Is the end of Article 370 the end of Nehruvian hypocrisy ?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 сер 2019
- Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
What do you mean " left the valley"? It was ethnic cleansing.
SG is being payed for such twisting of words kind of journalism under freedom of speech
@@ramendradwivedi7631 did you watch the video? I'm sure you didn't.... That statement was made by the anchor
Left the valley is more realistic than ethnic cleansing.... exaggeration ki bhi hadd hoti hai yaar...
@@ishqiyakumar6481 driven out of the valley with calls for "convert leave or die" would be more accurate. Highlighting the atrocities done to drive them out would be even more accurate....
@@ishqiyakumar6481 🤦🤦" Kashmiri pandit exodus " report padho .
The lady repeatedly makes factually incorrect statement that instrument of accession was signed on the basis of article 370. Instrument of Accession was signed in 1947. Article 370 came at least 2 years later.
This lady is always on the wrong side as she is stooge
For Imran Khan," dumb is a compliment"... masterpiece and a 3 pointer by Shekhar 😁😁😁
😅😅😅😅😅
@@malihabadi0 next stop is Muzaffarabad
Dumb imran ko bola dard jyoti ko hua..😂😂
@@Ravi.y jyoti ko pathan pasand honge :P
@@ramendradwivedi7631 😂😂😂😂
Who is this lady...?
she couldn't handle a negative statement, on Kashmiri ex leaders, Imran Khan or Donald Trump...but simply comes hard on BJP for abolishing a stupid article.
370 was a mistake in 1949. End of story. 35A addition in 1954 was even more insidious.
Both great conspiracies by Nehru and also " plebiscite "
Truth
Kashmiri Pandits left the valley, huh?! As opposed to forced to leave
Today the PM has shown what it needs to be a great great great leader. What courage ....what a bold decision.All hawalawallahs shedding bogus croc tears. Better support modi sir...He needs all the power he can muster. A tall leader like him needs a moat of ppl like you. A day of celebration!!!!.
Atleast sheker learnt a lesson and start giving neutral and true news and lady is so desperate to drag Modi in whole scene and wanted sheker to abuse Modi. Every time sheker talk about whole GEO POLITICS she drag him in Kashmir.
she goes to every Pak news channel and takes side with Pakistanis....I was surprised
K 2 you can but journalists should analysis not opinions
Ayush Chaturvedi bro,why did you drag allah in this? You shouldn’t do this. This is not about Hindu and Muslims. Plz talk with sense on social media. Majority of Muslims are also patriotic like other
This mrs malhotra and shekhar gupta are pro pak and anti Hindu
Need "Cut the clutter" ASAP
Shah has DONE it Clear & Sound :-)
There's nothing to be decluttered that too from a sell-out who openly confessed that he is a seel-out.
Yes
@@sasidharankarthikeyan3798 my point was to make an analysis video of 'cut the clutter'in this topic,'which shekhar sir has started.
Imran Khan is 'Dimmer than Trump', echos Salman Rushdie, love it.
"Pakistan Sucks" - Salman Rushdie.
Yeah Salman Rushdie called him ‘Im the dim’
Link bro ...
See 1:22 ua-cam.com/video/wF_Bxzzddnk/v-deo.html
How childish and immature .. a lot can be said about Modi and Rushdi as well. But if there are adults in this forum then think about what purpose is served by this.
Sometimes Durbari inside Shekhar takes the better of him... Of course economy is going through tough period but you have to applaud the courage the Modi-Shah duo has shown in scrapping 370...and no..it's not a small thing as you are trying to downplay it... It's a historic decision which is going to be decisive in solving the Kashmir problem once and for all.
First time I am impressed with Mr Gupta. This lady is cornered. She was not prepared for this conversation
"For Imran Khan dumb is a compliment." ROFL!!! 🤣🤣🤣
The lady(on the left😅 leftist) seems to be worried and unable to digest statements from shekar(leftist seems like he Is on right side today)......
Awesome....
SG is one of the most articulate political commentators and candid .
She was unable to decide whether to attend to her smart phone or the dumb camera or the ultra smart audience...out here :-)
what after 1 yr
@@RuNOuT3466 Nothing.
Pakistan failed to internationalise the issue. Terrorism and deaths have been reduced by 46%. A record 23 million tourists visited kashmir this year.
Mr. Gupta, never seen you so charged up like today! Glad to see you in this form. You're an inspiration!
@Saad King Cry me a river, bitch
gupta k andar ka indian jaag gaya..modi ne jagaya hai
Ashish Deshpande sir Ji Gupta r Actually Muslim
@@paramajeetsingh3557 I don't think him being Muslim or Christian is influencing his thoughts. He's an intelligent man who doesn't favor a particular religion.
people like someone at top of this reply section are those extremists ..who have annexed gilgit baltistan without asking people but will cry for internal matters of other countries ... right or wrong decision ..its still our internal matter .. how much we argue among ourselves we are united against outsiders ...also veiled threats work both ways ..do not think playing with fire will leave you unburnt
Best line for Pakistan: appka pyar pyar hmara pyar sex😂😂
Article 370 Goes
A very welcome step. This will lead ultimately to the end of feudalism ( Jagirdari system ) in Kashmir.
Common Kashmiri is very poor. In winters they come to Punjab as wood cutters , labourers etc .
There is little difference between the Separatists and so called Main stream Kashmiri politicians.
Both are feudal lords and exploit common Kasmiris. Why they support Pakistan is not because they feel threatened by a non Muslim India. They feel at home with Pakistan because Jagirdari still survives in Pakistan.
"He (Imran Khan) doesn't have the body mandate..!"..legendary!
I started liking and following Shekar Gupta after became neutral and unbiased.... Cheers
Amit shah offered mediation between America and North Korea!
Haha! Right bro! I also heard about that!
Shekhar, you can hardly conceal your joy and excitement. It's so visible. You are a hardcore Hindustani.
Tax raids possibility. Yes he is less of a congi leftie now.
Don't fall I trap...once election come close he will show his true colour
She seems to really agitated by SG's views.
Waited all day to hear from Shekhar Gupta and he did not disappoint.
@13:32 “For Imran Khan, dumb is a compliment”. I LAUGHED 😂😂😂😂😂
Jyoti Malhotra is worse than Sagarika Ghosh
payed , biased and truely shameless punjabi malhotra jyoti selling conscience for money in name of profession.
@@ramendradwivedi7631 bro don't involve Punjabi's in this. We don't want to be associated with such people 😂
13:26
Shekhar : Imran Khan is dumb
Lady: Hush! Young people are watching
Young people : What the fuck, lol .
Edit
17:02 "Aap kare toh ishq,hum kare toh sex" . Shekhar Mamu is on a roll😂😂
GUTS hai Boss !!!! Great work ... Its the.. Finally it will be integrated
Nope. Tibet never belonged to China though they might have been vassals at some points in history. Kashmir has been part of Indian civilization for thousands of years.
Agreed.. the basic Idea is the way Integration will happen within the rest of India .. economically and demographically...
North East situation is totally different from Kashmir.... Don't compare
Northeast is not affected by separatist forces inside the states. Its states and people are as Indian as anyone from the inner India. We are patriotic towards Our nation and will die for it. So yeah... don't fucking comapre northeast to kashmir situation.
True.. It's doesn't breed terrorism.. They are fighting for attention and basic rights
Ur next 😂
Camera should have included J&K, and Ladakh in the map at the back as well 🙏
Very nice Observence....
Shekhar sir on fire!! He is one angry man today 😜 nice to see you this way sir. Keep decluttering with the facts. 🙌🏼
Dumb is fine. Dumb is a compliment to Imran Khan 😂
Quint will be quint...however, this time, and I hope not for the last time, Shekhar Gupta....simply WOW!!
Distracted lady! She was not listening. Busy with her phone.
This was a live stream. She's checking the questions people were sending in.
It is good that art.370 was abrogated in J&K.
My only other wish was Jammu would have been made separate, so that it can develop freely.
Who is this lady.. real pain...Completely unaware of timelines of instrument of accession n article 370/35A
Jyoti can you please take some coaching in how not to interrupt when you interview anyone ?
rashida sitabkhan. Now we know why Indian leaders divided India? Every time Gandhi spoke for peace, Mohammad Jinnah interrupted him. Gandhi got so mad and fed up, he tells Nehru lets divide India and get rid of this mad Moosalmaan Jinnah forever. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha. I love your comments. .
rashida sitabkhan what are your views on triple talaaq bill and on halala practice?
Good riddance to TT (NH goes with it) @@austin426512
rashida sitabkhan
?no no hmm hmmjnoj
M
rashida sitabkhan
?no no hmm hmmjnoj
M
Very Smart Man. He Seems Like Najam Sethi Of Pakistan. Both Are Very Smart, Pragmatic, True & Loaded With Facts. Love Listening To Shekhar Ji
Yes, please watch Najam Sethi's analysis as well.
Excellent analysis
IMRAN KHAN RUNS TO TRUMP...TRUMP HELP PAKISTAN......TRUMP DONT WANT YOU PAKISTANI'S ANY WHERE CLOSE TO HIM
Shekhar Gupta on fire today 😂 rocked it totally 😎kudos to you uncle 🙌
Shekhar Sir, it seems your tilt is towards this decision, which is interesting to see😂😂
Gupta sir was on a different mode and electrifying energy, seems he is happy 🤔🧐
Not since 1947 , article 370 was imposed in 1949 , after 2 years of accession by Hari Singh ,it was temporary and could b removed after a year
@@manofsan it was introduced in 1949 during all state representative meeting where all state representative were asked to accept one constitution ,I agree I came into form 1954 as temporary provision
I'm afraid if this lady will continue to be in ThePrint after today's episode, she is one of favorite Panelist in Pakistani Channels ;)
It's a treat to watch him talk. It's like those frustrating monologues from Pyaar ka Punchnama.
Well done Shekhar Gupta, I used to see you on NDTV and you have grown a spine on the Print. I loved it when you batted Trump desire to mediate out of the field for a 6. Great analysis.
Hua so hua..give credit where it’s due..modi rocks
excellent i love this side of Shekhar .... i must say Sir you understand international & Indian Politics Bast 100/100.
Situation of j&k like cancer Amit oparate it very smoothly this is good for all 😊🙌🇮🇳🙏
Sharad Agrahari who started the cancer in the first place? Why Indians are afraid to point the finger? Can you reply who is the leader who started this you call cancer?
I believe he has cut the frame thoughtfully and deliberately so that map in the background cuts at Kashmir.
Government of Pakistan abolished State Subject Rule in Gilgit-Baltistan in 1974, which resulted in demographic changes in the territory.
Homework is definitely not Imran Khan's thing, he did not even know how to behave in the international conferences.
Shekhar is on fire today. Loved it, sir. May you live for 100 years. P.S. Your colleague (sorry I don’t know her name) is very good as well.
Excellent move by BJP. This will hopefully integrate Kashmir into mainstream India and open up the country for Kashmiris and vice versa.
"For Imran Khan, 'Dumb' is a compliment" Kudos Mr. Gupta :)
Superb off the cuff video. Lot of fire by Shekar sir. Nice to see
'Savage' Shekhar today... Loved every bit of this episode... Waiting for cut the clutter
the lady says "kashmiri pundits LEFT"... Wow!!!!! Heights of hypocrisy.They were brutally uprooted.....
It appears when Indian Security Interests come, Congress and Pakistan are on the same page.
Very well said Pakistan has no right to speak about Kashmir region since they gifted part of Kashmir to China. So also when Pakistan have not accepted Bihari migrants from Bangladesh , Pakistan Kashmiri love affair is also a joke.
intelectual need to shame, Shekhar gupta is real intelect and ost wonderfull journalist i have ever seen.
Abrogation of these articles should have happened soon after the British left our shores and the I Indian minds had decolonized!!
In any case this is may the right time since India is economically strong while Pakistan is at its worst economically!
Mota Bhai has thrown Imran and Trump outside the window.
India, did a quick move, thanks India, you saved us some tax dollars here. Now, get you're land back, India she misses her children, she wants all children together.
I think this guy deserves Ramon Magsaysay more than anyone!
Congratulation Shekharji. You very rightly predicted the move which demonstrates your deep understanding of the politics.
Why these two are talking about any political party... It's win for India why don't they talk positive about it... Is this lady moving towards Pakistan sentiments... Why the hell we should worry about Pakistan and telecasted in India, let them go to Pakistan...
Not all manifestos..just BJP ones...
I love this man, "sidhi baat no bakwaas"
How smoothly she use the term " left the valley" . And than they asked why these people are called hypocrite.
Superb replies from Mr. Gupta. The best show i watched today on this issue. 👍
Both of them needed to retire long time ago! They have been left behind due to their affiliations with the Lutyens gang!
That's a great compliment... Imran is totally ignorant about Kashmir issues
Humorous, insightful, sharp... But most important of all full of pure class journalism... Great work S G... Kudos to you...
Fantastic logic with facts put forth by Shekhar to very strict questions put forth. Calling out the hypocricy. Again even taking into precedence the fact that India went for plebiscite and Pakistan internationalising the issue. It has been delayed too long. Hail a straightforward Mr.Gupta..
You talk less about Non Accountability of 3 families. For which funds given from Union Government.
I already replied twice but it's such a great information delivery by this man.....he is now one of the people in my list I would love meeting at any point of time.....when he said Farukh Abdullah is the only revered man in valley now...blunt words but truth to the point...
Let's have more like this, expletives and all. This was the REAL blue-blooded De-Clutter !! God bless both of you for that.
When Shekhar Gupta talks about peace with Pakistan, shows his delusion! 😅
Why is the interviewing lady hijacking the dialogue ?.
How can the lady call it Amit Shahs political debacle? She is acting like Arnab of left by using such terms. Did not expect this from print.
In 2013 Pakistani army beheaded two indian soldiers and this lady was defending Pakistan on dd news.
Going against India and making senseless comments is her idea of gaining attention.
Happy to hear Mr Gupta
Very genuine talks
Day by day, I've started loving you Shekhar..not because of may be a true say on the current government but by the boldness with which you pace up your talks. Great job.
This lady hv soft corner for Pakistan and imran khan.
does any one know who she is ? why didnt she introduce herself?
GUTS hai BOSS MODI Me.😁🚩😍🇮🇳
This is SG not seen or heard before. Very aggressively explained. I always look forward to your decluttering of various issues
Can you please use a 5000 Rs. smartphone to record your videos so that we don't have to bear this terrible 10fps?
Its a youtube issue
Paisa nahi hai re baba!!!
Interesting analysis Mr Shekhar, will wait for more from you.
Thank you
Lesson- India needs to evolve into an Uncle 😀
pallavi rakshit it’s on the verge to become a father lmao
It”s a long awaited move from central governments in power. Only BJP had guts to do it. This will definitely enable people of J&K to progress in all aspects. Hopefully this will stop terrorism and provide good foundation for J&K youth and kids.
Jai Hind
People aren't seeing the dynamic. The interviewer is playing the role of a left leaning media person and Shekar is doing well to play a non partisan role. Helps you see the bigger picture through an argument. This guy is so savage.
Shekar loved this episode.Appriciate you for treating us like adults.
Could we please avoid the lady in future episodes. Seems to to quite biased in her views and. Constantly keeps interfering . Feels like I am watching Burkha dutt.
Very informative questions answers on the affairs of Jammu Kashmir and Ladakh after modifications of section 370 by the act of Parliament of India. Parm Gill, Canada
Mr Gill
Namaste from India
🙏🙏🙏🙏
Shekhar sab u nailed it. I hv no words to express.
Guptaji.. you tore apart all the hypocrisy. This is the way we need to stand behind our government at this critical time.
I laughed so hard that my eyes are full of tears.🤣🤣🤣🤣
Cut The Clutter is going to be Lit, can't wait.......!! 🔥🔥🔥
This time shekhar gupta gold..simply wow!!
Excellent analysis by two top tire journalists of our era. Loved it.
Shekhar sir !! what did you smoke today? really enjoyed your views....
Shekhar Gupta seems like a saint in the company of Jyoti Mehrotra. A case of the lesser evils.
Sekarji, thank god you are back in your true form, keep inspire us.
Shekhar Sir can you please share the name of the books (around 5 min mark) you were referring to understand more about the history of the state ?