David Sinclair & Brad Stanfield 2024: Rimon's UNEXPECTED Take
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 кві 2024
- David Sinclair versus Brad Stanfield. The most confusing controversy right now.
This video will try to clear up the confusion and will include 2 rare segments from David Sinclair addressing Resveratrol controversy and NMN ban.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Suggest watching next:
What happened to my wife?
• Why I Never Asked for ...
Brad Stanfield's Fisetin Mistake
• Brad Stanfield SERIOUS...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Support on Patreon & Get BONUSES:
/ wellnessmessiah
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Wellness Messiah podcast is available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and Overcast.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits: Scott Buckley
Track: Soulmates (Instrumental) - DayFox & BraveLion [Audio Library Release]
Music provided by Audio Library Plus
Free Download / Stream: alplus.io/soulmates-instrumental
Disclaimer & Disclosure: The information in this video and/or at this channel is not intended to replace a one-on-one relationship with a qualified health care professional and is not intended as medical advice. It is intended as a sharing of knowledge, educational and information from the research and experience of Rimon, who encourages you to make your own health care decisions based upon your research and in partnership with a qualified health care professional.
Rimon is not a medical doctor. If there is a contradiction between the advice here to your doctor or local authorities, always go with the doctor and the authorities.
Statements made, or solutions suggested in this video and/or at this channel are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. - Фільми й анімація
NOTE: Unlike these two, I am NOT affiliated with supplement companies.
And: I do NOT produce or sell supplements.
Also, apologies on content delays. I'm 24/7 with my wife, sleeping 3-4 nights a week in treatment centers with her, applying your GoFundMe donations for her recovery:
wellnessmessiah.com/help
I wouldn't sweat it either sir!
Thank you RIMON. This has been of concern to me. I fear that Stanfield’s
personal attack on Sinclair could adversely effect the well-being of his followers by steering them away from some excellent molecules. I owe my current robust health to the adoption of Sinclair’s personal regime. I am chronologically old and yet physically and mentally young
Hi Margaret, thank you. Like you, my issue here with these personal controversies encroached into other people's habits and supplements . Infusing confusion into people's life in my opinion hurts their habits and judgement. As I said, no confused person's stick to their habits.
The best thing I did today, after fasting until noon, was to heat up two hotdogs and eat them without bread. At age 92, I have no time for controversy... just knowledge. And what I know is, your belief makes it so.
You already made to 92, I’d say enjoy life!
@@vaivaivaiful I am... thanks. ❤
Your content and opinions, IMO, are right on. Before I watched your opinion on Brad Stanfield, I had the same opinion. I am a retired pharmacologist and caught many errors. On the other hand, David Sinclair isn't perfect - no one is, but I follow his protocol and adopt some of it. I even tried going vegan and that was a disaster - found out later it was too many oxalates. I make a 'brain stuff', which is a liposomal concoction with NMN, fisetin, Red Korean ginseng, berberine, AKG, and TMG. It lights up my brain! My husband also notices if we run out. We are in our 70s and I still feel young, no inflammation and lots of strength and energy. I owe this to following people like you and incorporating these practices into my routine. Routine is important! Also, I agree about fear. Your analogy of a fearful driver is spot on and I'll use that in the future. I always say 'fear is the opposite of faith' - That has been so true in the past 4 years. Thank you!
Yup, the key is staying relaxed and listen to your intuition. It sounds like you have already done it. Kudos
Send some details on your concoction, please!
Please could we have more details about the concoction? Is it possible to just take all the mentioned ingredients as separate supplements taken together?
@@mikelangele I buy pure powder supplements and weigh them into a small jar. I dissolve with distilled water and a little 95% ethanol (not denatured). Once dissolved, I mix in sunflower lecithin to make it liposomal. Once well mixed, I put the jar in an ice bath in a jewelry cleaner for vibration for 30 min. I store in fridge for up to 2 weeks and take about 1/2 tsp/day. You might have to adjust amounts. These are mine: NMN 5 gm, fisetin 3 gm, Red Korean ginseng 5 gm, Arginine AKG 7 gm, Berberine 5 gm, TMG 3 gm. Sunflower lecithin 25 gm. I just gradually added to and adjusted doses over years. 5 gm fisetin was too much for me.
What is AKG? Thank you.
I think Sinclair doesn't inspire trust.
He makes strange claims, but it's what we have.
Yes his behavior in the last 2 years has been confusing, to me as well. At the end of the day, we can use research to verify them and we are not dependent on one person's opinion.
Look at him and his father and tell me he doesn’t know what he is doing. Brad is not a researcher like David.
Science is a work in progress. Scientists provide their findings, then modify them as new research comes out. We are fortunate to have access to the evolving studies from researchers with varying backgrounds. Stanfield’s personal attack on Sinclair is ugly. He appears to be using Sinclair’s name to attract attention to himself. It is acceptable to express disagreement with another’s findings but never to incite the hate Stansfield has that is witnessed by his followers comments. I owe my current vitality to what I have learned from Sinclair and am immensely grateful.
Thank you for the intelligent and nuanced analysis of what's going on. Excellent points
Love your channel, great job! Super appreciate your hard work and dedication
The problem with the likes if Sinclair/Longo Vs Attia/Stansfield/Rhonda is that they basically have competing theories about longevity. So you have to choose a camp. The lower protein, fasting, fasting mimicking camp or the higher protein, more exercise camp.
Interesting, I hadn’t grouped them but you make a good point. OTOH Attia seems to be an outlier eg protein. Perhaps I missed it, but I haven’t heard Rhonda Patrick advocate that high doses (perhaps I missed it).
@@Scottlp2 I heard both Patrick and Stansfield state double the RDA, They have said it a few times now!
@@Scottlp2 Rhonda is now in the Attia camp. She's pretty much over the idea of fasting too as a regular thing because of the detrimental effects on muscle mass. It's difficult to choose a path because Sinclair's camp seem just as convincing.
And we are individuals so we need to work out what works for us. After a lot of research and some experimentation I know what works for me and it is all the usual ( good food, not too much , mostly vegetables, wide variety plus some supplements. Added is strength and cardio exercise at a fitness level not high performance and I have the physical age of someone 20+ years younger) habits and balance
@@Scottlp2I did not get what is OTOH please
You probably noticed but you need to move your ring lights. Go wider so they don’t reflect in your glasses 😊. Amazing content btw! Best wishes to you and your wife! ❤ Keep up the great work 🙌
Thank you, yeah, I'm bad with this stuff!
@@WellnessMessiah, nope, ur great on the stuff that matters...
Fear is the mind killer.
Stanfield was great for the first couple years of his channel. Then his fundraising for his rapamycin study failed and he changed his channel to being overly negative about everything. As for Kaeberlein, the guy hasn't produced anything useful in the field yet likes to set immensely high bars for people actually contributing.
Much clearer video from Stansfield. Maybe that's why it has 250K views to 8.9K here
yes more resveratrol content!!! 💘
Smart way to look at it, I agree on most.
I have spent a lot of time down through the years researching nutrients. Anytime money is involved that study is in question.
Thanks Rimon. I have doubts about both of these guys. Brad sounds like a big pharma mouthpiece and David has a deceptive vibe. I agree with your point about looking at different viewpoints...that makes us more balanced and I absolutely agree about living without fear. Fear will age you. I have followed your channel for awhile. I would love for you to give us some balanced feedback about Dave Asprey's work. i like him and even though he is clearly about making money he does seem to be developing biohacking solutions that he uses himself. I signed up for your course to support you more and look forward to going through that. Thanks again sir and I hope your wife heals. Make sure you study medical cannabis protocols for her.
Thanks for supporting me via the course! I need to check Dave's work, the issue is - I still need to interpret the data he bases his opinion on. So the person is only a stepping stone for deep dive into studies, data... that's where the magic happens - connect the dots.
In a old video you said is good to combine high dose with low dose resveratrol, could you give us a protocol about that? Can they be combined the same day?
Is it ok to take high dose resveratrol with a medication like omeprazol?
Yes health and longevity is all about habits. It takes work, but once they are habits its like autopilot. Thinking you can take the easy way by just taking supplements will not give you the results of habits. Diet, caloric limiting, fasting, exercise, mindset and sleep. I take some great supplements that are a beneficial peice of what I do, but the bulk of my great results are from habits. 59 yr old in great shape.
Yes and no because our soils are depleted of a lot of nutrients from industrial farming which is why we need to supplement
Hi there
Dr. Sandra Kaufmann, in her "The Kauffman Protocol" cites a bunch of studies about resveratrol and pterostilbene - page 306-308. Some would be "Journal of toxicology" 2013 Riche, Daniel M. et al., "Critical reviews in clinical laboratory science" 2013 Estrela, José M. et al. a.s.o. Cheers😊
Need to check that although they summarized probably studies I read. I will make some videos on resveratrol damaging effects to explore when and how, instead of "avoid, damaging" claims
Maybe, but you have to remember: MONEY CHANGES EVERYTHING. 💵💶💷💴
There is little to discuss, one is a genius scientist and the other is a simple clinic doctor!!
Does Stanfield actually have patients, or does he just do utube videos?
Sinclair profited massively on resveratrol - which he claims was $7M- $8M of personal profit, but may have given him much, much more - and the way his book popularized NMN, and his attempt to profit on it, show the true intent, in my opinion. Pay attention to actions/results not words. I don't agree with all of Stanfield's videos, but his only motivation seems to build a youtube channel.
He sells supplements. They are well known to be big earners for health YTers. So it's not really accurate to claim to be sure of "his motivations" I would say?
@@andrewnorris5415 No argument, Stanfield sells supplements as part of an outgrowth of his UA-cam station. And that is part of his motivation. UA-cam stations are themselves usually for profit for influencers like Stanfield, as everyone knows. And all this controversy is in Stanfield's interest, since it likely increases his viewers. I never "claimed" anything else.
@@andrewnorris5415he's unusually transparent about that - he's trying to fund his clinical trial for rapamycin. Also, it's only one supplement - a low dose multivitamin designed for (young) healthy individuals with an extra non-vitamin ingredient or two. Let's judge him only if he starts selling 10 different supplements, becomes a multimillionaire, and then never gets any clinical research off the ground.
@@andrewnorris5415 Building a youtube channel, as everyone knows, is for profit. So of course that is part of Stanfield's motivation. Same for selling supplements. But it is in the open and transparent.
Please tell me is it dangorus to take 1 gr of Resveratrol? It is important
@@ferdomrkvicka1247 Thank you, I wish you good health and recovery
Dr. Sinclair blocked Dr. Standfield when the latter asked to debate with the former on resveratrol.
I wonder if wellness messiah will make a video about his opinion on advanceing AI and how it might help us with anti aging science?
To be honest, this is an era of engineering which isn't my strength. There is no doubt AI will help us al lot... especially with genetics which is fundamentally a code with massive amounts of a mathematical data. It will help with genetic customization, for sure!
Sinclair/Longo (and almost all pro full time Phd Longevity researchers) - vs - Attia/Stansfield/Rhonda" . Lower protein, fasting - or - higher protein, more exercise. Personally I trust professional longevity researchers like Longo. It's popular to claim to you can live the longest AND have big muscles, eat lots of protein (double the RDA!). This gets book sales and YT views. And drives people to the supplements like what Brad sells. Longo BTW makes no profits from his books or the FMD packs - they all go to charity. PlantChompers says he is working on video to address these very issues on protein, I await that as he really does his research in my view.
But Attia made a good point: being old and frail ain’t without perils.
@@Scottlp2 Of course, everyone agrees there. Longo says a small increase in protein is needed. To quote him, "Over age 65, you should slightly increase protein intake but also increase consumption of fish, eggs, white meat, and products derived from goats and sheep to preserve muscle mass. Consume beans, chickpeas, green peas, and other legumes as your main source of protein."
Also Michael Greger has pointed to a lot of studies that say weight training alone is enough to maintain strength as get older. Most people get frail as they stop exercising/working when get older. That makes sense and studies back it up. And remember, it's women who live longer than men (less muscle mass). And small, slim men/women.
Marcel of ThePulse is going to interview Dr Stanfield and Dr. She at the same time!
We bough a resvertarol from natural sources included grean tea combined , is a suplement of 1 gram. do you think natural resvertarol is better than sintetick source for the suplement. and in this case maye the one from natural source is ok if mixed with medicines. Help please someone sick in the family and I belive resveratrol can help our family member
Hi in a couple of weeks I will show some studies for you to decide on the result you want. High vs low dose work differently.
@@WellnessMessiah ok thank you, pleas talk about supplements from natural source like the one we bought as well
I gave up watching Dr Stanfield. It's a shame, really. He pointed out the research that led me to start taking GlyNAC, but I gave up when it became obvious that he had stopped putting out useful content and had instead shifted to attacking Dr Sinclair.
Thank for the comment. It looks like the sales controversy somehow got mingled into resveratrol research which has nothing to do with Sinclair, as 99.9% of studies weren't authored by him. I will make some series of research videos about resveratrol and those claims, so people can make up rational decisions about this very cheap supplement, too.
@@WellnessMessiah I'd also be curious about research into pterostilbene, which is similar to resveratrol, but is methylated and has higher bio-availability. I'm wondering if lower doses of pterostilbene might be functionally equivalent to resveratrol plus TMG but haven't seen any research.
Me too. Stansfield used attacking Sinclair to promote himself via click bait attention
@@atholmullen Yes pterostilbene is more powerful no doubt (verified by studies), the problem is I discovered power here could be an issue, which surprised me. And only 1% of the studies vs res
@@atholmullenits actually the trans-resveratrol within resveratrol that is the stable compound of resveratrol
Brad is only 31 and thinks he knows everything.
The first AI doctor he shows no signs of being human.
Yes your so correct ❤
He doesn’t get that real life cannot be explained all the time in a study
I trust Matt Kaberlein a lot more!..😅
.
why arent comments showing?
I see you comment
🧐🧐🧐" I'm all for health not for profit" 🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤔Would you beleve that? 😊😊😊
Why is it if someone makes money at something they are good at we need to attack them? Does that happen to you at your job? I’m sure he could make a lot more money opening up a private lab and mass producing but he doesn’t
Also, Sinclair misrepresented his brother’s dog longevity project. Integrity is key.
what ?
?
Yes, I think Stanfield has made mistakes in his analysis. He chases views by stirring up controversy with overly personal attacks.
Stanfield is one of my least facvourite longevity influencers, and the one I have the least faith in.
Thx from India
Thanks back!
In my opinion you could really do without the stock footage. It doesn't add anything of value and makes the video look cheapo/cringey.
Thank you, I will take that into account
First Comment!
Saw it again
Team Stanfield here!
Great meeting you. See you in the next resveratrol's controversy research where will go into the actual studies and interpret them together.
@@WellnessMessiah clarify
1. He listed the incident where the company paid 700 million for the company Sinclair touted only to find they could not replicate his outcomes.
2. He listed the two well respected colleagues that renounced their relationship with Sinclair and why. (I know follow one of them on podcast).
3. Sinclair always made it clear that he’s experimenting and it’s not advice - but then sort of leaves it tooooooo enticing to not at least try given that his report that there are no side effects 🤞.
4. Sinclair tried to control the substance by raising it to from supplement to Rx.
5. I seem to remember a Chocran study saying they couldn’t replicate Sinclair outcomes either.
Sorry to say it but weird editing for a medical channel and it kills your credibility. Talking head would have been better. Looks like something a teenager would do in high school.
Usually like your content but this one was a pass for me
What didn't you like in the editing? I will take notes as I work with an editor
❤️💖🙏❤️💖
This video was very hard to follow and understand. You veered off onto fear and led everyone down a rabbit hole. There are no opinions, just science and misinterpretations of the science.
I am steering clear of Sinclair. Each person has to decide for themselves. Too much questionable "science" going on. This appears to be a very good example of this.
Once Stanfield showed himself getting a Covid booster, even after all the adverse evidence, he nullified his critical thinking skills in my opinion. Unfollowed him since there are others who are worth my time.
Brad is right 💯