Allah. Impressive.