आपको कोटि कोटि नमन! इस विषय पर आपके विश्लेषण का बहुत बेसब्री से इंतेजार कर रहा था । आपका विश्लेषण सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की ही तरह बहुत ही सरल भाषा में है ।
If we see there is inequality of promotion and very meagre representation of SC ST judges in various courts under different positions . Government should apply this judgement in the judiciary first.
आपका तर्क भारतीय संविधान और सर्वोच्च न्यायालय के खिलाफ है क्योंकि सरकार जनसख्या के हिसाब से हिस्सेदारी करती है तो समाज में जो पहले से असमानता चली आ रही है उसको बनाये रखना चाहती है अगर सरकार को समाज में समानता लानी है तो proactivly रहना ही होगा
We proud of honour of law specialist Mr Faizan Mustafa for his services to the Nation on issues of awareness for general body of our country,warm regards Maimoon Siddiqui
Yes it must end without any further dalay . It never good to have it in promotions . It has created lot of disparities in Government Services . Caste conflicts have been raised many times by these provisions .
When government privatising all govt departments ,the question as to employment and reservation will not arise ,,,there should be demand for employment and later reservation ,,,
फालतू में टैक्स के पैसों की बर्बादी करने वालों पर सक्कत action लेकर कार्रवाई करने की जरुरत है वो पैसा विकास रोड़ मार्ग सड़क रेलवे चिकित्सा खैती पशुपालन उधोग रोजगार में खर्च किया जाय जब देश आगे बढेगा जय भारत जय हिन्द
# It is possible because of you only that LAW has become that simple that a lay man cud also understand what the tough LAW is not comprehendible to even scholars... You speak Law and actually you are meant for it... The Law in LAW'S tounge... Regards sir...
Sir, I read entire judgment and there were so many facts to grasp, but thank you for simplifying it, now I am able to chronologically map all important points🙏
आरक्षण देने से पहले अच्छी शिक्षा दीजिए आरक्षण लेकर क्या करेंगे जब अच्छी शिक्षा ही नहीं रहेगी कुछ सीखी नहीं पाएंगे तो आरक्षण का क्या करेंगे कॉलेज और स्कूल की हालत क्या है किसी से छुपी नहीं है उसमें सुधार करिए यह सब होता रहेगा
Reservation ke apne hi fayde hai....Agar reservation nahi hota to...Baaki category ke log jee- jaan se competition nahi karte...Aur aaj jo pure vishwa me Bharat ke log acche aur uchh position me hai...Aisa time itni jaldi nahi aata.... Jo hota hai achhe k liye hota hai....👍 Baaki sudhar ki gunjaaish hai👍
बिना data के sc-st के promotion मे आरक्षण सही नहीं है। data के साथ ही ,sc-st को promotion मे आरक्षण दिया जाना चाहिए। और सरकारों को दिक्कत क्या है,data जुटाने मे।? स्पष्ट आंकड़े है,कि महत्वपूर्ण पदों पर sc-st कम हैं, उनको कोर्ट मे रखें।
Kaash k SC jaisey judges kahi distt & session courts mai bhi recruit ho jai... Sara kaam speedy ho jaye.. Kya ho ni sakta ki achey judges recruit ho distt & session courts mai.. 80% ko toh just date hi deni aati hai.. 10% date k saath saath kuch kaam bhi kar letey hai.. 10% sahi mai fast hai jo wakya hi kaam kartey hai inki vajah sey yeh 80% bach jatey hai..
सर आप के द्वारा समझाई गयी क़ानूनी प्रकिया हम को बहुत हेल्फ़ करती है हम उत्तराखंड के पहाड़ी गाँव से है हम को बहुत हेल्फ़ मिलती है आप की वीडियो से सर आप का बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद शुक्रिया आप जैसे गुरु हो तो देश बहुत ऊचाई पर पहुँचगा🙏🙏🙏
Sir thank you for your effort,video is very informative but it would be much more helpful for us if you try to explain the content in a simpler language.For people like us who are not from law background it becomes a bit difficult to grab the whole juice.I hope you will think about this.Jai HIND
You are a legend Faizaan Sir😃😃. You've explained everything in this video in very convincing way. As a student, I am enlightened. Thank you very very much!!
@@haramipandey6965 wo is baare me nahi bol paayenge unko sc st ki hits chaahiye is site ke liye, Mai bata raha hoon ki reservation in promotion raha hai rahega aur is aage aur badi matra me modi sarkaar karegi
Sir, I really appreciate the manner in which you explained this judgement. I will like to draw your attention to the fact that there is no reservation in promotion in Group A Posts in Central govt. So if there is consensus on continuation of reservation in promotion policy, then why restrict it to Group B & C Posts ?
भारतवर्ष में अब न्याय की प्रकिया में परिवर्तन की जरूरत है कयोंकि अब देश में राजनीति का बोलवाला है न्यायालय तो अब एक मोहरा बन चुका है. कर्मचारी पिछले 25 सालों से आरक्षण की मार झेल रहे थे और 2016से न्यायालय के फैसले का इंतजार करते करते कई कर्मचारी घर चले गए और बाकी भी ऐसे घर चले जावेगे. खोदा पहाड़ और निकली चुहिया.
@@ramkhelawansondhiya9606 आरक्षण राजनीतिक मजबूरियों के कारण दिया जा रहा है और ये मजबूरियां कभी समाप्त नहीं होगी। इसे न्यायालय कभी खत्म नहीं कर पायेगा। इसे राजनीतिक पार्टियां ही समाप्त कर पाएंगी। पर जनता का समर्थन धीरे धीरे मिलेगा। योगी के विरुद्ध अनारक्षित समाज पार्टी को 496 वोट प्राप्त हुए।
Well articulated description sir again. Kindly apprise viewers about regularisation of Temporary service. In the light of Uma Devi, Nihal Singh, Arjun Singh, Sachin Ambada Dawale, Narender Tiwari, Chander Mohun Negi, Somesh Thapaliyal Judgements pronounced by Hon'ble Apex Court
Vote ki rajneeti karne walon me munh par ye ek karara tamachahai.pramotion me reservation nahin hona chahiye.vo chahe sc St ka ho ya fir obc ka case ho .medical aur technical services men to bilkul nahin.sc ko lot of thanks.
We agree that there shouldn't be any reservations but then there shouldn't be any approach, but in India every body knows that here everything is fixed on the basis of caste, who will be selected or rejected. Private sector is highly biased in this context
I worked in Capgemini, most of my colleagues belonged to OBC, SC,ST. Yet they got selected and promoted because they are talented. Private sector is extremely transparent, please don't blame with your ignorance....First get into private job then give your experience....
जन्म से कोई गरीब नहीं है मेहनत नहीं करेंगे तो अमीर भी गरीब होने में देर नहीं लगेगी सो कर्म अच्छा करो सरकार की सुविधाएं योजनाएं का लाभ लेकर ऊपर आत्मनिर्भर बनाने का काम करें भगवान शिव ने हाथ पैर शरीर दिमाग हूनर सब करने को दिया है फिर फिरी की लालसा क्यो भगवान शिव भी नाराज होता है सोचो समझो जानो विचारों करो जय भारत जय हिन्द
Sir I appreciate the way you explained everything. But I think inadequacy in higher posts is because people from SC and ST generally join services very late. And for promotion to higher posts one has to serve certain minimum period of service and till they reach that duration they are near to retirement. SC and ST who join service at lower age reaches to higher posts even today.
Agar reservation promotion me khatm krna h to equal seat do, sc/St ko only 10 per diya ja rha seat or general ko 80 per seat dete ho or bolte ho ki reservation nhi milti h general ko
Britishers have laid down very complicated laws and procedures, to confuse people of India. Unfortunately, after 1947,not much has been done to simplify, as this is handy for Admn, to rule.
Sir in my opinion is the power full persons are willing to continue to caste system .now reservation is need to uplift the sc and St . SC and St are more suitable and mentally and physically capable fit comparing to the general caste people.sc St peoples are more honest and responsible.
Sar jab aap English language bolate Hain to sath mein uska Hindi language bhi jarur boliyega pleasekyunki special English AVN Court ki bhasha samajhne mein thodi si pareshani hoti hai aur sidhe sidhe shabdon mein samajh vaise aapane is decision ko bahut acche se samjhaya hai thank you very much
5. Concession in Promotions within Group A: There is no reservation in case of promotions by selection from a Group A post to another Group A post. But when promotions by selection are made from a Group A post to a Group A post which carries an ultimate salary of Rs.18,300/- (pre-revised), or less, the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Officers, who are senior enough in the zone of consideration for promotion so as to be within the number of vacancies for which the select list has to be drawn up, would be included in that list provided they are not considered unfit for promotion. Their position in the select list would, however, be same as assigned to them by the Departmental Promotion Committee on the basis of their record of service. Note: Fitness of the SC/ST officers in such cases would be assessed keeping in view the duties and responsibilities attached to the post and not on the basis of benchmark, if any, prescribed for promotion to the post.
आपको कोटि कोटि नमन!
इस विषय पर आपके विश्लेषण का बहुत बेसब्री से इंतेजार कर रहा था ।
आपका
विश्लेषण सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की ही तरह बहुत ही सरल भाषा में है ।
Very nice msg thanks Sahi kaha aapne Jay Bheem namo budhha Jay Savidhan
वोट दो...बाट दो.. लेकिन जो नोकरी की बात करेगा....
उसको पीट दो...वाह ये नेता shame shame
If we see there is inequality of promotion and very meagre representation of SC ST judges in various courts under different positions . Government should apply this judgement in the judiciary first.
if you don't know plz don't comment how do govt apply reservation in judiciary if there is a collegium system
@@vishalrai2859 there should not be any reservation fkin bs
बहुत बहुत शुक्रिया सर जी , आप ने सरलतम तरीके से प्रमोसन में आरक्षण को समझाया ।
एक मुसलमान की सोच में मुस्लिम देशों का स्थान पहला हैं तथा भारत का स्थान दुसरा हैं।
- बाबासाहब अंबेडकर
सरलीकरण के साथ साथ विषय की वैदुष्य पूरित प्रस्तुति;आपकी हौसलाअफजाई!***पटना से एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक सुरेंद्र प्र बिस्मिल
आंकड़े जुटाने मे कई वर्ष लग जायेंगे सरकार को और एक पीढी को प्रमोशन नही मिलेगा।
Aaj ke zamane mein data Lena koi difficult job nahi hai. If govt want they can get it in no times
Jaankari ke liye bahut bahut dhanyawad sir
भारत मे जातिगत जनगणना होनी चाहिए।
जिसकी जितनी आबादी उसका उतना ही संसाधनों पर अधिकार।
Ye tark hi galat hai... Abadi badh jane se resources increase nahi hotey hai
आपका तर्क भारतीय संविधान और सर्वोच्च न्यायालय के खिलाफ है क्योंकि सरकार जनसख्या के हिसाब से हिस्सेदारी करती है तो समाज में जो पहले से असमानता चली आ रही है उसको बनाये रखना चाहती है अगर सरकार को समाज में समानता लानी है तो proactivly रहना ही होगा
Kya yeah samvidhan main likha hai kya?
Outsourcing of manpower through GEM should be abolished for Young Generation Employment.
Very very good JayBhim
Thynyu. Sr. nyay ho. Sr
Kudos Faizan Sahab... Thanks for explaining it in such a beautiful manner .
Explained in a very fine manner with due references.
Salute Sir.
We proud of honour of law specialist Mr Faizan Mustafa for his services to the Nation on issues of awareness for general body of our country,warm regards Maimoon Siddiqui
Very relevant for exam sir . Thank you for helping.
विशलेष्णात्मक व्याख्या के लिऐ बहुत-2 धन्यवाद । सर ।
Yes it must end without any further dalay . It never good to have it in promotions . It has created lot of disparities in Government Services . Caste conflicts have been raised many times by these provisions .
When government privatising all govt departments ,the question as to employment and reservation will not arise ,,,there should be demand for employment and later reservation ,,,
U should rise these things on govt portal
एससी एसटी ओबीसी को नौकरीनहीं चाहिए❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
सर आपको बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद अच्छे तरीके से समझाने के लिए
फालतू में टैक्स के पैसों की बर्बादी करने वालों पर सक्कत action लेकर कार्रवाई करने की जरुरत है वो पैसा विकास रोड़ मार्ग सड़क रेलवे चिकित्सा खैती पशुपालन उधोग रोजगार में खर्च किया जाय जब देश आगे बढेगा जय भारत जय हिन्द
#
It is possible because of you only that LAW has become that simple that a lay man cud also understand what the tough LAW is not comprehendible to even scholars...
You speak Law and actually you are meant for it...
The Law in LAW'S tounge...
Regards sir...
Sir, I read entire judgment and there were so many facts to grasp, but thank you for simplifying it, now I am able to chronologically map all important points🙏
Very very good and clear cxplanation Sir Thans a lo Ad. Mustfa Sir and this channel too..
Thank you for providing very useful information' sir.
आरक्षण देने से पहले अच्छी शिक्षा दीजिए आरक्षण लेकर क्या करेंगे जब अच्छी शिक्षा ही नहीं रहेगी कुछ सीखी नहीं पाएंगे तो आरक्षण का क्या करेंगे कॉलेज और स्कूल की हालत क्या है किसी से छुपी नहीं है उसमें सुधार करिए यह सब होता रहेगा
❤ Great Explained by Sir 🎉🎉😊
Sir outstanding presentation. I like it.
Reservation ke apne hi fayde hai....Agar reservation nahi hota to...Baaki category ke log jee- jaan se competition nahi karte...Aur aaj jo pure vishwa me Bharat ke log acche aur uchh position me hai...Aisa time itni jaldi nahi aata....
Jo hota hai achhe k liye hota hai....👍
Baaki sudhar ki gunjaaish hai👍
Thank you so much respected sir
Judgement in true line with spirit of Constitution
Excellent views on reservations.
बिना data के sc-st के promotion मे आरक्षण सही नहीं है। data के साथ ही ,sc-st को promotion मे आरक्षण दिया जाना चाहिए। और सरकारों को दिक्कत क्या है,data जुटाने मे।? स्पष्ट आंकड़े है,कि महत्वपूर्ण पदों पर sc-st कम हैं, उनको कोर्ट मे रखें।
Thanks you sir ji 🌷 🇭🇺 🖋
Your great things tank thoughts 🌷
Thanks for the for nice video
Iam general category but i think sc,st nahi khatam hona chahiye.
What is right or wrong matters, not what you think
Very admirable Sir
Eager waiting for Ur videos... Thank you sir.
Very nicely explained step by step .Thank you very much. Aap ka shukriya ,❤❤
Kaash k SC jaisey judges kahi distt & session courts mai bhi recruit ho jai... Sara kaam speedy ho jaye.. Kya ho ni sakta ki achey judges recruit ho distt & session courts mai.. 80% ko toh just date hi deni aati hai.. 10% date k saath saath kuch kaam bhi kar letey hai.. 10% sahi mai fast hai jo wakya hi kaam kartey hai inki vajah sey yeh 80% bach jatey hai..
सर आप के द्वारा समझाई गयी क़ानूनी प्रकिया हम को बहुत हेल्फ़ करती है हम उत्तराखंड के पहाड़ी गाँव से है हम को बहुत हेल्फ़ मिलती है आप की वीडियो से सर आप का बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद शुक्रिया आप जैसे गुरु हो तो देश बहुत ऊचाई पर पहुँचगा🙏🙏🙏
Thank you for teaching us
Sir thank you for your effort,video is very informative but it would be much more helpful for us if you try to explain the content in a simpler language.For people like us who are not from law background it becomes a bit difficult to grab the whole juice.I hope you will think about this.Jai HIND
Actually this video is as complicated as the court order in this particular matter. No clarity neither in judgement nor in this video.
We salute you Sir regarding your Legal experience
Iska matlab ke sc / st ka reservation sarkar ke marzi se hai.
बिल्कुल सही पकड़े
You are a legend Faizaan Sir😃😃. You've explained everything in this video in very convincing way. As a student, I am enlightened. Thank you very very much!!
OK , so you tell me that whether there will be continuation of reservation in promotion or not as per this video.
@@haramipandey6965
To be decided by the Government. For the time being...it'll continue the way it is.
@@haramipandey6965 wo is baare me nahi bol paayenge unko sc st ki hits chaahiye is site ke liye,
Mai bata raha hoon ki reservation in promotion raha hai rahega aur is aage aur badi matra me modi sarkaar karegi
Faizan sahib tremendous help us your's technical and experience based detail..
From jalandhar Punjab..
SC - State k data k adhar pr promotion me aarkshan mileage.
State - hm data collect hi nhi krenge.
"Ek hi thali k chate - batte" 🙄😒😒
Exactly yhi kr rhi h govt jiski bjah se aaj tk sc st ko bhagidari nhi mili h
Sahi pakdha ,. Na noh (9) mann tel hoga na radha nache gi.
This happened from last many years.
Well expounded sir..👍🏻
Good information about
Great.
It's shameful judgement against SC st agar is bench mein ek bhi SC st ka judge HOTA to faisla Alag HOTA
Thanks Sir. Very nice narration by you. Again thanks
Sir, I really appreciate the manner in which you explained this judgement. I will like to draw your attention to the fact that there is no reservation in promotion in Group A Posts in Central govt. So if there is consensus on continuation of reservation in promotion policy, then why restrict it to Group B & C Posts ?
Egjmrnehwjwjgnjwgmtejee ttt illustrious
Kyon group B and c kaam to Sara inhi ko karana hai
TV
भारतवर्ष में अब न्याय की प्रकिया में परिवर्तन की जरूरत है कयोंकि अब देश में राजनीति का बोलवाला है न्यायालय तो अब एक मोहरा बन चुका है. कर्मचारी पिछले 25 सालों से आरक्षण की मार झेल रहे थे और 2016से न्यायालय के फैसले का इंतजार करते करते कई कर्मचारी घर चले गए और बाकी भी ऐसे घर चले जावेगे. खोदा पहाड़ और निकली चुहिया.
@@ramkhelawansondhiya9606 आरक्षण राजनीतिक मजबूरियों के कारण दिया जा रहा है और ये मजबूरियां कभी समाप्त नहीं होगी। इसे न्यायालय कभी खत्म नहीं कर पायेगा। इसे राजनीतिक पार्टियां ही समाप्त कर पाएंगी। पर जनता का समर्थन धीरे धीरे मिलेगा। योगी के विरुद्ध अनारक्षित समाज पार्टी को 496 वोट प्राप्त हुए।
Reservation jldi khtm kr dena chahiye specially jobs me
Well articulated description sir again. Kindly apprise viewers about regularisation of Temporary service. In the light of Uma Devi, Nihal Singh, Arjun Singh, Sachin Ambada Dawale, Narender Tiwari, Chander Mohun Negi, Somesh Thapaliyal Judgements pronounced by Hon'ble Apex Court
Suppose to be stopped forthwith.
Very informative.
Good decision by court
Vote ki rajneeti karne walon me munh par ye ek karara tamachahai.pramotion me reservation nahin hona chahiye.vo chahe sc St ka ho ya fir obc ka case ho .medical aur technical services men to bilkul nahin.sc ko lot of thanks.
Do you think without merit someone should hold secretarial post for domestic or international affairs......
Please reply
Bahut khoob g 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
You are doing great sir 👏
Good information thanku so much sir
Thanks a lot sir for your informative vedioes.
END OF RESERVATION IN PROMOTION
IT'S NOT DEMOCRATIC
BIAS DECISION IS INJUSTICE
. very informative
We agree that there shouldn't be any reservations but then there shouldn't be any approach, but in India every body knows that here everything is fixed on the basis of caste, who will be selected or rejected. Private sector is highly biased in this context
I worked in Capgemini, most of my colleagues belonged to OBC, SC,ST. Yet they got selected and promoted because they are talented. Private sector is extremely transparent, please don't blame with your ignorance....First get into private job then give your experience....
Reservation is given on the basis representation in services to SC/ST, in all caders or levels .
जन्म से कोई गरीब नहीं है मेहनत नहीं करेंगे तो अमीर भी गरीब होने में देर नहीं लगेगी सो कर्म अच्छा करो सरकार की सुविधाएं योजनाएं का लाभ लेकर ऊपर आत्मनिर्भर बनाने का काम करें भगवान शिव ने हाथ पैर शरीर दिमाग हूनर सब करने को दिया है फिर फिरी की लालसा क्यो भगवान शिव भी नाराज होता है सोचो समझो जानो विचारों करो जय भारत जय हिन्द
Buht khub
Excellent, SIR.
Sir I appreciate the way you explained everything. But I think inadequacy in higher posts is because people from SC and ST generally join services very late. And for promotion to higher posts one has to serve certain minimum period of service and till they reach that duration they are near to retirement. SC and ST who join service at lower age reaches to higher posts even today.
No, you are wrong
@@parvinder777 you can cross check by RTI
Jai hind sir🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Very Nice
Faizan sir namaskar, sir please keep it up,
Agar reservation promotion me khatm krna h to equal seat do, sc/St ko only 10 per diya ja rha seat or general ko 80 per seat dete ho or bolte ho ki reservation nhi milti h general ko
Mindless question
@@mohammedkamilshaikh8406 Tumlog ka to bahut achha question rhta h, abhi tak Hijab me hi lge ho
Kaha general ko 80 seat dedi
राष्ट्रपति का एक पद है तो उस ग्रुप पर एससी, एसटी, ओबीसी और जनरल को न्याय दो।
👌🙏sir for good information
Nice
Sir realy apriciat jujment
Britishers have laid down very complicated laws and procedures, to confuse people of India. Unfortunately, after 1947,not much has been done to simplify, as this is handy for Admn, to rule.
Sir in my opinion is the power full persons are willing to continue to caste system .now reservation is need to uplift the sc and St . SC and St are more suitable and mentally and physically capable fit comparing to the general caste people.sc St peoples are more honest and responsible.
जिस प्रकार परिस्थितियां बन गई, अब कभी भी एससी एसटी पदोन्नति में आरक्षण नहीं मिल पाएगा।
stop reservation and save country
Stop reservation and implement मनुस्मृति
गुरुजी नमस्कार।
Nice information Sir 🙏
Thank sir
it should be stoped
Awesome sir
Thank you sir 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Sar jab aap English language bolate Hain to sath mein uska Hindi language bhi jarur boliyega pleasekyunki special English AVN Court ki bhasha samajhne mein thodi si pareshani hoti hai aur sidhe sidhe shabdon mein samajh vaise aapane is decision ko bahut acche se samjhaya hai thank you very much
RESERVATION SHOULD GIVE ECONOMICALLY CONDITIONS
👍
Very nice
5. Concession in Promotions within Group A:
There is no reservation in case of promotions by selection from a Group A post to
another Group A post. But when promotions by selection are made from a Group A post to a
Group A post which carries an ultimate salary of Rs.18,300/- (pre-revised), or less, the
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Officers, who are senior enough in the zone of
consideration for promotion so as to be within the number of vacancies for which the select list
has to be drawn up, would be included in that list provided they are not considered unfit for
promotion. Their position in the select list would, however, be same as assigned to them by the
Departmental Promotion Committee on the basis of their record of service.
Note: Fitness of the SC/ST officers in such cases would be assessed keeping in view the duties
and responsibilities attached to the post and not on the basis of benchmark, if any, prescribed for
promotion to the post.
Totally injustice ho rha h but kya karein who will oppose
राज्य और केंद्र पास अनुसूचित जनजाति का डाटा होना चाहिये. कितने दिनो से टेस्ट मॅच खेल रहे है गेंद कभी इधर तो कभी उधर रिझल्ट आयेगा क्या नही 😡😡😡